Discussion Locked

Is it time to change tactics in the "war" on terror?

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A recent BBC story (http://tinyurl.com/53lebr) points out that anti-Americanism is on the rise in Pakistan. It seems American actions are almost universally blamed for the increased attacks by the Taleban.

The current tactics are doing little to win hearts and minds and much to increase hatred of Americans. I think it's time the US backed its forces out of Afghanistan and returned to surveillance and covert operations to identify and locate terrorists.

18 replies

by leezx10

I would say your right to a degree but we started something that should have never been started in the first place. So now with that in mind this war has gotten to sloppy to back out now. What needs to be done isn't being done. Our Military is spread thin and we couldn't protect ourselves if we were attacked, it's a crying shame what this administration has done. The handle of this war was done sloppy, my father always told me to never make an angry decision and that's what Bush did. And to be honest we backed him, instead of thinking about what we were getting into and thinking of a decent strategy we dived in head first. So now we suffer.

Another thing, we would have been way more aggressive with Russia if we weren't spread thin. Be honest it's the truth

by ontheropes

Personally, I want everybody to come home now. I've even got an attitude about it but I'm trying to keep it to myself lest the TR site politicians climb up my ass. I'm not playing that game.

What gets me everytime I read the type of article that you posted is the religious aspect of the whole war. This is not directed at you but I want to say that people are stupid! Flat-out ******* stupid!

I couldn't live with some religion telling me how to conduct myself everyday and I try to understand those who seek the shackles of strong religion but I fail to do it. From what I can see here in the great ol' USA religion is about control, power and money. I think it's the same the world over. That saddens me and pisses me off, both, at the same time.

Stopping before I blather on too far.

by delbertpgh

The Taliban is the creation of Pakistan's I.S.I., Inter-Services Intelligence agency, Pakistan's military state-within-a-state. You know how everybody spins ludicrous consipiracy theories about the C.I.A. and Israel's Mossad, the intelligence agencies that live beyond the law and seem to control everything? Out in the Hindu Kush, that's what the I.S.I. tries to be. They can't decide whether they're Pakistani nationalists or Allah-besotted jihadists. They try to be both. The Paki government is scared to hell by the I.S.I. and everything else it can't control, and cheerfully goes about trying to appease any force that seems like it might contest the sovereign government, were it angry enough. Hey, and also, they don't actually govern that quarter of their country adjoining Afghanistan; they just wave a flag over it. Nearsightedness seems to be a medical qualification for Pakistani politicians.

So, what to do about the Afghan war, when our strong right arm is an inveterate screwup? We have to be clear about our aims, and not get distracted by the Pakis. Except the atomic bomb part, which they have. That piece requires extra precautions, but it must not drive all of American policy.

This is a really complex mess, where politics constrain the military side. The military side is where we really have to work hard, like, bombing the Paki side of the border when we have to. But we should not carelessly bomb households along the border simply to save American soldiers' lives; this may seem unnatural to USA patriots, but we owe it to our mission to pretend Pakistani and Afghan civilian lives actually are important to us.

We shouldn't stop bombing and killing, and bribing the survivors, because this is an important thing and losing it would be costly to western civ.

Here are a couple of thoughtful links:
http://www.slate.com/id/2200134/
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3724/is_/ai_n27994317

In case this reads a little incoherently, please note it is Saturday cocktail hour, and I have been working on the Wild Turkey, pate, and cornichons, and going back for more of the bourbon.

by charliespencer

The war on poverty
The war on drugs
The war on terrorism

Can we stop using the word in circumstances where it doesn't fit?

We're not interested in the permanent capture of territory. There is no opposing commander capable of surrendering. We aren't taking conventional prisoners of war. We've asked no sacrifices of the civilian population to support the effort, other than taking off their shoes at the airport.

Yes, we need to change our tactics in how we respond to terrorism. Step One is to realize 'war' tactics aren't going to achieve our goals. This assumes we've defined our goals; does anyone know what they are in this 'war'? Maybe that should be Step One...

by delbertpgh

"War" is probably an appropriate name for a fight where we are trying to shoot somebody in the head and they are trying to fly airplanes into our cities.

With respect to invading Iraq, "war on terror" was probably a less appropriate metaphor than "missionary position", but since that's five years and 3,000 boys in the past, "war" will suffice, here, too.

Terror can be fought in Afghanistan, even today. Not so sure about Iraq, but we can't afford to leave that place in collapse.

by charliespencer

None of these terrorist organizations have conventional or traditional military goals. They aren't interested in taking U.S. land. They aren't capturing prisoners of war in the Geneva Convention sense of the word. They aren't going to submit terms of surrender to us. They have no military objectives or structure. I don't know what they're conducting, but it isn't war. If they're not, then it's a mistake for us to respond with traditional 'war' strategies and tactics.

I also notice that we haven't formally declared war on anyone. I blame the President for not having the testicular manhood ask Congress to do so, and I blame Congress for not having the genitalia to require such a declaration before providing the initial or ongoing funding.

I'm not saying military action isn't a necessary part of the solution. I fully supported our decision to take military action in Afghanistan, and continue to do so. Iraq was always a distraction, but I agree we can't leave it to collapse. All I'm disputing it the use of the term 'war'. The word carries certain connotations with the civilian population, implications that a military solution should be the cornerstone of our approach. I wonder how many hearts and minds we could have won airdropping a few hundred million dollars worth of socks and underwear, while simultaneously creating jobs at home. Yes, we'd be bribing the civilian population, but I consider that less of a compromise of our principles than waterboarding.

by tony hopkinson

Politically it's a good word, Rally the nation, patriotism, etc. In terms of a tactical mindset, in that it encourages military only thinking, it sucks though.

War is essentially two (or more) nations engaging in combat, none of our enemies are nations....

Sun Tzu would be appalled is all I can say

by john.a.wills

I think when you wrote "two (or more) nations" you meant "two (or more) states". The old Papal States were not a national state, but they made war, alas. The Gypsies are a nation, but they do not make war on anyone. You are here defining "war" are you not?

by nicknielsen

I don't like the word in this context either. We're fighting terror, but as you pointed out, it's not a war by the formal definition.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

it's time to drop war altogether. But the war on terror strikes me as an oxymoron of sorts right off the bat. Fighting violence and fear with violence and fear is futile. Violence and fear beget violence and fear.

by tony hopkinson

us supporting a Dictator (Musharaff) out of political expediency is the real problem.

Just like support for previous meglamaniacs that were pragmatically in favour of us. Hussein, the Shah, Stalin, even the Taliban at one point.....

by charliespencer

isn't automatically my friend, and shouldn't be automatically supported as such.

You forgot Noriega and many other Latin American juntas.

by tony hopkinson

just got to remeber the enemies of your new friend are now your enemies. In Musharaff's case this included a substantial portion of his population.

The Pakistani- Afghan border was nicely soft, gave us all sorts of openings, but borders have two sides.....

Entirely predictable, I'm afraid. Worth it, time will tell.

by tony hopkinson

States would have got my point across, a bit more clearly. But you could war on gypsies, or catholics, the souix, or even muslims for that matter.

Unidentifiable percentages of nations, No.

War against nations is far easier, check the uniform or the passport and off you go.

by tink!

by any means. I do not know the finer points of each political/military group.

I do think, however, that we should begin pulling our forces out of other countries. Especially in the Middle East. I think we're in over our heads over there and doing more harm than good. Yes, we want to stop terrorism, but the putting our forces in their countries is not going to stop it, but rather increase their hatred and give them more reason to attack us.

I'm not saying that covert action is better. We've failed at that many times overs. Diplomatically though, it probably is better for our reputation overall. When we make a worldwide scene with putting our troops in another country, we open ourselves up to scrutiny by the world. Every move is watched closely. If we got out and did things more quietly, it may be better politically at least.

This discussion is closed to new replies.