Discussion Locked

Help managing a very brilliant employee

0 helpful
192 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a person on my staff that is easily the most talented IT guy I've work with. He seemingly can do it all and can do it quickly and without supervision. I've been working hard to get this guy more exposure, more money, etc. and he is really at the peak of our company pay scale for someone that is not a manager of other employees.

He's expressed an interest in doing more and making more and I would like him to do this with my company and on my larger team.

The problem: In group settings the guy is a train wreck. He will either shrink quietly into a corner and defer to anyone else in the room or he will annoyingly finish everyone's sentances, make really bad (sometimes offensive) jokes, etc. A bit of a Jeckel and Hyde... I've talked to him about this and he is very sensative and doesn't react well. Still, he wants to manage people and get more freedom and interesting projects. These aren't good traits for a manager of others.

I don't want this guy to leave my company (we need more people like him and frankly, it only helps me as a manager to have others really kick butt on my team.) How can I approach him with this constructive criticism and help him get what he and I want?

I'm pursuing the creation of a new position in our new fiscal year but I don't have high hopes that this will happen as HR is very much against this kind of deal.

192 replies

by jmgarvin

1) First of all, he probably hasn't had much exposure to dealing with people in a corporate setting. I'd (god I loath to say this) send him to a sensitivity class.

2) Put him in charge of something, but with no reports. You can promote him, but he doesn't have to have any reports. Create a position like Lead System Administator of Project X. Then let him go nuts.

3) If he doesn't do well in meetings, just give him the minutes and let him continue to work during the meeting.

4) Sometimes the best thing to do is NOT let people manage. You can put him on other projects, but some people just can't lead/manage others. So don't put a square peg in a round hole.

by mia1bxa

Mucho good points here jmgarvin!
Efficient workers often dont make good managers. A good worker will always be a good worker, and if he's exceptional then pay him what he's worth or risk loosing him.
This is what is going wrong with our corporate America. Promote who's right, not who you like or feel sorry for. Why must we Americans manage our companies with our hearts on our sleeves? Stop feeling sorry for the guy and just give him a raise according to his merit.
Manage and promote according to merit, not feelings.

by ciscoguyinkc

In my opinion, it is a waste of time and energy to hone soft-skills. The only way a person will ever fix soft-skill problems is if the person WANTS to fix them. Then he will approach you for help. But that type of change comes from within, not an outside source. Spend 80% of your efforts improving his strengths. Manage around his weaknesses. Sure, at review time you need to address his weaknesses, but spend the majority of the time discussing his strengths, and give him opportunities to improve them, and to really shine. He'll make a bigger impact on the success of your projects, he can make more money and he won't feel bad.
Now, some people never really shine at communication until they are in a leadership role. How would you ever find out whyhen dealing with this type of person? Maybe one of the following will work?
Make him a project-leader for an important project. He'll have tracking, reporting and consultative responsibilities. While he is not in charge of people, he is the go-to guy when someone needs help. Remember how good it feels when someone "needs" your strengths? It gets the guy used to working with others as a leader. You can also start taking him and your team on some team-building (I HATE that term) functions at your local Chamber of Commerce networking functions. He'll be exposed to a lot of people, a lot of executives, a lot of sales people. In short, a lot of professional networkers with various communications tool-kits. He might look at them and say "WOW! How do they do that?" He might not. Bottom line, however, you worked on his communication skills without insulting him.

by jharrell

If this is a good employee, them mentor him. His problem could be a simple as not being prepared for meetings. Unfortunately many individuals that call a meeting do not provide an agenda before hand. Have you provided feedback to him during one-on-one conversations? Some people do lack meeting etiquette but they need to be informed of their shortcomings. I have seen many ?managers? that did not have any technical expertise but they had an MBA. These are the individuals that ?shoot from the hip? without any idea of the possible ramifications of there decision. In short it is every managers responsibility to provide both positive and negative feedback, provide an acceptable career path, determine how to get the most out of their direct reports. Maybe, as you instill these positive management traits, they will rub off on him as well as others.

by blarman

Management means dealing with people. Your concerns indicate that this individual doesn't have the people skills to effectively manage, so until those get developed, I'd stay away from that.

What you should do is sit down with the person and explain that you think they are a very valuable person, that they have a future with you, and that you'd like to help prepare them for future responsibility. Then develop a plan to prepare that person for what you want. This may mean specific traning classes or coaching to help them develop people skills, mentoring an intern, or some other interim step. By showing your commitment and helping him/her in the direction you'd like, you will be building a lasting relationship. In addition, the rest of your employees will notice why this person was singled out and may become more productive.

by gralfus

Sometimes the highly intelligent don't have very good social skills. I've attended meetings of a high IQ society and there are several folks with some peculiar behaviors. Having shared some of these traits, I have found that becoming more socially "acceptable" takes a lot of time and a personal desire to change. If the desire isn't there, or the person doesn't see a reason to be more conformable, then it is a lost cause to try to cause the change from the outside.

I used to hide in my clamshell and not talk unless I absolutely had to. I was content with myself and expected others to be content also. But they invariably wanted to force me to open up and be like them. Problem was, I saw myself as ok and I didn't particularly like them, so why would I want to change? Fitting-in was not a high priority for me. Since I didn't fit in (in school anyway), the others then turned on me and treated me like a turd (a common experience with people on either end of the intelligence curve).

Years later, I got a job on a helpdesk doing phone support. The desire to do well in a computer job forced me to change. I also didn't want to spend my life alone, so that desire forced me to research dating, personalities, marriage, and courtship. Now I have years of IT experience in various capacities, and have been married for 6 years. I only retreat into the cave after a lot of interaction with people, sort of a recharging.

by avalok

I do face similar problems with my highly talented Tech-support staff.
I did try out an experiment which has yielded positive results.
On working Saturdays we conduct interactive sessions on variuos topics chosen by our staff. The condition is that the topic should in no way be related to "Business"!
Employees are encouraged to choose their fav topic and give a presentation/talk to others. What i have observed is, since the topic is non-biz,people are more relaxed when they give the presentation and since it is their fav topic/hobby they are talking about, they do enjoy the sessions. I have noticed marked improvement,oevr a period of time, in my techies soft-skills...
A method worth trying...

by dcreader

I'm one of those people, and bored with the same tech responsibilities I had 15 years ago. Others with fewer tech skills (or even strategy skills) have passed me by, and it is a chore to work under people who make bad decisions.

Unfortunately, enough people do not see me as having management potential to make a difference, so I'm stuck.

My employer is not at all interested in helping me out of my current position, so they have raised my pay to unreasonable levels, but I'm still bored and frustrated. Moreover, being asked to manage a project without having any dedicated resources seems like asking the impossible if I can't do everything myself.

So, maybe your guy is like me, and would rather handle this new skill acquisition on his own. How would you suggest he do it? Dale Carnegie? I got an MBA two years ago, but it did NOT IMPRESS MY BOSSES OR COWORKERS AT ALL. I figured at least it demonstrated my eagerness to learn new things, but it didn't really target the social skills I need.

by firstpeter

Are you sure you WANT him in management? I'm a HUGE believer that the people that make the best individual contributors (which is exactly what this guy sounds like) generally make average managers at best (not ALWAYS, but generally). Check out "The One Thing You Need To Know" by Marcus Buckingham - great book on this topic.

Is it possible to create a position without management responsibility that enables you to provide him the freedom he's after? I know a lot of times the good ol' corporate world says that managers should always make more than individual contributors (a really bad policy to have if you want your business to be the best), but if you can get around that with a new position that may very well be your best route.

I would be very wary of putting this person in management. Ultimately if that's where he wants to go you probably want to make sure he understands what it takes (no crude jokes, patience when others are talking, etc.) and put the onus on him to make the changes necessary to get there. Even then be careful, but if he's showing the initiative to do that then you've got a great start.

by choppit

This guy needs needs recognition (as do most people), but promotion to the point of imcompetence is a bad policy.

From past experience I've seen many individuals (outside IT) promoted to management based on their technical supremacy. The end result is usually the same, you'll lose your best technical people and end up with a company run by lousy managers. Great technical ability and managerial ability are rarely found in the same individual. Not everyone is management material, which is just as well because the nature of the role dictates that not everyone can be a manager.

However, if you see a spark, then test the waters, by allowing him to manage a small (non critical) project with a small team and see how he fares.

by wingood

To set the stage for my comments, MENSA says I have an IQ of 135, way into the genius range. However, I would be near the absolute bottom as a manager.

The problem with HR is that they see everybody as interchangeable parts. Unplug Joe and plug in Fred, and everything will be the same. They have no imagination.

The ONLY thing to do with an employee like this is to create a special category, like a specialist, where they can earn more money and get more recognition for contributing what they are best suited to contribute. We have to get past this silly idea that the person who manages him must earn more money because they get all this production out of him. Everything happens because of who he is, not because of anything that the manager does. About the only effect a manager can have on him is to turn him off.

by tantor

And at the time I thought it was management I wanted. I was among the worst kind of managers too, I was in charge of developing and training those everyone else thought had management potential.

I know this fact intimately: You can't get a square peg in a round hole.

Making someone a manager just to recognize the contribution is a very dangerous road to go down.

I was pretty good at being a manager, but I just didn't *want* it. I became a manager because someone along the line thought I had the "spark". I never asked for it, and as a amanager I was pretty miserable. The money was nice at the time, but when I made the leap to leave that world and hone my technical skills and get into this world, it was the best day of my life. I make a lot more money now and I have considerably fewer headaches. I simply prefer to "manage" these logical little machines than illogical and emotional people.

Now, the best way my manager can reward me is to fight for raises or pay for more training to do my existing job. I like where I'm at. He knows I have no interest whatsoever in being a manager. He also makes it a point that when one of my ideas is approved by management that it is clear to them that I did the research and design.

He changed my title to "Senior Engineer". My life has not changed except 10% more in my check and the other engineers run tech issues through me before going to him. I don't manage them, I help them.

And I couldn't be happier.

Don't try to make this guy a manager, simply ask him what would make him happiest.

by ropperman

Hi All

I see a few questions arise:
1) Does this person really want to go into management?
2) If, YES, then why? To get paid more ? this is NOT a good thing. Rather speak to the powers to be and see if you can?t use the ?company policy? as a guideline rather than law. Everyone wants to be a manager, why? Because ?it pay Better?! If that is the only reason everyone will jest get frustrated.
3) If the person has the potential, I?d say give him a break. As most other people suggest, start small.
4) Why does he make the kind of comments? Maybe his is just looking for ?attention?.
5) How much time do you spend with this employee?

Comments/Suggestions:
1) Task him to do research on management!
2) Talk to him and setup daily/weekly review sessions to review his progress.
3) Work on the strengths, and see how you can manage the weakness.
4) Try more exposure in smaller groups.
5) He need to understand that a a manage you need to be ?a team player?. In other words, he should not try and do everything himself.

by dc guy

At least not soon enough to solve this problem. You need to face that and deal with reality. You can and indeed should send him to classes and do your managerial best to mentor him into improving his people skills, but that will take years, IF he can be motivated to do so.

Most savvy companies do exactly what you suggest, set up a parallel track for non-managerial technical people so they can keep giving them raises and keep them on staff. If your company isn't savvy enough to do that then that's just another reality you're going to have to face. Reality can sure suck, can't it?

Once you eliminate the impossible, to paraphrase Sherlock Holmes, what's left are your real-life choices. I have a feeling I'm about twice your age, and in my experience people like this guy can turn into real personnel problems when they creep up on middle age and it dawns on them that they can't reprogram the universe to recognize and reward their supreme magnificence.

He may seem like an invaluable member of your time at the moment, but if he refuses to grow up then he'll grow in some other much less likeable direction. Letting him go and become somebody else's problem might end up being your best choice in the long run.

by amcol

I'm going to take a contrarian view on this one, based on all the previous responses. I think you should promote him to a management position, and I think you (and everyone else) have misidentified the problem.

There's a huge difference between management and leadership. This guy strikes me as having authority related issues, which means he's probably a lousy leader. He fails miserably in a group setting because he's intimidated at being a member of a group. OK, fine...but how is he one on one?

If he's the same way when dealing with people one at a time, then you do indeed have someone who can't be promoted at all. Based on your description of the situation I'd be willing to bet he does pretty well in a one on one situation, which is one of the critical skills for an entry level manager.

Test the waters. Before you give him a promotion give him overall responsibility for a discreet project and assign him a single resource. Make it clear that the reporting relationship is dotted line, that he's responsible for his resource's work assignments but not for administration. He has no hire/fire authority, but he is expected to write and deliver his resource's performance review.

Then sit back and see what happens. Don't be entirely disengaged, of course, but resist the urge to step in the moment things go a little south. Let him work it out on his own, only getting involved if things are going completely to hell.

I've got a nickel that says he'll thrive under the challenge and learn something about himself in the process. As you watch him grow and become more emotionally mature and sure of himself you can officially promote him and change the reporting relationship to solid line, adding more resources one at a time very carefully and very slowly so as not to overwhelm him. You may have a diamond in the rough here, and the only way you'll know that is to spend some time and energy polishing him.

Of course, if what you really have is just some iron pyrite you haven't lost anything by trying.

by jaqui

you are suggesting he be made project lead.
head the team developing a project.

that would be my own recommendation.
a small team, of decently qualified people, each doing well in different aspects. let him make all the decisions about task assignments, scheduleing, reviews etc.

if he does well, give him a larger project.

if still does well, two small projects at same time.

at that point you know if he has what it takes to actually be a full manager, or if project lead is where he is best suited.

but, definately, never just promote to level of incompetence. that is nothing but trouble.

by too old for it

Just wondering what your view is of parallel tracks? One that heads off into management (sales, business facing, etc) and one that is purely technical (keeps the servers, LAN, WAN, NOC, backbone etc up ... but the office is the last door on the left, out of the way).

Kinda like the technical rates in the navy. You become the acknowledged expert at say fire control, you don't ever get to the Pentagon, but you still get paid the same.

by amcol

I was out of the country for a while, and things in the office have gotten very busy, so I haven't had too many opportunities to participate in discussions. Thanks for the thought.

I think parallel tracks are a great idea under the right set of circumstances. Early in my own career I was working in the consulting arm of a Fortune 500 financial services company and had the opportunity to spend a couple of years in sales. I was so good at it that it's lucky I was allowed to return to my technical roots, but that's another story. Actually, it did turn out to be my ticket into management...the technical skills and knowledge coupled with the sales experience made me a candidate for a technical management spot, and things went on from there.

In this particular case I'm not sure it's appropriate, however, at least not just yet. The employee in question seems to have some baggage to deal with, and putting him in another department having nothing to do with IT might be the worst thing for him. I base that assessment on the fact that the baggage seems to have a lot to do with interpersonal communication issues. The best chance this person has to improve and overcome his limitations is with his current manager, who knows him best...and seems to care what happens to him, more to the point.

After a year or two of success at addressing his underlying issues then, yes, I think it would be a great idea to move him around and get him some other more varied experience. It's a great career management technique for anyone.

by oneshotstop

The problem with the parallel tracks is that they are not parallel. The technical side rarely matches the pay scale of the management side. Yes, it is a much better place for the no social skills tech geek (myself included), but the rewards are not as rich.

by diana o

Why oh why does everyone assume that management skill is somehow just "inborn"? Yes, being an extrovert or an introvert is, but not being a manager. I have worked with and for more people who are managers, and behave inappropriately in their role (can you say "gossip about her/his employees to everyone else in the department" and "speculate on who's getting laid off in the middle of the floor in a loud voice"?).

Anyone who manages people needs management training to start and at regular intervals thereafter. And it's not just about people skills, there are laws that have to be followed (state and federal) when you supervise others.

My management training gave me lots of confidence because I knew what to do in most situations, and where to go for help when I didn't.

Get the guy some training. Ask him to read some things (such as Emotional Intelligence in the Workplace), and walk through some better ways to handle things without being critical. (My boss says, "That was good, but let's try to improve on it. What could you do next time?"

Of course, not everyone is cut out to manage others. If that is the case, and he doesn't want to do it, see if you can get HR to add a "grade" or senior version of his current position so he has a career path and a target to shoot for for more money and responsibility.

Good luck, and I hope he realizes what a good mentor you are!!

Diana O

by bfilmfan

Is there any chance this person suffers from Asperger Syndrome, which is a form of autism?

Individuals with AS can exhibit a variety of characteristics and the disorder can range from mild to severe. Persons with AS show marked deficiencies in social skills, have difficulties with transitions or changes and prefer sameness. They often have obsessive routines and may be preoccupied with a particular subject of interest. They have a great deal of difficulty reading nonverbal cues (body language) and very often the individual with AS has difficulty determining proper body space. Often overly sensitive to sounds, tastes, smells, and sights, the person with AS may prefer soft clothing, certain foods, and be bothered by sounds or lights no one else seems to hear or see. It's important to remember that the person with AS perceives the world very differently. Therefore, many behaviors that seem odd or unusual are due to those neurological differences and not the result of intentional rudeness or bad behavior, and most certainly not the result of "improper parenting".

By definition, those with AS have a normal IQ and many individuals (although not all), exhibit exceptional skill or talent in a specific area. Because of their high degree of functionality and their naivet?, those with AS are often viewed as eccentric or odd and can easily become victims of teasing and bullying. While language development seems, on the surface, normal, individuals with AS often have deficits in pragmatics and prosody. Vocabularies may be extraordinarily rich and some children sound like "little professors." However, persons with AS can be extremely literal and have difficulty using language in a social context.

I have worked with at least 3 individuals over the years, which have this disorder and the person you are describing certainly has some of the symptoms.

by edf_pa

Looks exactly like Asperger's. I am a parent to an AS child, fitting the above description almost perfectly. The differences in these people are subtle until they are thrust into a "spotlight" situation.
I also work with someone who fits the description of AS, but I don't know whether he's ever been diagnosed. He's advanced through IT, to the point where he is now the DBA. Although he has no directs below him, there are many dotted lines from him in this particular role. We've brought him along carefuuly, encouraging him to present in group settings, at first in small groups of people he is comfortable with, then growing the audience through time.
Soemthing off-the-wall that might be worth trying - if he is diagnosed with an Autistic Spectrum Disorder, which includes Asperger's, HR may view him differently and may make exception for him. Mention the Disabilities Act and you may get their attention.
Good luck.

by tyr67360

I have a son who exhibited many peculiar behaviors -
rudeness, thoughtlessness, obsession with minute
details (legos, computers, fantasy games/worlds). A
psychologist friend suggested he might have AS. I read
a few books and studied my son for two years and have
concluded he does. Funny thing though - as I was
learning about this I began to realize two of the three
employees I supervise align with these symptoms. You
mentioned that you have supervised three persons with
Asperger. It appears to me that the field of technology is
a perfect fit for those who devour and retain mundane
facts. Of the two employees I have one (webmaster)
prefers to avoid people and interaction with others. He
likes all the information given to him (spoon fed) and he
will take it from there. The other (direct Macintosh
support) is by nature required to interface. He just
wants to work with problems and equipment but finds
the best clues are usually given by the people so he is
forced to "deal with it". My Mac guy is in very much the
same perdicament as the subject of this thread.

Here is how I handle it. We have come to agree that his
people skills are lacking and in need of refinement. But
he also agrees that he has to work with people to be
effective in his role. I minimize the interruptions and
interactions by a in-house developed Help Desk. This
allows me to handle the difficult people cases,
circumvents the anger brought on by interruptions to
the task at hand and keeps some personallity and
emotion out of the communication. In addition I have
helped him to see and understand that he is great at
techincal support and expressed the reallity that he
may never be suited to a supervisory position. He has
accepted this. Now the real problem is that he wants to
move forward in the company too ( especially
financially). It has been my responsibility to raise the
percieved value of his giftedness so I can give him
financial rewards that keep him happy and employed.
The trick is in teaching HR the added value of these
people who are cream of the crop technically.
Fortunately this is not too diffiicult. Because he is
continually learning and pursuing deeper knowledge
he is at the same time become more and more
valuable. This causes me to re-evaluate his Job
Description more often than you would normally. At
each new realm of responsibility I begin gnawing away
at my boss and our HR department to recognize the
value of these new skills and repsonsibilities. I also
have the "what if he leaves" which works well in this
situation since his skills are so specialized and he is
the only one (besides myself) who can get us out of
trouble in a deadline intense environment.

To summarize: you may not ever (with good conscience
) be able to recommend your employee for a
supervisory position. However, remember people skills
are just that skills and they can be learned. So if you
have someone who is teachable you may be able to
work with them. If you do not have someone who can/
will learn people skills you need a come to Jesus
meeting where you tell them the truth about what their
prospect of management is. Of course you could shelter
them by giving them more things to manage and less
people interaction. In any case as their supervisor you
need to tell them the "truth in love". Commit to them to
help them grow if they are willing to do the work. If they
are not willing to do the hard job - change - then
explain that is why they are limited in their ability to
grow in the company.

by rrgilmore_2001

IT sounds like you are not reinforcing the good with the bad.... In other words say something when he does something good not only when it is bad.... How old is this guy? young under 25? I think you have to not care how he reacts when you get on his case. Just let him have it... I would call him to my office tell him we have to talk and you are going to listen.... Hell either get the point or he won't and if that is the case he still needs to grow up and that is that..

by robroynj

there are currently three levels for non-management IT in my company and he has received 2 promotions in 2 years and cannot move up formally. He's received great reviews and deserved them. He knows he's good and he knows he's appreciated. In fact, I sometimes wish he wasn't so secure with his current position but he is central to all sorts of major projects and is the resource of last resort for many other people in the department.

He is in his late 20's and was one of those guys that was doing consulting all the way through college so he has lots of hands on experience. He worked with a start-up that went belly up before coming to my company. I suspect but don't know that he made a good bit of $$ as the bubble was inflating.

You're point is a good one. I'm best as a manager with people that are more receptive to coaching. I don't like to ride employees and this might be a time where I need to do just that. He's very enchanted with becoming a manager and I won't promote him simply to keep him.

Thanks to everyone that has offered suggestions. Very helpful for the new ideas and the reinforcement.

by wayne m.

I may be reading between the lines too much, but I would suggest the underlying problem is with the remaining staff. Why have you let a single individual become "central to all sorts of major projects and is the resource of last resort for many other people in the department"?

How does the referenced employee relate to his peers? If his interactions in meetings are an indication, he may be well intimidating the others and keeping them down so that he can shine. The first order of business is to get him to hand over responsibility for some of his current tasks to his peers. Pick one task and one team member to take over. Meet individually with both and brief them separately, then have a kickoff meeting with both. Get updates on progress during weekly staff meetings. If the individual is not able to train and turnover a task to a peer, he will be unable to delegate as a manager.

I assume your staff has weekly staff meetings. You need to maintain control of the meeting. If the individual is quiet (common among technical staff), ask for his recommendations. If he makes inappropriate jokes or comments, immediately cut him off and state publicly that you find the comment inappropriate or offensive, don't wait until after the meeting, do it immediately.

You may want to recommend Toastmasters (find them on the web) to the individual. The dues are cheap, but the set up is pretty much learn by doing. He should at least learn some meeting etiquette, though some people find their rah-rah nature a little bit grating.

Focus on the remainder of your staff. Let the individual in question know you are looking at staff improvement and ask for his help. Only after this person shows some ability to work with his peers should you consider any additional promotion to management or a newly defined track. If he is unable to work well with his peers, you need to slowly ease him out of key roles.

by cuteelf

You and he have both discussed him promoting?

From what I read:
You think he's farking smart as a tack
He sucks with humans
He can kick A$$ with computers and troubleshooting

Does he want to be promoted for money reasons or for status? Or for going further up the food chain?

Because those are the 3 biggest reasons to be moving somewhere. And for what you're saying, he does not really need the $ *he gets it from you already*, he has tenure/ big fish status.

So have you really asked him what he wants? HIS goals in life? I mean ...really ask him.

You can do a goal setting promotion by saying: here, this is the deal.
You go take these classes, I'll give you smore responsiblity..and once a month we'll meet about you and work. In 6 months, I'll take a look @ if you're worth putting up into a different dept. or role.

Try that too.

If this person wants to change his role, he'll have to change behaviour. Big time.

I am horrid with people, and I'd much rather deal with cable and pc's and crappy keyboards than whiney users and people who demand to have it fixed five minutes ago ...gah.

You might not be able to promote him: it may be better to keep him as a tech, but up the pay. Fight for him if he wants that- he may be worth it.

Good luck,

CuteElf

by mygetbiz

Maybe find a weekend social skills program, start with the local universities.

Your employee seems to be a male about the age of 25 who has graduated with a gps of 3.4 or higher.

Odds are he spent much time in the books with little socializing.

He may spend too much of his time as an adult with tech toys over really socializing with adults.

A weekend social skills program that evolves study as well as pratice sounds in order.

Perhaps a communications courses and hiking combo. He seem to need communications skills and it has to be fun to keep his mind from wandering elsewhere.

by surflover

RobRoy,
I have had to deal with this several times, and the result was the same each time... The last company I worked for the previous CIO had to fire the Dir. of Engineering, and promoted the "star" engineer into this role (probably had a lot to do with his demise :-))... He was without doubt, the worst manager I have ever met... I attempted to reclassify him as a "principal engineer", but he was long time freinds with the CEO (had been with company a long time) and went over my head to keep the management job... the CEO backed him (1 of the many reasons I left) and they're still having unbelieveable problems with the engineering group... about 15 years ago I had made the mistake myself, and as one of the other posts said, I lost my best technitian, gained a crummy manager, and eventually lost some of his staff due to his incompetance, and eventually had to fire him...

I'd reccomend creating somthing like a principal tech job if you can pull it off...

by eric.p

I think all the posts I've read about somehow getting this guy into management are on the wrong track. This guy is a perfect fit for the "principal tech" type of position, which doesn't involve management, but includes enough reward to keep him in your company. The problem is with HR departments, who generally are not capable of understanding the advantages of such an approach. To them people are just people and you fit them into boxes based on tenure and their resume skill set. Every company should have room for such "brilliant" people without forcing them into management. The idea that someone can only provide maximum value to the company by managing other people is ridiculous. Microsoft has many people who are making a lot of money because of their technical expertise and ability to produce, who don't manage anyone. Some of these people are really strange and they kind of have to lock them off by themselves either because they rarely bathe, or they're just otherwise offensive to other human beings. They recognize the value of these individuals just the way they are and don't try and mold them into something they aren't. From a purely business perspective this is a really smart move in my judgement.

My employer allows me to work at home most of the time because of my difficulty coming into the office because of my health. While I do have management capabilities, and have managed in the past, my health won't allow it right now and my manager recognizes that and cuts me a lot of slack in return for the ability for him to give me all kinds of specialized tasks and count on me getting them done in a quality and timely manner. They also pay me quite well, and all this together makes me loath to seriously consider the outside offers that come along quite regularly.

by alan.duncan

I know this is an uncommon and usually not a possible approach, but one way to test the waters to see if this guy has management potential is to take the whole team out for a non business related team building exercise.

I've only really dealt with this kind of thing when i was in the military, but it always seemed to have a fairly major impact on someones natural leadership skills.

Aside from that, it allows your team to gel on a more personal level, allowing them to be more comfortable with each other, allowing them to be more productive in the long run.

Doing something like paintballing for example and putting the guy in charge of the other team is a good way to test him. Especially as field tactics aren't all that different from running a business (the same sort of decisions need to be made, but just in a different arena. i.e. you still need to be able to assess each persons strengths and put them in a position where they can put them to the greatest benefit of the team.).

If it isn't possible for the company to do this, see if the team members will be willing to go and do it in their own time (at their own expense obviously).

That might be one way to let the guy come out of his shell.

by hozcanhan

People of this sort ( your employee ) usually end up in a pit hole , because of their tongue. Sometimes for not using at the right time and sometimes for using it to sting others. The profile you draw points at an intelligent being . One way to put such a figure into an order of line is to show him video , give him books/documents and/or send him in person to a course where they teach the art of being a manager. Yes , you need to educate him in this respect as well. And don't forget to offer everything from your pocket . Challenge him : " if you are intelligent enough , you agree to train yourself and pass this rudimentary managerial course ..etc " . If he is a type to ever succeed he will take . Otherwise , no one can save him.

by jamesbr

Making this person a manager would be a huge mistake right now - even with a small team. A manager relies on totally different skills that the technical skills you've described for this employee - rapport-building, leadership, coaching, etc. Usually, the basic needs of high performers like this are 1) recognition, and 2) challenge. He may be pushing for a management role or more money because he sees it as a path to more visibility or recognition of his abilities. But, from what you've described, this would take him away from an area where he is excellent and put him into a role for which he is not at all suitable. I agree with previous posts that you need to find him a challenging, difficult, well-contained project where he can solve some difficult problems. Then, it's your responsibility to see that he gets the recognition for it throughout the company.

by too old for it

You remind me of the consulting bit I did at a major truck manufacturer.

As a management trainee, you spent some time in every department, niche, nook and cranny of the place. Now, rarely did you actually DO work, due to the union contracts, but if you gained the respect of the line workers (or maintenance, or whatever) they would let you watch real closly, and maybe put a hand to it yourself.

(When I or a management trainee did "work", we had to make sure that a union employee was on the clock, but idle at the time ... hands in the pockets idle. Sometimes we had to call an "extra" over, just to make sure we had someone who was idle, so we couldn't be accused of taking "work" away from a represented employee.)

by too old for it

... of what to do with qualified people who are much better at fitting their mark and doing their assignments than interfacing with the business side, or moving into management and having MORE! BIG!! MEASUREABLE!!! ACHIEVEMENTS!!!!

You keep them wehre they perform the best .. and pay them commensurate witht he guys in the other tracks.

That was simple.

Much simpler than promoting them out of thier realm then having to "demote" them back to the
duties for which they have repeatedly demonstrated unswerving ability. (yeah, a Star Trek moment ...)

by kris.palmer

As a manager and supervisor, my advice is to be up front with him. Tell him like it is otherwise either his career will never take off, or should he by some means get a supervisory/manager position he will probably get fired. He may not want to supervise/manage, so you need to establish that first. Quite honestly, if a person has a lack of social skills they will not move up the chain. Offer to send him to training on this topic. He has to want to do it and he needs to understand that his behavior is unacceptable for progression. I had a boss tell me one time - that he would prefer someone less skilled to administer his network than someone with top notch skills who can't work with people. The position I have currently - the guy before was exactly like that and he lasted 3 weeks!! That is the bottom line for your employee!

by mygetbiz

He knows that management envolves interaction with others, keeping the peace to get the work done. Delegate to the wrong on, problems occur because of skills or drama.

I would promote the person that is competent in tech skills and people skills.

Morale goes down as well as production in environments to too much drama.

The drama builds because the manager doesn't have a grasp on his people.

A bad manager creates drama, people actually refusing to work better because the boss upsets them. Most can understand if they do not get want they won't based on something logical and fair, a manager without social skills will lack fairness in the eys of his subordinates.

I believe when people truly understand the tasks at hand and where they fit in, most will make fair decisions about what they can and can not have.

Human behavior course are still electives at Universities instead of core. It should be core because ot's so important to understand different behaviors, the roots of them and how to more effectively communication what you need done with the different personalities.

Management/Marketing courses are full of behavioral science, IT courses are not. IT needs to have behavioral sciences enlaced in the ciriculum, more so than less.

OH, you're management style that you have rvealed makes me wish I had you as a boss.

by dmwoodcock

What is a manager? Are they born that way? When new technology and new inventions develop, do you think it was on the inventors mind that he wanted to immediately find someone to manage the invention? Can a comapny run and be successful without manager's? We have got so caught up in the everything has to be nice and if you don't fit the corporate mold, then hit the streets. I guess that is why we are seeing such a flux in CIO/CTO/COO etc...You have idea people, you have doers, you have structured people, you have adhoc people, and guess what, you need them all.
Your boss that told you he would prefer someone less skilled needs some real life events to show him why just a smile sometimes just don't get the systems back up.

by eldane

At the begining of my career, I was in this very situation from the other side. I had watched as others around me were given pay rises and advancement but I remained static. I raised this with my manager who told me a very similar story to the one you describe: "technically sound but interpersonally challenged"

To cut a long story short, I asked "how do I fix this" he helped me get those skills that I was lacking and along the way I relaised that making a career in IT is about more than playing with really cool stuff, but about working with people. I have never looked back.

I am still grateful to that manager for telling me the truth and helping me become the IT professional I am today.

No surprises then, that my advice is to be honest with this person and help them make it work. Mentoring is a good method and one I have used successfully myself to develop young engineers.

by fgarvin

You will be lucky if you can keep the guy around in the capacity he is already in. The problem is with this line from your post:

In group settings the guy is a train wreck. He will either shrink quietly into a corner and defer to anyone else in the room or he will annoyingly finish everyone's sentances, make really bad (sometimes offensive) jokes, etc.

In today's workplace, someone who routinely tells offensive jokes is going to get fired the first time someone complains to upper management. If they don't take that action, they are openeing themselves up to a lawsuit for having a hostile work environment if not a Sexual harrasment lawsuit (Depending on the content of the offensive jokes). Companies are routinely brouht into court by employees even for offensive behavior that most would not consider offensive. It only take one person. Given time, that will happen eventually.

by byronvn

Sitting in the same position as employee, I've been told that I lack the ability to communicate with others from non-technical / networking background.
I work for a subdivision of a retailer in the IT Division.
My quetsion is this. Does your employee have difficulty speaking to techies or non-techies?
If he has an issue with non-techies, I suggest those non-techies rtfm.
I would address the offensive jokes thing though.

by edeldoug

This guy sounds like a classic adult with Asperger's Syndrome... which is on the Autism spectrum. Very high functioning and intelligent, very focused on a single field of expertise, having social ineptness and sensitivity are all characteristic. My best advice is to google the syndrome (just look for "ASPERGERS") and learn a bit about it... then respond to what you learn. EXCELLENT book recommendation: "Right Address, Wrong Planet" about parenting a now-adult with the syndrome.

by mygetbiz

Maybe find a weekend social skills program, start with the local universities.

Your employee seems to be a male about the age of 25 who has graduated with a gps of 3.4 or higher.

Odds are he spent much time in the books with little socializing.

He may spend too much of his time as an adult with tech toys over really socializing with adults.

A weekend social skills program that evolves study as well as pratice sounds in order.

Perhaps a communications courses and hiking combo. He seem to need communications skills and it has to be fun to keep his mind from wandering elsewhere.

by autumn_leaves

ADHD -- somewhat similar -- I work with some ADD employees, and they are like that. HR would probably help coach you on how to approach the topic. Ours suggested that that you can either request or require thay be checked out by a doctor to have approval for working if it affects performance, which it sounds like it does.

by bizzo

If you had an employee who was a brilliant "people person" and could manage everyone at any level but wasn't at all technically minded, and they expressed a desire to become part of a technical team, would you let them just because you needed more technical people?

Probably not, because they're not suited to the position, and they'd lose respect from their colleagues.

Like most people, in the past I've had some dire managers who were technically brilliant a few years ago, before they became management. But as managers, frankly, they sucked. But they had to become managers to get a promotion.

I think it would be a really bad move to make this person a manager. Aside from the inter-personal skills, would he be bored with the management role? Would he actually be able to let go of his technical role and manage people full time? Would he get sidetracked or frustrated when his team have technical problems?

One thing you could try doing is making him a technical team leader, which would involve, not managing the people as such, but managing the tasks they do which will also allow him to keep the technical part of his role and become a sort of mentor to the rest of the team.

by nemesis"t"warlock

Many of the responses here have focussed on training him or mentoring him into this new kind of role. Problem is that from what you say he has never shown any sign of having the capability to perform these new responsibilities.

It is often possible for people to change but generally it is combination of factors the vast majority of which are out of your control such as age, life experience, and external social factors.

Be honest with yourself. Have you seen any sign that he could do what he needs to do to be promoted into the positions that are available? At any point has he stepped up and done something well? Have you ever really put him in the position where you will find out if he has the ability or have you watched and hoped he will distinguish himself from the crowd? I hope there is at least one or two good examples.

If you are at the point where he is pushing for promotion and a raise but you have not already addressed his shortcomings then you have probably left it too late. The key is to identify your stars early on and coach them from the beginning to fit a future role. Miss this critical point and you might as well resign yourself to losing him.

If you haven't done this then try it. You have attempted to speak to him to address his shortcomings but he has been defensive and oversensitive. Did you approach them head on or did you let him identify his own weaknesses? As another post says, the willingness to change is critical in getting someone to change and therefore it is important to have the person acknowledge that the weakness exists.

Sit him down and give him the simple instruction that he is to document what he sees as his personal barriers to getting to where he wants to be. Alongside this he should also identify what he sees as the possible actions for him to take to address these issues and most importantly over what timescale he thinks this should happen. Hopefully he will be honest enough with himself (and remember your past discussions) to identify at least the key items, and by listing what he should do he may buy into the change itself. Committing himself to a timescale will show you if he also has Realistic Time Perspective. Don't forget to allow him to focus on the positive too; let him list the good aspects of his personality that will match future roles but still work on how to accentuate these positives further.

If he does well here then you have a chance to do the gradual work needed to improve him. If not then you know you need to work on the rest of your team to avoid the potential impact of the loss of a good tech.

by wblackwell

First off is to get him to recognize not only his skills but his weaknesses as well. You also need to see if this is just a part of his personality as it will revert even if he makes changes to achieve his goal of moving up. Ask him directly if he knows that he is shooting himself in the foot by these offensive manners, his reaction to you should show what type of control he can exhibit.

by tcampbell

How would his peers respond to your promoting him? I suspect they may be offended at the thought and it might cause more problems.

by sborder

Try showing him ways to be diplomatic. Explain to him that he must think before he speaks and always think about how what he is about to say will affect the person he is saying it to. Let's face it; we're not in our positions because we are great sales men or business men. We're here becaue we know how to manipulate software, hardware, or any electrical devices.
When I first started at my current company I didn't send out the best emails. I didn't know how to be diplomatic. Instead of saying something like, "Let's help each other and get this issue resolved!" It was more like an order. "See that it doesn't happen again!" I had to focus on how my emials were being read. I didn't mean for them to sound aggresive and mean, even bossy. I was just trying to get the attention of my team. I learned to read each email before I sent it and made sure that if I were reading it from some one else, I didn't have a bad taste in my mouth afterward.
Just explain to the guy that he is a bit unbalanced when it comes to his actions and your trying to get him a promotion, but it isn't going to happen if he keeps making remarks about the chesty blond that signs his checks...

by wdoliver

First, it disturbs me he makes offensive jokes. You need to call him down on that now. This behavior definitely should not be happening within a work environment.

IRT not letting people finish their sentences this is not unusal for a person who is passionate about the subject being discussed. This is one of my problems I am constantly working on and have people around me letting me know if I start the behavior again. He probably does not even realize he is doing it. Bring it to his attention and provide suggestions to try and be more aware of what he is doing.

Being a social person does help one advance faster, but one can still advance without socializing. People skills is another matter. If he cannot communicate and collaborate effectively with others then he will never be more than a Subject Matter Expert.

People like the individual you described are needed in an organization. You promote them into management or leadership and there is no desire he will leave. Give him a choice change or get fired he will start looking for another employer and you will have just provided your competition with a valuable asset that your company has invested a lot of time and money refining skill and experience base.

Many organizations are now recognizing a top technologist does not necessarily make a good manager or leader. In recognition of this they establish two career paths. One for the technologist who specializes in a skill area and the other for individuals that desire to go into management. They allow individuals to change career paths if they change their goals.

There is a place for people who work well in teams and those who work well alone. There are some people who do not desire to lead nor manage. They just want to be left alone to accomplish their responsibilities and have enough lattitude to have a say in how they are accomplished.

It sounds like this employee does not desire to manage, but desires more responsibilities. I would assign a new hire or a person with a lot less experience and skills for him to mentor. Keep abreast on how the mentoring is progressing and make suggestions in approaches or behavior that will improve his ability to lead.

You might have him attend or take a CBT course on effective communication, leadership, etc... Your company should be doing this regularly for their employees anyway.

by cb0503

I'll confess I haven't read all the replies to this. In the last couple of businesses I have worked for we have had a set of skills and competencies which each role is described by. The level of skill or competency varies by role, and by person. So the role may require someone to be "full operational" in a particular skills but as it is a role they are developing in, they may only have "basic awareness". This is then one of their development needs, because of the gap between role need and person practice.

Can you approach this issue by looking (and discussing - as par of a coaching programme) the competencies (as opposed to technical or professional skills) he would need to exhibit as a "manager" rather than the role he has now.

Then you can say that he needs to show evidence of these competencies at a certain level before he would be considered for such a role. (Not necessarily at the full level required for the role, but a long way towards it).

by rocjoe71

He's probably feeling very uncomfortable, maybe threatened in groups, hence the aggression (shyness/rude jokes). Pair him off with one of your other employees, prefereably one of your more popular employees, to do a collaborative project (like authoring some specs for a bigger project or produce some productivity tool for the rest of the team).

Explain it to the brilliant one that the other fellow needs his help and that it would look very good on him if he was seen helping other people in the office raise their game.

Explain it to the friendly one that they've got a good opportunity to learn and produce something bigger/better than they have yet done on their own.

It would be good if they can sit nearby to each other to foster more opportunities to talk, adjacent cubicles/desks.

It's not going to happen overnight but as this guy develops one-on-one relationships this way, he'll feel less threatened in groups when he's got an ally or two in the group.

by 50kilroy

Hello,

I would suggest that you ask your brilliant staff member if he wants to be a manager. I have been avoiding management positions for years for some of the reasons that you quote in your post.
Management is not, and will never be, the only path of advancement that is best for all. Some of us do not _want_ to be managers.

Please keep that in mind.

by beoweolf

We need more tech, that actually "know" something...and to reward them for being good at what they do, instead of trying to push a square peg in a round hole!

This problem was very big in the military for years. They resolved it by creating another..."non-Leadership" role. Thus the "Specialist" and "Warrant Officer" classification was born.

The point is....despite the very American dogma that you can be anything you want to be; some people just aren't leadership material or social or even very nice. So your effort to create a "special position" for your "Special person" is the way to handle this situation. You would do yourself and him a big favor by keeping him in the trenches, where his skills are best suited than in trying to make him over into some kind of "silk purse". This is not an issue like a person having bad hygine or failing to "dress for sucess". Many people in IT gravitate to it because they already know they are lacking in people skills...we make reasonable accomodations for the disabled, lack of social skills could be a marker for any number of clinical conditions for ADD/ADHD, Asbergers syndrome, functional Autism or any of a number other "high functioning" mental disorders.

I am not a big fan of inventing a disease to fit a lack of social skills, but in this country you need some validation before people will accept the facts as they are instead trying to "fix" people.

As far as his input at meetings and possible glib responses to questions or in voicing his opinion; there are any number of executive training programs that you could send him to...that could make him more aware of the impression he makes on others and help him to find a balance between his shrinking personality, contracted comfort zone and his need to participate in meetings.

From my point of view, you don't so much have a problem as you are forcing a bad fit for a unique resource.

Making exceptions for his shortcoming might be the best way to handle this individual. There is nothing wrong with having a weird uncle that lives in the basement.

This might be a case of killing the goose that lays the golden egg, his value lies in what he can do, not in what you want.

by workin4$$$

You need to focus more on your career, not his. Would you like to be Director, or VP?

Next time he asks tell him that he hasn't proven himself as management material yet. He may ask why, so give him a project, to go away and come back when he knows why.

He'll react one of two ways.

1. He'll withdrawl - This is a sign of what some people call low self-esteem, but I call an acute recognition of position in society. Some people aren't cut out for senior roles. If he reisgns himself to this, he's proven it for you. If he hits this wall, you'll congratulate yourself for not taking the risk in getting him promoted.

2. He'll figure it out - This is a sign of someone who may be management material. Of course, he still has to prove that he's capable of acheiving those things that are management qualities.

The long and short of it is;

The only person who can change an employee's attitude and focus is them. If you spend too much time stressing about it, you'll detract from what you really have to do. Get promoted.

Hope it's helped...

by robroynj

First, thanks again to all for their thoughts.

I've been doing this a long time. I do pretty well and my job is to make this organization work. Until recently, IT was a very big internal organization. Now, I lead a team that supports only our R&D division. The rest of IT now works for a major consulting firm and we have IT for hire. My team has about 25 people and manages a very large infrastructure for the scientists and others. It is intersting work and I like it but it is much less stressful than my previous job.

I've seen situations like this come in the past and I've always let the person leave the company and I'm sick of this. Also, this guy is an amazing talent and I'd like to see his career grow. This is an old, big organization that has been a very good place to work but is not known for its flexibility. I worked hard to get this guy to stay with me and I don't want to lose him.

Again, thanks for all of the responses.

by angry_white_male

Don't let this guy hold you hostage. If he's not leadership material - you will take the heat for his failures.

No one wants to see good talent walk out the door - but if the next step he's aspiring to isn't a good mutual fit for both the employee, the team and the company, don't try to force a square peg into a round hole. You'll have more headaches trying to backtrack and clean up the mess, than you will trying to find a replacement when he walks out the door.

Speaking of which, if he's already hinted that he's looking to make more $$$ and move up the ladder, odds are he's quietly looking for another job anyway.

It's clear you have your doubts about this guy's ability in a leadership role, otherwise you wouldn't have come here to ask for our advice.

You need to do what's best for the team - and not for the individual.

by diana o

You sound just like the kind of supervisor I like to have, interested in coaching and developing their employees!

Good for you! "Riding" is for horses, not people :-D Those comments just highlight that some people who really need management training don't get it. And then they wonder why they have so much turnover.

by tomaaa19

You may be dealing with the archtypical geek, talk to him one on one and see if he wants to move into management, then discuss the path he wishes and some possible courses to take, EG: public speaking etc.

Let him know that you want him to grow and thrive in the company. And remember critisize the behaviour not the person.

TTFN

by jocelyn.boyer

Well, you need to help the one who is living in its own world. He likes tech task. Meeting seem to be boring situation and a must to do. In fact is uncomfortable in group. With the help of HR to seek for ways to help him to trust other in group and value of respect in the meeting process is the key.
Personally I will meet with him to identify what he like most, see what his feeling with meeting is and see also around his level of communication with the client its serves. This will be an indicator of the status of his social communication. Maybe it is only group or everyone (he is solitaire). This may come from the time he study where competition for mark where high and he want to preserve his knowledge. Maybe he feel meeting are futile compare to the tasks to be done.
Once you know where he stands (emotionally) about meeting and group work you be able to task him with trainee or coop student to help him to communicate its knowledge. In US you are extremely focus on performance as job done, and less in client satisfaction (needing to talk to your client). Your client is only $$$$$ earn or spend and less seen as a co-worker or part of the benefit the company have. He may be in a mood to do his job, still ?techky? at home and living on this state of mind 24/7. If so, you will lose him soon as your tech. will not be as interesting as another Cie. So find where his stand and you will be able with HR dept. to figure out how to make him more social and respectful and interested to share.

PS.: English being my second language, please forgive my mistakes.

by mistymtn0208

Something else for you to consider: Promoting someone to a management role that does not have adequate people skills for the position may allow you to retain this particular employee, but it may cost you to loose several other employees.

We have an employee on our team that behaves similarly to what you've described; only this person is brash, loud, and controlling in both group and one-on-one settings. This person has strong technical skills though, so he's valuable to the company, and he knows it. He has the most seniority on the team, and he seems to feel that that entitles him to a more supervisory role. He's been placed in a technical lead position, but the people who were placed below him hate dealing with him. He wants the glory of being in a leadership position, but he doesn't want the actual responsibility of having to keep track of how his team members are progressing with their projects or having to deal with them when something goes wrong. As a matter of fact, he hates dealing with problems so much that he has actually designated one of his team members to be his go-between to deal with issues so he doesn't have to. This is not the behavior of a person who should be managing anything. I can guarantee that if he were actually made a manager, several team members would leave the company.

I know a lot of people on the forum have suggested training, but as others have pointed out that only works if the individual recognizes that he needs to make changes to his behavior. Our employee has been sent to "sensitivity training", but the only effect it seems to have had was to send this person crawling deeper into his shell so that he practically refuses to engage in direct communication with any staff members that he's had run-ins with in the past. The problem is, he doesn't think there's anything wrong with his behavior. He thinks the problem lies with the rest of the team; therefore, he thinks the rest of us need an attitude adjustment, not him.

Take care in promoting a highly technical person with inadequate people skills into a leadership position. Promoting one person in an effort to keep him from leaving could end up costing you much more in the long run if his staff revolts and walks out the door.

by Ramon Padilla Jr.

Rob
I am sure I am echoing many who have replied who have said not to promote this individual. The MOST important skills for a manager are people skills.
Clearly this person is a technical wizard and should be put into positions where he can succeed - which means dealing with technology not people. Putting him into a managerial position is setting him up to fail - which will make both of you miserable.

It certainly doesn't sound like this person aspires to management and you should have no fears of him landing a managerial position elsewhere given your description.

It does sound like you are concerned you may lose him due to pay. My suggestion would be to work with HR to create another grade of his current position WITHOUT including supervisory or management duties in it.

Good luck!

by blue-knight

He sounds like a good employee and it will take a little to fix. It is a vision problem. If he is willing to see that this is a area that needs work, probably he will address it on his own. A little coaching or getting him to go to toastmasters will give the polish he needs.

If he does not think he is 'broken' then he will resist and thwart most attempts to 'fix' him. The same drive and skills you value will be against you. Write a short a letter either to yourself or him. List some of his good points in paragraph one. List the problem in the second paragraph in general terms, how do I get to recognise he needs to improve in a area that he is unaware of?

If it is ignorance or he just does not value it enough, then change is easy. Once he knows it is a major goal, he will take care of it. The problem is if he rejects it, (This is the way I am and it is ok type of reaction). This is where your and his communication style and abilities determine how to proceed.

Blue

by harlemite

If he can't understand (and accept!) that with any such promotion come reponsibility and higher expectations then he shouldn't get the position. It sounds to me like he may not be mature enough for the promotion. That's not a good thing.

Some things to consider:

1) You are who you promote: Remember, this person, if promoted, becomes a reflection of YOU because YOU deemed him worthy of promotion. I imagine your boss is watching you and evaluating your decision making skills as well. Will this person be someone you'd be glad to introduce your boss to? If not...

2) He'll appreciate it... eventually: Some of the best bosses I've had are the ones who were honest with me. This doesn't mean they were tyranical in any way, but they pointed out my faults. I worked on them and became much better for it. It didn't always feel great listening to the criticism, but that was when I was young and didn't know much about life. I bet you can remember some folks who were like that.

3) Don't treat him like an idiot: If this guy's half as smart as you make him out to be and you create some position without any real management potential he's going to see right through it. You either want him to manage or you don't.

4) There will be others: NO ONE is that valuable. If they are, then you might want to have a talk with yourself about YOUR management style. And if he actually starts to believe he's that valuable he may decide to leave on his own anyway. Trust me when I say I've seen many a superstar. "Many" being the key word. They come and they go.

Just my two cents.

Good Luck!

by angry_white_male

You'll only make a bad situation even worse.

One very important trait that a good leader has is the ability to handle the brutal truth. If this person retreats back under the rock he crawled out of every time he's challenged, imagine the impact this will have when he's put into a management role. Finding someone with both good technical skills and good leadership/people skills is very hard. Doesn't sound like this guy cuts the mustard in that regard.

Make the best of his abilities in the role he's currently in. Even if he's at the top of his pay grade, try to bump him up another grade and continue to reward him with a generous paycheck. Do a salary survey - see if his pay is in-line with similar positions in your industry and geographical area.

If you put him in a management/leadership position and it blows up - you're the one who will be held responsible for it. Don't put your own career at stake. If this employee feels that he's hit the ceiling - let him take his chances on the job market. There are 100's of people out there who can run circles around him and are willing to do it for less pay.

by manny

One approach may be to require customer service training for this employee as part of the deal to take on new responsibilities. I am a strong believer of training. While we can't always change people, everyone IS capable of learning and adapting. Traits are what they are but I believe that good solid customer training can be effective to the extent that the employee is willing to use it as a vehicle of personal growth. He must also understand embrace it as a pre-requisite for his new task, or job.

In today's market, we can not effort to lack the basic skill of emotional intelligence no matter what are of IT you are involved in.

by thomas moser

The last large company I worked for recognized that the engineers and not the managers contributed the most to the bottom line.

They had a salary and position structure that reflected this awareness. When I left there I help the position of Senior Technical Consultant and had the same pay grade as a Director of Engineering. The
next step up the chain was Vice President.

My pay scale was significantly higher than the line / middle managers I worked for and was the same scale as the Department Director.

You do not have an employee problem you have an HR problem.

by rick.leonard

When I worked for a small, but rapidly growing, consulting firm we had a group of people that were very similar that we called Trolls: They could live under the bridge, but they couldn't ever, ever meet the customers!

They were essential, and although I was a pretty experienced geek, they schooled me on a pretty regular basis. But they didn't have the social skills I had, and there was no way to move them beyond the Troll stage, so we focused on finding ways to add value to the work they did, so we could bill them out for more, so we could pay more and retain them.

What we never did was try and mold them into something they weren't. When I'm hiring I make it practice not to focus on technical skills (although they have to have the minimum) since I can train anyone to do just about anything technical. What I can't do is train them to do it with a smile on their face and kind word for team members, and that's the key skill I often need.

If I need a Troll, I'll hire one and get what you've got, but I'll never try and make him something else. He won't be happy, and neither will you.

by mgfyo01

There are two kinds of positions : expert positions, you do and manager positions : you make people do.
The brilliant guy seems to be a brilliant expert. May be he will be a poor manager.
The skills an expert needs have nothing to do with the skills a manager needs.
Why should a promotion necessarily take a guy out of an expert position into a management position ?
Can't your company create two parallel stairs, one for managers and one for pure experts ? Can't you use this guy as an internal high level consultant ?

by rocksteady

Sometimes we all must realize most of the very best techs are somewhat reclusive people. Any manager with any tenure, in this forum, will attest to such. There are options. I like to give these techs project control. Your project will be done amazingly and they will get the sense of dealing with people. This is their test. Most of the time you will never hear about managing people again. Also, most of my best techs are members of TechRepublic. So, watch your step.

by workin4$$$

If you're manager material, prove it to me. I'm not, however, going to waste my companies resources trying to find something that may or may not be there.

If I know it's there, then I encourage cultivation. I reward over-performing employees with extra money/perks, etc.

Eventually, some of them leave, and some of them get promoted.

The last thing I am is a tyrant, but Employees are a necessary evil. I wish our organization could run and make money without them. It causes less headaches in the end and employee turn-over would be non-existent.

by computercoach

I have seen this problem many times in high tech positions. One company I worked for was smart enough to recognize that many highly skilled technically superior people are not management material. They had the same problem of running out of reward for individual contributors that just are not management types. Their solution was to create new positions with titles like principle engineer and consulting engineer. As far as the finacial side the were small increases in salary but the motivators were now things like performance based stock incentives, etc. If you have an open minded, enlightened management team they may consider this approach. Good Luck!

by gawiman

Very interesting thought that this person may have mild asperger syndrome. There are a whole range of neurological conditions including ADHD and Tourette's syndrome, or even petit mal epilepsy that can affect a person's social range.

Unfortunately for all our yapping about "diversity" our workplaces are not very diverse. We're not good at dealing with people who have different personalities. Our sensitive widdle feewings get hurt too easily. Makes it hard for a guy like him to get anywhere.

Tell him straight out; his technical skills and his interpersonal skills come out of different mental bank accounts - he is apparently rich in one and poor in the other. He would not be happy in a job (management) where the primary demand is on interpersonal skills and he would have less opportunity to shine technically.

Forget "Emotional Intelligence." Buy him a copy of Dale Carnegie's "How to Win Friends and Influence People". If he can come to view interpersonal skills as a technical problem he might have a strength on which to draw there.

by the admiral

You are in essence describing me! Now I have your job in my company. The thing to do is to coach him properly and not make it look like it.

by placidair

don't put this guy in a position where he's managing employees you want to keep. I've reported to a few like that over the years, and they drive the other talent right out the door.... sometimes in droves. A former employer of mine lost almost all of it's key people within days of each other, because none of us could stand to deal with him any more. There wasn't any one thing to complain to HR about, it was all the little things that made working there a living hell on a daily basis. They lost their network manager, top network engineer, DMS and desktop person and top litigation support person -- we all gave notice within 2 days of each other. Send him to classes, buy him a copy of Dale Carnegie, do whatever you want to to help bring this guy along -- but don't put him in a management position unless he changes drastically, unless you're willing to lose other staff members in the process.

by karon.rice

It's clear that your staff person is technically capable of delivering your needs. You might explain to him the requirements of good management and expanded scope of responsibilities. Companies now depend on teams to deliver and in order to be a good manager he'll need to acquire the necessary skills. Show him how interested you are in his development by requesting that he take Team Training; Interpersonal Skills; etc. Use these as some of the criteria for his next review (make sure everyone else is getting the same treatment though). Use team reviews as one of the measurements for personal success on the job. He should be aware of how everyone else views his contribution/interaction with the team. Once he sees the Team Review applied to the team as a whole, he might understand that acquiring these kinds of skills are valuable and key to his ascent in the organization. He won't feel singled out.

You may have to have ongoing discussions with him to ensure that he understands the requirements. Use every opportunity to encourage him and include the topic of team/interpersonal skill dynamics as part of the discussions.

If this doesn't work, then he is determined not to be a team player, will not develop necessary leadership skills (to be a good leader you must first learn to be a good follower/team player). One cannot avoid the requirement of good personal skills in today's organizations and his future is at risk even if he goes to other companies to work.

by gaston nusimovich

Rob,

It really seems that you are in a rather tight spot, very much like a catch-22 situation: damned if you do, danmed if you don't!.

I have a suggestion for this kind of situation, which may sound weird or even crazy, but I think that you either take a shot (a wild shot, that is), or you loose.

The problem is with this guy interacting vis-a-vis (face to face) with the team in meetings and the like, and not necessarily with his comments: his comments may be useful, even great, but cannot be uttered to the rest of the team in the face!.

So, use technology to disengage face-to-face contact (two-way communication) between this guy and the team.

Put a web-cam with sound in the meetings, with this guy in another room, taking all the comments and registering all his feedback in any way you see fit (he could even talk to you though headphones during the meetings, feeding you with comments and suggestions, and you can do the filtering).

That way, the team could have feedback from this guy without the awful moment of anybody loosing face (either him, you, or the person that is the "target" of his feedback) .

From what you describe, he is a very resourceful asset for your company to afford the luxury of loosing him over a stupid communications problem.

Many geeks have social and/or communication difficulties of various degree that appear very hard for them to resolve, and it looks like it comes with the package, so you either take the geeks as they are, or you don't take them at all.

I am not using the word "geek" lightly or with disrespect: many of these guys are wizards in various fields of expertise.

If we are to build a better society based on mutual respect for diversity, we must add and build on diversity, not divide on diversity.

Regards, Gast?n

by skip harden

I marvel at how much emphasis we place on "finesse," when clearly there is a fit for your "socially inept" employee and his talents.

I see this a great deal on my side of the business: tech sales. I had a sales and marketing ace on my team who was promotable because of her outstanding, consistent performance, but her internal selling was sorely lacking. She managed herself well, but could not manage others.

In short, you'd think a salesperson who hits consistent home runs would have excellent management and people skills (every time I write/hear that phrase I think of Tom Smykowski in "Office Space": http://www.bullshitjob.com/officespace/whatdoyoudohere.wav).

They almost never do! The two skill sets are completely different!

The question I asked HR (you probably have already), is a simple one: "Why can't we create a new position - combining ono-on-one (instead of group) training, mentoring, coaching, or whatever else will utilize her skills - instead of trying to make this well-rounded peg fit into an obviously square position?" This accomplishes two things: it makes HR your partner in the success/failure of the promotion, and challenges them to live up to the "we embrace change, creativity, diversity, blah, blah, blah..." they espouse all the time.

I'm afraid that if you move such an employee into group management, no matter how much sensitivity training they are given, they will be set to fail. That's what happened to my sales guru within six months of her promotion to VP Sales (I'm the CMO).

She now works for one of our toughest competitors...

Skip in MA

by activated

He has basic personality flaws for managing others. This NEVER gets better. Leave him in the backroom, and pay him according to his value their.

by techrepublic

Read the Peter Principle. It still applies. People will tend to rise to their level of incompetence and then remain there. There are only two things than can get you fired - 1. super-incompetence or 2. super-competence.

Your guy's talents lie in the technical field, not in managing people. Supervisory positions, while often requiring technical competence are primarily administrative and people management, totally different skill sets.

Often people will think they want a promotion because of social pressure to "succeed" by moving up the corporate ladder, which can also equate to a bigger paycheck. (Spouses are the biggest promoters, prodders and nags.) However, when they get into the administrative/supervisor position, they are no longer doing what they love to do and for which they are ideally suited. The dumbest thing a company can do is move a brilliant, competent employee from what they love to do to something that will frustrate them, and everyone around them. High turnover can result and eventually (or sooner) the brilliant, but now incompetent employee will move to another company, perhaps also triggering a divorce.

HR may not like "special deals". However, smart management recognizes a gem and creates the environment (with pay) that reflects the unique talents. Dumb management follows the Peter Principle and screws up the individual and the company.

Inspite of Hollywood scripts, you are not going to change this guy's personality. Your guy still needs social interaction to feel accepted, but will cause chaos as a supervisor. Why not ask him what types of creative projects he would like to pursue as the lead "investigator". In his opinion, what whould be the best of all worlds for him. Give him time to do some creative thinking. You might also want to emphasize the various unpleasant tasks he would have to do if he were shifted to an administrative position. And remind him that people can be such a pain in the butt. :-)

by aoglanian

If this is an employee that you want to keep and keep happy, then try giving him a small starting management opportunity contingent upon him working with an independent coach who will design a program to teach him successful management skills. Give him a time frame (12 mo) to work on the skills. One of two things will happen: he'll either be successful and loyal or he'll be unsuccessful and appreciate everything you've done for him. Hiring a coach also takes some pressure off you...

by workin4$$$

You're trying to solve someone else's problem by throwing company money at it. He will see hiring a coach as giving the salary he was intended to someone else, worse off, he'll report to him.

We need to get past the idea that the employee is only trying to good for the company. It's just not true. Employees have their own agendas. All of them. VP's, CIO's and CEO's all their own agendas too. As manager, your agenda should be 2-fold.

1. To increase shareholder value
2. By performing 1, get a promotion.

There are many ways of increasing shareholder value, but encouraging under-performing employees by throwing money at THEIR problems is not chief among them. Save corporate money for cost-saving solutions.

In short, don't reconfigure your organization to fit an employee, reconfigure your employee to fit your organization. If this doesn't work, he or she will leave, and you'll hire somebody that fits the mold better.

by wdsnead

1) Sometimes people are realy great with their skills and do not have people skills and can't seemingly develop people skills. The trik is to keep them and isolate them from the public. Something like a Senior Specialist where their need to interact with people is limited to personel in their own department.

2) I believe that the best way to offer constructive criticism is to begin with their positives and instead of the "but" word try using the "and" word. As an example:

"You have shown great knowledge and skills in improving our downtime but we need to find a way to work on your people skills."

versus

"You have shown great knowledge and skills in improving our downtime and I know that I can count on those same strengths to..."

It may sound like I am harping on a word (but vs and) but the feeling is really different. Try a sample example on a friend and see how it "feels" to them.

David

by robbin.johanson

I understand the desire to make a place for a technical guru who lacks teaming and interaction skills. With over 25 years of managing IT organizations, I have been bit a few times attempting to fit a square peg into a round hole. There is no other department within a company in which it is more important to ensure you have staff with people skills. Technical skills can be taught to bright energetic employees. Regardless of all the social skills training one can receive, the success rate is not high. Over the years, my most successful IT people have been those who possess decent technical skills but have excellent communication and interpersonal skills along with a natural understanding and empathy of customer needs.

At minimum, your employee needs to understand his strenghs and weaknesses and the role in which he can best contribute to the organization...as an idividual contributor...and not be allowed to talk to your customers without a chaperon!

by blueknight

As jharrell stated, if this is truly a good employee, it is up to you, his manager, to mentor him and "groom" him for advancement. While you're doing so, continually evaluate his progress (or lack thereof) and include your observations in his performance reviews. Watch for traits/behavior that might tell you that no matter how good this guy is "in the trenches," he won't make a decent manager -- you don't want to short him on mentoring/training, but you also don't want to waste your valuable time after a point if it won't pay off in the future. Also, be up front with the employee... tell him honestly, that you think he is top notch and you'd like to help him move up. While you're at it, tactfully let him know where he needs improvement, and why - give specific examples so he has no doubt as to what you mean.

One more thing that jharrell made note of... if an upcoming meeting is yours, make sure you send out an agenda beforehand. Prior to the meeting, review the agenda with the "problematic" employee so he'll be prepared. This may help keep him from shrinking into a corner as you put it. He may also give you some additional ideas for the meeting. After your meetings, debrief with the employee so you can 1) get his feedback (which may give you insight as to why he said/did something you disliked, and 2) provide feedback to him so he knows that his participation was valuable, or that something in particular he said was off-color. I think most of us at one time or another make "shoot from the hip" comments, and most of us know where the line is that makes comments off-color or offensive. Others, like this employee, need help locating that line -- some never find it.

Best of luck to you both.

by workin4$$$

The only responisbility Managers (and this guy's a VP) have is to their shareholders.

Employees are replaceable. All of them. Management is as well.

Employees are necessary to meet company objectives and satisfy the pockets of the shareholders. Nothing more.

Employees who are management material will make themselves known, and if they are ready, they can be promoted. Some people never have the hope of becoming managers, and anyone who thinks mentoring helps is wrong in my opinion.

When I was an employee, I felt that I deserved to be a manager. I bought into the rhetoric that is pandered about how everyone can be a manager, and that my manager's responsibility is to coach me to be one.

I became a manager 3-months after I shunned this approach and decided the only way to become a manager was to not rely on my manager to manage my own psychology and career. I took into into my own hands. 1-year after making manager I made director. 5-years later, I made VP.

The only way to advance an employee is have them come to this decision of their own accord. I cannot provide petty means of motivation to all of my employees. I reward the successful ones, and discipline the unsuccessful ones.

It's the only logical way. People are a commodity in any organization. If a company could by without them, they would.

by pmoleski

I always like to think about a technical career, or any career, as a ladder. As one progresses up the ladder in terms of skills they overlap with the job above them so that by the time they move into the next job they already have proven that they can do the entry-level competencies for the job.

I will give you an example for a system developer. You can modify it for any (technical) position.

Rookie ? write electronic reports using something like SQL to learn the structure of the data
- Do very simple changes to programs like the colour of a button to learn how to use the tool set and to move things from development to test to quality and finally to production
- Learn the flow of systems in the production including the files and tables involved have the ability to start and stop things as required to ensure production continues

Junior programmer

- All of the above
- Ability to code a transaction and or module of code given a design
- Ability to fix code within a single module given the design of what it is supposed to do

Senior programmer

- All of the above
- Ability to trouble shoot complex problems across multiple modules within a major system
- Ability to write complex code independently
- Ability to write designs for modules of s system given requirements that include the data and flows between data stores

Junior analyst

- All of the above
- Ability to write a design for a whole system where you do the work from requirements
- Ability to mentor a junior employee and start them up the learning curve
- Ability to work with an end client to determine if a system is working properly as per what the business needs
- Ability to provide system designs to a junior programmer and mentor them to ensure the work is completed properly
- Ability to work directly with an end client to determine the business requirements for a small project
- Ability to manage small project consisting mainly of your own work and maybe one junior staff member to learn the basics of project management

Senior analyst
- All of the above
- Ability to project manage the efforts of everyone involved in the unit working on a large project
- Expert level problem solving skills that span production flows crossing multiple subsystems and databases
- Ability to mentor several employees including junior analysts
- Ability to fill in for the unit manager when required meeting with clients on a strategic level to discuss broadly where the business is going
- Ability to architecture complex IT solutions and work with the clients to define the business requirements for those projects

From here the career can split in many directions including Project manger, Unit/Program manager, technical specialist/DBA, etc.

The key is that for each stage the person takes on progressively more tasks from the next stage building on where they are so that when they move to the next stage they are set up for success.

In the case of the employee with strong technical skills he needs to have this ladder explained to him quite bluntly. Before promoting him he has to prove that he can take on tasks that involve the mentoring and appropriate direction of at least one other staff member. In the example above the employee slowly takes on and develops people skills mentored by people further along at each step of the progress. If your employee can work up the ladder proving that he can do the people skills then some day he may development into an analyst or manager. If he can?t develop the people side them his career is very limited. Some times companies will create what is called a technical ladder to allow an exceptional technical resource to move up to the equivalent of a senior analyst. But even in this case he is no good to the team if he can?t work with and mentor other people.

Summary ? prove you can work at the level above your job while in your current position before you get a promotion. Hopefully the above provides some incite into how you can grow any employee.

For Your Consideration
Phil

by gprinsloo

Sounds like you are happy with his technical abilities and performance.

Why not then leave him in his corner, use his skills and pay him according to his knowledge not his ability to interact.

After all, sounds like you need him as a technical person. Your problem appears to me to be, you do not pay your technical staff enough and as a manager you perhaps are not able to convince top management that they need to re-adjust their wages.

I have experienced this where companies start living a brain drain as a result of such problems.

My cents worth is, pay management to manage and technicians their fair wages. So what if a great technician earns more than his manager we are talking about technical and administrative abilities.

The guy is probably more than peed off about the money, but is happy working in a corner.

by rkerr

I don't like to recommend that people read books, but...

An excellent book that will help you to think through this discussion is Crucial Conversations by Kerry Patterson, et al. It lays out a framework to think about what you are going to say ("work on me first", which included thinking about what to address and if you need to address it, and then to master your own story with the facts and just the facts), then to actually have the conversation ("confront with safety", which includes keepng it emotionally safe, describing the gap, among others) and then what happens after the meeting ("Move to action", which includes agree on a plan and follow up).

If you don't have time for a book, they have periodic webcasts on their approach.

Excellent, excellent book that has helped me a lot.

by jonf

Tell the guy straight up that he is a valued and talented employee. Then go in honestly on what improvements need to be made with his behavior.

by jaredh

Have you ever read the book called The 5 dysfunctions of a team? It is great and may help you in your managerial struggle.

by nojacketreqd

After having read mostly the threads where you've replied - I am compelled to suggest the you (as a VP) may get hints by looking up blogs posted for CIOs.

You find this individual valuable beyond his technical skills (quote "kick butt") in your fast paced A-type company doing R&D for scientific solutions ... alternate CIO blogs suggest that a senior / executive manager may benefit from having a side-kick / 2IC for support and soundboarding - ideally mentor this talented person towards such a non-line management senior role (which you'll have to create if this works for you) ... this could be an excellent option for your succession planning ... I assume that your team of +- 25 resources contains a 3 (maybe 4) of sub-managers, they may be more suited as admin managers and may need to be teamed with a visionary to one day take your place (heaven forbid, you could be met by some misfortune like the proverbial "being run over by a bus").

An alternative / additional option is to address your role and payment structure .... Can a specialist earn as much or more than his / her manager? It ought to be possible, but some organizations don't make allowance for it and therefore encourage incorrect desires or career paths for some techies.

However, in parallel sub-managers may elect the prize assignments for themselves to stay in touch and retain technical credibility, thereby failing to grow their subordinates fairly, this could be happening to this individual unbeknown to you and could frustrate him (possibly resulting in perceived unsocial behavour and criticism from the sub-managers perhaps spawned in fear / competition of this talent) - another thing to avoid / resolve.

You may also want to analyze situations creating the most noise and where this individual becomes most engaging or disillutioned - chances are that you have some unresolved departmental focus areas needing attention (not related to this individual talent, but that actual functioning of your R&D division).

Good luck!

by ludditeatheart

In looking at the postings you have done throughout the discussion, it seems that this employee wants to be in management. If that is the case it doesn't really matter why - it is his goal. This person went to school to learn how to work in IT, why don't you suggest that he go to school to learn to manage?

Anyone who has suffered under a bad manager knows how miserable life can be, so why take the chance on promoting this person until they are ready? I think it is wonderful to help this person develop some social skills using the helpful suggestions you have received already. But it won't hurt the employee to take some management and supervision classes. It may give him some insight into other parts of business that will be helpful in the future. If we all emphasize training to keep up with current technology, why not training to be a manager?

I know many on this list disparage formal schooling as not "real-world" but this is a very smart person. He will be able to take what he learns through classes, compare it to what he sees at work and be able to develop his own managerial style that works for him. Besides, course work and degrees are popular with HR departments and can do nothing but improve his status there also.

by eff

Perhaps this kids attitude is a direct result of the attention he's already gotten for his allegedly "great" tech skills...

Managers who feel they have "lost touch" with the techie world often latch on to some younger and seemingly more tech savy employee to keep their hand in it...and they often attempt to justify this to themselves by saying they are trying to "develop" this person. Often they pick some guy who is not really a threat to actually be someone to develop, therefore they keep their resource close, without really having to fear losing him to anything except his own ego (i.e. leaving for a bigger better deal).

This symbiotic relationship between the non techie or previously techie manager and the young, aspiring techie wannabe manager is just going to become a bigger and bigger issue in business as more and more non techie's become managers (for HR\EEOC reasons) and fewer and fewer manager jobs become available for for techie manager wannabes.

by cfblmc

What you are describing is ADHD. People who have ADHD are generally extremely intelligent; however, their social skills are lacking. The issue of finishing sentences, inappropriate jokes, and personality changes are common issues with adults with ADD and ADHD. It is believed that both Thomas Edison and Albert Einstein had ADHD. Thomas Edison was kicked out of school at a young age and his mother was told basically that he'd never amount to anything. The key here is people who have ADHD have a hard time picking up on the signals in social situations (I know I have it also). They are very good at things they enjoy (they tend to become hyperfocused). The answer to this situation might be to discuss this possible problem and have it evaluated by someone who is skilled in Adult ADHD. There are medications that can greatly improve his ability to deal with the situations that you describe. I can say from my own experience that the medication gave me an ability to focus not only on what I like but also on the other things around me. It also took away the impulse control issue (that's why he interupts). Personnaly, I've been on Adderall XR for 5 years and have seen a dramatic difference in how I can handle things and also in my level of performance. You might even mention to him that ADD and ADHD have actually helped some individuals in the world of business. The gentleman who started Kinco's has ADHD (it was his wandering that actually made him see the need for copying services). ADD and ADHD are also covered under the ADA. A good site to read about Adult ADHD is: https://www.additudemag.com/selfhelp.asp
You probably have someone who is very capable of being an excellent manager if he can get help resolving the other problems. I know also that one of the other things that has helped me a great deal is finding a mentor at work who takes the time to teach me skills in which I am lacking. For instance when we were meeting with a group one time (I interrupted one of the men a few times), after the meeting my mentor took me in private and went over the problem with me and said that once before he had a guy who did that and during meetings he would sit across from him and they had a cue that he would give if he started interrupting.
The last thing is even though your employee is intelligent and capable, he most likely is aware of his faults and has some insecurity because of them. That is partially because when you have ADHD you usually can't control them on your own and it's very frustrating. Just be sensitive to those things when you talk with him about it.

by cio

Jeckel & Hyde does even begin to describe the imbalance in your situation.

If he's not repecting others, then he will eventually not respect his manager or supervisor.
He's a ticking bomb. It's not a matter of "IF" it's a matter of "WHEN".

When some event sets him off, I hope he's not quietly vindictive. Hopefully he'll give you early verbal warning.

You could always encourage personal pursuit towards company consulting. The outside angle. (Start his own business)

This relationship would mutually benefit both the company & this guy. "Money" would not be so much of an issue, HR would be somewhat out of the loop, and company rules & regs would gain leverage & authority. His self awareness could be the best thing for your company's gain.

by dcreader

It's not just about the money, either. Parallel tracks still put the techies who understand the details under the managers who understand the big picture (if only that were really possible without understanding the details).

I get the idea that people are pidgeonholed as detail-oriented, just because they can work with details. The rest of the people are automatically assigned "big picture" jobs, even though they may have no capabilities at all.

Somehow social skills are the key to getting the "big picture" in one's mind across to others. Often average managers just dumb everything down to the point where it's no longer true, just to make a paletable presentation.

There's nothing really parallel about it.

by dcreader

Can you tell me more? What would it be called? How does it work? Know of anything like that in DC?