Discussion Locked

communication problems

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have 3 computers that have a communications problem
pc 1:
Windows XP pro, connected to ADSL internet.
Norton Firewall.
2 Network cards
This pc have Internet Connection Sharing.

pc 2:
Windows 2000 server
member of a workgroup same as pc 1

pc 3:
Windows 2000 pro
member of a workgroup same as pc 1.

All the computers are connected to the same switch. pc 1 and pc 2 working fine, both in intranet and internet.
The problems starts here. pc 1 can communicate (ping) whith pc 2, butnot whith pc 3.

pc 2 can communicate whith both pc 3 and pc 1.

pc 3 can only communicate whith pc 2, not pc 1.
Can anyone explain what I can do to resolve this problems??

Roy F

5 replies

by quintar51

This sounds like a name resolution problem. Since you're not in a domain, but in a workgroup, each machine acts as its own DNS server. What you need to do is make each machine aware of the other 2.

on pc1 and pc3, search for HOSTS.ETC file. It might be hidden, so you'll have to unhide it by going to My Computer, Tools, Folder Options, View, Show all files.

Use Notepad to open the HOSTS.ETC file. It gives you instructions on how to input entries into it. What you need to do is type in the IP address of each machine, followed by the name of it.

So, on pc1, you would type in the IP Address and name of pc3. On pc3, you would do the same thing, except you're adding pc1's IP Address and name.

Normally, your DNS server cando all this for you, which is why it's so great. However in your case, you're not in a domain, you're in a workgroup, which means that you'll need to 'micro-manage' each machine.

by rfoss

The suggestion dident work. I dont know if I use HOST file at all. Pc 1 and 3 cant ping each other. They are unrechable to another.
Pc 1 dualboot with 2000 server, and if I boot up in server, all three can see each other. So the must be XP(in pc 1)that mess up the net

by riverfreight

See if your LAN is actually there, it takes only one missed keystroke to not have one the way it is supposed to be. Reveiw what you've done to establish the LAN in the first place.

AH HA! did you set up a LAN or were you just told you had one and did you move the equipment from one place to another and mix up the components some?

RIVER FREIGHT

by rfoss

First, I have 2 pc (1+2) and they work exelent. Then i put the third pc on the switch, and write the same workgroup name.(and reboot). I cant even ping from pc 1 to pc 3 and visa versa. But in a clean w2k environment, all work togheter.

Today, pc3 have static ip adr to reach pc 2.
It must be any adjustment or parameters in XP that I miss.
In pc 1 there is a firewall, and I try to disable it. And enable and put the ip range in a trusted zone.___ Why does XP see pc 2 and not pc 3?

This discussion is closed to new replies.