Discussion Locked

GNOME vs. KDE, which is better & why? Also what Linux distro do you use?

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm new to linux and I've been downloading quite a few different distributions to determine which version to settle down with. I've noticed that not only are the numerous linux distributions different from each other feature wise, I've also noticed that some of them default to either a KDE or GNOME desktop environment. My question is why the difference exists, is one better than the other, is one better suited to a workplace environment and one better suited to a home user environment, why can't one desktop environment (KDE or GNOME) handle both needs - this isn't a complaint, it's a genuine question from an interested Linux newbie.

Currently I've installed Ubuntu v5.04 which runs GNOME v2.1 (or 2.6? both values have shown up in different places) and I've tried SuSE v9.1 which runs KDE v3.2. Both of these distributions are Live EVAL CD's which means they run directly off the cd. They both set themselves with automatic network connections so they have internet access as soon as the load up (typically @ 2min. bootup times), they both have an office suite and both do an OK job at detecting the hardware. I've noticed that SuSE does a better job of allowing the user to configure desktop settings (screen resolutions, desktop backgrounds, screensavers, etc.) just by right clicking on the desktop while Ubuntu only allows you to change the desktop background by rightclicking on the desktop, all other desktop settings have to be searched for through the system\preferences menu. Ubuntu has a better terminal server client compared to SuSE's, both work well, Ubuntu's is just easier to use (I don't have to throw in vnc:/ or rdp:/ prefix before the workstation or server name). I've tried Mepis v3.3 (live cd) because I've read some good reviews on it but it seems to be pickier hardware wise, Ubuntu & SuSE ran well on pc's that Mepis would lock up on during the bootup process (even using test boot modes) and Mepis loads some junk on the taskbar that I've tried to get rid of but can't (cpu & resource meter along with weather indicator - if anyone knows how to remove those items please post it as I'd like to try it)

Another interesting live cd linux distribution that I've tried is Beatrix v2005.1 and it seems to run on everything that I've thrown at it (from really old digital 3000 series desktops running 166mhz cpu's, to kind of old but still worthy p3 500's to newer desktops running p4 2.8ghz pc - it also comes as a live cd with an hd install option and comes with an office suite and browser/email apps built in, it lacks some multimedia ability but I think is done on purpose by it's creators.

I plan on test driving RedHat v9 desktop ("shrike"), Novell's linux offering, along with Gentoo and a few others that catch my eye (Anyone know where I can download a free version of turbolinux's desktop distro?) Xandros sounds interesting but I'm not too keen on the bittorrent download and don't want to pay money for a cd to be shipped to me for something I'm not guaranteed to use.

I've also tried Lycoris v3, DSL v0.9.2 as well as College linux v2.5 and none of these IMHO are worth wasting your time on just in case you're a linux newbie and wondered about them, save your time and a few blank cd's.

Once I pick a distribution, I want to setup several linux boxes, connect them to my existing windows network and see if I can get them running as normal office workstations. Anyone know how I can access windows network shares from a linux box, I've tried it on Ubuntu and SuSE, I can browse network folders but once I try to access a specific share, ex. smb://workstation_name I'm prompted for a username and password, I provide my network login credentials but it returns an error so it looks like I'm missing something, if it requires a domain name infront of the user name or if it wants it in a specific format, it's not telling me how it wants the login info entered so I'm at a loss.

I'm still in the beginning stages of becoming a linux user, I'm nowhere near being an expert, more of an informed "newbie". Still lots to learn and there's alot of info available on the net but if you have a few words or comments to spare on the contents of this hugely verbose post, please do share.

thx.... unclerob,wpg

25 replies

by stress junkie

As as newbie you probably wouldn't like what I do but lets get to that last. I saw a couple of comments and questions in your post that I thought I might clarify.

You wrote "... is one better than the other ..."
No, one is not better than the other. One is not better suited to work and the other better suited for home or any other combination that you can think of. These projects are independent of each other. The reason for the differences is very simple: different developers arrive at different styles.

You wrote "... why can't one desktop environment (KDE or GNOME) handle both needs ..."
They can. They do. If you install both GNOME and KDE then you can run GNOME based applications while using KDE and use can run KDE based applications while using GNOME. For instance you can run the GNOME desktop and still use Kmail and Kontact and any other KDE based application. You can run the KDE environment and still use GNOME Evolution and gnome-terminal and any other GNOME based application.

Applications designed for use in either environment use environment specific tools. KDE is QT based, which is an engine for creating X objects, DCOP for sending command line arguments to KDE applications, and MCOP for other interprocess communications. GNOME uses GTK+ for creating X objects. I haven't learned as much about the guts of GNOME as I have KDE.

The nice thing is that all of these parts can work simultaneously. They don't step on each other.

I'm going to stop here so that this information doesn't get lost in a huge post. I will end by telling you my configuration.

I use the ICE Window Manager. This is just another possible solution that performs the same function as GNOME and KDE. I like the ICE system because it starts a lot faster and is easy to configure via text files in the $HOME/.icewm directory. I use applications that are based on KDE tools, applications that are based on GNOME tools, and applications that are based on the general purpose X interface standards. THEY ALL WORK!!!!

That's the really good news that I have for you. You can choose any window manager that runs on top of XFree86 or X.org window system. All of the window managers will work. All of the applications will work with any window manager.

Lastly, I recommend that you install the Xfce window manager just for the xftree application. This application is the most like Microsnot Windows Explorer of any file manager that I've seen on Linux. I love it.

by jaqui

try a hard drive install from 3 cdroms ( or more depending on distro )
make sure you get to select individual packages.

my preffered desktop isn't kde or gnome it is enlightenment.
no bars, a widget in a corner and absolutely everything accessed through mouse clicks.

the only time you hit exclusivity in linux is hardware devices.
you can't run two drivers for same hardware at same time.
( good thing too )

with support for multiple logins into the xserver you can have multiple gui systems running at the same time.
( different user accounts for each )

mandrake/mandriva defaults to kde, but they include xfce, icewm, icewmlight, enlightenment, gnome, blackbox... they have a dozen gui systems included even in the dowload edition.

as much as people say they are no good, they do offer a fairly good selection, and everything is open source with them.
( thier own software is all open source as well )
very user friendly, and no longer bleedng edge.

by jmgarvin

1) It doesn't really matter what window manager you use. I like Gnome and FVWM, but they all have the same basic functionality
2) The distros I like with live cd are Knoppix, Gentoo, and Ubuntu...but to each their own
3) RH9 is dated. Try Fedora Core 3. For distros try: Fedora Core 3, Ubuntu, Knoppix, Gentoo, Suse, or Debian. If you are pretty hardcorps, try Slackware.
4) College Linux is ok, but too limited in scope. It is good for getting into the kernel.
5) Good for you! Samba is what you need. There are TONS of great samba tutorials on the web.
6) Welcome to a whole new world!!!

by jdclyde

have you created an account in both the linux AND samba? samba (at least for login) needs an account setup and a password.

Good luck with the toys!

by unclerob

Yes, I'm quite the inquisitive one, it gets annoying I'm sure, thanks for your patience.

Do any of you know or have experience installing linux on an existing pc running winxp using a vm environment like virtual pc 2004? Is this even possible? I was just having brainfart and it occurred to me that it might be cool to have both running simultaneously on the same pc. I have a decent p4 pc with plenty of drive space, memory, etc. Let me know what you think.

Again, thanks alot for your replies on my original post - this Linux world is definitely alot bigger than I had first imagined! Aside from a BartPE cd (which really doesn't count), you can't run windows live from a cd and have a suite of office, internet & email apps installed and ready to use. Linux is pretty cool.

by jmgarvin

Sure it costs, but it is WAY worth it! I love VMWare and all it has done to...uh...for me!

There are free VMWare clones, but I prefer the feature set that VMWare offers. You can demo it (www.vmware.com) and see if you like it.

It is a little pricey at $200 a pop, but IMHO it is worth every penny.

by choppit

VMWare is a great tool for loads of reasons. In my case physical space was an issue, so having virtual machines allows me to play without restrictions. My only constraint now is memory and disk space, particularly when I'm running multiple virtual hosts.

You mention free VM clones, I'd be interested to take a look at these. Any chance you could post some names/links?

by jaqui

that is designed into vmware:

no hardware access ( network card specifically )

you have to also use a bridge with it to get online with the vm.

this is meant to allow hosting windows in a linux box, and see what damage a virus does with no risk of spreading, or real system infection.

fortunately, most install ditros ( if not all ) come with an ethernet bridge package, so you can vmware linux and still get online.

only concern is the performance hit..wirtual machine to os to bridge ... opportunities abound for chokepoints in processor access, specially with windows host and firewall / antivirus running. you will be able to use it, but mayu not get the full benefits with a vm hosted os.

by apotheon

Gnome and KDE are more than just window managers (WMs): they're desktop environments (DEs), or graphical user environment frameworks. Each consists of a set of libraries and applications designed to work together to produce a feature-rich user interface environment. The Windows equivalent is the Explorer environment, which consists of a set of libraries plus the OS-integrated Internet Explorer rendering engine and a set of default-install applications, though in Windows this is all integral to the total OS install whereas in Linux, Gnome or KDE is simply something you install if you want its functionality and remove (or never install in the first place) if you don't want it.

Gnome is built on a design philosophy in a similar tradition to that of classic MacOS, and KDE is likewise built on a design philosophy in a similar tradition to that of Windows. You can see these similarities in superficial design decisions when you start looking at the differences between Gnome and KDE, and the parallel differences between Windows and classic MacOS. There are other DEs besides Gnome and KDE available for use with the X Window System, and they too are inspired at least in part by the design philosophies of other OSes, generally, though there's no programmatic reason why that has to be the case.

Generally, a DE seems to evolve out of a desire to implement a certain set of useful and convenient GUI functions from an initial starting point of a window manager. A window manager is, in short, just a means of creating a place for application windows to open, a set of minimal behaviors for controlling those application windows, and some guidance for the applications in terms of how their windows should appear. As more and more features are added on top of that, a DE eventually begins to evolve.

Ultimately, the application base and libraries of a DE tend to end up divisible from the standard window manager that goes with a given DE. As such, a mature DE can be coupled with any of a fair number of WMs, so long as those WMs are functionally compatible with the feature set that DE was meant to implement. Sometimes, however, the window manager associated with a given desktop environment doesn't work without that environment, thus creating a one-way divisibility: the DE can be separated from the WM and used with other WMs, but the WM cannot be separated from the DE, and to use the WM with other DEs requires the use of the DE with which it's associated as well. You can add to it, but you can't replace it, in other words.

There are exceptions, however. This will come up as I list some WMs and DEs below:

[b]Gnome[/b]
Gnome is large and "feature-rich" (a synonym for "bloated"). This means that it includes lots and lots of features, and these features are essentially indivisible from the desktop environment. The Gnome window manager is a part of the environment, though it can be "ignored" by implementing another WM with the Gnome libraries and application set running behind it. There is a Gnome window manager spin-off called Metacity, which is the closest you'll get to the Gnome WM existing separately from the DE. It is much less feature-rich, much less bloated, and much more simplified in general. It uses the GTK+ toolkit for GUI design.

[b]KDE[/b]
KDE, the "K Desktop Environment", is also a large, feature-rich graphical user interface environment. It shares much in common with Gnome in terms of its status as a DE and WM pairing: the WM is part of the DE, and can be "covered up" or "ignored" but not really replaced because much of it is part of the basic libraries used to run the DE and its application framework. It doesn't have a WM spin-off as similar to its own integral WM the same way Gnome does in Metacity, but such really isn't needed as there is a "work-alike" window manager already in existence that is simply completely different under the hood, called IceWM. IceWM is blazing fast and feather-light, and is one of the snappiest and quickest WMs available, rivaling minimalist WMs like fvwm, fwm, twm, aewm, and so on for its quick responsiveness and minimal resource footprint. About all it has in common with the integrated KDE window manager is its superficial similarity to the Windows GUI appearance and behavior, and its ability to work well with the KDE libraries and applications. KDE uses the Qt toolkit for GUI design.

[b]XFce[/b]
Usually viewed as a lighter-weight, faster variation on the Gnome idea, XFce is actually another animal altogether, complete with its own window manager, XFwm. Unlike the window managers incorporated into Gnome and KDE, it is a simple thing to run XFwm without the rest of XFce. It is, in that sense, truly modular and orthogonal design, which should appeal to quality programmers. XFce lacks the individuated, easy GUI development tool functionality that Gnome and KDE have, respectively, in the form of GTK+ and Qt (respectively), but for the end user it is faster, just as functional, and almost as featureful. It is also close in lightness, lack of bloat, and snappy, responsive behavior as IceWM. XFwm can be separated from it easily and run with full functional compatibility on top of the Gnome or KDE graphical interface framework. XFce doesn't work quite as well with other WMs as Gnome and KDE do, though -- it is designed for XFwm.

[b]GNUstep[/b]
Whereas Gnome (and to a lesser extent, XFce) is based on a MacOS-inspired design philosophy, and KDE is based on a Windows-inspired design philosophy, the GNUstep framework is based on a NeXTstep-inspired philosophy of functionality. It actually provides significantly unique functionality that doesn't exist with the various DEs and WMs outside of GNUstep. In fact, though GNUstep in many ways fills the same needs as a DE, it isn't one: it's an application framework and GUI development toolkit, all optimized toward implementing NeXTstep-style capabilities and interface look, feel, and behavior. It works in concert with the WindowMaker window manager, though there is nothing to prevent its use with other WMs. The main reason there isn't a lot of credible compatibility between GNUstep and other WMs is that other WMs are simply not flexible enough to adjust to the functionality that GNUstep provides. Whereas XFce and XFwm are somewhat orthogonal with the separation of XFwm from XFce, GNUstep and WindowMaker are actually separate to begin with and are simply seamlessly compatible. Each is its own implementation of NeXTstep design and development philosophy, and each has been adjusted to be as compatible with the other as possible. WindowMaker runs with equal facility on top of the GNUstep framework and the Gnome and KDE graphical user environments. GNUstep can be installed alongside Gnome, XFce, and KDE, and its full functionality can be accessed from within Gnome, XFce, or KDE, but the DE-specific apps with each don't benefit from the additional functionality of the GNUstep environment as much as more independent apps might in a GNUstep-oriented environment. My preferred environment, by a long shot, is GNUstep with WindowMaker. Interestingly enough, WindowMaker (with or without GNUstep) runs about as quickly, with about as much snap and responsiveness, as IceWM. The GNUstep environment is of comparable lightness and lean design with XFce, lacking the bloat and feature-creep of KDE and Gnome; GNUstep favors added flexibility and functionality over added features.

Interestingly, Apple bought NeXT and incorporated in MacOS X the same general application framework and functionality capability that has been implemented in GNUstep. It's extremely easy to develop software that will run on both the GNUstep framework and the MacOS X Cocoa framework, thus allowing for easily ported software. There's even a cross-platform development framework that runs on top of GNUstep called Renaissance, which can be used to produce GUI applications that can be implemented without alteration on either a GNUstep platform or MacOS X (using the Cocoa libraries instead of the GNUstep libraries).

A word of warning, regarding GNUstep: Don't try using it with the expectation that it will not require some adjustment. Moving from Gnome or KDE to GNUstep is about as large an adjustment as moving from Windows or classic MacOS to Linux. It is, after all, a unix-platform implementation of the functionality of a whole different operating system. It'll take some getting used to. Everyone that has decided to give GNUstep/WindowMaker a serious try after seeing me use it, however, has found it increasingly attractive, comfortable, and useful, and has starting thinking of Windows, Gnome, IceWM, and XFwm as being increasingly ugly, unwieldy, and difficult as they got used to it. I don't know if that's because I'm good at finding people who are well-suited to WindowMaker and GNUstep, or if it's something more universal, but that's my experience anyway.

It might also help to know that I use Debian for my desktop and laptop systems, and that the GNUstep system for Debian is extremely well tested, and extremely complete. I don't know how well GNUstep is incorporated into other distros. I imagine it would run beautifully on Slackware or Gentoo, though with something as keyed to a given set of GUI environment options as Mandrake/Mandriva, SuSE, or even Ubuntu or Kubuntu, I'm not sure that things might not be more difficult to adjust to suit.

by camalfa

No desktop environement is better than the others they all got something the other dosn't have, a little something, you want to have but there's no limit to mix them all if it's compatible to xfree or xorg. You can start with KDE and run a GNOME application.

from my part, i use xandross open circulation 2(winmodem compliant)with kde but i have evolution ( outlook like) and it's working.

by choppit

VMWare Workstation 4/5 handles hardware access, USB, drives, audio, NIC etc including bridging VLAN to LAN

by lastchip

Bit Torrent put you off downloading Xandros.

It is by far the closest I have come to a Linux system that mimiks Windows.

Before I get crucified by the Linux diehards, let me explain.

I have tried, Redhat, Mandrake, SuSE, Ubuntu, Knoppix and each has its own merits. But if you're coming from scratch via a Windows background, you really do need a Linux "plug and play" system. Xandros is the closest I have come to being able to feel completely at home from day one. Of course there are differences; you must expect that, but Xandros needs no knowledge whatsoever to enjoy a full Linux experience from scratch. Just load and Go!

My installation self configured on to my network. I had Internet access right from the start and I could share files to and from the machines (Linux - Windows - Linux). The update tool (Xandros Networks) lets you keep the system bang up to date with all the latest security fixes at the click of your mouse.

As you become more proficient in Linux, you may prefer one of the other distro's that allow easier "tweaking" via a command line. That's not to say you can't do that in Xandros, but it is really designed to be used "as is" and to be a simple Linux system that can just be used. It achieves that aim admirably. It is based on the Debian distribution.

Just out of interest, this has been written from Firefox within the Xandros operating system.

by jmgarvin

I wouldn't mind using it if people ACTUALLY shared their bandwidth, but they don't. Either they block it with a firewall or their ISPs don't allow bandwidth snarfing.

by ripvan

I wish I had more experience with Linux. I have loaded quite a few, but after Winders, I have problems with doing extensive command line work in Linux. It isn't always necessary, as the Linux systems become better and better, but it is pretty powerful. I won't feel comfortable until it becomes second nature, and that, apparently, is a long way off! I can do it, though, while reading some instructions (provided they AREN'T from the HELP files).

But since I loaded MEPIS, I have been stuck on it (most of the distros I loaded were after MEPIS). I think once you find one that is comfortable, you finally start comparing everything to that one. Of course, that is the first distro that recognized my wireless card out of the box, and (with some trouble) found, recognized, and printed from my print server. That made me gravitate toward it.

Get Linux Format magazine, there are CD's and DVD's on each issue, and even though all of this is readily available on the web, putting it together and reviewing the OS's and software makes me more likely to try it on my extra boxes. I like the fact that there are differences in KDE/Gnome from distro to distro, (they are all trying to make everything easier to use) but generally, anytime I boot something new and KDE pops up, I just feel more comfortable from the start. I am sure that Gnome users feel the same way. Whichever becomes more intuitive first is the one you will like the best.

by apotheon

People aren't intentionally blocking BT bandwidth with firewalls, generally. They're just using firewalls that A) they don't know how to configure to let BitTorrent traffic through effectively or B) their firewall isn't really configurable enough to allow free flow of BT bandwidth without also making their computers/networks vulnerable at the same time. I certainly don't expect anyone to turn off firewalls just because I want a downloaded ISO.

by groenem9

I prefer KDE, because its graphics is more appealing and dynamic for me than Gnome.

The other difference of course is the software applications bundled together with the KDE and Gnome.
Kontact (from KDE) is closer to MS Outlook than that offered by Gnome. KDE combines a Calendar, Contacts, To Do, and a Summary. In Gnome you have different applications for Calendar and Contacts.
Kontact has more Import/Export options than Gnome.

I once had a look at Enlightenment. Now that looks "cool". You feel like using a computer out of a futuristic movie.

I must say I have one BIG problem with Linux - there is too much to choose from - can't make up my mind.:) No, actually, Linux is great. The only reason I am using MS Windows at home is for study purposes and my winmodem to connect to th internet.

by jaqui

http://linmodems.org/

drivers for most winmodems.
for linux.
utilities to see if they have a driver that will run it.
if not, the output of the utility is what they need to start making one.

by alangeek

Thanks, everybody, this has been one of the most informative, least contentious, and highly useful discussions I've found here! It gave me a lot of insight into the various UIs available that I'd been putting off investigating. I'll be rushing home to try several out tonight!

by jaqui

when everyone responding is actually responding not trying to sell m$ware?

;)

by emyr

I have been a linux newbie now for about 6 months and I found that Xandros and Mepis were the easiest distros for a windoze user to be introduced to(Xandros was the first distro I installed). Gentoo was far to techie for me (the install alone but years on me) but I think I will revisit Gentoo again when I have a few more linux years under my belt |D

I am currently using Vector Linux SOHO 5 (KDE) and Fedora Core 3 (GNOME). I personally find that KDE is easier to work with from a windoze point of view, but I also enjoy using GNOME. At the end of the day it all comes down to personal choice. That's the beauty of Linux, choice!)

by dproske

I am also somewhat of a newbie, I wanted wine (windows compat. builtin)and good apps while not "giving up" anything and found it at http://overclockix.octeams.com/
I use Azureus as my w2k bittorrent (only way overclockix is available sorry) and it is easy to use. Overclockix is a live CD and smb and cd burning (if you have dual cds)and etc etc all just work from it

by ozwes0071

Out of the box Xandros is the best distro I have found. Installs quicker than windows, connects to windows file shares out of the box(through Samba)
Try KDE with Konqerer(?) type man: in the address bar or smb:/, or help:/, etc. good hunting.

by jmgarvin

But I wish that there could be the OPTION of BT or "normal" downloading. If the BT is too slow, than let me get it direct...

This discussion is closed to new replies.