Discussion Locked

Global Warming - The zealots are getting desperate

0 helpful
265 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Have you noticed the new onslaught of global warming warnings?

Did you see the picture of the Polar Bears "stranded" on that iceberg? (Stranded, by butt! They either swam out to it -- something Polar Bears naturally do because they're, well, because they're Polar Bears -- or the right half of that picture was deliberately cut off so it only gave such an appearance.) The picture and accompanying headline was, nonetheless, both leading and misleading.

France is advocating "taxing" the USA by imposing a "carbon tax" on imports to Europe. (Who still maintains this isn't to extort money from the USA?) Up yours, France, is what I'd say. You go ahead and raise my hand a Euro; I'll call that Euro and raise you another Dollar! (A little poker lingo, there.)

Did you see where some loony tunes actually advocated charging people (like me) who denied the notion of man-caused global warming with crimes against humanity in a "world court"? (Who says it's not about "control?)

Have you seen any of the reports showing how many global warming dissenters in the climate-science community were being silenced? (Of course not; the "main-stream media" is advancing the notion. Why would they "report" anything to the contrary?)

http://www.delawareonline.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20070201/NEWS/702010363/1006/NEWS

Have you noticed how when a global warming skeptic does present compelling arguments against the notion, he/she is summarily dismissed as being paid by big oil or some other nonsense? And have you noticed at how the global warming zealot's source of funding is never questioned and/or is never cause to dismiss THEIR arguments?

Did you see where Al Gore was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize for his efforts in global warming awareness? What does this have to do with world peace? But we all know that the Nobel Committee has been taken over by the world's extreme left-wing. Why else would they give such an award to the communist Nelson Mandella (and considering he supported his murderous wife at the time)? Or Jimmy Carter, the person who, almost single-handedly, allowed the middle-east to be taken over by radical terrorists? Or one of the biggest terrorist the world has ever see, Yasser Arafat? Or Kofi Annan, the corrupt and criminal mastermind of the oil-for-food scam, whose greedy and criminal behavior probably caused the death of thousands, and whose incompetence at the helm of the UN caused millions of more deaths in Africa. The last legitimate "peace" winner was probably the Dalai Lama!

Have you noticed how the reversal of the "extreme" weather that was predicted because of "global warming" is now either being ignored -- OR the new doom-and-gloom of the day is being called "climate change"? What happened to the terrible 2006 hurricane season they predicted because of the rising ocean temperatures? Did the temperatures drop, or were they wrong to begin with? Why is it that when these people are so blatantly WRONG, they aren't discounted as kooks?

Have you noticed at how many "new reports" or "new books" that advance the notion of man-caused global warming are being dumped onto the gullible public? And have you noticed how books that dispute the claim are not being reported on or touted? Of course, it's hard to "notice" something they aren't doing, but it doesn't mean the books aren't being published! But there are! For example, [i]"Unstoppable Global Warming Every 1500 Years, by physicist Fred Singer"[/i] and [i]"The Chilling Stars: A New Theory of Climate Change, by Danish physicist Henrik Svensmark and former BBC science writer Nigel Calder"[/i] Why aren't these new releases mentioned by the New York Times? (Do an Internet search for reviews on these books, or better yet, buy them. The latter book is due out in March. The former has been out for two months.)

Have you noticed (no, of course not -- for the same reasons!) the lack of reporting on the studies of sun cycles -- ones that suggest any global warming that might be happening is caused by increased and measurable sun activity?

Have you noticed how people who question and dissent aren't given equal time? (no, of course not -- for the same reasons!) See:http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/front/4487421.html

Did you hear about the meteorologist who doesn't know another single meteorologist who believes in the notion of man-caused global warming? (no, of course not -- for the same reasons!)

http://www.jamesspann.com/wordpress/?p=650

The zealots are getting desperate, folks. And they're getting loonier than ever!

265 replies

by orefa

...the zealots are sounding desperate based on the tone of your message. Except that it's not those you oppose who are sounding a bit loony. I've only read a few of your posts but I admit that I have found them entertaining.

I am not a climate expert. I do notice that the vast majority of climatologists subscribe to the notion of man-made warming, therefore we hear about it. A minority disagrees, so we don't hear them as much. It's normal. If their arguments were more sound than the opposite point of view I would expect them to become the dominant opinion in this field, but it's not the case.

In other parts you have other so-called scientists who scream politics as they vehemently dispute global warming. Of course, even though some of them really are scientists, most are not climate experts. Those who dispute something that is not even within their field of expertise just like to be heard. They hope to be taken seriously.

Finally, I have to wonder why the world experts in climate would cook the books. You have to come up with far-fetched conspiracy theories to explain why they would purposely try to curb the well-being and economic interests of every nation on the planet. On the other hand, the motivations of the naysayers are painfully clear: don't mess with my lifestyle, don't touch my SUV!

Having said all that, I still like to read different opinions about anything so of course keep dissenting away. I know you don't need my blessing.

by orefa

Your post contains plenty of groundless assumptions from the state of a polar bear to the motives of various countries to exaggerations about silenced scientists to other unsupported opinions. Pick on that first.

by deepsand

It is [i]your[/i] claim that those who represent the scientific community are but a vocal minority.

Prove it or shut up.

by tonythetiger

[i]I do notice that the vast majority of climatologists subscribe to the notion of man-made warming, therefore we hear about it.[/i]

You only "notice" what they want you to notice.

by deepsand

While that may or may not be true of yourself, why assume it to be so for everyone else?

by drowningnotwaving

Personally I believe the global climate change phenomenon and in particular the accelerated effect due to mankind and industry, is real, provable but with work amendable.

But I am not sure it matters any more, in terms of the scientific data either way ...

Because the definition of "truth" in democratic politics is simple - are there enough votes in it?

And, just quietly, I'd say the pendulum has swung ...

And, of course, for the pollies that argued against it and are now jumping on the bandwagon - their credibility battle is ever so slightly more difficult.

by deepsand

You either know little of the feeding habits of polar bears, or you chose to ignore such.

What a sophist you are.

by deepsand

You'd think that the Republicans would have been able to prevent such.

Or, are they too a party to the ruse?

by Member 25348569

This ones another "might be" I admit but it's potentially a little more immediate. I'd take your bet but I'd rather not win on the basis of a million, a hundred million people drowning in their own blood.

This has happened before. The 1918 pandemic was pretty much the same sort of flu. Check it out, The difference this time is that with modern communications, once human-human transmission was established the disease would be everywhere before there was a chance of containing it.

We have no choice on this one but to wait and see - and hope a little.

by maxwell edison

I agree, Neil, we should not wager with stakes (or steaks) that involve the lives of others. So regardless of which way it goes, it's a loosing bet. You, however, would lose both ways, because it's just another one of "those"! (How many of "those" have we seen over the past thirty five years?)

By the way, did you see where Newsweek Magazine, a few months ago, formally admitted they (and the "science" they wrote about) were wrong in those foolish "global cooling" predictions they made back in the 1970s? That admission didn't get much wide-spread news coverage, however, did it? I wonder why? (Goes to credibility perhaps?)

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15391426/site/newsweek/

I'd make another bet with you. In thirty years, all this "global warming" nonsense will be debunked and discredited. The only question will be, Will we be too old to eat steak? The hysteria this "scare" has produced is amazing; and it's all a bunch of crap. In thirty years the wager should be for omelets because of all the egg that will be on so many faces.

Neil, will you visit me in jail when I'm arrested and tried for speaking out?

http://epw.senate.gov/fact.cfm?party=rep&id=264568

Unless, of course, my dissent is severe enough for me to be put to death!

by jdclyde

and yes, we don't hear a retraction from them when they shift from one extreme to another.

Had to laugh a month ago when Dennis Miller held up the cover of NewsMax from the seventies showing global cooling as the big crisis.

I remember how they wanted to sprinkle coal dust on the ice caps to warm them up!

The dishonesty is amazing, as well as the blind stupidity many of the rabid followers are inflicted with.

Hmm, earth has gone up a degree, plus or minus a degree?

by deepsand

If not, have you read any of the earlier reports. If not, why not?

BTW, there have been [b]no[/b] such abrupt shifts in the outlook of those who study climate science over the long term, despite claims to the contrary. (Did you know that climate science began in the 19th century? And, that the prevailing opinion has been that which is now demonstrable fact?)

In any case, before you put your foot deeper into your mouth, at least read what it is that you're taking issue with. See

IPCC WGI Fourth Assessment Report

This is the full text. Note that it is a 21 page, 2.2 Meg PDF file.

http://www.ipcc.ch/SPM2feb07.pdf

by orefa

I guess you have not learned yet that patience is a learned skill. Ok then:

Groundless assertion #1:

"Stranded, by butt! They either swam out to it -- something Polar Bears naturally do because they're, well, because they're Polar Bears -- or the right half of that picture was deliberately cut off so it only gave such an appearance."

Prove that either one of these two groundless assumptions is correct.

Groundless assertion #2:

"The picture and accompanying headline was, nonetheless, both leading and misleading."

You did not even bother to make reference to the article in question. Explain why it is leading and misleading, don't just say so.

Groundless assertion #3:

"Who still maintains this isn't to extort money from the USA?"

Prove that their intentions are what you claim and not ecological or otherwise.

Groundless assertion #4:

"Did you see where some loony tunes actually advocated charging people (like me) who denied the notion of man-caused global warming with crimes against humanity in a "world court"?"

I didn't. Show that what you are talking about is actually what you claim it is.

Groundless assertion #5:

"Who says it's not about control?"

Show that it really is, don't assume.

...and so on and so on, through the rest of your post. This was just the start. You give opinions, not facts. Then you pick on the opinion of someone who responds to a post that you really wanted someone to respond to. But it's not just my opinion. Maybe you trust NASA (http://www.nasa.gov/worldbook/global_warming_worldbook.html) more than me: "A majority of climatologists have concluded that human activities are responsible for most of the warming."

by dr dij

that nasty gang of 46 nations and climate scientists who decided it's for real:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070204/ap_on_sc/france_climate_change;_ylt=Av.qOlmyLMEx5lGNEuOoGS8PLBIF;_ylu=X3oDMTA2Z2szazkxBHNlYwN0bQ--

I'm sure they're ganging up on the US and China, as they're jealous of our lifestyle.

The Chinese have the advantage, Max. Their press can simply downplay and deny it exists if that's what their Minstry of Truth decides.

But the Chinese appear to be scared into doing something unlike the US: they are planting trees, opening the largest solar farms, etc. tho they are starting off worse, with very few pollution controls, and horrible coal smog.

Sorry to break into this Max love-fest. I'm not going to call you names or tell you to get a clue. You've read lots of arguements from others. And yet you still fail to admit there's a problem.

See the latest Business Week. They suggest a solution.

It's no point saying that 30 years ago we thought something else. Science improves, computer simulations improve, satellites were launched, mud and ice cores gathered, more data overall. We also improved our understanding of the atmosphere, and the carbon cycle.

And also in the meantime 30 years and more, additional hundreds of billions of tons of CO2 and other gasses were emitted.

by karmashock

if you analyze the majority of this movement it's emotional. There's too much random hostility, hatred, bitterness, and fear. If you read all of these reports fully there are always qualifiers on the serious reports. That is "probably", "maybe", "we think", etc.

Thinking something is a problem is not a basis for taking this kind of action on this scale.

What's more kyoto and similar measures are widely regarded even by their supporters to be of little over all consequence to the projected problem should their estimates be correct.

Think objectively here... Judge a given solution with these known properties:
1: Solution will be extremely expensive.
2: Solution might not actually fix the problem or might do so little as to be insignificant.
3: Solution puts your assets/country's economy under the control of some other group that you'll have limited to no control over.
4: Problem that solution is designed to fix has not in fact manifested and might well never manifest ever.
5: If problem is real it might be impossible to stop or even significantly slow.

Judge the solution. Be objective. Think logically.

I think we need to find different solutions. The US previously has suggested two ideas that I like a lot better.

1: Modernize factories and power plants in poor countries where they didn't put carbon scrubbers on their generators. This might well include something to help clean up their cars as well. Go to Mexico City and you'll see what I'm talking about.

2: Build/develop programs to take carbon out of the air. I've heard of two different systems to do this... one uses algae vats and the other requires electricity. The issue with the algae vats is that they eat up a lot of area, use a lot of water, might not work as quickly or cleanly as you'd like... the problem with the other is that it uses electricity... BUT if you use nuclear, solar, wind, or hydro to get that electricity then it's still a major net drop in carbon. Calculations should be done to see what kind of a facility to cancel the total carbon emissions of a city like Los Angeles for example. I think this idea would ultimately be much cheaper and easier to deal with then kyoto.

What's more the dirty secret of kyoto is that it effectively is international socialism. That is rich countries that need to produce CO2 pay poor countries with dirty power plants for the right to keep producing CO2.

It's a shell game. Effectively at the end of hte day what you have is a rich country paying a poor country to upgrade it's power plants... but you're paying WAY WAY WAY too much. Just offer to upgrade those systems for free. I think there was an estimate that put the total price of such a program below a billion dollars. Which is NOTHING compared to what kyoto would cost.

Please... in all of this... stop. think. form your own opinion... on your own.

by absolutely

They are distinct varieties of mental activity. Although both occur in the brain, the title of your post is a fallacy.

"Thinking something is a problem is not a basis for taking this kind of action on this scale."

Which kind of action? What scale?

"What's more kyoto and similar measures are widely regarded even by their supporters to be of little over all consequence to the projected problem should their estimates be correct."

Really? If so, then "therefore, what?" Do you mean to suggest that the experts' opinion (that it will be difficult to make even a small change) implies that the proper course of action is to do nothing? If so, why do you think that these experts have not themselves recommended doing nothing, but do instead recommend doing something? Whatever your answer, do you have evidence to support your answer, or mere emotions?

A more direct contradiction from your post:

[i]"Think objectively here... Judge a given solution with these known properties:
1: Solution will be [b]extremely expensive[/b].
...
Judge the solution. Be objective. Think logically.

I think we need to find different solutions. The US previously has suggested two ideas that I like a lot better.

1: Modernize factories and power plants [b]in poor countries[/b] where they didn't put carbon scrubbers on their generators. This might well include something to help clean up their cars as well. Go to Mexico City and you'll see what I'm talking about."[/i]

[b]If[/b] there is no problem, [b]nobody[/b] needs to do anything to solve it. [b]If[/b], on the other hand, there [b]is[/b] a problem, treating it as somebody else's burden is irresponsible, as with any problem to which one contributes.

"Please... in all of this... stop. think. form your own opinion... on your own."

Thanks for the tip. When I [i]think[/i] about these questions, I'll consider (1) whether global warming is in progress (2) whether human activity is the cause and/or a significant contributor (3) what should I do about it for the purpose of discovering the truth, not mixing and matching those questions, and their answers, with the goal of supporting a pre-determined answer or set of answers.

by karmashock

"Which kind of action? What scale?"
Kyoto. Global disruption of the world economy with little to no regard for it's impact there to.
-------------------------------------------
"Really? If so, then "therefore, what?" Do you mean to suggest that the experts' opinion (that it will be difficult to make even a small change) implies that the proper course of action is to do nothing?"

My response was made completely upon this point when I asked you to judge the situation objectively.

I laid out conditions and asked you to evaluate the situation based upon those those conditions. If you think I omitted a point from that list then cite it and I may agree with you.

But simply refusing to participate in a very simple exercise neither refutes my point nor makes your own.
---------------------------------
"Whatever your answer, do you have evidence to support your answer, or mere emotions?"
Evidence of what in particular... Citable evidence could easily overwhelm this entire forum.

Please engage the objective list... if you think any element of the list is wrong or something should be added then let me know. We can both be rational about this.

by deepsand

Said assumptions are that:

1) Those who reject the notion of global warming's existence, or of man's role in such, are [i]rational[/i]; while,
2) Those who accept such are [i]irrational[/i].

In so doing you have set up a fallacy known as a Straw Man argument, one that evidences [i]your personal bias[/i] in this matter.

To therefore exhort others to "[i]Be objective. Think logically.[/i] is without merit, as you yourself have yet to do so.

by sn53

deepsand has my sympathy. Something must haave gone very wrong for him to have turned out the way he did.

by deepsand

[i]Ad hominem[/i] attacks are of no avail; they serve only to dissipate your efforts.

by jdclyde

Or was man-made global warming responsible for the ice age ending?

Is the sun going through an active time, which would raise the temp of everything? Did we do that too?

by maxwell edison

http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2006/10may_longrange.htm

[i]In what could be the simplest explanation for one component of global warming, a new study shows the Sun's radiation has increased by .05 percent per decade since the late 1970s..... The increase would only be significant to Earth's climate if it has been going on for a century or more, said study leader Richard Willson, a Columbia University researcher also affiliated with NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies..... The Sun's increasing output has only been monitored with precision since satellite technology allowed necessary observations. Willson is not sure if the trend extends further back in time, but other studies suggest it does..... "This trend is important because, if sustained over many decades, it could cause significant climate change," Willson said..... Solar activity has apparently been going upward for a century or more," Willson told SPACE.com today..... Scientists, industry leaders and environmentalists have argued for years whether humans have contributed to global warming, and to what extent. The average surface temperature around the globe has risen by about 1 degree Fahrenheit since 1880. Some scientists say the increase could be part of natural climate cycles. Others argue that greenhouse gases produced by automobiles and industry are largely to blame.[/i]

The whole article at:

http://www.space.com/scienceastronomy/sun_output_030320.html

http://www.prnewswire.com/cgi-bin/stories.pl?ACCT=104&STORY=/www/story/11-09-2006/0004471126&EDATE=

Sun Cycle 24 will peak in about 2011.

Sun Cycle 25, which will result in a COOLING effect, will peak in about 2022. And look at the chart (first link) showing the HIGH peak in the 1930s -- another WARM era.

These global warming whackos are losing the argument, jd, but they sure are persistent. The mere fact that they ignore these scientific and proven facts in their argument, and considering they refuse to factor them into the debate (much less even mention them), their credibility is about zero.

by deepsand

unless and until you get [b]all[/b] the facts, rather than just those which suit you, your credibility is zero. [b]READ[/b]

IPCC WGI Fourth Assessment Report

This is the full text. Note that it is a 21 page, 2.2 Meg PDF file.

http://www.ipcc.ch/SPM2feb07.pdf

by sn53

I am reluctant to waste my time on a UN-sponsored document. Immediately it places a bad taste in my mouth. That body is anti-west, anti-capitalism and pro-terror.

Or am I wrong? Was there some apolitical group not depending on public funding seriously involved with this?

by sleepin'dawg

1: The paper remarks that the there has been a warming trend beginning in 1750. I woulld be interested to know how this is being determined since , at best, meteorlogical data and global climate records have only been maintained since the latter part of the 19th century and even then the records were regional or national, not global in scope. Global records only commenced being maintained with the advent of global communications, starting somewhere in the early 20th century.

2: Geo-anthropological studies indicate we are at the end of an ice age, one that has endured for approximately 40,000 years, so a certain amount of global warming is to be anticipated. Are we on the threshold of a tropical phase. Nobody knows, yet, however, core drilling into the polar ice caps indicates these areas once supported tropical fauna so it may be assumed that dear Ol' Mother Earth has been down the global warming path before. These same core samples have even shown there have been periods when the atmosphere had even higher hydro-carbon content than it currently has.

3: Global population in 1750 was less than 1 billion but is now around 6 billion. With man producing approximately 20tons/capita/annum of hydro-carbons on average, it would seem the solution would be to curb and/or reduce global population. Trying to reduce the per capita production of hydro-carbons would appear to be difficult if not impossible unless there is a concurrent agreement to curb global population growth. Even if you were able to reduce per capita hydro-carbon production by 25% in the next 25 years, which would set the per capita levels at 15 tons/capita/annum, nothing will change and with the current level of population growth the global level of hydro-carbons will actually increase. The solution you really are seeking is a global pandemic which would reduce the global poulation by 25%.

4: Nobody has any idea of what level of atmospheric hydro-carbon content the earth can tolerate but as I said it has been higher than current levels.

5: Is man the cause of global warming??? Depending on how you look at it; both answers, yes and no, are correct. We are in a natural warming trend and the presence of man, and his growing population, is probably accellerating it but is not the only cause.

Global warming studies are what sells currently and scientists, like all of us, are out to make a buck. The picture of the polar bear??? If you have ever been down north and observed polar bears at first hand, you would find it not unusual for them to swim over stetches of open water exceeding twenty miles; so yes Max's statement of, "they're polar bears" could very well be accurate. Speaking as a professional in the imaging business it is equally possible the picture has been doctored. They say the camera never lies, to which I say, "Bullschit!!!" I've made a better than average living making the camera lie for well over 35 years and that was before PCs and Photoshop were ever in existence.

Say and believe what you want about "Global Warming" or "Climate Change" but as for me I demand a lot more concrete data than has been presented to date by either side of the argument.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sn53

Maxwell, this will never do as it fails to develop sufficient reason for a one-world socialist government.

by jdclyde

It is a vast right-wing conspiracy to raise the Earths temperature so we can corner the market on ice cube trays...... Oh yeah, we love to make elderly Democrats eat dog food too.

But this is a secret, so keep it to yourself..... ;\

by thechas

Max,

Looking at the quotes from the story below, it looks like even your conservative hero is admitting the human activity IS responsible for climate change.

Story Link:
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=aYeoMlUZyJY0&refer=home

Bush Administration Says Human Climate Role Now Clear (Update5)

By Jim Efstathiou Jr. and Tina Seeley

Feb. 2 (Bloomberg) -- The human role in climate change is no longer debatable, U.S. Energy Secretary Samuel Bodman said today, while he defended the president's policy of addressing the issue without mandatory greenhouse gas limits.

Bodman and other Bush administration officials were responding to a report from a United Nations panel that concluded it is more than 90 percent certain the Earth is warming because of carbon dioxide that is released by burning fossil fuels. The report, released today in Paris, predicted rising sea levels, increased storms and more droughts and floods.

``Human activity is contributing to changes in the Earth's climate,'' Bodman said at a press conference in Washington. ``That issue is no longer up for debate.''

President George W. Bush has rejected proposals for mandatory limits on emissions of greenhouse gases. Bush in 2001 went back on a campaign pledge to limit carbon dioxide emissions and withdrew the U.S. from the Kyoto Protocol, the international agreement that forms the basis for caps in Europe and elsewhere.

Democrats who took control of both houses of Congress last month, and some Republicans, are pushing for mandatory emissions rules in conjunction with a trading system that would allow flexibility in how industries comply.

Mandatory Caps

``Today I am again urging the president to show leadership and work with Congress to implement a mandatory, market-based cap and trade program to address this challenge,'' Senator Jeff Bingaman, chairman of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, said in a statement today. ``The consequences so clearly spelled out in this report, and many others, compel us to act now.''

Bingaman, a Democrat from New Mexico, and Senator Arlen Specter, a Republican from Pennsylvania, are co-sponsoring legislation to set mandatory limits on carbon.

Bodman said the administration still opposes such a move. ``The imposition of a carbon cap in this country may lead to the transfer of jobs and industries abroad,'' he said.

He declined to say whether the president would veto a carbon cap approved by Congress. ``That's a judgment the president needs to make.''

While Bush has acknowledged the need to address climate change and mentioned it in his annual State of the Union address on Jan. 23, the administration has drawn criticism for past action on the issue.

Cooney

This week Democrats in Congress accused the White House of withholding evidence they say will show how administration officials downplayed the dangers of global warming in research reports. The allegations focus on Philip Cooney, a former lobbyist for the American Petroleum Institute who became chief of staff of the White House Council on Environmental Quality.

Cooney is accused of editing reports to play up the uncertainty over the scientific basis for global warming. He resigned in July and joined Exxon Mobil Corp.

Today's report, from the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, finds more scientific certainty compared with a 2001 document from the panel, which said the probability of a link was in a range of 66 percent to 90 percent.

``The message is that it does make a difference what we do,'' Gerald Meehl, who contributed to the report, said in a conference call with reporters. ``The longer you wait, the worse the problem gets, and the longer you wait, the more you have to do to do something about it,'' said Meehl, a scientist at the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colorado.

Temperatures are likely to rise by 1.1 degrees to 6.4 degrees Celsius by the end of this century relative to the last, the report said. The probable range for warming in this century is 2 degrees to 4.5 degrees if the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere doubles from pre-industrial levels.

Uncertainty

``The uncertainties have been narrowed,'' said Stephen Johnson, the administrator of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, who appeared with Bodman in Washington today.

The U.S. produced 22 percent of the world's man-made carbon dioxide emissions in 2004, according to figures from the Energy Information Administration, part of the U.S. Energy Department. The International Energy Agency last year predicted China would overtake the U.S. as the biggest carbon emitter in 2009.

The world's 12 largest emitters of greenhouse gases should be called to a summit at the White House, Senator Barbara Boxer said today at the United Nations in New York. She also said she would bring the scientists from the UN panel to Washington to brief lawmakers in the next few weeks.

`Hand in Hand'

Bodman said the administration's energy policies, featured by Bush in his State of the Union speech last month, already ``go hand in hand with our efforts to address climate change.''

There is a short-term need for more research on hydrogen, solar power and ethanol production technologies, Bodman said. Longer term solutions will involve the creation of a new generation of nuclear power plants and coal-fired generators that don't release carbon into the atmosphere.

The administration's refusal to back mandatory caps has put it at odds with General Electric Co. and DuPont Co., which were among 10 companies that urged the government to set a cap that would cut emissions by as much as 30 percent within 15 years.

``We believe that voluntary measures, while constructive, are not sufficient to address an issue of this magnitude by themselves,'' Linda Fisher, vice president and chief sustainability officer for DuPont Co., the third-largest U.S. chemical producer, said in a statement.

To contact the reporters on this story: Jim Efstathiou Jr. in Washington at jefstathiou@bloomberg.net ; Tina Seeley in Washington at tseeley@bloomberg.net .
Last Updated: February 2, 2007 16:18 EST

Chas

by sn53

TheChas, President Bush is no conservative. The best I ever hoped for with him was that he might surround himself with people who were.

He got it right on tax cuts and the war. Off the top of my head I cannot think of any other place where I support his position. He is a big government guy, not a conservative.

by maxwell edison

First of all, please spare me the condescending comments. I've never called (or considered) GWB my "hero", nor have I ever called him a "conservative". For some warped reason, people (like you) obviously believe that if a person doesn't abhor President Bush, it automatically equates to hero-worship. It's no wonder reasonable dialogue is so elusive.

Second of all, if you're trying to make some kind of point suggesting that since GWB is taking a position on something, therefore I should as well, that's a silly thing to suggest. Moreover, it goes to show that all the other suggestions that I "blindly follow" him are dead-wrong.

I've said all along that politics has hijacked this issue; and just like the looming Social Security train wreck, politicians are almost forced to take certain positions and/or ignore problems just so they don't get massacred in the press. The left-wing has advanced the silly notion of a "global warming disaster" ONLY to advance their political agenda of gaining power, and their accomplices in the press are facilitating the effort.

By the way, since it's YOU who hate and distrust President Bush, how do you possibly justify using HIM as support for your argument? I thought you considered him a dishonest liar? Were you being disingenuous then, or are you being disingenuous now?

by thechas

Well Max,

As I recall, you have stated in this forum that you consider GWB will be judged by history as one of the 10 best Presidents.

You have also been pretty unabashed in your support of GWB and his misbegotten policies.

Based on how much you support him, it is not a stretch for anyone to conclude that you consider him to be some kind of hero.

I only posted the article as a sign of how far the political debate on global warming has changed over the 6 years the GWB has been President.

If anything, it is supporting evidence for one of the other posts where it was suggested that you get over it and accept that you have lost the battle.

Now, the reality might be that GWB is going to capitulate on every other political issue to preserve what little political capital he has left for the war in Iraq. Excuse me, the Bush jobs plan. So much for his taking strong positions on issues.

By the way, one can despise and distrust someone without hating them.

I do hope you can survive as the US swings to the political left again, and it becomes safe to be a liberal Republican.

Chas

by des949penn

That, In a nutshell, appears to be the strategy of Al Gore and the other would-be environmental czars, with a lot of help spoon-fed to our children, by their unionist allies in the National Education Association.

But having pointed this out, I'm perfectly willing to allow the issue to be seriously studied and addressed, but only by a well-chosen group of no more than a few hundred experts from the hard-science disciplines alone, in a Manhattan-Project styled environmrnt which will not require a huge expansion of the buraucracy.

Clearly, the only effective recognition and resolution of this issue must be driven by market forces, rather than working against them. There can be no serious progress until those whose principal motivation is the advancement of a collectivist agenda are told to get out of the way.

by sn53

Who benefits if a majority of the people believe we are in a crisis? I bet it would be the scientists and the politicians. The scientists get more money to come up with solutions. The politician gain more control.

by drowningnotwaving

I want my family, and their family, and their family to have a chance at the same kind of life I enjoy.

When the purposeful and criminal actions of companies and in some cases national governments are significantly contributing to this ability of my children NEVER being the case, then my collective agenda says we join forces and f'ck them up completely.

Example? Australian government saying "we refuse to ratify the Kyoto Agreement because of the detrimental economic outcome to our coal mining industry".

If that isn't "claiming the right not to incriminate myself", what is???

That's my collective agenda.

My market force is my vote and my mouth and my wallet and all those things and more. I'm going to tell as many people as I can about what I think needs to be done.

I've bought 50 copies of Tim Flannery's book and sent them all to my friends as Xmas presents.

Are we generating a ground swell? Just check the headlines and see if we're successful. The politicians think so, so that is the first step.

And I'm no longer interested in an academic discussion of the truth or frailties of the science.

In this part of the world a huge majority of environmental scientists, whose vested interests are NOT served by bucking the system or the companies that offer jobs and sponsorships, are now standing up and being counted.

That's enough for me.

And if that means that your taxes go to cleaning up the mess that we have all contributed to, as doers, consumers or maleable sheep, then f'ck you pay up.

by sn53

Gee CanI, it sure seems you are alive with religious fervor over this.

How is your fervor any different than the Islamofascists who would convert us to Islam by the edge of the sword? You see those who disagree with you as infidels and would convert us to environmental-whack-ism against our will.

by sn53

deepsand I was being serious. Something in your past has really screwed you up. It takes effort to be as mean, nasty, and contentious consistently as you have shown yourself to be.

You have my sympathy. Nobody should hurt that much.

by deepsand

The only thing "screwed up" here is the vocal presence of those who refuse to get [i]all[/i] the facts, prefering instead to insist that their beliefs are sufficient for a conclusion to be drawn.

Keep your pity; you need it more.

by sn53

Anything sponsored by the United Nations is suspect. It is not likely to be science nearly as much as a way to get more public funding and more governmental controls over every facet of our lives.

No thanks.

by jdclyde

more US public funds is what you meant. Us American dollars to push their Anti-American agendas. It clearly is time for us to re-analyze all funds going to this corrupt organization. If we only get the same voting rights as any other country, then we should not be giving one penny more than any other country.

by deepsand

Like maxwell, rather that deal with the facts, you dissemble; in this case, by attacking the character of an organization rather than by honest appraisal of the facts.

You are maxwell's favor epithet.

by Member 25348569

is the present US administration doing absolutely nothing. Considering that this is a sure-fire way for politicians to gain more control, at least according to you, are you suggesting that the Republicans are too honest (hah!) or to stupid (much more likely) to jump on the environment bandwagon.

You have a President who has done absolutely NOTHING to move US greenhouse gas emissions in a sensible direction. What's HIS excuse for doing nothing?

by sn53

You asked, "Then why
is the present US administration doing absolutely nothing."

It is the right thing to do. Up until now the Republicans got it right.

You continued, "Considering that this is a sure-fire way for politicians to gain more control, at least according to you, are you suggesting that the Republicans are too honest (hah!) or to stupid (much more likely) to jump on the environment bandwagon."

Actually they ARE jumping on the environmental bandwagon. That is one complaint that I have. Republicans have abandoned their principals. That is why they lost control of the Congress. If they fail to govern in accordance to conservative principals it will be a very long time before they regain control of the Congress. They need to grow a spine, especially in the Senate.

You said, "You have a President who has done absolutely NOTHING to move US greenhouse gas emissions in a sensible direction. What's HIS excuse for doing nothing?"

Why do anything? And what would sensible mean to you?

by sn53

Your comments clarified and improved upon my thoughts.

Thank you.

by sn53

deepsand, I do not need any help in recognizing that a snake will always be a snake. The United Nations is probably the most corrupt organization that has ever been devised by politicians. I will not trust any document that was written by them nor sponsored by them.

Your mileage may vary.

by sn53

I think the sensible course is to let the market decide. If people want to do green things for environmento-religious purposes I have no problem with them doing so. I object to government getting involved when it seems likely that the sole purpose of this "crisis" is to elevate the power of the state.

by sn53

Just for fun let's see how serious the left really is. Let's agree that carbon dioxide and cow farts (methane) might be a problem. I propose the answer is to go nuclear. Let's have a moratorium on anti-nuclear power plant lawsuits for the next hundred years, build nuclear power plants at the edge of every city and solve this problem once and for all.

Oh yeah. And kill all the cows.

Any takers?

by deepsand

Whoops; don't choke now. You did'nt see that coming, did you, what with your being so cock-sure that you had everything and everyone figured out.

Oh, well, it's back to the drawing board for you.

by sn53

You are one person. We need just a few more of the left-leaning anti-nuclear zealots to sign on, I think. Or maybe two.

Even the French are 80% nuclear.

by deepsand

"environmento-religious purposes"?

What the hell is that. You sure do like to make up big, impressive looking and sounding words that are devoid of meaning.

"sole purpose of this "crisis" is to elevate the power of the state. "

Yet more [expletive deleted].

If you want to sh*t in [i]your[/i] house, go right ahead; [i]but[/i] you've [b]no right[/b] to sh*t in mine or anyone else's.

by sn53

I said,"environmento-religious purposes"

deepsand said, "What the hell is that. You sure do like to make up big, impressive looking and sounding words that are devoid of meaning."

Environmentalism as religion. I see a lot of it. Add a little politics and it begins to rival Islamofascism as a danger to the freedoms and liberties of Americans first and all in the west second.

I said, "sole purpose of this "crisis" is to elevate the power of the state. "

deepsand said, "Yet more [expletive deleted]. If you want to sh*t in your house, go right ahead; but you've no right to sh*t in mine or anyone else's."

I am sorry if I have offended your religion.

by deepsand

That's bullsh*t; you know it, I know, the whole world knows it.

In case it escaped you, there are [i]plenty[/i] of right-wingers who oppose nuclear energy.

by sn53

Uh-huh.

Sure. Perhaps a Republican in name only or two. They are probably the same few Republicans who oppose drilling for oil in ANWR.

by deepsand

Clearly you hold the citizenry in contempt and to be of little import, with the exception, of course, of those who happen to agree with you.

Has your arrogance no bounds?

by deepsand

I'll not dignify your pathetic attempt at explaining your nonsense by rebutting it.

I simply summarily reject it.

Done; over with.

by des949penn

sn53 didn't want to bother with a reply, so I will.

(Quote) If you want to sh*t in your house, go right ahead; but you've no right to sh*t in mine or anyone else's.

Sandy seems to think he represents a group of people (the usual assemblage of teenyboppers, technophobes, touchy-feelies and the front row at Wrestlemania) whose desire to indulge their pet cause as a collective right outweighs the individual right to life, liberty and property of those who don't agree with the pseudo-liberal (only liberal on the issues they agree with) agenda of the global-warming lynch mob.

Franklin said it best about 250 years ago -- lie down with dogs and you'll get up with fleas.

by deepsand

For someone who knows nothing of me, you certainly are a presumptive b*stard.

I'll not even dignify your bullsh*t with a rebuttal.

by tonythetiger

If the rabid radicals start a war over this, the nuclear winter that follows will take care of any possibility of the planet warming up.

by drowningnotwaving

Many longer-term environmentalists see nuclear power as a strong component of the solution.

And many contributors here have rightfully pointed out the numbers of people that die mining or producing coal power during each year around the world.

Nuclear must be a strong long-term component of the overall solution.

by sn53

Great. So far we have two for nuclear power. Shall we gets some laws passed to prevent your brethren from suing to keep nuclear power plants from being built?

by jdclyde

like happens to all of the scientists that show other conclusions than in favor of man-made global warming? All are working for "big oil" or some other form of attack to discredit them without having to discuss their conclusions.

A lot of that going around it seems. (not you personally)