Discussion Locked

Critique of private web site, please.

0 helpful
34 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hey, y'all! Any suggestions on how to improve the readability or layout of this site? I'm primarily concerned with the page below; any of the linked pages are of secondary concern.

http://www.switchracing.com/index3.html

I'm not concerned with passing W3C tests or the cleanliness of the HTML. The audience for this site is less than 30 people, and all can display the current version of this home page without any problem.

Thanks in advance.

Edited - and I already intend to lose the 'checkerboard slide' effect when the page loads.

34 replies

by fregeus

...I think there is too much color. Either make the background different colors but keep the fonts the same or the other way around.

Make sure all square are aligned perfectly and maybe put more room in between them.

A table look might work better than all theses squares everywhere.

Just my 2 cents.

;-)

TCB

by charliespencer

This site is the home page of a fantasy league. The garish squares in the middle each represent a player, and he or she chooses his or her own background and font colors.

I'm responsible for the light blue, light green, and light red across the top and left.

I'll clean up the 'fit and finish' issues regarding the alignments.

I'll make a note to look at a table during the 'off season' (Dec, Jan, Feb). I actually had a table in a version many years ago but didn't like it. I use a WYSIWYG utility to create this, and I don't remember how much control I have over table elements.
Thanks!

by purpleskys

too much color...looks too busy...personally speaking, i would have just used a table/s in word and then highlighted each cell, row, or column to suit

by gsg

I can see why you used the colors, as they seem to be the "team" colors. However, it is a bit "busy".

Is there a way you could go with plain font, but make a smaller "flag" with the colors on it to the left of the font? Sort of like a custom bullet point?

by charliespencer

The idea of a colored bullet beside a team's name is worth looking into. That may be another off-season project.

by charliespencer

Yeah, I've been trying to minimize scrolling. Would you add more space between the rows, the columns, or both?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

:)
Not a lot, mind you. Just enough to 'tame' the color.

I think you could shrink the font size in the color boxes somewhat, too. Also, it looks like you have two different font sizes in those boxes. Changing font size so they're all the same size would be good. That would help reduce the 'busy' feel of it.

etu

by darryl~

Like the others said....the colors are pretty hard to look at.

What about making the "race summaries" smaller....may not even need the box they're in....maybe left justify them instead of centered....that might make them look a little neater.

You have March 7th as no race....but have #4 Alanta March 7th - do the "no race" bars have to go right across or could they just be listed with the summaries.

Just a few thoughts.

by charliespencer

I'm in the process of converting the other 'No race' weekends from the earlier black bars visible further down to the blue bars with text. Like the lack of white space, my motivation was to reduce the amount of scrolling. Maybe centering the 'No race' bars instead of running the whole width?

"What about making the "race summaries" smaller....may not even need the box they're in"

You mean having the location / summary and date / detail links on the left as left-justified text?

Thanks!

by darryl~

/ detail links on the left as left-justified text?
Yeah....then it would line up better & not look so jagged down that side.

The only way I can see to reduce the scrolling is to make the boxes smaller & making the font of the "location / summary and date" smaller.....then you'd reduce the amount of white space between each row....but with all that color it would be some hard to read.

Up at the top seems to look okay to me...looks tidy....it's all that color giving you trouble...if you get it too close together it makes it too hard to read.....can you talk them into pastel colors or something not as "bright"?

by darryl~

in the colored boxes also....the "Michael Jay Racing" looks like a good size....you could make them all that size & make the boxes a little smaller....that would reduce the scrolling.

by puppybreath

when you select Driver Worksheet.

Overall, I think the page is too busy but understand why you set it up the way you did.

by charliespencer

At the moment, this is intentional. I post a new worksheet before each race. There was no race this weekend, and NASCAR hasn't yet posted the entry list for this weekend, so I haven't been able to post the new worksheet yet. I have a checklist of operations to perform before during each weekly update (Tuesdays and race days), and I test the major links each time.

Thanks.

by charliespencer

The larger font is the 'default'; I use the smaller one if the team name is too long to fit in the square using the larger font. I'll switch to one size and see how it looks.

Edited - Based on the feedback so far, it sounds nobody favors making the colored squares larger to allow the larger sized font to be used across the board.

by charliespencer

Looks like I have to balance my players' desire to see their team colors against the resulting garish appearance of the web page. Their color selections are usually based on their favorite driver's car colors (dominant color of the car paint scheme, and the color of the car number).

by boxfiddler Hot topic

to members of your fantasy racing league (?), perhaps you should 'keep the customer satisfied' by keeping their colors, while providing balanced white space, same size fonts, losing color elsewhere? As PurpleSkies suggested above, you may find using a table helps considerably.

etu

by charliespencer

Agreed. The current version of the site home page provides even more information (!)than this one. I polled the players during this 'open' weekend to determine what features they wanted and which ones they didn't care about. I was able to drop a few features and make things 'cleaner' (and easier for me to update), but all the remaining features were desired by the majority of players.

"...losing color elsewhere?"

Maybe I can either go lighter on the light blue and green or even go white. The light blue indicates info and links related to the last race or previous ones, and the green stuff is about the upcoming race.

by seanferd

the URL, but is there a particular reason you used the bass-ackward Windows-type slashes rather than whacks (forward slashes)? Handy if you don't the link clickable, especially by automation, perhaps?

As to the site itself: Not bad, especially if the colors, etc., are what your site users want. I believe the little fiddly-bits like alignment have already been fully discussed.

The only other consideration I might make regarding the eyestrain effect as mentioned by other people is to experiment with different background colors until it works for most everyone, assuming that your intended users have a problem with it at all. Or offer alternative CSS in monochrome or similar. Otherwise, there are a few different ways for the site visitors to change the appearance on their end (browser settings, GreaseMonkey, Stylish, or other script customization tools).

But as long as everyone can enjoy and easily use their favorite fantasy racing site, don't fix what ain't broken, as they say. If you think you will be getting an influx of new users, maybe leave a suggestion box link on the main page.

by charliespencer

"...is there a particular reason you used the bass-ackward Windows-type slashes..."

Uh, oil in the Gulf? The Obama administration? E. coli? Hitler? I'm a dumb-ass who was wondering why the text didn't get converted to a link?

Yeah, let's go with that last one.

Thanks.

by darryl~

put a table of links or something on the front page that would go to the others...

Maybe put a "race" pic or something as a background image on the front page.

by seanferd

Probably a good idea for "first impression" purposes if you are expecting new users. If you don't expect many new users and your current users like it the way it is, don't bother unless it makes the site easier to maintain.

by charliespencer

No, it would actually make it harder. I don't get more than a half-dozen new users each February. I'm just looking for ways to better relate the information my viewers say they want to see.

by nexs

- Group months with a border of 1 or 2 (helps with decipherability)
- perhaps separate the draw from the rest of the data/links (ie: wrap a coloured div or table around each 'section' of the page)
- Make the href's noticeably different to everything else (as in Vincent Flanders' tutorials, Mystery meat navigation is major turn-off)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Fade it hard. I've used what might be considered a 'busy' photo, faded hard, as a web page background. Looks great if you get the fade right.

by dawgit

I would used the boxes on the left of what is now the top of the page as link boxes to other pages (now as 'scroll down') I see at least three separate web pages trying to be one page. I think a lot of your worries will be over if you'd split them up as separate pages.
IMHO (& my 2? cents)-d

by michael jay

I found the old layout ok, and the new layout looks fine as well, the busyness that some refer to is not so busy to me as I have looked at the site for quite a while.

The only improvements I can offer is that I need to be higher in the points, at 1000+ out of first that sucks, my fault, and the Pocono race is August 1 not August 21.

All in all it is a usable site and since I go there almost each week I am used to it, and it works for me, aside from my bad picks.

This discussion is closed to new replies.