Discussion Locked

Firewall, Use Router or Buy External Box

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm a Junior network admin at my company of about 10 people. We have a windows 2000 domain network connected to the net via dsl. The netopia router we're using has a built-in "basic Firewall" but doesnt really seem to cover the needs of my company. We are a contractor for the Department of state and therefore have highly sensitive yet declassified information on our network. what would be our best bet for a firewall/network intrusion detection?

BTW - explaining the need to purchase new equipment to my boss is like teaching an 80 year old to bungee jump...they'd just rather not. needless to say, under $400 is my best bet.

BBTW. here is a copy of the "basic firewall" rules my router has...do you have any recommendations for other rules that may help? the only thing I need to get into the network with is my VPN using "MS Win2k routing and remote access"

--SRC----DST----PROT----SRCPORT--DSTPORT--ON--FWD
0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 TCP NC =2000 Yes No
0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0TCP NC =6000 Yes No
0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 ICMP =8 NC Yes No
0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 ICMP NC NC Yes Yes
0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 TCP NC >1023 Yes Yes
0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 UDP NC >1023 Yes Yes

3 replies

by tcallagh

Use FreeBSD as your firewall. Find an old PC, install FreeBSD and configure. To do IDS, install snort and mysql along with ACID.

by big-jim

I would suggest that you enlist the assistance of a professional security firm to discuss your options.

The problem is that you have not outlined the purpose for the security. If you are protecting sensitive data, you should determine your liability in the event of a breach. This will give you the information needed as to how much $$ you should spend to secure the data.

This will then give you the answers you are seeking. With a budget of $400, any script kiddie within a thousand milescan have your systems. If you are protecting data that belongs to the state, I would recommend that you contact the state, and ask them what their REQUIREMENTS for security are. This will give you and your boss the clear plan as to what to purchase. I would recommend an Enterprise class Firewall Product, either from CheckPoint, CISCO, Symantec. SonicWall is good, for the casual connections that don't need strong protection... (no flames please, I have the experience)

I would expect that after you receive the requirements from the State on how to protect their data, that your budget will become a much more reasonable figure. (I would budget ~$6k for a firewall)

Just my 2cents.

This discussion is closed to new replies.