Discussion Locked

Is Microsoft *really* the only game in t

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I often hear people complaining, sometimes loudly others in passing, about Microsoft's pricing and licensing policies. Additionally, we've all seen some reliability problems in Microsoft's Operating Systems. Don't get me wrong, I'm not here to bash on Microsoft. I use plenty of their products for a variety of reasons. I accept the aforementioned security/reliability issues as the price for that use.

I have to wonder about those that complain about Microsoft's products, but buy them repeatedly anyway. So I ask: "Is Microsoft *REALLY* the only game in town?"

The answer, of course, is a resounding "No". Why is it that we would rather complain about Microsoft than do something about it? Last time I checked, this was a free market. Why not exercise the power that this system inherently bestows on the consumer (vice the provider)? Are the various flavors of UNIX (BSD, Linux, SystemV) really so bad as that? I don't think so.

Many complain about the learning curve associated with UNIX. The truth is that when running X (gui for UNIX) you can add other software, such as Gnome and Enlightenment, to it in order to make it look like windows. This radically reduces the learning curve associated with the use of the operating system.

Need productivity software? How about StarOffice from Sun? Corel offers WordPerfect suite for Linux/UNIX. Both of these packages can read from and write to your current MS Office documents. Both are available either free or at least inexpensively. Last time I checked, WordPerfect Suite was available from CompUSA for under $100 last time I checked, and it included the install CD's for Corel Linux.

I don't see a need for any user, corporate, government or private, to feel locked in to Microsoft's products.

Am I wrong?

2 replies

by salmonslayer

MS is not the only game in town. Many people still use Novell for their servers, and I know of quite a few locations which are still running Novell 3.11 (bulletproof and secure). BUT the people that make the decisions will see a big shiny ad in a magazine and think "We should have this". As a result, those that have the best advertising do not need the best product.

Linux (and StarOffice) is slowly making inroads, especially in smaller shops, but many of the larger shops claim compatibility issues, stating that policy makes them use NT for their server, Win98 on the desktop and Office for their suite. As long as policy dictates, MS will continue to rule the larger shops.

by charley

Is it not our jobs, as the technical experts of our respective companies, to look out for the best interests of the company from an IT perspective? I believe it is.

For me, that means finding solutions that are a) fast, b) reliable and c) inexpensive. That means hand-built workstations, Win98 for the Art Dept., FreeBSD for the developers, and Linux for just about everyone else. Using this approach, we were able to completely re-equip our entire inventory of PC's (~100 workstations and 6 high-end PC-based servers)for a little over $260k. I could not POSSIBLY have done that using all MS products.

In the end, as it is said, there is a time and a place for everything. I use MS products where they fit and not elsewhere.

This discussion is closed to new replies.