Discussion Locked

E-mail retention policy - ethical dilemma

0 helpful
221 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

My company presently does not have a policy regarding the retention of e-mail. With only 75-100 mailboxes on our Exchange server, reasonable mailbox size limits in place and plenty of HD space - we really never gave it much consideration. We do have a practice of running AutoArchive in Outlook to keep the power users from amassing monster-size mailboxes to keep the load on the server down, and to keep the "mailbox is full" warnings from populating their mailboxes - and the archive files are saved on the file server. Everything gets back up to tape every night and archived monthly. So far so good.

This is where things get dicey. It was just handed down to the IT dept from the top of the mountain that we must delete _everything_ off the Exchange server and keep only those e-mails which are less than 30 days old - and to make this an ongoing policy. This also includes destroying 4 years worth of archived backup tape that we have secured in our records room. Red flags are waving and alarms are ringing. From an IT perspective, we have enough disk space on our Exchange box for at least another 20 years of e-mail - and the hardware we run it on barely breaks a sweat. My boss told me to make this happen starting next week. He's just as perplexed about it as I am, but said we need to follow orders.

The twist is that we're a government agency that falls under a number of state and federal regulations, requirements and obligations. For all intents and purposes, e-mails are business documents. From an operational standpoint, most of my users rely heavily on e-mail and often need to go back several months or longer to retrieve information regarding any particular project they're working on.

Now, I'm sure by doing this, I'm probably not breaking any laws - however, there are guidelines and requirements in place by the state/federal government that pertain to record retention, in addition to the legal implications of destoying records -- especially if they can save your company in the event of a sizeable lawsuit. But what if all those records are subpoenaed in court and we can't produce them because they were destroyed? If we're in compliance in what we're supposed to do, then we shouldn't have to worry about any damaging documents floating around our mail server - so no need to destroy them.

I'm sure you remember the Ollie North Iran-Contra scandal with the all of the document shredding, and the hot water he got in for obstructing justice. Do I really want to be implicated in this when I have mouths to feed and a mortgage to pay? Do I want my name and reputation tarnished - even though I was following orders?

But if you were put in this situation, what would you do? The IT job market has yet to recover from it's heyday (and likely never will).

221 replies

by bfilmfan

You are required and compelled under the National Archives and Records Administration Act of 1984 (Pub. L. 98 - 497, 44 U.S.C. 101 note) to preserve certain documents, including email.

You can verify most of your requirements here:

http://www.archives.gov/records_management/records_management_basics/federal_government.html

Personally and in writing, I would immediately contact my superior asking how they planned to meet compliance with the Federal law. If they should tell you to "jus get with the program," immediately call the Justice Department and use the Whistleblower's law. You might also wish to contact the National Archives, your senators and congreeman and those fun party gang at the General Accounting Office.

It never ceases to suprise me how mnay Federal agency department heads look really good in prison atttire. Don't be one of them.

by jdclyde

So cover your a$$!

BFilmFan is right on track with this.

It is a poor business practice in a PRIVATE business, and almost certanly illegal in an governmental institution. Freedom of information and all.

Looks real bad.

Make sure your not breaking any laws, and then get it in writting for when the brass ask why they can't get that e-mail back from 32 days ago that he NEEDS.

by pedwards17

I agree with jdclyde--following orders won't absolve you of responsibility. If you follow these orders and there is an investigation in the future, you'll be the one who will take the fall. As others have suggested, get the request in writing (not in email unless you're going to print it--it'll be gone in 31 days otherwise;-) ), ask how the regulations are to be met, and then contact the necessary authorities.

by caestelle

I do not know what I would do in your shoes, but I am sure glad I am not there. Are they giving any motive as to why they might be wanting to destroy these emails. If not, maybe their motives are pure....like maybe their thinking is that they do not want confidential emails floating around out there and they just don't realize that by deleting them, they will be breaking some laws. If this is the case, then maybe pointing out these laws that BFilmFan is referring to deter them. Regardless...like BFilmFan said, I would express your concerns to your supervisor in a manner that you can keep for your personal protection should you need it. Good luck in whatever you decide!!

by angry_white_male

No idea what's motivating them to do this. I just hope it's because the HMFIC here fell and hit his head and isn't thinking straight. In any event - I did some research and called a lawyer friend of mine and while I may be clear from a legal/civil/criminal perspective when I dump the info store and trash the tapes, it won't look good for the company - and it may very well bite us down the road. My boss is pushing this back onto the HMFIC and advising him of the pitfalls, so we'll see what happens.

Apparently they want this done within the next couple of weeks - seems like a hasty decision, so it tells me that something's up.

by elliemk1

Take BFilmFan's advice. He knows what he is talkign about. Then take the other guy's advice who said to burn it all to DVD or make tapes of everything - even if you have to do it on your own time. Get a lawyer, blow the whistle, call the Washington Post and the New York Times. Ask them to run an article about how government agencies have to keep e-mail archives just like other companies do. Put a copy of the article on your CEO's desk. Plan to get fired, but by doing the right thing, you'll probably get hired by some ethical company or start your own business with the money you make from the book and movie rights to this story :) I'm a writer and can direct you to some savvy political writers who will gladly ghostwrite the story for you.
Whatever you do, get a lawyer and listen to what he tells you. Have him write a letter to your CEO. That's always a good move.
And whatever else you do, don't destroy everything without having blown the whistle big-time.
Have your resignation letter ready to go the day before the article appears in the papers.
Contact me offlist if you want any more help along these lines.
I just love these modern day "whodunits."
Don't participate in a crime. It's not worth it.

by elliemk1

I wrote "Godd" advice. Well, let's change it to "Good advice," can we? Maybe I really should get to bed now!

by neil leacy

> Don't participate in a crime. It's not worth it.

If I were in your position I too would take all the previous advice. As in your thread never a truer word has been written than those above, I think it would also be prudent to point out to your CEO that he is asking you to break the law which is an offence in itself.

Cover your back as best you can. You are in the right and anyone with an ounce of common-sense will see that straight away, it's just the legal eagles that will need the hard proof of proposed wrong-doing.

Regards, Neil

by cgresley

The Wistleblower's Law might have good intentions, but end of the day you have to come back and work in that office. How-ever will find out you are the snitch. Follow another route like speaking to your superior.

by mcseford

You are going to have to be clever on this one. Do what they say, but first back the entire database up onto tape and store a copy someplace, (perhaps with your attorney - where you are covered by client/attorney covenent).

If and when the fit hits the shan you are holding aces over eights.

by cagedmonkey

Sounds to me like someone is trying to cover something up. I'd most definitley get all of this in writing along with a copy of this so-called new policy and who approved it.

Expecting a 30 day retention period is just assinine. As an IT admin I need more than 30 days retention just to keep track of documents when making network changes. I'd have to resort to using .PST files and we know how well desktops get backed up if ever.

by barbedwire

I've never heard anyone working in a federal agency call there dept. a "company", or a fed. IT guy talk about "busines documents". So what is this place he works for?
Anyway, are the laws different for fed. agency, state agency, or company?

by amcol

Because he's exactly, precisely, absolutely, positively, 100% correct.

I also work for the government. I know the laws and regs in this area, from NARA to OMB to FOIA to FISMA. Do what BFilmFan is telling you to do. And document every move you make, every conversation you have, everything that happens from here on out.

by mikeblane

I'd start researching these laws, making printouts and keeping in a binder. I'd also start talking quietly to the Ethics and Legal offices to see what your options are. Also, it never hurts to update your resume.

by ohiois

Record retention policies have to meet several tests.

1. Is the policy in compliance with all laws and regulatations governing the company or agency?

2. Is the policy in align with other similar companies and agencies? In other words, does it stray from acceptable practicies in similar companies?

3. Is the policy in compliance with certifications awarded by professional organizations?

4. Is the policy established without any consideration to existing materials? A policy cannot be implemented while there is information under subpoena or explicityly to avoid litigation.

If the answer to any of these is no, present your reasons for disobeying in a professional manner. I would also document all conversations with dates and names. And yes, I too would make a wistle blowing call under these circumstances if they do not listen to reason.

by angry_white_male

I talked with our CEO - brought up the fact that the state and federal gov't have retention guidelines regarding data - but he seems to think that e-mail doesn't count as a business records (which it is). He's concerned that a potential "exhibit A" may be lurking on our mail server somewhere (with lots of thinking hard long pauses trying to manufacture a BS excuse on the fly)... then later he changed his tune and said that it was more about efficiency on our mail server.

Our mail server is just fine - so their claims of server efficiency is total bullshit since we're upgrading it in a few weeks from a P3 1 gig dual processor with 3 gig RAM and 100 GB of disk space to a P4 3.2 gig dual processor with 4 gig RAM and about 216 GB of disk space. Our Exchange info store now is only about 25 gig... and the only reason why we're upgrading the server is because the one we have now is out of warranty and eating up 7U of rack space.

So I go and put out the blast mail to the entire company stating this new policy will take effect in about a week to give people time to go through and get anything they deem of importance off the server and onto hardcopy (yeah - now that's efficient with people printing 1000's of pages of e-mail at an additional cost to the company... and where are they gonna put it all?). What really sucks is that the message is coming from me and not my boss because my boss is out of the country til Wednesday on vacation and they wanted this done yesterday. So I'm gonna take the heat from everyone who'll be pissed off at this whole thing. I'm basically lying to everyone who works there... the responses I got back so far I haven't had a good answer for them because I was never told how I should address it... so I'm just playing stupid and either ignoring them or telling people we're still hammering out the details. People are not going to be very happy when they realize that e-mail from 3 months ago they need now is gone forever.

So red flags are waving and alarms are ringing that something isn't quite right if this is coming out of the blue for no reason other than efficiency when we're upgrading the mail server in a few weeks. The CEO/COO have some ulterior motive they won't talk about and they're putting the whole thing on IT to make it seem like it's our idea. Something's fucked up.

I've been quietly looking for a new job since January anyway. Underpaid, overworked and tired of the politics that run the place.

by amcol

Find a country that doesn't have an extradition policy with the US.

You're in a heap of trouble, son. It's YOUR name that's all over this, and the law's going to come looking for YOU when the sauce hits the blender.

Doesn't matter if you leave your job, what's done is done and it's on the public record. You shouldn't be soliciting our advice, you should be spending your time finding legal counsel...BEFORE actions are taken that can't be undone.

by angry_white_male

I have copies of the e-mails sent between our CEO, COO and my boss regarding this whole thing - in addition to e-mail from our VP of legal who's telling them the same thing I am (it hasn't dawned on them that a network/mail admin knows _everything_ and has full complete access to everything).

If this turns out to be a bad hand, I hold the trump card (and it's legal here for me to inspect mailboxes, as well as company policy gives me the OK to do so).

And if I get canned, I have a willing ear at the newspaper who would love to run an expose on us (helps that we quietly fired her husband last year). Either that or my guaranteed silence will by me nice severance package I'm sure.

by tech

Don't just write the Email to the company - Forward and comment on the order from the Big Boss. This will help show who the instruction is from, and help point the finger at them. Also does your arm of the Governmental tree have a specific regulator - if so drop them a query as to the specific data retention requirements, under current conditions. There have been a number of special orders made in various countries, with legal status, but in addition to the published statutes, as part of the various anti-terrorism laws.

by zetman

If your CEO's saying that he wants to lessen the load on the server, tell him you'll keep the archives off the server, onto tapes...

by komodo

There are many precedents out there that dictate the you have an obligation to disobey orders that are illegal/immoral or where a "reasonable man" would find it wrong to carry out the orders.

In your case I would protect myself by burning two copies of the data to a CD or DVD then delete as instructed. I would keep one copy of the media in the normal company records (i.e. with archived backup tapes) and the other in the custody of your legal counsel as a means of self-protection.

If things blow up you can always point to your documentation of your archives and where they were stored at the company. If they were disposed of without your knowledge you can always fall back to the copy your legal counsel has.

Finally, before you do any of this you __must__ obtain the best legal avice you can afford. Your future employability is at stake so make sure the counsel you choose is an expert in employment law and data retention law.

by jsdutcher69

If it was me doing this I would keep copies burned to a tape or DVD on a monthly basis that was if anything happens and you get blamed, you're covering your own butt. In this day, alot of big wigs are going to send you out to dry before they go.

by sloan

The Freedom Of Information Act requires all government agencys to not only retain all communications, but to classify and catorgize them for efficient retrival. It's a felony to destroy any of these records (including email), and any government employee ordering the destruction is also committing a felony.

Also, if there are 3 or more people involved (you, your boss, and his boss, for example), you could also be convicted under the Patriot act for "acting in a conspiracy" to destroy potential evidence.

Even with a CYA (or "get out of jail" letter) letter from the top dog, you would still be convicted should it ever come to light. An earlier post suggested that you get a signed order from someone up the ladder -- a very good idea, but I wouldn't actually destroy the backups until you got advise from a lawyer and/or the FBI.

An agency I used to work for got in trouble, and several people's careers were ruined, because they weren't backing up the local email stores on user's computers. You really should get some legal advise because of the exposure you may have. For instance, if you keep a copy of the emails until you have a clear legal answer, you cannot take them "offsite" (Patriot Act & simple theft laws). You would need to find a safe place to keep them at the office.

Good luck, and I hope you post the final results of your delima.

by gentlerf

And the others are quite correct in the CEO has something to hide that showed up in one of his e-mails. The aspect of "I was just following orders" didn't fly at Nuremberg (WW2 Nazi War Crimes trials) and it doesn't today either. Document, document, document and make a private backup of that data as was suggested elsewhere because I know from my personal readings of court cases involving e-mail that your CEO is dead wrong about it not being covered by Federal Data retention laws. No, I am not a lawyer nor do I play one on TV but I do listen and read a lot.

by neal.cleaver

Although I do not work for a government agency, I do work for a company that is regulated by a federal agency. I am not an expert on document retention rules either. Our present email system is similar to the one described. I was told by management that archiving a monthly backup was not acceptable for log term arhiving. For legal purposes, we would have no way of proving that a user did not send or receive mail and then delete it during the month Because of that, they felt we were better off not making any attempting any long-term storage program. We currently use a 3-week tape rotation for disaster recovery purposes.

by zaferus

I believe in "Walk softly and carry a big backup".

I would keep a comprehensive "off site backup" of everything (two copies - 2 different places with the original memo) and then comply with the request. As long as you make sure you're not the one without a chair when the music stops - it should at least buy you time to find another job. And if the music stops you can say "yes I did delete it, but to comply with the law I kept a good backup".

Zaf

by alanlox

I have read the thread here and I would put a very big Warning on deleting and email, This smells like hell to me best report him as others have advised you to do.

And CC the Memo to this CEO So he cannot say he does not know why this was done.

by larry.barnhill

This situation is not new. It ( most probably ) means someone is trying to cover their tracks and prevent an email trail from pointing to them. especially if you are a Government Agency ( of any kind ) or affiliated with the Government. You should deffinitely get a Lawyer or very good legal advice.

by haylocks

1/ Burn 'em to DVD, then follow illegal orders.
2/ Get some legal advice

Sounds terrible!

by keithx

Ive worked in and out of government and public sector organisations in the UK for the last 8/9 years. The single most important thing you learn from these places is that you can trust NOONE. Its a sad fact. Keep a copy of everything. Double backup that copy and give it to a lawyer or someone you trust implicitly.

The law may differ between the UK and US somewhat, but im no lawyer so it matters not. There are three things you need to do asap.

1) Get independent legal advice in writing it is unadvisable to present this to your employer as he may see it as a threat, but if you can provide evidence that you disagreed with his instructions your already in the clear.
2) Archive everything on the mail server. Then copy that archive and deposit a copy of it with your third party. DO NOT keep a copy for yourself, that would most likely be illegal but DO keep a copy of the receipt from the third party of the archive.
3) Do as asked by your employer.

I would be looking to get out of the company now too, but its not necessary. However, if/when the shit starts flying you DO NOT want to be in the scatter radius. No matter how protected you think you are this sort of shit sticks. The only thing you have in any business is your reputation. The moment it gets tarnished its damn near impossible to get it shiny again.

Good luck.

by cgresley

1. Burn 'em DVD's. Do as asked.
2. Create some fanciful story about the contents.
3. Sell to the highest bidder.

If just!! :)

by donovan

No matter what you do, get a written order from the top instructing you to delete those mails. Make sure they sign and date it and keep some spare copies. This will then be admissable in a court of law in the US.
If they refuse to give it to you in writing then I think they have other intentions for deleting these mails.

by rapell

Do not accept to do this. Blaze the data onto DVD and archive.
Make three copies, one for storage, Second to your legal counsel, and the third in a hidden location on company premises, not home. The boss might sweet talk counsel, after all they are the big shots in suits and they may be alike when issues are hot for the company. Finally run for the hills, squeal everything from up there.

by ncc

Be careful about making those copies and taking it off-site, or giving it to anyone (including lawyers). In most cases, you would be guilty of breaking the law doing this by taking confidential information. I'd burn the copy and leave it somewhere in your files in the office.

by fgarvin

Not only that, you write the order. Make sure you put in it that you have warned the Executive in question that the action he is requiring is not legal, and that he is still ordering you to do so under threat of your continued employment.

If he signs, you have him taking full responsibility for the action. You might even think about sending a copy of this order to the authoities.

by nonsequitr

As an attorney, I'd tell lwilson to go to the corporate legal counsel and ask for regulatory direction before deleting any documentation. Federal and state regulations may require you to retain that data for a certain period of time no matter what the top of the mtn says. Ignorance of the law will not save you or your agency if someone finds out what you've done and it is a violation of the law. Also, make sure there's a documented policy in placed signed by the on-high person establishing a data destruction policy. This is your CYA if anything happens in the future. I would NOT destroy anything until there is written documentation with a authorized signature that establishes the policy and a legal eagle that tells you it's all right to do so.

by rosaticrew

I tend to agree with others, you are the one who's head will be on the chopping block if you destroy records and not your supers. Follow the laws that are in place and question why this is being done. Most likely the honcho who is ordering this is clueless.

by michont

If you feel you might be in danger of losing your job over this either way, guess it depends if you want to lose your job by following illegal company policy or lose your job by following what the law says and protecting yourself for future implications. Since the CEO seems clueless here, you could just set up his account to not see email over 30 days old and he'd probably never know that the new "directive" is not being followed. What about local hard drive copies of emails that people archive? I'm guessing that any lawsuit would grab the local hard drives, so it wouldn't really matter if the server is not storing things over a month old. There will be copies around.

by robert_m_knight

I would remind my supervisors of the law. I would then follow the law. If something goes wrong, you will be the first one put out on an island all by yourself. If they give the order through email and you follow their directions, after 30 days, you would not have proof of what they said. Stick to the law. It is the right thing to do.

by ramonas

Absolutely NOT. Job or no job, its a matter of ethics. Government requires retention, you retain.

by mllwyd

You asked for the advice of your peers. We all are telling you not to destroy the email. Listen to us!

by dr.phil

During my 25+ years working with the Fed Gov I can tell you that almost all of the recommendations are correct on this thread. I can also tell you that I've been where you are right now. Document, document, document. Cover yourself several times. If you burn DVD's make sure you put one in a safety deposit box in a bank. By doing this you have the FDIC and other agencies involved as well and when the feces hit the air handler you'll have been covered once again. Find the local Fraud Waste and Abuse hotline and keep that number on you. If my hunch is right we will find out that this is not a management mis-judgement. It is way too blatant. If this is a cover-up the company may loose it's ability to gain future contract work which usually puts a company out of business.

I was in the same position as you are back in 1984 and I can tell you that you must cover yourself very well. Moving on to a new position will not guarantee you anything as you have already documented yourself in the overall picture by sending out that email telling the users the new policy.

Even if you are working for a contracting company to the Gov you aren't saved from Big Brother "inviting" you to testify. I know, I've had to do it 3 times.

In closing, the work place isn't as simple as it used to be nor as friendly.

by dancejoe

Report this directive to the agency Inspector General without delay. Do NOT comply, as you WILL be in trouble. And try to keep your head down.

by landsharrk

That's an order that I would follow ONLY IF I got it in writing and ONLY WHEN that document was in a safe place off site. Then I wolud gladly get in step.

by landsharrk

Get the order in writing. Use any excuse you need to get it. Follow the whistle blowing protocol listed previously by other posters. REMEMBER!!!
There is business and there are friends. Never the two shall meet.

by mollenhourb9

Keep in mind that IT is a service to the rest of the organization, not the other way around. If higher up (an executive group, for instance) says you have to delete the emails, you have to do it.

That said, you should keep documentation of who said to do it, and when. You should also keep any documentation you have showing that you advised them otherwise; that they were probably breaking the law. Lastly, alert the appropriate governing organization (in your case probably Management and Budget, or some other GAO type department).

If you are not sure how to do this properly, without leaving your tail in a crack, talk to some "old timers" who know how to work within the system. People who know how to do what is right without hanging themselves out to dry.

by rikdee

AWM,

I too work with government, albeit in another country.

I would write a memo to the CEO detailing my concerns, stating that I believe that carrying out the instructions would violate document retention rules. I would also state in the memo that the capacity of the email server can handle the archiving needs and is not a restricting constraint. In the memo I would request a signed, written document from the CEO that requests the deletion of the emails and a confirmation that deleting the emails is not a violation of document retention laws. To make it esier for the CEO (if he/she indeed thinks it's legitimate) I would prepare the wording of the document for him to sign but leave it to him to put it on letterhead and sign.

It is quite likely that the CEO will be mad and may even fire you for insubordination. You will, however, have proof that you did your due dilligence with a copy of your memo. Better to be out of work than to be working in the big yard with Bubba behind you. You even have the option to sue for unlawful dismissal if you are so inclined.

On the other hand, if your CEO signs then make sure you compare his signature on the document to others he has signed to make sure he can't claim that you forged his signature. Save the hardopy of the signed confirmation away from the office in case you have to leave the office on someone else's terms.

This may seem a bit extreme but you may be set up. Your boss is out of the country? Hmmm.... He gave you verbal instructions so he can claim ignorance in the future and dispute everything you say. You'll almost surely be the fall guy.

I'd rather be fired than implicated....

RikDee

by jeffersnet

Good thoughts but I'd be less extreme. Something close to this happened to me while working for the State of Nebraska. I used email to communicate my thoughts to my supervisors and they wrote back right away confirming their previous orders. I kept those emails and even burnt an extra copy on a CD for my personal records. If you word it write and only voice your concerns then your boss won't think you are questioning his authority and you will get a reply that you can save to save yourself.

by shraven

At first it would seem you either have to comply with the request and break the law or refuse the request and risk your job...
But what if you simply archived all the email to be deleted, notified your superiors of the potential legal conflict and delivered the archive tape with a copy of the legal requirements to your boss? Make sure you have copies of your responses and let your boss do any actual destroying of archive tapes. You will not be guilty of anything and will have complied with the request presented you.
If you're really concerned, keep a copy of the archive tape for yourself which you could produce if you ever got dragged into court (at that point I'm assuming you would have no interest in keeping the job - just clearing your name.)

by kjenkinsaf

A couple of things that aren't clear. Is yours a sensitive/secure area and are the files/emails you are asked to destroy of a sensitive nature (read National Security or of Intelligence Value)? Regardless, if you have a "written directive" authorizing destruction from a superior. You should be good to go. Just make sure the OPR has a clearly written policy on this. And if all else fails, try to get the supervisor to sign an authorization (fat chance). Last but not least, the Federal Govt has whistle blower's lines. You may want to avail yourself of this option if things look bad.

by dpuls

I'm a CISSP - Certified Information Systems Security Professional. I sat for a 6-hour exam and signed a document that basically says that I will not do anything unethical or against the laws of the country I work in.

If you are actually working for a government agency, then you are right about questioning the policy. A member of the Clinton Admin just got fined and my do jail time for destroying gov't information by mistake --- his clamin.

And I know the IT market is still very tight - I have to live away from home for my job - but I thing you need to contact either the FBI, the AG's office, or GAO. The SOx Act has a whistle-blower protections written right in the act; so I am sure there are many rules against this in gov't.

If you knew of this and you did nothing, and actually followed the order your future will be greater jeopardy.

by drew.mashburn

To answer your question, "What would you do?" It's high time we quit using the email backup system as the Official, santioned location for storing official email records. Over 90% of the email we create is transitory anyway (non-substantive) and has a very short (if any) required retention period), so we are spending a lot of resources keeping all these email records that should be purged anyway every 30 days. I would advice leadership that the official email record, if meeting the requirement of retention, be kept by the creater of the record itself. This will require some education for the email users. One problem with the current practice of storing all email in the backup system is it makes it hard to retrieve particular records when requested, due to lack of organization/indexing of the email records. Making the IT shop responsible for storing and indexing email records is poor records management. If the users are big enough to use email as efficient means of communication, then they are big enough to learn how to retain their own email records that are subject to retention requirements.

by rmonaco

Drew, although your comments have some validity, they really are not germane to this discussion. The current law explicitly specifies retention requirements and must be followed as written until and unless the law is amended.

by beachy

I am the head of the IT dept. for a county government. I would never comply with a dictate such as that. To force people to delete emails, let alone destroy backups, that's jsut asking for a scandal. As a gov agency in Ohio all of our emails are public info. in fact regqardless of whether we have a email retantion policy, the State does.

On ethics questions I always consult our local prosecutor's office. If this is an option for you, I'd suggest you do it. If not (this won't make you a popluar person) I'd suggest you force the higher ups to get a court order from a judge forcing the issue. I'm sure you aren't the only person who does not feel comfortable with the decision, you are just the person who will get into trouble because you enforced the dictate.

If that still isn't an option, put your thoughts and refusal in writing, take it to your boss and force him to do the records destruction. I'd then start looking elsewhere for a position, because clearly there are ethical issues going on behind the scenes.

I know this ins't much advice, but I hope it helps.

by enserfud

In this day of high technology there is a low technology way of CYA. Mail a copy of the memo stating your objections to this order to yourself, your attorney, significant other, grandmother; you get the point. However, do not open this letter once it arrives. What you are wanting to establish is proof of your objections and when you objected. The postmark on the envelope proves this. Spend the extra five bucks on the postage and send it registered mail. That way it is kept under lock and key throughout transit. I call this my poor man's copyright.

by stan.kappiris

If the details are as you've stated: federal vendor, etc. then consider these options...
1. consult your personal attorney
2. ask your boss to have the company attorney confirm the legality of the request.
3. Freshen up your resume
4. If they fire you 'after' you ask for a legal opinion from the company attorney 'then' you can claim Whistleblower status.
5.good luck

by adelpreore

First off make sure what the policies are regarding e-mail for a government agency (4-7 years).

Second, make sure Mt. Olympus knows what the statue is - that's why they pay us - to take care of the details. Someone might have "read" somewhere that it's good practice to keep 30 days worth of e-mail on the server. It may just be that the higher-ups don't realize waht all the legal ramifications are. Communicate with them.

Third, absolutely back-up up everything.

Fourth - I don't know what procedures your institution has place for implementing policies - make sure they are followed. At the very least you need a written memorandium to protect yourself.

Fifth - and I'm sure this is very unpopular - follow your gut. If its telling you it wrong then it probably is. So if its not a miscommunication/misunderstanding - and it is an order - tell your boss you have a problem with it. Worst case you get fired - more than likely you get written-up. Sometimes an employee's refusal is the quickest way to draw attention to the given case. The person who "sanctioned" the order will be the one under scrutiny, not you.

Lastly, I don't know what agency/department you work for but I'm sure there are a great deal of IT positions that you could "laterally" transfer to. Its not the end-of-the-world - its a job. You have to make up your own mind about what you do. WHat ever you decide to do, you must be willing to endure the consequences - whatever they might be.

by consultant davea

I read all the preceeding replies, and agree that you have received some great advise. As a consultant to many banks and brokerage firms, I have planned my response in case I am placed in a similar situation.

1. Verbal command from the boss? Follow it up with an email to him (this is an expected action on your part):
a. restating his instructions, including specific deadlines.
b. state my concerns from the perspective of the company or organization - legal (try to cite one mandate or order), ethical, whatever - but do not question his authority; let the others do that for you.
c. request an immediate face to face meeting.
d. Inform him since he out of town, I will take no action at all until this meeting takes place.
e. CC his boss (if he has one), my boss, my boss's boss, the legal dept, and HR - the 'others' I mentioned before. Hopefully, they will feel compelled to send a representative to the meeting, or contact him prior to it.

2. I have just put Legal and HR on notice that I am questioning his authority in this matter, without directly being insubordinate. I am giving them the opportunity to step in on the company's behalf - that's their jobs, after all.

3. Do not as yet get anyone outside the company involved. Until that first meeting, this is still an internal matter.

4. Sit back and wait. Legal Dept will no doubt get involved quickly.

5. Contact an attorney for further advise. I am sure his first advise will be to document and/or record everything.

6. Play it by ear from this point on, under legal advisement.

The rest will now depend on how the company's internal politics plays out. In the meantime, take your backups:
a. keep one copy locked in your desk or your office, where it would be expected to be found should it be searched for.
b. keep 2 copies hidden in 2 different, relatively secure places in the office; above ceiling tiles in your locked office, or your bosses office, or behind some furniture; the idea here is to be sure that no one will easily stumble upon it, yet it must not leave the guarded premises.
c. give one copy to a friend in the legal dept, or another trusted company officer or senior manager; try to get a signed receipt for it.
d. be sure the ongoing off-site archives include your email and all responses to it, including message exchanges between others regarding it; once offsite, it would probably require a court order to be destroyed.

Good luck, please keep letting us know what happens.

by no name specified

Just remember this: the phrase "I was just following orders" does NOT make you innocent, and you can bet that there will be someone out there itching (or getting paid a lot) to prove that you aren't. Another something to remember is that you are NOT innocent simply because you "did not know it was illegal", and bottom line is that the lowest person on the totem pole always pays the price. Don't believe it? Ask the seven soldiers from Abu Grahib. You pushed the button = you pulled the trigger = "nobody told them to abuse the prisoners".

by ask_why

Not knowing your environment or management ? how would they take it if you ?Asked Why????.specifically due to the legal implications that may exist for your company. Like always there is a worst case ? you could get fired. My take, as you implied there is an ?Ethical Dilemma? and we have seen in the last several years the results when those of us who have to perform the work are coerced into doing things that we did/don?t feel comfortable with ? one big result on our side, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002. Oh, by the way I know of several suits that have filed suit based on the ?Whistle Blower? section of the Act - they were won.

by the admiral

If the word does not come in the form of an official email, then it is not the word. You have to have documentation stating that the top brass has stated that this is the case. If not, it is business as usual.

by no name specified

Just remember this: the phrase "I was just following orders" does NOT make you innocent, and you can bet that there will be someone out there itching (or getting paid a lot) to prove that you aren't. Another something to remember is that you are NOT innocent simply because you "did not know it was illegal", and bottom line is that the lowest person on the totem pole always pays the price. Don't believe it? Ask the seven soldiers from Abu Grahib. You pushed the button = you pulled the trigger = "nobody told them to abuse the prisoners".

by abelm

There's no doubt that you are in an ethical dilemma. If you do not follow the orders, the "top of the mountain" would think you are such a rebel, but if you do what they ask for would be a policy violation. The way i see to sort this issue is doing a tape backup on your own, hidding it in a secure place. Then proceed to follow the orders.

by trapper

I am an employee of one municipal government and an elected official in another. If I did this even with my personal e-mail I would potentially be in violation of several open records laws, and would certainly be considered suspect. The higher the level of government your agency is, the more laws apply. Someone is acting like they are in deep trouble - do not let it be you. Get legal help yesterday.

by jdgeek

The world needs more of them. Keep them honest, and get your resume ready.

by wwwebster

Sounds like a lot of good advice from the list to me. If there are laws requiring record retention (and I'm certain there are) then YOU are obligated to follow the law, as well as the Agency you work for - Doesn't matter what your employer tells you. It would seem that a prudent course might include some or all of the following ideas (mostly drawn from other posts):

1) Document that you have raised the issue;
2) Backup everything that is to be deleted (for your protection, not the Agency's);
3) Consult your agency's legal counsel if their is one - let them argue the point;
4) If you can't get them to re-evaluate their decision, you either have to follow through or seek employment elsewhere.
5) Seeking personal legal counsel would probably be a very wise idea.

As someone else mentioned, if the law is violated and you were on deck when it happened, you WILL have to discuss it with the authorities, maybe even testify in court, regardless of your personal stand on the issue. Going forward, it may not be any concern of your whether your agency is in compliance with the relevent laws - that would depend on who the authorities considered responsible for guaranteeing compliance. As far as backups are concerned, being in personal possession of the backups might place you in jeopardy as well, as those materials would probably be considered 'corporate/agency' property, opening the door for a problem for you of a different sort.

Finally, I would just like to say that I don;t think anything good can come out of your situation ad you have my sympathy. Your CEO has entirely too much time on his hands if he is concerned about email server efficiency - I mean, exactly what does he need you for?! Isn't the resolution to a systems problem best left to the systems people to resolve? Rather curious that such a decision comes down to your department and unfortunately, you may have set your self up for 'disciplinary action' as a result of raising a red flag.

Going forward, it isn't your problem if they are in compliance

by cgoeckel

After reading the discussion I would have to agree with everyone telling you to
1) Document your concern and the responses from the higher ups.
2) Inform the company/agency law dept as well as HR. Doing the CC for them will set off red flags for them. The law dept will be or should be up to date on any of the issues you have. Especially with all the activities of late.
3) Don't do anything till the Boss is back from vacation and arrange a meeting with him, your boss, HR or Legal. Cover your bases and yourself. Look at it from a company point.
4) The whistle blowers act was designed to cover you in case of retribution. True some companies don't like that.
5) Make copies of the back ups and store them on site. Like it was mentioned earlier. Taking them off site could get you in more trouble. The one copy in your desk or office was a good suggestion with another still on site. One to the legal folks with the signed receipt covers you as well.

Your definitely being pushed to do something that is covering up someone's mistake. It may not even be a company issue. The Boss may have had personal "talks" with someone outside the company that were immoral, illegal etc. and he realized there is a trail out there and wants it gone.

But if you work for a government contractor or agency, its better to have your rear covered when or if it all hits.

Cover yourself and everyone else in the trenches. Let the higher ups take the heat when it hits.

Personally...I work in a public "company" so we of course keep email backed up and saved. Just like the financial records. The public can view these records at any time thanks to the Public Information Act. And it isn't a bad thing either. Supposed to keep public offices honest.

So in ending...don't do it, cover yourself and get the legal folks to back you up on it. They will have the companies interests in their mind and their own jobs in their hearts if they get asked why they didn't step in at the beginning if everything goes south.

by jeff

Since IT people aren't lawyers why do their job. Get the authorization of the new policy in writing. Then take the letter to the lawyers within the dept. to verify the legal issues. They will then send you a letter stating that the new policy is ok or not. If it is not then you, they (lawyers), or both send a letter to the person requesting the policy change that the policy cannot be administered.

Your butt is not on the line since you were not the one that said you can't do it.

by buddana

any idea why your managaement .. want to delete the backup .. when maintaining a backup vth surplus hard disk space and mailboxes available... is damn affordable and easy task to do......

unless you have something to do vth this issue.... why do you want to ... become a spacegoat for others foolish decissions... it migh look ok for now.. but in the long run .. for a company .... you need to refer to many things .. that may not be just 30 days old...

hmmmm poor situation you are in .. reminds me of only one thin g.. quit the job and save you neck and your prestige...

by spadata

I read quickly through your letters on this subject --- you appear to be more of a vindictive employee with political goals contrary to your company's ??

Especially the comments that you have been reading all their private email and you now have admitted to have commited a FEDERAL CRIME!

by angry_white_male

Company mail = company property - everyone signed an internet/e-mail use agreement where they consent to their mailboxes can be inspected at any time. I'm also the IT security guy here. I suspect a problem - I look into it and report my findings, even if it was just a random audit. No laws broken here.

Don't want to get in trouble? Then don't speak of your malfeasance on the company mail system.

by jdriehm

First, discuss the matter with your supervisor and ensure that he has made the powers-that-be aware of the effects of this mandate on business process, compliance, liability, etc.

Second, even if your boss did not get this directive in writing, make sure that you get it on company stationary, signed and dated.

Third, you might even want to consult with an attorney.

by kwilliams30

If your state law (Open Records Act) requires that you keep emails for a specific period of time, then you WILL violate the law by deleting them. Fixing this is easier than you think. Just send a copy of the memo/order (anonomously of course) to the local news media, both print and television. Let them take the agency on.

If you don't want to cause a stink, then talk your agency's legal advisor and pose the question to him/her and them deal with the top brass. If you don't have a legal advisor in-house, then your govening body will have a legal department --- contact them with your question. They don't want lawsuits if they can avoid them.

Good Lucj

by oregonnative

I agree with kwilliams that you should take a strong stand on this. I don't think I would go straight to the media; I would presume first that this mandate is coming from an idiot rather than a felon. But I would CYA.

One other thought; it was not mentioned if the mandate came down orally or in writing. My bet is that this is an oral instruction. If that is the case, you are under no obligation to comply. However, everything you do must be in writing from this point forward.

Finally, start lookiing for another job. I'm sure this is not the first moral dilema you've been in at this agency, and it won't be the last. Unless there is new leadership committed to cleaning things up, you've got to protect your career and get out!!!

by lholder

Obeying the law comes first. Explain to the powers-that-be that the requested action would violate the law. If they will not listen, take it up the chain of command.

by digi-tal

My advice is to store the email in a different way, Archival storage on say a DVD to cover yourself. Here is the probable cause... Email clutter and requirements for storage are growing at a phenomenal rate. I have users who refuse to delete ANY email whatsoever. The only way to manage it is to archive it, save it as a DVD (since this takes less space than tape) and label the DVD with the date of archive - I make the powers that be happy because I am not using as much storage and tape space on the servers. I also shop around for quality DVD media at a decent price and I use a workstation in the server room (no one knows about it but I.S.) to store/backup from. No matter what the scenario, I am pretty well covered.

by bob.wasson

We are each responsible to someone. I suggest you inform those above you of your concern in writing and if their decision does not change get the request from them in writing - always in writing! They may reconsider enforcing this if they have to put their signature on it.

by jsmith2

I'm Canadian, so I apologise for not knowing the American terms, but if that happened to me up here, then I would call the Auditor General. Here in Canada, the Auditor General is the government watchdog. She's the person who digs through government emails to find out who is doing what to whom, and who is pocketing the loose change, so if anyone would know of a legal reason to disobey your boss's boss, she would be the one. Is there an American equivalent to this person?

Either way, I highly recommend that you talk to your personal lawyer before you put your head on the chopping block. If you're being forced to break the law, even an obscure or ambiguous law, then you need protection.

by johnri60626

Knowing that you will be in violation of federal law if you follow this instruction you have been given, your choices are fairly clear.

You cannot violate the law, but to be in compliance with yout order, simply squirrel the current backup tapes away to CYA and continue using a new set of backup tapes. You should have these available through your department anyway, and having a second backup kept in secure vault off site is what I advice my clients to do as disaster, such as flood, fire, etc. If you do this, you are not only smart, but covered and compliant.

by johnri60626

Knowing that you will be in violation of federal law if you follow this instruction you have been given, your choices are fairly clear.

You cannot violate the law, but to be in compliance with yout order, simply squirrel the current backup tapes away to CYA and continue using a new set of backup tapes. You should have these available through your department anyway, and having a second backup kept in secure vault off site is what I advise my clients to do as disaster recovery measure against flood, fire, etc.

If you do this, you are not only smart, but covered and compliant.

by steve.simpson

If keeping copies of the data is all that is required to satisfy the law. Than make one before you delete everything. Give it to your boss and ask for confirmation that he's looking after the only backup. That way it's up him what he does with it.

I think I'd be very tempted to make a copy for my self though, just as insurance.

by scott.sorensen

If in your shoes I'd backup and document everything first for myself then I'd pass another copy up the chain of command. I also find it helpful to talk to someone above the guy wanting to delete everything. You dont know when the shi*t may hit the fan or if it even will. Maybe things have change in the corp and you now have a dept that will back eveything up for you. There may be a bright side to it, just dont look for it so hard you forget to cya.

by stampout

Of course, don't break any laws. You might try getting the order signed and in writing before taking any action.(optional) Then either backup or copy the email destined to be deleted to tape, another server, or perhaps an external hard drive if one can be located that's large enough. Either way, save and store it. Then follow the request that came down from the top. It would probably be best not to announce that the email is stored elsewhere, just in case the deletion is intended to eliminate culpable evidence.

by kmiller

How about making 2 backups (to tape, DVD, whatever you've got) and giving one to your boss? Stash that second backup somewhere safe and don't let anybody know it exists. Good luck, it's tough to be put into that position, I was there once and this is exactly what I did. Luckily, I never needed that 2nd backup and I left that company for another position a few months later.

by bootp

If necessary, pay for one yourself.

When the soft brown stuff hits the fan, you can bet your last paycheck that the mountain won't be pointing at itself.

Depending upon how delicate the situation - meaning how many years your boss could serve if whatever it is managements wants deep-sixed - you may or may not be able to seek out the advice of organizational legal staff. If it is too delicate, then their advice will have been compromised. Also likely, the internal legal staff will ignore client confidentially oaths and will instead pass up your "insubordination" to management - probably not what you had in mind.

If time is short - then draft a written document to YOUR supervisor that you believe the destruction activities are illegal and ask HIM/HER for clarification IN WRITING. .... this is called passing the buck and trying to pre-empt a defense when the bullets start flying.

Welcome to the world of hardball politics.

Ethical issues aside, it is easier to secure employment when you are OUTSIDE jail than when you are inside jail. Or in the middle of legal difficulties. So, get clear on LEGAL vs ETHICAL.

Finally - yet another example of why so few really good (honest ??) people wind up in the political arena.

BTW - Been there and done it. I stayed honest and ethical - but it did cost me my career. Now in another field and still breathing the air of my choosing.

by oscaro

Having worked with International companies I would have a IT director in one place and a business director at the local office. As such one provides technical direction and the other business direction. Sometimes one would get into the others territory and it was my job to be diplomatic and clear in these issues. When all is said the choice is what is best for the organization as a whole and not us as individuals.
Hope this helps.

by raclapp

Unfortunately, you are being put in the position of WhistleBlower. Here in Ohio, an action like this COULD be considered ILLEGAL. Get the order in writing (if anyone is dumb enough to do so). Then, it is time for a "leak" to local media. The order will reversed along with the careers of some idiots who are way to high in the chain of command.

by consultanttrish

As a government agency, you should have a Records Manager and a records management schedule. Handling of the e-mails that are records should be covered in the records management schedule. Get the records manager involved and talking with the IG office about this matter.

At the least, better education on the records management policies and practices needs to be done; at the worse, a records management decision and change in policy and procedures needs to happen to make sure that records that exist only on the e-mail server are considered and handled by the records management policy and practices. I know because I have done this as a consultant for government agencies.

by raclapp

Might be time to make copys of the archive tapes and put them into the hands of an attorney. If something is up, you can be the hero by producing the destroyed info. If nothing comes about, then simply ask the attorney to see they are destroyed. Might give you some protection, in case the idiot upstairs does not wise up.

by anthem

You have copies of all of their emails regarding this, and still don't know exactly why they want to do it? Come on, go ahead and read them...

by raclapp

I wonder if there is also any protection from HIPPA or SOX law. There are records clauses in both, dealing with retention. May be some good reasons to convince the CEO to stop. You may be able to tell him the company won't pass their next SOX audit if they do it.

by jeremyhoughton

I'd listen to the advice of almost everyone here especially those of us that have been in similar situations or ones that work for gov't agencies or gov't contractors.

You need to remember that it is you on the line initially so definitly CYA, if your relationship is a positive one with your superior then talk to them, but don't do that until you make a back up of everything first. One thing that can be learned the hard way is those you think you can trust in a company may have to cover themselves as well and that means letting it fall on you.

If you can, make backups and keep them in a secure location. Before you take them offsite you will need to find out the policy of your org. You don't want to be the one trying to do right but end up getting arrested because you have "stolen" company property by taking it offsite. There are usually places with in the company you can hide things.

Also depending on where you work take a micro casette recorder or a voice recorder of some kind when you talk to your upper management. Try to get in recorded in some way. And know what questions you are wanting to ask before you go in but don't act scripted just concerned.

If you can't record it then follow up with an email confirming what you spoke about, get a read reciept of some kind and keep that. You will want to be able to verify later that it was sent, recieved and read.

These are just some thoughts, hope it works out.

by wildmarjoram

And you've provided evidence right here that you know what you're about to do is illegal. And you're going to do it anyway (with the note that you might consider taking a payoff bribe as severance too - that would play well in front of a jury.) I hope you will decide to speak to a lawyer before taking any irrevocable steps.

by d.warwick

It is prudent to notify all E-mail users that the action to destroy the E-mail records is going to take place and the time and date of the intended action. This is also a way of notifing the legal counsel specifically of the inpending action. As a dept. manager of a public agency it is important to communicate any such request, regardless of the source, to the general counsel of the agency and seek advice on the "legal procedure to affect the action".

Depending on the applicable juristdiction, the enacting manager (you) could be held personally liable for the action. This does not ensure the action will not be a problem in the future, but you have taken the appropriate action to defend your legal liability. Be sure to keep a copy of the legal dept's response. If it is a violation of the laws, then the legal dept becomes responsible for the decision once provided notification.

By notifing the E-mail users you will also protect your trust with them.

Having served for 13 years in a similar position of a public agency, the decision may not have been made to cover someone but rather at the suggestion of an uninformed administrator. Let the Legal Dept. take the "heat", but protect yourself.