E-mail retention policy - ethical dilemma
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by mikercol
Start talking to a lawyer, a PAID lawyer, if you are using a lawyer "buddy" and they have not told you to hire your own, they are giving you bad advice.
You should NOT post anything else here because TechRepublic will DEFINTELY respond to a subpoena by coughing up their backups.
Angry White Male - why did you pick that alias? It's perfect for your bosses lawyer. "We didn't know that he was a disgruntled employee. How could we have know that he was SECRETLY destroying company records. We have always been able to trust our IT pros........"
by wildmarjoram
by donaldjj
Since there are lots of us who read this series of posts it is PROOF you were not trying to hide anything. And be glad that these poswts are here as when they are grabbed by court order they will back up you NOT your boss.
1) get it in writing.
2) back up everything at least 3 times and spread the sealed copies around to those that can hold them wiyhout problem.
3) regestered mail and not opening them is good since it proves the custodian did not read anything.
Thanks for the advice everyone.
The plan of action is to make a last attempt to scuttle these plans and ensure we as a company is excersizing due dilligence and following the law.
If that doesn't work - I'll document everything, hide a backup tape, make a call to the state Inspector General's office, update my resume and pray.
We're set to be audited sometime starting next month which may explain the timeline they're imposing.
Red flags and alarms.
Wish me luck.
>> We're set to be audited sometime starting next month which may explain the timeline they're imposing.
Oh, so now we all know what the problem is. Your boss (CEO) is no doubt expecting something serious to show up in the audit, and wants the emails banished to perdition instead of him.
Congratulations are in order to you. Because of your tougher moral fiber, you will no doubt be the first step to putting this guy (and probably others) where he belongs.
BTW, please make sure in the meantime you try to get this verbal order either in writing or electronically, to provide evidence of his desires. When the auditors come to your group, and ask if there has been anything of note they should be aware of, you can innocently present them with your evidence and your back-seat quarterback suspicions. 'Nuf said.
Dave A.
by chi_girl
by scott.geiger
Hmmm, good idea, the only thing I see as a problem is that if you do go ahead and "destroy" the emails, even with a backup copy, you could still be considered an accomplice and get in trouble for "attempting to destroy data". Not quite a serious as actually destroying it, but still... Also, what if something happens to the backup? I would say stand firm and refuse. It's not about CYA, it's about not doing something illegal. An employer CANNOT compel an employee to participate in an illegal activity.
Good Luck whatever you decide.
Scott Geiger
by tonythetiger
by schmidtd
Contacting the AG office is the best first step. Legal and procedural advice is a great idea. So is documentation of your actions. But in the process make it clear you are doing this to "understand" your legal requirements, not because you think something is being "covered up". This is pure speculation on your part (I am not saying your wrong, merely that legally you don't want to take a stand on this issue.)
BUT whatever you do, don't start archiving and hiding organization data!!! Under no circumstances should you allow yourself to become the arbitrator of what data should be archived or how long it will be archived for. You make yourself liable both to outside parties and your organization.
It is becoming standard pratice for many organizations to delete non essential data. In fact a policy of this kind is often designed to protect an organization from the retention laws, let me explain.
You need to read the regulations very closely. If you have no policy on data retention, you potentially become liable for any and all data, after all why did you delete A but not B? A defined data retention policy will answer this question and in fact is one thing audit often looks for.
You may be pressed for time, but hiding data is a dangerous option. I should hope it won't come to this and you have time to get advice from the AG office, but if you still decide you need to keep the tapes, you should turn them over to a legal authority of some kind, like the AG office.
by john
After reading more of this thread and thinking a little more about it, I think if I were you I would go ahead and look for another job, or at least request a transfer.
I can't envision a scenario where this would occur except for one: there must be some damning stuff in that email for someone, and that someone wants you to assist them in a coverup. There is no other logical explanation. If the concern had to do with the efficiency of email systems, then it would have had to have been preceeded by an incident where the email systems did not perform up to spec, probably an ongoing issue where management felt they had to step in and ask for a fix. Since you state that this is not the case, then the only remaining conclusion is that there is some information in that email archive that someone wants erased. Personally, I would not work for such an organization. Post your resume and get out!
Been job hunting since January, mostly fishing... a couple of interviews, lunch meetings with recruiters, etc... - seeing if something better comes along... but the IT job market is still a bit slow in these parts. But the search has shifted into a higher gear now that I've been tasked to do something that I object to for a multitude of reasons.
I have a feeling that your hunch is right and it's the same thing that I'm thinking - something ain't right. If the mail server was "inefficient" - I'd be the first to know since it's part of my job (and my phone would be ringing off the hook if an e-mail or calendar appointment took more than a second to come up).
by ogils
by breadtrk
in a public lawsuit. After you are fired, turn over all of your evidence to all of the local news stations, govt agency's.
Let this clown make you a millionaire.
by blueknight
Usually there is a reason provided with a directive such as you've received. It seems to me that the "top of the mountain" is attempting to cover something up.
If I were you, there are several things I would do before I carried out "Mr. Mountain's" order:
1) Research laws and legal requirements that regulate your particular business. If you find that it would be illegal, inform your direct supervisor of your finding, tell him that since it is illegal, he will have to find someone else to carry it out if he still wants to be part of the activity.
2) Check with the users you said need documents available for extended periods. Inform your boss of your findings and set up a meeting with those users and "Mr. Mountain" so he is made aware of the need. If it's a legitimate business need the users have, he'd be stupid to destroy documents they need to accomplish business objectives.
3) Once you find it is NOT illegal, and assuming the users can be satisfied regarding retention periods, then, and only then carry our "Mr. Mountain's" directive.
If you happen to find that "Mr. Mountain" has done something illegal during your "research" phase, report it and stop -- do not carry out his directive lest you implicate yourself in the "crime."
We in IT need to do what's best for the company and what's best for the users. We need to do what is right and ethical. If we don't, we're no better than the hackers and others we all despise.
If it comes down to it, look for a new place to work. Your integrity is worth much more than the job.
Jim
by steverd
Having run IT and SOX audits and been in IT for more years than I want to count, something stinks here. The advice given is good. Please get a lawyer - one who specializes in white collar crime. I would listen to the lawyer before I start going to the press.
If you go to the press, you'll be labeled a pariah. There are legal avenues to take first. DOCUMENT EVERYTHING.
This will be very uncomfortable for you but you will be so much better off in so many ways doing the right thing.
by dc_guy
If time is of the essence, you'll have to pay more to get one right now, but it will be worth it. We all make jokes about lawyers, but there are times when you just flat need one. This is one of those times.
Most, if not all, of the options you have available are dicey. You really could be prosecuted, and it's not clear which option will eliminate that risk. Don't take chances with your future!
by donaldjj
by pmpsicle
That was a big mistake... you've been avoiding the look of being unprofessional by acting like you're unprofessional ("I don't know - we'll figure it out later").
What you should have done is make sure that everyone who complains knows that you've been told to do it by the CEO. That way if the post-processing food waste hits the rotating ventilation device everyone will point at the CEO. As it stands you've let the company think the IT department is going off half-cocked.
The only comment I have is that this is your boss's problem.
Other than that ... follow the advice you've gotten so far.
Do an archival backup to CD or DVD ... but perform your normal archival procedures (i.e. store offsite, store in fire-resistant room etc.). Then document where it is in a method that will allow an auditor and/or investigator to find both the archive and the document. Keep a copy of that document.
Call and report the "potential" violation ... but wait until enough others know of the situation that any of them could have blown the whistle.
Finally, contact the ethics bureau for your area of government (if it exists) and a lawyer familiar with the issues. Do what they tell you to do to protect yourself. At worst you can point to the lawyer and say ... "But he said it was actually legal and that I was overreacting".
Remember your first duty is to yourself. Don't outright refuse and don't get the reputation of either acting without thinking, mulish behaviour or "Pretty Perfect Programmer". And don't make an enemy of the CEO - you'll lose.
Let him be caught on his own petard not yours. Just don't get caught yourself.
Glen Ford, PMP
Can Da Software
IS Project Management
Business Systems & Process Improvement
by jattas9
I too was given a new electronic retension policy in my company which happens to be a newspaper. Whether or not there are regulatory issues, I found the policy highly problematical with the executives of the corporation (A newspaper group). Although never stated in writing, the reason for the policy was to eliminate any audit tracks that could be used in the future for a lawsuit.
For the most part, most managers and executives, found the policy incredible. They as I used the system to maintain our communications records, and reference past contracts, etc. This is exactly what the parent corporation wanted broken.
The crumb supplied as a solution, was that if you have something that important, print it out and file it. I believe that would have been addressed later, and dealed with in a similar situation. Alternatively, save the file some where else in your "My Documents" for future reference. I believe that was going to be the next issue. I being the IT Director, found the need to keep many records, since they related to our 1000 employees, as well as a hundred or so vendors. Since there are only 4 or 5 secretaries in the entire corporation, everyone is responsible for their own documents. This creates a tremendous labor intense activity for most managers.
I frankly believe that all corporations should be legal required to keep all communications for several years, written or electronic. I would not be surprised to find that there is a law somewhere that supports that position. My opinion only.
by meesha
by jharney
Take a look at SOX (Sarbanes Oxley), then remind
your management about their (not yours)
resposibility to be accountable. This may be the
answer to your audit question. We also are
assisting our customer with becoming compliant.
Good luck to you.
JGH
by kevin.uberti
by xrogers
by zzyp
It has been well established that it is not a federal crime for a company employee to read e-mail sent on company computers.
Spadata is wrong.
by xrogers
http://www.usbr.gov/recman/rcd/rcd07-01.htm
Directives and Standards RCD 07-01
read paragraph B
PENALTIES MAY BE IMPOSED ON EMPLOYEES WHO ENGAGE IN THE UNAUTHORIZED DESTRUCTION OF FEDERAL RECORDS.
Getting the CEO to approve the directive in writing, by email or otherwise, would therefore authorize our poor Network guy to delete the emails. The person who does NOT have the authority to call for the destruction of the emails, is the CEO. Therefore he would be guilty and not the IT person.
This really sounds like a story out of WWII. The front line grunt is ordered to kill another human. He doesn't want to, but he has his orders!
He should really get his manager to do it. If they won't do it, then he should decline to do it as well. No matter what happens, it will probably cost someone their job.
Damned if you do, damned if you don't
by johnri60626
Actually, the CIO ought to be having the final say on this. A CEO is not knowledgable enough on the topic to competently give such an order without consulting the CIO first.
Where is the CIO's sign-off on this? IS the CIO even cognizant that this order has been given?
by kevin.uberti
by govtcio
IT provides a service. We are not the email police police... We just make sure the email that the company needs is backed up. We do not tell them how long to keep it or where to keep it.
I saw in another email that the original poster is reading email of users - I hope not.
everybody signs a piece of paper that email is company property but I'll bet the company didn't give him that access whenever he wants it. You should always have a written request to do that from HR or a manager. You are commiting a crime if you are reading email without authorization.
govt cio
by rimman.larry
IT's responsibilities for managing the information are little more than providing a place to store it and seeing that the hardware, networks and systems remain available.
The responsibility for the management of the information (which is a corporate asset) belongs to the originating organization, which is also who funds the service provided by IT in all but the smallest of organizations.
In the Federal Arena, IT has virtually NO RESPONSIBILITY for the information, as all Federal Records ultimately are to be either destroyed per the retention schedule they are managed under, or transferred to NARA for permanent retention.
IT is a service that supports the mission of an Agency or a Corporation. As for being the "one to guarantee" information will be there, I'd put my money elsewhere.
Ask an IT person about persistent format, conversion and migration, media degradation, software and hardware obsolescence planning and see what their response is. In the Federal Arena, many records have retention periods of 75 years and longer, and the same is true for records generated by any Contractors to a Federal Agency... do you HONESTLY THINK that IT is willing to accept this responsibility? They seem to think that 1-3% loss of data during migration is acceptable, and simply state that it's a "lossy process"... ask and RIM Professional if that's acceptable.
by tmalandro
by dc_guy
Oh sure!
The guy is looking for a way to resolve this with minimum fallout, so that he just might barely still have his job when it's over. Blabbing it to everyone in the company is NOT the way to accomplish that.
He has to decide:
1. Do you want to do what you think is ethical and avoid prosecution?
2. Do you want to keep the job?
3. Do you want the organization to magically change overnight so this will go away?
Number one is fairly easy although I still advise talking to a lawyer before doing ANYTHING.
Number two is not easy but it's possible. But only if you don't care about number one. The two goals are almost mutually exclusive.
Number three is of course everyone's choice. The big problem with it is that it's impossible. Forget number three. It will never happen in the real universe.
Deal with reality, but at least try to avoid making it worse. Which I guarantee is what's going to happen if you send out that broadcast. DON'T DO IT!
by schmidtd
Public disclosure laws don't necisarrily apply to every email on your system, just as they don't apply to every telephone coversation (otherwise you would have to tape and keep everything you say.) They only apply to genuine public records as determined by the agency or courts.
You as an email admin have no way of knowing what documents on the server are public records or not or even if any are. The end user ought be responbible for determining which documents need to be kept and storing them. Indeed, having a set policy for email deletion schedules will save you and your organization a lot of headaches later.
That said, involentarily deleting email used by customers seems like a little overboard, but your not making that call.
by mross01
There has been a considerable amount of mentioning of you breaking the law. But no specific law has been mentioned. Lawyers can be expensive and copying all the data and taking it off site can be construed as stealing (first law mentioned that you would be breaking).
Take the advice of most, document what you are required to do. Voice your concerns, get it documented, check into it the best you can on what laws are out there on this type of behavior. This can't be the first time this has happened.
It does seem that something is up is this is being pushed hard for no apparent reason, especially with a short deadline for it to happen. You may want to talk to the governing body above your government organization and let them know what is going on (anonymous of course), but its possible this is coming from there.
Becareful, start looking for a job, one way or another its going to hit the fan.
Good Luck
by mross01
In your email, you should suggest creating a personal PST and have it stored on a server. This way the data is being backuped and the folder just looks like a regular folder in OutLook. You can mass copy everything to it including, sent and deleted emails.
I do this everyday, so that I have a copy of all my emails. I rarely delete an email, I just move it to its appropriate folder.
The first thing I would do is get a paper copy of this order. Second I would letter, which I would keep a copy of, to the person who issued the order and let them know that this violates federal laws and regulations. And finally I would send a copy of this order to the approprate Federal Agency to let them know that this is going on. Of course you would want to keep a copy of this.
Just remember all of those accountants and IT personell, at a major brokage firm that were indited for failing to save manitory E-Mails and documents.
by mross01
Not sure you should be shouting this information out. If you did do the deletion and you sent the email out saying you were, you are tied to it. Remember the post talking about lowest man on the totem pole. This is the first post you have done that sounded vendictive and childish. You now are going down the wrong road here.
Cover yourself, don't look at this as a easy road possibility, it won't be, you will not win here. There are no possible situations where you are going to be better off than right now.
No matter what you may think is your rights to private emails, only HR has the right to requisition them. You are now crossing a different line.
by mross01
You have painted yourself into a corner and now are starting to sound vindictive and looking for a easy road. Things only seem to be getting worse for you here.
By the way, I'm not sure you mentioned it, but govenment agencies don't have CEOs.
other than health records and some financial records, the Feds have very little records statutes governing state government general records. It's primarily STATE records law that determine "what" and "how long" records be kept.
I don't know of any Federal General Records Retention Laws you seem to be inferring exist.
by slurpee
Check here: http://www.archives.gov/about_us/regulations/part_1234.html
It specifically states: "Agencies shall establish policies and procedures to ensure that electronic records and their documentation are retained as long as needed by the Government." This includes e-mails.
Or more bluntly: "(d) Electronic mail records may not be deleted or otherwise disposed of without prior disposition authority from NARA (44 U.S.C. 3303a). This applies to the original version of the record that is sent or received on the electronic mail system and any copies that have been transferred to a recordkeeping system. See 36 CFR part 1228 for records disposition requirements."
I would talk to one of your agency lawyers, if you have any; otherwise I would be prepared to quit/be fired and contact the Feds prior to the actual destruction of the e-mails.
by rimman.larry
The fact that you don't know of them underscores that you're in IT/IS and NOT in RIM!
Take a look at 36CFR, Subchapter B, Part 1220 for the lead-in requirements and 1220.30 specifically for requirements. After you've gotten your feet wet here, go to Part 1234, 1234.24 specifically to find out about E-mail.
There are the General Retention Schedules, which are managed by NARA, that all Federal Government Agencies utilize to develop their Agency specific schedules from, and if items are not include in the GRS, the Agency must submit an SF-115 form to NARA for the assignment of a retention period. Until that time, these records are considered "Unscheduled" and the retention period for unscheduled records is PERMANENET until they have been evaluated and assigned a retention period.
The GRS is based on the function a record serves and the series it's assigned to to determine the retention period and a HEADS UP HERE FOLKS, the requirements in the GRS apply not only to all Federal Agencies, but they apply to their CONTRACTORS and SUBCONTRACTORS as well.
In addition, the rule with the Feds on records is the retention period is determined by the CONTENT of the record, not the SUBJECT and once something has been determined to rise to the level of a record, the retention requirement is the same "irrespective of media, form or format" of the record.
E-mail is a CONTAINER, the retention period is applied to the CONTENT, not the container. There is NO ASSIGNED RETENTION PERIOD FOR E-MAIL as an object, and E-mail is NOT A RECORD SERIES.
Recently, there was a document in the Federal Register for comment regarding "Transitory E-mail" and the ability to delete copies of E-mail messages in 30, 90, 180 days once they were determined to be transitory in nature, but the final rule on this has yet to be issued.
My recommendation to the original poster of this thread is to consider the fact that BECAUSE YOU ARE AWARE that there are guidelines that are to be followed, if you KNOWINGLY DESTROY FEDERAL RECORDS, there ARE PENALTIES. Take a look at 44USC, Section 3301 and follow the bouncing ball to the balance of the requirements....
by barbedwire
Drew said "the Feds have very little records statutes governing state government general records", if you read it again. Both replies talked about Fed agencies...
So what about state agencies.
I still think the original poster works for a private company anyway. Among other things, he said he went and talked to the CEO - doesn't exist in government.
by deansonn
by govtcio
Shouldn't be a problem as long as your organization/agency got the policy reviewed and approved by legal and/or senior management.
IT is not tasked with enforcing or dictating records retention policy - you don't want that responsiblity. Most government agencies give that to the holders of the information. Where it should be. IT is responsible for backing it up and making sure what you do have is available.
We keep email for 60 days. The user is responsible for backing it up or printing it out if they need to keep it longer. Not IT.
Good luck.
Govt CIO
by rimman.larry
Beg to differ, and if you truly ARE A Govt. CIO, you should know better than to say this.
IF there is a pending legal action, and the Agency has been informed to not destroy any information related to a specific subject, this means ANY INFORMATION... which includes backup tapes.
Unless all backup tapes are segregated to the level of the user, or information is indexed at a fine level before servers are backed up, the backup tapes contain a compendium of information that is only sequential and chronological in nature. There's really no way to tell if the data on the backup tape may be related to any pending litigation, so if the practice is to rotate and write over tapes every 30 days, you could be found guilty of "spoliation by practice".
There have been recent cases where this has occurred, when the court asked for policies and procedures related to the management of backup tapes, even though it was asserted that the backups are used only to re-initiate systems in the event of a disaster for recovery of information, they DO EXIST, and they DO INCLUDE information that is impacted by the order to preserve.
The fact that IT doesn't need to dictate or enforce retention policies doesn't relieve them of the responsibility for following them either. Ignorance may be bliss, but if it were me, I think I'd ask to be "put in the loop" on decisions related to records retention.
by bilbobybath
We all get ethical dilemmas, and none of us asks for them. It's a test of manhood - or personhood', if you must!
So, you either believe in US law, your Constitution, and the Freedom of Information Act, or you don't. 'Just following orders' was what the Nurnberg Trials was all about.
If you're worried enough about it to ask the question here, then there *is* something to be worried about. It's the 21st century. Do what you will be comfortable telling your grandchildren about.
Leak it to the press.....
Cleverly.
BB
by bilbobybath
We all get ethical dilemmas, and none of us asks for them. It's a test of manhood - or 'personhood', if you must!
So, you either believe in US law, your Constitution, and the Freedom of Information Act, or you don't. 'Just following orders' was what the Nurnberg Trials was all about.
If you're worried enough about it to ask the question here, then there *is* something to be worried about. It's the 21st century. Do what you will be comfortable telling your grandchildren about.
Leak it to the press.....
Cleverly.
BB
by govtcio
I replied to your original post with what you need to know - I don't know how many other posts gave you the same info because I can't take the time to read them all.
BUT, your job is not to be the records manager for your organization. Unless you have been given the responsiblity to enforce your agencies records retention policy you have done the right thing by raising the issue but there is nothing, I repeat nothing, wrong with deleting email after 30 days. Happens all the time at good companies and other well run government agencies.
govt CIO
by tenderfoot
by rimman.larry
Sure...
Like Tyco, Arthur Andersen, ENRON, WorldCom, Morgan Stanley, UBS Warburg... the list goes on. All of these companies had policies, some of them even followed them... which in some cases, is what got them in trouble.
Retention is not a time-based function and the period for retention is not based on the "vessel" the information is delivered in. It's based on the CONTENT in the information object. E-mail is just the manner in which the information is delivered, organizations do not establish their retention periods for records based on the manner in which they receive it.
Some of the work being done by the SEDONA Conference and the recent comments requested to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP) indicate there is a DEFINITE SHIFT in the courts opinion on how they view the manner in which information (especially electronic forms of information) are managed by organizations.
It would do many posting in this thread a world of good to familiarize themselves with these changes.
by danetter
by unixmandt
by jquade
by jcbrooks_bs9
by mandrake64
Company law does not override state and federal law. But if you must follow orders, get someone else to hold the accountability for the action of deleting the records and sign off the action.
In there is still some doubt then cut an encrypted copy yourself and shelve it at the back of a filing cabinet for safe keeping.
by free_lo2002
Well ...consider yourself lucky in the first place , for being in the U.S. where laws and regulations some how influence the company decision- making and help you personally solve this issue.
Because for me the solution BFilmFan gave in the fist place is the right one.
In Europe we are not that lucky, particularly in small countries where the State is still finding it's own way and doesn't have time to "teach" companies.
Just hold to the law and be careful with locking company's data because even if you do it for a greater purpose it still is illegal.
by amtek
The first thing I learned was cya or cover your a__.
Have your boss get it in writing and give all It\
personnel a copy before destroying anything. Then
all IT personnel have their a__es covered.
by john
Personally retaining a copy of this data offsite, like in the proposed solution where you leave it with a lawyer, is illegal in and of itself. It is definately data theft. What they are asking you to do is not legal, it is not even legal for them to ask you to do it! Don't follow those infractions with one of your own!
I would follow all of the other suggestions, contacting the authorities, contacting senior management, etc. In the end, I would walk before I stuck my head in the noose by complying with this demand!
by lavetta
by rimman.larry
They're potentially RECORDS under the Federal Arena. See 44USC 3301 or 36CFR 1220.14 for the definition of a Federal Record
Take a close look at 36CFR Subchapter B, Part 1220 and Part 1234. to find out more about the requirements for managing records and specifically E-mail as records.
If you work for a Federal Agency, your Agency's CIO website should have information on their Records Management Policy, and if it doesn't you may want to find out who the liaison to your agency is at NARA to discuss this a bit further.
by rimman.larry
Even in the Federal Arena, the CIO isn't always the one who makes the decision on how things are done when it comes to records.
It's common for an Agency's policy on RIM to be under the CIO, but not EVERY Agency follows this organizational structure. Also, keep in mind that E-mail is considered (incorrectly by many) as a business application, and therefore, the manner in which it's managed may be determined by business rules rather than Records Management rules.
The requirement in 36CFR is that if E-mail is determined to be a record (based on appraisal of the content) then it must be managed in an ERMS OUTSIDE of the E-mail application for it's assigned retention period (which is determined by the record series it falls into).
Most of this should be in a RIM Policy document, and carried out at a much lower level than the "C-Anything" when it comes to day-to-day decisions.
Where the primary problem seems to exist in both the Public and Private sector is the turf battle over who is in control of, and who makes the decisions about, the management of the actual "information". The user group/originator needs to be involved, RIM (who typically manages the organizational retention schedule) needs to be involved and IT (who maintains the repository) needs to understand the business needs of the users and the requirements in the retention schedule.
A properly designed retention schedule takes into account a number of factors:
1) Legal, Statutory and Regulatory requirements for retaining information
2) Business needs (determined by the end users) that may exceed these required periods
3) Historic, Intrinsic or Research value of the information beyond the required and business needs
4) Risks associated with retaining the information beyond required and business needs
The retention period is based on all of the above and should be approved by a committee including members from the user community, legal, audit, research, records management and archives (if they all exist) and approved by Senior Management (CEO, CIO or whomever).
Once this process is completed, IT should be informed what the requirements are for retention of the information and needs to design systems that accommodate this... and prior to disposition of ANY INFORMATION, approval needs to be obtained, to ensure there are no pending legal actions related to the information.
IT needs to better understand the perspective of the information managers that they are only responsible for providing the tools necessary for enabling storage and access to the information, it's the originators of the information that determine what's to be done with it.
by rimman.larry
TITLE 44 > CHAPTER 31 > ? 3106
? 3106. Unlawful removal, destruction of records
Release date: 2005-03-01
The head of each Federal agency shall notify the Archivist of any actual, impending, or threatened unlawful removal, defacing, alteration, or destruction of records in the custody of the agency of which he is the head that shall come to his attention, and with the assistance of the Archivist shall initiate action through the Attorney General for the recovery of records he knows or has reason to believe have been unlawfully removed from his agency, or from another Federal agency whose records have been transferred to his legal custody. In any case in which the head of the agency does not initiate an action for such recovery or other redress within a reasonable period of time after being notified of any such unlawful action, the Archivist shall request the Attorney General to initiate such an action, and shall notify the Congress when such a request has been made.
by rockymtnman
Wow. 75 to 100 mailboxes and I'm assuming some public folders and calendars running on dual 1 gig CPU with 3 gig RAM with about 75 GB free space... and you're getting a new one!?!
Anyway, I agree with everyone else who's telling you 'something else is going on'. You should already have reported this to someone mentioned in the other recommendations. I work in health care and while deleting the email may not be a problem, removing them in any form to an unauthorized location or giving someone possession of potentially HIPAA (a federal law) related info is a felony. Attorney or otherwise. That's just plain a bad idea no matter what unless you're directed to by some higher athority like the Justice Department. Good luck.
by govtcio
We will be implementing a email retention policy here soon that will delete all email over 60 days from the email server. We currently keep it all but are working with legal to define a formal policy. If you don't archive it will be gone after 60 days.... It happens all the time - dont' read more into this than is there.
govtcio
by it-guy
by art66
As an IT manager, NO WAY would I do this. I have had to go back and give years past of e-mail to lawyers for law suits. Nothing is more humiliating than having a certain week NOT backed up because of tape jam, or something silly, and then having the lawyers NEEDING that week. Imagine not having ANY of it? You would be the scapegoat.
My thoughts, make copies of EVERYTHING, and put it all in a lock box somewhere. Government? I wouldn't even take it home, I'd get a box at a bank or something. THEN call the FBI, or someone to see if they would like copies of it all JUST IN CASE.
Even then, I would submit a written response in e-mail and snailmail, saying "no", and your ethical reasons. I would send that response to your boss, his boss, and your state Senator.
It is VERY scarry when it comes to e-mail. I wouldn't lose a single one if I were you. Let the Manager do it.
by knot_mine
The fastest and most effective way to stop this proposal is to call the biggest media outlet in your community. After getting their agreement to keep your identity confidential, tell them your story. Be prepared to provide proof. Newspeople don't go out on a limb unless they have thoughly checked it for cracks first.
This is the nuclear option. Chances are that you will not be able to outrun the resulting blast. If you really don't trust those around you to do the right thing and strongly suspect that you will be the fall guy, this may be the only choice open to you.
A better solution is to find the private ear of someone in authority who is likely to "get it." A quiet end-run coached in terms of "I want to make sure nobody gets in trouble," may very well make the problem go away without any ugly muss and fuss.
by rose.flood
by dc_wabisabi
Wow - How about this one for a completely vague and misunderstood aspect of our jobs. I'm sure some can point to specific laws governing RIM, but I've only seen specifics from RIMMAN... and if I read his posts correctly he's stating that the retention policy is dependent on the *content* of the emails. This is pretty subjective, but in the end common sense must rule the day. Even as storage capacities grow by the day, we cannot be expected to retain every single piece of spam we ever received (which is implied by many of the responses here that say *everything must be kept*). I could go on - but suffice it to say that this issue is not clear to most IT folks I know.
You have received the most common-sense and specific advice from RIMMAN and GOVCIO - I would listen to them.
I am posting to leave my one cent here, since I have seen no one mention this specifically.
Although CYA is tops on your list - going about it subversively doesn't seem to be the most prudent choice. Others have mentioned retaining copies of all communications with your bosses and getting them in writing.
Why not follow this advice and start with an email to your CEO, manager and legal. Tones of disgruntled employee acting as unwilling victim will probably push the conversation in the wrong direction. Keep it clear, concise and coming from a member of the team that wants to improve the efficiency of the organization. You've mentioned that your current server capacity is more than sufficient and is even being increased soon. Start by detailing your understanding of the request. Your CEO states server capacity as the reason for this policy change. Remind him that you are paid to provide your technical expertise to the org and go on to document current capacity/future growth expectations/costs & ROI for records retention/etc (execs like pictures don't they?) - the point being to clearly show that there is no need to delete the archives. End with a concern that since you have been researching this (for the good of the company) you are unclear on the legal ramifications and feel it is in everyone's interest to document the new policy so that no one walks away with a vague set of expectations. You might go on to explain the need for some tools and training to assist employees with the new policy (outlining some potentially unseen issues that may result e.g. - number of times sales folks have had to refer to emails from 3 months ago, etc).
And hold off on wacking the archives until you have a copy of their response in your personal folder and printed out. Who knows - if your CEO is not acting illegally, but out of misunderstanding of the technology and laws - maybe they'll notice your stellar attitude and how much trouble you saved them by doing the right thing. Worst case scenario, you've shown above and beyond diligence, documented this and saved your cya copies. You make the choice whether or not to delete on your own based on what you've found.
insanity breeds insanity - take the higher road
by itgal
by dr dij
so we may soon see a movie based on this situation: black suited goons come to his door, (pan to him running out the fire escape).
they hold his family ransom, demanding return of the 'hidden copy' of archive email because it contains (either secret project document or evidence of some gov't officials [bungling | crime | putting a hit on someone]).
Our hero contacts a senator who should have authority to clean out 'the crud', only to find out later he is in on the plot and rats him out. (insert more twisty turny plots here).
by it cowgirl
by shadowdark
1) Here is your ammo:
http://www.netdiligence.com/pdf/SarbanesOxley.pdf
and
http://www.cio.com/archive/011505/compliance.html
Print these & give copies to the CEO, CFO & CIO. Draw their attention to page 2 of the Sarbanes-Oxley.pdf, especially the part about the $2 million dollar fine per incident for records (email) violation.
2) Ask if they are familiar with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002. As a Network Admin you yourself should be familiar with it. If not, get familiar & quick.
3) As Network Admin it's your responsibility to respectfully educate mngmt when what they are requesting is illegal & would put them in the way of liability. (read: felony if you are any kind of govt agency.)
4) Firing or otherwise discipling you for refusing to would leave them open to charges of wrongful termination, bringing to light in a court of law whatever it was that they were attempting to hide in the first place.
5) Do Not make secret backups & Do Not turn over tapes, etc to anyone unless subpoenead by a court of law. Doing otherwise would make you guilty of stealing corporate/gov't data, an offense which would give them cause to fire you and/or bring suit resulting in a hefty fine or worse, jail time. You'd also have a tough time getting employment after that.
Very simple. Quit stressing it & get a good night's sleep 'Angry White Male'. Peace.
by rimman.larry
by danetter
by eyost05
It is going to take some guts, but buddy you need to
BLOW THE FREAKIN WHISTLE.
you are protected under federal law. If you feel your life would be threatened by this action, take that to the Home Land Security Offices first and explain to the proper agency...they will point you in the correct direction. We need people like you to do the right thing and keep our government strong. We are a nation of laws, you will be protected. Please do the right thing.
If you feel there is wrong doing going on don't jeopadize yourself by not doing anything, you can end up on the witness stand a friend of the prosecution or not...which would you choose? This could be the course you are on, if it were me I would choose "justice being served rather than serving justice in a bright orange "leisure suit"
I have blown the whistle on a private industrial polluter and I survived quite well thank you very much and our local water resources are cleaner for it. I would do it again, no problem.
Ed Yost
by rimman.larry
"The twist is that we're a government agency that falls under a number of state and federal regulations, requirements and obligations"
Based on this comment it seemed as if he identified himself as a "Govt Agency" and said he falls under Federal Regualtions", the advice provided and citations of laws were correct. Many State agencies are also bound be Federal Law as the over-arching authority that controls how they manage records, or the State regs are crafted in the same language as the Feds
by saurbh1
Just because a person is low in the company hierarchy does'nt mean that the person can't shout and make noise!
If i was you i would make my point (politely) to the top. Shout politely!! And if they still don't listen, get them to sign on legal papers saying that it was THEIR decision to do this!
by mrsgarbers
I too work for a Federal Agency and I can attest to the archives dept and its strict policies.
BFilm is correct.
by nenary
by kcalabama06
You are in a spot. Damned if you do or don't. However, I am a CEO who works with the government. All emails are considered business correspondence and are legally required to be retained for a period of time. Especially if the company is involved in government work or public. We have recent evidence of this with the Arther Anderson deal and the more recent Air Force deal that put Mike Sears in jail.
If server performance were an issue, then backing them off would be sufficient.
I would get it in writing (or email) and send it in a registered letter to yourself at home or a lawyer so it is legally documented and don't open it.
I would back them off and then follow directions but use the advice in the first posting -
make sure you document document document.
Don't read the emails that is not your job - but do back everything off.
KC
by irete
Document to management through your boss, the implications of obeying the order. If management insists, ask for a written order; take a discrete private copy and implement order.
The advantage of documentation amongst others is that management will not be able to claim ignorance or lack of full understanding of implication in the future.
Good luck.
by gil
I can't believe all the paranoid responses by a bunch of midlevel geeks who apparently have nothing better to do but second guess management directives.
I'm not familiar with federal regulations for gov agencies, but in health care, it is common practice to have a short window for the retention of emails -- read some trade journals. In general, most email has about the same content value as a post-it note.
Smart companies -- who are completely ethical and aboveboard -- are simply trying to protect themselves from a long, protracted discovery process if a lawyer-shark hits them with some frivolous lawsuit.
I am also detecting a current of resentment from these folks who feel miffed that they were "given a short timeframe to make this happen". The implication is that management has to clear IT policy with low to mid level IT staff. Sorry, that isn't how it works. If IT is told by senior management to change a particular policy, they (IT) should write up the policy change in standard policy format, get it signed and then do it.
You can't simply assume that a change of this nature is illegal -- that's just paranoia. BTW, don't you have a server to build or something?
by scott.geiger
for some reason I feel the need to be completely politically incorrect for a moment...
Yes massa, yes massa
Ok done.
"I'm not familiar with federal regulations for gov agencies" Ok so then since you admit this how can you claim he [we] are being paranoid? Just because you don't do it in health care?
I wouldn't work for you no matter what the pay, but then you probably wouldn't hire me since I have a brain and can think for myself. Now I'm gonna get back to building a server or something.
by maryi
The law does not exempt you from being arrested by the many Federal and States Laws, you will probably be the escapegoat. I would use your email from your home if possible also office, documentation, and detail with dates and time
journal on this topic to your supervisor on up the chain give them two days to reply. There is a new law to add also the Sarbane-Oxley (SOX) Act of 2002 which came in effected.
If no results go to attorney or go now; its better to pay now then later when you are faced with jail time.
by rrosca
I seem to remember Tech republic posting on this very subject not too long ago. I don't want to lead you on a wild goose chase but do yourself a favor and read up on this piece of legislature (Sarabanes-Oaxley) and it should clear some things up.
If you are correct and you are legaly bound to archive items then write a memo to the company owners or president (anyone in charge) and put down on paper your concerns and objections. Make them say that it's legal to destroy the archives. Leave a paper trail that exonerates you in case of trouble and puts the blame and responsibility squarely where it belongs if the crap hits the fan.
by avid
There are two entities normally accountable for statutory/regulatory and risk management related to the retention of both paper and electronic records. This is the Legal and Finance/Treasury departments (or individuals) in a company. The IT department is rarely accountable for company policy creation/maintenance to assure governmental requirements are met. The IT department is accountable for the safekeeping of the data dn the integrity of the data to prevent unauthorized access or alteration.
Larger firms have a staff to address the various global requriements in this area, smaller firms are often at risk due to a lack of visibility or funding to assure the is closely managed.
Email management is particularly difficult unless you have the tools in place to manage the end to end behavior of your personal computer user. This is rarely the case. As a result, the PC user can put the company at risk by merely keeping a local mail archive that is in violation of company policy.
The risk associated with long term mail retention must be balanced against the need for the facts and data contained therein to run the business as well as protect the company in the event of litigation.
by rbarrie
To quote one of the great talents of our time - "Babes, your screwed."
Do it and you are the one who is taking an overt action to destroy records. You don't say if you got a memo to do this or if everything has been verbal. If the communications has just been verbal be prepared for "...he must have mis-understood our intentions..." (at the best) to complete denial at the worst.
Contact a criminal attorney. If you can't afford an attorney (try expensing this one!) call the Justice department or the GAO or even the FBI.
Making a secret copy for offsite storage may also be illegal. That is why it would be best to contact an attorney or another government official body that can authorize the copy or put a stop to this follishness by throwing a lot of daylight on it.
You are going to be fired. Probably for something else down the road.
If you think it's fishy it probably is. If you ignore your own concerns and go ahead and do it you may not get caught and all may turn out ok but you'll be a weasel and know it.
I'm sorry that you have to face such a crisis. It sounds like you work in a fear driven environment. Even if it is all innocent and the whoever at the top set this in motion is just a dunderhead, it seem that none of the buffers above you has the the intelligence, integrity, or guts to speak up.
Good luck.
by rsanchez
Sort by Trending