Discussion Locked

Insecure networks? Can you trust them?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Is it viable to remove a member of staff when you have an insecure network - i.e passwords are first names if you find deleted porn files on their machine? They claim they did not do it, but Windows 2000 server bug was in existance - could a 3rd party have input evidence into the "innocent" party's machine?
Is it also viable to use as evidence printouts of cookies/cache which have been recovered - can you check when they were created/deleted?

Should the user name that comes up in the recovery data be the same throughout. Would it be possible to log onto that machine and put files on the c: drive.

What about e-mail security, could staff be fired for being sent unsolicited porn e-mails? Surely it is what they do with them (i.e delete them) that is the important thing.

Please let me know your views.

6 replies

by jamesrl

In an organization where people use NT or Win 2000, and security policy is clear in stating that the user is responsible for using good passwords, not sharing them and keeping their machine clean, then you'd have a good case for removal - if you have a stated policy which says no porn on machines - I know it sounds like common sense, but you have to document these policies and make them known. Did the user sign any such document?

Same thing with cache and cookies - if the policy is to keep the machine secure if they let someone else use the machine then they are liable for the consequences. You can check cookies and cache for creation dates.

As for the possibility of planted evidence, it is possible but not probable. Check for trojans like backOrifice, check the logs of any remote control apps your org uses, check to see if the user shares their hard drive.

If you don't have a) a limited number of admins or b) admins you trust, then you have a bigger problem, and you might have trouble making any accusation stick.

As for being fired for receving unsolicited porn spam, you'd have to fire many including me and most of my management.

When you post to any usenet newsgroups you are almost guarenteed to get porn spam, asthere are people who build up lists by combing the newsgroups(with automated tools) for addresses. If you allow users to post from work, and use their email addresses in their post or in the header of the post, you will get all kids of spam, including porn.

Hope that helps.

James

by katherineg

If the user of the machine did not look at porn what so ever, but the password system in the organisation was first names - so let's face it, not too difficult for any other user to figure out, not a case of the user publicising his/her password, but the fact that other people knew it, and they had no juristiction to change it.

Also when the server printout showed the user logging on at out of office hours looking at the sites, when it was physically impossible for them to do so? What couldbe the explanation for this. Surely the printout should match up with the telephone bill - it did not!

No policy in existance for guidance on what is appropriate and what's not - ok, ignorance is no defence, but this could well be a victimisation case.

how thorough would you expect investigations in to this to be? Would it be reasonable not to check for recovered files/cache/cookies etc until 4 months after first suspicion?

Thanx

by ebob

Imagine an organisation where The Policy on passwords was "use your first name"!? That, IMVHO is just asking for trouble (on the part of the company)!

If the log shows that the offending material was acquired during some specific period of time, and if the user can reasonably establish the she/he was not present during that time period, I would suggest that this organisation had very little case, and ought to back off, before the user sues the he** out of the company.

by admin

Policy should be in place and definately it is unlikely that this was planted, but "reasonable doubt" can make it difficult. I have had cases like this, and while this may not help in this instance, once you have strong evidence like you have, it can help to get a keystroke monitoring program, and document what buttons they are pushing while you are observing them in a session -BEFORE someone confronts them on this issue. If they are guilty, it's hard definate evidence. If they are not, then itgives you a chance to find out who is doing this and then piece together where from etc. from your logs. I had a problem like this about 2 years back and I was really hoping the guy wasn't doing this. But he was, and we had the keystrokes with a physical observation of him logged in. We actually never fired him. When confronted, he said he wanted a little time to find a new job, two weeks later he left quietly. It's a lot harder to argue an "outsider" did this to him with documentation.

by shanghai sam

the server log showed that the user id was logging on in the evenings and in the early hours of the morning, when it was impossible for the member of staff to be there. i.e no key to the outer door, nor no knowledge of the security alarm code on thedoor, also the fact that they live over an hour away from the place of work, and had no physical means of actually getting there.

The log showed that at these out of hours times the actual connection with the internet site was for 2 seconds e.g
12:33am (for 2 seconds)

4.07am (for 2 seconds)

Recovered files are on the hard disk of the machine. They were recovered but have no creation times/deletion times - is this right, can recovery software show when they were created/deleted?
The staff member has been out of the office on suspension for 4 months, and the company have only just run recovery software now, and in fact did not examine that laptop in question until after disciplinary action (i.e dismissal) had taken place.
External company who rent an office from the company had full access to the office of this staff member, and were also well aware of the company password system too, which is not only bad internal security, but if a whole other company can know thedetailed in's and out's of another company - that is a bit worrying.

No physical witnesses/video cameras etc have caught the member of staff "red handed". There had been a previous history of deterioration of staff relationships between the staff and this particular person. E.g left out of staff social events, made to work late (when on specified contact) with no overtime pay, when had previous personal commitments to honour. Told to "spy" on the staff and report to an external line manager at a different location and told to copy Microsoft disks without licences.

There are too many if factors? or am I paranoid?

by admin

with all the data you have given, it looks to me to be far from a bulletproof case, and possibly a case of someone getting fired because they were unpopular. One thing to ask is if given the same situation, would one of the "popular" staff members be treated in a similar fashion? I'm not saying that you shouldn't fire people because they are unpopular, sometimes it's better for everyone including the person.....but, I see potential litigation here that could be successful on behalf of the staffthat was fired. At least in my state (which is a "right to work" state i.e. employers can get away with a lot!)

This discussion is closed to new replies.