Discussion Locked

How much should this job pay?

0 helpful
130 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

130 replies

by lindo_wvw

"Thanks to the bosses who took a risk, I have a MSc and a Ph.D. degree in areas of IT, and it was all payed for."

Come on, there's no PH.D. in IT. What is it really?

by lindo_wvw

There are skilled people out there still trying to find jobs so don't just quit, job search and get a job offer first!

by techexec2

Some of your advice for Beachhead was good. Some of it not so much.

More information is needed to assess your salary. There are many factors. Skill and education are only two of them and not necessarily even the most important ones.

Questions:
- How large is the city where you work? (in terms of population; jobs in larger cities usually pay more than those in smaller ones)
- How large of a company? (number of employees; annual revenue; larger companies pay more than smaller ones)
- How many servers, users, etc.?
- How old are you? (sounds like you're about 25; age discrimination is illegal, and done every single day; "too young", make too little; "too old", make ZERO!)

And, the less clear but still relevant questions:
- Are you willing to move to another city to get what you want? Does your employer know that?
- Male or female? (yup, another illegal act done every single day)
- Married or single? How many children? (yup, ...well you get the idea)

Another question: Given your VERY little experience at this, why do you think you know you could not make $50-60K if you were marketed correctly?

by lindo_wvw

Thank you for your response, TechExec2.

-How large is the city where you work?
It is in a city of about 20,000. It is in the Metro-East area from St. Louis, Missouri, about 20 minutes from downtown St. Louis. I realize that the midwest has lower salaries and lower costs of living.

-How large of a company?
It is quite a small company. They have other offices in Bay Area, CA and MN but I am in the main office. There are probably 15 people there. They are however growing nicely and in a relatively new and growing field. (Data recovery.. clients are business with lost data, deleted, broken hard drives, raids, etc.). I will actually be the only one in my position, department even, which is programmer/analyst to work on their proprietary data recovery apps (real CS work there), their customer database and applications, and to eventually completely redo their customer database and related apps.

-How many servers, users, etc.?
This I cannot answer since I haven't yet started working there, very soon however. I won't really be an "IT" worker, more a developer. Everyone there is a computer geek to some degree. They seem to be doing all right without anyone in my position right now. They have had someone in the past however, but the position hasn't been filled for a while. They want to progress their business and proprietary tools (plus fix problems) and that is what the position is for. I will pretty much be doing my own thing, which I am ok with. I thought I might be worried, but I think I will like it. It could be beneficial to have people above you to learn from, but I won't have that.

- How old are you? (sounds like you're about 25; age discrimination is illegal, and done every single day; "too young", make too little; "too old", make ZERO!)
Hahah, well you are very close, I just turned 26. Also, I look younger apparently.

- Are you willing to move to another city to get what you want? Does your employer know that?
Yes I am. I am not tied down. I was actually applying to jobs in California since I have friends and relatives there, and I love hiking there (plus silicon valley, tech capital, etc). I am not sure if my employer knows that but he (CEO, President, founder, whatever... I interviewed with him) did mention that people with my background often get their first job, get some experience and then are out the door to something bigger and better. I don't know if that actually happened to him, maybe he reads slashdot or sites like this just like I do, only from the employer's perspective.

- Male or female?
Male. I didn't see a female in the place the couple times I went there. I guess that didn't surprise me since they are all computer geeks.

- Married or single? How many children?
Like I said, I am not tied down, so no wife or kids. As I understand it, this might be a hindrance to getting a job in the first place, but perhaps less of a depressor on wages as I am more mobile, correct?

-Another question: Given your VERY little experience at this, why do you think you know you could not make $50-60K if you were marketed correctly?
I don't know either way, because I have little experience :) Actually, we kept hearing that we (CS majors) could look forward to 40-50-60K right out of college. This was before the tech bust, but some people probably do now. At this point I am very glad to have a job that will give me experience because I went for a very long time not being able to get a job at all due to lack of experience (the obvious catch 22). Nevermind salary.

"...if you were marketed correctly?"
I don't really "market" myself. It has always felt like a lame and arrogant thing to do. I know that I should do it, I just have something against it. It is a problem I know, but I'm just not good at selling myself, and I don't brag. I royally hate the interviews with "life questions". I did well in school, worked very hard... have glowing recommendation letters from my last job, but I guess that isn't enough for some people. "Tell me about a time when you had a difficult project due and you were pressed for time, what did you do and what was the result?" "Tell me about a time when...," AAAAAAA "Where do you see yourself in X years?" How the hell should I know? Let's see how my first fricking job in my field starts out before I answer that one! "What is your greatest weakness?" What? How should I know? Maybe it's stupid interview questions.
If I was lucky, I could remember a particular situation and blubber out an answer, trying to spin it so it matched their criteria. If I ever become an interviewer, I won't stand them up, I won't be late, I won't mind if the interviewee is a little late, I won't ask ridiculous life questions, I won't require a full grueling day of interviews with half the people in a company, and I might not like people who sell themselves excessively. Wow I have much more to say here but this is incredibly long already.

by lindo_wvw

We hit max messages so I had to reply to one higher up:

Thank you very much. As I wrote my last comment, I felt quite good about the job.

Here is something I should probably tell you to get your thoughts. He says I will have a 1 year contract...a commitment...no way out of the contract within that year. I have not seen the contract yet. I take it that means I can't leave to work for someone else or what? Is it a two way thing? What does it imply?

-----

"You've worked hard and achieved some early success in your life."

Thanks. Well I had considered it a failure before this since I hadn't yet gotten a related job. I will put my diploma back on the wall (still in moving box). What I love is that I will regain that purpose in my life that I had in college, but was lost after college. I have a motivation beyond just my personal pride to do my best now unlike my last job :)

-----

"Your employer should know what you want in your life. If she likes your work and wants to keep you, she might do things to keep you happy and help you get what you want."

These things should happen regardless of my willingness to move to another location. Stupid reality.

-----

"The unspoken response from you should be that people with HIS background of not providing something bigger and better often lose their good people. It's a two-way street for opportunity providers and opportunity seekers. Your new job is clearly a stepping stone for you. First jobs, or near-first jobs, always are."

Yes I felt that. Since they are a very small company it almost seemed inevitable. I didn't say anything but I felt that is something that could be expected. I did explicitly mention that one of my major goals is to gain experience and he himself acknowledged the catch-22 with no help from me. I will try to make that clear from now on. I guess I'm not really one to ask for raises or complain about something. I feel it should come after I do a good job and they learn how good of an employee I am. I worked at my last job for 3 years and did my best (which was quite well), despite hating the work. When the employee review came I'd get the max 3% increase. Well 3% of nothing is nothing :) A quite large chunk of my income was from their incentive bonus program so my actual wage was kind of small. I expressed disappointment in one of those meetings and my supervisor at the time said she'd try to get me moved up a level on the income chart and was sincere. Also my coworkers thought I should be, even the ones on my same level. Well if I had stuck with it I probably could have gotten it, but the real problem with that job was still there so I left. I didn't like the work and had no desire to become a lead or supervisor or even manager in that department because it was just the same stuff.

-----

"Not exactly. Single people are less tied down and less stable than those with families. They are more likely to quit and become unemployed (as you did!) and are more likely to change employers."

Wow, it would be awful to be stuck in a job like my last one the rest of my life. It feels like I am a long way from being able to start a family.

In my last job, it really seemed like all the people getting married got promotions. It was crazy. I guess they were 'in'. Meanwhile I felt I could get laid off at any time, the entire time I worked there. They outsourced our same jobs to India, the dept on the other side of the wall disappeared, they've had layoffs in our area before. It was always a mystery what the higher-ups would do next. And this was when our dept and company was supposedly making more money than ever. Seriously, we should have made a union.

-----

"For employers who value stability, being single would be a hindrance. For employers who like people to work long hours it is a plus. It sounds like your new company is the more the latter."

You might have it there. I just heard last night that someone working there was getting home at 11pm. Now they are in the process of moving so that could be it. I could definitely see that. That's why I don't start right away, they want to move and get settled first. There were jokes about that since the guy is married. I said I'd look into it :) Well they can't make me work long hours if I don't want to. Since I should be doing my own thing and won't be in the production environment, that should help. I imagine I will choose to stay late if I have a problem I really want to fix or I want to get to a certain point on something. That is much preferable to the general pressure to work longer hours in my last job.

-----

"You might think it is a little early to be asking some of those interview questions of someone who is just starting out. Many will not have good answers. But, those who do are the stars who can often do extraordinary things far beyond "the job".

..or they are a good salesman and everyone perceives them as a star, but you still don't know if they'll be a good employee or a good person. I consider Bill Clinton a decent President but you have to admit that he was a sweet-talker. I sometimes feel that people that are good salesmen have advantages despite not being materially any better than others. I prefer plain honesty. I have decided to answer the "weakness" question in future interviews with "selling myself". Oh, also I should care more about money :)
Obviously, I did't answer questions that way.

There is something to be said about networking as well. I read that 80% of people get their jobs through networking. I have not been very good at it in the past, but I am working on that now and definitely improving. However I do hate that people get jobs because they know someone. I heard one employee at my new work who I was acquainted with a few years ago told the boss that I'm a good guy. Now that feels good, but I think it's awful for other people to get shut out because they don't know someone and through my long job search that seems to be the game.

I am very grateful for your input and time. I'm saving this conversation :)

by vince21

At least $40,000 a year and in Cali maybe ask for $60,000. Call IT support companies and ask them how much they would charge to do that for a company. Then show them how much are you saving them.

by the admiral

Outsourced - $.05 per hour

In-sourced - $14.00 per hour

You with experience - $22.12 per hour.

Add 120% for California

by jtakiwi

I would say your pay should be in the $25 - $35/hr w/ 3 or so years experience in those disciplines, less w/ less experience, but not $10/hr for crying out loud, you aren't washing cars. Now, that being said, that company won't pay you that, almost guaranteed. They will however pay a new guy that rate. Crazy world, huh? I'm sure they would give you a bit of a raise, but in their world view, they just don't double folks pay. They'll pay whatever they think you'll take. I've done work for car dealers in the past, the guys I did work for weren't happy w/ the rates we charges (too bad) and eventually got their alpha geek to handle stuff, then they called us to assist when it was more than an spyware problem.

by singerguy

I had a good friend named Nico Zwaneveld when I went to Orem Junior High School. He was from Holland and living in the states while his dad worked as a Dutch translator. He'd be 47 now. Any chance that's you?

by studpony

i have been in IT for almost 15 years. 1 thing i have learned is that all companies are going to pat you the absolute minimum you are willing to take. If you ask for a raise, you might get 5-10% at the most. If you move, you could easily double what you make.

I have spent several years working my way up at several companies only to get 2, 3, 4 % raises per year. When I have changed companies, the least I was able to get was a 35% increase.

Make sure you have a solid offer before you quit. Do not tell your new employer what you are making now. If it is low (and it is) they will not think you are experienced enough and won't respect you. If you tell them you are making way more than you are, they might find out and consider you dishonest.

If they ask you how much you make, counter by asking how much the position pays (usually expressed as a range).

Good luck

by gizelle

I'm from a small town in Wisconsin and we are known for conservative pay scales and $10 for what you do is unheard of. With your skills and experience (not knowing what town/city in CA) I would expect to be getting a minimum of $18-$20/hour. I work for the County, and our pay scale is well below the private sector. Our entry level IT personnel (people who just hook up the computers and might have Associate Degree in networking) start at $17/hour. I would start looking for another job because most dealerships won't pay what you're worth.

by jck

grease you up first? Cause, you're getting screwed.

$10.00 an hour? My God. There are kids working in McDonalds in CA making about as much as you with 2 years experience flipping burgers and mopping floors.

Honestly. First step...hunt for other jobs...line some up...get offers.

Then, go to your boss and tell him that you feel you've proved your worth in the past two years and that you would like to discuss wages more in line with your job function. And, don't ask him what he will pay you. Suggest what you want that is reasonable.

I don't know what area of CA you live in, but I'd guess that if you live in a very low-cost area for CA...you'd wanna make a minimum of $40k per year. If you're in somewhere like Marin Co. or Santa Rosa Co., maybe $55k-60k.

That way if they're not willing to pay you what you are worth, you have jobs lined up and can move onto better pastures if they're not willing to treat you right.

by techexec2

I like your attitude. You've worked hard and achieved some early success in your life. You have a good new IT job that sounds good for you. I would say the salary of your new job is about right for where you are now. All the best to you in your new job!

Below are some more detailed comments that I hope will be of help to you.

-----

St. Louis, Missouri
- A smallish city. About 2.75 million people in the entire metro area.
- Your suburb of only 20,000 is very small.
- You could make more in the same job in a larger metro area like New York (19 million), Los Angeles (13 million), or Chicago (9.5 million).

Company size
- There is nothing wrong with this company for you at this time. It's a good place to learn and grow for now.
- Your company is very small (15 people in your office).
- A larger company in a larger metro city will pay more.
- There would be more opportunities to grow in a larger company. But, once again, this is not a bad place for you right now. You can grow in your new job. Growth is the most important thing early on in your career.
- There is not a strong career path within this company for you due to its small size. You will likely need to leave it after a few years in order to continue learning and growing.

-----

Regarding:

"...I am not sure if my employer knows that..."

Your employer should know what you want in your life. If she likes your work and wants to keep you, she might do things to keep you happy and help you get what you want.

-----

Regarding:

"...people with my background often get their first job, get some experience and then are out the door to something bigger and better..."

The unspoken response from you should be that people with HIS background of not providing something bigger and better often lose their good people. It's a two-way street for opportunity providers and opportunity seekers. Your new job is clearly a stepping stone for you. First jobs, or near-first jobs, always are.

-----

Regarding:

"...I am not tied down, so no wife or kids. As I understand it, this might be a hindrance to getting a job in the first place, but perhaps less of a depressor on wages as I am more mobile, correct?..."

Not exactly. Single people are less tied down and less stable than those with families. They are more likely to quit and become unemployed (as you did!) and are more likely to change employers. For employers who value stability, being single would be a hindrance. For employers who like people to work long hours it is a plus. It sounds like your new company is the more the latter.

-----

Regarding:

"...I don't really "market" myself. It has always felt like a lame and arrogant thing to do. I know that I should do it, I just have something against it. It is a problem I know, but I'm just not good at selling myself, and I don't brag. I royally hate the interviews with "life questions". I did well in school, worked very hard... have glowing recommendation letters from my last job, but I guess that isn't enough for some people. "Tell me about a time when you had a difficult project due and you were pressed for time, what did you do and what was the result?" "Tell me about a time when...," AAAAAAA "Where do you see yourself in X years?" How the hell should I know? Let's see how my first fricking job in my field starts out before I answer that one! "What is your greatest weakness?" What? How should I know? Maybe it's stupid interview questions.
If I was lucky, I could remember a particular situation and blubber out an answer, trying to spin it so it matched their criteria..."

You know this: There is a lot more to life and work than knowing how to fix a computer, even if that is your primary job. There is management of people and projects. Sales. Marketing. Advertising. Customer support skills (every business has 'em). Being a good judge of character. Business planning. Steadfastness under pressure. Etc. Even if your job doesn't make you responsible for leading others and the business itself, knowing these things makes you a better follower and a better employee.

You might think it is a little early to be asking some of those interview questions of someone who is just starting out. Many will not have good answers. But, those who do are the stars who can often do extraordinary things far beyond "the job". Not to introduce politics or endorse anyone, but I would expect that Bill Clinton would have given stronger answers to those questions at age 26. He was elected Governor of Arkansas at age 33 and President at age 46.

A ship without a rudder can sail around really hard in a circle and go nowhere. Think about it. Most companies have a five-year plan. They change it every year, sometimes significantly. But, that plan gives them the rudder they need so they go somewhere that they think is worthwhile.

Those interview questions are relevant even if you are just starting out or don't have huge ambitions. There are some very big and important things for you to work on in addition to the tech stuff. All the best to you and congratulations on your new job.

by firstpeter

The real answer is really whatever it would cost them to go find the appropriate person(s) to do it for. If they had to replace you, what would it cost them?

To manage all of that I'd GUESS (because I'm not sure the particular situation) that you should probably be at - bare minimum - $50K. If you're managing servers, 150 workstations and all the telcom stuff they're probably not going to be able to find anyone to do all that for less...much less someone familiar with the company that's a known entity (a HUGE value).

To ask for it I'd probably put together a list of the duties you've got, do a little outside intelligence work on what folks doing the same thing are making, and then set up some time with the boss. Not confrontational, but very appropriately point out that you've shown for the last two years that you can do this, and you're currently making x% of what an entry-level person would make in this type of situation. You know the company, you know the business, you know the people, the systems, etc., and you'd like to request that your salary (or hourly - whatever) be bumped up to a reasonable level.

Make sure you point to past successes and any data you've got that shows that a replacement would cost more than you. Not to give them an option, but to show them that you're still a great value at $y/hour...just not as great a value as you were at $10/hour. :)

by jeroldo9

Considering the responsibility level and the knowledge required in order to maintain the spread of hardware you describe, if you are not making $20 per hour and receiving benefits such as Medical, dental and vision coverage, then you are being underpaid. $20 per hour pays just over 40k for a forty hour week. ($20 x 2,080 hrs/yr)

Generally, people working at McDonalds and Wal-Mart make more than $10 if they are living/working in California. What is your idea of your own self-worth?

One problem,IMHO,is that IT is generally considered to be a "maintenance" position. Jobs in maintenance areas are usually looked down upon by employers because they "cost" but usually do not directly produce income. They do produce income by keeping the income producers producing but "appear" to bring little or nothing in while being responsible for seemingly large amounts of money going "out." Convincing an employer that they should pay you for costing them lots of money is not an easy thing to do. Still, in all fairness, your responsibility level, education level and skill and experience are worth a heck of a lot more than $10 an hour.

by wncsnoopy24

I have read through most of the posts and agree that $10 per hour is sickening! I'm a server in a restaurant..not even upscale and I make 20$ per hour(during tourist season) and about 15$ during the "off season" + my $2.13 in "wages" that I donate to Uncle Sam..

I'm currently going to school(at age 40!) for CyberCrime Technologies and HOPE I can get a job that will pay more than 35K per year..If not, I suppose I'll continue in the restaurant biz as a server!

The best part about your job is that you gained some incredible experience and at a very young age, however, you're not a teenager anymore and you deserve more respect. You have way too many responsibilities for too little pay! Web Masters alone make more than 35K here in the mountains of Western NC.

What ever you do, good luck to ya! If you find yourself between jobs and unemployed, there's always fast cash in restaurants..and I assure you , more than 10$ per hour.

by techexec2

A contract can be anything. You know THEIR objective: To put strings on you so you cannot quit for a year. The contract will spell out the penalty if you do. It could be a monetary payment from you to them. Or, this might be a non-compete contract. That is, if you quit before the year is up, you agree to not work in the field for a competitor. That kind of contract is illegal in some states. I don't think it is illegal in Missouri.

In any event, when you give something in a contract agreement, you should get something from them in return. Perhaps you should get a no-layoff provision for the year -- they cannot fire you without cause. Or, even better, they should pay for your MCSE certification training and exams.

I recommend you get a copy of the contract ASAP and ensure you really are in agreement. And, if you can, politely, get them to agree to give something in exchange for what you are giving them beyond coming to work each day.

Good luck!

by sakuhara

How much do you really have anything to do with the servers and routers? DNS, Active directory, Symantec, Backup and restore. Or is all this done from a remote location after you make the phone call or submit a service ticket? 1 help desk for 75 clients is not bad ratio depending on your toolset such as Altiris etc.

I definetly think $10 is WAY under paid. but if you are help desk and not admin then think of your carrer progression and get some certs on their dime....ignore site specific things like the phone stuff and pick an area you'd be interested in. But honestly don't even start in the IT feild, with all the remote asset management capabilities companies feel just fine letting users wait for trouble ticket remediation and do not care if the user sees an IT person or not.

by angry_white_male

Factor in a raise above that if you're in a high cost of living area.

Bottom line - you're being exploited... odds are you won't get the pay you deserve... update your resume and start looking for another job.

by skydive36

Rule number one for asking a raise " you gotta check the financial status of that company at the time of demand". Usually managers will refuse such request if the company is not doing that well, so this is for you to check first.

For your wage i think 10/hour is way too low, you mentioned multi-franchise auto dealership, for sure they can afford to pay you more if you are taking care of all these branches.
Prepare your approach, garnesh it with some future project for the business, some needed upgrades and among all strenghten yourself by planning on getting a new certificat(and tell them about it) for example if you have a windows network go for and MCSE, it will empower your knowledge and get you on higher scale income!

Hope all goes well!

by oldbag

Sorry it took so long to reply to this but I was on vacation and did not touch a PC for a whole week.

I did work for ADP but with the Parts and Service application. Since all of this interfaces, I still may have had the occasion to speak with your better half.

By the way, there are a lot of really great microbreweries in Portland.

by kevinf

Certs are nice but experience and a sense of efficiency and a level head are a must. I don't have any certs and yes, it is tough finding a job. I am looking into that. I find though that experience has always been the best indicator of someone's performance.

by uplinkspider

Pardon me for being blunt but you?re not being underpaid ? You?re being exploited. Look at the local job ads and assess the skill sets they?re looking for versus the pay being offered. This should give you a pretty good idea of the current job market and salary/wage potential but be aware that the scale of compensation has gone down drastically from just a few short years ago and continue to devalue as well as terms of employment. All it takes is a few techies willing to discount their services to set a standard and depreciate a compensation band. Perhaps this is another argument for unions but that?s the subject matter of another posting. As a previous commentator posted; I too never saw a company moved to pay 200% to 300% to bring an employee's salary to par with scale/skill sets ? Not while somebody else is willing to do the job for much less. They rather look for somebody like you who will sell their hard earned/learned skill sets at a great discount and if you do play the ?Give Me a Raise or I'll Walk Out? hand make sure you?re playing from a position of power by having something lined up ? better yet when you do find something better just leave as gracefully as possible because let?s say that you do get your raise you can be assured that it?ll come with a payload of resentment and end with the ultimate retaliation in the form of a dismissal after replacing you with somebody just like you, somebody you most likely trained to replace you.

by rayanami

I am handling 30 computers, 3 servers, purchases, maintenance, web designing, and network administration. I am quite happy with the pay as I am earning akmost twice the minimum wage in our country. But should I be happy with it with the amount of responsibilities that I have? I am a one-man IT manager.

by sakuhara

For what you are doing that sounds about right 10-15 dollars an hour. You will not get much more unless you can get some real exposure / experience...You did not mention any education, certs or how long you've been there. Your current enviroment sounds like a really small business...and they just dont pay!

by rayanami

that's my problem, I am an undergraduate. I was in my fourth year taking up computer science when I quit and worked. That is why, even though that I feel that Im not getting enough for what I do, I still work here.
i think i'll be staying here for a year or two to get enough experience then try my luck with bigger companies.

by necomputerpro

I agree, but would first look for and accept another other opportunity elsewhere. When you inform them that you are leaving they may or may not want you to stay.

If they have fired others in this position, I question whether you should stay. Ideally, work for a place that appreciates you.

This discussion is closed to new replies.