Discussion Locked

I Just Want to Program! Don't Make Me Learn Math!

0 helpful
473 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

473 replies

by daveo2000

I have often thought that academia is where you learn many of the questions and, more importantly, how to question.

True, some people come out thinking that if they question anything then they look elite; but, I am not referring to them. I am thinking of the folks that learn to spot an assumption and look deeper.

Going a bit off topic here, outside of academia the focus is usually on "R&R" (Remove and Replace) instead of asking "Why did it break?". Whilst in the cocoon of university life you have the luxury of learning how to question. If you are very lucky you can learn how to reduce the number of questions to a very focused triage.

It is often a basic understanding of the technology accompanied by a deeper understanding of spotting assumption and topped off with a deep understanding of human nature that leads one to be a better leader.

by apotheon

In theory, that's what academia is supposed to provide. Generally speaking, it does the opposite, at least these days -- it indoctrinates and propagandizes.

In theory, theory and practice are the same. In practice, they aren't.

by apotheon

I prefer a "significant other" who doesn't spend an entire debate trying to manufacture some kind of "moral high ground" out of nothing.

by daveo2000

In some circles it is defined as the person that can make the computer do exactly what you want it to do. If what you want involves little to no math skills then the math skills may well get in the way. I can see a Monty Python skit work it's way out of this scenario.

Also, the Universe is made up (again, depending on whose definition you use) of stars, planetary systems, dust and people.

The jury is still out on whether or not you can define people using a function. And with that in mind, I am sure that there are a lot of folks out there that will be perfectly happy being the programmer equivelent of a french fry cook.

by tony hopkinson

is one who writes code that does what it is supposed to and can be changed at minimal cost.

Sometimes math lends itself to this, sometimes it doesn't.

Math can help you program, just as domain knowledge, psychology, communication and language skills can.

However if you come out of a CS course still writing code that can't be read, therefore can't be understood, therefore can't be tested, maintained or enhanced, a qualified developer is going to rip you a new one, until you pick up what's important.

The annoying thing is 'french fry' programmers have the most tools to do it well, yet in general seem to make the poorest use of them, most of them have CS degrees as well.

by daveo2000

I expect that what you wrote is quite enlightened. You may well have well thought out points that would amaze us with their brilliance.

Without spaces between logical groupings (paragraphs) it is really annoying to try to read.

I know that this will appear picky to you as your text is way above such trivial matters but it is a small request and I hope you can take it to heart.

We now return you to the regularly scheduled deep ponderings.

by absolutely

I also prefer to understand how things work at the level of the underlying math. Most folks prefer to understand how things work at the minimum level required to make them "go". They won't be persuaded.

by wayne m.

I believe Tony intended to use "you" as an indefinite pronoun, which caused the confusion. I will usually attempt to use "one" instead, so as to avoid confusion where a reader interprets a statement as directed at that reader. Go back and reread Tony's post replacing "you" with "one" and I believe it will come across as a light-hearted comment rather than a personal attack.

My advice to a speaker or writer, try to use "one" in place of "you", unless specifically speaking to an individual. My advice to a listener or reader, try to interpret the use of "you" as meaning anyone in general.

Tying back into the main theme, I usually find understanding ambiguities in language to be a far more important skill for a software developer than anything related to mathematics.

by wayne m.

Could you perhaps provides some examples of where you found it beneficial to apply mathematics? I think this might provide a baseline for discussion. Thanks.

by joules ampere

Oh no my friend I am not for one
minute suggesting that you
are a mathematical luddite, I read what you said and I could not
conclude from
that any such thing, I am not like that, I respect what you are saying
I was
just hoping that we could just find some common ground, for your
argument is
not by any means baseless, if I thought you were a novice I would not
even
bother to reply.

The map is not the territory that is
for sure but you can
reason that the whole territory can be mapped and that it obeys the
laws of
that already mapped. This is a priori reasoning that has to be used
countless
times in science. It
is then safe to say
the territory is mappable, similarly I did not say mathematics is the
universe;
I said the universe is mathematical. All the major strides we have made
in
science and technology over many years come from mathematical
understanding of
our surroundings.

Please let
us focus
on the core of the argument, even the original discussion that triggers
this
one suggest what I am saying, here is a quote from the original
article; ?Occasionally
I do feel the lack of higher calculus or linear algebra or graph
theory? I have
already admitted that you do not have to learn advanced mathematics to
be a
programmer , however, mathematics is such a useful tool to use for
abstracting
our ideas, a technical communication language if you will, that I
believe it
should be taught with any high quality programming course you should
not
indulge too much in the statistics of your own experience, mine is
different.
Once I was developing an Excel spreadsheet using VBA this application
was used
to program some communications receivers and transmitters that requires
as part
of the synthesizer calculation to convert some number to binary
Excel?s
engineering add-in has a DEC2BIN function for this purpose but to my
surprise anything
over 511 causes a #NUM! error and the calculations were coming out
quite often
greater than 511 the solution was needed quickly and could not wait too
long, since
the input number is not going to be negative and all the zeros need to
be
retained I came up with this function to solve the problem; note; error
traps
left out here.

Function
Deci_to_Bin(n As Double)
Dim bitval() As Integer
ReDim bitval(0 To 15)
For a = 0 To 15 Step 1
bitval(a) = (Int(n / (2 ^ a)) Mod 2)
Deci = bitval(a) & Deci
Next a
Deci_to_Bin = Deci
End Function

Now you may have a more clever
solution to this problem but
it did not take long for me to come up with this mathematical solution (Int(n
/ (2
^ a)) Mod 2)and fit it right into the for next loop

While there may be none mathematical
ways to solve this simple
problem, a search on the internet turned up nothing at the time, even
recently I
noticed someone at this
link
that has a similar problem and having a hard time
finding a solution on the internet. This is just a simple example of
what I am
trying to illustrate, just a question of being armed with the right
weapon when
the time comes.

by tony hopkinson

I don't care how good your model is , it's a model.

That's the sort of nonsense that says I can manipulate a point on a line therefore I can travel back in time.

Or gived you Dark Energy, the multiverse and phlogiston.

by apotheon

The issue is that you seem to think that electronics engineering and computer science are somehow the same thing, or that programming is about calculating the area under a ballistic curve, or something like that. You seem to think that computational theory is all about constructing physical models of the universe, to judge by some of your posts about how modeling the analog universe is so critical to computer science.

This crap about how I "belittle" people almost as much as you do (but have the balls to just come out and say it) is just your attempt to distract from the issue at hand so you can try to claim a "moral high ground" win.

by deepsand

You got flagged for bad conduct. While you may have gotten away with it elsewhere & at other times doesn't mean that should expect to always immune from censure. But, rather than simply accept a well earned rebuke, you persist in being uncivil.

by deepsand

You don't like being publicly taken to task for your bad behavior? That's not my problem.

Deal with it.

by apotheon

I used some strong (though not obscene, at least) language to emphasize the fact that you were somewhere way out in left field. You, then, set out to insult both me [b]and someone not even involved in the discussion[/b], not as emphasis for an argument but [b]in place of one[/b], then dissembled and pretended that you hadn't set out to insult anyone.

. . . and what does my use of the word "dolt" have to do with the fact that I was right? Answer: Nothing.

by deepsand

And, should I ever [i]intend to insult[/u], rest assured that there will be no doubt held by anyone.

by deepsand

Some think that such use of "one" is naught but an attempt on the writer's or speaker's part to make himself seem more educated than the reader, and thus feel offended.

Sad, but true.

by deepsand

for the forms used by an insurance company.

A very large number of the forms were used by different departments, for different purposes, with their usage levels being driven by activites, not directly involving the use of said forms, in multiple departments. Furthermore, the re-order lead times required varied both by the printing source as well as by the re-order quantities; likewise, so did the ability to take partial delivery of a given printing order.

Statistics were invaluable in measuring the historical usages, as were determined from warehouse records of shipments received & requisitions filled, and current samplings of departmental activities records with regards to those activities which drove demand. both directly & indirectly, for each form.

The intricate relationships between those inputs which in any manner affected the demand for a form or forms were best described by partial differential equations. From these I was able to model the expected demand for a given form based on real time levels of activities, and set re-order points that were self-adjusting so as to accomodate both the anticipated demands and the variable & quantity dependent lead times.

by apotheon

. . . and [b]nobody[/b] has any doubt you intended to insult -- at least, nobody with a brain.

by deepsand

You resorted to [i]ad hominem[/i] attacks, and then attempted to misdirect attention from that fact; said comparison served to succinctly & clearly describe the totality of such. That you are offended by a legitimate comparison serves to neither void nor diminish your offense.

As for the views of others re. my intent, best leave it to them to speak for themselves.

by apotheon

Change the subject . . . ? You're kidding -- right? Didn't you notice when I just pointed out that, after letting myself be led astray for so long, you changed the damned subject in the first place?

As for civility, using prettier words to achieve worse insults is hardly civil. This, combined with the above, adds up to one thing:

Hypocrisy much?

Now . . . maybe you could [b]get back on the damned subject[/b] -- specifically, maybe you could explain how tensor calculus relates to programming language design.

edit: typo

by deepsand

Where, when & how.

And, who declared that this discussion was about tensor math?

And, if so, this gives you the right to resort to [i]ad hominem[/i] attacks?

by apotheon

Whack! Ouch, gotta hurt.

"[i]And, who declared that this discussion was about tensor math?[/i]"

I'll try to use small words: We were talking about how math does or does not apply to CompSci.

"[i]And, if so, this gives you the right to resort to ad hominem attacks?[/i]"

I'm not sure whether you're being hypersensitive about someone being less than perfectly worshipful or you simply lack the educational foundation to understand that an [i]argumentum ad hominem[/i] fallacy requires that a personal attack actually replace logical reasoning. If the former, I don't care. If the latter, you're out in left field again.

by tony hopkinson

I can see why it would work, just wondering whether there was a real benefit from the extra effort?
Must say I'd have hacked at that one from expected demand, course that assumes a few other sytems in play. :(

by deepsand

dependent on the future levels of various activities involving marketing of both new & existing products, both to existing policyholders, active & lapsed, (internal marketing), via direct mail (DM), and new ones (external marketing), via DM, TV, radio & newsprint; internal marketing tp active policyholders for the purposes of having them increase their coverage amounts and/or add optional benefits riders; internal marketing for the purposes of improving conversion and/or renewal rates; and, internal marketing to lapsed policyholders soliciting reinstatement.

Given that the response, conversion, renewal & reinstatement rates varied greatly by product, demographics & marketing channel, and that future marketing efforts were highly dependent externalities, forecasting forms demands for more than a few months into the future was problematic.

That I was called upon to design a new system was owing to the fact that the existing one used fixed re-order points that were really little mores than SWAGs, and no longer worked; too many forms were either being used up more quickly than they could be replaced, or gathering dust in the warehouses.

by tony hopkinson

The issues I had were more data quality, recording planned usage, that was originally non existent.
Minimising inventory was always important of course, but came second to the mill being stopped and 350 blokes playing cards on full money, waiting for a part.

by nighthawk808

of not having done this already have clearly demonstrated that no matter how "difficult" the implementation, it is much better than throwing up one's hands and say, "That's hard, therefore it's impossible."

Besides, hasn't the federal government already created a whole slew of standardized tests to measure aptitude in a wide variety of subjects? I believe it was part of some obscure legislation that no one's ever heard of. Some "No Child Misundereducated Act" or something like that. So it's not a hard problem after all.

Would it really be that hard for those same psychometricians to create a short quiz to determine that a voter has a basic level of awareness before being allowed to vote? Hell, I wrote the other one in less than five minutes. Surely it couldn't take a room full of Ph.D.'s more than a month or two to come up with the same basic thing. I'll even officially release the quiz I wrote under the Creative Commons license so everyone can use it.

I'm not talking about making sure people have a Master's degree in international diplomacy here; it's merely a matter of making sure they have at least as much knowledge about the issues they're casting votes on as the average garden snail does. Right now, the only thing you need to qualify as a voter is the fact that you've managed to breathe for 18 consecutive years. In Diebold districts, even that requirement is waived, provided you're a registered Republican. Call me conceited, but I think something is seriously wrong when the 400-lb. screaming woman throwing a chair on the Jerry Springer show is entitled to a vote that counts just as much as mine does simply because she's managed not to get hit by a bus yet. If she can demonstrate a basic level of awareness of what's going on around her, then more power to her, and good for her. But until then, redneck cowboys with gun racks in their pickup trucks should be able to identify something positive about Duhbya Bush besides "He shore gots a purty mouth" before being allowed to cast a vote.

by deepsand

You're only digging a deeper hole for yourself by refusing to own up to your incivility here.

I gave you fair warning when you called me a "dolt," and let you go with that warning only; but, you persisted in repeating your bad behavior.

Why you should do so is a mystery to me.

by deepsand

That project was truly a bitch-and-a-half, which it what made it so memorable & easily called to mind when Wayne asked his question.

I suppose that, like myself before said project, most think of inventory control as being quite straight forward & simple, a function wholly lacking in cachet, one which should offer no challenge to other than the true neophyte. Man, was I wrong!

by deepsand

"[i]I'll try to use small words: We were talking about how math does or does not apply to CompSci.[/i]"

Which fails to explain why I should specifically address [i]tensor[/i] math.

"[i]I'm not sure whether you're being hypersensitive about someone being less than perfectly worshipful or you simply lack the educational foundation to understand that an argumentum ad hominem fallacy requires that a personal attack [b]actually replace[/b] logical reasoning.[/i]" (Emphasis added.)

Perhaps you should revisit the meaning of [i]ad hominem[/i], and its various forms, at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem

by apotheon

"[i]Which fails to explain why I should specifically address tensor math.[/i]"

I think you must have gotten your wit shot off in the war.

"[i]Perhaps you should revisit the meaning of ad hominem[/i]"

Perhaps you should stop pretending you got an effective education.

by deepsand

I bear you no ill will, but I will not quietly suffer abuse from any other here or elsewhere.

Only you have the power to control your emotions; why not exercise such?

by apotheon

When was the last time I was "uncivil"?

"[i]I bear you no ill will[/i]"

Sure -- but you'll still try a "moral high ground" approach to argument when you don't have any factual arguments to use.

"[i]I will not quietly suffer abuse from any other here or elsewhere.[/i]"

Yeah, it's already quite obvious you can't take what you dish out. The fact you try to apply a more dignified veneer to your insults and attacks doesn't change what they are.

"[i]Only you have the power to control your emotions; why not exercise such?[/i]"

Now you're a psychologist . . . ?

by mmutleab

thats on the spot,actualy in everyday life u need maths,even to park a car u need maths.understand maths n de rest are details.i promise you you will enjoy life.

thanks

by deepsand

And, as my post to which you replied was made [b]after[/b] TR "fixed" the new View All function to truncate the allowed nesting depth, it cannot be that your reply was possible owing to that "bug."

If you are able to post a Reply to this post, TR's "fix" broke something.

To answer your question "[i]When was the last time I was "uncivil"?," rather than search for all such occasions, I will point to one that is easily located & obvious - when you called me a "dolt," at https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=221757&messageID=2234043 .

As for "[i]Yeah, it's already quite obvious you can't take what you dish out,[/i]" the fact that I'm still here, despite your hostile attitude & continued slurs, proves otherwise.

If you truly disbelieve me when I say that I bear you no ill will, ask yourself then why it is that there is not evidence of ill will in my postings to you in the discussion re. the new View All function.

by apotheon

I haven't been using the "view all posts" thing to make greater-depth posts at all -- I think the way I've been doing it is a "bug" (or maybe just loophole) that has been there from the very beginning.

"[i]To answer your question[/i]"

I think you missed the point of my question. You told me I needed to stop being "uncivil" and, without commenting on your complaint that I've been "uncivil" in this case, I just asked a question meant to wake you up to the fact that I haven't been "uncivil" for quite a while. It's only your obsessions that's causing you to keep pursuing the matter, and prolonging the agony of your attempt to distract from the actual topic of discussion.

"[i]the fact that I'm still here, despite your hostile attitude & continued slurs, proves otherwise.[/i]"

The fact that, despite your incredible arrogance and far-from-clean hands in attacking other people all the time (just trying to disguise it with pretty words), you throw a hissy fit when someone half-jokingly suggests you avoid acting like a "dolt" makes it pretty clear that you can't take what you dish out.

"[i]ask yourself then why it is that there is not evidence of ill will in my postings to you in the discussion re. the new View All function.[/i]"

I didn't say you bore me, personally, ill will. It just seems obvious you can't handle having your ideas challenged by anyone that actually makes sense. In any case, you'd entirely throw away what little illusion of general civility you think you maintain if you flamed me there, in an entirely separate discussion, where I haven't even really contradicted you.

by goodoh

'... but I'm a freak.'

Wonderful point on the passing away of the 'true' systems analysts.

Couldn't agree more.

Having someone who just performs testing and analysis of function / interface / etc. without attempting to consider the code can make a huge difference to the quality of the finished product.

Yet another example of 'efficiency' (low cost) being the prime driver with quality work being seen as an unsustainable 'cost' instead of an investment.

Funny how we never have time or funds to do things right from the 'get go' but we (almost) always find the greater amount of time and money to fix the mistakes later.

Bring back technical writers to build help files, FAQs etc.

Bring back 'real' system analysts.

Bring back respect for specialists and what they bring to the table.

Team work where the goal keeper isn't expected to also wear the 'striker' hat just works so much better (most of the time).

I know I'm dreaming and that time has past. I just think that, just maybe, if enough heretics chant this maybe it will get tried again and let's see what the real cost/benefit outcome is.

by deepsand

And, you are quite right to mention the tech. writer, who's always seemed to be an afterthought, one worthy of little consideration.

The lack of adequate, if any, documentation today manifests itself in every instance of conceivable need.

Today's creed seems to be "Just get it in the customers' hands; we'll worry about whether or not it works, or if the customer can use it, latter."

Where's Mr. Peabody & his Way-Back Machine?

by deepsand

It may be that this happens only if it's your own post, as clearly you can Reply to where I cannot.

As for "someone half-jokingly suggest(ing) you avoid acting like a "dolt"," the post in which such happened, particularly when read within the context of preceeding post, did not strike me as being even remotely in jest. However, I will accept your word that such was your intent.

Likewise, I would ask that you accept that my comparison of your behavior to another was that which I have earlier said, and not that of insult.

by apotheon

I've been replying beyond "max depth" by editing the URL, not by using the "view all posts" feature.

by zarathustra2010

A man who claims to be a programmer without advanced math skills won't leave his initial interview with a job, unless the job he is applying for is Janitor, dishwasher, or other unskilled positions.

Unless he can demonstrate his math abilities to the interviewer(s), they will politely dismiss him immediately(after all, they will be professionals, unlike such a prospective "programmer), and will all have a huge laugh once he is out of the room.

If all one wants to do is dink around in GWBASIC, he will at the very least need High School math to write any program more complicated than displaying "Hello, World!" on a text display.

Windows/graphics programming REQUIRES Advanced math abilities, as well as advanced programming knowledge, knowledge of the CPU/computer architecture, and at least 2 year of college-level English, as well as the Math necessary for his projects.

Everyone wants to "write programs", but they forget that modern programming languages are quite a bit more advanced than the BASIC we learned on our Atari's and Apple's.

Wanna be a "programmer?"
1) Finish H.S, and concentrate on Math, Science, Business, English, and Programming skills while there.
2) Get a BS in Science in University, with heavy emphasis on Math (Higher Math is better) and Applied Computer Theory
3) Take lots of Business courses, lots of English, and lots Math and Science
4) Finish with a 3.5 GPA or above

Do those, and you will be assured of a bright future as a programmer.

Donald McDaniel

by deepsand

I see "Absolutely get ...," rather than "Absolutely, get ..."

Though, it could just be my eyesight.

;-)

by jo2006

Dan,
How ironic is it that you have deemed it important to point out the requirement for math skills, yet you seem incapable of maintaining proper punctuation and spelling throughout your article?

The argument could easily be turned against you, stating that if you are a technical person, what's the point of learning English? After all - you might only end up writing technical articles that get posted to millions of viewers.

Converting Hex to Decimal might have been a useful skill before the advent of multi-function scientific calculators, but it sure does nothing to improve your grammar.

You will note that English is also a mandatory to get a degree or diploma.
By your own example you've made it apparent that you don't have to have great English skills to be a writer, so it stands to reason that the non-mathematical people out there could easily be more than prepared for technical careers.

Sorry Dan, I'm not trying to flame you. I'm just pointing out the irony behind your posting. I know a lot of techs out there that have no college or university education who are more than capable of figuring out complex formulae *and* writing about them using proper English.

by deepsand

And, as has been noted, written and spoken communications are much more flexible & forgiving by nature than is mathematics, as evidenced by the fact that you understood Dan's post.

Furthermore, that one may not commit the requisite time for closely editing a particular post or posts prior to such being here commited to publication is not necessarily a reliable measure of their language skills. Heaven knows that, on more than one occasion, I've later viewed one of my own posts and been less than pleased.

Best here to avoid critiquing the writing skills of another, lest you yourself be so judged. If you are certain that you understand the writer's intent, let that be sufficient; if not, inquire.

by joules ampere

Why the attack on Dan?s grammar, punctuation and spelling, is this not pedantic nitpicking?

Have you ever looked over the comments in some German programmer?s code intended for English speaking people? The grammar is usually terrible but you still get the idea and the programs are usually good, now do that with the code or the mathematics, if any, in the program. It is a trifle conceited to suggest that the two carries the same weight in this regard, I would very much prefer, or at least, have more respect for the programmer that writes good clever code and accurate mathematics and the odd grammar or punctuation error in documentation, than a kludge monger (or even a clever one) with mathematical errors and pristine journalistic capabilities,

That said though, a good command of English is important in conveying ideas and opinions, and is useful in impressing potential hirers and feeling good about ones? self, what we must understand is that even repeated misuse of words and bad or missing punctuation in the posts here does not have to mean that such individuals would do the same in a resume or an official report, posts are usually done in a careless hasty fashion compared to formal writing. From the general idea is conveyed, and you understand it why go off in this direction?

A lot of us here are guilty of making English mistakes in our posts, all we have to do is point out a mistake that would throw off the understanding or move on if that is not the case.

You seem to be missing the point, you do not have to go to college to understand mathematics, even advanced mathematics, you could very well train yourself. Dan did not suggest that self taught people cannot learn mathematics and hence, can not increase their possibilities, what he is suggesting is that if you are already in school learning programming then they should be teaching you mathematics as well because so many problems in the field of business requires mathematical solutions, I do not gather from what he wrote that you cannot be a programmer without mathematics. It just depends on the kind of programmer you want to be.

The same applies for other professions, you are taught a subject that is not a core part of your field but is of such usefulness that the subject in question is mandatory, such is English in the U.S., he is suggesting that college courses in programming should have mathematics as mandatory,this is not a bad idea at all.

by danlm

chuckle, my reply would have highly offended. No point in offending, it's the weekend. Cheers.

Dan

by absolutely

You're correct, of course. There was no comma, but it was close enough for corporate work.

:^0

by absolutely

No pay = no expectations of quality, as we can plainly see from the recent flood of 'need help password crack' posts.

by danlm

I was going to tell him to f.o.a.d. And ask him if that example of communicating via the English language was acceptable. That it met the requirement of communicating both my intent and my feelings on the specific subject. And if he understood both my intent and feelings by that choice of words?

Language is first communicating of ones feelings, intent, and ideas. I feel that everyone understood what I was trying to communicate even if it wasn't grammatically correct. It was quite obvious that everyone understood my argument that mathematical skills should be a requirement in any formal education with regard to Comp Sci was met. My evidence being the number of replies that have occurred. I feel that I met the primary requirement of any communication. The understanding by the recipient(s) of what I was saying.

Chuckle, just as my choice and phrasing of f.o.a.d. communicates my lack of care about what he thinks. Wonder if the primary requirement was met again?

;o)

Dan

Ya know, all things aside. I'm sick of dick weeds like this twit busting my balls. I've about had it with posting here because of it. I try to research everything that I post about. I also try to listen to both sides of any discussion that occurs on this site. I feel both of those qualities are missing in a lot of posts that occur here. But, because I do not have firm control of written communication. I am constantly at the mercy of twits like him. Screw it, if I wanted my balls busted constantly I would go back with the x wife.

by absolutely

"In reality, unrealistic expectations abound."

Agreed, and that abundance is directly responsible for the vast majority of the abundance of disappointment. Granted, that there is some bad luck, but the chronic, widespread dissatisfaction of welfare statists for example is the result of collective irrationality, not of bad luck. The application of that observation to the question of mathematics' importance to programmers is left as an exercise for the readers.

by absolutely

But it's available to those who want to exercise. It's no Socratic Method I'll admit, but perhaps better than nothing.

by contact

You have just made my point. Everyone can slap together something using visual tools but understanding what these tools do and how to control them properly is the art of programming. Thake the Java SDK by Sun. Who do you think determins where and how the windows open? A programmer who is able to do a little more then 1+1=2! You are hacking! In other words what you call programming is using a utility to do your work. Everyone can use software. These things have limits. And as you have not reached these limits yet may I suggest that you have not done any proper programming to date.

by contact

Hi mate,

Here schools are funded by the government to ensure that everyone is getting at least a basic education. That should include math, reading and writing. These skills are basic in the modern world. Unfortunately people like the original poster, in the US system as you explained it, would not learn one of these basic skills as he does not demand it. Here government actually did not fund some of these basic skills for some time. Now it has been recognised as essential and a huge "catch up" with very limited funding is on the way. Silly! Math is needed! Do not even think to cut one of these essential areas of learning. I am a teacher of IT in a technical high school just outside Sydney and my students are at times not able to work out how much change they are to get in a supermarket. Teaching these people programming, even simple things like HTML and CSS, is close to impossible. However they are very able to make things look good in in e.g. Dreamweaver. How about when things do not work in a certain browser version? They haven't got a clue where to look in the code to fix things.

This discussion is closed to new replies.