Discussion Locked

Help managing a very brilliant employee

0 helpful
192 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

192 replies

by cio

more than ADHD....slightly Bi-polar and the list goes on....what about tramua or his childhood???? Codependency???

I'm not paid at my company for my medical and Psych certifications....but it's not rocket science...so this "GUY" -- obviousily imbalanced; whether medical or tramua related.

We can discuss all possibilities and excuses for his behavioral problems....behavorial modification is at best, temporary

The questions is.... Is the risk worth the reward?

by cfblmc

It's sad that you choose to look at ADHD as a crutch or excuse. It's obviously a real disorder as it's covered under the american with disabilities act. So what if you had an employee who had a TIA and ended up with some loss of mental capacity, would you just call them mental or crazy? I would have to question your company's diversity if they allow an attitude such as the one displayed in your email. There are a lot of illnesses and diseases which we don't understand; however, that doesn't change the fact that they exist. How would you feel if one day something happened to you and caused you to have a lose of mental capacity? Would you truely appreciate the people around you having an attitude of you're just mental?

by zentross

If it is within your ability to authorize such.
Try sending him to a training seminar
Give him a project that should take about a week or so and put two techs under him.

After completion, sit down for a Q&A. Ask him what he liked about the project. How well did the two jr's work out? Were there disagreements? How were they resolved?

By taking this approach, you're giving him a fair shot, an eye opening experience, and a realistic outlook on what needs to be done to succeed.

Be sure to drive the point home that you want him to succeed, but you'll need to be firm that he should overcome his people limitations.

By nature, I'm not a people person. 12yrs on helpdesk has made me so though and now I do more than just that. You can't go wrong to augment tech skills with arts and social skills.

by yipp

I saw the recommendation to hire a coach, and like you, I really cringed at the idea. I am not anwhere near a techy, but we all can use help in communication. I happen to be lucky enough to have a friend who is a personal coach, and it is unbelieveable how he has taught me to say the same things in a different way.....and have a very differnet impact/turn out. He also helps me to realize "why" the way I said it can be misconstrued. It is just like anything else, it may not be intuitive, but once somebody tells you what to do, it clicks. Many times reading books just doesn't do it like personal interaction with someone you respect. Respect is the key. My coach has a very disarming, non-judgemental way about him. He knows he is there to help. Some of the things my coach tells me I am doing wrong in my communication style quite frankly anger me initially, but I put my ego in check and know he is an expert so I try them, with stellar results. Don't underestimate what a good coach can do for this guy. They are expensive, though.

by theslaw

I was an engineer for 20 years, with almost no mentoring or communications training. I rarely got promotions and was good at NOT influencing people.

I left engineering and for the last 7+ years have been studying communications, relationships, the mind, and have become a coach.

Why? Because I knew I was not the only one out there.

And why coaching? Because weekend seminars without ongoing support create almost no change in thinking, behaviors and results. People need ongoing effective support if they are going to make significant behavioral/lifestyle changes.

So, now I work with those who suffer like I did.

And as for the cost, only get a coach if you see the benefit to your company as greater than the cost. Otherwise, it's not worth it.

So, check out some coaches and see if ones a fit. It may work.

steve-cole.com

by eric.p

Maybe the reason your most successful IT people have been those with people skills is because you either have not had one of these brilliant people come along, or if you have, you didn't manage them correctly. I'm not suggesting that all such people will work out, but if their talents are recognized and the environment properly shaped to allow them to excel, they can way out-perform a lot of those people with better interpersonal skills. Again, I'm not saying this is always the answer, and not always possible, but I believe it's something worth giving serious thought to if you are privileged to have one of these unique souls come your way.

by robbin.johanson

Yes. I have a few staff who are brilliant technically but lack the social skills inspite of significant training and counseling. Cetainly these staff are important to the organization, but are usually higher maintenance. Most everything boils down to ROI.

by shane

Ask yourself why he is asking to be a manager. Is it because he wants to manage people or is it because he thinks that is the only way to advance in your organization?

Sit down with him and ask him what he really wants. It might be that he just wants a raise and thinks being a manager is the only way to get it. He might want more respect or authority and perceives that only being given to managers.

You acknowledge his value as a technical authority, but does the rest of your organization? Does your company view the corporate latter as a single dimension triangle or is there a career path for purely technical leaders?

Also, his behavior in meetings sounds like he is desperate to be heard. You might consider changing the type of meetings he attends to be more about brainstorming, collaboration, and review.

As a technology leader myself, I've had to evangelize the differences between people leaders and technology leaders and how they are rarely the same people ... and that it's perfectly fine and should be supported by any tech-infused organization.

by librarygeek

I completely agree with this response.
Technical staff in my organization are stymied from moving upward because only managers are promoted up the power grid.
The organization has listened to some extent and extended the salary ranges on some developer/business analyst positions. However, there is still no ability to sit at the table and influence the organization's direction. One does not need to manage people to have strategic ideas.

I think that this issue exists in a number of organizations. I am considered to be equal to middle management -- even though I do not manage people -- I manage processes and projects.
However, I will not be able to move upward in this or in most other organizations (according to postings I've seen) without managing others.

by craig.engel

I've met people like this. The biggest mistake managers make is they assume because they are A Manager that this somehow enables them to deal with significant personality disorders or behavioral problems. The guy could be acting this way because he is an alcoholic, a drug addict, his parents were pedaphiles, he has low self-esteem, he may be bipolar or otherwise in need of psychiatric medical treatment. Give it to him straight, explain the dilemna, give him a chance to demonstrate his capabilities, and if he can't then he doesn't get promoted to a management position. You're not an adoption agency.

by eyost05

Place the individual in the group, and let the group discuss his traits, if he walks, so much the better, because he will take employess out of the company by making them victims of the train wreck attribute you discussed.
He can go one of two directions, and it seems he needs confrontation for the cure. The change you desire can only take place if the person wishes to change him or herself for what can be considered good not only for him/her but for the entire group.

by theslaw

Many of us engineers, me included, learned to think very effectively technically, but not at all at the human level. We never learned the dynamics of how to communicate in a way that everybody wins (win-win-win You-me-eveyone else). The techies among us with the best of these skills ended up getting promoted, yet still need to learn the dynamics of how to create these winning scenarios.

I suggest trying to find a way to get your person to understand that in order for him to become a manager within the company, he needs additional communication training (as evidenced by his behaviors). And if you fall into the management category described above, you may decide you could use it, too.

The most powerful, yet simple communication tool I have found is Nonviolent Communication(TM). Don't be fooled by the name. It is a straitforward process that helps people learn the dynamics of effective language, connection and meeting everyone's needs. This skill will help him, not only in business, but in all relationships in his life.

See www.cnvc.org for more info. Or feel free to contact me. http://www.steve-cole.com/contact.htm

Steve

by firstpeter

With all due respect, it's apparent you've never been a manager before (or you were only jesting in your post). I don't mean that as a put-down, but the first part of your post indicates (to me, at least) that you've got the purpose of "management" confused.

Management, in the most basic terms, IS coaching, plain and simple. It's taking a team of folks and helping them get the most out of themselves (for the end purpose of improving the business). To recommend a "stop coaching" approach is the equivalent of telling a fireman that he should stop putting out fires and just worry about saving cats from trees. The simple fact that this question was posed originally tells us that you've got a person who's concerned about an employee - that's one heck of a start for a good manager.

I'm constantly surprised by the sheer number of managers who stop focusing on their employees and wonder why things go wrong. Managers in good companies who focus more on _their_ career than those of their employees are going to quickly find themselves stuck in the exact same place that they are today.

You are correct, though, that the only person who can change an employee's focus and attitude is them. Absolutely, no doubt about it. And if you spend too much time stressing about it to the point that you ignore your other responsibilities then absolutely - that's bad. But as a good (or even an AVERAGE) manager you can never forget that your responsibility IS your employees - you exist only to the extent that you can help them get their job done. If you focus on getting promoted instead get ready to see "poor" attached to your name.

by workin4$$$

I am an executive. I manage my company's profitability through technology. If I could get by without employees, I would. It's cheaper, and employees only cause problems.

The company has a goal. My objective is to make them meet those goals. Generally, the goals involve making more money, and thereby the shareholders and my salary/bonus is tied to all of that.

Maybe you've been a manager and some people have reported to you, and you've managed their personalities well enough that they got on as a team.

Executives are responsible for a larger picture than human resources. They are coming up with ideas that employees can not. They are making decisions that will determine whether or not stock prices go up, or if I implement a new technology (like we're in the process of right now) that will eliminate the need for 150 of my 800 employees.

Yes, I'm going to have almost a quarter of the workforce eliminated. That was my decision. 1 pice of technology for $1M, with $1/2M in implementation and project fees will reduce my company's operating budget by over $5M per year. Go find work, you're not needed.

I don't disagree that management is responsible for the actions of their employees. They are not, however, responsible for the direction of their careers.

A perfect executive will make sure an good employee with no people skills and outstanding technical skills with no inherent ability to be management stays in his job and his happy doing it. If he/she is not happy, there's always the door. My business isn't going to meet their every needs, they're not snowflakes.

Either way, if he stands in the way of the companies objectives, or hurts its ability to be productiive, he's out the door. There's no need for ineptitude or internal sabotage.

I give credit where credit is due. I reward good employees (call it positive reinforcement) and I think so does the rest of the world. I punish failure. Generally by telling them they made a mistake. Repeated failures are another thing.

In the end, as long as my shareholders are happy, so am I. After all, I'm a shareholder too. It affects my profitability. So show another technology to eliminate jobs, and I'll have it bought and implemented.

by mtufts

To me, this is hilarious. This is why I was hired. We had a brilliant IT Director--absolutely brilliant--but he was so nervous around end-users he just couldn't effectively get his (excellent) points across in interacting, training, etc. Thus--he hired me for end-user help desk support and invited me to many of the meetings he attended. Then he left...now I have to learn a lot of his duties and try to match even a fraction of his brilliance--and it is hard (if not impossible). I have some advice that I have TAPED to my computer and it works for me: "As for soft skills, it's paramount that you have good communication skills, staying cool under stress, listening, patient, positive, kind, and happy. People will always call on a person with these qualities even if his skills are less than the others. In most instances, people don't care how much you know until they know how much you care. I know, it's corny, but it's true." AND IT IS! Get the guy a Dale Carnegie course--you'll be glad you did.

by theslaw

Maybe he just learned to be that way.

Yes learn about this, but be open to all possibilities.

by theslaw

This brings up a good point. You say you don't want to lose him. But it's not as clear as to what you do want.

It sounds like you want to promote him, yet with his behavior, management wouldn't work for you.

So, something needs to shift:
Add another technical level or
He changes his behavior.

If you can't do the first, then he has to change the second for you to succeed. The changes he needs to do are what others have described here. Good luck steve-cole.com

by b9girl

I agree with the gralfus to some extent. Desire to change is the first step, but it's not the whole equation. It's admirable to pull yourself up by the bootstraps, but not everyone can pick up a book and change themselves. Social behavior is very entrenched in our psyches. It takes a whole lot of work to change.

People's brains can just be wired differently - like seeing through a polka-dot filter when everybody else sees through blue stripes. You just think differently. Self-help plus a desire to change may not be the right course for people who need structured, individual guidance. A personal-trainer for the mind. AKA therapist, shrink or whatever you want to call them. There's no shame in hiring a consultant to fix a software glitch, so why should people hesitate to get mental help when it is so clearly impacting their work, relationships, life etc? #1. I don't have a problem, it's everybody else's problem.

It can be very hard to deal with employee's/management's psychological issues at work. Brilliant and damaged, but valuable people. The biggest lesson is that YOU CAN'T CHANGE PEOPLE. They really do have to WANT to do it for themselves. That doesn't mean you can't throw them a lifeline. For the employer who wants to 'fix' an employee, hire a consultant who deals with psychological and behavioral issues in the workplace. Don't bury the issue or pretend it doesn't exist.

And last, some people are truly not suited for management. There's no shame in that. It's not the be-all end-all of a career. And don't beat yourself up if that is you. A high-level career path for a not-a-people-person personality could be a strategist, or have split responsibilities with another who is a management type.

Change doesn't happen overnight. It's one click at a time...

by amcol

I don't think I've ever been involved with any organization, either via direct connection or through collegial access, that gave anyone a management job without some kind of training, either in advance of taking the position or sometime soon after.

Management is not something that just comes naturally, but training alone is insufficient. Training's required, but you can't train someone who lacks natural ability. It's a combination of the two.

The bad behavior you describe is more of a leadership failure than that of management. Two completely different things, and while one can certainly take any number of training classes in leadershp this is an area in which natural ability is absolutely a prerequisite.

People should get training for any career, but in management and leadership as in medicine and law and carpentry and plumbing a certain amount of natural ability needs to be there first. It's not one or the other...it's both.

by gsg

There has been some speculation that Bill Gates has Asperger's syndrome. I read an article about this recently. Apparently, he's admitted that he has issues with some social situations, and, whether you are a Microsoft, Linux, Mac, or whatever devotee, you have to admit, the man is brilliant. It does seem that the tech industry does seem to grab these apparently eccentric people.

Also, coming from this guy's point of view. I was in his situation, and felt I had to take a supervisory role to make more money. I was terrible at it. Luckily, I had a manager that realized I was terribly unhappy, and she helped me to transition in another direction. Namely, into IT. Since then I've been quite happy, and have trained myself to be more comfortable in some of these social situations, and am better able to deal with some of the interpersonal relationships that I have to have as a Project Manager. Be frank with this guy and tell him that you've noticed that he feels uncomfortable in meetings, and ask him what you can do to help. It could be that he's just an extreme introvert and by trying to fit in and become less so, he's inappropriate.

by alanaaa2

I have spent nearly 30 years managing employees so I have a great deal of experience with this type of situation.

First, I would never create a position just to placate an employee that might leave. Organization and positions are created based on the mission of the organization, and not based on the people in the organization.

Second, as a manager it is important to provide both formal and informal coaching for every staff member. The informal coaching might be to pull the person aside after a meeting where his performance was either good or bad and let him know what he did well and one or two items that he needs to improve with SPECIFIC suggestion on how he may have handled the situation differently. The reason for only one or two is that you don't want to overwhelm the guy, you are just trying to emphasis the things that he did well and give him one or two things to work on. The formal coaching would be during a performance review. (I would guess that this guy has never received a ?bad? review.) I always found that if I broke the performance review into two parts, the skills and behavior for the current position and the skills and behavior for the next position, that I could give positive feedback on the performance in the current job and then address performance deficiencies that are limiting the employee from advancing in the context of trying to help the employee advance. While not everyone has the skills for management it should always be clear to every employee where they are lacking and what they must improve to be considered for advancement. Please note that I said considered. Just because an employee has the skills necessary for advancement does not mean that they are the best person for the limited advancement opportunities available.

If you are honest with the person and he knows that you have his best interest in mind, then I don?t know why the person would want to leave.

I can suggest a book that will help in dealing with employees. The book is ?Winning? by Jack Welch (yes, I worked for GE for almost 15 years) I would especially recommend that discussion on candor.

by too old for it

Rather than management-or-out, most companies would be better served if someone tacked the CFO, and figured out a promotion and pay track for techies that equalled management (or sales or whomever).

by bphardy

Dear Sir,

I have a few suggestions for this employee. Well first thing you have to acknowledge is at least he has a personality. You HARDLY get that in droned out office settings nowadays. These are people if trained right who cannot only be an good IT guy but also sell almost anything because of their personality.

When I read this this almost sounded like the guy in high school who makes all the jokes but when the teacher is asking questions in class or something is asked of him. he shirks in a corner. I think they called him "The class clown?" I know what that type of person is like because I used to do that in my office settings so I'm that guy too! Sensitivity classes are good but a personal talk is better because you are telling him one on one without any third party as this builds and sustains the relationship of employer and employee as it should be, just tell him to keep his myrth and attitude because without him there would be no fun at all in the office (isn't work supposed to be fun anyway?..don't answer that) but to please lighten up on the comments because some of his jokes can be taken the wrong way by employees or come out in the wrong way. This is an office setting and we are more than just a group of people working together, we are a family and family respects each other and we consider you as family here.

That's about it. Like I said you are talking to one who had to really take a look at himself and see what he was saying and how some comments do more damage than good. Sensitivity to others however is the key.

Well thanks for letting me post. Please take care and have a nice day!

Sincerely Yours,

Blanton Pierre Hardy

by merlin the wiz

I was that guy. Well almost like you described. My company sent me to the Dale Carnegie. It helped a lot. i'm still that guy sometimes..

by jan.witschge

You should give him the opportunity to look into a mirror and see his own behaviour. Personal skills training exists to do just that and to make him aware of the consequences of his own behavior. These trainings last 2 - 5 days and can change his world and make him a better candidate. From that point onward give him personal coaching or a personal coach.
Do not pull him out of his comfort zone of technology, instead give him some mediors that he can co?rdinate when the time is ripe. Do not make him a project manager. Other people will do a better job.

by jakaiju

Although I agree with the gist of your response, one cannot seriously assert that "people are a commodity in any orginization." By describing employees as "managed material" is simply de-huminizing, and is an opinion that is (thank God) not shared by all managers.

I have managed employees in a lesser capacity, but have not been in your position. However, since you are an upper-level manager, you should know that employees [as people] are still human, and like it or not, bring in the human condition to any job. What I mean is that people cannot simply turn off being people and change into efficient, money-making machines as soon as the work day starts.

Granted that employee behavior, as well as performance, is dictated by company guidelines, there remains a certain amount of behavioral margin for people to function in and still be efficient at helping the company make money. The way you seem to want employees to behave is to be like robots -- completely stoic and without a soul.

Yes, good performance should be rewarded and bad performance deserves discipline, but are you considering the effects of employee morale to overall production? It seems that your not really concerned about this aspect and if you treat all of the company "commodities" as something less than human, then your going to have a lot of declining morale, and subsequently less productivity and greater resentment towards you and the company. The opposite is true also -- a manager providing a little motivation to an employee now and then can be a good thing.

Somewhere I read or heard a quote from a successful business person who stated that a company's employees are it's greatest asset. When you think about, that's true because the employees are the ones running the whole operation (even the managers). The employees are the ones who interact and deal with other people, especially the customers, who make the decisions and who operate the business machines (not the other way around).

Maybe your position doesn't require you to be a good people manager so all this doesn't matter to you. However, you stated, "when I was an employee," don't you mean that you are STILL an employee of the same company even after reaching your VP position? Unless you are actually the owner/CEO of the company, you are technically still an employee -- one who is, in your terms, "managed material" by others who are higher up. Even your user name, "Working4$$$," indicates where your real values lie (as in the dillusional idea that the acquisition of lots of money and material things are the only true measure of success).

Your stance towards people in your organization makes you seem a little resentful. I wonder, could that have been because your were treated with disdain by managers in your climb to the top?

by lsmith1989

I too was not concerned with fitting in. In fact I didnt really care for a number of years and got treated like an outsider, even among my relatives like cousin's, etc. I had a lock on my door to my room and I would lock myself away to either play online MMPORGs or read the latest dragonlance book or try and learn about computer stuff.

Soon, I picked up a desktop support IT job and was forced to socialize, interact with the people I support. I then gradually worked my way up to Network Admin and now have to plan and lead huge IT projects which involve plenty of face to face interaction and resource management. I would say that I am at the opposite end of the scale personality wise from where I was 6 years ago.

I too need to "recharge" at the end of a busy workday. Some folks go out and party as soon as they are done working, like my wife for instance, but I feel the need to sit at home where its nice and quiet and read a good book and watch a "no brain power required" TV show like Spongebob Squarepants or Family Guy.

by workin4$$$

Tell me different and you're lying. Sure, you get to do something you may like, but take away the money and you'll leave pretty fast.

Yes, I'm still an employee. I report to a pair of CEO's and a Board of Directors. I'm not in the same company I started out in though. I tend to be brought into organizations when they're having morale problems to get them fixed. (that's a joke)

Do some of my employees suffer from demotivation? Of course they do. Empowerment is up to themselves.

Do my CEO's and board care if I'm having a bad day/month/year? That my cat just died?

Of course not. They're concerned that I produce. They still don't want to see me cry in front of them. I don't mis-treat my employees. I use them as tools for the companies productivity. If a robot could do their job, I'd buy one. I don't have to educate a robot. I don't have to coach one either.

I didn't mean I can buy and sell people as commodities. I meant that they have their uses, and when the day is done, if they're management material, they will get noticed by me and promoted where appropriate.

by darinhamer

Some of the things that Workin4$$$ says are true. Not everyone is management material. Employees should be replaceable and a company should never allow itself to get in a situation where someone is irreplaceable. If you find you're in that situation, figure out a way to get out of it quickly. And, ONE of the responsibilities IS to put money in the pockets of the shareholders.

But understand that managers and especially VPs have obligations to others besides the shareholders. The data and research--and common sense--on management all show that it is not only possible to seek profit as well as higher ideals, but it essential to do so. One of those ideals is to do some succession planning. Good companies don't see their employees as a commodity input, but as a resource that, if invested in properly, can help make a profit. Yes, the labor is a commodity input, but the employees are part of the company's assets.

Companies that have values like you have expressed have no soul, no character. They don't add much value to our society and while they can be financially successful for awhile, they tend to be short-lived in the whole scheme of things. The long-lasting, visionary companies have a reason for existing other than to just make a profit, and I think they would applaud this guy's efforts to help his employee achieve his personal goals while adding value to the company.

It is rather smug to make it to VP, but to turn your back on others who might also like to be there some day. But then if all you're doing is working for $$$, I guess that point will be lost on you.

by darinhamer

Take away the money. I'm gone. I've got a family I have to support. But I'm not JUST working for money. That's the point in my earlier post. You don't have to just be doing one thing. I'm working for money. I'm working for career advancement. I'm working for personal satisfaction. I'm working so that I can do some good. It isn't all about money. And the "use them, then dispose of them" mentality is deplorable. Of course, you're the VP. I'm sure you know better than I do. The day will come, though, when you will be the one who is used up. And I wonder if you will feel the same way.

Good luck to you.

by workin4$$$

I think some of the details that go on in someone's head always get missed through personal interpretation.

I'm going to number this up in point form to bring some clarity and consistency to everything I am attempting to get across on all of my posts.

1. The only purpose of any company is to make money. If a company's stock prices plummet, investors run faster than employees. If investors run, the company goes under. (P.S. - the 5% share I own of my company, makes me an owner, and though I report to my CEO's, they also report to me.)

2. Employees effect (either directly or indirectly) the bottom line of any company, public or otherwise. They require space, care, attention, salary, benefits, parking spaces, vacation time.

On the flip-side, employees are there to assist the company achieve its goal of making more money. They ARE INTEGRAL to its survival. I know and believe that, and anything I've said that seems to the contrary is taken out of context.

Again, if I COULD live without them, I WOULD.

I cannot live without them. I don't have any employees like the one in question. I received my current position about 8 years ago. The first 2 years saw a lot of turn-over. I have a department of 150. I have the lowest turn-over in the company. Last year I had 7 people leave for good, 1 was after a maternity leave. 1 was terminated due to negligence with our Intellectual Property. 1 was terminated because he stole a laptop. 1 was terminated because he could never show up on time.

Here's a reality for you;

3. When I think about every decision made, I don't think about the employees it will affect. I think instead about my share value and how it will be impacted. I also think about the long-term profitability of my company. If my company goes bankrupt, 800 people are terminated, not 1.

This means that nobody has any work, even the honourable that want to because they enjoy it.

4. I enjoy my work, I wouldn't be doing it otherwise. I have enough to retire and live a reasonably comfortable life. I stay because I like it. Not everyone likes their job. When I was at the bottom, I hated my job. Do I want to be CEO? Nope. I'm happy with the level I've reached. I didn't quit high-school for nothing!

5. My CEO's don't coach me! WHY?

I bet it's because they're too busy planning and strategising like I am. If I do something wrong, they just tell me. They don't hand-hold me. If I keep doing it, they fire me, I've seen them do it with other incompetents, and I'd do the same to any incompetent employee of mine. I don't hand-hold employees through their careers either, and neither do my drectors, their managers, their employees, etc. It's my mandate. If you want to get ahead, figure out how. (You'd be surprised how many do figure it out)

6. If you lose a customer, you will be reprimanded. Customers are our business, period.

7. In the end, employees are assets of the company. But again, if I COULD do without them, I WOULD. I spend far too much time already focussing on human resources.

Thanks for you time.

by conquistador

Too bad he's technically competent. If he weren't he would jump straight to the top of the organization.

by davidpenrose61

I am an IT manager and Division Governor with Toastmasters International in Sunshine Coast, Australia. I can appreciate your situation. If confidence is the issue, send him to a local Toastmasters Club. It is the cheapest professional development around and will develop confidence, speaking and leadership skills. Check out the web site www.toastmasters.org. I have seen many people come from this situation totally transformed in a relatively short period of time - and gain rapid promotion. Of course he has to want to be in management but that is another issue. by the way it is better if he pays for some or all of the cost so he has ownership! Toastmasters is a Win/Win situation. Check it out. You cannot lose. David Penrose.

by tejas73

I think employees have a serious mix of ego and inferiority complex.Inferiority complex because they know they dont know how to behave prfessionaly in socially. And ego problem because they have been so ideaalised by the management that they think they are the best of all and knows everything.I have seen some cases in my company and they have caused serous problem to themselvs and company in general....

In my opnion the best way to get what u want is to first humblise the character and them grove them professioanlly

Thanks

by dgjacquin

As a mgt employee for a large corporation there are some fundamental truths.

1. If the corporation can get by without you they will.

2. They're in business to make money.

3. An employee that is not good at dealing with people will have limited career growth and all things being equal, is the one that departs when difficult times arrive (as in automotive).

A good manager provides frequent feedback which leads to improved behavior/performance or helps the employee out (as in departure).

by workin4$$$

I knew that someone else out there was sick of pandering to employees.

There are 2 kinds of employees.

1. The artificially ambitious. These are the ones that love motivational seminars and self-help books. The one's that never get anywhere, but gossip a lot at work and are always finding new ways to do less work for more money.

2. The authentic ambitious. THere are the ones that regard self-help and motiviational courses as uninspiring, condescending and generally a waste of time and money. If you put road-blocks in front of this person, the find detours quickly. They hate company mixers and don't tend to volunteer for things like the social committee.

I have all #2's on my management team. Any #1's aren't promoted unless they make a change in themselves. Most #1's in my environment, are happy to stay in their jobs, once they realize I won't take their crap about how it's my fault they aren't succeeding.

#2's don't like praise as much as #1's. #2's take more pride in actual acheivment. They're refreshing to have working for you.

Thanks!

by lambe_m

try to get him to interact more with the group.
Ask him to present something to the team. That way he may be able to gain confidence to speak up and interact more with the group

by absolutely

The best analytical minds do not learn "people skills". Tell him shut up unless he has something substantial to say. Explain to him what you told us: he has exactly one positive attribute, and it isn't his "humor". His understanding of pertinent facts is the [b]only[/b] thing he should be attempting to communicate. Actually, that's true of everybody, but in his case it's obviously an issue.

Tell him that he's the most talented member of the team ("easily the most talented IT guy I've ever worked with" might make him unmanageable!), but to advance he needs a more reserved, professional demeanor. All true, right? If he can't take that criticism when it's delivered [b]with[/b] such high praise, he not only doesn't belong in a business, he probably doesn't belong in society.

by jrgnvogel

We had one manager which acted exactly the same way as $$$. He lasted about two years, then he got fired as he well deserved. We lost two many good people due to his attitude. I discussed the matter with our CEO and it was decided that we could not effort this troubleshooting maniac. Yes the company has to make money but not at the expenses of our most importand workers. The company in question had a total of 148.000 employees worldwide. The gentleman in question also got blacklisted and probably will never work as a manager again. Companies do talk together.
Regards

by ou jipi je

Maybe if you promote him and listen to him a bit closely, you might find out that it is not "personality problem"; it might be just a different style of approach.

If someone is "good worker" a bit of an aversion towards management might play role here as well (if person deals with management requests and does the good job, often he sees dow deep the problems go -- so he says once I am manager I am going to solve it)...

2 Options:
a.) Involve him in information (management level) he previously did not had access to. Ask him about his opinion before you make a decision. Start small. Make him understand that there are two teams -- management and work floor, both have different issues, and on the management team often numbers and not comon sense dictate outcome of a decision. Make him understand why some decisions are taking place. Make him understand why he needs to be quiet at times.

This does not have to take longer then three months, in which it should be obvious whether he is the management material (from your description, people like that usually are, it is the rest of the management team that might have a problem...). Then promote him.

2. He will leave and if he is good as you are saying, it is your loss really, not his.

by benb

Does he want a promotion? What is the history of promotions in your company? Do you normally promote the sharpest technical people or the ones who would make the most politically correct? Sharp technical people are often not interested in promotions if that promotion comes with a lot of political stuff that limits their ability to speak freely and solve problems directly. Your employees approach to group situations may be his cynical response to, what are obvious to him, bad management choices (or politically motivated decisions) in which he feels helpless to act - so he acts out. Perhaps you can have another discussion with your employee, tell him your plans, and ask him what you can do to help. The employee must decide that this is something he wants.

Good luck!
benb

by leonard j rivera sr.

I've only gotten through several posted responses. Some make sense and some don't.

Do not abandon the possibility of turning this employee into a manger. Managers are made. And you, as his manager, have a responsibility to yourself and your company to grow and challenge your staff. And to train them to replace you someday. Maybe this guy is your perfect replacement. By replacement I mean, if you don't have one, the company will be less likely to promote you out of your current position, but if you have someone fully capable of filling your shoes, everybody wins.

So I say this, work with HR. Do not rush into creating a new position and trying to promote this person. You must mentor and coach him. Don't stick him into the position and hope he can grow and develope that way. He clearly has interaction issues with others, these issues need to be taken care of first or you are surely setting him up to fail.

Train him, send him to management classes for new IT managers or even project management classes. Work him up to the responsability. At least by taking this path of career developement you will bide some time and be able to know if he can be made into a manager or not.

At the very least, you'll give him something to look forward to. He has to understand that tech skills alone will not get him into a manager's position and you are willing to coach him along and help him reach this goal, but in the end it is up to him and not you.

Just give him the challenge and see where it goes from there. Sure, it hurts to losed a good tech, however, if he turns down your offer for a position elsewhere, then he turns down an opportunity to grow in his field and clearly does not understand what it takes to be a successful manager.

Being a manager is one thing, being a good manager is another. Do the right thing by him, yourself and the company by opening up the path to him, offer to walk it with him, but in the end, he's the one who needs to put one foot in front of the other.

by nojacketreqd

I somehow get this nagging feeling that his two promotions in the last two years diplay that you're already giving this talent a lot of attention - perhaps YOU are mentoring / coaching him already? And hence your convictions towards his capabilities!

Do you have a structured environment with no-one else displaying this behavior? Not even executive management!

Is there a chance that YOU yourself perhaps display similar characteristics / behavior, OR perhaps some of the more senior staff and/or someone that this talent looks up to?

My thinking is that this talent is already aware of his development areas (thanks to previous discussions / coaching), but that he may be copying seniors (who get away with this behavior because of their seniority ... so he withdraws when he's trying to control himself (conscious behavior), but then he joins the gang when things get informal (but his juniority does not make his behavior acceptable). I think you may want to address your team and meeting dynamics - maybe try team building and then analyze the behavior patterns.

Additionally he may be speaking out of turn, or finishing others' sentences at times when they are battling with something AND he already sees the answer. You may have senior / management staff who are not his equal - causing him frustration, and causing others to feel threathened by him (don't want him to bypass them for some "social status" reason perhaps - e.g. age) - a loose-loose situation. Be prepared to look deeper at the broader team, the working structure, team dynamics, and be honest to yourself when you analyze the overall team performance rated by your user community.

The fact that he currently assists everywhere shows competence and leadership abilities - evidently a passionate change agent! - YES, probably a talent to be nurtured as your own successor - and you may be freed up and empowered to greater power WITH a truely confident person supporting you in your past role.

by leonard j rivera sr.

I stopped reading too soon. I agree with these past two posts (see my post way down the list). I'm glad to see others stepping up and voicing "the right thing to do". I see we have some good managers here.

by hagrinas

Many companies will promote people to a certain level, after which the only way to move up is to manage. It's not necessarily in the best interest of the company or the employee.

If an employee is more valuable than his current compensation, then change it. Don't move him up to management.

The problem is that many companies won't let you do that. I used to work for the top VP in a company, and he moved me up to management, but for the most part, he just let me do my work. I did have a few employees to supervise, review, etc. But I did not have to go out and bring in new clients as most managers did.

It's up to the company to figure these things out, and many companies are foolish about this. The problem is that management comes up with the rules, and it seems clear to them that managers are the ones on top. Why put somebody in charge of somebody else with a higher salary? It's a rhetorical question for most managers, but the answer is that the manager still has the authority, and by having the best possible workers, he can move up by having his projects come out well.

by too old for it

... your learned words onto a piece of granite, to be delivered to every CEO's desk in America:

"One does not need to manage people to have strategic ideas."

by hagrinas

The problem with being brilliant, or even moderately gifted (there's a defined IQ level for that) is that the person's intellectual maturity and chronological age do not match while growing up. If those things matched, he'd have a normal IQ by definition. This is a problem when growing up because a person's maturity is more likely to follow his chronological age. It can even lag that if he does not have normal social interaction with his peers.

Having normal interaction with peers while growing up can be difficult for the intellectually gifted. For one thing, other kids will have no idea what he's talking about most of the time. And he might not relate to them either. This impacts the development of social skills.

I'm sure your employee is aware of some of these issues, and the subject was broached many times while he was growing up. It won't be a surprise if you talk to him about it. But you need to have the right approach.

Chances are that the approach that his peers took when he was growing up was to call him weird, keep him out of certain activities (brilliant people are not always the best athletes or team players, bu sometimes they are) or much worse.

A different approach is to discuss the issues on a point by point basis. Tell him that you would like him to move up, but there will be certain expectations. For example, he can't make jokes in meetings. If he points out that others do, be frank. It's not jokes per se, that are the problem, but how others react to them. In his case, others have been offended or annoyed, and that's just not going to work. They have a different mindset and won't appreciate it. He may have to try hard, but it's important.

The shrinking part is not surprising either. If he grew up in an environment where he was alienated from his peers, it's either fight or flight. Shrinking works if he can't relate well, and so does being overbearing. He needs to understand that management requires a "take charge" attitude. He would be responsible for the work product of others, and for taking care of certain issues that arise outside of the scope of the projects. Employees must feel that they will be taken seriously by him, and that he can be genuinely helpful when working with them. Give specific examples, and let him know that if he's not sure how to handle a situation, he can talk to you first.

He won't change completely overnight, but if it's clear that you find him a valuable employee, and you'd really like to see him move up he'll understand that he must do what it takes.

You may have to point things out discreetly that others would pick up on by themselves, but it can be workable. If his direct reports start going over his head to you, then you can address those issues on a case by case basis and see if the trend changes.

Another issue is that many brilliant people have problems in group meetings because of the way their minds work. A disadvantage of having an active mind with many ideas spinning around all the time is that it makes it hard to focus in group settings. If one point brought up in a meeting causes his mind to go in a different direction, it's easy to get side tracked. And if many people are talking, ideas are moving back and forth, but the comments are not directed specifically to him, it may result in sensory overload because of the way his mind juggles information. For every idea that others bring up, he may have a dozen of his own to consider. That might create the impulse to finish others' sentences because it's a way of taking back control of the flow. If all questions and answers either came from him or were directed to him, it might work better, since others wouldn't go on while he's thinking an idea through. But that's not a sure thing, since he might still get side tracked.

He may have to adapt a management style that has more one on one meetings with others, or there may be other things that help, such as a more detailed agenda before a meeting. A psychiatrist would be helpful, but it would not be appropriate to tell him that.

It's impossible to give a comprehensive solution when I don't know the guy, and some of this may be off base, but if you keep in mind that there's a reason for all of those behaviors, and they could even be expected for people with specific backgrounds, you will no longer see him as somebody who is out of control for no reason.

by robertmi

Your man is super-intelligent. He operates on a different plane from 'ordinary' people. He is good at the technical stuff because it is complex but mechanical in that it does not involve interaction with people who cannot understand his approach and speed of problem solving. In group situations he lacks confidence, perhaps because he is smart enough to know he doesn't fit in, or perhaps because he has been told he is seriously weird and he knows that people discount what he says. His lack of confidence can manifest itself in shy or over assertive behaviour as he tries to overcome his self perceived shortcomings. It might depend on the group makeup and what individuals in the group have said to him in the past. He operates on a different wavelength, and his speed of thought will lead him to finish other people's sentences. He might see this as affirmation of the concept on his part and may not realise how irritating it can be for the speaker who is developing a concept as he/she speaks, only to have the conclusion snatched from their mouth. The guy obviously wants to fit in, but does not know how. He needs help of different kinds so that he can understand the dynamics of his workplace and of his situation within it. My bet he is an INTP (Myers-Briggs) and is doomed to be misunderstood for much of his working life.

How do I know this stuff? I am highly intelligent. I empathise completely with your guy, because I have been there. Unlike him perhaps, I had a strong instinct for leadership (when custard occurred I could always be relied upon to spot the solution and implement it) Much of the time my ideas were laughed at because my peer group were 'ordinary' folk of normal intelligence who thought in linear fashion, and whose problem solving approaches were more conventional than mine. I nevertheless rose through the levels of management over 36 years to manage an operation of over 200 staff, and was genarally regarded as a 'good boss'. My management skills were learned the hard way. Your man will benefit first by understanding his situation, and making a big adjustment so as to neither "look too good nor talk too wise". Next he needs to understand that others around him do not have his capacity for near instantaneous uptake. He must pace himself to the group and sometimes make his contribution through planting the seeds in the minds of others. He needs to discover that being a team player involves celebrating team success, and contributing quietly to that success in a way that does not make his colleagues feel threatened or resentful. He can reserve his brilliance for the occasions when the team is stuck and needs a truly innovative solution. Even then he should be aware that office dynamics do not always reward the guy who is different, especially if he is 'clever'.

Get him onto management courses where communication skills are taught, so that he understands the importance of interpersonal interaction in the workplace, and that it is as important to be successful in this area as it is in the technical area. An alternative career for this guy would be to find him a blue sky project that he could sink his mental teeth into while at the same time coming to grips with the disciplines involved in project management. I liked the diamond analogy made earlier. This guy needs some new facets cut and polished so that he can become the complete jewel.

by lumbergh77

"Your man will benefit first by understanding his situation, and making a big adjustment so as to neither "look too good nor talk too wise". Next he needs to understand that others around him do not have his capacity for near instantaneous uptake. He must pace himself to the group and sometimes make his contribution through planting the seeds in the minds of others. He needs to discover that being a team player involves celebrating team success, and contributing quietly to that success in a way that does not make his colleagues feel threatened or resentful. He can reserve his brilliance for the occasions when the team is stuck and needs a truly innovative solution. Even then he should be aware that office dynamics do not always reward the guy who is different, especially if he is 'clever'."

This reminds me of the school teachers who pass every student so that nobody "feels bad" about failing. Or the sports leagues where they don't keep score and "everybody wins".

Let's face the facts. We live in a compatitive, capitalistic society. This guy is to contribute less and worry about making others feel good so he doesn't "hurt somebody's feelings"? What a bunch of crap. We were once the most technologically advanced nation in the world and we're losing ground because of this type of thinking.

"Get him onto management courses where communication skills are taught, so that he understands the importance of interpersonal interaction in the workplace, and that it is as important to be successful in this area as it is in the technical area."

Yes, I agree with this. he SHOULD improve his communication skills. And then LEAVE corporate America and start his own company. He probably makes twice the contribution as the other team members and getting paid the same or even less. He should stop subsidizing his "average" co-workers and take advantage of that IQ of his. DO NOT dumb this guy down and ruin the confidence that he does have in his abilities.

by hagrinas

AS is an autistic spectrum disorder, and has many common characteristics with autism, but is not technically a form of autism even though that's an easy way to put it. It's a pervasive developmental disorder, and is very closely related to autism with a lot of overlap.

It's also a medical diagnosis, so I personally wouldn't go there (neither would any doctor) without much more information. But you may be right.

Many necessary aspects of AS were not mentioned, so they may or may not be there. But there are other things that could cause those symptoms ranging from ADD to simply being expected consequences of being brilliant. I covered that in another post.

by too old for it

... in the country can figure out how to shitcan a quarter of their employees and still keep going. You take the (newly created) 25% unemployment you have created, add it to the existing 6% or so true rate of unemployment, and with say 31% of the country out of work, the economy helps your company prosper how?

Is it truly necessary to have such an unbridled prejudice and hatred for everyone beneath you to make it to the executive suite, or does it merely anecdotal?

by workin4$$$

...that employees can retrain themselves. We're not talking macroeconomics of a state, or nation or the world entire. What we are talking about is one guy, who has a chip on his shoulder. My initial point was to say that not everyone is cut out for management. Any attempts YOU make to motivate someone else to do anything, are just that, YOUR attempts. An authentically ambitious person will motivate and educate themselves. They will see their short-comings. They will take genuine criticism easily and use it to better themselves. They will consider self-help and motivational seminars to be condescending, uninspiring and generally a waste of money.

They will pull themselves up by their own boot straps and acheive greatness with or without anyone else's assistance.

The more you promote the mediocre, the more you develop mediocre middle-management. The more the truly ambitious get left behind, because they're not happy-go-lucky people pleasers who love motivational posters and after-work functions.

There's a saying, but I'm not sure from where, that I think sums it up pretty good.

MOTIVATION - If a pretty poster and a cute saying are all it takes to motivate you, you probably have a very easy job, the kind robots will be doing soon.

This is my last post on this topic. I'm done my vacation now and have to get back to ruining my mediocre employees lives by finding the company I partially own more efficient ways to make money. When I'm done, if there's anyone left, I'll probably find another poorly run company to fix.

After all...that's what they hire me for.

by hagrinas

The problem with broad generalizations is that they are never true. Many people can't change, but it does happen.

I once worked for a VP with extreme problems relating to people. He was overbearing and anti motivational. He ignored what others said, and often did not give them the chance to state their reasons for anything. Instead he would tell them how he could have done the entire project by himself in a few hours so there's no excuse. Sometimes he left during meetings since he had other more important things to do. I'm talking about meetings with him and a single employee who was called to his office.

Then one day, he changed. It seemed to happen overnight. He somehow found out that the way he acted was not effective or conducive to business. After that, he always heard people out before he told them why he was right. He no longer berated people and became more of a social butterfly.

by tonythetiger

You could have him taking the minutes at the meetings. That way he gets the exposure but won't be able to say as much since he's busy.

by crseel

Supeheroes = challenges, Retaining them is a short term option.
Fully occupied and distracted from other opportunities is the main goal. Perhaps your company could outsource some of his skills, send him to support external area's where your company could gain knowledge and extra skills, with his learning curve. You can keep him interested, increase his salary, make more income for your company, and retain him for a longer term. and take some of the heat off the rest of your team.
Letting him stagnate and become dissolusioned will mean you loose sooner rather than later. The Later you let him go the better.
It is a fact that talented individuals, have less tolerance for mediocracy, see no value in procrastination. Even with their gung ho attitude and their mammoth mistakes they drive businesses forward and are sadly missed by the companies who invested in them, when they leave, often the rest of the staff are a bit happier then, as others have a chance to shine, remember superstars are resented as much as appreciated.
Is it profitable long term to invest? the overall benefits have to be weighed against the short term gains, profit and loss. Teams need team-members!

by carolange

You said this employee is sensitive to criticism, so that makes it very difficult to broach the subject of his behavior. If you are the least bit concerned about his reaction (or your safety), you might want to have another person in the room wheen you talk to him.

This person sounds like he has a dysfunctional background and if that is the case, he should seek out some therapy and books that will help him better understand why he is the way he is.

One book that you might recommend is 'What your boss doesn't tell you until it's too late: How to correct behavior that is holding you back' by Robert Bramson. It should probably be required reading for anyone who is frustrated that they are not moving up and they don't know why.

Good luck.

by el_gazzítò

The employee that you are describing is very similar to me when I first started out. I was very similar in behaviour and technical ability. It's like ciscoguyinkc says: "The change has to come from within."

The way that I got around this was to try many different things, none of which worked, until I tried Sahaja Yoga Meditation.

This is taught for free in over 96 countries around the globe. It's not the bending and stretching type of yoga, but straight meditation. Not the meditiation that you are constantly thinking the same mantra over and over again, but clearing your mind of all thoughts meditation.

Even though this sounds hard, it's really quite easy, and can be learned in about 10 mins or less.

Go to http://www.sahajayoga.org/experienceitnow/ to learn more. You will need a PC with a soundcard and speakers attached, as well as Shockwave player installed or the ability to download and install it.

Using these meditation and clearing techniques, (That you will learn further down the track at free classes) I have managed to get rid of the emotional baggage that had been holding me back, become more easy going and friendly and generally be more relaxed whilst dealing with clients. This has been the most beneficial for me, as I used to sieze up around other people.

If you knew me 5 years ago, and saw me now, I have totally changed and it's all thanks to this meditation.

Once you have given this a go, let me know what you think.

Gazz.

by sgt_shultz

you both:

1. need a mentor to help with problems you are not practiced in resolving
2. need team building, management, conflict resolution/negotiation training.

be careful not to inadvertently blame HR here. this is opportunity to team with them, don't blow it

you want him to:

learn more people skills
learn how to listen
take responsibility for his career

so you do that.

Here is a crazy idea about how to figure out how to give him 'constructive criticism' (don't those words void each other out or something?)
take him to lunch and ask him for constructive criticism on your . (if you are now thinking that personality is not the thing you want criticised: bingo)
make some rules up so you can control it so you do not feel attacked. be as specific as need to be. 'no raised voices' 'no swearing' 'keep smiling' 'limit to 3 things'. what ever you need so YOU feel comfortable taking his constructive criticism. you will be not speaking much except, 'thank you' after his comments or to clarify what he means. write it down and get him to approve it. you do not criticise him a whit at this meeting.
is this not a model of what you wish him to do?
(and, do you now think that is a reasonable expectation of him?)
how to give constructive criticism: don't.

you have to be willing for him to not take your advice. it has to be ok with you for him to be like he is or he is never budging...i bet Troll manager's approach got some of those trolls out from under the bridge. just guessing.

you have to just figure out what you will accept and let him know,in very friendly way. you are doing yourself and him no favor accepting rude meeting behaviors, is my reaction.
until you get a mentor who can model for you tossing off words to the wise when subject appears receptive, wouldn't management class or team building class for you two or boy, your whole team, in the forest (learning meditation?) be oh so much better? go patch up that relationship with HR right now!
they can help with this. really.

by too old for it

I'm sure you know better than I do. What is more important, the VP is convinced that they know more thanyou do, despite the fact if they walked into an empty shop one day (news of their "I hate my employees" attitude finally leaked out?) they wouldn't know how to do it.

Every day I am convinced that it is not the Osama bin Laden's of the world who hate the citizens of this country as much as the "shitcan American workers and outsource the rest" managers!!!

by darinhamer

I appreciate your taking the time to explain your position in greater detail. It's been a lively debate and I appreciate it. There are definitely some things you and I agree on. First of all, bad employees should be canned. Period. Companies should not spend time and effort trying to make a bad employee good. Furthermore, good employees don't need "hand holding" but they do need to learn from those who've already been there, one way or another. Maybe they can figure it out on their own, or maybe the VPs have a vested interest in making the investment in training and mentoring to see that the best they have get better.

I still have two points where I disagree:

1) Companies do not necessarily exist JUST to make a profit. They exist to fill other roles as well, but they cannot do that without making a profit. It is possible--imperative--to seek a profit at the same time as seeking other goals, such as making the higest quality, most affordable widgit on the planet.

2) GE is an example of a company that has always groomed its leaders from the time they enter the company to the time they step into the CEO role--or whatever role they end up with. Perhaps your CEO doesn't coach you, or maybe it's subtle--for instance, rather than firing you immediately for doing something wrong, he tells you about it and expects you to fix it. That's coaching. I'm not talking about hand holding. I'm talking about preparing the next generation of leaders for the company so that the company outlasts its current leadership. To me, that's smart business and you have to be proactive about it.

In the end, I suspect working4$$$ and I agree on more than we disagree. There are certainly days I wish I could work with androids without emotions and personal agendas instead of working with humans. But I can't, so I have to work at ways of getting past all the human stuff to get the job done. I suspect this is what working4$$$ is saying. With a very low turnover rate in the company, I would say that he must be pretty good to work for, or people would be scratching at the door to get out.

by fm

If the guy really is a good IT guy, it is probably fair to say that his brain is hard wired for logic as opposed to EQ and soft skills.

I would appeal to his log, start to discuss his future with him. If he truly sees himself in managment, then he needs to follow the behaviours of managers. It would be good to pick out a few successful managers at your company and use them as case studies - allow him to join up the dots by himself. Guide him along a path that shows him that those who climb up the corporate ladder are predominantly individuals that display considerable soft skills in addition to SME (sunbject matter expertise). You may also wish to introduce the examples of individuals known to you, who have been excellent in their technical skills, but who have been superceded in their careers by individuals demonstrating the balanced portfolio of skills.

In my experience employees such as you BYT (bright young thing) need to have the penny drop by itself as opposed to being lectured.

Hope this helps in some way.

Regards
Frederick Martin
Programme & Change Mgmt Consultant

by amitabhajo

Well to be very frank, I was something like the employee you have described above, though I didnot finish other people's sentences. ;-). I was told my my then boss than though I had done wonderfully when, I was just not fitting in the group.

So my boss started giving me individual projects first. the after some time he started deputing some juniors under me. I was rather rough with them. the blow came when we had the half yearly 360 degree feedback. Though I had met my targets in the difficult year, I was rated very badly as a boss and mentor and this was very humbling. I decided to have a frank feedback session from both my juniors and my boss.

I guess I have improved a bit only because of that.

So my advice -
1. Give him some rookies to handle
2. have a regular session where in the rookies give their feedback and so do you.
3. Make it clear to the rookies that their feedback will not be held against them. If the need be, have anonymous feedbacks.
4. For most brilliant guys , failures are difficult to come to terms with and usually allof them will delve deep into the causes of the failures. this would help him.

by soul_bro

by warrior_king

Anonymous feedback from his peers could work. Have him consolidate the responses, come up with possible solutions and you help point the problem areas out in the future to break him from the behaviour. Support him by reminding him in private and continue to make it part of his performance reviews.

by drcglobal

First the IT staff in this case is an introvert, the behavior (acting out in group settings) is a result of his insecurity - fish out of water. Brilliant but unfortunately socially inept.

It appears that as the manager you are attempting to find solutions to an HR issue. Go to the HR department and both of you brainstorm alternatives to assist you in getting the max from this employee. Your suggestion about creating a new position does not fly with HR as they do not want to set the employee up for failure, plus this only adds to their workload.

go back to the basics - job description and job performance - if you truely see opportunity in this valued employee - get help from the HR department and coach him. Put in place the tools/learning opportunities he needs that will help him move forward. You need to look at skill (people skills in this case) and motivation - in end is this employee willing to change or unable to change?

any way hope that helps is some small way

by mart1n

I rate myself as a talented employee and am progressing up the management ladder. However I feel I am still underutilised. I feel if more managers were as objective as working4$$ talented people would be better off. Instead we have weak VPs who promote "yes men" and "buddies" in hope of keeping their position unchallenged. This is short lived as they are destined to deliver poor results.
A VP who is brave enough to promote the best people will be successful.

As for moral, anyone who knows about competition knows the greatest motivator is success. And I don't mean spin. To many VPs hide poor results behind spin and their staff all know it too.

The objective is all about profit, this is the basic that makes all the rest happen. Forget this and you have lost it. Be successful and everyone will be happy.

by mr l

Very nice flame bait. Your use of inflammatory and derogatory comments earns you a solid 4 on the troll-o-meter. Next time though, in order to get serious troll points make sure you have an account you created years ago to lend you at least the illusion of credibility. Now go away.

by stelian

What can be more rewarding than getting manager dollars without all the hassles that come with the actual manager job?

by wheresundontshine

Try the following...

DO NOT LAUD NATURALLY TALENTED PEOPLE USE BODY LANGUAGE ITS MORE NATURAL AND IF YOUR FEELINGS ARE GENIUNE THEY WILL BE RECOGNISED IN RESPONSE.

IGNORE FELLOW WORKERS THEY WANT HIM THE SACK!

MEETINGS MAKE SURE THEY ARE FOCUSSED NO BULLSHIT HIT THE GROUND!

LISTEN TO HIM AND I MEAN LISTEN!

IGNORE THE HUMAN RELEVENCE DEPARTMENT STAND YOUR GROUND ARE YOU MAN OR MOUSE!

IF ITS THE LATTER HUMAN RELEVENCE DEPARTMENT FOR YOU!

SHOW LEADERSHIP COURAGE BUT MOST OF ALL DONT GET IT WRONG.

I WAS ONCE A "BRILLIANT" EMPLOYEE MY BOSS LOVED ME

NOT THE MOST GIFTED BUT USED MY TALENTS WELL

MY JEALOUS COUNTERPARTS GOT ME THE SACK

OH WELL I AM MY OWN BOSS NOW SOB SOB

THANKFULLY NOT IN IT BUT I HAVE CODED MY IT SOFTWARE SO IT WAS NOT POINTLESS

MY OLD COMPANY IS NOT DOING SO WELL

DON'T LOSE TOP TALENT! THE IT INDUSTRY IS LOSING TALENT BY THE SACK FULL!

MONEY IS NOT THE ONLY REWARD...

STILL STUCK?

FORGET THE PRIMA DONNA AND LISTEN TO THE SHITS CONSULT WITH HUMAN RELEVENCE DEPARTMENT AND SACK THE BASTARD.

WOW THAT IS WISE...

OR GET AN INDIAN OUTSOURCER FOR 2 RUPEE

NOT EVEN PRINCESS ZELDA COULD DO THAT ASK LINKS

HMMM IT IT's A SHIT BUSINESS TO BE IN

HOPE THIS HELPS

PS A PRIMMA DONNA NEVER ACTUALLY EXISTS WORK IT OUT

by darinhamer

Your post is unintelligible. The only thing it is good for is proof that punctuation is really useful and that alcohol and computers don't mix.

by cedric.tanga

What has worked for me in the past is to team such a person with at least 2 females of your current team(if youu have them), who are outgoing no-nonsense woman though with bubbly personalities, a good sense of humour and technically IT savvy and put them to work on a project.
This brings in positive gender social skills that are tranferrable in a social setting, a "working with" rather than independant approach, and having to discuss collaberatively a projects challenges. It will take some time though the end result will be positivelly more than anticipated.

by jkowolf

You may have to face the fact that this person is not a manager. Maybe this person could be promoted to a higher level programmer instead.

The other option is to make this person aware of their problems and see if they can get some help in the social aspects of a manager's job. Some people are not aware that they may have to work with people differently if they want to be in a leadership position.

Many sales staffs run into the same problem. The best salesman is not always the best manager (Usually they are not.).

by whiterdragon

What worked for me is sane training in people skills. I'm not talking about psychology -- I tried that first and dind't find out anything useful in real life. Any sincere religious organization should be able to help, but the best results I've found are with Scientology. In addition to being "the world's fastest growing religion" and "the science of knowing how to know", Scientology is the first truly scientific study of people in that it was formed by 1) looking at lots of raw data, 2) forming theories about the data, 3)using the theories to predice new phenomena previously unknown, 4) verifying the applicability of the theories to ALL data -- old and new, and 5) discarding or refining any theory that did not cover all the data. The result is a workable science of people that ANYONE can learn to use to get along better with others.

by jrl21

Send the superstar to a training area where he will be taught how to deal with other people. This seems to be the only area he needs guidance on. If he comes out well and people start to like him a bit more and you'll feel better about promoting him.

by rdl

Try asking him whether he perceives (or has noticed) any issues or problems in his relationships with other staff. If he has, ask more questions about how he feels this could be addressed - get him to outline the problem and the solutions, then help him to achieve them. If the discussion falters, ask more targeted questions to lead it where you need it to go. The object is to bring him on side by getting him to contribute to the answer, and feel he has identified with the process. Keep it constructive (ie free of criticism of him or anyone else) at all times, if you can. Show you value his opinions, but steer the discussion and keep control of it - don't let it get into a slanging match. Show him you all value his work - the root of his problem could be insecurity. Also, if you can, bring other colleagues into the process, slowly at first, get them to show they value him as a person (but choose carefully, some people can be unwittingly cruel). Social skills need to be learned, but before they can be there has to be willingness to learn. Look at training for these situations, possibly for yourself as well as for him, as we can always learn more about handling these situations.

by goldmoon

You have raised a very interesting question, in response to which I would like to emphasize three points to consider
(I have not read all the replies in the thread and do apologize if some of these have been already mentioned):

1) Could his ?shrinking into the corner? indicate that he is occupied with this own thoughts on how he would approach, prioritize and solve the issues being discussed at these meetings? The very fact that he wants to become a manager suggests that he indeed has already developed his own managerial ideas, which he would like to bring forward and realize as a leader. His crude remarks may indicate that he is simply frustrated by the current managerial practices and there is a vast likelihood that his manners will greatly change when he is the one to organize and lead the meetings instead of merely participating and obeying the instructions concluded. What you may also want to look into is if the competence and attitude of majority of the team members are compatible with his exceptional mind and passion for work. (?)
2) Managerial skills are much more complex than mere people/social skills; these include much creativity in practice (which he does seem to possess) and the pre-existing knowledge of the specific techniques and best practices of how to organize, monitor and prioritize project/company goals and tasks and how to foster knowledge-sharing activities and a result-oriented attitude within a team. Most of the knowledge of the managerial methodologies and principles normally is acquired in a business college, which incorporates the understanding of what company culture and professional conduct means. If he does not yet possess this knowledge, he needs to complete his education by taking the respective college courses.
3) Just like managerial skills are much more complex than people/social skills, the so called people/social skills cover a much wider concept than one?s professional aptitude and conduct. Social/people skills can be beneficial ? both for team leaders and members - but the importance thereof should not be misrepresented and overemphasized against the values of great minds and field professionals who make the success of a company on an essential level. Furthermore, most of the social skills in a wide sense cannot be learnt; one needs to be born with them or born into the social/family environment where these can be naturally developed. However, not all of these social skills are needed for a manager. What is needed is the knowledge mentioned above and business-like professional conduct, which, as it was pointed out above, can be and should be learnt.

by rmrenneboog

I can see how your point of view works, but I sure don't agree with it. People tend to act only in the way that is expected of them. If you want to believe your employees are a commodity and treat them that way, then that is exactly the type of employee you are going to have throughout your company, including management. Predictable productivity, but well below what they are capable of in both quantity and quality, and a decided lack of creativity and innovation coming from anywhere within the company. If I had to guess, I'd say your company has to outsource just about everything that calls for creativity and fresh points of view, and has a monumental employee turnover rate. You can't soar like an eagle when you're working for turkeys.

by mgordon

Short answer: You'll probably lose your geek -- hard to say whether he will walk before HR fires him.

Long answer:

Social Darwinism is the game we play; it is the means by which each "kind" of person manipulates the environment to ensure success of his or her own kind.

Management is one kind; usually ESTJ but often ESFJ (Reference: Myers-Briggs MBTI). This kind enjoys control and involvement of people and is motivated by control and involvement of people. This kind values others of the same kind and is in competition with others of the same kind.

Readers of this site are very likely to be INTP, sometimes known as geeks when sufficiently intelligent and educated about computers and commensurately under-educated about human beings.

Being in control of machines, or pure logic (computer programming) is where the INTP obtains thrills. People are impediments, except for other INTPs with whom he may be intensely competitive, since it is the INTP class that invents machines in the first place.

In a sense, therefore, INTP's seek to control other people by dominating the inventions of those other people. Hackers are the extreme example of this; by finding flaws in software, he has found a flaw in the inventor, and thereby demonstrated his superiority over the inventor. Hackers are competitive with each other; hence the portfolios of "zombie machines" each possesses.

What this is supposed to lead to is reproductive success, wealth and fame; but in fact it seldom leads to this, which is why the INTP type is only about 3 percent of the population.

I obtained great wisdom from a negotiation seminar I once attended; followed by a series of tapes on the same subject.

INTP's need to consider some facts:

1. Everything you want is owned or controlled by someone else (an oversimplification but it will suffice).

2. Others cannot know what you _know_; they can only observe what you _DO_.

3. Consider carefully the message you are sending from what they observe. Do not rely on your own obviously flawed judgement; ask some "normal people" for help with dress, grooming, personal habits. It may seem incomprehensible that it makes a difference what color tie you wear with what color (and kind) of shirt, shoes and so forth; but it makes a BIG difference. When I worked at CacheNET for a while, I had just come from Washington DC where (almost) everyone wears shirt and tie every day. I continued to do so, I feel better about myself when I do. The combination of my self-awareness and dress radiated an authority; so that even though I was just an administrator, one of three such persons, when customers came in they invariably came to me with their questions, proposals, complaints and so forth. My dress and my demeanor conveyed authority and competence.

If it happens that what you do is "invisible" (you are stuck in a cubicle writing assembly language device drivers that will be incorporated into an application for which someone else gets the credit anyway) then you are doomed. Bad choice of occupation, unless you work for one of the five people in America that still value that kind of specialization.

But it's too late -- what if you already are a geek in a conventional corporation? You must diversify! What you do is "FM" to most people; do also some things that are comprehensible. Be the company graphic artist, the company photographer, write the newsletter. Most people are self-centered; be the LISTENER and let them talk. Amazingly, they will think YOU are brilliant when all you do is let people talk about THEIR achievements. Along the way, you not only ingratiate yourself, you actually do gain quite a lot of diverse knowledge and you will be happier in your employment. You will start to realize that "civilized people" are good people, and that dress codes are really a secret language by which civilized people detect other civilized people.

You can still be a geek at heart, but it makes a huge difference that outwardly you listen more than talk, dress neatly, and make other people happy.

by darinhamer

Pretty amazing post. I like what you say.

On caution, though, with MBTI. It can be useful in helping to improve communication by identifying different people's styles, but be careful about pigeon holing someone because of their MBTI type. I am an INTP, but not at all like you describe because I am middle-of-the-road on most of the measurements. What you are describing is someone who is off the charts on each of the measurements.

But in the end, your advice is great. Unfortunately, the off-the-charts INTPs will likely not be able to do what you suggest, no matter how hard they try, or even really understand what you are talking about. It takes all types to make the world go around. Sometimes it is best to realize what type you are and be O.K. with that. If that means you are an invisible geek, try to make the most of it. Enjoy it.

by goldmoon

While reading some replies in this thread I remembered that I have also observed a tendency of omitting an analytical approach to the concept of an employee?s ?good communication skills?, which is an issue implied in your original problem.
The questions I would like to raise related to this, are: who decides about the general values of an employee, - with an emphasis on his/her communication skills - why and on what power granted to him/her by what authorities,- especially if/when such skills are evaluated in a a context outside work?
The factors that should be considered in this regard:

1)How would the person who is empowered to perform such evaluation define the elements of ?good communication skills??
In most cases a person considers those to have ?good communication skills? with whom he/she can easily communicate.
2)However, on what OBJECTIVE basis can a person be empowered to decide if someone possesses good communication skills or not? For example: someone forming such judgment may as well be considered a bad communicator by the person he/she has been judged. I have personally observed on many occasions that the standards of the so called ?good communication skills? are often set by those who actually do not possess the necessary analytical and logical skills to make decisions in such matters, nor are they qualified to contribute to the expert content, within the context of which they are supposed to evaluate someone?s communication skills. The higher level an expert may be the more difficult it is to follow his/her thinking, hence the lower his/her communication skills will be deemed by the majority.
3) Further to the former point: since communication skills can be examined and evaluated only in a specific context and only with regard to the particular subject of a particular communication in a particular environment, one person can be an excellent communicator at work but may be silent and dull in social activities when topics outside of his/her interest are being discussed. The same person shying away from discussing a simple everyday subject at a company dinner, may as well be brilliant, witty and funny in another group discussing other topics, suc as scientific articles, philosophical questions, etc.
4) Good communication skills are also often referred to as good self-presentation skills, which is a very common conceptual mistake. These skills are essential only for the personnel directly facing the clients and/or the public, but considering this as a general requirement for all employees and managers is a rescue argument mostly cited by those who have nothing else to add to the company than an image.
I agree with the former poster that what the others will perceive is not what you know but what you DO, but to be precise: within what one does what really matters is what one DOES as a manifestation of his/her knowledge and work ethics, which is the knowledge, attitude and action that brings tangible results to the company. If your company?s managers and HR can only notice what your employee displays instead of what he/she does in essence, then HR itself and your managers should be fired as incompetent, otherwise your company will start to sink at the speed of light.

As I pointed out in my former post, the only absolute basis that can be referred to as a requirement in this regard is the objective elements of professional conduct, but the primary objective professional values are the actual and proven knowledge of an employee, his/her effective and efficient work and willingness and ability to transfer his/her knowledge, as well as his/her genuine love of work combined with perfect work ethics.

by stan0228

Toastmaster training of public speaking, planning, structuring presentaitons can spill over into the daily conversation and planning what and how to say it. Have him involved in committees with a mentor.

Don't give up on him. Let him know his weak points and strong points. Have a written plan of what to attack first with miles stones and time lines.
Good luck.

by ~neil

I've had to fire myself from management. Company I used to work for promoted me to team leader -- I happen to be a terrible manager. I did manage to get in on the hiring for my old position, found somebody who could do the management, and switched him into the team lead. I was much happier in my more technical role.

I see a lot of diagnoses in these threads based on little information. The actual answer is, you're going to have to troubleshoot him. *IS* he add/asberger/something else, and act accordingly. If he can't deal with people, can he be kept to a technical role? (My current position is sort of a 'floater'; I work on issues from all departments, whether they have much to do with my position, or not.)

If you've eliminated medical issues (some people have neurological issues, some are just shy ) then, sure, you might want to offer him advancement with people, contingent on his learning how.

Find out what his concept of management is, specifically. It might not be the same as yours (my concept of management I can do has very little to do with meetings).

Be as creative as you have the room to be (eg, maybe get him an assistant, or a junior he can mentor, that can take over at meetings, etc, etc), but if that doesn't work, you might have to let him go. There are a lot of good geeks out there.

Two good, old, articles on this topic:
http://www.fastcompany.com/online/25/geeks.html
http://www.plethora.net/~seebs/faqs/hacker.html

by hippikon

Made a lot of inflammatory remarks that many VPs surely feel (you HAVE to be that ruthless to reach there), but to actually express these opinions is blasphemy!!!! You have to be a really accomplished hypocrite (often fooling yourself) to reach these positions, and this person wasnt even trying to preach goodness to mankind through their deeds, as all leaders infallibly do...

by 39fhao9!z

Have you put yourself out in the marketplace since you got your MBA? What sorts of responses did you receive?

I'm thinking of getting my MBA. I have 10 years of tech experience, with 1 year of supervisory experience from a job long ago. I'm paid very well at my current job. I am not in management, but would like to be (I think). Primarily because I want the chance to be at the table when strategic discussions are held and decisions are made regarding how the company conducts its business, how to improve performance, products, skill-sets, delivery time, etc. I am convinced that getting an MBA will NOT help me at my current place of employment. But I can't help thinking that it would improve my chances of landing a low-level management position somewhere else.

Have you tried to find a management position somewhere else? Why not (if not)?

by asarme

Sounds like this employee may have a disability, perhaps high functioning Autism or Aspergers Syndrome. He/she may not even be diagnosed. If this is the case, it is a matter of understanding and providing the type of environment that suits them, rather than forcing them into the "expected social environment" that you speak of.

by ieorlady

He sounds like someone who is under the "Autistic Spectrum", Asperger's etc. as I am. I had similar problems and enrolled in a many month long Dale Carnegie class(es). I am now known as a "people person". I basically just learned techniques on how to handle people which where never inherent to me. Good luck!

by mdpetrel

Your "genius" is a train wreck for the same reasons he is brilliant: he is focused on his work.

That is why he will either not participate, or why he will say something socially inappropriate.

Have him work from home.

The odds are that he will put in 18 hrs per day for you, and you will get even MORE productivity out of him. If he is isolated from the rest of the team, what do you lose? Probably very little (be honest here...).

by a_dangerous_mind

I'm a developer and Mensa member, and I work off hours with a support group for gifted adults. This person sounds like he qualifies as gifted.

It's a stereotype that the gifted do not have social skills; rather, their giftedness means that they relate to others socially differently. Often others are far more sensitive to the faults of a gifted person than they would be to someone else.

Try videotaping at least one meeting and let him observe his own behavior. He may well see what needs improvement. He may well be his own best critic.

BTW, there are two good resources on what it means to be a gifted adult:

Jacobson, M.E. (1999). The gifted adult: A revolutionary guide to liberating everyday genius. New York: Ballantine Books.

Streznewski, M.K. (1999). Gifted grownups: The mixed blessings of extraordinary potential. New York: John Wiley and Sons.

This discussion is closed to new replies.