Question Locked

External Hard Drive problem!

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi everyone. I will try to explain this the best I can.

I have a 250gig External Hard drive, USB 2.0, that is a few years old. I never had any problems with this drive at all until recently. A few weeks ago, I brought the external to a friends house. We just needed to use the enclosure for a different hard drive. So we took MY drive out, put the other drive in, did what we needed to do. I put my drive back in the enclosure. When I went to use it again at home, it was acting funny. It does not make any loud noises or anything like that, but it was just being slow. Then a few days later it was painful to try to load anything off of it. I thought that the enclosure may have been damaged while at the friends place, so I bought a new enclosure. Unfortunately, that did not help the problem. The drive powers up fine, and Windows (XP) detects it. It shows up in My Computer. But I can't access it at all. It is partitioned in to 2 parts. Drives I: and J: When I click on I: it asks me if I want to format - when I click on J: it tells me the "parameters are incorrect."

The drive went from working fine to working at a limited capacity to now not really being able to be accessed at all. I was advised to use SpinRite by a friend. But I am using a lap top (Sony Vaio PCG-GRT100P) and I am unsure of how the process works. I know I have to boot from a CD with SpinRite - but then what? Will it work on the external drive? Someone told me to pop the drive into a tower and then to use SpinRite, but will that work considering there is no OS on the drive? What would happen after I boot from CD with my external in a tower? And how will I know if it's working or not?

I just want to be able to get this drive working long enough to salvage maybe 20 gigs worth of stuff. Which for the time being I can just put on the internal HD and then burn later. Mostly just pictures, sentimental stuff.

Does anyone have any advice for me?

THANK YOU!

4 replies

by hal 9000

It has it's own OS in the Boot CD. I would first however test the HDD with the Makers Utility to see if it's working properly if it isn't then no data recovery software on the face of the planet will do any good.

When you removed the drive how did you store it?

I'm betting that at this time it got a Static Discharge which damaged the Integrated Circuits on the Control Circuit Board and it's been in the process of dieing ever since. You can try buying a identical model drive and changing the circuit boards over.

If that works remember that Kodak recommends that you not leave photos on CD and I would suppose DVD Media for longer than 3 years as you start to have the pictures degrade. It's really much safer to keep them on a HDD that is never removed from its caddy as that is when most damage occurs.

If all else fails you can send the drive away to a Data Recovery House and get them to recover your data but this can be terribly expensive and if you mess with the drive you are likely to make it more expensive as they have to spend more time recovering the data.

Col

by vincefesta

how long should I leave Spinrite running? Or does that varry? Thank you for your help!

by hal 9000

On the size of the HDD involved. But you need to check that the Drive is actually working before you attempt to run anything on it or you'll just be waisting your time.

So remember to use the HDD Makers Testing Utility or Sea Tools before starting Spinrite.

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.