Discussion Locked

Defrag/optimize

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
When Windows 2000 defrags a hard drive does it also optimize it? ( Move files that need to load first to the faster part of the drive ).

7 replies

by thechas

If you are referring to a built in defrag tool from Microsoft, not really.

Diskeeper from Executive software, or Norton Speed Disk do a much better job of "optimization".

I don't know if Norton is W2K compatible prior to version 2002.

Chas

by sfowler

I understand that Norton and Diskeeper do better jobs at Defragmenting the hard drive. But do they Optimize it for load and running speed?

by dklippert

Norton, at least does optimize. Diskkeeper probably does as well. This is not as important as it was it the slow old days.

by b_pope

I've used Norton's & ended up going back to Windows defrag. If you download lots of files & such, Norton takes forever & I never really found that it helped speed anything up.

I defrag everyday now & it takes less than 10 minutes. You also need to get rid of temp files & cookies regularly.

Unless you use the exact same programs everyday, no defrager will ever optimize your system anyway.

by thechas

Microsoft's built in tool pretty much does just a simple defrag.
It does little if any file location optimization.

Norton's tool is reported to do a decent job at Optimization.

Disk-keeper is also reported to do a decent job of optimization, and may be better suited to a W2K system than Norton.

The important consideration for overall system performance in my mind is to reduce / prevent fragmentation of the swap / page file.
Windows tool does NOT do this, unless you move / disable theswap file on the drive being defragmented.

Norton's tool can be configured to place a fixed size swap file on the fastest section of the hard drive. (at least for W9X)

I believe that Disk-keeper can also be configured to "optimize" the swap file.

Check out this link for a comparison of Diskeeper to the W2K defrag utility,
http://www.execsoft.com/diskeeper/dk-comparison.asp

Of course, they are trying to sell the product. They also have a white paper and trial version that you can download.

Hope this makes things clearer.

Chas

This discussion is closed to new replies.