Global Warming - The zealots are getting desperate
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by karmashock
Bro, listen if you're not open to debate then that's cool... you wouldn't be the first... but then don't waste my time keeping up the pretension of it. I laid out my thinking on the subject fairly clearly. I offered up a hypothetical situation and while you did mention it you didn't really justify any of your criticism of it.
You're blowing through this too quickly and ironically wasting time by doing so.
Either make the effort to fully engage or don't bother.
Love and peace, Karmashock.
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
True. And, more to the point, that which is in large, bold print. Still, that does'nt mean that it's necessarily the wrong choice.
As for the drink, do you ever travel to OSU away football games? If so, come to the PSU one, and I'll treat you to both the 'Skeller and the Phyrst.
by spacewarp
Well, let's see now.
I'm a firm believer that if a company goes and dumps chemicals into the groundwater or spews massive clouds of stuff into the air that they should be responsible for cleaning it up. It's not environmentalism to say that, it's common courtesy.
What I see is a group of people with an agenda and control of large amounts of money being very directly involved in forcing a political movement on people to get the control they want. Follow the money.
I see a group of left-wing, commie, greenie environmentalists pushing an agenda that is anti-growth, anti-people, anti-free-will. For the sole purpose of controlling others. Ask any of them how we can continue to grow if we can't burn fossil fuels and you'll get hundreds of different answers, but basically, it boils down to "we don't want you to." Alternatives to fossil fuels are abundant. Nuclear is one of the cleanest (look at the track record of accidents), safest (again look at the track record of deaths) and environmentally sound methods of producing electricity. When California was experiencing brownouts, it wasn't Enron or any other company that was the problem. It was simply that the greenies, in their effort to be true to their cause decided that Californians couldn't buy nuclear energy. They even have a nuclear plant in CA, but the energy there can't be sold to CA.
A plan for hydroelectric generation from ocean currents was scrapped because someone was afraid that some shrimp, which breed in multiple locations, but one of the more than 50 locations happened to be in the path of the new hydro-plant, couldn't be disturbed.
A plan for solar collection was scrapped. Politicians didn't want it in their back yards. The Democrats who happened to live there. Same with wind turbines. That and the birds that the turbines could kill.
So, tell me, which plan of energy creation would you support that would allow us to be both environmentally friendly and grow?
And as far as your right to take my freedom, it stop at my door.
I think we've got companies that are poor stewards of the land. And they suffer economically eventually. But, that doesn't mean we need to cripple our world production just to eliminate something that may or may not be a natural cycle of the earth and the sun.
Paul
by karmashock
but not about journalists. The problem with journalists is that people respect them too much, not that they have too many freedoms. Journalists everywhere need a good firm wedgie... they're often wrong but can't be expected to be right all the time either.
So people just need to stop thinking "if it's in the paper it must be true!" a common line in the fucking bullwinkle cartoon that sadly is still true today. I loved how those Boston Mooninite campaigners dealt with the press when they came out of court. That's exactly how the press should be dealt with until they get over themselves. Their pretension has gotten entirely out of control... someone needs to put a giant needle into their egos and let the hot air out.
by tonythetiger
by karmashock
The problem is that people tend to just believe the media. This is dangerous as we've seen with the AP of late which has come to use fairly random people in the middle east to be their sources for reports... this has led to fake stories, fake photos, and a decline in the credibility of the AP.
Which is valid. The most precious thing the media has is our trust. Saying "there ought to be a law!" doesn't fix anything. You'd just create a government censorship commite that would be just as prone to bias and error as the media would be. Who after all watches the watchers? And worse still you'd be giving the media credibility it doesn't deserve because you'd be assuming that the government would make sure everything was accurate.
At best the government would really do anything and the net result would be that more idiots blindly trust the media. At worst the government would crush american media like a police state.
No, the solution is to stop respecting the media. Stop trusting them... That doesn't mean don't listen to them at all, but do so with a more skeptical ear. Know that they are just people... JUST PEOPLE. Walk down the street and talk to random people... at their core the media is merely a collection of people with perhaps some education that many lack. But they are just as prone to bias, distortion, and in some cases bald faced lying.
Getting back to the whole global warming thing, note how anyone that speaks out about global warming is immediately attacked? Their funding cut, their jobs lost/threatened, their credibility assassinated before anyone has even read their argument or research.
IN that kind of environment you can't have science. And upon those ground principle I stand for what it's worth with the skeptics... because they're being attacked in a manner DISGRACEFUL to science. Science is not about calling people crazy before reading their research. It's about dispassionately going over it and finding specific flaws in it if you can. Al Gore and company are a disgrace... they are political creatures. Not scientists and certainly not saviors. All they've accomplished is to turn science into a Michael Moore circus.
by des949penn
any more than you can legislate morality, or security, or equality.
Your post contains all sorts of rants against a less-than-perfect (by YOUR standards) world, which you seem to believe could be corrected by the imposition of a few more layers of politically-correct bureaucratic influence and a new layer of taxation (imposed on an international basis for the first time, but only in those nations civilized (by YOUR standards) eonugh to be fooled into participating.
The advance of civilization rests upon the continued development of an economic system which provides enough of the necessities and, hopefully, a few of the finer things (the definition of which covers a great deal of latitude) to inspire men and women to get up and go to work every business day.
That process has to be driven by individual choices in the free market of both econonmic goods and human opinion.
Interference with this process, whether in the name of religious doctrines, social predjudices, some imagined "common good" defined by the dreamers, or just raw state power invariably has the effect of diminishing the system's ability to produce goods and services (and thereby encourage greater education, which allows marginal issues such as global climate change to be brought to the attention of the public), and it occasionally spills a goodly quantity of innocent blood in the process.
Facism and socialism are not opposites; they are merely different strains of the same corrupt process. When better means of addressing climate-change threats are developed, it will be through the use of free enterprise, rather than working against it.
I can absolutely legislate those things!!! It's my right as a voter to participate in those things!!
Does that mean that by my legislation i guarantee that everyone will act in a moral, secure or equal-rights fashion? of course not.
But should those people who don't act to, or within, the law know that they'll face time in the cell with Bubba, pay a huge fine or combinations thereof? Sh't yes.
Of course I can participate in making those laws. It would be foolish to suggest otherwise.
Indeed I'd argue it is directly my responsibility. To see a criminal act (and deliberately polluting my world is in that bracket), and NOT proactively act to stop it and cease it's repeat in the future, is simply criminal in itself.
Are you suggesting a totally free market that is totally self-regulating?
by deepsand
Actually, it rest upon the continued advancements of [i]Science & Technology[/i].
The problem with the issue at hand is that far too many actively seek to a avoid the problem because they do not wish to bear the perceived economic costs of remediation. In so doing, they exhibit extreme myopia, failing to understand that the long term cost of doing nothing now will far exceed their perceived cost of prompt action.
by tonythetiger
We tied a record for the most consecutive below-zero days in over a hundred years, and after tonight will be the most since recordkeeping began.
The icecaps aren't melting... they're moving... into my yard :)
by jenueheightz
by sn53
mhb said, "The fact that can't be disputed is that approximately 85% of the world's pollution has occurred in the last 50 years."
What does this mean? Are you aware that 65% of all statistics used in arguments are made up on the spot?
What is pollution? How much of it is natural versus man-made? How much of it is relevant?
mhb said,"Changing course at this point demand a world-wide effort in order to make a difference."
I do not want to change course? How is it in my interest to do so? Why would I want to? Why would you?
mhb said, "The world's oceans, rivers, and streams that used to be full of life are dying from being used like a garbage dump. The world's forests are being clear cut and not replaced."
Not where I am. Probably not where you are either. However, if you are unfortunate enough to live in a socialist nation of the kind that Hillary wants for this nation, or a former socialist nation then you really do have it bad. They are counted as the ten worst polluted places on the planet. Where are the cleanest places? Usually in free-market, capitalist nations.
mhb said, "if we don't change what we're doing soon, we're all going to die anyway."
Newsflash. No one gets out alive.
by deepsand
It's ever so easy to claim that problems don't exist; facing up to them, finding a solution and implementing such are hard work.
To take the easy way out, by denying that there may be a problem, is, in fact, the selfish choice.
by deepsand
It's ever so easy to claim that problems don't exist; facing up to them, finding a solution and implementing such are hard work.
To take the easy way out, by denying that there may be a problem, is, in fact, the selfish choice.
{Sorry was at the beach getting a melanoma pump-up yesterday ...}
The challenge with the answers is that we're literally worlds apart, physically. So what I say has little real bearing on your world. But for the exercise in understanding where I come from I will happily answer.
I agree with much that you say. I too see a lot of negativity where in fact this should be a huge opportunity. The business opportunities are boundless. Little entrepreneurs starting up recycling businesses in my city are going flat-out! It's great.
But added to that is the inevitable "let's stop the machinery of humanity" and get back to tree-hugging.
At the same time there is money being spent by companies (and therefore individuals) telling me why pollution is actually a good thing, and the fact that my harbour is unfishable and in some parts unswimmable is good in the overall, relentless drive forward.
So there are freaks on both sides.
I fully concur - our future must embrace all available technologies. Given improvements in technology nuclear is very much a part of that answer.
In our part of the world it is not economically viable. Someone in an earlier post said the cost of the machinery was in the order of $150m (or close to that) but the legal fees in the USA blew it out to billions.
I don't know where they got their figures from, because the straight building costs of reactors from French and US companies that are being feted by our federal government are in the order of $1.5billion build and (I can't recall what) to run per year. At those costs it only becomes economically competitive if we add the true costs of the other sources including the cots of the pollution and environmental damage.
But in our part of the world, for obvious reasons, the answer is the sun. We have the highest proportion of desert than any other continent on the planet. And, of course, it would be in "someone's" back yard. Fact is their house could be a thousand miles away!!
So the huge solar plants that focus the heat into super-heating water to run generator-turbines is imminently practical.
As is the simplistic process of forcing every new home built to install solar panels. If you do it at the time of building, the cost is extremely economically viable and will make the home-owner money within four years both in terms of reduced electricity bills and in terms of returning power to the grid and being paid for it.
It's a building regulation that is so common-sensical and has positive economic benefits for all concerned.
{A ridiculous and (to many insiders and outsiders) unbelievable example in our country is that up until 5 years ago it was ILLEGAL to have a water tank to collect rain-water in the state/capital cities. This is over 80% of our entire population! The reason was to protect the government-monopoly water commissions. Now, of course wee face the worst drought in history and finally sense has come through.}
[i]But, that doesn't mean we need to cripple our world production just to eliminate something that may or may not be a natural cycle of the earth and the sun.[/i]
I agree. I don't suggest that companies be forced to shut, per se. But I do suggest that the true and full costs of their actions need to be recognised by them. That includes, for example, a carbon-trading scheme.
It would have the domino-effect that whilst some companies of themselves are not atcually polluters, they do consume power from carbon producers whose prices will rise to reduce their emissions (perhaps in the short term anyway).
Can this be long-term economically financially beneficial? Yes and there is a direct correlation. In Australia and New Zealand this is analogous to completely removing government subsidies for farming (well almost completely), about 20 years ago. Yes, some farms and farmers fell by the wayside. But the end result is one of the highest quality and most competitive agricultural industries on the planet.
So I do see that some companies will not be able to afford the costs of updating (in whatever form that means to them in their industry). But others will fill the breach. And the costs of updating in itself is an economic bonanza for the companies that are quick and smart enough to present products and services to fill the void.
(I accept that you do not think there is compelling evidence to take these actions, but I do, so perhaps agreeing to disagree on the premise may be necessary).
Given that difference in premise, I accept your rights in your home. I expect that you will pay for those choices that you make, and if the impact of those choices is deemed to be negative then there is a price to pay for reparations. EG like I said - have an air-conditioner in every room. But expect to pay HEAPS for your electricity bill. And expect an inverse price relationship - pay MORE per unit, the MORE you use. Because that recognises the actions of people who are reducing their usage. But the freedom and choice remains yours.
-0-0
I agree there is a dangerous element "on the left" that just wants complete control of you and me, our thoughts, actions and our money.
I'd also point out that there is an equally dangerous element "on the right" that wants (what they dictate as) free market conditions at the complete expense of the rights of any individual person, family or community.
Both must be rigorously guarded against.
I'd further point out that, despite our best efforts, the fact is that most western countries are run by the public service, and not by politicians or governments.
We, or our representatives, can scream blue murder for reduced government and reduced intervention. I'm still waiting for the first public servant to put their hand up and say "yes please sack me".
But that of course is an emotional aside.
......then you must be the circumcised foreskin.
At least I serve a purpose and get to have some fun!
by maecuff
by deepsand
The mere fact that you've "numbered" something makes it neither factual nor correct, let alone a complete logical argument.
The heart of your post is that you [i]believe[/i] those who see merit in the conclusion that global warming is both realized and exacerbated by man's activities is irrational.
That remains your's to prove.
by deepsand
by planemech
Dude, record high Temps?
So what? This same year we've had record cold temps too. Big deal. Are you going to flip flop and say we are now entering a new ice age?
Record temps only apply to local temps since man has recorded them, that's all. A record cold snap in NY City doesn't mean a thing, nor does a record heat wave in Juneau in July. They are just local weather patterns.
You can't seriously or honestly for that matter point to one or the other and claim that one day records are indicative of the temp for the entire planet moving one way or the other permanently. Of course algore can, but he?s a dishonest liberal Socialist religious nut job, just hucking and jiving his brand of fear mongering to the plebs.
by deepsand
by tonythetiger
except that it's cold here, and since I changed all my incandescent lights to florescent ones, I don't have all of that "waste heat" to help with my gas bill :)
[i]And, why ignore the record Highs?[/i]
Ignore them? I'd [/b]welcome[/b] them right now! Besides, at least 90% of the record highs in my area were set before I was born (1957 FYI), so I don't have too much experience there.
by dawgit
I've got you beat. :^0
And on that note: wasn't there record 'Blizzards' in the 1800's? And Buffalo's roaming around there before that? But, I think there has been recorded that, oh, 15,000 years ago, there were Lions in the Savana that is now 'North' America.
Point is the Earth is Changing, wow. The Earth has always been 'Changing'.!.
by planemech
Your only ammunition for an argument, is that vast majority of climatologists subscribe to the notion of man-made warming.
Do you have an actual head count on scientists or Climatologists that subscribe, or are you just aping what you heard elsewhere? The Apostle al gore says it, and the sheepeople repeat it as the gospel truth. That would be the first clue that you?re being abducted and brainwashed by a religious cult?s ideology and not following real science.
Speaking of apes, and accepting the learned opinion of the majority without question; well once, the 'vast majority' of the scientific community subscribed to Piltdown Man being the missing link, in support of Darwin?s evolution religion. To that end the stuffed shirts in charge, of publishing science papers and approving research grants, closed the book on all debate, on their proof. They could do this, because they had a lock on the numbers of those who liked getting published and paid to do the research they way they were told to, thus these scientists and researchers were held hostage to the system in place. Under such heavy handed conditions ?scientific consensus? was easily reached, without anyone once ever taking a so much as a slide long look at the object of their ?proof?.
What makes you think Liberals don?t play climatologists the same way they play biologists in order to support the religious dogma?
http://www.geocities.com/zacherle_hoag/tball Be Informed.
Read it and learn something, useful; think for your self, don't let algore and Branson do it for you.
by planemech
Interview With Dr. Timothy Ball- The Myth of Global Warming?
Dr. Timothy Ball Interview Questions
Introduction: Dr. Timothy Ball has the honor of being the first Canadian with a PhD in Climatology. Dr. Ball has been a Professor of Climatology at the University of Winnipeg for 28 years, and has appeared on such radio shows as the Lowell Green Show and Dr. Stanley Monteith?s Radio Liberty.
Q: When did you enter yourself into the Global Warming debate?
A; I have been involved in climate change issues all my professional career. However, when I started the scientific consensus and concern was global cooling. Some of the same people who were saying this was going to be the end of the world are now saying global warming is the end (Stephen Schneider for example.) The difference is the warming is attributed to human addition of CO2 to the atmosphere. This converted the issue to more political than scientific and there has been little rational discussion since.
Q: What is your alternative explanation to Global Warming?
A; There is no doubt warming has occurred since approximately 1680 the nadir of the Little Ice Age. However warming has also generally occurred since the major ice sheets started to melt about 18,000 years ago. In between there have been periods of cooling, the most recent from 1940 to 1980, hence the concern about cooling at that time. The mistake was in assuming the trend would continue. The fact is the climate changes all the time so you can pick any period you want to argue it was cooling or warming. The critical issue is what is causing the change and that is where it becomes very complicated. Weather outside your window is the total result of everything from cosmic radiation in deep space to geothermal heat from the bottom of the ocean and everything in between. However, as every textbook tells us the sun is the major source of energy that drives the earth's atmospheric system so downplay its effect is foolish. Arguments about the level of its contributions to climate change are derived from computer models but they don't work and that is a major source of the problems. For example, the Milankovitch Effect that measures the sum total of changes in Sun/Earth relationships including orbit tilt, and precession of the equinox are left out of the models.
Q: Who are the major players promoting the theory of Global Warming today, and what motivates these people to promote this theory?
A; As lawyers advise it is unwise to attribute motive. However, the problem is complicate by the political nature of the debate and the emotional issues introduced. We all care about the environment and our children and their future so when those are invoked it puts those who dare question in the awkward position of appearing to not care. There is also the use of fear so eloquently set out in Crichton's book State of Fear. Creating hysteria tends to preclude calm rational discussion of the issues that might lead to understanding and wise decisions. Ask yourself what the proposed solution would have been when global cooling was the threat, or as appears to be happening if the earth was to cool again.
Q: What are the Kyoto protocols and how will it affect the common citizen?
A; Kyoto was a political solution to a non-existent science problem. It was actually a transfer of wealth from the developed to the underdeveloped nations. Even if fully implemented with all nations participating to achieve the original reductions of CO2 no scientist would have been able to measure the difference in the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere. The hypocrisy of the entire exercise was and is evident in the carbon credits. This allows continue production of CO2 by buying credits from other nations. It does absolutely nothing to reduce CO2 going into the atmosphere yet that is the supposed objective. In fact Kyoto is dead and is rapidly being replaced by the ASEAN plan which is a reasonable less damaging to economies proposal that includes major players like India and China, although still mistakenly assumes CO2 is the problem. Reducing dependence on fossil fuels has logic because diversification and self sufficiency (especially for the US) has logic.
Q: What is your opinion on the idea of aGlobal Warming tax?
A; Ridiculous. Almost every country in the world (remember most didn't sign Kyoto were exempted or didn't plan to implement) said they would not do anything to harm economies, limit development or cost jobs.
Q: Why is it in the scientific community if you question the idea of Global Warming you are called names such as a ?nut? or a ?Global Warming denier?? Why do they not attack the theories rather than the person who is skeptical of the idea of Global Warming?
A; Good question; notice the holocaust implications of the word denier. I don't like the word skeptic in this context because scientists are required to question and challenge.
This type of attack is called Ad Hominem Latin for to the person and is usually used when you are losing the intellectual and evidential side of a debate. It is unfortunate, annoying and sometimes defamatory but an unfortunate part of human discourse.
Q: What is the main weakness in the reasoning of Global Warming promoters?
A; That all predictions of future warming are based on computer models that don't work. They can't forecast one year from now so how would they be able to forecast 100 years from now? In addition, all forecasts made by the models to date have been wrong. The other major weakness the assumption that an increase in CO2 from human activity will result in warming. The evidence shows that CO2 does not correlate with temperature change. Even more damaging is that the 420,000 year ice core record shows the complete opposite with temperature changing before CO2 not as hypothesized. The models all assume a doubling of CO2 will occur. They are all programmed to have temperature increase if CO2 increases and they are unable to include feedback mechanisms. For example, an increase in temperature will result in an increase in evaporation that will cause an increase in cloud that will block the sun and cause cooling.
Q: What are the main reasons scientists like yourself are questioning the idea of Global Warming?
A; It is our job. The science as presented is so politicized that presenting all the evidence and putting it in the proper context is essential.
Q: What is causing climate change?
A; The same things that have always cause climate change and as identified above. Also as I mentioned most of them are not included in the computer models. There are long term variabilities such as change since the earth/sun relationship, changes in the constituency of the atmosphere including particulates (dust), which are not handled in the models, changes in the oceans and so on. One issue ignored is geothermal heat, that is heat added, particularly to the oceans, by volcanic activity. Notice they no longer talk about global warming but climate change. This allows them to avoid the problem that human addition of CO2 continues to increase while global temperature declines (since 1998) and claim any change, temperatures up or down, precipitation up or down and so on, are due to human activity. Most people are educated to believe that change is gradual over long periods. In fact change is significant in space and time - significant climate change is the norm. Just consider that over half of North America was covered with an ice sheet larger than the current Antarctic ice sheet just 22,000 years ago.
Q: Why could humans not contribute a great deal to climate change?
A; The amount of our contributions relative to the global scale are miniscule. Consider CO2 where estimates of atmospheric CO2 range from 750 Gt (gigatons) to 820 GT or an error of estimate of 70 GT. We add 6 Gt to the atmosphere but remove 3 GT for a net contribution of 3 GT, in other words our contribution is about 4% of the error of the estimate. More important, every year when they calculate the carbon cycle there is at least 7 GT missing, hence it is known as the missing sink.
Reader Submitted Questions:
Robb Revere Asks: I wanna hear this dude debunk al gores new movie.
A; Gore's movie is pure propaganda someone said to me it is the Da Vinci code of climate change. If you can arrange it I would like an hour on Larry King alone to go through each part of Gore's movie and show the errors and distortion. Of course, it won't happen.
AdamOmega Asks: I?d like to know what he feels are the most relevant arguing points when trying to explain to someone that global warming doesn't exist... what are the smoking guns, or the "building 7" so to speak, of the G.W. hoax?
A; I assume AdamOmega has access to the answers above. Notice that the NASA report says we are at the warmest in 400 years - nobody has disputed that - a safe political and scientific position that keeps the heat on so to speak but is purely a function of your starting point. I have much greater conflict with the claim that human input is the only explanation for some of the recent warming. This statement is bad solely on the input and output of the computer models and I have touched on their limitations.
Whitehead Asks: Is he aware of HAARP. And if so could it be plausible to simulate the type of effects they describe with GW or could they in fact produce a global warming cascade themselves using the technology.
A; Yes I am aware of HAARP and think we need a great deal more information from such high altitude projects before we can even begin to make definitive statements about causes of climate change. I think the magnetic field and the interaction with the solar wind (corpuscular radiation) are significant aspects of climate change but virtually ignored and almost unknown to the public.
Dr. No Asks: Tim Ball, you?re a Global Warming Skeptic.
Does that mean that the global climate is NOT changing rapidly??
Does that mean that we don't need to invest in floating rubber devices?
is the weather measurements plain disinfo?
A; The climate is changing rapidly, always has and always will.
Yes, unless you live on a coast where isostatic adjustment is occurring such as the Gulf coast of the southern US which is sinking as it adjusts to melting of the massive ice sheet I mentioned earlier. Incidentally sea level has risen 500 feet (150 m) in the last approximately 8000 years but that was because the ice sheets of the ice age formed on land. The current ice sheet, Greenland and Antarctica are largely already below sea level. Also, the current average temperature of Antarctica is approximately -20?C so how much warming would have to occur before there was any significant melting to affect sea level?
Derek Asks: Are the ice sheets in the Arctic and Antarctic growing or shrinking?
A; The Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets are increasing in volume There is a slight increase in temperature in parts of the Greenland coast and on the Antarctic Peninsula, that small tongue of land that stretches up to South America. Temperatures at the South Pole have decreased since records began in 1958. The arctic ice is sea ice that covers approximately 16 million square kilometers every winter but about 10 million square kilometers melts every summer. So when they say an area the size of Texas melted more this year than last it is a fraction of the total melt of 10 million sq. km.
Derek Asks: How much have global temperatures varied throughout history?
A; Most scientists avoid this question. If you look you will find a wide range of 'guesses'. Generally the range you will find is form about 11?C warmer than present to 4?C cooler. Right now we are in an interglacial (a warmer period). This includes even estimates of the current global average temperature. Right now we use a global average of about 15?C but we can't even agree on the amount of warming due to the greenhouse effect. Some estimate (computer models) the earth is 33?C warmer because of it others put the figure up to 37?C warmer. There is considerable debate as you can imagine particularly because the degree of accuracy decreases as you move back in time. Even with the instrumental record there is difference of opinion of at least 0.5?C. Jones' claim of 0.6?C in the last 130 years is within the error factor. When you get into estimates based on tree rings, ice cores, sediments, foraminifera etc the error factor increases significantly. A ?2?C accuracy range over the entire course of Earth's history is questionable.
Derek Asks: Is there any correlation between global temperatures and fluctuations in the Sun?
A; Yes, there are very extensive studies showing correlation between solar variations and temperature. However, you have to understand there are three major changes in solar activity that contribute to temperature variation. These include changes in the sun/earth relationships mentioned above, changes in the corpuscular energy (solar wind) from the sun and the one most know about changes in electromagnetic (heat and light). Although there are very high correlations in variations in each of these they are generally set aside, especially by modelers, because the mechanisms are not clearly understood. This is reasonable scientifically because you cannot assume correlation means causation.
Bvegh Asks: Why are the artic waters six feet lower than the rest of the ocean? Where'd the water go and was it fresh water or salt water?
A; I am not quite sure what you mean by this although a recent study confirms the arctic levels decreasing contradicting predictions from other studies and theories. First of all the oceans are not level. The Atlantic is at a different level than the Pacific on each end of the Panama Canal. Sea level varies because of temperature differences which create density differences and gravitational pull due to variations in the earths crust and underlying Mantle. It is also difficult to determine what is happening at a coastal location as I mentioned earlier because there are two movements occurring both of which appear to make sea level change. One already referenced is isosasy. This is the fact the continents are floating and rise up and down in a process called isostatic adjustment. I mentioned the Gulf Coast, but Hudson Bay is getting shallower as the land rises up with isostatic adjustment following removal of the ice sheet. The other change is actual changes in sea level called eustatic changes which can be due to several factors as well.
Lucas Asks: We are told Ozone levels have also returned to their same levels that they were before the influx of chemicals that destroyed them. Is this false?
A; No. That is what the measurements show. They claim this is due to the Montreal Protocol but this is rubbish. They told us it would take 100 years to correct. The plain fact is there was never any evidence of CFCs affecting the ozone layer. However, as with CO2 the politics overrides calm rational scientific debate and if that fails the personal attacks begin and if that fails they invoke the Precautionary Principle, "Shouldn't we act anyway?" Yes, if you want to waste money ignore other real issues an scare people.
How quickly does ozone replace itself if left alone (like if it is no longer being hit by aerosol chemicals)
A; The major mistake in the original scare over ozone holes was to assume the sun's energy is constant. Ozone is create in a process called disassociation when ultraviolet radiation strikes free oxygen (O2) breaking them briefly into single oxygen molecules (O) that quickly merge in threes to create ozone (O3). Obviously if you assume the sun is constant then measure variations in ozone you are forced to assume it was caused by something from below. Ultraviolet radiation varies by up to 200% and the last IPCC report said solar variation was not a significant factor in temperature change but important in ozone variation. Scientists put CFCs in a chamber in a lab with ozone and assumed because the chlorine part of the CFC was destroying ozone this would happen in the ozone layer. Of course what they didn't tell you was that the ozone was varying to different degrees at different levels in the ozone layer which extends over several kilometers. There is a self correcting mechanism because as the ultraviolet penetrates further into the atmosphere it contacts more O2 and therefore more O is produced and more O3.
What would cause a big hole in the Ozone over the poles where there shouldn't be any chemical release?
A; First of all there never was a hole in the ozone but the term like the greenhouse effect, which is equally invalid, has become entrenched in our lexicon. There is an area over the South Pole where ozone is thinner - on average about 1/3rd thinner than the global average and this appears in the winter when there is no sunlight to produce ozone. However, as with all issues as I hope you are realizing by now, there is a great deal more involved. The lack of ozone is partially due to no ultraviolet but also due to atmospheric circulation (the circumpolar vortex), and the pressures and temperatures. The latter reach 90?C in winter and this forms polar stratospheric clouds (PSC) which appear associated with ozone depletion. In short ozone varies considerably naturally all the time just like the climate.
Darren Asks: Is there a correlation between the number of category 4 & 5 hurricanes and the increase in water temperatures off the gulf and eastern seaboard?
A; Hurricanes are a function of water temperature, which is why they form at the end of the summer over water transported across the Atlantic during the northern hemisphere summer. The energy for the hurricane comes from water evaporated in to the easterly wave system that as it expands away from the equator come sunder the influence of Coriolis Force that turns it into a spinning motion. I have heard estimates of evaporation of 2 billion gallons an hour in a medium size hurricane. When this condenses the heat used for evaporation is released in to the system providing its energy. this is why when it moves over land it is like clamping the fuel line and the hurricane quickly loses force. There has been no increase in the number of 4 and 5 category hurricanes. In fact there has been a decrease with the most numbers occurring the 1940s. Similarly there has been no increase in the maximum wind speeds by which hurricane categories are determined. The worst hurricane in terms of loss of life was in 1900 in Galveston when 6000 people died. This, like Katrina was mostly due to dike failure. Katrina was only a force three when it actually came ashore although it was briefly a five out over the Gulf. The distortion of numbers is due to the insurance industry who used increase costs of repairs as a measure of increased severity (look at the web page for Swiss Re one of the largest insurance company in the world and their claims of more severe weather. Two other factors the media love to hype things, but also the US Army Corp of engineers which has effectively tried to control the Mississippi over its entire course blew it. Incidentally, the worst year for tornado deaths was in 1905 when 254 people died and yet there were far fewer people living in the tornado prone areas.
Daniel Eaton Asks: Is it true that the most industrialized countries are the ones showing the least warming in their instruments?
A; No. They are showing more warming because of the urban heat island effect (UHI) I did measures in Winnipeg Canada in 1972 and discovered the centre of the city was 3.3?C warmer than the surrounding countryside. My studies were a result of reading Chandler's Climate of London published in 1952. Most weather stations are at airporst nar big cities. As the cities grew the heat from the city caused the readings to rise and this was incorrectly interpreted as global warming. Rural stations show little or no warming. Indeed Idso (CO2 Digest) claims no evidence of real warming for 70 years.
Daniel Eaton Asks: Is it true that the countries with the least accurate technology are the ones showing the most temperature rise?
A; No as explained above. However, there are other problems. For example, we now now that Siberia which they claim shows the most warming received money during the Soviet era based on how cold it was thus the reports showed colder than actually occurring. Since that is the point of reference we now interpret that as most warming. Canada, due to bureaucratic bungling has less weather stations now than in 1960 and the official useable weather record for all of Canada begins in 1948. Most of the world has virtually no record, especially beyond 50 years including the oceans, the boreal and tropical rain-forest, the deserts, the Polar Regions and so on. I ask what data they used to construct the computer models.
Daniel Eaton Asks: Is it true that some icebergs and glaciers are growing?
A; Yes, glaciers fall into two categories Alpine and continental. We only monitor about 10% of the Alpine glaciers and while some show retreat others are advancing. However, glaciers of either kind are not just a function of temperature. Precipitation variations are also very important. Gore used Kilimanjaro but neglected to point out that the temperatures at stations surrounding the mountain show no signs of warming. However, there has been a decreasing level of precipitation for at least 80 years. Icebergs increase with advancing glaciers as the ice pushes out into the water more calve off. We have seen an increase in the numbers but this more likely due to the increase of volume in the Antarctic and Greenland domes pushing the ice down and increasing the flow around the edges.
Daniel Eaton Asks: Is it true that some of the years with the highest emissions correspond with the mini-ice age of last century?
A: There is no correlation between atmospheric CO2 and global temperature at any time in the earth's history. In fact the geologic and biologic evidence shows we are at a 600 million year low in levels of atmospheric CO2. Interestingly commercial greenhouses are increasing CO2 levels by up to four times and plants seem to grow best at about 1200 ppm. This suggests they may have evolved at higher earlier levels. The min-ice age more normally called the Little Ice Age (LIA) correlates (remember the warning) with a period of virtually no sunspots called the Maunder Minimum.
Daniel Eaton Asks: Is it presumptuous of mankind to think that they can change, much less control, global weather patterns?
A; Yes. I won't get into the entire philosophical debate but when you let science become the religion it creates a problem because science is an should be amoral and apolitical. As I think I said earlier what would the solution have been when the threat of cooling was the scientific consensus - "Get your SUV now. Increase CO2, stop the cooling."
Daniel Eaton Asks: How accurate are the weather models that predict global warming?
A; Totally useless. I already commented on the lack of data at the surface but there is even less above the surface yet the models are three dimensional. I have also mentioned the lack of known mechanisms etc. They are mathematical linear models but the climate is non linear. I have no problem with them playing around in a lab where there is only a need for scientific responsibility, which they generally fail to meet. The problem is when they go public through such vehicles as the IPCC and the NAS to say their models work and are accurate predictors of future scenarios.
Daniel Eaton Asks: Are the dire numbers we hear the extremes of the weather models, or the moderate numbers?
A; The weather models provide a range currently about 1.5?C to 4.5?C. The media nearly always report the highest value. All you have ot do is ask why there is such a wide range in the predictions. All we usually hear is "worse case scenario,"
Daniel Eaton Asks: What percentage of greenhouse gases are produced by man?
A; I gave the numbers earlier but repeat them here.
The amount of our contributions relative to the global scale are miniscule. Consider CO2 where estimates of atmospheric CO2 range from 750 Gt (gigatons) to 820 GT or an error of estimate of 70 GT. We add 6 Gt to the atmosphere but remove 3 GT for a net contribution of 3 GT, in other words our contribution is about 4% of the error of the estimate. More important, every year when they calculate the carbon cycle there is at least 7 GT missing, hence it is known as the missing sink. I will also add that we have only crude estimates for the amount of CO2 in the oceans, soils and forest. We only began measuring the amount of gas inputs and outputs of the boreal forest about 8 years ago and then only at two sites in central Canada.
Daniel Eaton: Does global satellite temperature data confirm ground-based temperature readings showing a warming trend?
A; the global satellite was launched in 1978 and has shown far less warming than the surface temperature. There was a recent flurry about adjustments to the satellite data but it still shows a different trend, although Christy acknowledges a very slight warming. It is a much better measure because it covers the entire globe but not really long enough to be statistically significant.
Daniel Eaton Asks: What is the real agenda of the global-warming scare mongers?
A; I wish I knew some point the finger at Maurice Strong's comment that "Isn't the only hope for the planet that the industrialized nations collapse? Isn't it our responsibility to bring that about?" There are charges now emerging of eco-imperialism for instance the millions dying from malaria because of bans on DDT.
2TUFF Asks: I believe that EISCAT, HAARP, SUPERDARN, CEDAR, SPEAR, SOUSY, SURA are the true cause of the weather chaos were seeing right now! Do you believe this to be true?
A; I can't comment on this since I know of enough natural factors to easily explain the normal weather patterns we are seeing now.
2TUFF Asks: What are the official documents which show that we're actually in a slight global cooling just under the 0 mark? I'm sure it was some NASA documents.
A; The evidence is we have cooled since 1998.
2TUFF Asks: Do you believe that we would be heading for another Ice-Age rather than a Warming if they weren't heating the Ionosphere?
A; I am not sure about heating the ionosphere. I do think NASA is afraid they are going to be blamed for gases released in to the stratosphere. I also know that the sunspot cycles are decreasing and some, including NASA are suggesting another mini-ice age by 2030.
2TUFF Asks: William Cooper claimed that Project Lucifer was to create a second heat source to help starve off the coming Ice-Age using the probe Cassini smashed into Saturn's atmosphere with its onboard nuclear payload! Do you think this may be so or simply another reason entirely? I do not believe it?s simply to maybe help geo-engineer Titan as a place for new life support. Remember that they attempted this with Jupiter and the Galileo probe.
A; Don't know enough to comment.
2TUFF Asks: Can you tell us more on how they take readings within built up areas so that the readings are higher and thus aid their hoax?
A; I have explained the urban heat island effect above.
2TUFF Asks: Do you believe its simply another stunt in order to fulfill one of the agendas of `The Iron Mountain Report'?
A; Not familiar with this report so again can't comment. All I know is that fear and panic create bad decision making and we need to calm down.
http://www.geocities.com/zacherle_hoag/tball
_________________
Liberal Socialist Democrats and Muslims are like slinkies
They really don?t serve a useful purpose,
but they still bring a smile to your face
When you push them down the stairs.
Free range rancher raising sacrificial animals
by deepsand
by planemech
Dude,
It's also ever so easy to act the brainwashed sheep, and run off bleeting after any silly fad the Liberal Socialist Left cooks up. Every single time they put lipstick on a pig, they can be sure that some of you guys from the hive mind will converge in lockstep to bow down and worship it as the new religion without ever asking to first see what?s behind the curtain.
The problem here is your lack of faith in God. The Libs are always trying to replace god, and make man into god. They don't believe in a heaven or a life after death, so they fear death and seek to create a paradise here on earth. Thus, without God, the planet is dependant on us, and man causes all problems on the planet. The free man is the problem, and only socialism and the redistribution of wealth can save us all from freedom. Which is really stinking odd, because one of the main selling points that bowls you guys over to the cult of Liberal Socialism, is that of the article of the faith that says you are not responsible, the government is. You don?t have to make any choices or hard decisions the government will come in and make them all for you.
Now for you it?s religious heresy, to question the ?vast consensus? of your latest article of religious faith. In order to stifle debate, you quote the Apostle al-gore and one scientist from NASA, and shout down anyone who offers opposing scientific evidence as global warming deniers, and seek to fraudulently put them on par with holocaust deniers. Can the Lib-Socialist Inquisition of Global Warming deniers be far be hind? Then what for your little wack-job enviro-cult turned State Religion, burn SUV drivers at the stake?
by deepsand
by planemech
Hice hit dude,
I think you sank his battle ship with that one.
by planemech
Exactly!
You are right. The Polar Bear photo is bogus as is everything else the Liberal Left has thrown up in the way of emotional argument devoid of scientific fact.
You know why there are so many stinking bears?
Because we stopped beating baby fur seals, and mild winters are good for bears eating them. Thinner ice, warmer air actually helps them find the seals. Thus the bear population is actually up across the board in all but two small areas.
This whole bear photo just shows the sophistry and the lengths to which the Lib-Socialist America hating, God Loathing, Commie Far Left is willing to push their anti-western lies onto little kids, and dupe them into believing they are seeing the very last two polar bears on what?s left of the ice shelf at Santa?s north pole.
Ever notice with the left it?s always hate and no. They hate Bush, hate God, hate Christians, Hate America, on and on. Then when they don?t fear and loath something they are busy little busy-bodies telling us all no this or that. No war! No Oil! No Global Warming! No Fishing! No Hunting! No Babies! No Roads! No Men! No Religion! No God! Etc.
What ever it is you want to do in life, there?ll be a thin skinned liberal group of the easily offended, formed to protest against it and object that it offends them and violates their rights, never mind how selfish they are in trampling yours in the process. They have rights! Rights, mostly to be offended, which much like the Separation of Church and State, is not in the US Constitution by the way. Liberals are the most unhappy bunch of godless religious zealots on the planet. I wish they?d all pull the purple sheets over their heads, shut the hell up and catch the next comet, out a here!
by planemech
Every single time you post you tell us all how much you really don't know nothing about anything.
Fascists are in fact and practice, Socialists; as are Communists.
The difference is that one is of a Globalist bent and the other was of a primarily Nationalist first bent.
Neither of them have a legitimate place in American Right vs Left politics, historically. Our Left was always far far to the right of anything the Europeans were allowed to come up with.
That is until recently when the Democrats ran out of ideas and went casting about for new old ideas to steal.
by thechas
Fascism is a far Right wing ideology.
While fascism shares some aspects of socialism, it is based on the concept that everyone works for the benefit of the central government. The people only get what the government allows them to have.
Nazism was a form of fascism.
Socialism on the other hand holds that all people should share equally in the proceeds of all labor. The government may provide a lot of services for the benefit of all. Still, the government gets it's power from the people not the other way around.
Chas
by deepsand
That you and your ilk are left with naught but self-centered policy views to bolster your bankrupt claims is a sorry sight to behold.
Come back when you are both willing and able to engage in a civil and rational discourse.
by planemech
You got noting to bring.
No fact, no bling, no sing, you can't even sting.
But I do.
Read this and weep troll.
http://www.geocities.com/zacherle_hoag/tball Be Informed, educate your sorry self, and dine on fact.
Stop letting the likes of sore losers like algore lead you about by the nose ring for the rest of your miserable little life, pathetic lies and appeals to your emotions.
Learn to think for yourself, and stop following the herd of popular consensus over the cliff.
by planemech
You do realize that the UN report has no science or more importantly scientists, right?
That was a collection of political appointees attending the conference that created that report.
Having Jane Goodall get up and hoot like a chip at breakfast, is not a serious review of science fact.
The UN delicates made a monkey out of her and she ate it up.
by planemech
An experiment that hints we are wrong on climate change
Nigel Calder, former editor of New Scientist, says the orthodoxy must be challenged
When politicians and journalists declare that the science of global warming is settled, they show a regrettable ignorance about how science works. We were treated to another dose of it recently when the experts of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change issued the Summary for Policymakers that puts the political spin on an unfinished scientific dossier on climate change due for publication in a few months? time. They declared that most of the rise in temperatures since the mid-20th century is very likely due to man-made greenhouse gases.
Read the full article here:
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article1363818.ece
by deepsand
by planemech
Yep, neither Bush 41 or 43 are conservative.
Far from it sadly. G.W.Bush is a open borders guy and following along with what Cheney and Clinton and other members of the Trilateral Commission tell him.
by planemech
President of Czech Republic Calls Man-Made Global Warming a 'Myth' - Questions Gore's Sanity
Mon Feb 12 2007 09:10:09 ET
Czech president Vaclav Klaus has criticized the UN panel on global warming, claiming that it was a political authority without any scientific basis.
In an interview with "Hospod?rsk? noviny", a Czech economics daily, Klaus answered a few questions:
Q: IPCC has released its report and you say that the global warming is a false myth. How did you get this idea, Mr President??
A: It's not my idea. Global warming is a false myth and every serious person and scientist says so. It is not fair to refer to the U.N. panel. IPCC is not a scientific institution: it's a political body, a sort of non-government organization of green flavor. It's neither a forum of neutral scientists nor a balanced group of scientists. These people are politicized scientists who arrive there with a one-sided opinion and a one-sided assignment. Also, it's an undignified slapstick that people don't wait for the full report in May 2007 but instead respond, in such a serious way, to the summary for policymakers where all the "but's" are scratched, removed, and replaced by oversimplified theses.? This is clearly such an incredible failure of so many people, from journalists to politicians. If the European Commission is instantly going to buy such a trick, we have another very good reason to think that the countries themselves, not the Commission, should be deciding about similar issues.?
Q: How do you explain that there is no other comparably senior statesman in Europe who would advocate this viewpoint? No one else has such strong opinions...?
A: My opinions about this issue simply are strong. Other top-level politicians do not express their global warming doubts because a whip of political correctness strangles their voice.
? Q: But you're not a climate scientist. Do you have a sufficient knowledge and enough information??
A: Environmentalism as a metaphysical ideology and as a worldview has absolutely nothing to do with natural sciences or with the climate. Sadly, it has nothing to do with social sciences either. Still, it is becoming fashionable and this fact scares me. The second part of the sentence should be: we also have lots of reports, studies, and books of climatologists whose conclusions are diametrally opposite.? Indeed, I never measure the thickness of ice in Antarctica. I really don't know how to do it and don't plan to learn it. However, as a scientifically oriented person, I know how to read science reports about these questions, for example about ice in Antarctica. I don't have to be a climate scientist myself to read them. And inside the papers I have read, the conclusions we may see in the media simply don't appear. But let me promise you something: this topic troubles me which is why I started to write an article about it last Christmas. The article expanded and became a book. In a couple of months, it will be published. One chapter out of seven will organize my opinions about the climate change.? Environmentalism and green ideology is something very different from climate science. Various findings and screams of scientists are abused by this ideology.?
Q: How do you explain that conservative media are skeptical while the left-wing media view the global warming as a done deal??
A: It is not quite exactly divided to the left-wingers and right-wingers. Nevertheless it's obvious that environmentalism is a new incarnation of modern leftism.?
Q: If you look at all these things, even if you were right ...?
A: ...I am right...?
Q: Isn't there enough empirical evidence and facts we can see with our eyes that imply that Man is demolishing the planet and himself??
A: It's such a nonsense that I have probably not heard a bigger nonsense yet.?
by shaun.g
Maxwell...
What about the hole in the ozone layer? You left that out... let me addd a little... appparantly the hole has always been there... for exhaust gases... at least I heard a scientist some years back claim this... but I dont hear much about it... perhaps you do...and can say I am right o perhaps not.
by planemech
Hi Shaun, this might help you out with your question.
From my post titled: Interview With Dr. Timothy Ball- The Myth of Global Warming?
Q; What would cause a big hole in the Ozone over the poles where there shouldn't be any chemical release?
A; First of all there never was a hole in the ozone but the term like the greenhouse effect, which is equally invalid, has become entrenched in our lexicon. There is an area over the South Pole where ozone is thinner - on average about 1/3rd thinner than the global average and this appears in the winter when there is no sunlight to produce ozone. However, as with all issues as I hope you are realizing by now, there is a great deal more involved. The lack of ozone is partially due to no ultraviolet but also due to atmospheric circulation (the circumpolar vortex), and the pressures and temperatures. The latter reach 90?C in winter and this forms polar stratospheric clouds (PSC) which appear associated with ozone depletion. In short ozone varies considerably naturally all the time just like the climate.
by shaun.g
to you...but it is a geocities site, and really does not hold much authority at all.
However:
http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/lookingatearth/ozone_record.html
http://www.antarctica.ac.uk/Key_Topics/The_Ozone_Hole/
http://ozonewatch.gsfc.nasa.gov/
http://www.theozonehole.com/
All say different... I think, like in my post about the moon landing, the evidence to show it happened is more substantial than that to show it didnt, and same in this situation... the evidence shows that there is a hole, and probably always has been.
From my understanding it like an exhaust outlet...letting gases escape, but that is my understanding and it may well be wrong, but to say there is no hole... I think you are more than just wrong on that one.
by deepsand
Yet another example of selective winnowing of the facts.
It's called intellectual dishopnesty.
by planemech
I have. Many times. The map you are using is a Leftist lie.
I think you have been trapped into thinking the same amateur mistake others have; in that, if communism is historically considered to be left of center, and Communists fought Fascists, then Fascism must be some how right. Right? Now, American Democrats devoid of any new ideas going back to say 1846, have since adopted Commie Socialism in order to have some ideas at all, therefore the Republican Right must, because the Dems are Commies, some how be Fascist. Right? Well that?s just plain wrong. First of all, because all forms of Socialism have no place at the table in historic American politics. You?re attempting to compare apples to cabbages here.
Fascism is not a rightwing construct that can be applied in American Left vs Right Politics. It's a common mistake people have been allowed to make, that just because Fascists and Nazi?s were opposed to Communists; that they were not also Socialists with their own version of a Socialist Utopia in mind.
The only way one can successfully ague Fascism as being to the Right of anything is in comparing European left/right Socialist politics, with Communism on the Left and Fascism being the polar opposite.
Fascism, Communism, different sides of the same coin, my friend. Both were socialist in aim and goals just differed on how best to get there.
And yes, the Nazi's were and are National Socialists. That?s what they called themselves. What you were attempting to describe was communism and confusing it with being the end all and be all of Socialism.
Yes the Fascists (National Socialists) believed in limited private ownership of business and some elements of capitalism, but they felt it was just a temporary means to an end. A intermediary step that they could eventually do a way with. The National Socialists felt that was one of the areas were Russian Socialism had failed, taking all personal property away from the slaves too soon. Better to let them hang on to something and offer some small window of hope while the trap is being set.
With Communists (Global Socialists) everything including people are owned by the state.
In both systems and any Socialist system really, no socialist government gets power from the people, so there you are wrong. Socialists believe they are granted their rights and material wealth from the Central Government. National Socialists just believe in a more modulated form of wealth redistribution only because they recognized that in the Soviet model the economy was failing and there were advantages to allowing some capitalist elements to continue to exist in order to generate wealth that could then be seized and redistributed as needed.
Only in the United States do we believe our Rights are God Given and thus inalienable, and only here do the We the People grant limited powers to the Government.
Yeah, the Communist manifesto might talk a good game, but history shows practice in action is far from the promised ideal.
The end game of Socialism has always been slavery and state Ownership.
The American Republican Party was formed in opposition to human slavery in all its insidious forms and even fought a war to end slavery here.
With Democrats in stark opposition, under the guise of 'peace democrats' (look it up) nipping at the Union's heals and undermining their efforts the whole way and much as they still do to this very day. Today, giving aid and comfort to the enemy and negotiating outside of proper channels in attempts to preserve that slavery whether it's promoting Socialism, wealth redistribution, or manufacturing a static underclass to falsely champion.
by absolutely
2-dimensional ideology maps.
Take "liberty" vs. "state control" as the fundamental question.
Now, draw a horizontal line. Make it the "economic" axis.
Draw a vertical line through the center of that line. Make it the "social" axis.
Figure out for yourself where to locate which ideology. You're welcome.
by absolutely
"if you analyze the majority of this movement it's emotional."
does not move me to an irresistible desire to "engage" your list. What it does tell me is that you have already made up your mind, not only about global warming, but about the intellectual inferiority of everybody who does not already fully agree with you. Knowing that I disagree with you on your opening paragraph, why do you expect me, or anybody else who disagrees with those claims, to "engage" your list, which proceeds logically only from [i]acceptance[/i] of all this?
[i]if you analyze the majority of this movement it's emotional. There's too much random hostility, hatred, bitterness, and fear. If you read all of these reports fully there are always qualifiers on the serious reports. That is "probably", "maybe", "we think", etc.[/i]
I have not analyzed "the majority of this movement", I have analyzed the original research, and although there can be ulterior motives in [i]anything[/i], the mere speculative [i]possibility[/i] of such motives is not a counterargument.
by absolutely
"The move away from scientific forecasting of the weather to sensationalized leftist political advocacy is in part due to the influence of Wonya Lucas, executive vice president and general manager of The Weather Channel Networks.
Lucas admitted in a recent interview with Media Village that the reprogramming of The Weather Channel was influenced by her tenure at CNN when that network shifted from presenting straight news to personality-driven programming."
No matter which channel you dislike, the market is to blame for what it buys. Sometimes it's hard to support a market that ignores the news, unless it's presented in the style of frivolous comedy.
by shaun.g
Its not whether I disagree or agree... the question is not:
"There are JUST AS MANY reputable "scientists" and/or "climatologists" who agree with the notion of man-caused global warming as those who don't.
Do you consider that statement true or false? (And agree or disagree, please provide some support.)"
But rather:
How do any scientists explain the increase heat, globally... and the severe change in weather patterns?
Just a simple illustratation... I am in the UK... and it used to get really cold... and we never used to have super hot summer, that is 30+ degrees celsius for as long as we do now... and places that used to have much snow often, dont have so much now...
In Moscow, they only recently got snow... and they should have it from end of November...
So, if its a 'fallacy' how do the ...err... 'reputable' scientists that disagree, deal with these factual climate changes due to increased heat?
I am curious.
by deepsand
You'll find that those who deny either that global warming exists or that man can have any effect on climate are long on opinions and short on facts.
They have elsewhere here on TR been challenged to a serious and formal debate, and they have declined to participate.
by shaun.g
I understand what you write about thinking emotionally, but I think what you mean is that people react on emotions rather than on respond to a given situation with due care, thought, and consideration.
Also, when one is emotionally disturbed (and I use that in a very broad sense... and it will include very happy to very angry to very sad to very depressed - so all the emotions except a balanced one) any decisions taken will be wrong due to an external influence affecting that decision.
Furthermore, if all all the facts are not looked at, then decision taken will be a biased one rather than an objective one.
I read your list... and your list is not to do with good, bad, or emotional thinking... its all based on policy decisions. Whereas policy is good, it still needs balancing with everything else.
In order to reach a qualified reasonable and as fair as is possible decision, ALL the facts need to be obtained meaning to look into all possible situations. That means talking with everyone. Then and only then can a decision be taken.
And if you dont know, then it is ok to say it.
This applies to any problem that arises or may arise.
by planemech
Shaun,
regardless of which site I found the article at and that it linked back to a geocities site, if you would bother to read the article you would find out who Dr. Timothy Ball is.
Then you wouldn't need to post protests over geocities sites. K? I really don?t? care that you can find 'numbers' to back you up. The majoriy is in fact almost always never right.
A thousand drunken idiots backing you up doesn?t make you any more right or less, than a hundred.
Of course these guys are perpetrating the myth, they have research grants, papers and cushy chairmanships riding on it.
It's not a hole, As Dr Ball in formed you, in the interview that I provided you with, that's a gross misnomer and a hoax perpetrated on the public.
What it is, is an area were the Ozone is less pronounced, thinner if you will. As Ball stated ? ?on average about 1/3rd thinner than the global average and this appears in the winter when there is no sunlight to produce ozone?
Exhaust port? Exhaust port for what? It has nothing to do with being an ?exhaust port? there Red Leader, so stand down with the photon torpedoes.
?The lack of ozone is partially due to no ultraviolet but also due to atmospheric circulation (the circumpolar vortex), and the pressures and temperatures. The latter reach 90?C in winter and this forms polar stratospheric clouds (PSC) which appear associated with ozone depletion.?
What part of that is so hard to follow? Or are you still stuck on the fact that someone?s? been lying to you, and they?ve got a whole bar of drunken scientists to back them up?
As I said before there is no hole, but saying there is, and calling it a ominous sounding name like ?a hole? will get you continuing research grants you can retire on.
And Shaun, regardless of what you call the condition; its? always been there and always will be due to planetary mechanics of weather, radiation and magnetic fields, etc. We had nothing to do with it, and there?s nothing we can do to ?fix it.?
by planemech
Things have been changing on this planet,
ever since we were knocked into this orbit, and picked up a moon, to give us seasons.
Ever wonder how the big Dino?s were able to cope in our current gravity? Fact is they couldn?t.
by planemech
I have, seen many of those models, Sir, and most of those are bogus leftist constructs as well. And trying to use one to compare L/R European Socialism to American L/R Politics is the most bogus of all.
There are often ulterior motives behind many of those models, that seek to hide the true nature of the Left and their association with Fascism.
I was trying to explain things for the little troll that is infecting this discussion in linear terms I was hoping he would understand.
However if you prefer the two-dimensional, for you I will.
Euro-Socialism is better viewed as a Bell curve that becomes a circle with both sides at the bottom. The commie left and fascist right sliding down their prospective sides of the curve into the utter oppression of pure Socialism. Eventually the sides will meet closing the circle and completing the trap. Either way, in that closed model liberty is lost to total State Control, eventually. And none of that non-sense has anything to do, or shouldn?t have anything to do with American Politics and a good strong Capitalist Society, provided that is , we stick to being a Constitutional Republic and ditch these silly and dangerous notions of ?pure Democracy?.
Euro trash Left/Right politics has always been historically far to the left of American L/R. That is until the Dems ran out of ideas and managed to allow themselves to be taken over lock stock and barrel by the Socialists.
Regardless, Fascism is still a component of Socialism. And deepsand?s dishonest attempt to link the American RNC with Fascism is patently false, and as I have proven, he would be better served looking into the of the neo Socialism of the modern DNC, if he is so concerned with any sort of ?socialist fascism? rearing its? ugly head on these shores.
by sn53
jdcl said, "SN53, didn't you get the memo?"
Darn it. No! And I love vast right wing conspiracies.
by sn53
CanI said, "And guess what? My enviro-fascism isn't going to be limited to what we call the global warming stuff, either.
There is a whole stack of other things that have or are ruining the world for my kids..."
Fascism is never limited, is it. Fascists always have their reasons. The democrats usually do their damage "for the children" just as you have stated in your case.
It always ends up the same. Every time fascists rear their ugly heads terror, murder and ultimately a corrective war must occur to set it right. It is no different this time.
by deepsand
by deepsand
UN boy?
Let me know when you've got some scientific facts to discuss.
by deepsand
"Fact is they couldn?t."
Fact? Where did you study the sciences? On another world?
by deepsand
by sn53
by deepsand
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending