Discussion Locked

HR Folders, know your rights

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
In the past when working in retail, a sum of over ten years in management; I was always told and what seem to work best in reprimanding, documenting a situation or incident such as tardiness, non-cooperative, repetitive negligence and so on was to first document the situation then cover it with the employee ask him to sign it or just acknowledge the act then file it in their employee folder. In my current job a typical office environment, one of my duties is to manage the HR folders; just recently I discovered that every one had a separate folder with write-ups of one such thing or another. I went through a couple of weeks of coming late to work, no more that ten minutes at a time but never the less late. I had conversation with a supervisor on a more personal level on solutions in handling my tardiness and offered to do what ever it took to make the atmosphere more comfortable for the other employees, which started to point fingers when ever they were late. I expressed that I would not have a problem with a write-up or a training day on my downfalls. She replied that she had already sought after council and was told that she did not need to show me or anyone her write-ups nor did she need us to sign them. So my questions are; isshe using the correct procedures and how can I guard my self on a legal dispute.

8 replies

by penguinsrule

Give everybody a pager and tell them that they are on 24x7x365 support. When you are chained to the pager then there is more flexibility as you are responsible for work when the pager goes off.

by ann777

I don't know which state you are in, nor do i know any specific laws pertaining to these issues.

It seems to me that she is incorrect in her statement that she does "not need to show me or anyone her write-ups nor did she need us to sign them." My understanding is that any Supervisor that is trying to correct a behavior, needs to (1) first issue a verbal warning and (2) if the problem persists, she then needs to document and write up the problem and present it in written form to the person with the problem. (3) the person then has the right to request a written plan from the supervisor on how she/he will be evaluated for improvement in that issue (lateness is easy) plan of action should be signed by both parties agreeing to the planfor correction and the ramifications if the problem continues. This could lead to termination. But depending on your state's laws and specifics....

You need to seek the advise of a local lawyer specifically with regard to "wrongful termination laws."

by timwalsh

Labor laws will vary from state to state. Not being a lawyer, I can't say for certain that there are specific processes for documenting the types of behavior you describe, layed out in labor law.

I, however, also come from a background (the military) where this process of documentation and counseling was necessary to be able to prove any disciplinary action taken was warrented. In a business climate, I feel that this same process is prudent to prevent disciplined (or fired) employees fromfiling frivolous harassment suits (I was fired because: I'm black, I'm a woman, I'm Jewish, I'm 63 years old, my boss didn't like the color of my hair, etc.). Without something to prove that an attempt was made to correct improper employee behavior, with the acknowledgement of the employee that the attempt was made (signed counceling form), it often comes down to the word of the supervisor vs. the word of the employee.

There can also be an issue of what are the companies acknowledged policies for dealing with improper employee behavior and are these policies followed.

Ultimately though, I think this is just a matter of prudence vs. legal requirements.

To guard yourself, you might want to create a document laying out your version of the events, any mitigating circumstances, what remedies you are willing to take to correct the situation, etc. Then try to get the supervisor to sign your document (acknowledging that your version of events at least substantially agrees with the supervisor's version of events). If the supervisor refuses to sign the document, you might want a witness available to at least acknowledge and verify that you attempted to remedy the situation.

(continued)

by timwalsh

But, the bottom line is that if the company has written policy or guidance (show up to work on time; three strikes and you're out; etc.), and your actions were not consistant with those policies (which you appear to admit), the company probably has no legal requirement to take into account any mitigating circumstances (whether beyond your control or not) before taking disciplinary actions. This may not necessarily make good business sense, but it doesn't make it illegal.

Hope this helps.

This discussion is closed to new replies.