Discussion Locked

Is Lotus Notes the worst business application ever?

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

My current job is the 3rd position I have taken with a company that has inflicted Lotus Notes on its employees.

There is a great web site http://lotusnotessucks.4t.com/ that elaborates on many of the frustrating quirks of this fine application. I have tried to post some of my own favourite application anti-features to the site, but without success (I'm guessing that the site is full).

Here I list my 9 favourite stupid annoyances that come with Lotus Notes v6.5:

9. 'You cannot drag and drop out of trash with soft deletes enabled, use restore instead' - It knows that I want to restore an email from the trash folder to the inbox folder, but for some reason insists that you use the restore command.
8. 'You are not authorized to perform that operation' - This message is displayed when you try to send an email to a list of invitees on a meeting which you did not schedule. You can see the invited people, and Notes even displays a menu command, 'Send memo to all invitees'. If you select this command while focused on someone else's meeting this is the message you will get - duh!
7. Refresh your inbox. It knows that you have new email, because it displays a refresh tag on your inbox, but you have to click on the tag to retrieve your email. If it knows I have email, just go get it, why are you asking me to get it?
6. Create a new email from a Windows application while Notes is displaying the Trash folder. When you display an email in any folder other than Trash you will get the expected 'Reply', 'Reply To All', 'Forward', etc commands. If the email is in the Trash folder all you get are 'Restore' and 'Delete' commands. If you create a new email from outside Notes while Notes is displaying the Trash folder, guess what, you get the Trash folder commands displayed on the new email. You have to 'Restore' your new email before you are able to send it.
5. 'The document could not be deleted because you currently have the same document open in the preview pane. This document will now be closed so that it may deleted from the current view' - oh, give me a break. You know I want to delete it, so just delete it, but no .. Notes will display it in a view where you may press the delete button again and this time it will delete it.
4,3,2,1. This annoyance gets the top 4 spots because it proved to be a total embarrassment to me at work this week. There are at least 4 annoyances with the repeating functionality associated with scheduling a meeting. Firstly, once you schedule a repeating meeting and send out the invite there is no way to change the repeats. You have to cancel the meeting and reschedule. Also when you cancel, Notes will automatically send an email to all invitees informing them that you have canceled the meeting. Earlier this week I attempted to schedule a repeating meeting every Monday, Wednesday and Friday for the next couple of months. I copied an existing meeting whose invites included some high level managers. After several failed attempts to schedule a repeating meeting, I finally gave up and sent a meeting notice for each day. The result being many many meeting notices and canceled meeting notice being delivered to the inboxes of my management and several colleagues. The result being that I looked like a total idiot who could not schedule a meeting with Lotus Notes.
Addendum: One I forgot, I guess because it happens so frequently it almost appears to be normal behaviour - if you have any text selected in a message and you hit 'Delete', nothing happens. Deselect the text and the 'Delete' button now works - duh!

If you are ever offered the opportunity to work with this unique IBM application be prepared for a whole new software experience. Alternatively just run away, it's better for your health in the long run.

If you are interested in reading more, visit the Lotus Notes Sucks website to see many unique features offered by this application.

Les.

24 replies

by maniacman

Having established my career around HP servers, I am a bit biased yet open minded, but when I saw the problems involved with setting up an IBM server and all the rediculous firmware updates that have to be performed for every separate subcomponent and the post OS install of RAID and NIC teaming utilities, I was convinced that IBM servers are joke and shouldn't be called servers. There is too much third party crap inside IBM servers, explaining why one has to run around with a stack of CDs' just to get all the firmware updates in place. Setting up an IBM servers is nothing like an HP using the SnmartStart CD that bundles all the drivers and utlities together. With IBM's ServerGuide CD, all you get is an unattended install of the OS, afterwhich you have to apply the appropriate NIC drivers, RAID Config Utility, and NIC teaming software separately. My condolences to any company running IBM servers and even worse, their sorry excuse for a messaging platform they call Lotus Notes.

by hal 9000

The worst application that was ever forced onto Business is M$ DOS and latter Windows. Both of these should be called [b]Microsoft Denial Of Service[/b] not an OS of any kind. Why anyone would consider using a Cheap Domestic platform for Business is way beyond my understanding.

If I could lay my hands on the Moron who came up with the idea of adopting a Domestic OS to a Business and consider this as a Usable Alternative to what was previously available I would quite happily string them up by their [b]Family Jewels[/b] and leave them hanging for all to beat up when they feel like it.

Actually what you are complaining about is a problem introduced by the OS that your beloved Application runs on not the actual application itself. Lotus Notes has to live with the short comings of the OS.

Col

by hal 9000

OK then back in the old days there where Computers Without Microsoft being used. Granted they cost an Arm & a Leg but they worked. Then along came MICROSOFT which is really an Acronym for [b]Most Intelligent Customers Realise Our Software Only Fools Teenagers.[/b]

I got that of my desk calender last year noting worth repeating this year. :(

Col

by jonathanpdx

There's very little in the way of business software that could be considered well-written and/or really user-friendly...in fact, I can't think of any right now.

And yes, I agree with Col that Micro$oft takes most of the blame for the poor stuff we get to work around...um...I mean "with."

by sobaldrick

.. that if I have text selected in an email, it is not possible to delete that email.

Hmmm, I'll get Bill on that right away.

Les.

by hal 9000

That Bill had left the Office and was no longer around.

So attempting to contact William and make a complaint will do no good. But if you ring Steve up he'll bend over back wards to fix your issue. He really cares about the Product that the Company that he runs sells. :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D :^0 :D

Col

by jdclyde

Your top peeve? Drag it to a new day. Easy.

Permissions problems? That is because your admin has not given permission, probably because they don't know HOW.

Logically, no one would EVER reply to an email they had deleted. Sorry the programmers expected more out of you than to delete something you really wanted.

Have to restore? Wow, is that a hardship.

The top reasons to use Notes over exchange? Virus infections. The scheduling and calendar features are far superior to exchange because Notes is DESIGNED for global communications.

Notes does not allow the virus to get a hold of your address book and pass on to all your contacts, no matter how stupid the end user is, or what attachments they decide to open.

We also run it on Linux and it is rock solid. It is rare that we have to take the server down, can the exchange counter-parts say the same?

Don't confuse a few quirks that you are not used to with a system being a good business tool. The mail gets through, and the employees have a good tool to communicate more than simple emails through, and that is what counts.

Or was your whole point just trying to be funny and I just missed the joke?

by sobaldrick

.. and address the other 750 complaints about Notes.

"Logically, no one would EVER reply to an email they had deleted. "

Er, you are joking - aren't you?

Les.

by jdclyde

then you would be smart enough to keep the original email as part of your correspondences, correct? That means you would decide that you had made a mistake when you deleted the email and would restore it, and then file it accordingly.

Other than clearing up attachments, one should never be too quick to delete a business email.

by jamesrl

I've been a Lotus Notes admin and developer. Not familiar with the current version but spent three years with the product.

I've also had the joy of working with Exchange for a few years, 10 in fact, but only as a user. Mind some of my staff were exchange admins.

While I prefer the Outlook client to lotus notes for mail, I do undertsand why some companies choose it. Its development environment is far better than what you can do with Sharepoint (I do some sharepoint admin myself now).

From the number of times I've seen exchange fail to send out meeting time changes, send duplicates, fail to delete meetings I've deleted etc., I have come to think there are some fundamental issues with exchange calendering too.

The other shining thing that Notes does better is indexing. Doing searches in Outlook is really slow - so much so that many people like me use third party tools like Lookout to build a separate index. Notes indexes very well. And key encryption is helpful to some of us too, though a pain to admin.

James

by dr dij

encryption well. It was automatically enabled for our whole global enterprise.

by sobaldrick

Yesterday's work experience with Lotus Notes. This is beyond anything I thought even Notes could inflict on its users.

I was asked by a manger for a copy of an email I sent out over a week ago. Now, normally I'm pretty good a filing, but in this case I could not find the email in the folder where I should have filed it.

Nevermind, Notes has an 'all documents' view, which displays every email. From there I can simply search for the elusive email.

I type in the search word and Notes displays somewhere around 20 emails for me to search through. No problem .. but ah, that first is a duplicate, I should delete that while I can see it. So I select the email with the mouse to highlight it and press delete. Guess what happened!

Every one of the 20 or so emails that were displayed were sent to the Trash folder. Duh!

Ok, annoying, but I can recover. Simply open the Trash folder, search for those same emails and restore them. What happens when I search for emails in the Trash folder? I get a message stating that the search operation is not valid in this folder .. fer crying out loud. How can any company get away with implementing software to STOP you doing your job - arghh!!!

Les.

by jdclyde

You had something very simple assigned to you, get and forward an email. You seem to be easily distracted that you would be sidetracked so easily.

by sobaldrick

It's so that you can reply to emails that you have deleted. What else .. otherwise when I delete an email it would just disappear - no!

So if I reply to an email in the trash folder any idiot with minimal common sense would realise that it was deleted by mistake and that the application should help me out by prompting me to restore the email - not making it as difficult as possible to reply, as Notes does.

Ok, name one other application with similar behaviour - just one.

This is the major complaint about Notes. Other applications have learnt from user feedback how the users want the application to behave. It's as if Notes is stuck in an 80's time warp and the developers have learnt nothing since Microsoft took over. I'm not saying Microsoft is perfect, but at least they solicit and respond to user experiences.

Les.

by jdclyde

You can write your own applications, anyway you like. The "problem" with Notes is it gives you TO much flexibility and to many options. It seems zero level users don't WANT flexibility.

As for the Trash, that is for the "oops" factor. If you ACCIDENTALLY delete something that your not done with, you can easily get it back without having to have your admins restore it for you. It is NOT a work area, and if you are still working with the email, you restore it. It isn't trash if your not done with it, right?

Your blaming the program because of your own inability to manage your mail, or make a sound decision on when it is time to delete or not.

Compare the calendar features to outlook, and the way you can work with others to schedule and plan. You will see that the group features work together much better.

Don't confuse you not "liking" a package with it not being a good business tool.

Ask the Exchange admins here how often their systems need to be rebooted. I can't speak first hand for the Notes installed on Windows, but running on Linux it is a tank that just keeps going.

by sobaldrick

Unless you are using Lotus Notes, it would have been a simple task. LN can make the simplest of tasks extremely complicated. What were they thinking of when the developers built this crap? My guess is .. they weren't.

This is a case of an application being designed by developers without any analysis being performed on usability.

C'mon this is BS and you know it.

Les.

by robo_dev

At a prior company they used simple Notes ACLs to control a database of everybody's password (17,000 users), then they accidentally setup the security such that indidivual mail NSF files were browsable (!!!)

Lotus Notes ACLs can be hacked by any script kiddie with a simple hex editor. Browsable NSFs mean you can download it to your PC and open it with your email client, and now you've got the person's email...all of it.

The net result was that we could grab ANYBODYS email password, and we could read ANYBODYs email and also access anyone's notes databases, except for the ones who accidentally turned on encryption. (we were allowed to do this, BTW)

Even better, the "consultant" who did a HR Notes database migration left a database export of all employees on a company-internal anonymous FTP server. SSNs, salary info, the whole works....

Now not all these issues are the fault of Notes, but the system was setup by their 'Expert Highly-Paid Consultants' who were only one of the three.

by apufford

It's unfortunate that you had this experience because Notes/Domino is more secure than any other messaging/collaboration package available. The CIA uses Lotus Notes. Yes, there are many 'Expert Highly-Paid Consultants' that don't have a clue, but that's true in all technologies.

by shaneho

Number 5 is the real killer for me.

It is incredibly frustrating that it won't let you delete an email, just because it is open in the preview pane. This is the most non-user centric piece of design.

I found somewhere on the IBM site where this action is considered to be 'by design' so they're not going to fix it.

Thanks guys

by apufford

You do realize that you are using Lotus Notes 6.5 which is two major releases behind the current version of 8.5.2. You're using a product that was released in Sept. 2003. Not your fault but your company should upgrade as Notes is a totally different experience now. Outlook was garbage back then too. I use both Notes 8.5.2 and Outlook 2010 depending on what mail account I am accessing.

by bradley strider

This is the standard defence offered up by Notes fans: "You're still using version X? Just upgrade to X+N, it'll fix that".

In Notes's case, this is rarely true. Sure, every now and then a longstanding and truly hated issue is fixed (like the Function hotkeys on Windows). But the fundamental user interface problems that make the product so frustrating for regular Mail & Calendar users are never really tackled.

The redesign a few years back is little more than porcine lipstick, adding a new layer of Eclipse complexity onto a product that already shows its age in a bad way.

Menu bars and preferences (Location? Application? etc) are still all over the place, and seem to mutate randomly. The Soft Delete vs. drag issue persists. The Mail Rules editor is still brutal. Long network operations still hang the UI. Leaky abstractions are everywhere.

Workflow is the problem. More sidebars and pretty skins aren't going to fix that.

This discussion is closed to new replies.