Discussion Locked

Certifications doesn't measure

0 helpful
414 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am MCP+I, and acting as Trainer for MCSE subjects for years. I found so many people certified as MCSE, who don't know basics of Networking or Backoffice family products.I found one MCSE installing Windows NT Server in a stand-alone machine, and when it wants network adapter he stopped it. And he installed a network card there, completed NT Installation and removed the adapter again. Can you think of it? Yes, afterwards all the network service were malfunctioning. This is one example.
I foundthe Micorsoft tests so easy that one can pass it by memorizing some demo questions and answers. I found same questions that appeared in Network Press Study Guides.After that I really feel shy to mention me as MCP.
Microsoft ( and all other certification autorites) should be carefull of it, and maintain the quality. Otherwise certifications will be meaningless.

414 replies

by kevinosar

You are right certification without any experience impies a whole lot of nothing. I think to many people want to take part in the "big money" that they are willing to do anything to get in. Should certification be trashed - no (what would you replace it with). What needs to be added on is a clear career path which adds experience to an individuals knowledge.

by johnm

Why does everyone "assume" that a certificate is a replacement for experience. Last time I check, a certification was nothing more than a piece of paper. If you are so worried about the less "experienced" getting a certificate, I suggest you build your experience or get a certificate. Either way, quit whining.

by itjforbes

If an individual gets into the IT industry due to certificates and doesn?t actually know how to do the job, then that person will quickly either get burnt out or fired for poor job performance. Simply put being book smart is only half of the requirement IT people need to know how to fix problems and research solutions (and when to not touch something until you have enough information about it). The certification courses can only do so much, there will always be ways to get around the integrityof tests.

by cmoncar

I suggest you build your experience . You syand a better chance when u have the experience and later get the certs.Once u can deliver thats kool.But the question here is "can u deliver ? " A certification is nothing more than a piece of paper.

by lanman52

What big money are you talking about? 50-60 grand a year? I doubt most techs even make that much! I am so tired I hearing a bunch of uncertifiable senior techs tell me they think certification is a waste of time. Are you telling me that after reading two 500 page books on one subject will leave a "paper" MCSE with nothing? What experience are you talking about??? I was a paper MCSE that has troubleshooting skills. I am constantly working on newly designed systems I haven't seen before. I am nowrecognized in my company as one of the most knowledgeable techs in the whole of IS. IT has little or nothing to do with experience, it is your ability to take what you have learned either from a book or otherwise and apply it. I have met guys who have been setting up NT accounts for 10 years who say they are experts but couldn't pass a test if their life depended on it. In certification you a forced to learn all, with experience you might only learn one thing and that's it!!!

by mrval

I disagree. Setting up NT accounts for 10 years makes a person a clerk (I have nothing against clerks) and they can certainly call themselves experts at setting up NT accounts because they are.

IMHO, I.T. is about gaining experience by gaining and using technical information efficiently and appropriately.

You ability for troubleshooing does you credit and differentiates you from the User Manager experts. Unless you are really good in memorizing questions and answers, I doubt if you would have passed the exams without troubleshooting skills.

by netropolisii

Here is a senior tech who makes the 50-60k a year you mention. And it's all based on experience. The only certifications I have are NETWARE and A+. I've been in the IT industry since the early 80's, and I took the plunge to get the those certs. only at my boss's recommendation so that he could continue to justify my salary.

I have interviewed so many paper MCSEs, MCPs, looking for Sr. Net Admin positions, who have more knowledge about NWA and EMINEM that about PCs and NT. Get real!

by keblerelf

I completely disagree on this one. First off I have no college and no certifications (working on MCDBA currently). However I've been incredibly successful with nothing more than the experience I've gained by grinding it out from the bottom of the ITcareer tree years ago. To say that experience doesn't amount to squat is ludicrous. Would you let a brain surgeon work on you that did nothing more than take a test but had no experience? Would you let an investor run risks with your money if he hadno experience...but wait...he took a test and passed. I agree that certs force you to learn a wide variety of things you simply might not see otherwise, but for the most part the examples and situations posed in certs are for the most part set up ina utopia environment. At all the different companies I've consulted at I've seen a "utopia" environment. If someone has a cert then great, but if they had no experience then I'd know they were just looking for the money and not risk hiring them. Even though I'd have to take the much more difficult tests if they make them harder I'm still all for it because it will weed out more of the ones with no clue when it comes to IT...and I've seen way to many.

by kenneth_taylor

From what I've seen over the past couple years, the only people who have Microsoft Certifications on their wall are the people who have a very basic grasp of a few MS office apps and no other computer knowledge. IT pros know the type, people who can make and print an excel sheet and therefore think they're qualified to handle any computer problem, almost certainly making things worse. Unfortunately these people will be impressing people in power with their limited knowledge for as long as thepeople in power are still computer-illiterate.

by jlombardo

Your comments are so full of generalizations that they are meaningless. Just because you got yours, you're hell bent on making sure no one else does. Ever hear of sharing the wealth? I hope I never have to work with someone as narrow minded as you. Good Luck!!

by dwnoles

The few certified pros that I deal with don't have those "I love me" walls. The idiots that have the certs and no experience love to show off there pretty pieces of paper. I do know that Cisco, Novell, and MS are all trying to find ways to make the certs more meaningful. And besides, those idiots don't last long and they make those of us that know what we are doing look even better. =-)

by dtraina

Let's look at the facts. The only reason that I became a paper MCSE is because no company would hire me with out experience. Therefore I needed to get some sort of certification to get my foot in the door. Now that I have a job with my A+ and MCSE,
I can get experience, and I have. I'm sure all of you started somewhere and this is where we chose to start (At the top). If someone shows the iniatiative and gets there MCSE and so called MEMORIZES the exam Imagine what they can MEMORIZE in the field.I think that everyone should lighten up on paper MCSE's. They will be catching up to you real soon.

by ab3_tek

I don't think that one can group most certified professionals into a group like that. If you know your stuff then you know it. If you take and pass a test based on certain criteria then you might know that criteria. I noticed while taking my MCSE courses that when one understands the theory he/she might be able to answer questions based upon that theory but to use that knowledge in the real world one needs the hands on training. The course I took included 350+ hours of lab instruction utilizingall the principles learned in the instructor lead training. I obtained my MCSE, MCP+I in 8 months, (not 5 days), the reason being I practiced ALL the material. The certification got me a good paying job 2 weeks after I achieved it. This got my foot in the door. Now I had to prove myself as being competent in the field. Which I did. 6 months later and 3 more certs (CNA, CCNA, CCDA) I have changed jobs and received a 45% increase in pay. I have only 6 months paid experience at 24 years old but I assure you I know my stuff. I now work in a senior level Network Engineering position that usually requires 4 years experience.
A certification should be an assessment of what you know. Your job is the assessment of how well you use that knowledge.
---Unfortunately these people will be impressing people in power with their limited
knowledge for as long as the people in power are still computer-illiterate. --- I don't know about you but my boss (the guy that hired me) is a net engineer witha CCIE certification. Try getting that by remembering questions. He did the interviewing and hiring. I don't know of anyone that interviews for a real IT job with the VP of the company or without an assessment test first.

by emilyjoy

im in agreement that hands on experience means more than the certs, just as a degree doesnt mean much if all you did in college is flip burgers. im only beginning to think about certs (im a 5th year Senior, CS major in college & am waiting to finishthat 1st) in the meantime, i am aware that one needs experience with the certs, the best way to learn is by doing. HOW DO I START? are there books anyone can recommend in order for me to start teaching and applying things myself, that can go hand and hand with going after my certs? and where would i find a job in which i would LEARN what i need, instead of needing to know how first? the age old question: how to get experience w/o experience?

by "jb"

I tend to agree with in the aspect that there are so called paper MCSE's out there today. But there are also alot of good MCSE's and MCP's that take their work seriously and are doing a good job. Yes the test can be memorized and some easily passed. That is why Microsoft is taking steps to insure when you get your Certification you are certified. Have you seen a Win2000 test yet. I am an MCP and don't mind stating the fact.

by bill cassada

As with most other "hand out" certs in this country (ie driver licenses) not many companies require any proof of experience. Too many people can cram and pass the tests without real-world experience. There is nothing wrong with working TOWARD a cert and not getting a cert then working for it. I've been in the field since 1983 and have only recently applied myself toward any certs. I'm currently working on my CCNA and you bet your butt I'm getting real-world experience. I am NOT going to goout with a cert and look like the fools I've seen waving their papers around.

by basicdogs

Complaining about certs, or lack of is simply being lazy. There are plenty of people with certification that know nothing, and just as many network guru's that have never been certified. Taking the guesswork out isn't hard. Look at those resumes, check job history and performance. Ask what he/she uses at home. Don't whine because you didn't bother to find out ahead of time.

by cmoncar

Certifications doesn't measure whats matters is the kind of experience that one has and can offer when requested.They are lots of guys out there that dont have any form of certifications but can deliver.They rather dont get the jobs u know.Others have the certs get the jobs and cant do it.which way is the best now,Experience or Certs ?

by fanchant

I got my MCSE in July - this is my first technical job and they paid for the training so I could become the network admin. I feel like I worked hard for the paper, but it doesn't mean anything until I get more experienced! I wish Microsoft would adopt an attitude towards these certs they way A+ does - that you're ceritified in entry level information only (which is how I feel).

by kai66

I am an MCP and currently working toward MCSE. I also realize the number of 'paper MCSEs' out there, who had no experience at all in networking or even basic PC knowledge. This is why it takes me almost two years for me to complete my MCSE Certification, because I don't want to rush and go out and write half a dozen of exams by simply studying some exam cram book, like a lot of people do. However, with the old NT exams being retired in December, I guess that leaves us very little time to complete MCSE whether you have experience or not. I know so many people who study MCSE to change their career field, meaning these people didn't know anything about networking or PC basics, and the easy Microsoft exams make it possible for these people. This pattern lowers the quality of MCSE certifications and makes it less valuable. This is why MCSE is not such a hotshot anymore, like it used to be two years ago.

by rpeeples

I have been turned down for a good position and even been denied interviews because I don't have any type of certification. They didn't even bother to look at the fact that I have been out there in the real world fighting all types of battles in the IT Industry for almost 20 years. Apparently that want soembody that just looks good on paper, not somebody that can do the job. Think of it this way: Does the fact that a person has a driver's license automatically mean the he/she is an expert driver? I think not! The same is true with certifications.

by rpeeples

If companies are going to look at certifications only as a guide for new hires, I think the people imposing the certifications should be made to assess an individual's work experience when awarding the certifications. They should take into account the number of years, the type of work, and the companies the person has worked for to name a few. In addition, I beleive a person's attitude, personality, and moral values should also be taken into account. If it all depends on a paper certificate then let me print out a diploma for myself from some hoity-toity college, hang it on the wall, and call myself a brain surgeon.

by oceanhai

If you guys with 20 years experience think the exams are so easy, why don't you just take them? It can't hurt. I mean, $700 to complete all of the MCSE exams can help raise your salary by 10k-20k! They're really not a breeze and they do make you think about concepts more than just memorization. Just my two cents.

by rpeeples

I didn't say exams are easy. If fact, I have never been able to take an exam and pass with flying colors. If somebody asks me a question I can answer it easily or I can prove to him/her what I know by doing it. But when it comes to writing the answer down on a peice of paper (or computer screen), even with the answers right in front of me, I simply can't choose the correct answer. I just have some kind of block against tests. Furthermore, I beleive taking such tests are basically gambling;you are lucky if you get some questions that you just happen to know the answer to. I don't beleive you can assign a letter or number to person as a gauge to what he/she really knows. No, I am not an idiot! In fact I have an IQ in the 130 - 135, or so the "tests" claim. Figure that one out...

by rrenfro

Now this is an interesting subject, I have 30+ years in the field. Took ten different BrainBench certs/tests without studying and passed them (all in the same week). Why do you want to give your money to someone else ?? Anyway been certified as atelecommunications engineer by the FCC since I was 17, hasn't done me any good, but the 24+ years with the military sure did. So again I ask why do you want to make microsoft richer ?? (or Novell etc)

by gene pinson

And if worse comes to worse, we could always get a degree from one of the degree mills that will give you a degree for supposed work/life experience.

by ctracey_1888

You're right there. I just studied for months to sit the NT Server exam. The weekend before I sat it I found a braindump site, and realised that I could have saved myself the bother. Every question I got in the exam was directly from these dumps andI only read about 10. I did however find a harder test from an independent certification body called brainbench, at www.brainbench.com. I skated the MS exam but only scraped a pass with brainbench.

by chrispace13

I believe there is some truth to what everybody is saying. But if anyone hires someone with no experience, that is what he is getting. I think a big problem with IT positions, it that they are being interviewed by not tech. people.I have my MCP, andall that says is that I know enough to pass Microsoft's test. Hopefully I know it, and it isn't just memorized long enough to pass the test. But that is why technical positions should be interviewed by technical people. But don't throw the baby out with that bathwater, a certification means that that person knew enough to pass the test. Which does at least give you a point of reference.

by alpha geek

I agree that there is nothing better than experience, however companies, expecially small companies, often lack the resources to be able to inverview a candidate indepth enough to determine the limit of his knowledge. A certification does say that the individual had a strong enough desire to learn the basics. I would rather have an MCSE with no experience than someone without an MCSE and no experience.

by adrian c

Brainbench is simply great, from many points of view. I agree their NT tests are harder than MS server/workstation ones. But MS server enterprise and TCP/IP are tough cookies.
Using the braindumps is a waste of time in terms of just memorizing someanswers, as opposed to actually learning the concepts and applying them.
And I'd say cert AND experience is the winning formula; a moron will always be a moron, certified or not. Looks like the dumber they are the louder they get.
One more thing. Why isn't anybody mentioning that Novell actually started this certification craze (1989 I think)? MS followed in 1992, CompTIA in '93 and then the rest of them.
All this certification talk seems to surround the MS ones. Makes me wonder...

by suhreed sarkar

Yes, BrainBench exams are really tough, and you must know to pass those eaxms. After passing my MCSE exams I sat for BrainBench and fouind it very tough which measure your experience. I have passed about 20 Brainbench exas in two months. I haven't seen any dump of BrainBench yet. But m,ain problem of it is that it's FREE and you can sit for exam from your home. And there is no method of identifying who are you? Those who are trying for MCSE, please first sit for BrainBench Exam. Thanks.

by gene pinson

I have been in the industry for 23, from assembler programming to zenix, and to this day hold no certs. Now when you look at people that are applying for positions that you are offering, you stop looking for the Cert, and starting looking for the actual experience. As you have stated, they have made it so any one can pass, and so there is no value to it. We have no MCSE's on staff, and just recently we picked up a product that the manufacturer wouldn't even ship to us unless we contracted a third party to install and configure the software. It wound up being a fiasco. Before it was all said and done we had 6 MCSE's sitting in our server room for this application, and after 5 days, they still couldn't figure out why they couldn't get it installed. (The application when first installed ran into problems, and left a bunch of orphaned information with the Exchange Information Store.) So every subsequent attempt at reinstalling bombed. After we got them all out of there, and I spent two days going through the information store in raw mode and removing all of the software's insertions, installed like a dream. Needless to say we still had to foot a huge bill for what was supposed to be one MCSE that turned out to be six that none of them could get it running. This is just one example of many of the trials I have run into with people that are supposed to be qualified, that don't have a clue.

by rreutlinger

In every career there has to be a starting point. The employers have made that the certifications. Why don't all of you experienced techs get together and change that to an apprenticeship system like any other trade, instead of griping about everyone's lack of experience. Experience that, by the way, they can't get unless they flash that paper.

by rpeeples

I worked for a company that hired a hotshot certification holder with absolutely no experience whatsoever to handle the network admin responsibilties. They paid him much more than they were paying me despite that fact I had been doing that particular job for several years without the first hint of a disaster. Within his first month, the main Netware server crashed and had to be totally restored from backups because he didnt know what he was doing. He begged me for my help and I flat refused. Then I got a tongue lashing from management about it. I gave them a very convincing oppposing viewpoint. They compensated by paying me more and making me his supervisor. The first thing I did was recommend his replacement with a more experienced person. He was demoted to, more or less, JR pc technician (at much less salary) and hired the right person for me, after consulting with me about it of course.

by basicdogs

You are a mean, spiteful person. And by reading several of your posts, I now believe most of it is fiction. Point being...stop ranting. Get involved. Discuss hiring practices with your Human Resource officer. Someone of your IQ should have figured that out by now.

by krioux

I've been reading all these e-mails regarding certifications. I have been in the IT industry for approximately 5 years now in the Training/Technical Support field. I have been considering getting a certification in MCSD. After reading all these replies I am now skeptical. What would be the best road for me to take to enhance my career?

by brianharris

I sure get sick of this constant discussion about the value of certifications. The value doesn't lie in the certification itself. The value lies in the process of getting one. A lot of MCSEs don't know what they're doing because either its not covered on the exam or they cheated to get the paper. I have meet a surprisingly small number of MCSEs that are fantastic at their jobs because they put in tons of hours learning BEFORE the exam. If you put in the effort then the MCSE isn't important, what you learned is.

by jackuvalltrades

I have seen a lot of complaining and precious little problem-solving from both camps here. While I agree that "paper tigers" are not truly qualified and should not, by virtue of cerificate, be granted the smae status as those with experience, it is not necessarily bad. Going the "paper" route gives them at least theoretical background and proves an essential capability for learning. That being said, Paper folks, without a lot of experience, you can constitute an over-priced danger to your employer and your own career. Be wise, tell the truth to perspective bosses and be willing to start at the bottom.
I am certfied myself in several areas and I believe the process is badly flawed. I propose that ALL certifications include a mandatory practical exam that is thorough and unpleasant. It is already done for the CCIE and proves not only your memory and learning capacity, but practical application skill as well.
Now, don't get me started on college degrees.........
Ta,
Jerry

by adrian c

Making a practical exam mandatory wouldn't actually mean refusing the certification opportunity to almost everybody outside US/Canada/Western Europe/Japan?
And speaking of exam prices, I wanted to take Network+ and i-Net+ and had to forget about it. Living in Eastern Europe, any of them would cost me almost a month pay, which I find ludicrous for entry-level exams.
It's not always what you can, but what you can afford.

by jackuvalltrades

Hey, I sympathize, really; however, folks from all around the world line to take the CCIE practical (and THAT is EXPENSIVE!!). I am unfamiliar with the testing procedure/costs outside the U.S., but I can absolutely assure you that if one get the experience, pays the price and takes the test, the rewards will be damn substantial! I have an assistant right now who is taking a CIS college course and this person is incompetent and unqualified; yet, she is smart enough to pass a paper test. Let me tell you, as of right now, she is dangerous to my network in the extreme. She is not stupid and, given a couple of years, she is going to be an excellent employee.
All that aside, going for the paper just to get to the top quicker is a moronic thing to do. You have to have a balance between theory and application and the industry certifications need to reflect that.
Enough ranting.......
Ta...........Jerry

by vanguard

Let's put the ball in whose court it belongs. The problem starts with the training companies that push their training by touting big bucks. This training is almost always just the theory with very little hands-on. I believe the solution is to have a required amount of practical hands-on after each session to verify the learning. The training companies should also be required to have a COMPLETE system of hardware for that purpose. I'm using my previous training many years ago as a mainframefield engineer with Control Data to back this up. A student went thru the theory and then the lab every day on an actual mainframe for each phase of the course. Tests were administered for each phase on both theory AND practical. If you didn't average a passing grade with both, you had to retake once. Second time, goodby. You also had access to the lab after hourswith an instructor present to reinforce your learning. Credit should be given to the students that did complete their MCSE and only got their certificate because the lack of practical experience or knowledge is not always their fault. The rest of the fault lies with the companies that hire the so-called "paper" MCSEs. If the MCSE has little or no experience, he should be hired as an entry or trainee level person just as in other line of work. This way he gets the job and can get his experience growing along the way. The big bucks? will come along in due time.

by gregpip

Even though getting certification adds credibility to one's abilities, I would say experience plays an important roll in how you define yourself as an 'expert.'

by freshbeat

I have just started to study for my MCSE. I have been helping others with upgrades and correcting crashes they caused on thier PC's. I don't know much about networking yet so many company's won't hire me for PC help. I need to learn and the certification is the only route company's want to see. I feel that its just a new standard for the companies of today.

by basicdogs

You are correct, most companies want to see your cert first. Then you can gain some experience afterwards....Silly, but true. You are probably doing one of the best things you can though. Keep playing with other peoples problems. It's a good exercise.Best of luck to you.

by robsmith47

It would be in your best interests to go to a technical school or try and get a entry level job in IT, anything, an internship or answering phones. I see a lot of resumes every day and when I see a person with an MCSE and no real world experience do you know where it goes? Right in the trash. If you do get your MCSE set your goals realistically, you will not be managing a large network with no experience. You will never get a junior level admin job with no experience. If you are the type of person who can pass the exams quicky then do it but don't waste a lot of time on something that actually may hinder you rather than help you.

Regards,
R'

by basicdogs

First off, I am not so sure someone who touts there supposed IQ is so smart...but that's besides the point. It would be absurd for people who are studying towards their mcse,a+,cne, or anything of the like to have to prove a viable tech history employment to recieve certification. And if we start trying to account for personalities....your boss would fire you. You clearly have an ego problem.

by rayvenwolfe

I have no certifications, and I have no resume-worthy experience that most employeers would take seriously. It doesn't seem to matter that I've been working with networking for the last five years in my home, am able to make machines which run a conglomeration of OS's speak to each other, and am well-versed with the installation and administration of all the OS's present in my computer room. I adamantly refuse to take the MCSE tests simply because I don't find the $200 worth it. However, if someone would allow me to prove myself in an interview, I'm sure I could. That just doesn't happen anymore.
Someone mentioned BrainBench earlier, and frankly, I like their tests. I've done well on the ones I've taken and they were definitely a challenge. With any luck, employeers will find out about the place and see for themselves. For me, I maintain my home network, learn what I can, and will get a job doing web page design for some person who doesn't know a computer from a wastebasket. ;)

by danthebestman

Microsoft Certifications are a big money maker for them. The certification materials are also a marketing tool for Microsoft products. Does anybody recall any questions on their certification exams about dealing with bugs in their products?
This is where the rubber meets the road in the real world. What Microsoft doesn't tell you is often far more important than what they do tell you. This is why experience is (and should be) the determining factor in hiring a IT professional.

by mlemperle

Yes I have a few certifications but everything I know is from experience. Working with NT for about 10 years and I would certainly go up against most MCSE's. I have seen some real sharp guys in my time and also my share of the not so sharp. Here is a funny story. I knew an MCSE that I worked with once that came up to me saying that the domain was down. I was very questionable because I was up and working. I asked him to show me how he came to this decision. He took me to his workstation and proceeded to ping the domain name. Now unless I had something setup in DNS then maybe he would get a response but I admit when I saw him do that, I started to laugh and walked away. I guess it might have been on the rude side but things like this have certainly discouraged me on completing my MCSE. Some people are just really good test takers and can absorb material in a book. All the power to them but let's just see how well they do in the real world.

by rpeeples

Ok, so what you are basically saying is that, for example, a person with absolutley no driving experience should be able to fire up an 18 wheeler, drive it across the country, and make all his/her deliveries on time without once running a stop sign/red light, never going over the speed limit, and never making a wrong turn. And as far as an ego goes, yes I might have one, but its because of my experience. I have put in the time and effort to make myself one of the best network admins/technicians/programmers/etc. in my area. Most of everybody's replies are missing the point, and that is that experience and know how should greatly outweigh certifications of any kind.

by msamson

...But up until now, the only thing I ever got out of MCSEs and MCPs and so on is major loads of annoyances... I had one individual in particular ask me where the DOS 6.2 disks were so that he could fdisk and format the HDD prior to installing NT server!!! This is not a joke!!!! And yes, this guy was MCSE certified!!! NOTHING beats experience!!! The only encounters I've ever had with certified individuals who actually showed me something was back in the days of Novell 4.0 and 3.12. It seems that back then, in order to become a CNE, you actually had to know something about computers. Nowadays, you can practically get the certs out of a cereal box!! I'm not saying that there aren't any got MCSEs and the like out there... it just seems like they're few and far between... and it's a shame because it only works to undermine the profession.

by txsteddybear

I am trying to get my MCSE..I work hard at school and it does not come easy. I believe like most experience counts. The certs I have right now helps me get looked at but I am working to prove myself. All book learning gets you is alittle more knowledge but its hands on and working through the clients/company pc probs that re-enforce what you know and have learned. We need the certs but we also need the experience to show what we know and learn what we don't.

by robrainwater

I can see every ones points. I am planning to go after certifications, but only after I have some experience and make the decision of which one is right for me. Unlike some, I have gotten lucky in that I am in my first IT job with out certifications. Although I am only two classes away from finishing an associate?s degree in CIS, I owe where I am to the vigil of a couple of my instructors. It was through their High expectations of what they wanted from me that I have the confidence that I am inthe right field. They expected my best if not more than my best. Which brings me to my point. Some people can study something and go into a test and just do a brain dump and pass. But does that truly prove what you know? I think not. It is my opinion that if you truly have a love for what you do and an undying hunger to know more about it, you can never go wrong. The knowledge you have about a topic will stick with you. This applies to certifications. The certification is just a piece of paper.It along with true knowledge, and a hunger for more knowledge and experience poses the true key to true success.

by basicdogs

Why don't we stop blaming the poor people who are trying to make a decent career, and start blaming the business community. That is where the problem is. HR depts wants to see the certs. If you want experience, you have to have the certs. But Hr is rarely looking for experience. That would take time. Pat the poor kid on the back for studying to begin with. No matter what you think, it wasn't easy. Then take it a step further, and offer to help him learn something.

by unicornrider

As someone who has worked in the IT field for close to 19 years and who has worked his way up from the bottom (data entry to Network Administrator) I find it exasperating that people with just 8-10 months of training (and no experience) can land jobs I worked and studied hard for all those years. I spent 2 years as a consultant in Silicon Valley 4 years ago and heard a lot about paper CNE's and MSCE's who could even fix the most simpliest of problems. During that time I worked with a paper CNE who worked as a hardware tech because the company felt he couldn't cut it as Net Admin and yet I came in as a consultant, with some training and a lot of experience, and was doing Helpdesk support, tech support, some Net Admin duties, and built Win95/NT laptops for the companies sales division that I had to integrate into their world wide network. I found out that experience is worth a heck of a lot more then just having a piece of paper. Certification is nice but would you trust a doctor who had just graduated but who had not done his 6 years of residency? I certainly would not.

by lapavoni

Thank you, "brewster". I could not have said it better myself. When I interview candidates for Desktop Support positions, I frequently see "MCP" or "MCSE" on their resumes. After many interviews, my colleagues and I conclude that either candidateslie about their qualifications on their resumes or simply have little or no "real world" experience. I have 15 to 20 standard questions I ask in an interview for a Tech. Support position. These questions cover procedures such as creating an Emergency Repair Disk in Windows NT, the definition and use of "Safe Mode" in Windows 9x, defining the differences between FAT, FAT32 and NTFS, and how to troubleshoot printing and network connectivity. At first we were astounded to hear that supposed "MCPs" or "MCSEs" could not describe basic procedures, or even more advanced procedures that one would expect a "certified" technician to understand. After several interviews, we sarcastically suggested that our manager either ask more difficult screening questions over the phone or shred any resumes that had the letters "MCP" or "MCSE" on them. In my mind, NO formal training, NO so-called "certification" can replace real-world, hands-on experience in Tech. Support. A certification might *supplement* ones abilities and experience, but it will never replace them.

by mbw72

Why do we get certified?? One reason...Money...Money...and oh yeah Money. MCSE's get paid more. Wether you are just starting in the IT field or you are a wily vet you get paid more, pure and simple. Everyone knows experience is better than simpletests,but everyone also knows or should know that MCSE get more MONEY; plain and simple. If bosses are paying more for experienced AND non experienced MCSE's then what's all the debate about? Those understand this are the ones sitting on the sidelines whining that their experience should be worth more. If we are so good at troubleshooting, let's trouble shoot this idea: What does experience + nothing equal? What does experience with an MCSE equal? Wait! Here's a rough one: What does no experience and no experience get you? And you know what those who can't cut it will be found out, those who can will seperate and rise to the top. Yours truly,
MCP+ E (Experience)

by spankmeister88

I agree that hiring somebody based solely on their paper certificates may be a mistake. I currently am a General Manager of a pub, but am looking into changing careers in Jan(when my commitment is completed). I have been in the restaurant industryfor 15 years and only in the last couple of years fired up my love for these silly machines. But these are my passion, and am on them virtually every moment I am not doing work to pay the rent. I have no real experience in IT, yet am a MCP, and am studying for my CCNA. All this from just reading books and working at home.
Luckily, I have the resources to support my thirst for knowledge, I have built from scratch a TCP/IP network in my house(Server, 3 workstations) as a lab I use to test networking. As of today I have used NT Server with Win98 workstations, Win2K with Win98 Workstations and Solaris(my current install) to test my knowledge and to try to gain a bit of experience. Most IT companies where I live won't look at you unless you have some sort of certification(it's a college town). So on the surface, I would be considered "Paper Certified", but in order to achieve my goal of working in the industry, it is what I need to have.
To me, it would sound funny to go into a interview and say "I just love the damn things, no I am not certified, but I can learn whatever you need me to do, that's what I have done in the past."
It isn't a perfect system, but until the IT labor crunch is lessened and companies start hiring forskill level rather than paper certificates, it is all we have.

by kenneth_taylor

There are three types of responses in this thread- 1) Certified means nothing, experience is everything, 2) I may be certified but i actually studied, or 3) i know IT but i'm clueless about the industry, should i get a certification?

All of which can be summed up with this simple statement: In the IT Industry today there are people who have the experience to do the job but generally don't have the Certification, people who have the knowledge to do the job but generally don't have the experience, and "paper MSCEs" who have neither but are making it hard on everyone by taking the easiest route to the most money. My original point still stands- Until the world's collective computer knowledge raises to the point where most everyone in the industry at least knows what the heck a file extension is there will continue to be high paying jobs going out to whoever has the most impressive paperwork and the nicest suit. Not every job of course, and there are intelligent, computer-literate people looking for experience, but so far they are still the exception rather than the rule. Sad but true.

by basicdogs

I am so glad I came back and saw this post. My husband is in the same position pretty much. He is working for a tech support company while studying for his CNE,CNA,MCSE,and A+. And he would have never had a clue if he were not working in the field to begin with. Everyone keeps acting like getting certified is easy. It's not. Not if you expect to actually learn anything. And you must eventually. Otherwise you will drown.

by mrval

Last time I checked, you have to be qualified to do a job to deserve the job - there are some exceptions of course.

Perhaps your company needed an MCSE without any experience or you may have been very fortunate. I agree that 'paper MCSE's will eventually catch up - IMHO, that's the least they can do to be getting paid the wage of a true MCSE.

by bartware

Being new in the IT field (only 18 months) I have come to the conclusion that; certifications help get the doors open, it does not ensure that you get the job. Experience,college education as well as the interview is what will get you hired. In short it's you not the paper that the employers are looking at.

by cavedweller

Certifications seem to measure your ability to memorize the test material. While a large knowledge base is important, the ability to analyze information and apply your knowledge is paramount. "Book knowledge" alone is nearly useless in the problemsolving arena. Experience isn't always a good measure either. Many times ineffective administrators are assigned trivial tasks to keep them from doing major damage but rack up the years anyway. You need to be able to think through a problem and assess it from a variety of viewpoints, not just run through a checklist. A performance-based certification would be a better solution.

by its a secret

I believe there should be an internship (like ASE cert Mech.). Take the test and pass, plus two years practical experience in the feild, before you can display your certs.

by jackuvalltrades

Well said!! My point, exactly. Problem is...getting the industry to buy the idea. Who is going police it or set the standards for the "right" kind of experience? More importantly, how do you get employers who need good people now to start a mentoring program?
Rhetorical questions, all, but still worth thinking about. If we start talking, who knows what may come............
Ta........Jerry

by thejrc

Quite True!!

I may not be an IT expert, or a hardware engineer for that matter. Point is, without so much as a high school diploma :::yes I have a GED, and a few minor certs I just picked up to have::: I can honestly say that in the last two years experience and curiosity alone has moved me farther ahead than any school ever could.

I work with certified technicians, in fact, I train them and beleive me, its hard. I engineered and administer two networks, NT based at work and BSD/Linux at home, can boast and prove my knowledge of at least 90% of compaq full line of product and 60% of all other large vendors :::ibm, toshiba, HP, etc::: I can troubleshoot, repair, and in most cases rebuild all of it. Fact of the matter is, its nothing special I just spent my time on experience rather than paper.

???THEJRC???

by khravi

Certifications today tend to have only resume value. I have in my past 10 years seen so many people and also interviewed many for openings within my organization. It is extremely sad to say that most of the so-called experts have achieved the certifications by dubious means. There are options like question banks, web sites and other sources which only aim at passing exams rather than concepts and technology. This has led to a de-valuation of the Certfication status of many. I only wish & hope that people don't take the easy path out for only getting a paper to add to their CV.

by zk

No commercial exp. in NT, but done favors for dinners & dates in college. Got graphic degree in 98. No title. Client hired me FT for graphics. Not underpaid nor disgruntled, I'm happy & stress-free. I'm a web designer. I've MCSE, iNet+, Network+, A+, RHCE, my 1st and last cert revelation on forums btw. Nobody knows, but I?m happy I improve. CEO tried to pay, but no (need self-pressure). Stupid? Never smart, just wanna learn. Work 8-5, 6-3, I play with 8 computers, read NGs. Everyone is my mentor, I repay by helping others. I am a netizen. Certs with less $, I?m ok. Exp., means nothing when u r hanging on chk to chk. My boss is MCSD with 6 yrs NT, coding exp. and asked me what's PDA & how to setup OLXpress for news, and cries to MS when his code "can't create object" after a big domain+dc ren, on live svrs which crashed for 2 days! After 2 days w/ MS w/o telling the renaming spree, MS gave up. I said try sp6a (had 128bit sp5, he said don't wanna download 128bit sp6a. I HAD TO DWNGRADE128BIT SP5 TO 56BIT SP6A. Spent 5 hrs pounding his baby). After all is well, he blamed MS bug. Cute. 1/2 my colleagues vanished & I miss them. Sure he knows all Vs, but simply setting up news reader? Still love certs? He said ?putting IIS behind proxy?ll slow web down.? So his baby IIS is sticking out with port 139 for take. And admin MCP, CNE, 5 yrs exp. not knowing the difference in hosts and lmhosts, said WINS was up since 99. Sure, with 6 entries for 200 clients. Put 044, 046 scope for him.They've certs and exp. But, who do u think they beg for setting up the beloved OWA with that SSL? fixing exchange when priv.edb filled the disk w/ eseutil? RRAS, VPN? Still like expd ppl? How come a 19 yr old, no cert, highschool dropout is a senioradmin in SP. Must?ve started at 10 then. Seen his basement w/ 24 computers? When u know, u know and ppl know. Thanks for listening. Me? I am just a stupid designer.

by t. e. walker

Many managers lack the technical expertise to judge knowledge. They rely, at least in part, upon paper certifications to judge whether someone has the requisite knowledge for a job. I did not get a job a few years ago due to a lack of certain certifications, despite my 10 years experience. The job went to a person who had the paper but not the knowledge. The kicker was that it was an in-house position and I was working in the same office, and he came to see me 4-6 times a day to ask my helpwith something. The moral of the story is: paper counts. Sometimes more than what you know.

by brkeck

I don't know about the rest of the world but during my time in the military we always thought of the 'junior' officers (Ensigns and Lts) as being or becoming 'fully qualified' .... it was only when you started competing at the field grade level thatyou started competing as 'best qualified'. The same might be said of certification. A certificate is the first hurdle to becoming fully qualified in my opinion ... and represents only that the individual has received the basic training needed. Just like an apprentice may have just graduated school ... there is no way that someone with only a certificate can be anything more than an apprentice ...

by bfanska

I am a computer/network tech and server administrator that began before the "certifications". Recently, without any formal training, I passed a series of certification tests at the request of one of my customers. The point is that the certs are good, but nothing replaces experience.

by its a secret

How about an internship
I believe there should be an internship (like ASE cert Mech.). Take the test and pass, plus two years practical experience in the feild, before you can display your certs. (mechanix,doctors,dentist... do it)

by chucko76

I am a director of IT and occasionally post IT jobs to be filled. I do not use recruiters. If you are a paper MCSE looking for experience, you should make that clear in the cover letter or e-mail reply to the ad. I recently posted a job for an Entry Level help desk position. I received over 100 resumes about half of which were MCSE and MCP holders with no experience. As a manager who has to keep vacancies filled and train replacements, I am not going to hire an MCSE or person with a BS in Computer Science for an entry level job. My impression, and I am sure other managers feel the same, I am not going to train you and give you the experience while you are searching for a better job for more money on your breaks. If you want to get the experience, be up front in the first contact and if you get the interview make the committment to stay and grow with the company.

by cliff.meyer

True, paper does not necessarily make you knowledgeable, but that goes with all paper. I know people with a BS or MBA who are not worth the paper either. Some people are hobbyist at what they do and in many ways that is better than any professional experience. So cirt or no cirt it?s really what they no and not what they can put on their resume, and that includes experience

by rodney.smith

Your statements are true, however we in the industry need to work hard to get that view to the upper management of companies. In my department, we have 4 IT techs with a combined experience total of over 40 years and 3 BS degrees, 1 CCNA, and also an AS. With all of this I've still been given several warnings that I don't have an MSCE...why, because today those who are not so computer savy feel that unless you are MS certified, your nothing. It's sad, but it's true

by waddell_lee

I am an A+ certified technician with an electronics background that trains prospective IT pros. I also train them on networking essentials for the MS Net Essentials exam that a partner that I work with (who is an MCT) neglects to fill them in on thefull story. His students are repairing computers without any knowledge and experience and touting that they can repair computers. They then bring these computers to me to repair their mistakes. I finally said "if you want to be a PC tech and advertise that you are something that you are not, then you should fix your own mistakes." I totally agree that we have many certified individuals that are besmirching our professions and that they should have the practical knowledge and experience to get the job done.

by basicdogs

Again, blame the company you are working for. For the most part, we are talking about young people. People who were told that study and certification would make them computer gods. Most of them have no idea how little they really know until faced with a problem.

by jlyons

It's interesting that we should spend so much time in a topic such as this "and look at me Im reading it all too". It takes all kinds of people to make a good IT group or IS department. Imagine if we were all senior MCSE+, or all juniors, that wouldnot work. The fact that some have experience and some have paper, both have learned or gained knowlege through different paths. The real question should be am I doing my job to the point that my company is getting thier monies worth? And if not whatcan I do about it. We need to be more tollerant of each other and realize that everyone starts somewhere. I started with experience and am only now taking the tests, but what does that mean, Im no more or less of good employee because of that. Enjoyyour life in IT and hey "Whats all the fuss?"!

by bolinb

I have to agree. I know of many people who have certifications of one type or another that have no clue on how to use that information in the real world. I know one MCSE that didn't know some of the basic functions of Windows (Alt + Tab to cycle through different Windows, etc.) I really believe that all certifications need to be redone to include more adaptation and real world testing.

by brian_w

There appears to be two sides to this argument, people who have certs and no experience and people who have experience but no certs. Where are the people with both? I fall into this category and it annoys me that people (in this discussion anyway) now to seem to automatically assume that someone who has an MCSE has to be, as they so eloquently put it a "paper MCSE". Well I know the MCSE is an actual piece of paper but I believe that where my association with such a term ends. I worked for my MCSE over two years whilst working full time in my job as a Net Admin. Studying involved coming home form work and working for 3 hours a night on it and taking tests when I could. I feel that having certifications is a necessary part of my IT career; Iwill be following the 2000 track and am now also attempting the CCNA cert. I wouldn?t belittle the MCSE to the level that some people here have. Yes the tests have been compromised but there are things I learned from studying for the test that I would otherwise not have known, and I have worked with NT for 5 years now. Would I have known the intricacies of domain replication without the test? I doubt it. The MCSE also gives me more confidence to speak with authority on certain subjects in meetings and the like, and those purveyors of doom wont believe it but it still does demand respect out there. I understand the argument "no cert no job" but any hiring manager who cant see from a resume that this person has no experience but is still fully convinced that they can run their 1,000 node WAN without any problems because they have an MCSE doesn?t deserve to be in a management position.

by brian_w

The 2000 track will weed out clueless people at the outset. The number of MCSES will probably be cut by 75%. That?s a good thing. However as people become more familiar with the tests, there is going to be a certain amount of degradation and the number of MCSE's will rise again. It seems some people won?t be happy until a certification is absolutely impossible to attain. What use would that be to anyone, least of all Microsoft.
What I would like to see is Microsoft demand that people meet a certain criteria to qualify them to take the tests. Much like Compaq do with their ASE certification, you have to be an MCSE to sit. That qualification could be a verifiable number of years experience, a lesser certification. Something. It would also be good if the MCSE track had exams that built on each other. You start with an exam like Net Essentials; the next test includes its own material but encompasses the curriculum covered in the first, and so on. This would certainly stop people from cramming from one test and then forgetting the knowledge once they past it. By the time you do your last elective you would have to have as good a knowledge with your first test, as you do with this, your last, as questions related to the first will still pop up. Well your supposed to be certified in it so is it not fair to expect you to know it.
That?s it for now; in my opinion certification is a good thing.

by its a secret

I agree. I have met more to use the term paper certs. who are thinking this is the way to attain a fortune quick and cheap. They do not realize that IT is very demanding. They will be weeded out soon enuff. I have met a few who have the passion andare top notch. I really think that an internship following the exams would give the whole industry validation. I believe the certs are worth the effort.

by basicdogs

All praise Allah, or Jesus, or a cookie for all I care. I'll praise Brian. For the most intelligent postings I have seen. Everything I was thinking, and just couldn't form into words. Now I think I can stop posting to this debate, he has covered allthe bases I wanted set fire to moments ago.

by cliff.meyer

I fully agree. I put in a lot of time studying on my own for my MCSE+I and my MCNE while working in many different network engineering positions. I feel that it brought knowledge out that not even my current manager with 6 years experience, BSCS andwith no certification knows. Even with all those years ?experience? and a degree he still comes to me for the answers, more often than not. Just because you work for someone for a period of time does not mean you really have the knowledge. We just let someone go after working here for over 4 years. Why you ask? He could not engineer his way out of a wet paper bag. Politics was the only thing keeping him here. He still can show work experience of 4 years though.

by cliff.meyer

? to continue, I am not saying my manager is not knowledgeable. In fact quite the contrary, he is extremely knowledgeable, but even with all of his experience, and mine we still find ourselves asking each other questions from time to time. I say that at least one third the time my answers comes from my studying for my MCSE, and not just the 8 years experience I have. I recently setup an Intranet site and a FTP site which, believe or not, I had never done before. If I had not studied to obtain my MCSE+I, I would not have been able to accomplish this easily. I do not like the idea of testing prospective employees, but asking a few technical questions related to their future responsibilities probably is a good idea.

by moehrinp

4 Certifications and several years doing volunteer desktop & networking support landed me a job as a "Network Support Tech.
The jobs about ideal and was worth the effort and I am exposed to more than I can handle at one time and am happily working away, without the certs it wouldn't have happened.

by brandon_ricci

Ok to me a certification is more than a piece of paper. I spent the last six months studying like I have never studied before, and working with computers. I receive A?s in all my classes. To me this is a major accomplishment. True I have very littleexperience, however with some time and good training which is the most important thing I will be very successful. The question is do you want someone certified with no experience or someone not certified with no experience. What I am trying to say is give us a break cultivate what we have learned instead of dismissing it.

by ygg

I hear a lot about people that are certifide but don't know much. You need experience to be good. But give some credit to those who got certification and if you can, give them a job that will let the get the experiece too. Complain about people who are cerifide and have a lot of experience and don't know much.

by adrian c

Lol... I sympathize with your employee situation.
People seem to focus on MS when generally talking certification. What I wanted to emphasize is the cost of even more irrelevant exams in terms of actually performing on the job. What do actually prove N+ and i-Net+? Even less than a MCP I think. And MS exams are quite cheap compared to the others. Actually, even CCNA and CCNP are comparable in terms of prices to CompTIA's own ($100-200 in the US, $150-300 outside).
CCIE is a huge exception. Itcosts both arms and legs, takes total dedication... An individual passing that *is* IT elite.
That is if they can get an american or canadian visa to go to the center and take the test. ;-)
However, in theory, a practical exam is an excellent idea. Red Hat cert requires one. Maybe implementing it under the form of a software simulation would do the trick.
Someone asked here a good question. If having the experience and admitting to the benefits of being certified, why not just take the damn exams instead of just moaning and bitching about those worthless paper whatever?

by teburlew

I totally agree with your observation.
After 29 years in this field, the last 5 as a Senior Technical Architect, I am finally going for my MCSE. I interview 5 to 10 "certified" candidates per week on average. I reject most of them because they don't know enough to perform the work we expect. The only reason I am going for the MCSE is to help the consulting firm I work for maintain their MCSP designation. Besides, in consulting Cert + Experience means more to most clients than not having the cert in the first place.
If one doesn't have a solid 1-3 years MINIMUM to back up their certification, I find them basically useless and unhirable.

by darlene

I started completely green, never having a computer class in my life. I studied my butt of and got my MCSE and CCNA. I then got a job at the bottom of the totem pole doing network admin assistant stuff and deskside support. I would have never gotten the job if I didn't have the certs because I had no experience. The certs gave me enough background to learn quickly and build skills.

I haven't been in the industry for years and I didn't spend my teenage years hacking. Certs were the only way I could break into the IT field. Everyone is whining about the IT worker shortage, but if you give a paper MCSE a chance, they might just fit your needs. I was a paper MCSE but now I'm a real one.

Katie

by isc unlimited

I would have to agree with you, but only to a certain point. Recently I started classes for MCSE certification, simply because the new job I was after required it. To me, I have always believed experience can FAR outweigh ANYTHING certification can do for you. I have always been self-taught right from the start. Now, I teach others - and I don't have a single sheet of paper that says, "I know what I know". The fact remains that I STILL know it. It's true, certifications can lie, but it doesn't mean that everyone who has them is JUST "certified."

by rodney.smith

I completely agree, the fact is that most of the MCSE holders I have interviewed and eventually let go have been quite impressive on paper but have little or no experience in the field, and worse yet have absolutely no knowledge of older non-GUI systems. How can an individual claim to be an IT proffesional and not have knowledge of the foundation(s) of todays systems. I say if you can't do a simple DOS copy across a network you shouldn't be able to work in the field.

by sdefor

I have been administering a enterprise network for 3 years without any formal training. So I decided to increase my worth and become certified. First I have gone through A+ certification and passed with no problems whatsoever. However there was something that i noticed while I was taking classes... It seems to me that there are alot of people trying to jump on the "money train of technology" with no prior experience with even the most elementary understanding of PC computing and Networking. Granted I have learned alot from experience, and learned much more from training. What remains is that I see more and more individuals entering the field with little or no experience. Hopefully adaptive testing with scenario based questions will weed out the phonies.