Discussion Locked

Certifications doesn't measure

0 helpful
414 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

414 replies

by rdean97588

I too am an MCP. I have 10 years experience as an SA in Novell and 2+ with Windows NT and tons of work experience, but I am woman and we don't get the same kind of opportunities that men do. Men seem to get thrown into their first IT Tech positions. Women have to be brighter than the brightest with A's etc. I have taken the NT 4.0 srvr test 2 times recently and failed by a slim margin the 2nd time (today), but I know what to do on building a machine, or how to administer a domain. I am gladyou think the tests are so easy.

by gonzo2

I hope someone is moderating this discussion of "paper MCSE's".

I am not a MSCE, though I have spent many years at the sharp and pointy end of IT Tech Support. I do not purport to have a strong opinion either way, there are good MCSE's and bad ones, good and bad "non=certified" IT support staff. It all depends on results. I have worked with MCSE's who had _no_ _clue_ what to do with what they had learned from cheat sheets in a real life situation. I do feel that hands on is entirely missing in certification training and that Microsoft and the Certification centers may not hold up to scrutiny in this issue.

Kind you I'm not too fond either of Microsoft's attitude on behalf of the MCSE's hung out to dry on the Win2k issue...

by shamesh

Hai,
I am shamesh. I am a CCNA,MCSE,CNA(3.x&5.x)and an IBM Certified Instrctor. I believe that certification is a must to get the solid background. But as some friends said certification can be done by memorizing some questions. But there you should not cheat yourself by doing like that. And dont relay upon any dump questions / sites.

by frank

Those that complain about certification rarely have one. Good professionals will continue to certify as an augmentation of their experience. Weak and lazy technicians will rest on their laurels and continue to whine.

by rgatch

I manage a 50 client nt domain and am not certified in anything. I would love to get certified in all that's available. Im just too busy with real life situations to find the spare dedicated time and space required.
Certification and good experience are great partners. I hope to make the time soon.

by teburlew

For some of us, married with children, it is not a sign of lazyness to not get certified. There is a thing called time. Time to study and/or take the exam along with the money for a family have to be weighed against PDO (the corporate world's way of reducing your time off) and expense. I know many people in the industry like myself that don't have the time to take away from family and job to get certified. Also, those of us in consulting, downtime, also known as bench time, is the only non-productive time you have to study and or take exams. I have the next two weeks scheduled as bench time. I plan to take that non billable bench time and write all my MCSE exams back-to-back before my next billing time starts after labour day. It isNOT a case of lazyness, it is a case of priorities; making money and raising a family come first to some of us. On the other hand, if you are rich and single, with lots of time, then it is a case of laziness.

by spytooth

That was great advice. I got my MCSE and then found an entry level job. I've since added A+ and Network+ and continue to learn every day. I didn't start at what the salary surveys say but I am very happy and love my job. I'm up for a raise soon and am working to help the less knowledgeable in my department to learn. I am taking on more responsibilties and working to build a future here. I have tailored my training to my company's needs and know that I am building value here as well as the rest of the world. We all chose this profession and all that comes with it. My only suggestion is that if you don't love what you do then you need to go do what you love. And some of us here could stand to work on our general business skills, like spelling and writing skills. I hope that you realize that basic communication skills and business skills are just as important as technical certifications.

by mooseman

these old guys are so jealous, what a waste, maybe this is a crummy field to break into which all the bitterness and bile that the old timers spew forth. Don't help out the new guy, he may take your job from you. A band of pirates would be more fun to work with.

by teburlew

I may be one of those "old guys", but I am not your enemy. I enjoy mentoring you up and coming newbies and hope to impart some of my hard earned knowledge. The greatest thrill I get out of being a consultant is when a client or new consultant can keep up with or exceed me technically. It just means that I did my job in passing the tourch. Ok, so I don't have the same attitude of most of the rest of my generation, those of us who caused Y2K, but, us older and wiser ITers are not all against you.

by ronjodie

You need the experince to be able to handle the unusual problems that come along. Theory only gets you so far. Customers look to the certification as making that person an expert and we all know that is not true. Maybe Microsoft can make different levels of MCSE with takes in account experience, just an idea.

by edrox

Hi,

I think certification helps.
But we need to give certification the proper weight it should have.
I have worked in IT for 5 years.
I started certification after three years and learned a lot of theory which improved my work, but if I would have started the certification immediately I would have learned the text without understanding it.

Let's face it, certification without experience show 2 things;
- The person has the theory to do the job, not the practical knowledge.
- The person is really dedicated to make it in the industry since (s)he put a lot of effort into becoming certified.

At our company, or at least in our department, we are willing to hire certified people without experience as long as they know their place, everyone starts at the helpdesk to learn the basics, and can then move on.

We did this at a large consulting company, and I try to do it now at my new company where I work as a team leader.

Regards,

Eduard de Vries
edevries@footlocker.com
MCSE, CNE 4.11/5

by dgoldberg1

As someone who is going to school to learn IT skills I think a good way to solve the certification over experience problem would be the forming of IT apprenticeships. Go to school at night, do the job during the day. Large companies would benefit from such a plan by having a constant supply of qualified personel to hire from.

by teburlew

That's how I started in IT when I got out of the US Army at the end of the Viet Nam war. However, back then, the companies ran the training. We went to school mornings, and worked in the department in the afternoons applying what we learned. Thenonce a month, we spent two full days in class followed by one full day of exams. You signed up for a six-month apprenticeship. When each of us got out of the apprenticeship and started our full-time assignments, we were as productive as our fellowprogrammers. Trouble with today is that most companies don't want to pay or be bothered paying someone to learn. Again, I think you are on to something; bring back apprenticeships.

by Member 24557189

I came from an industry that has apprenticeship programs. In time, "apprenticeship" translates to "Free Labor". Or a lot cheaper anyway. This system doesn't take long to become rife with corruption. It can easily be a system of keeping cheap labor supplied to the "man".

by bestweet

You sound like you're guarding your status jealously. People have been lied to, promised a good salary without anyone delivering, and you have the gall to tell these "paper" certified techs to quit whining?! Most of the time, experience is overrated. A company will tell you, "Forget what you've learned and do it our way." Or they're too lazy or paranoid to train newly certified techs. The rationalization: they might bolt within a year. Bull$#^%!!! It's just a copout.

by bestweet

This is exactly the point. I am a recently certified--but unemployed--A+ tech, and I can't even get an entry-level job as a lowly computer assembler because of the old catch-22. On the other hand, I taught myself how to build computers, and the one I'm using is built at my own hands. There is more to it than just certification vs. experience. Although experience is valuable, where does a newbie start? At an unpaid position? It shouldn't be (last I checked, slavery was illegal).
Just look beneath the surface, read between the lines companies feed you and you'll see the rampant prejudice and jealousy. Just ask and 40+ crowd put out to pasture due to kids' bigotry. Just ask women and minorities, otherwise qualified and you'll get the truth. No whine, just fact.

by mason.smith

I hear a lot of people saying that certifications are just pieces of paper. What I've found after job searching is that without the certification no one wants to look at you. I put my certifications on and everyone is banging down my door.

by teburlew

I understand your point. But, if you have good enough credentials in the first place, you don't need the certification to get looked at. Your reputation as a guru holds more weight than a cert. I havn't had a cert yet and after 29 years in IT, even when I am not looking, I get a path beaten to my door. I'm only getting my certs to help my employer maintain their MCSP.

by teburlew

Jerry here hit the nail on the head. It is really the old chicken and egg situation. You need the cert for recognition and you need either knowledge or experience for the cert. Knowledge is golden either from books or on the job. My first mentorin consulting reminded me that we are only as useful as our KNOWLEDGE. So, the more each of us knows, the more marketable we are. Also, you are "right on" as far as telling the truth and be realistic as to where you fit in the job market. I interview many certified and uncertified individuals weekly, and I give them both the exact same weight when considering them for positions. They have to pass our company's stringent technical screening process of several tech interviews followed by computerized TechCheck exams. It all comes down to practical application of knowledge like Jerry said.

by teburlew

I would recommend working in the computer lab at school. Also, look at summer intern programs. At a previous company, I hired a summer intern as a full-time IT employee once they graduated. By doing this, you receive a realistic compensation for your experience (new BSCS) and then after 6-12 months go for your cert. Even in consulting, we take new grads who have proven thenselves by working outside the classroom. I have even hired an outstanding grad simply based on his work-study experience for his senior project for a real employer. Go for experience, any experience, then study for your cert.

by bethll

I, too, started out green. I knew enough to know I did not know enough. My first IT job was as a level one at a Help Desk. I studied, followed the experts around, pestered everyone, enrolled in more classes and now I work in engineering support.I'm still not where I want to be, but the CNA opened the door for me. I've come to believe, certifications show a person can learn computers but, the information becomes dated almost as soon as it is taught. There is so much to learn and so littletime . . ..

by andywright

Personally i think the big problem with the entire MCSE certification is that its very much presented in a "the world according to microsoft" way. A lot of stuff thats covered throughout the courses and exams is stuff that with experience you know would never be done in the real world. This is where the Paper guy might have problems as they won't know the difference. I think to solve the Paper MCSE issues MS should do an advanced MCSE which you can only obtain with company sponsorship or something like that.

I still think an MCSE with no experience is a valid approach to breaking into IT. But only with realistic expectations. So many of them think they deserve to be network admins the day they pass. It only when idiots let them do thisthat you'll find them lacking.

by tony

Experience is the way to go, but to get experience you need a job, to get a job today you need a cert. Even though a cert. is just a piece of paper and lots of bookwork, in todays job market you need it.

by fluxit

Over the years I have spent nearly $25k on training and certifications as post college development. However, I have never realized a return ($) on that knowledge investment. Employers use certs as a filter mechanism either to supress pay if you lackit or state you are over qual'd if you do have it. Moreover, as the employer I have let go more people with certs for lack of problem solving skills. I typically seek the potential employee who has state-of-the-art in his home and does not have a cert. In short, vendor certs are nothing more than glorified menu training and having little to do with problem solving skills and developing business solutions. IT staffs need better training in problem solving and business operations than software menus.

by teburlew

The truth comes out. However, one of my co-consultants just completed his Oracle 8i exam and he reminded me that he would have failed if he hadn't already installed and managed 3-4 databases before taking the test. Also, your point about developing better problem solving skills is quite true. If you can't program your way out of a wet paper bag, your cert is useless. I side with you. Let's improve training courses and then maybe certs will have meaning.

by netmarcos

My experience has been the exact opposite. The certs I hold have been my calling card to some very lucrative engagements. While it is true that certification alone does not guarantee competence, it does show aptitude. As for certification exam questions not being relevant to business solutions, I recommend that you look at the Windows 2000 core exams or the current CCNA requirements. Pass Microsoft's 70-216 - Implementing and Administering a Microsoft Windows 2000 Network Infrastructure exam and then come tell me that it requires nothing more than "glorified menu training". The vendors are aware of popular opinion and will try to counter negative impressions with improved products; this includes certification exams.

Just because it appeared to be true yesterday, does not guarantee that it will be true tomorrow.

by mooseman

mrmiami: Netmarcos seems to have made an effective rebuttal of your observations. Would you please respond to his post? Your opinion would be valued.

by fluxit

Granted I have not taken any recent exams resulting from past experiences. Its great if 'vendors' are addressing some business issues. Are these financial and operational issues (understanding financial reporting documents and operational concepts often taught by APICS) or are they administrative business solutions (ie improved ways of administering IT to reduce cost and improve stability)?

In business we need well rounded staff. Users need a little technical savvy but IT staff must have a strong business savvy as its impacts are broad and sweeping on an organization. Desktop support not only should solve a technical problem but provide insight to the company that better leverages technolgy in the workplace. They can do this by understanding the users job but don't have to be able to do the users job.

by fluxit

Case and point. I run a cell that monitors a large WAN for IT Attacks and network status. My staff had marginal technical skill. Mainly they knew Win98 and NT. However, we had firewalls, UNIX, intrusion detection, Network management probes, Data collectors etc... My workforce was almost robotic performing procedures over and over. I was seeing no situational awareness and rcv'd no feedback. So I set out to create my own training program. I established 3 tiers. Foundational knowledge, Skills andtooling Development, and training on situational awareness. The return I got was phenomenal. Moral went through the roof. My staff now is regularly providing feedback and has situational awareness solving problems without my involvement. To continue...

by fluxit

But early on my staff was almost always gone in some kind of certification program and not contributing to the work effort. They were getting cisco and mcse certs. They got training on Visual C++, Oracle, and other software. Then returning to thier procedures within the cell. Happy with the training they would take off for another job shortly thereafter. I Know what they were thinking since I did consulting at one time too. Now I keep my staff in the cell and train new employees within 6 monthsusing a Personnel Qualification Standard. I find they are more interested in thier job and its become a competitive game to detect threats and faults on the WAN. I am getting more bang for my buck. Now Netmarcos is one of those consultant types andthe certification is a marketing tool to perspective clients who expect a 'higher' level expert and are willing to pay for it. But his engagements are focused on a specific technical issue and when resolved he is on to the next client. My staff hasa much broader scope and must understand the operations enough to support it. At the Situational awareness level is where everything comes together. I see the cert programs as only a small piece of the second level of training. I am glad to see thatvendors are addressing the issues. However, I think the industry needs to address a far more comprehensive training plan for the IT professional that is not vendor specific.

by sal37

I agree, there are too many Paper Certs going around, I have MY A+ and other online certs. I earned them because i know what i am doing in this computer industry of today.

The day this industry stops looking at people in college and technical schools that push "how to take the test" and start looking at true hands-on people this industry will be better off and people like myself can earn a great salary because i deserve it not because i took four years of college or a technical school to teach me how to just take a test.

by monyhunter

You have to look at the facts. There are not enough IT people out there right now. It is only going to get worse. How in the heck are new people supposed to get started in the field. They have to start somewhere. I would rather be a paper mcse than just someone who wanted to work with computers. I know experience is needed, but I had to start somewhere. I would NOT have been able to find my first IT job had it not been for my cert. Now that I am in the door I can work on experience. Some of you "vetrans" need to look at what you are saying. You sound like you "don't play well with others" and are very clickish. Grow up and look at the whole picture. THERE WILL ALWAYS BE PAPER MCSE's!!!! Learn to live with it or get out of IT.

by rmccain

I find that if an MCP can not use proper gammer then maybe he should look at another carear....After that I really feel shy to mention me as MCP. Microsoft ( and all other certification autorites) should be carefull of it, and maintain the quality. Otherwise certifications will be meaningless.

Enter Comment/Question:

Title of Reply:

(max length: 40; defaults to first characters of Body if not specified)
Body:
I find that if an MCP can not use proper gammer then maybe heshould look at another carear.... After that I really feel shy to mention me as MCP. Microsoft ( and all other certification autorites) should be carefull of it, and maintain the quality. Otherwise certifications will be meaningless.

Enter Comment/Question:

Title of Reply:

(max length: 40; defaults to first characters of Body if not specified)
Body:
I find that if an MCP can not use proper gammer then maybe he should look at another carear.... "After that I really feel shy to mention me as MCP."
(max length: 1930)

Review Alias:

Current alias: rmccain@landstar.com

NOTE:The alias above will appear as your attribution both in discussions and in our Technical Q&A. If you'd like to change your alias,follow this link to your Passport details page.

(max length: 1930)

Review Alias:

Current alias: rmccain@landstar.com

NOTE:The alias above will appear as your attribution both in discussions and in our Technical Q&A.If you'd like to change your alias, follow this link to your Passport details page.

by netmarcos

Now, that was really embarrassing. The instances of poor spelling and grammar in your posting clearly identify you as one of those against whom you rant. I highly recommend that you enroll in a basic english class at your local college or community outreach program.

by wvfd_32

I am not a consultant, but a full time employee for a large corporation. To me, the only time certification is needed is during a job search. I first entered the IT field with Novell 3.12, over eight years ago. I spent a lot of time and money getting my CNA, and then my CNE. This certification opened doors for me. However, this certification is now useless, and about to expire. I have no plans to update my Novell certification, or get certified with Microsoft. I am an NT administrator, and havebeen for several years now with no certification. And I get MCSE certified coworkers asking me for help all the time. If I ever think about leaving this company, then I will get my certification. And I will use all the brain dump and demo tests I can find simply to make the exams quick and painless. The certification may open doors, but the experience will get the job.

by fdisk18

Try having the certificates and being female.
I eat, sleep and dream computers. I just wish someone would give US the chance.

If you are male you are one step ahead of the game. I know of someone in the IT profession who earns 70,000+ a year and has no certification behind him. So I guess in some situations experience is everything!

I think the answer is to do volunteer work until you feel you have some experience behind you. Sometimes you have to suffer to get anywhere in life. I think the IT profession is one of them. When you get there though you'll have it made!!!!!!

by zaarkahn

I just interviewed 5 prospective IT folks for a position and the only female beat out the other four males. SHe didn't get the job because she was female, but because of her knowledge and yes, certifications. Experience played a large role as well. I have however hired someone based solely on their experience...lots of it. Part of the interview process is a questionaire targeted towards the position they are applying for. No questionaire for entry level positions. Certifications and experience must go hand in hand. If you are an IT Manager and have entry level positions, give the "newbies" a start.

by Member 24557189

Try being new to the professional side of IT. I've been living and breathing computers for ten years. Where would I get without certs? Not even an interview. Gota get the certs to get your foot in the door.

by quantdoc

The certification process should not be done in a 5 day boot camp.

It should be a process, like other engineering disiplines, that evolves over years.

In the old days, the guilds had apprentice, journyman, tradesman and master. Each rank signified several years of training and experience.

Maybe we should return to that type of mentality.

by nathan_fisher

You seem to have a problem with an incompetent employee who is a CIS major at college. Well, you know what? Two years out of college I have been promoted 5 times. I went to college because support for me is fun, but I didn't want to do it forever. Itook 3 internships while in school and have my A+, MCP, and 6 years experience. I'm sick of these construction workers and has-beens taking the MCSE and getting paid more than me (two years ago). This market has become flooded, and the need is moving towards people who have the ability to put IT support into a "can". The simpler and more defined you make the support functions, the less skilled labor and less pay you need to part with. In my major, I got a great understanding of all areas of IS (6 programming languages, database, networking, etc). I also took some accounting, statistic, psych, security, investigation, and writing classes. Couple that with 3 internships where I worked with hardware, and you have one person that will move to the top. This problem employee you are talking about will be your boss within 2 years of graduation. She does not need to be the best tech, but have the comprehension of what your job entails. Start puckering for her now..

by adrian c

First of all, I think Jerry didn't mean it the way you took it and it was quite clear in the posting.
Second, just for the record, I have a BS in Computer Science and had a few collegues that were both an insult and a threat to human intelligence and still managed to graduate.
Good for you if you did all that stuff, but I don't think I'd want you for a boss.
By the way, just praise your lucky stars for not being born somewhere in the 3rd world.

by uma

I was reading number of discussions regarding certification. I feel some of those points are not true because if someone has a certification, he will definitely know about the subject. He may not be a Guru but definitely have some knowledge on the subject. This gives the interviewer a sense of confidence that he may be the right person to do the job instead of trying some "non-certified" person. I also agree that experience matters, but if you have the certification with experience, that will make a lot of difference.

by precious2dmosthigh

I think you should do exactly want you want to do. You must realise that all these people are giving their own personal judgements which can be biased at times. On the other hand, they advise to the best ability and might not be right, the decision is still yours to take. If you want to go for certs, you should. You cannot loose out for doing this - it can only be an addition, of course you have to make full use of what you learn, but the certs will be an addition to you.

by kai66

Your suggestion for a better MCSE certification program is a valid one. However, it'll never be done in real life. First of all, Microsoft will not make their exams being too hard or having too many requirements, this prevents them from having more people taking the exams and they would result in making less money. Second of all, not all training schools out there are willing to do this. By providing extra hours of hands-on experience labs and verfifying tests, it'll lengthen the course time and thus resulting in fewer classes/students over a period of time, and therefore meaning either higher cost for the course or less money made by the training school. With the kind of competition out there for training schools, I don't think too many of them would want to do this. Let's say one school offer complete MCSE course with 600+ hours of hands on lab experience, for $8000, and takes nearly a year to finish. Another school offering the same MCSE course package with little or no hands-on lab experience, all for less than $1500 and can be done in less than half a year. Which one would you choose?

by kai66

Even if you are a CNE, it doesn't necessary mean you know something about PC. There are many MCSEs and CNEs I've come across knowing who don't know anything about DOS. Because DOS isn't part of MCSE or CNE and the exams certainly don't require youto know it either. But think about it, it's very stupid for someone who's a MCSE or CNE not to know anything about DOS. DOS is supposed to be a pre-requisite for any certification out there, but apparently most people find their ways to obtain MCSE or CNE without having to learn DOS.

by mking

The value of certifications has long been questioned, particualiry by those of us who have been in the business for a number of years. I have been commercially providing services to corporations as a consultant for over 12 years, started using computers about 1978, I have never been in a position that allowed me to worry about persuing the certifications. I have however, repeatedly, gone in after a 'papered fool' and cleaned up. I think there needs to be more to getting a job than just a certification, experience has to be counted. Are certifications worth the money they cost individuals or companies that underwrite their personnel's training/certification process? I think it is dependant upon whether the employee (or individual) treats itas an opportunity to begin learning: NOT STOP, propping up the rest of their professional lives on that piece of paper.
Knowledge without application is as useless than no knowledge at all.
It is the mind set of 'students' that requires an adjustment. A certification doesn't, and shouldn't, be a garrauntee of magnificant salary unless one has the practicale experience to back it up.

by durocshark

I've been in the biz for about 3 years now. Started off as a tech in a small computer shop, and ended up as a helpdesk "lead" or "senior" or whatever you want to call it. I make more money than anyone I know.

Know what? I've got no certs or degrees. I'm just good at customer service, troubleshooting, and I spend as much time as possible tinkering with machines and software. But I'm finding it hard to make any kind of position as a manager without a piece of paper. I've essentially run into abrick wall.

I'm sure I could get a cert of some kind, depending on where I want to go from here. MCSE, CNA, etc. Get a somewhat larger salary, and get up that friggin corp ladder.

A cert isn't necessary for everything, but you've gotta get inthe door first. If I hadn't had that first job fixing and selling PC's 3 years ago, I'd still be waiting tables. A cert wouldn't have done much at that point without that first job.

by teburlew

I couldn't have said it any better myself. Even though I am now going for my MCDBA and MCSE back to back, it not to get a better job or more money. You said one thing I tell everyone starting out... Congratulations, you now know how to study. Nowdo that for the rest of your life. In this business you must continue to learn each and every day. Again, well said.

by lapavoni

Congratulations on your success, Kate. I would like to comment just a bit on your comments. I, too, never had a "computer class in my life", but that didn't make me "green". I bought a computer when I was 25, played with it, tinkered, and taught myself the fundamentals. I had an interest in, and a knack for, working with the technology. I realize that your perception is that "network admin stuff and deskside support" is "bottom of the totem pole", but those things certainly are not at the bottom. Data Entry and perhaps Help Desk positions are more accurately "bottom of the totem pole". I'm sure in your geographic area along with your limited hands-on experience, your MCSE has assisted you immmensely in the field, but I suspect that you, too, have a knack for computers, system administration, etc. Where I work, we simply cannot afford the time or training expense of just "giving an MCSE a chance." If you have a moderate amount of work experience, some computer savvy, and are a good communicator/"people" person, then your MCSE will go a long way in *supplementing* your experience and abilities. It will *not* replace them.

by wwong

I totally agree with you. I finished my MCSE in 3-months. I quit my job before I began, just to do nothing more than to be able to concentrate and focus all my energy into studying the material. Now, with only about 5-months of desktop support and my "Paper MCSE", I am a MIS Manager. This was mainly due to the part of me explaining my basic experience and my learnability. They realized I had minimal experience in the real world supporting a whole network with the works, however, I was givin the chance to prove my-self. They asked me "can you learn what you don't know"? Ahhh..answer is? YES! I believe you need your MCSE to get your foot in the door, then it's up to the person to learn as much as he can and find as many resources as he can. Hey! I'm still learning! So, please give us Paper MCSE's some slack. Most of us put a lot of effort into obtaining this certificate and I am very proud of it!

by rlafflick

I am an MCSE and I think the whole Certification is your path to true fulfilment and recognition was a whole farce perpetuated by Microsoft, COMPTIA and a whole lot of organizations. Tests have never been a true test of knowledge since a crash course and intensive reading of materials could take you through the test sucessfully. The whole MCSE Winnie whatever certification has not proven anything to me or helped me in any way and i have seen people with MCP certifications that cannot map a network drive. this whole certification gamut is a ruse which is why i have taken on UNIX and i am getting more fulfilment from that in less than a year than i have gotten from microsoft winnies for the last five years

by mjaneczk

What I mean is that all the current certifications are for an individual product. Thus, if I am certified in MS technology, I tend to only think in a MS manner! "I've got a hammer, and everything is a nail!" type of mentality doesn't do well for any certification. We need a non-product specific certification - kind of like the PE (Professional Engineering) certification they have in the engineering field.

by keblerelf

First off I want to commend you on taking the step to do the tests in advance...lot's of people simply don't want to put forth any initiative whether they have experience or not. I can see both sides...it definitely does help you get in the door. The problem I have is those that took high level jobs by "faking" experience by having nothing but tests. When working on fast paced consulting projects I've ended up having many projects go long over deadline due to waiting on paper MCSE's that got the job due to the cert but had no experience and honestly didn't have a clue as to what they were doing. In regards to if someone hired a paper MCSE over myself since I don't have it but have tons of experience, well "They get what they pay for". Maybe the other guy will turn out great...more than likely not. I'd rather work somewhere that isn't solely looking for certs anyway so I don't really care. Either way though I don't like the fact that lots of paper MCSE's go on about how they are betterthan experienced IT individuals without certs. I don't have them but then for numerous years now I've worked 80+ work weeks. Months on end I'd do 100+ hour weeks. I simply don't have the time and if an employer takes someone that had nothing more todo than study while working a normal job over someone working their ass off actually doing the job then screw 'em...they're not worth working for.

by keithwilliamsatl

Corporations don't want hire nobody without an MCSE or experience. Yet, they don't want train or send someone to training so they can get the experience and training they need, because they're so scared they're going to lose that person to another company.

Yet, they're willing to hire foreign workers with credentials they're unable to check, but who have the certifications.

The problem is not with people who are certified or not certified. The problem is with companies that will not train the people so that they get the experience they need.

by dksj

Certification is not meant to replace experience. People are not born with IT experience and the industry desperately needs new people. Certification is only a tool for employers and other IT professionals for determining whether or not a prospective employee has at least a basic understanding of the job he is applying. This seems to me another self proclaimed IT elitist patting himself on the back.

by jduckett

Certification does matter. It supports your experience. It is up to the employer to make the determination of how much it backs it up. If you've got a paper MCSE before you who only works on the neighborhood friend's computer and a paperless guyswho has been in the field for five years, I would hope the choice would be obvious. However, a lot of credibility is added to the latter fellow when you throw an MCSE at the end of his name.

Also, Microsoft has taken what you have said to heart (well, not you, but the general idea). The MCSE 2000 track is harder than hell and will wash out those people who think an easily achieved piece of paper will get them a good job. This test should seperate the men from the boys.

by dj

I read your post and you mentioned that your manager wanted you to get the certification so he could justify your salary. Was your manager a personal friend of yours? Oh and every Tech guy should know about NWA and Eminem.

by philip_hammer

Certifications are essential in all career fields not just IT. It is the resposibility of the hiring manager to not only ask the crucial questions relating to ones position they are seeking but to use a hands on evaluation in the case of a technical hire.
You are correct in your analysis that certifications without expereince mean very little. But on the other side of the tracks there are those with expereince and no certifications. I firmly believe that if your going to survive and be competative in the IT arena your will need to complete your certifications either through self study or formal classes and focus on your skills set. As a top level manager looking for specific skill sets I view experienced IT professionals with certifications as serious technicians and a bonus to the group. Look at the resumes folks, it's not hard to see the smoke and mirrows and those in questions put to a hands on test.

by tcporet

As you pointed out certifications do not always tell how much experience you have.A better measure of skill is you qualifications
(experience). As some one works toward certification they need to also work toward qualification. That was pointed outto me by a metalurgist while I was working toward a Certified Welding Inspector Certificate. So as you teach always stress the importance of qualification.

by Member 24557189

I agree. They have theirs and you will never be as good as they are because they 'learned the hard way'. These folks are in every walk of life. Don't let people like this discourage you.

by lstrawnadams

I have been in the Computer field for 9 years. I am self taught. I did not have a computer background and I have learned "on the job". A piece of paper is just that. A lot of courses now days can give you the book knowledge, but when you are out the in field, you have to have that hands on knowledge or else you will look like an rookie.
I have an aquaintance who is making the transition from nursing to an MCSE. I am waiting to see how long her new career lasts.
She will have the certification, and virtually zero hands on.

by t_dolman

I think that certification is a bunch of crap! I do not have a MCSE and my most of my day is spent cleaning up a certified tech mess. I think that to many employers rely on industry standards instead of ability to do the job!!!!!!!!!!!!!

by mal4462

I know just what you mean. I am not an MCSE either and yes, I do have to clean up behind a Certified Tech who also calls in outside help when there is anything technical to do. He gets paid only because he has a piece of paper that says he is certified to do his job, but realistically, he is C.R.A.P.

by monyhunter

You can compair your argument like this.::: I think we should not hire one more college grad. Dang if they just don't have any experience. There are to many new grads floating around. We need to stop them from graduating unless they have TONS of experience and are as great and smart as ME. We need to make it harder for young people to ever get that stupid deploma. CAN ALL OF YOU SEE HOW STUPID THIS SOUNDS. TO ME THIS IS THE SAME AS WHAT YOU ARE SAYING ABOUT THE MCSE AND OTHERE CERTS. How can you get a job without something to say what you know. How can you know anything if you don't have a job that will give you the knowledge. Give new people a place to start and if you don't like it move to the mountains where you won't have todeal with people AT ALL!

by rumbottom

I'm just finishing up with my studies.Have not been looking for employment as of yet, but will be soon. I have a bach of bus from "ASU" and an assoc from "Northeastern" in mech eng. I'm afraid I'll have trouble getting work. let me know what y'all think ???

by teburlew

It's too late for a summer intern program. You might try to find a fall one. At the least, latch on to a university lab assistant or post-grad associate in the school's data centre. This at least gives you something on your resume other than class work. Also, check the various local job banks for 6-month intern programs. They do exist though few and far between. That way you have a true reference on your resume. Who knows, whomever you do the internship for may just hire you. At a previous company, I used to do just that. Another area to concentrate on is non-profit or not for profit companies. For experienced people, they pay low. But, for the newbie, they pay the same as others and provide a wealth of experience. Good luck.

by clintoca9

You're correct about brainbench. I maintain computers and equipment and I thought I knew quite a bit, until I took the brainbench exam. Those questions were very challenging and requires you to think twice before answering.

by ayelagin

Yes, I quite agree concerning Brainbench. They have very challenging exams, and their quality (and hardness) is very high. Again, the environment is more realistic: you can use any documentation, but the time is limited, and if you don't know the subject it won't help you much. It has more to do with real life than 'artificial' MSCE tests. By the way, their Delphi sert helped me a lot in my salary...

by yagamishawn

from what i have heard from the discussion is either that you got cert,no experience you are no good.if you got experience without the cert,you are no good either. quite like the chicken and egg things.so think about it,are we going to sent our kidsto work first before enrolling them for high school?or shall we stop education ourself because we thought we have finished our?guys,it all in the name of continue education,education is just the foundation of everythings you want to know about,yes, certification is a demand now,in future it will be a requirment.how are you going to prove that you have more then 5 year of hardcore experience to a company?by just saiding you have?if the longer you work is going to prove that you wil be better,then i might as well not go to school and start young with this industry.

by teburlew

Stay in school, work for IT during summer, and even get your cert (yes, I know I said this differently before.). Then, after you graduate, become a full-time professional Continuing Education student. Besides my 29 years in IT, I am an ordained minister and a Christian councelor. The latter two require annual CE training. I also attend every IT seminar and or new technology training I can afford. So, the bottom line is learn to constantly study and expand your knowledge or the IT world will pass you by overnight.

by mdonley

As I see it, most of the problems relating to certification are induced by the "business" itself and the self-serving "business media". As we're all aware, certification is big business and continues to be a cash cow for the training industry as newand upgraded software products are constantly paraded out. From the standpoint of the small to medium sized business with little to only moderate IT skills in-house, what are they to think? The only criteria they can use to evaluate prospective consultants, vendors, employees and others who would take advantage of them is the certification paper. They do not have the knowledge base to know bs from experience. I have run into way too many clients who have been burned by unscrupulous "computer" people and feel they must protect themselves from being burned again. I for one would love to see some industry-wide certification/license/degree with which we could validate our knowledge and skills as professionals and which would carry the weight and respect of many other types of licnesures. For ourselves and our industry we should develop a program that would insure at least a minimum competentcy with increasing levels comensurate with experience and proficiency. The present certification process will never approach this type of program. Any suggestions?
mark

by dwilcox22

Mark, I like what you said, and I beleive that you have identified what most everyone is saying. There isn't a gauge that can be determined with out experience. Certifcations has prove to be lacking in many instances. The industry is ever changing, and certs does not cover that. Many of us are looking at the viability of alternative operting systems in our structure that is new or not fully developed. But with experience and training we can implement these systems. Training can simply be self-study or class room. But remember -- we all have to continually refine our knowledge to keep our companies competitive in the ever changing marketplace.

by dj

There is no commitment anymore. Companies expect employees to commit but then they won't commit. If you truly wanted a MCSE to stay with your company you would pay an income that would make him want to stay. YOu would assist him with tuition so hecan further develop technical skills.

by fluxit

Check out vendor certs are worthless. Specifically my comments in the discussion. I'd like to hear from you.

MrMiami

by fluxit

Vendor training programs are just a small part of an overall comprehensive training plan. Solid training requires foundational knowledge, tooling (Vendor) training, skills development, and situational awareness training. I established a training plan like this and had phenomenal results with my staff. Situational awareness is where all the training comes together as experience. In short, we actually train experience. What do I mean by that? What makes experience? Time is the conventional wisdom but time can be compressed. Experience is composed of understanding the basics, knowing the capabilities and vulnerabilities of your tools, Skill (the how to's), and knowing what external information or events to draw into the picture. Situationalawareness is the ability to assemble this knowledge and information then make quantum leaps in understanding that is often called experience. We train on all of this and how to assemble this information quickly. My staff gains 'experience' in 6 mos for what my cell does. I believe the IT industry should look and developing professionals in a similiar manner. Moreover, when I was developing this training I trained my inexperienced staff to learn and they developed the training for new staff incoming. Its my belief that anyone can do this. CERTS other than a market tool for consultants are worthless.

by harald.nygaard

I do believe that saying Brainbench has abetter test than Microsoft is oversimplifying the matter. A test that is harder is not necessarily a better test. My experience with both is that they have atendency to test only factual knowledge and not theskills they say they do. Citing a lot facts is not a way to prove your skills. In other words, I beleive it is all a matter of what you want to accomplish with taking a test. Look at Microsofts new tests, like Windows 2000 Network Infrastructure andyou will see that a lot has changed. You do need more practice with the product to pass now.

by amin khair

Unfortunately, <>, I have noticed the same caliber of problems from within the city in which I live, Valdosta, GA. A percentage of folks with certifications, can not implement the solutions they were "trained & certified" to do. However, I do believe that certifications are important to the IT industry, when approached with a serious and willingness to achieve, implement, and learn the materials necessary to empower success. I do wish to praise all those that take on the certification role with an aura of professionalism and assertiveness, and give certifications the realistic and deserving reputations they truly deserve.

RGM

by brucepringle

If you already have a good job getting your certification does one of two things. I gets you about a $5K to $15K raise (I think free evenings and weekends are more valuable than more money) or you send a message to your boss that your getting ready to jump ship. If your happy with your job and your boss is happy who needs em. But if your company is on the skids and you see layoffs coming the certs take a lot of grief out of job hunting.

by merlin

In my opinion, the fault belongs to Microsoft, Novell, Cisco, ect.

Many people trying to better themselves, get the paper as you described with no experience or idea of the real world demands and challenges. The Big Three above, should
require at least some knowledge of networking before the certification class is offered.

Others may just not be cut out for this kind of work. Consider 49% of all Doctors graduated in the lower half of their class.
Scarry isnt it?

by tim.mcduff

Certifications based on my own experience have really enhanced my knowledge and understanding of a particular system. Experience and talent in real world situations however are extremely important. The person you consult with on a problem at 2:00AM may not necessarily be the one with a cert.

by patrickd

Both my 16 year old son and I have taken the A+ certification courses. He passed the Core, but blew the timing on the Win portion.
I didn't take either of the tests as just wanted to be better informed.
To truly become proficient you must use theknowledge on a daily basis. That is a problem for my 16 year old as he doesn't drive. Any suggestions? Anybody need a 16 year old in the Marietta area, cheap?

by thad.andrews

Been her in IT for 11 yrs. Started in parts room rebuilding "dumb" terminals, went into IBM Midrange systems, then started in the 8088 days. Went onto more of the PC environment. Fact of the matter is, I have alot of legacy experience that today's certs will not touch. Certs have their home and as I have read on many replies, they should go hand in hand with experience. Currently Novell 4.11 CNA and working on MCSE and CCNA. It will be nice to add on the resume, but I believe that my exp.will get me just as far.

by tami

In regarding to training not taking place in a 5 day boot camp...agreed...If in fact you are new to the industry. Boot camps are made to quickly certify IN FIELD professionals needing that elusive "piece of paper"....not to educate an entry level employee or person looking to get in field! It is sad that soem training facilities do not screen their students better...new students need a long track, experienced students can handle a boot camp!!

by monyhunter

You can be the judge as to whether the "certs" are good or bad.

About a year ago I learned about the MCSE track and took the plunge spending $6500 on the classes. I spent the money on the classes because I felt I knew nothing. Which was true. I studied VERY hard, and learned a lot. I then started looking for jobs to start getting experience.

I have worked hard to get where I now am. As my knowledge and experience have grown, I have been able to get newer and better paying jobs very fast. I am now working for a great company on a contract project for HP. I now work with 2 others and we support an entire building of 500+ users. I make decent money and it will only get better from here. I feel I have made a "killer" return on my $6500 investment (many people have laughed that I spent so much and even told me it was money wasted) as now I have a very bright career and future.

I don't care what anyone says but I was once a paper MCP/MCSE. I still don't have much time behind my cert, but I am good at what I do. You are going to have "numbskulls" in every field of work you look at, "idiots" are everywhere. But you also have to look at the "paper" MCSE's that have to start somewhere, and end up being very good and skilled techs.

I think there are many people who think they know so much more than everyone else. For some reason they are insecure about having so many people wanting to learn and start careers in IT. I feel there is plenty of room for all of us. Isn't there supposed to be some 1 million new IT jobs in the next 5 years. I feel there is room enough, and the crappy techs will make the skilled techs look much better. (although it is better to NEVER have crappy techs in the first place)

You be the judge for yourself. I for one am VERY glad I did not listen to all the negative crap about "paper MCSE". If I did I would not have such a great future in IT as I do now.

by fcorom

I look at people like you I i would not hire you. I rather hire who knows what they are doing. I have no time to teach you the ropes. when you come work for me, you have to hit the ground running.

by teburlew

Back in the dark ages, when I first got into programming, that is close to what was available. You came in as an apprentice, now called intern, associat programmer, or junior programmer. You trained and worked and qualified to move up to journeyman, called programmer. Then you became a tradesman, called programmer analyst. And finally, Master, called Senior Programmer or more often Manager. Since then, I consult at companies that have the experience level approach even today; IT1, IT2, IT3, SrIT... For those of us who review resumes and recommend applicants, this approach definately shows where an individual's skill level is. My rule of thumb is if it on your resume it is fair game to ask you any in depth question about "it". Those that are certified, I ask practicum questions taken directly from the cert exams. Many fail! Be prepaired to be grilled on both your experience and certifications on a tech interview.

by vyb

I my experience, which has spanned over 4 fours, I've found that even with glowing recommendations and 2-3 years of experience, you will not get any respect without a certification. But the certification means nothing without practical application! Sadly there is no way to test practical knowledge. That can only be seen on the job, something IT managers and HR people will not even give you.

Then the IT industry has the audacity to say that there isn't enough talent in the pool. Baloney! Give the recent graduates, the ones with 2 to 3 years of experience, a chance. You'll see that not only will they do a good job, you'll also give a good AMERICAN a chance to work for a living.

by teburlew

We hire talented college grads with 1-3 years of experience. In fact, I find most of them have no problem passing my technical interviews. None of the new college grads we hired this year had their certifications at the time of hire. At my last company, I worked with the department head of one of the local colleges in Chicago. She provided our company with resumes from the top 5% of each of her graduating class. We tended to take at least one from each class. We then teamed these databaseapplication programmers (SQL, PL/SQL, C++) and teamed them up with an experienced mentor on their first project. We also used them as maintenance programmers for one client while they participated in developing their project skills as a team memberfor a second client. In each case, these new college hires with less than 3 years experience were productive, respected memebers of our project team from day one. And as a comment to another thread in this discussion, all of them are female as thecollege is for women.

by emanisiojo

The industry should give more preference to older network administrators who knows a lot without getting certified. Let the young ones line up. Whatever it is, it does not really matter. If you are past 40 you are out. Why ????? Is this a Miss Universe contest?

by deaner

I'm MCP+I, MSCE and wondering what for? I didn't get the "great job" (had to work help desk at first) even though I had a letter of recommendation from an instructor the content of which contained the line "his knowledge of this subject goes beyond the scope of this training". I've worked a few jobs where management thought that I could just walk in and do the job without any information as to thier network structure. That was a waste of my time as well as thiers. Is certification worth it? I don't know. I gave up the "job" portion of it and went into private consulting. The hours and duties are twice as much work as a 9 to 5 would be but I get the paycheck. I guess the "certified" looks good on a business card. Catches peoples eye. To badthey look at that instead of the quality of the people standing behind it.

by jarnette

I'm an IT consultant for a Hospital and I have to admit that the market is tough. There is this need for people to work in IT but it seems to fall into the depths of the EXP w/o EXP pitfall. I was fortunate that this hospital has an exceptional temp program, I got lucky, and paid my dues by working my ass off and moved up. If I didn't prove my skills and willingness to learn I would have been out on my butt months ago. That's part of the temp contract that my supervisor and myself had to sign.
I've only been working in IT for about a year(I REALLY worked hard) and plan on taking the MCSE 2000 track.
Last year I looked at websites for the NT track and I was surprised and almost disappointed at how easy it was to get questions/answers off of the web. The problem is that it is TOO easy, make it harder, make it near impossible.
I think certs R important to land that entry level position w/o EXP. EXP is important to prove reliability and competence. No one should get a 60,000+ job with a paper cert but they should get a 30 to 50,000 entry level spot to prove their skills, once EXP is gained, move them up and pay them more,(or risk losing them) if they don't cut it keep them at the low position or get rid of them. Ithink there should be some sort of clause instituted and assumed by all paper certs that they must prove that the certs are worth much more than the paper it was laser printed on.
The REAL problem is that big brother industry doesn't follow the same hiring model that this hospital implements.

by tom_putnam

I compare getting a certification to graduating from flight school and getting a pilot's license. It is a start and tells others that you have the basic knowledge with which to begin a career. The certification is not the final goal, it is the start. I've seen people say "Get experience and then I'll hire you." What that says to me is that they want somebody else to do all of the training and then they'll come in and reap the benefits. Are there positions where there isn't "time" to train someone? Of course there are, but they're not all that way! To me, falling back on the "get experience and then..." line is a cop out in many cases I suspect. I used to train pilots to fly attack helicopters and NOBODY thought that at the end of the transition course that those people were completely knowledgeable about everything they had to know. But they sure as heck had the foundation on which to build their experience! Certifications are the same thing. Will you find people with certifications who are complete idiots and can't do diddly? Of course, but I suspect that you'll find the same type of people among IT people who DON'T have a certification also, but that sure as heck doesn't mean that not having a certification is any indication that the person isn't intelligent and can't do the job. A certification, as I said, is a start, not the end.

by techzus

I attended a job fair last month, and most of the businesses I spoke with asked me if I had any certs. only a few asked what experience I had. I was also told that my Bachelors degree(BSCS) that I am close to finishing wasn't a big deal. The paradox is that anyone can get web experience, no problem. but you can't go up to Joe Blow IT manager and get the same op. to work on a network. Cert's are damn near the only way to get looked at unless you know someone. It's all a bunch of crap!

by ahsan

I am 101% agree with suhreed@bigfoot.com, though i don't have any certification but working on a very comfortable post in LAN/WAN environment.
One thing i would like to Add : There are many testing centers in different countries which are involved in giving the certificates through unfair means(Like a other person is seating on some one card,or helping some students through books etc).
The point is simple: Certification is not necessarily prove a person's ability for desired post.
I hope some solution will come out soon.or microsoft should take the test in tradional class room style and in every country they should be present!!!!.

by netmarcos

I am impressed with the initiative that you have shown in providing relevant training for your employees. Few companies show that much understanding of the value of a well trained workforce, and are willing to take the appropriate actions. I do not dispute your contention that vendor certifications cannot be your sole source of training, but I take exeption to the assertion that they have no value. Also, I think that you would be pleasantly surprised at the format and content of some, but certianly not all, of the new MCSE exams. They are more focused on business realities rather than OS trivial pursuit. Incidentally, my primary job function is training within a consulting organization and, as such, I must constantly remind others of the realities that you have presented in this forum.

Peace.

by monyhunter

I agree. Getting my MCSE was one of the best things I could have done. I went into it with much bigger hopes though. Now that I am working as client support/jr. network admin, I realize each day how much I don't know. But I would not be here hadit not been for the "paper". It is VERY shallow and thoughtless for many of you to be soooooo down about the certifications. They are good and they are bad. To me it sounds like the person doing the hiring is the one that needs to learn better hiring skills. To me is sounds like middle management is the one to blame for not having good management and people skills.

by netmarcos

Certification requirements will always vary from job to job and place to place. I too am a full time employee of a large corporation, but must stay current with vendor certs and assist others in doing the same as part of the companies policy. It will all depend on the focus of the business being done and your own need or desire to stay on the "bleeding edge". As for your plan to re-certify in a hurry through braindump and demo overdose, I do not recommend this course of action for the Windows 2000 exams. However, if you have a very solid networking background, good business sense and are willing to do some serious hands on study, it can be done. Just don't expect the old style "trivial pusuit" type exams.

Peace.

by dwilcox22

I have found that those who have certifications whether in MS or NetWare lack a significant amount of experience in with installations, troubleshooting, and maintaining network systems. Unfortunately it is those in the bigger offices who hire and are impressed with the letters that a person can buy.