Discussion Locked

Copyright law - I was the customer, who owns the code?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I hired a web developer and database programmer to design me a website with some interesting functionality that no other site provides. The company I hired to build the site had me sign a statement that they would own the code.

Now I want to have another company redesign the site. Do I have the right to take the code somewhere else for a redesign? I don't like what this company did in terms of the layout and overall look and feel of the site. They claim that changing around the look and feel will cost thousands of dollars, and I found another company that would change for much cheaper. I am held hostage to the original company because they "own the code". Don't I own the idea, since it was my idea? Can they legally sell the idea and the code to my competitors??

3 replies

by seanferd

You may need to check with a lawyer here.

They may have the copyright on the functional code, but I'd think a layout redesign is within your rights. "Look and feel", if it is dependent on the "unique functionality", is a whole other problem.

You definitely need to make sure that other web designers you hire know they can't take the "special sauce" and reuse it elsewhere.

But you should really check with a lawyer.

by deadly ernest

of the contract. The normal rule in most legal areas is when a client pays to have something special created they also get a limited use right so they can use for themselves in any manner but nor allow anyone else to use or to sell or rent it. While the copyright own has all other possible uses.

If they charged you development time to design the code in the first place, then you shouldn't have agreed to let them have all the rights since you paid for the development, but that's too late for this, but keep in mind for next time. There are legal differences between who owns how much of what when an employee (temp or otherwise) and when a contractor.

by tony hopkinson

If they've two grey cells in close proximity, you are f'ed in terms of changing it.

Had you sign a statement that they would own the code, seriously large red flag right there.

You are not being held hostage, you are paying the medical bill after blowing your own foot off.

The key part now is next time the opportunity to shoot yourself in the foot comes along, pass on it....

This discussion is closed to new replies.