Discussion Locked

I Just Want to Program! Don't Make Me Learn Math!

0 helpful
473 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

473 replies

by dbenito

[i]"You don't get around much. Some computer geeks have interests -- and knowledge -- outside the limits of mathematics."[/i]

What I meant is that computer geeks tend to shy away from pseudoscience. Do you also check the astrology readings in the daily newspaper?

[i]"Considering you're the one who brought up high school, I cry foul on your straw man. Feel free to keep rambling about it, though."[/i]

Considering I never said anything for or against high school, I fail to see how this has any relation to our discussion.

[i]"Where you got the idea that I claimed you meant that symbolic logic is not related to programming is beyond me. Where do you get these ideas? I never said, nor even implied, any such thing. Is it because I mentioned it in a sentence that also mentioned your difficulty recognizing the strong relevance of algebraic mathematics?"[/i]

Go back and re-read the first and second paragraphs of your response to my original message, and you'll see why. If you dedicate an entire paragraph to explain the role of logic in programming, it's fair to assume that you think I am not aware of it.

[i]"You didn't say it before, so you're not saying it again."[/i]

Actually, I did say it before, only in another post in this thread. You see, I've been dealing not only with you with two of your worshippers whose central argument was that I wasn't supposed to argue with someone of your stature. What you said was "programming is basically just really fun algebra"; in another message I explained that while certain programming languages bear a superficial resemblance to the high-school algebra, programming itself bears little relation to any kind of algebra you care to call on.

[i]"Yes, I do. That's why I talked about it. Do you?"[/i]

I definitely do. I just found it surprising that someone lacking even a basic understanding of the foundations of calculus would have bothered to study considerably more complex mathematical subjects. Congratulations.

[i]"What kind of idiot are you that you think I confused "orthogonal" with "tangential"? I very clearly differentiated between the two, you f*cking dumbass."[/i]

As a sanity check, I went back and re-read your original response to my message. Lo and behold, you do indeed claim that you used "orthogonal" instead of "tangential" because it was "more appropriate". If you understand the difference between the two concepts, you'll also understand that there really isn't any context in which one would be acceptable but the other is more appropriate. They mean entirely different things! To infer from your message that you don't understand the difference is therefore not at all unreasonable.

[i]"Don't take it personally when I describe calculus in terms that don't make it sound like the fruit of the tree of knowledge. You may, if you like, take it personally when I point out that your inability to think outside the box is simply appalling, though."[/i]

I'm sorry, but you can't say you aren't criticizing calculus and at the same time call it "mathematical guesstimation". It makes about as much sense as if I suddenly claimed that I had nothing against the whole MBTI rubbish, and yet I kept on calling it a pseudoscience.

[i]"The fact that I mentioned a distaste for calculus in the same post that I mentioned calculus isn't much relevant to programming doesn't link them as a statement of causation. Learn some reading comprehension. Attack the argument, not the person. Get a clue."[/i]

It's hard to attack the argument when there is none. Positing calculus as something incompatible with "algebraic thinking", and therefore blaming calculus for making "algebraic thinkers" change majors makes no sense at all. You might as well have pulled it out of one of the Discworld novels.

It's funny that you should get all incensed by what you perceive to be an ad hominem argument, and yet have no qualms in employing it constantly yourself.

[i]"It's not my fault that your thinking is so limited in scope that you can't clue in on the concept of a descriptive phrase like "algebraic thinking". I suppose you would have the same problem with the phrase "circular reasoning", since examples of reasoning don't have radii."[/i]

And yet you still haven't been able to explain what you mean by "algebraic thinking". Care to elaborate? And try to keep the vulgarity down to a minimum...

by apotheon

"[i]What I meant is that computer geeks tend to shy away from pseudoscience. Do you also check the astrology readings in the daily newspaper?[/i]"

Let me know when you're done with the "psychology isn't real science" straw man. I don't want to interrupt your romantic interlude.

"[i]Considering I never said anything for or against high school, I fail to see how this has any relation to our discussion.[/i]"

It doesn't have anything to do with the discussion. That's what makes your repeated mention of high school a "straw man".

"[i]Go back and re-read the first and second paragraphs of your response to my original message, and you'll see why. If you dedicate an entire paragraph to explain the role of logic in programming, it's fair to assume that you think I am not aware of it.[/i]"

Your claim was that I said you claimed symbolic logic wasn't related to programming. What I actually said was that you apparently failed to link algebraic logic with programming logic.

What makes you think that claiming I've said things I haven't will somehow convince me I'm wrong?

"[i]Actually, I did say it before, only in another post in this thread.[/i]"

Quote it, with a link to the source. I don't believe you. By the way, all your nattering on about "programming" and "algebra" bearing no relation to one another is not only poppycock, but irrelevant to your assertion that you'd already said the fact some functional languages use "brackets" (actually, they tend to use parentheses) and function names doesn't mean they're algebraic. Since the commentary about the relationship between programming and algebra had previously been about similarities of logic and not parentheses or function names, your commentary about syntactic sugar was not only irrelevant, but previously unrepresented in the discussion.

"[i]whose central argument was that I wasn't supposed to argue with someone of your stature[/i]"

Como se huh? Nobody said anything of the kind. They just pointed out that your argumentum ad hominem fallacies were particularly ill-conceived considering they're aware of my history of useful contributions while your history so far is of vitriol and trollish behavior (paraphrased).

"[i]As a sanity check, I went back and re-read your original response to my message. Lo and behold, you do indeed claim that you used 'orthogonal' instead of 'tangential' because it was "more appropriate". If you understand the difference between the two concepts, you'll also understand that there really isn't any context in which one would be acceptable but the other is more appropriate. They mean entirely different things! To infer from your message that you don't understand the difference is therefore not at all unreasonable.[/i]"

When did I say one is "acceptable but the other is more appropriate"? The problem here is not that it's reasonable to infer that I don't understand the difference -- it's that you are making inferences based on things I never actually said.

"[i]I'm sorry, but you can't say you aren't criticizing calculus and at the same time call it 'mathematical guesstimation'.[/i]"

Sure I can. I never said "mathematical guesstimation" was a bad thing, for instance. You're attaching valuative judgments where they are not warranted or intended. Perhaps your problem in this case is that you take some things [b]way too friggin' seriously[/b].

"[i]It's hard to attack the argument when there is none.[/i]"
. . . that didn't go over your head.

"[i]Positing calculus as something incompatible with 'algebraic thinking'[/i]"

Reading comprehension again. I never said anything about incompatibility.

"[i]It's funny that you should get all incensed by what you perceive to be an ad hominem argument, and yet have no qualms in employing it constantly yourself.[/i]"

I get the distinct impression that your understanding of "argumentum ad hominem" was gleaned from a website somewhere created by someone who got the term from another website somewhere, and you stopped reading at the point where it was mentioned that an argumentum ad hominem fallacy involves "attacking" the "person". An argument directed at the person only becomes an argumentum ad hominem fallacy (literally, a fallacy of arguing against the person -- not necessarily of attacking the person) when the argument against the person [b]takes the place of an argument against the preceding argument[/b]. In other words, while you have engaged in argumentum ad hominem fallacies by attacking me [b]instead of my arguments[/b], I have not engaged in such fallacious reasoning because my (rare) disparaging comments about you were simply seasoning sprinkled over my actual arguments.

"[i]And yet you still haven't been able to explain what you mean by 'algebraic thinking'. Care to elaborate? And try to keep the vulgarity down to a minimum...[/i]"

Wow. I'd really hoped that my reference to circular reasoning would have clued you in.

Do you think differently when reasoning through the logic of an algebraic expression than when you react negatively to kiddie porn? Okay, good. Now, start thinking about how that thinking is [b]different[/b], and you'll be halfway there.

I'd analogize it for you, but at the moment nothing comes to mind as a useful analogy. C'est la vie. Sometimes I forget my telephone number, too.

by apotheon

Basicaly, computer science is all about [b]computation[/b]. Programming is manifest computation. Thus, while I speak specifically of programming, I refer in general to computational theory and related matters.

Now . . . explain to me where calculus fits into that.

by apotheon

. . . but [b]computer science itself[/b] is not grounded in calculus. If you want the complementary electronics engineering, complete with calculus, study that [b]along with[/b] computer science -- don't try to substitute parts of it into the CompSci curriculum.

by apotheon

"[i]You've missed my point, which is that, by and large, universities have become trade schools.[/i]"

That may well have been [b]a point[/b] of yours, but it's not the point that was conveyed by the statement "That flexibility exists by way of different degree paths."

"[i]To maintain that one is 'forced' to study that which you find extraneous in order to learn to be a 'programmer' is specious indeed.[/i]"

Replace the word "programmer" with the term "computer scientist" if it makes you feel better. My statements are still accurate.

by dbenito

[i]"If that's what you though the "logic" was, I think you either failed some logic courses or failed some reading comprehension somewhere along the way."[/i]

I'm sorry, but several posts later you still haven't explained what you mean by "algebraic thinking", in a way that explains why "algebraic" thinkers cannot cope with calculus. If by "algebra" you mean a set of elements and operations on them according to some specific axioms, I fail to see how calculus doesn't come under that category.

If you did really have a point, and did not use the term "algebraic thinking" to distract us from the fact that your argument was based on your distaste for calculus, then I would be very grateful if you could enlighten me, given my extremely limited comprehension ability.

[i]"It's blindingly obvious."[/i]

Then why are you having such a hard time explaining it? You ramble on about the "characteristics of algebra as contrasted with something non-algebra", and say absolutely nothing.

[i]"So . . . now you're putting down psychology, too. Are you capable of going three sentences without insulting someone?"[/i]

OK, time to nit-pick. Where have I put down psychology as a field? The fact that I, along with a number of other people, consider MBTI concepts to have no basis in fact (I find it hard to believe that any scientist would consider Jung's introspection to be acceptable scientific methodology). This is a classic case of what Feynman called "cargo-cult science" - just because people publish papers about it doesn't mean it's correct.

[i]"which, while clearly related to mathematics in general, has very little to do with calculus"[/i]

Would you be willing to reformulate the entire field of analysis without using set theory and logic? I didn't think so - so we'll just strike the whole "has very little to do with calculus" from the record.

[i]"Algebraic mathematics fields are not just about variables. Holy crap. I suddenly doubt your claims of mathematics-fu."[/i]

My bad - as I mentioned in another post, given your patent lack of mathematical knowledge I never expected you to be acquainted with anything going by the name of "algebra", beyond what is taught as "algebra" in high-school (and you'll see that in several other posts I make that distinction specifically).

That said, given the way you sometimes refer to specific concepts like linear algebra or abstract algebraic logic and sometimes simply talk about "algebra", it's not particularly easy to know what you're referring to at some points. You might as well talk about "stuff", and redefine it every time you backpedal.

I won't deny that certain classes of Boolean algebras can be used to model computational processes (they're an essential tool for chip designers), but that is far beyond the scope of any CompSci curriculum. Do you really think programmers need to know about cylindrical algebras? Might as well teach them about the zeros of p-adic L-functions ;-)

To close this inane discussion, I'd like to pretend that you did actually have some kind of structured argument against the need for calculus, and explain why I think that studying calculus can actually help a programmer. Any decent course in calculus should cover topics such as functions, limits and convergence (otherwise calculus doesn't make much sense), and these are all extremely useful when reasoning about algorithms.

I hope you're very happy with your moral high ground! I've got better things to do than argue with someone who, when confronted with his ignorance about calculus, goes into calculated tirades...

by apotheon

I just don't understand why so many people seem to think that calculus is a core competency for such a "deeper understanding". It's not. It's a dingleberry on the butt of computer science, a cling-on left over from the days when CompSci grew out of other disciplines (as Tony Hopkinson pointed out).

Think of it in another context. Would you say that evaluating the quality of a hammer is a core competency of architecture, just because architecture can ultimately be traced back to carpentry? The fact that both need to know something about the comparative strengths of different types of wood does not prove that the architect requires all the skills of the carpenter just to do the job of architecture.

By the same token, while a deep understanding of mathematical concepts related to computation can be invaluable to a computer scientist, those mathematical concepts that are essentially irrelevant to computational theory are also essentially irrelevant to computer science as a field of study. They provide no "deeper understanding" of computer science.

by mikeh

Relational databases came out of the work of Edgar Codd, who laid down the mathematical framework upon which they are built. ANSI SQL is a set-oriented language, among other things. SQL has solid mathematical underpinnings and could not have been developed without math.

A software module can be represented as a strongly connected directed graph. The number of basis paths, and therefore the number of test cases required to exercise all the logic in a module, is defined with mathematical precision by its cyclomatic complexity metric. This is a direct application of graph theory to testing software.

I have both created and implemented algorithms. Inductive logic can be used to prove the validity of algorithms. Inductive proofs are taught in discrete math courses.

It is not possible to write device drivers without knowing math. It is not possible to understand UNIX permissions without understanding bit fields and binary arithmetic. It is not possible to use the bit operators that are part of almost every programminglanguage without knowing math. It is not possible to write hardware abstraction layers without knowing math. It is not possible to model systems such as weather or routing without math. It is not possible to write control software for machinery without math. It is not possible to write operating systems without math.

Without math there would be no computers and no programming languages. To say mathematics is not fundamental to software development and provides no unique insights borders on absurd.

by apotheon

"[i]I'm sorry, but several posts later you still haven't explained what you mean by 'algebraic thinking, in a way that explains why 'algebraic' thinkers cannot cope with calculus.[/i]"

I never said anyone couldn't cope with calculus. Stop putting words in my mouth. Either your reading comprehension is even poorer than I thought, or you're making crap up maliciously.

"[i]If you did really have a point, and did not use the term 'algebraic thinking' to distract us from the fact that your argument was based on your distaste for calculus, then I would be very grateful if you could enlighten me, given my extremely limited comprehension ability.[/i]"

I think you could solve that comprehension problem pretty quickly if you stopped imagining I said things that I didn't say. Until you do that, I don't think anything I say could help clear up the matter. Once you do that, I think you'll notice that I don't need to say anything else for it all to make sense -- you just need to read it without making unfounded assumptions about my meaning and without concocting bizarre statements to attribute to me.

"[i]I find it hard to believe that any scientist would consider Jung's introspection to be acceptable scientific methodology[/i]"

I find it absurd that someone can talk about scientific methodology but doesn't realize that the questionable origin of an idea does not itself impugn the idea.

"[i]Would you be willing to reformulate the entire field of analysis without using set theory and logic? I didn't think so - so we'll just strike the whole 'has very little to do with calculus' from the record.[/i]"

I wouldn't be willing to reformulate the entire field of analysis [b]at all[/b], so we should just strike that comment of yours from the record.

"[i]My bad - as I mentioned in another post, given your patent lack of mathematical knowledge I never expected you to be acquainted with anything going by the name of 'algebra', beyond what is taught as 'algebra' in high-school (and you'll see that in several other posts I make that distinction specifically).[/i]"

You make many, many unfounded assumptions, and that I think is really the root of the problem here.

"[i]That said, given the way you sometimes refer to specific concepts like linear algebra or abstract algebraic logic and sometimes simply talk about 'algebra', it's not particularly easy to know what you're referring to at some points.[/i]"

Generally, if my reference to "algebra" is generic, I refer to algebraic mathematics in the generic. Is that so difficult to understand?

"[i]I won't deny that certain classes of Boolean algebras can be used to model computational processes (they're an essential tool for chip designers), but that is far beyond the scope of any CompSci curriculum. Do you really think programmers need to know about cylindrical algebras? Might as well teach them about the zeros of p-adic L-functions[/i]"

When did I ever say that CompSci majors should study cylindrical algebras? I similarly did not say that electronics engineers (people who actually [b]should[/b] study a lot of calculus) should study tensor calculus. The fact that I pointed out algebraic mathematics is more important than calculus for computer science in no way implies that someone majoring in CompSci should necessarily study every mathematical subfield that has the word "algebra" somewhere in the name or description.

"[i]Any decent course in calculus should cover topics such as functions, limits and convergence (otherwise calculus doesn't make much sense), and these are all extremely useful when reasoning about algorithms.[/i]"

Functions, limits, and convergence as concepts useful to algorithm design do not necessitate twelve credits of calculus study. Somehow, though, a CompSci major generally [b]does[/b] require at least that much calculus study -- because people advance exactly the facile, and incompletely reasoned, argument that you just presented.

Hell, limits and convergence can be covered sufficiently in an afternoon for a reasonably intelligent student body, and functions are in no way specific to calculus on any planet. In fact, I actually learned about functions in junior high school (since you like bringing up high school so much), long before I ever encountered calculus as more than a word that vaguely referred to some kind of mathematical "stuff".

edit: typo

by dbenito

[i]"Let me know when you're done with the "psychology isn't real science" straw man. I don't want to interrupt your romantic interlude."[/i]

Clearly you don't know much about psychology if you equate MBTI with the field as a whole. Read my other post and stop repeating yourself. Psychology, when done properly, can be a science. Personality indicators are an example of what happens when you pretend to do science but make things up instead.

[i]"It doesn't have anything to do with the discussion. That's what makes your repeated mention of high school a "straw man"."[/i]

I only mention "high-school" as a qualifier for what most people on this board would call "algebra" (and which, without any previously knowledge of your education, one might reasonably expect you to refer to by that name). If you had been condescending enough to explain to us what you were talking about, we might have spared everybody else a pretty stupid discussion. As you said yourself, you're the only one who knows what you mean - but if you don't explain it clearly people are bound to misinterpret you.

[i]"Your claim was that I said you claimed symbolic logic wasn't related to programming. What I actually said was that you apparently failed to link algebraic logic with programming logic."[/i]

Again, one has to go by what you write, not by what you think. Show me where you said that you thought I had failed to link "algebraic logic" with "programming logic".

[i]"Quote it, with a link to the source. I don't believe you."[/i]

What I said was: "I am well aware of the superficial similarities between writing down equations on paper and writing programs in Miranda or Haskell..." (https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=221757&messageID=2231340)

Again, this all hinges on the fact that you repeatedly failed to clarify what you meant by "algebra" and "algebraic". Then again, being vague is handy, because then you can rectify when your arguments are challenged, and claim that you meant something else.

[i]"Sure I can. I never said "mathematical guesstimation" was a bad thing, for instance."[/i]

I never said pseudoscience was bad either. But you could probably infer it from the context and the tone. And yet when I'm forced to infer something from your vague rants, I'm incurring in some sort of logical fallacy. How can you possibly expect anyone to understand what on earth you mean by "algebraic mathematics"? You later make the incredible clarification of "as opposed to, say, geometric". Wow, that makes a world of difference.

[i]"Reading comprehension again. I never said anything about incompatibility."[/i]

Are you going to backpedal on absolutely everything? You said: "Calculus is a great way to make people who think algebraically (the perfect people to do programming) throw their hands up in disgust and pursue a career in politics or window-washing instead." If that isn't saying that people who "think algebraically" are somehow unable to study calculus, then explain exactly what you meant.

[i]"I get the distinct impression that your understanding of "argumentum ad hominem" was gleaned from a website somewhere created by someone who got the term from another website somewhere, and you stopped reading at the point where it was mentioned that an argumentum ad hominem fallacy involves "attacking" the "person"."[/i]

And you have the nerve to say that you "have not engaged in such fallacious reasoning because [your] (rare) disparaging comments about [me] were simply seasoning sprinkled over [your] actual arguments."?

[i]"I'd analogize it for you, but at the moment nothing comes to mind as a useful analogy. C'est la vie"[/i]

Wow, that has got to be the best argument ever - "I could explain it to you, but I won't." Wasn't it "blindingly obvious"? Then do us the favor of explaining the terminology you keep on making up as you go, so that we can actually figure out what you're really saying, as opposed to having to make inferences that you dislike.

by nighthawk808

Try telling that to a compiler. I still haven't found the DWIM option in gcc or Visual Studio.

Let's call a spade a spade and admit that saliva-boy Dan has always had the English skills of a Nigerian 419 scammer, except without all the charm and redeeming qualities. Lazy English reflects lazy thinking and lack of attention to detail. If you don't have enough pride in yourself to ensure your words look good to the world, why would your work be any different? I doubt it's a coincidence that apotheon's (for example) posts are usually both well-written and well-reasoned. One comes from the other.

"I don't have time to proofread, capitalize, or check for sentence fragments. I'm too busy doing [foo]!" Well, if that's true, then you don't have time to post, either.

This is certainly an odd thread. Usually I agree with you, deepsand, and couldn't disagree more with him. This time, I actually wholeheartedly agree with him.

by dbenito

[i]"I never said anyone couldn't cope with calculus. Stop putting words in my mouth. Either your reading comprehension is even poorer than I thought, or you're making crap up maliciously."[/i]

I seriously have never met anyone who continually changed his stance the way you do, taking specific advantage of being incredible vague.

[i]"I find it absurd that someone can talk about scientific methodology but doesn't realize that the questionable origin of an idea does not itself impugn the idea."[/i]

If the idea is eventually formulated in the framework of a credible scientific theory, then I have no problem with it having a questionable origin. But when it isn't, it's a pseudoscience until proved otherwise.

[i]"I wouldn't be willing to reformulate the entire field of analysis at all, so we should just strike that comment of yours from the record."[/i]

Then, given that modern mathematical analysis requires axiomatic set theory, I fail to see how you can claim that set theory has very little to do with calculus.

[i]"You make many, many unfounded assumptions, and that I think is really the root of the problem here."[/i]

Again, it would help if you were a bit more specific. You claim that I make unfounded assumptions and inferences; I claim that I have no other choice because you intentionally use vague terminology, and refuse to explain what you mean.

[i]"Generally, if my reference to "algebra" is generic, I refer to algebraic mathematics in the generic. Is that so difficult to understand?"[/i]

It is, if you just conjure up the term "algebraic mathematics" and expect everybody to know what on earth you're talking about. Just to show you that I'm not alone, I went to the trouble of googling "algebraic mathematics" (with the quotes, so we get the exact expression). Lo and behold, we get an amazing 2600 results, and a cursory evaluation of the first few pages of results reveals that, when used at all, the term can mean just about anything. Funnily enough, one of the hits is about a book called "Lectures on expansion techniques in algebraic geometry". Weren't you the one defining algebraic mathematics based on how it differed from geometric mathematics?

[i]"When did I ever say that CompSci majors should study cylindrical algebras? I similarly did not say that electronics engineers (people who actually should study a lot of calculus) should study tenser calculus. The fact that I pointed out algebraic mathematics is more important than calculus for computer science in no way implies that someone majoring in CompSci should necessarily study every mathematical subfield that has the word "algebra" somewhere in the name or description."[/i]

Again, if you mention the need to study "algebra", vaguely state that "algebraic expressions" and "algebraic logic" are related (https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=221757&messageID=2231135), and claim that the programming is built upon algebraic logic, what kind of "algebra" is one supposed to infer you think CompSci majors should study? Oh wait, you later changed that to "algebraic mathematics", making it that much clearer.

Once more, it's hard to figure out what you mean if you say something incredibly vague, and only define the terms you use as a reaction to a counter-argument.

[i]"Functions, limits, and convergence as concepts useful to algorithm design do not necessitate twelve credits of calculus study. ... Hell, limits and convergence can be covered sufficiently in an afternoon for a reasonably intelligent student body, and functions are in no way specific to calculus on any planet."[/i]

Huh? I beg to differ. Spending a mere couple of hours explaining limits and convergence are bound to leave people with the impression that calculus is "mathematical guesstimation". If anything, I think CompSci majors should spend much more time studying mathematics and less time learning specific languages.

by apotheon

"[i]Clearly you don't know much about psychology if you equate MBTI with the field as a whole.[/i]"

Again, with the things I didn't say. I didn't say that. Stop putting words in my mouth.

"[i]Personality indicators are an example of what happens when you pretend to do science but make things up instead.[/i]"

Saying it doesn't make it so.

"[i]I only mention 'high-school' as a qualifier for what most people on this board would call 'algebra' (and which, without any previously knowledge of your education, one might reasonably expect you to refer to by that name).[/i]"

Assumptions like that just make [b]you[/b] look stupid -- once they're done wasting [b]my[/b] time.

"[i]If you had been condescending enough to explain to us what you were talking about, we might have spared everybody else a pretty stupid discussion.[/i]"

You claimed to know something about mathematics. I proceeded with that in mind. Why should I assume that someone that claims to know something about mathematics needs me to explain that algebra is more than the use of variables?

"[i]As you said yourself, you're the only one who knows what you mean - but if you don't explain it clearly people are bound to misinterpret you.[/i]"

That's especially true when they're so obviously [b]determined[/b] to misinterpret my statements as much as possible.

"[i]Show me where you said that you thought I had failed to link 'algebraic logic' with 'programming logic.[/i]"

I said "the common threads in algebraic (as opposed to, say, geometric) mathematics, symbolic logic, and programming" in [url=https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=221757&messageID=2231135][b]this post[/b][/url]. There was, I would think, a fairly clear and obvious progression of concepts from algebraic mathematics, though symbolic logic, to programming. Thus, I distinctly referred to a relationship between algebraic logic and programming logic.

"[i]What I said was: 'I am well aware of the superficial similarities between writing down equations on paper and writing programs in Miranda or Haskell...'[/i]"

Ahhh . . . okay, so you did say that before. I apologize for failing to recall the previous statement and make the connection.

Now . . . maybe you can explain how that ended up being such a big part of the discussion.

"[i]Again, this all hinges on the fact that you repeatedly failed to clarify what you meant by 'algebra' and 'algebraic'.[/i]"

I was very clear about what I meant by "algebra": I meant "algebra". You assumed I meant "high school algebra", but I even corrected that assumption by pointing out that algebra goes well beyond what's taught in high school.

I was clearer about "algebraic", and sooner, too: I pointed out that "algebraic" is basically just an adjective that denotes characteristics in common with algebra, et cetera.

"[i]How can you possibly expect anyone to understand what on earth you mean by 'algebraic mathematics'?[/i]"

Do you know how to operate that wonder of modern technology, the "dictionary"? It might help. At http://www.onelook.com I discovered that "algebraic" means "of or relating to algebra" just now, with only about three seconds' time invested. You might try that some time.

"[i]You said: 'Calculus is a great way to make people who think algebraically (the perfect people to do programming) throw their hands up in disgust and pursue a career in politics or window-washing instead.' If that isn't saying that people who 'think algebraically' are somehow unable to study calculus, then explain exactly what you meant.[/i]"

One would think context would help inform you that the intent was to take "algebraically" as at least somewhat exclusive of other modes of thought related to calculus. In other words, I meant that some people who think in a manner more related to algebraic logic than the fine art of mathematical guesstimation might be less than enthused with a course of study in calculus instead of actual computer science, while you took my statement to mean that anyone who has the capacity for thinking in a manner consistent with algebraic logic is congenitally incapable of doing calculus at all.

"[i]And you have the nerve to say that you 'have not engaged in such fallacious reasoning because [your] (rare) disparaging comments about [me] were simply seasoning sprinkled over [your] actual arguments.'?[/i]"

Yes. It's true.

In response to my statement that no analogies came to mind:
"[i]Wow, that has got to be the best argument ever[/i]"

That wasn't an argument. Stop pretending it was.

by apotheon

"[i]I seriously have never met anyone who continually changed his stance the way you do, taking specific advantage of being incredible vague.[/i]"

I'll try to put it in [b]very simple terms[/b], just for you:

My comment about people being unenthused with calculus is not equivalent to your recasting of my statement as a comment about people being incapable of doing calculus. There is no change of stance.

"[i]If the idea is eventually formulated in the framework of a credible scientific theory, then I have no problem with it having a questionable origin. But when it isn't, it's a pseudoscience until proved otherwise.[/i]"

There's an ungodly volume of study data and scientific research (assuming you admit psychology as "scientific") related to personality inventories. It's mostly in the area of behavioral psychology in particular, if you need a nudge in the right direction.

"[i]Then, given that modern mathematical analysis requires axiomatic set theory, I fail to see how you can claim that set theory has very little to do with calculus.[/i]"

When did I claim that? In point of fact, I didn't -- but I wouldn't say "set theory has a lot to do with calculus" so much as "calculus has a lot to do with set theory", as the latter of the two more accurately reflects the foundational relationship between the two. Set theory is not specific to calculus, in other words, and some regard it as the foundation of mathematics in general -- even mathematics having little or nothing (depending on your definitions) to do with calculus.

"[i]Again, it would help if you were a bit more specific. You claim that I make unfounded assumptions and inferences[/i]"

I've been more specific in a piecemeal fashion all along, pointing out most of your unfounded assumptions as they cropped up or otherwise made themselves unavoidable. The statement to which you responded was just a generalized statement of a trend I've observed.

"[i]It is, if you just conjure up the term "algebraic mathematics" and expect everybody to know what on earth you're talking about. Just to show you that I'm not alone, I went to the trouble of googling "algebraic mathematics" (with the quotes, so we get the exact expression). Lo and behold, we get an amazing 2600 results, and a cursory evaluation of the first few pages of results reveals that, when used at all, the term can mean just about anything. Funnily enough, one of the hits is about a book called 'Lectures on expansion techniques in algebraic geometry'. Weren't you the one defining algebraic mathematics based on how it differed from geometric mathematics?[/i]"

If I specify that the point of my use of a term is in contrast to another term -- well, I'd think that would be a clue.

How's this: "I refer specifically to fields of mathematics that primarily employ algebraic logic, as contrasted with other fields of mathematics that are more concerned with other operational models." Does that help?

"[i]Again, if you mention the need to study 'algebra', vaguely state that 'algebraic expressions' and 'algebraic logic' are related (https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=221757&messageID=2231135), and claim that the programming is built upon algebraic logic, what kind of 'algebra' is one supposed to infer you think CompSci majors should study? Oh wait, you later changed that to 'algebraic mathematics', making it that much clearer.[/i]"

When I use the term "algebra" and the term "algebraic mathematics" in contrast to calculus, someone with an average or better capacity for reasoning and communication should be able to infer my intent -- that calculus should be secondary to algebra, speaking in general terms. Notice that my point was not about how [b]much[/b] algebra one should study, and as such I in no way implied that [b]all algebra EVAR[/b] should be studied by any given CompSci major.

"[i]Once more, it's hard to figure out what you mean if you say something incredibly vague, and only define the terms you use as a reaction to a counter-argument.[/i]"

Do you lack the ability to differentiate between "general" and "vague", or is this just an extremely persistent temporary lapse?

"[i]Huh? I beg to differ. Spending a mere couple of hours explaining limits and convergence are bound to leave people with the impression that calculus is "mathematical guesstimation". If anything, I think CompSci majors should spend much more time studying mathematics and less time learning specific languages.[/i]"

Maybe that's your problem -- you think that being a mathematician makes one a great programmer, when in fact all it does is provide the fundamentals of programming through a circuitous and in many cases cluttered route. What CompSci majors should [b]actually[/b] study so much is not mathematics per se, but computational theory -- and the specific mathematical fields and concepts that best contribute to it.

In any case:

1. I don't care what impression a few hours' explanation of limits and convergence will have on students' impressions of calculus when the point of teaching them about limits and convergence is to prepare them for further study in algorithm design. It is not (properly) the job of a CompSci course of study to teach CompSci majors all about calculus -- its job is to teach them all about computation and practical manifestations of computational theory.

2. If, in the process of teaching students about limits and convergence in an afternoon, you don't tell them that's all there is to calculus, I don't see how that problem would arise anyway. Do you imagine that I think at the end of the class the instructor should say "And that's all there is to calculus!"?

3. Calculus basically [b]is[/b] "just" the fine art of mathematical guesstimation. The fact that mathematical guesstimation is, in fact, a very complex, rigorous, and important field doesn't change that fact.

by dbenito

[i]"Again, with the things I didn't say. I didn't say that. Stop putting words in my mouth."[/i]

It's pretty simple. I criticize MBTI and [b]twice[/b] you claim that I'm putting down psychology. You're either equating MBTI with psychology as a whole, or you're a fool. I assumed the former, but I guess I'll have reconsider.

[i]"Assumptions like that just make you look stupid -- once they're done wasting my time."[/i]

Assumptions like that are entirely reasonable given that we're on an IT website.

[i]"You claimed to know something about mathematics. I proceeded with that in mind. Why should I assume that someone that claims to know something about mathematics needs me to explain that algebra is more than the use of variables?"[/i]

I never said I needed you to explain whether algebra involves more than the use of variables or not, but exactly what you meant by algebra. I quote Eric Weisstein's MathWorld: "In modern usage, algebra has several meanings." MathWorld goes on to define the various senses, as do a number of other mathematical and general references.

Is that not clear enough for you?

[i]"That's especially true when they're so obviously determined to misinterpret my statements as much as possible."[/i]

And you're not making it any easier.

[i]"There was, I would think, a fairly clear and obvious progression of concepts from algebraic mathematics, though symbolic logic, to programming. Thus, I distinctly referred to a relationship between algebraic logic and programming logic."[/i]

Again with the vagueness. First you talk about "algebraic mathematics" and later talk about "algebraic logic". I will assume (correctly, I hope, although at this point I expect just about anything) that the latter is contained in the former. Even so (or perhaps because of it), the progression is not clear. Neither can it ever be obvious, given that symbolic logic has been around for a while while algebraic logic is considerably more recent.

(Of course, if we let "algebraic mathematics" be whatever you want it to be at any specific point, as you seem to be doing, then your statement is a tautology.)

It makes about as much sense as saying there is a clear and obvious progression of concepts from abstract algebra to quantum mechanics to classical mechanics.

[i]"I was very clear about what I meant by "algebra": I meant "algebra". You assumed I meant "high school algebra", but I even corrected that assumption by pointing out that algebra goes well beyond what's taught in high school."[/i]

Again, the term "algebra" has a wide range of meanings. The way you talk about it, you could be referring to pretty much anything in mathematics (or maybe everything, which is even more convenient). And yet, somehow you manage to somehow place algebra and calculus in different categories. I'm sure Descartes would also be thrilled by the fact that you consider geometry not to be algebraic.

[i]"I was clearer about "algebraic", and sooner, too: I pointed out that "algebraic" is basically just an adjective that denotes characteristics in common with algebra, et cetera."[/i]

Clear as mud. You're basing your definition on the term "algebra", which you have failed to define. Even if we assume that you're talking about abstract algebra, it is such a wide field that talking about "characteristic in common with algebra" is as vague as it can possibly be.

[i]"Do you know how to operate that wonder of modern technology, the "dictionary"? It might help. At http://www.onelook.com I discovered that "algebraic" means "of or relating to algebra" just now, with only about three seconds' time invested. You might try that some time."[/i]

Again, I was asking about "algebraic mathematics" and "algebraic thinking", not the adjective by itself. Would accept "numbers related to algebra" as the definition for "algebraic numbers"? Moreover, have a look at the definitions that www.onelook.com returns when you search for algebra.

Seriously, if you had said something like "algorithmic thinking" (not that I'm implying that it means the same thing as whatever you're talking about), it would have been pretty clear, because an algorithm is a pretty specific concept. Algebra, on the other hand, isn't.

[i]"One would think context would help inform you that the intent was to take "algebraically" as at least somewhat exclusive of other modes of thought related to calculus."[/i]

What other modes? Do you even know what you're talking about? I would think it would be pretty simple for you to define something that is "blindingly obvious", and yet you haven't (and I'm beginning to think that rather than not wanting to, you simply can't).

[i]"In other words, I meant that some people who think in a manner more related to algebraic logic than the fine art of mathematical guesstimation might be less than enthused with a course of study in calculus instead of actual computer science, while you took my statement to mean that anyone who has the capacity for thinking in a manner consistent with algebraic logic is congenitally incapable of doing calculus at all."[/i]

Whoa there! So now "algebraic thinking" means "thinking in a manner consistent with algebraic logic"? We finally have a definition, even if it isn't particularly intuitive. Whether you're talking about Boolean algebra (not to be confused with Boolean logic) or abstract algebraic logic in general, that is defintely the last thing anyone would take "algebraic thinking" to mean.

You could at least try to be consistent in the use of the adjective "algebraic". At this point I'm not sure if even you know what you're talking about when you use that word.

[i]"That wasn't an argument. Stop pretending it was."[/i]

Given the depth and quality of your arguments so far, one cannot be faulted for thinking that you might have considered it to be one.

Vagueness and figures of speech like synecdoche (you really love it, don't you?) may work well in poetry, but if you're having a discussion, I sincerely think you should be aiming for clarity (and stay away from grandiloquence while you're at it).

by nighthawk808

And how many times have I used the concept of limits as a programmer? Approximately d/dx(e^(pi*i)+1) times. How many times have I used matrix algebra, discrete math, symbolic logic, boolean algebra, etc.? More than I can count. Apotheon's point, and the view I take as well, is that there are certain types of mathematics that are very important, but calculus is not by the act of being a type of math eo ipso one of them.

I am not disputing that calculus has its place, nor that it is very useful in its own right. However, that does not mean that calculus and computers are a match made in heaven. The math used in computing is not calculus simply because calculus is a form of math any more than a plane and a car do the same thing simply because they both have wheels.

I've said the same thing three different ways in two different paragraphs. If you can't understand it, here's an executive summary suitable for PowerPointing:

programming != calculus

You are another example of Larry's Law of Lame Posters.

by nighthawk808

Some reserved keywords and other types in C (IOW, things that were so important that they're an integral part of the language):

|| OR (boolean algebra)
&& AND (boolean algebra)
^ XOR (take a guess)
some_type foo[][] a matrix
lim -- oops, that one doesn't exist. I suppose it wasn't worth including in the language.

But wait, maybe it's in math.h! Uh, no. Somehow both the wizards who designed the language AND those who extended it to make it more useful didn't find it worth the time. A good programmer is a lazy programmer--one who squeezes out the maximum result from minimum effort and will use a tool available if it will save them time. If limits were a tool that could save them time, you can bet they'd have been included long ago. None of the programming languages I've used (C/C++, Java, Python, Lisp, Prolog, et al.) have a built-in limit function.

As far as C/C++ are concerned, "limit" means INT_MAX.

by deepsand

I took him to task.

Had he addressed the subject a hand, with mention of matters re. writing skill as a gentle aside, I'd have overlooked such. However, not only did he wholly ignore the subject, but his own missive is less than perfect.

In short, he here stepped on the stage, not as a participant, not even as a spectator, but solely as a pedant, i.e. "[i]one who unduly emphasizes minutiae in the presentation or use of knowledge[/i]."

by deepsand

I could, but I'll not, as it's a distinction with a very important difference.

There is no need to soften the requirements for a BS in Comp. Sci. when suitable alternative paths of study already exist for those who would be programmers.

by deepsand

Were it the case that all computations required only inputs and outputs that were rational numbers, then calculus would of course be irrelevant to Comp. Sci.. However, it is because the real world is analog, and cannot be adequately described by rational numbers alone, that gave rise to calculus.

Thus, to exclude calculus from Comp. Sci. is to bar that discipline from addressing the real universe in an accurate and comprehensive manner.

by apotheon

The fact that math is useful to computer science is not in dispute. The fact that you, with a blindfold on your face, walked up to an elephant and grabbed its calculus with both hands is my point.

by apotheon

Electronics engineering is the interface between computer science and physics. Use calculus for electronics engineering. Stop wasting half my computer science education on calculus when I'd get a lot more value out of algebraic mathematics.

by apotheon

Who said anything about "softening" requirements? Don't be a dolt. I'm not talking about removing advanced mathematics from computer science degree programs -- I'm talking about replacing calculus with [b]relevant[/b] advanced mathematics.

by absolutely

to vote, _stupid_!

And, if you know some words Thomas Jefferson said about an informed electorate, you get to fully appreciate the irony of your answer, as I'm sure you do.

by deepsand

Those that need to be pushed to the polls almost certainly know little to nothing re. either the issues or the candidates, and are therefore not fit to vote.

Their participation should be limited to sitting by the radio or TV to learn of the results.

by nighthawk808

I think all voters should have to pass a small quiz before being allowed to vote. Nothing complex; just a simple

1. Name the senators from your state and your Congressional representative (2 out of 3 required).

2. Who is the mayor of your city?

3a. Give a brief description of at least seven of the first ten amendments. (No more than a sentence required for each.)
3b. What are these amendments usually referred to as a group?

4a. How many amendments are left?
4b. Briefly describe at least five of them.

5. Name the years Ben Franklin was president.

6. Name at least half of the issues on the ballot by issue number and give a one sentence description of each.

So, you see, nothing complicated. If you can't pass it, or you can't be bothered to fill it out, you've got no business casting a vote that will affect me. I suspect this requirement would either completely exclude any Texan from ever voting, or would result in teams of Republican (D, L, I, and G voters wouldn't need them) coaches swarming there for voters heading to the polls, possibly with crib sheets.

In any population, about 50% of people are below average. About 50% of people voted for Bush. This is not a coincidence.

Motor Voter is yet another reason I didn't care too much for Clinton. Registering to vote should be something you have to go out of your way to do.

by absolutely

geared to being informative rather than instructive. I agree with the basic sentiment about voters who take their agenda from MTV or other campaigns to merely encourage voting, rather than provide such information as to motivate substantial participation in all levels of government from federal to local. Facts are useful. Urging otherwise disinterested people to vote seems bound to be stupid or worse.

by deepsand

That hardware is outside the domain of Comp. Sci.?

That one can program an analog computer with no knowledge of calculus?

That one can implement and/or use analog functions on a digital computer with no knowledge of calculus?

That one can model physical systems on either an analog or digital computer with no knowledge of calculus?

That the only ones involved in the design and use of computational systems who use calculus are EEs?

by deepsand

Now would be the time to remind you that my experiences greatly exceed those of yourself, and, from such experiences, I can unequivocably state that that which seems irrelevant to you is [b]not[/b] necessarily true of all.

Dolt? I will this once ignore such; but, expect not that I shall be so gracious in the future.

by deepsand

what about [i]irrational[/i] ones, particularly those pesky [i]transcendentals[/i]?

And, just how do you go about determining the slope of a curve at a given point if you don't know how to calculate a derivative? Or, calculate the area encompassed by it if you can't calculate an integral?

In general, how do you model that which is [u]analog[/u]?

by apotheon

It's astounding to see you have the unmitigated gall to make a comment like that after your reference to the blind men and the elephant. Holy freakin' cow.

by apotheon

"[i]Are you saying that all analog calculations are done by hardware?[/i]"

No. What are you smoking, and where can I get some?

"[i]That hardware is outside the domain of Comp. Sci.?[/i]"

Mostly, yeah.

"[i]That one can program an analog computer with no knowledge of calculus?[/i]"

Where do you get this crap?

"[i]That one can implement and/or use analog functions on a digital computer with no knowledge of calculus?[/i]"

Admit it -- you aren't even reading what I say. You're just making this crap up, pulling it out of thin air, because it's easier to refute what you want me to say than what I am saying.

"[i]That one can model physical systems on either an analog or digital computer with no knowledge of calculus?[/i]"

Umm . . . I thought we were talking about computer science, not game programming.

"[i]That the only ones involved in the design and use of computational systems who use calculus are EEs?[/i]"

No. Again -- where do you get this crap?

by apotheon

"[i]Now would be the time to remind you that my experiences greatly exceed those of yourself[/i]"

Yes, that's right, I forgot -- and your penis is bigger than mine, too.

"[i]Dolt? I will this once ignore such[/i]"

Funny -- two thirds of your inane rambling in that post was about that.

"[i]expect not that[/i]" you will stop talking like Yoda because you think it makes you sound smart.

by tony hopkinson

was part of a foundation course required for a self study degree program.
The other was an admittedly short lived investigation into multi dimensional mathematics after reading about string theory and Kaluza-Klein spaces.

Fascinating stuff, but I'd need to embark on a two to three year study program and that would be after I'd revised calculus and some other math which has gone rusty from disuse.

Perhaps when I retire.

by tony hopkinson

in computer science courses ?
I've never been convinced of this.
Calculate the efficiency of a sort routine vs write one that doesn't crash when there's an odd number of items.

Seems to me the emphasis is in the wrong place. There's nothing wrong with picking up the math, but in my opinion, things like why side effects and global variables are bad is way more important than say predicate calculus.

I'm firmly convinced it happened because the teachers didn't want to expose their ignorance and so fell bqck on their own expertise.

by daveo2000

I fully understand what you mean and by no means do I fully support forcing calculus on everybody. I didn't do a stellar job on the topic myself.

What worries me is that there are so many corners cut these days that major issues get forgotten. People that lose touch with the end job will often skip elements that are critical in getting that end job accomplished.

Let's take the hammer / carpenter / architect example. No, the architect doesn't need to be an expert carpenter but they do need to know about wood. They also need to know about construction techniques or they can make stupid assumptions. What happens when they design a set of walls coming together in a wood frame house and they make no allowances for driving the nails into the frames? If the location only allows for hammers to be in use and the only thing the architect knows is an air gun, the results could cost a lot of time on the site to jury rig a solution.

Look at cars. Does a car designer need to know how to tune up an engine? Ask anyone who owns (well, owned) a V8-Vega from Chevrolet. Part of tuning up the engine usually involves replacing (or at least checking) the spark plugs. The designers failed to consider this (or didn't care) because the engine sits so close to the frame that you have to remove the motor mount and jack up the engine to take out many of the spark plugs.

In some Chevy trucks, if you wanted to replace the heater core (the thing that heats the cab) then you had to take off the right front wheel, clean off the crud from the wheel well and half-way remove the wheel well lining to get at the heater core.

When people (as a collective) forget what needs to be done, they will cut corners such that it may prevent or severly hamper what needs to be done.

Determining what the "what needs to be done" is? That is an art form of hindsight.

by daveo2000

What has bothered me for a long time now is how people complain about coming out of courses with more questions than when they started.

THIS IS WHAT YOU WANT!

When we go into a class, we usually know very little (relatively speaking) about the topic. There is no way that we can learn all there is to know about a topic in a single semester (or even several semesters). What a class can do is expose you to a surface view of many facets of that topic so you can figure out where you need to ask questions to learn more.

I am amazed at the number of people that really don't understand the evils possible with global variables or structures. Worse yet, there are people who absolutely forbid globals and don't understand the times that they are most useful or even necessary.

People that grew up with C++ missed a wealth of learning opportunities by not learning C. (And don't tell me you know 'C' if you don't know what calloc is or can't build an object oriented structure in 'C'!). The lessons (if not the background) of 'C' and memory management is vital to building responsive applications in C++. However, I keep meeting people that tell me that it is far cheaper to buy new processing power or more memory than to hire programmers that understand these concepts.

Oh, woe is us... :(

by daveo2000

Speaking from the "Sr. Developer" side of the world, we often assume capabilities from resumes and far too brief interviews. The warning signs are far to unreliable and the expectation of some degree of "objective evaluation of self" by the candidate is often really absurd.

Too often we skip the parts of the interview that could help point out problem areas and, as research has shown, the hire or not decisions are usually made in the first 30 seconds of meeting the person.

Many managers will impose arbitrary restrictions to limit the number of people that they have to see to make their job of hiring somebody that much easier. Remember the line "MBA or equivalent experience" in any job specs? I don't. Have you ever seen job specs that require 2+ years experience in a [i]new[/i] technology (as in maybe 1 year old)? I have seen these.

Then, after we learn all of these lessons, we STILL make fun of and berate the HR departments. Of course, most of them deserve it. ]:)

by absolutely

would be primarily in physical modeling, or other [u]scientific[/u] programming applications, a small field within comp sci, and not much of a reason to require all comp sci majors to know calculus, IMO.

by wayne m.

Differing definitions are often the basis to misunderstanding. I usually find it quite helpful to ask about underlying definitions and assumptions in order to follow the conclusions reached by others.

Within your definition of computer science, I will readily concede that study of mathematics might be applicable.

There is another definition of computer science that is implied by the typical course of study for a BSCS degree. This seems to fit your definition for computer programming. It is for computer programming that I would contend that study of higher mathematics is unnecessary. I would also suggest that a vast majority of the industry and those posting in this discussion are doing computer programming.

Differing axioms, those underlying statements assumed to be true, will result in differing conclusions. When conclusions differ, it is always valuable to verify the axioms in use.

by tony hopkinson

was when the hardware / operational cost became cheaper than the human one.

We have a larf about 640k being bigger than you'd ever need, but educating and paying for a coder to be able to cram a lot of code into a small space either in time or size, vs doubling up your ram or processor speed is to be a no brainer nowadays.

Optimisation aside from on massive relational databases is becoming a lost art.
There too, based on some of the posts I've seen about SQL onj this site. :(

C, far too advanced to start with, gates, flip - flops and counters is where everyone should begin. :D

With a good laymans understanding of transistor theory of course.

by danlm

Not trying to flame in the least. Just an observation. You have to admit though nighhawk. You know what my positions are. That's communication. Without the style and grace that everyone may wish to see, but you have no doubt where I stand on things.

Dan

by woutiger

[There are 3 kinds of people in this world, those who can count and those who can't]

by wayne m.

There is a difference in saying programmers use concepts that have also been described mathematically and saying that a mathematical course of study is fundamental to programming.

I have great respect for database programmers, but few have the need nor skills to define the mathematics behind something like a database. The "set theory" required is no more detailed than is typically covered in the first two years of grade school. Given the difficulty inherent in describing a basic concept like an inner join using a Venn diagram, I would find it hard to conclude that detailed knowledge of set theory is fundamental to database development.

Thomas McCabe developed Cyclomatic Complexity Metric and a description can be downloaded from http://www.itl.nist.gov/div897/sqg/pubs/publications.htm listed under the title, "Structured Testing: A Testing Methodology Using the Cyclomatic Complexity Metric". The mathematics that validate McCabe's rules are complex, but applying the rules requires counting, addition, and subtraction - basic arithmetic.

The keys to writing device drivers is understanding critical areas and response times. The mathematics needed is limited to counting, addition, and perhaps multiplication.

The knowledge needed to understand Unix permissions is that of Yes and No, concepts most children have mastered by the time they reach grade school. George Boole was a mathematician and study of his mathematics is a very advanced topic. To say that this makes mathematics fundamental to programming is the same as saying mathematics are fundamental to an electrician because he can wire a three-way light switch.

Mathematics are a mechanism with which to describe the physical world. The concepts described by mathematics are not unique to mathematics; they can be learned by other means. If the concepts of computer programming can (and usually are) learned by means other than the study of mathematics, it is not possible to say that this is fundamental to programming / software development.

by apotheon

Since CompSci is all about computational theory and the like, it is in essence the study of the theoretical foundations of programming. Computer science and programming are more closely linked than someone like deepsand seems to realize. Apparently, when he hears the word "programming", he thinks "writing a shell script", and when he hears "computer science" he hears "physics as it relates to computers". When I hear "programming" I think "computational theory in practice" and when I hear "computer science" I hear "computational theory in, well, theory".

Because of the fact that programming is essentially just a lucrative manifestation of computer science, I believe that advanced mathematics is extremely valuable to a programmer. It is not necessary to do the job of a programmer, but it is valuable as it provides a lot of foundational understanding of how and why programming works, which can aid greatly in being good at it.

However . . . just like "corporation" isn't synonymous with "business" and "computer" isn't synonymous with "technology", it's true that "calculus" isn't synonymous with "advanced mathematics". The fact that millions of people in the world seem unable to differentiate between calculus in the specific sense and advanced mathematics in the generic is, I think, where this ridiculous belief that calculus is somehow necessary to a computer science education arises.

by apotheon

Calculus is pretty much useless to computer science. They should be sticking to advanced mathematics subjects that are actually relevant to computational theory.

by tony hopkinson

For most people in programing the level of abstraction is great enough to isolate them from the underlying mathematics.
I never had to work out how to ramp up a motor, I just popped a rate into the controller that was bolted on the side of it.

Mathematics alone would not have helped me work out how to ramp the motor up either. A sizable dollop of electrical and mechanical engineering would also be a pre-requisite.

If you wanted to rotate an image 30 degrees at most you might have to remember pi = 180 and then discover you really wanted -30.

I enjoy maths, I use it quite often, but I do/did a lot of 'low level' stuff.

Then there are other problems. Do you say the customers are in customer number order or start looking for predicate calculus symbols with charmap?

Do you implement a recursive algorithm for finding the nth sentence in a document or do you count full stops like a sensible person?

If it was like you say learning maths = learning programing. Nothing could be further from the truth.

by nighthawk808

"Never do in 30 seconds what you can do in two hours." Or, perhaps, "If the poor sucker who will be maintaining your code years from now can understand it, then you're doing something wrong." Or, maybe, "Wimpy programmers abstract. Manly programmers obfuscate. And real wizards obfuscate their abstractions."

Besides, customers don't care about having a finished product; they insist that it be written in the most beautiful, most elegant, most mathematically brilliant way no matter how long it takes. If it actually works, that's a bonus, not a prerequisite. That's why the field of computers ceased to exist after John von Neumann died.

by daveo2000

Maybe we are just repeating an earlier rant.

[i]With a good laymans understanding of transistor theory of course. [/i]

I have never gotten a firm grasp of how transistors really figure into all of this. Yes, I know that there are a whole bunch of transistor thingies glued together to make a CPU, I have been told so. But what, exactly, they do in there is way beyond me. I can carry on a moderately uneducated conversation about assembly instruction sets and how a line of code might translate into assembly but the jump from assembly to binary and into transistor-land is pure black magic to me.

I can see where the same would apply to a lot of programmers today with regard to stuff that we took for granted.

by daveo2000

This reminds me of when my son (4th grader) was doing some math assignment and was trying to fill in a table for a pie chart. The numbers needed to add up to 100% and I was whining about him making sure to "show his work."

It all came home when he added everything up and it came to something around .95. I got him to review his "shown work" and he started finding mistakes and eventually got it to add up to 1.00.

I felt vindicated and he was happy to have the asignment complete.

I will be happy to say that he learned his lesson and ALWAYS shows his work now...

if he had actually learned his lesson and always [i]did[/i] show his work.. :(

by apotheon

Transistors are the reason computers "talk" in binary. As they're used in computer CPUs, they're basically just a bunch of on/off switches (ones and zeros).

by tig2

I considered TiggerToo briefly.

When I joined, Tigger was taken so I needed a plan "B". I wasn't willing to give up on my first choice for an alias- I earned the right to be called Tigger when I was young and stupid and living in Southern California. TiggerTwo seemed to work for me.

by deepsand

While I do understand your position, the problem as I see it is how to determine who will & will not find use for certain knowledge. Absent prescience, it that possible?

by deepsand

beautiful woman, and told that each minute they may advance half the remaining distance to her.

The mathematician lamented "But, I'll never get there," to which the engineer replied, "Yeah, but I'll get close enough!"

by absolutely

with a more precise plan.

The mathematician knows very well how to estimate "close enough". Such is not a learned skill, but the limit of the engineer's ability.

by deepsand

It is the engineer who brings to realization that which the theorist either cannot or will not.

by tony hopkinson

Xena's Paradox

is it not.

7 steps to paradise if you are the bragging type.

No fingers, do it in your head.

No the math!

by deepsand

I'd already done the math before posting this.

It's one of the several paradoxes of Xeno of Elea; specifically, The Dichotomy Paradox.

by deepsand

If naturalization must be earned, why not also the privilege of voting? The only voting "right" should be that of being allowed to [u]try[/u] to qualify, and to then vote [u]if[/u] qualified.

No doubt, like me, you've been accused of being an elitist for espousing this view.

by absolutely

as the programming profession exists today. As long as coders know what options their academic choices do not open for them, what's the differential?

;)

by tony hopkinson

I can remember building an and gate out of discrete components, never used one in a practical circuit though.
Buy a chip with 8 on, costs less works much better, uses less power...

The circuit diagram for that chip was more than you could take in, in one go. A modern chip not a prayer, it might as well be black magic.

Work on a non trivial application, let it evolve for a year, then say you understand how it works, you'd be lying your ass off.
You'll know the main blocks, the main logic paths, which bit started off where, after that, it's get out your metaphorical multimeter and figure this bit of it out.

Not black magic, but black box. The only time what's inside it matters, is when you have to lift the lid.
When you do lift it do you find

A well layed out circuit diagram?

A rigorous mathematical proof?

Or a boiling mass of tubular invertebrates?

Programming is a messy discipline that's why those of us who do it, call it 'getting your hands dirty'.

Now if all that study for comp sci made a science out of it, I'd be well pleased.

However this is self evidently not true, I've seen code written by mathematicians.
File Open TinOfWorms.c

by deepsand

Are you saying:

"That hardware is outside the domain of Comp. Sci.?"

[i]Mostly, yeah.[/i]

Why "mostly?"

"That one can program an analog computer with no knowledge of calculus?"

[i]Where do you get this crap?[/i]

Non-responsive.

"That one can implement and/or use analog functions on a digital computer with no knowledge of calculus?"

[i]Admit it -- you aren't even reading what I say. You're just making this crap up, pulling it out of thin air, because it's easier to refute what you want me to say than what I am saying.[/i]

Non-responsive.

"That one can model physical systems on either an analog or digital computer with no knowledge of calculus?"

[i]Umm . . . I thought we were talking about computer science, not game programming.[/i]

Non-responsive.

by deepsand

"[i]There is another definition of computer science that is implied by the typical course of study for a BSCS degree. This seems to fit your definition for computer programming.[/i]"

This was not the case when I studied Comp. Sci.; and, absent any at hand contemporary evidence, I will allow that it may now be otherwise, as you suggest.

If so, I am not surprised. In another sub-thread here I addressed the fact that, by and large, universities had become more and more like trade schools, with the emphasis on teaching specific skills required for a specific career path.

Nonetheless, so as to make a clear distinction between the two, I shall here continue to use the standard definitions that I posted.

by apotheon

If something is irrelevant to the subject at hand, there's no point derailing the subject at hand by talking about other subjects related to that irrelevancy instead.

by apotheon

The problem is that you're a hypocrite who's more interested in "winning" than in actually discussing the matter rationally.

by daveo2000

A guy at work came up with a truly geeky way to remember the zip code of the office. Now I can't forget it.

It is a NYC address and the zip is 10010. Binary 18. It is virus-like since I have mentioned this to some other folks (IT folks, of course) and they have had the same complaint: dopey but hard to forget... :(

(Edited because the subject was misleading)

by deepsand

save us from ourselves.

I've seen fat too many of the help-wanted ads of the sort mentioned. Not only do they frequently call for experience that exceeds the age of the technology in question, but some to the extent that it is highly unlikely that the implicitly targeted youthful respondent could have accumulated such in his lifespan.

by deepsand

When I started, on PENNSTAC, a 1st generation machine, constructed of vacuum tubes & relays, one needed to have an intimate understanding of the hardware, as all programming was, of necessity, in machine language.

Even with 2nd generation machines, i.e. those constructed with discrete semiconductors, the introduction of relatively large amounts of core memory - 16K words was the considered large - allowed for the introduction of assembly languages. Still, one needed to know a great deal about the architecture of the machine in order to effectively & efficiently use its still limited resources.

With the introduction of 3rd generation machines, those constructed of integrated circuits, and the commensurate increase in resources, which allowed of compilers and formal operating systems, the point was reached where only systems programmers need understand the inner workings and hidden machanisms; applications programmers were now free to deal with the machine as an abstraction.

Today we are at the point where many, if not most, applications can be developed by simply selecting and joining the appropriate pre-built routines in the proper sequence. In a sense, many programmers today are little more than the functional equivalent of operators, in that they merely specify the tasks to be run and in what order.

by absolutely

To use the term "opposite" we need to specify rays, not lines. Now that we are using the correct geometric terminology to illustrate the meaning of "opposite", perpendicular is not "opposite", antiparallel is "opposite". Perpendicular lines (or rays) are 90 degrees apart. Antiparallel rays are 180 degrees apart, aka "opposite".
Opposite != Perpendicular

by absolutely

The idea that voters "should" all know, & to some substantial degree, understand what they're voting for, sounds swell until I consider implementation.

Want to let me decide how much you have to know, about what, in order for your vote to be counted? That's what I thought.

by absolutely

The engineer brings to realization that which he cannot conceive, but which the theorist can. The theorist can also perform the tasks of the engineer, but instead leaves the simpler mathematical chores to those not overqualified for them, leaving the theorist free to continue advancing theory.

by tony hopkinson

The idea of an invisible listbox control to do a sort, or the fact that some poor chump thought it was the right way to do it.

I still pray the hardware types will hit a wall technology wise and in depth knowledge of the basics again becomes generally valuable.

by apotheon

When someone with a vested interest in the outcome of the voting process, such as Bill Clinton, starts advocating voting without specifying how people should vote, that is a de facto bit of self-marketing. Consider it: this supposedly selfless bit of voting advocacy in fact convinces people to vote for the advocate (or for whatever is perceived as that person's cause). In other words, Bill Clinton's supposedly nonpartisan voting advocacy was nothing but a cynical ploy to convince people to vote for [b]him[/b].

So . . . it's very smart, if your goal is to win an election. It's stupid if your goal is for good things to come about as a result of people voting.

by apotheon

I don't want hardware to hit a wall at all. I want it to continue advancing like crazy. I want the technological Singularity to happen, not just in my life time, but before I'm retirement age. I want to be a part of it.

I want the same result as you, though, Tony: I want people to learn to program a little more efficiently again. There's a better way to get there, though. I'd like that to be achieved through a shift in the software industry away from the Microsoft business model and toward an open source development based business model.

by trent1

I have a year of college. I took college algebra because I realized I would fail my calculus class in the first week (I had no interest in it).

I work with engineers (Chem, Mech, Structural, Electrical). I write the software that does what they used to have to do in excel spreadsheets on their own.

I am capable of understanding the formulae they use for their work and I apply them in appropriate ways.

I realized long ago I am not a linear thinker, and so programming has long been a struggle. Analysis has largely been easy.

I don't think you need math, per se. You need (in certain circumstance) to be able to understand concepts that you might not otherwise have been exposed to.

by bluechimera

Having programmed for over 25 years, I have found that basic algebra is all that is really required in most situations. I am a former Physics major and have Lots of math classes under my belt. Calculus up to differential equations and linear algebra.

I only had to use calculus once. CMM4 had no sine or cosine functions, so I used a MacLarien series to make my own.

There are areas of programming where math is heavily used: graphics and DSP come to mind.

I worked in DSP for 4 years as a contractor for the Navy. In every case a DSP engineer would come up with the algorithm. My job was to render it into code.

by tony hopkinson

for MS where quality became mandatory in order to survive would do the trick, I'm just not seeing it happen while throwing more hardware at a problem is the get out of jail free card.

by joekarumba

This discussion is not new.When I was in campus, most of my course mates used to question why we had to do a lot of mathematics units.We did a lot of Maths.Basic mathematics,Linear Algebra, Discrete mathematics, Scientific computing/Numerical analysis,Calculus-to mention but a few.
To this end, I concur that mathematics is to a CS major what language is to a Lawyer.
This is the language for programmers.
Let me qualify this proposition.
One, you can never code except you can reason logically.Discrete mathematics comes in handy.How will you write conditions if you cannot interpret them logically?
Next, every programmer knows that he/she must think.The thinking required for solution of mathematical problems in college prepares you for this.
Think about it....How do you even understand Data Structures without some mathematical skills? The many concepts in Data structures and Algorithms require mathematical-logical intelligence.
You do not need to consult a mathematician when writing a function to compute the compound interest earned by a given principal amount also.
Still, what will differentiate you from Word specialists?
Computer Science is a Science.I do not want to say it is not an art.
No student should ever be admitted to any CS class if he/she is weak in mathematics.
You may never user the Euler's method or the Jacobi's method in your entire life as a developer.
But the bare fact that you can understand these is emblematic of programming capability.

by brokeneagle

The real issue is not whether there should be a math requirement, but how much and what kind of classes.

I avoided the math department in high school (after the required algebra and geometry) by taking German, French, and Spanish. Russian and Latin where taught the same periods as German, so I couldn't take them.

Then after getting a History degree, I took COBOL, FORTRAN, BASIC, SNOBOL, LISP, PASCAL, and several other languages I have forgotten because it has been a quarter century since using them.

I could substitute "language" for "math" in most of the arguments. How can you understand programming without understanding syntax, nouns, verbs, direct objects, indirect objects, etc.?

When I taught college classes I used to tell the students that the job of a systems analyst is to know everything about everything. Math isn't the only discipline that computer scientists need to be proficient in to do their job right.

by drray

My God Dan, did you also decide not to learn how to express yourself correctly in the English language because you write code?