Discussion Locked

IT Admin "Was Fired" But... Was it a GOOD idea?

0 helpful
266 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

266 replies

by oldtimer1

IT and law have little to do with each other. It was the company`s responsibility to have policies in place. It was the companies resposibility to make sure they had the tools to run their business.
And I`ll go one step further. It sounds to me like the reason for firing was concocted. They claim he ran it wrong on purpose. Maybe all he did was let it run as designed till it failed. (I`ve done this many times to prove a point-or to get something to actually work-not sure if this applies here because I worked for a huge company with layers of so called design engineers).
And as far as the encryption goes, all he has to say is that it was part of security and how many years do you want to spend in court to prove him wrong?
Just by the way this company handled the whole situation I have to give the guy fired the benifit of the doubt. I`m not going to assume him guilty of anything. And if I was the guy fired I sure as hell wouldn`t tell you what the passwords are. Hiring a lawyer would be worth it to me. I`ve delt with enough asses in management positions to know better.

by whiteknight_

the original post stated:
"They found in there investigation, that this IT Admin, deliberately mismanaged the net work to obtain software and hardware for both personal use and for personal private transactions."

Why would you give this person "the benefit of the doubt"?

by xerxes612

Wayne has the right answer. It sounds like you have run a few projects in your lifetime. Plan ahead, life is similar to a chess game.

Comment: Kind of a Monday Quarterback answer. This is a fix you don't want to get yourself in to begin with. Seems you will need to pay big bucks for a security firm to come in and decrypt passwords. Hiring back is not an option you want to even think about. If thi man was sabotageing the network to get new products he would raher work with, I wouldn't let him back on the property. Matter of fact, maybe not even within wireless range.

Good luck in your endeavors.

by oldtimer1

Other than when you do drag him in front of a judge 6 months down the road..."Encryption was part of my job and...mmmm..I forgot what the passwords were judge. They fired me and i just forgot when I stopped using them"...duh
I`d love to attend that court case.

by fooser dan the network man

To answer your questions:

1 - Try to contact the previous admin and get the passwords.

2 - Some smaller/growing companies may have never had to deal with "Real" IT issues in the past, and ignorance of IT is their main problem. I have an uncle with a small company who is sort of in the same boat (I have helped him out a little along the way, but I try to keep my distance for various reasons). This type of situation provides a very steep, yet valuable, Learning Curve for people like this.

by oldtimer1

From what little details that were given in the original story I don`t see a case, especially a criminal one.
Maybe a civil one, but I doubt it. And this company doesn`t have the time.
This company had a special secret group that found all this wrong doing?..but didn`t have the common sense to know hoe to run a network? Explain that one in court.
Sorry but the mangement that put this company in this position should be fired. total incompetence.
I worked for a large telco that did this all the time.Blamed the little guy for management design that didn`t work. And the ass that designed it? Promoted and long gone.

by whiteknight_

Sheiba, the original post stated
"They found in there investigation, that this IT Admin, deliberately mismanaged the net work to obtain software and hardware for both personal use and for personal private transactions."

Is this not sufficient reason for you?

by techrepublic.com

I just went through this, I own a consulting firm in Scottsdale, AZ, where we offer outsourced IT services for companies. We act as their Chief Technology Officer, and they rely on us for everything from phone service and systems, to computers and servers, to copiers, etc.

We recently had a run in with a client, where we would not release a password, until payment was made in full on the last invoice for service, as we didn't think we were going to be paid. This client went nuts, and ended up calling other clients, making false statements to federal agencies, etc., so we decided that we weren't going to be paid for the invoice, so why would we give up the password? It's their fault for not demanding to know the password while we were all on good terms, I figure.

Anyway, everyone always says that this is a federal case, when one won't give up a password. I'd love to see the statute one is in violation of when they refuse to simply tell someone a password which they know? I don't believe there is anything that can be done, except maybe a civil law suit, but proving that is a difficult thing at best to do.

My 2 cents worth, anyway.

Incidentially, we signed Non-Disclosure agreements will all of the rest of our clients after this client acted up, and we canned him, included in there, is an agreement about how the last invoice is handled, and how the password is handed off, if the relationship ends, so all works out in the end.

-Toby Alan Dion

by tonythetiger

That's the equivalent of the landlord locking out the tenants for not paying rent, which is illegal in most if not all states. Though there may be no statutes now, I would not be surprised to see some pretty soon.

It's just a personal opinion, but I think you were wrong to not turn over the password, instead you should have taken the client to court for payment.

"It's their fault for not demanding to know the password while we were all on good terms, I figure.
"

A company that takes intentionally takes advantage of its client's ignorance is not a company I'd recommend to my associates...

by mgordon

Pretty good analogy. Another is a mechanic's lien; if you take an automobile in for repairs, they do not have to give you the automobile back until you pay. Am I wrong? Anyway, I looked it up; it appears that in Texas, landlords can lock you out, in Hawaii, they cannot. This suggests that it depends on whether you are in a "red" (republican) or "blue" (democrat) state.

by wernerlr

Toby described a completely different scenerio than Tony & Neil. Toby had a legitimate reason for denying password(s) from their client and should/probably would prevail in court.

As far as I'm concerned, the admin described in this thread should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.

The admin apparently carries the ethics of a snail. Not only did he/she violate the policies of the company paying their salary, they also violated the principals that any reasonably ethical person carries.

They abused the company system for their own personal gain and intentionally encrypted and held back passwords that the company needs to carry on their business.

Certainly, immediate management carries some of the blame for allowing this to happen, but the admin bares direct responsiblity for intentionally making it happen.

by tony hopkinson

He caused a security incident so he could authorise the purchase of an enterprise security solution instead of relying on the windows firewall. Clowns who let themselves get shafted like this probably thought they were safe.
Why he got sacked misses the point,there have been and are many law-abiding admins who could easily end up leaving their employers in a similar state.

by cmc

We are a small healthcare company and I am the Operations Manager. We have an IT person that managers our server, software, network etc and continually puts off my request for documentation for our company. He says that we have a Disaster Recovery Program and Ghost images and that is enough.

Can you tell me what specifically I need documented and how to encourage this fella to do this for me?

Desparate

by jaqui

you need a list of all software installed.
a detail list of what hardware there is
a detailed diagram of the network topology
a complete listing of all admin passwords in use.
cd keys / software serials
hardware serial numbers

in writing to the it guy:
this data is required for company records, we need it fully documented by $DATE
( give reasonable amount of time for the deadline, the more detailed data you want, the longer the time required )

if he doesn't have it for you by then, you are looking at someone who is trying to maintain job security through illegal means.

by jay51

Where was his anger aimed? It appears to me that management wasn't doing their job at all here. First thing's first some companies can't afford to have more than one IT admin, but most just don't understand how important IT is and there for don't invest into that department or the IT staff. This guy was obviously unhappy and bored with his job and a good management staff would have known this and solve the problem before there were harmful actions taken by this IT Admin and prevented this entire thing. I agree that IT to IT talk would probably get the new guy what he needs but I warn the new guy will probably get enough information that he will quit. Sounds like a lack of good management and lack of knowing how important your IT department is. Now what I can't figure out his how they could afford to hire the investigators but were unable to afford a larger IT Staff. Which would have been more effective here?

Jay

by rush2112

I agree, there was no prelude discussed, just "your fired" bye!

WHOOPS...we let him go now we not have any keys master, how will we operate?

...once upon a time....
Fear not Goblin clerk, we shall hire a rogue RANGER who knows the ways of the wild and he will come in with his trusty band of fighters who will restore our business network and the Hobbits once again shall have their gardening supplies.

Then the quest for the Dragon-Admin shall begin once we have the funds to hire more Urukai to (ahem) "HANDLE" the situation within the confines of the law.

by tonybaggadonuts

With a little scripting know-how, a true IT pro can change any PW w/o knowing the original PW.

This would be simpler and way less confrontational than contacting the firee (is that a word?).

I also think IT ignorance is out of control. Luckily my CFO is tech savvy and aware of most issues, but whatever company one works for... those in non-IT positions have no clue what is possible from the help desk, though IT peeps know everything about what goes on at their desks. In today's world, knowing only how to do YOUR job isn't enough anymore. The synergy must be there.

by bronzemouse2003

Losses pile up quickly - and are probably recoverable from Administrator1.

In his best interest to give up the passwords as soon as possible.

by mgordon

I concur with the two person rule and there's slightly more to it than that -- they should be cooperative but not "best buds". As the old saying goes, "Who is watching the watcher?" You have two admins able to watch each other, cooperative but maybe slightly suspicious of the other one. Maybe each has a sniffer; everyone knows it and keeps the admins honest.

It would be expensive if people think "inside the box"; two network engineers, two server admins, two helpdesk staff, etc. But a smaller company can keep the two without busting the budget quite easily; it is what we called in the Navy "collateral duties". One person is the network engineer and another the database administrator (DBA). The Network engineer obtains SQL knowledge and is the backup DBA. Not an expert, but a backup. Likewise the DBA can obtain some Cisco training, maybe get CCNA certification. That way you may, on paper, still only have one of each, but in fact, you have two of each.

I am emphatic about this and spend typically 1/10th of every day training my subordinates in my skills. I'm also a Boy Scout leader and do the same thing; if a Scout can do it, the leader should not. Likewise at work. In many areas I am the expert. This produces strange results -- upper management is often quite young and does not comprehend the strategy -- I'll take a tier 1 helpdesk call so that my new technicians can work on a complicated (to them) database or Cisco problem. They don't want to be Tier 1 forever and I want to go on vacation someday! They must learn my skills so I drill them pretty hard sometimes and to make it so I sometimes take the easy or tedious stuff like installing a printer driver for the 500th time.

Sometimes younger people do not recognize what is happening and suppose that the elder is just lazy; but in fact the elder is surreptitiously watching carefully to head off disaster in case what the junior is about to do would be a Bad Thing.

Some of my best mentors were real a**holes that made me angry and thus I became motivated to show my stuff.

One solution to the obvious problem of making the CEO an administrator (he is not so where I work) is an 'escrow' where the boss or secretary keeps certain critical information.

Companies that do not think of this are obviously lower on the Darwinian evolutionary scale and may not survive a shakeout event such as a rogue administrator taking the keys of the kingdom with him.

by beoweolf

first bad Idea. In the effort to keep IT dept. "lean", too many companies have too few employees, pay to little and expect too much. They got into this situation because of mismanagment...not having sufficent staff, an equally talented assistant, would have required equal access to the system.

Second bad Idea. Annual or more frequent security reviews or audits, are set up to reveal and document just this sort of potential problem. Passwords to all signigant systems, applications should be stored in multiple locations. One should be a written list, sealed in an envelope and kept available, on site, in a secure safe(?) in an area distant rom the servers.

If they knew they were going to fire him, they should have taken precautions to secure the password before discharging him...at the very least, during the exit process, they should have had him remain and provide the passwords to the new administrator who would then logon to each server, service or application to verify the legitimacy of each before escourting him off the property. As it is, final settlement of his related company affairs (should be leagally seized, held in escrow until he is forthcoming). Have a formular developed to propose a daily charge aginst his settlement, that accesses a charge for each day he does not comply.

Third, seems they could have handle the discharge better. Summary dismissle seems a bit harsh (as well as imprudent) for assumed software theft. On occasion we have all purchased software or taken "evaluation" software that could be used in support of the company...home to spend our own time learning the ins and outs, in a less visible arena. Then installed it on the company servers. Was this the case, I don't know, there aren't enough facts to determine, but if the guy is as good s they thought he was, seems he was owed a fair hearing and possibly a probation instead of summary discharge. One of the conditions for probation could reasonably be made to require he place redundency for his position as a priority.

Final: this is not as much of a tresspass as it might seem. Give the history of "time bomb" packages being left in systems by disgruntled IT workers, those with a tenuous grasp on their position or those who have some form of precognition. Just getting the passwords is no guarantee of security. If the guy has any abilities with assembly language, they could be in hot water for a long, long time.

Moral: treat your IT people with some respect, manage, review, require justification for purchses and regulary audit system procedures...and watch them like a Hawk.

PS. most Certificat base encryption systems have an account that can reset or remove lost encryption. Get a pro if you don't have inhouse staff that can perform the service.

by jhogue1

George Bernard Shaw remarked that the British and Americans were two peoples separated by a common language.

by gnx

You could have some people assist him in remembering what the passwords are. Or I would just take him to court and sue him.

by it-latino

Is it possible to sue this guy? I mean, has he legal responsibility for encrypting critical files and walking away?
Regards,

by gnx

I have all my passwords etc. written down and placed in a safe that I and two others have access to. This is because of SOX. If the guy blatantly passworded everything you may have a case to sue him for the cost of getting them or you could do like they did when I was a kid. A drug dealer was in the nieghborhood and wouldn't move because he was getting free rent (not paying) and new the renter's rights. One night around 2:30 in August there was screaming coming from his house. Two guys were holding him from the third floor by his legs making him an offer he couldn't refuse. He moved 3 days later. I don't recommend this option but it works.

by too old for it

... you would have for fairly complex and arcane technical, moral and technology questions being decided by 3 housewives, 2 retirees, a truckdriver, four plant workers ....

by abrannon

Management should have documented everything before the fired him. There are plenty of reasons why you would need password/server builds/network setup documented. After they fired this guy they should have forced password changed company wide. My current employer had a similar situation occur and they did exactly what I suggested. When one person didn?t change his password the ex-IT guy logged in and sent some bad email to a few people. End result is Document Document before you get rid of the guy that runs the show. When he leaves make sure you?re now the only one with access. Management should swallow their pride shell out the $$ to get a legitimate password cracking service to open things up.

As far as the current IT guy goes, I would help this company get their IT in shape then leave for better waters.

by dfnet

I agree the importance of documentation. This should be part of IT management to ensure the continuity of business. What happend if the only "know all" guy had a misfortunte and cannot come back to work? With proper documentation the company can ensure smooth transtition with minimum disruption to business. Although it is tedious to maintain good documentation of everything but at the minimum there should be a good disaster recovery plan, and this is what a "disaster" can do to company....

by jhogue1

I teach IT at the University level. I tell my students that they can get a job in IT with lousy spelling and communication skills. The problem is that them limit themselves to lower level jobs. To move up to the top of the ladder they need to be able to express themselves in "business speak" and not just geekology. In order to become a corporate VP, you need to look, speak and write like a corporate VP.
I know that this has no relationship to how well you can crank out code but the higher up you move the more you write reports and less you write code.
Since this is an informal chat area, I don't mind any sort of spelling but on a business document I do care.

by mgordon

I am experiencing a similar problem; not that the critical files were encrypted -- they don't exist! A whole network was built in a 24 story building, zippo nada documentation.

Now you might think that once bitten, management would become smart, but this seems not to be the case. What is very likely to happen is that the NEW administrator will be perceived as "inept." Computer networks are all FM anyway; it is his _job_ to make it work so if the new admin doesn't make it work, he or she _will_ be blamed by at least some of the staff.

People who keep meticulous documentation (as I do) are sometimes considered challenged or old fogeys: "the OTHER guy could do all this in his HEAD! Why do you need all this documentation?"

Old school, I suppose. I grew up in an era when documentation was MORE important than the computer code itself. "Empire builders" were despicable; showing very poor character as they tried to make themselves indispensable.

So what does the new admin do? Insufficient information exists. If the critical documents were encrypted with some sort of Public Key encryption, such as PGP, basically you can forget decoding them. You might attack the passphrase on the private key if you can find the private key; you can use a Scanning Tunneling Microscope to try to recover uncoded fragments along the edges of the disk tracks. Got a million dollars? Probably not.

So you start over but mind the politics!

I was labeled inept a few years ago because I could not break the WEP key of a tenant's access point. The problem lay in that the manager did not believe it was a tenant's access point, but the corporate access point. So, what "matters" for your continued employment is what management "believes".

That can be helped with meticulous documentation; and we come full circle. Management needs documentation to believe that you know what you are doing.

by jhogue1

brotherj brought up a point that the rest of us missed. The new folks need to make sure that the person who was fired does not have backdoors into the system. If he was a real crook, he may have other things going that have not been discovered yet.

by too old for it

If you can't figure out how to keep him from being disgruntled, make sure someone else can keep the lights on before you let him go.

by freemarkets

Well said. Too many people are crying for the management in their responses. It was total mismanagement.

by jhogue1

What is to keep me from saying that "I told the person who terminated me that the passwords were in the red folder in my upper right desk drawer. Since I was terminated, I purposely forgot them to protect the company's security. It is not my fault if you can't find the folder. It was there when you marched me out of my office." Unless you video taped the termination, you can't prove that I did not tell you where to find the passwords.

by dryflies

Each time I go through a password cycle, I record all of the passwords, software keys, license details, and computer inventories on a CD. The CD is sealed in a jewel case and put in the Lead administration office Safe Just in case I win the lottery. (It's much more fun than being hit by an ambulance :-)

by krawnsley

I believe originally I began reading this posting to identify what was happening. I am not sure we have a grip on the issues at hand. It is easy to place blame, and throw comments back and forth. I am sure this is out there to remind ourselves there is an issue and we all should protect ourselves as well as understanding the potential pitfalls.

by jhogue1

Our ex employee might be willing to trade passwords for an agreement not to file charges or a law suit.

This gets him off the hook but puts the company back in business. Questionable ethics but possibly a good business decision.

I want to thank everyone who has participated in this discussion. It will make an worderful discussion for a digital ethics course.

by too old for it

A company that does not limit stratigic thinking to next Friday's earnings forcast.

Where do I send my resume?

by reinhardt

I apologize if I offended you (or anyone else).

I can assure you I understand fully that, if done correctly and with the customers best interests being served, I have no problem with consultants in any field. Perhaps to be more accurate I should have used the term Engineer. My sole point was that after many years in this business, listening to the so called experts has led me to the conclusion that the only difference between them and me is a piece of paper that says they passed a test and the amount of money they are being paid to do what I end up doing myself anyway. (This may be hard to believe but self satisfaction in a job well done, satisifaction and pride in knowing I can handle it are more important than the money.)

I cannot tell you the number of times our company has paid big bucks to have "the professionals who know what they are doing" tackle operational glitches only to end up finding the answer and fixing it myself.

Take system software installation and setup (such as Exchange) for instance. My experience with this has been that these "experts", having done this at least several times, can run the installation program and apply the standard, as learned in class and via hotfix info, tweaks and setup. But come up with a question and they can not answer as to the "why's" for it. Develop a problem and they have to do the same things I do - search out the answer. In some cases I have had to tell THEM that "No, that's not the way it works or was designed to work..". It's almost as if they know just enough to pass the test to get the cert.

Major difference - working for a company as one of these "experts" gives them direct access to the manufacturers engineers who have the answers.

Most of the 50 or so I've worked with are merely paper dragons.

by tony hopkinson

it's gross misconduct that's instant sack and potential prosecution for fraud.
However a bent admin is not the problem, the real problem is he was the only one with the passwords.
What if he'd got dead, or even hospitalised, what did they do when he was on holiday ?.
This situation reeks of unprofessionalism on all sides.

Ignorance is not an excuse it's a reason.

However they get out of this, if it was me taking responsibility for sorting this situation, I'd make a definite point of doing it right. Someone above this admin, either had his head in the sand or someone's ass.

by tony hopkinson

They need to know where to access the access, so they can pass it on in the event of an interuption in service. They'd have had the same problem if this guy was underneath a house in Kashmir, or visting his relatives in New Orleans not so long back.

by tony hopkinson

If he was defrauding the company I'd prosecute his ass. Part of his show of guilt for it would have been the professional way he helped pass over his reponsibilities.

When I said ask I meant.
Stage 1
As a fellow professional ...
Stage 2
We are initiating legal proceedings ...
Final Stage
Give me the passwords or you get a visit from my friend Critical Bill.

by mike

First off .... Worrying about the who, what, why and how this happened is not my concern. This company needs help and worrying about anything except the current problem is simply not productive.

Additionally in order to provide a solution to their problem I would need as much information as is possible about the network. I would need to know what types of networks I would be working with, (their size, OS's used, number of users, etc. etc.). I would need to establish a clear set of priorities for restoration of the most crucial systems. I would need to know exactly what information is and is not available for restoring. I (depending on the systems OS) feel that most of the systems can be restored by hacking them and clearing the password or by setting the drive that contains the data as a slave in another system allowing usage of numerous tools available to recover the data. This is a breif (really breif) set of basics that I would start with.

As far as the second question, yes I have established backup plans for exactly this type of scenario. Our systems are mapped down to the serial number, amount of memory, cpu type, passwords, etc., etc.. I montor and get any new or changed passwords on a regular basis. These passwords are tested and verified for access limitaitons and then documented (mostly using the free TechRepublic forms I have downloaded and modified).

I do want to note that no matter what precautions one uses, there is always a way for an "insider" to damage your system. The best defense is to ensure that you have a current reliable backup source.

by tony hopkinson

Even if the old admin coughs up the passwords or they get someone to hack in. There are still a bucket load of things that need to be put in place, including of course setting up such a system as you describe.

None of that will happen though unless someone at the top of the food chain with a cheque book admits their part in this snafu and resolves to have his new Admin make sure it can't happen again.

Bet a years time they've got the system going, the new guy's in charge and nobody above him has a clue what he's in charge of ?

It cost's money to do things properly, and you might not need to spend it.

by maxwell edison

.
The first thing I'd do is to call the city/county/state District Attorney, and ask if charges could be filed against this former employee for theft, sabotage of my computer system, interference with my business, and anything else that might place the fear of God (and me) into him. In the very least, this guy could be forced to return to the scene of his crime and set things straight.

If not, I'd throw the book at him, tie him up in courts, both criminal and civil, for years to come, and make him regret his actions. But my guess is that after he cleaned the drawers he soiled because of the phone call from the District Attorney, he'd be more than happy to come back to make things right.

by tony hopkinson

Not sure why we went off topic apart from someone thought better handwriting and spelling would have prevented the situation in the first place.
Seeing as we were discussing this as a technical issue, some of us felt it necessary to point out that this might not necessarily be the case.

Wouldn't want the types in charge of us to think this was a solution, after all that would be unprofessional.

The pitfalls are enormous, this is like finding out your spymaster works for the enemy, you can rely on nothing they've been involved in.

Hardly mentioned at all is the fact that if they don't have the passwords, he still does !. That would worry me personally.

by jspencer

Do a side by side install of a domain controller on DC for the domain, this will get access to the files. Copy them to a windows 95 machine, that should remove any encryption. Get the hives from the first DC and use any of a myriad of Linux hacks to get the original password of the IT admin.

by oldtimer1

Instead of getting caught up in the whole who is wrong fight(I`m guilty)you`ve gone right to the core of the problem...find a way to fix it...Congrats

by eric-m

Definitely a good idea, that would get you access to all the files that are not encrypted. But the entire purpose of encryption is to make the latent file jumbled and garbage until it is decrypted.

If you just copy the file without decrypting it, it will be unusable.

Assuming the files were encrypted using Windows EFS, then the best thing to do would be to wipe the local admin password on the DC, go into DS restore mode, create a task to launch DSA.MSC after 1 minute of idle time and run it as local system. Then reboot the system and wait for DSA to launch. That should work under 2003.

If it is Windows 2000 then set the default screen saver to be cmd.exe with a 60 second timeout. Then reboot and wait for your command window to pop up, running with local system privs. Type DSA.MSC and then you can change the domain admin password.

Then get in there and find out if there was a recovery agent.

If the files were encrypted by the only domain admin, then you are screwed... If you change the password for a user from the server side I am pretty sure that breaks the link between the user's account and the encrypted file, meaning the file can not be recovered by anyone but a recovery agent.

But if the files were encrypted by the guy's second account, and not the single domain admin account (Administrator for example), then log in as the domain admin, dump the SAM and send the hash away to a company with a good rainbow table.

Good luck!

by bob.mcgough

I think it's unfair to make reference to the company and lack of intelligence regarding this type of situation. Those of us who possess and yield this kind of power position, know that regardless of who you give a password to, when you give it, it is only valid so long as I don't change it. Even if others had this password, this SA once discovering he was being investigated for something he knew he was guilty of or anticipated being fired because of being placed under investigation, could change the password at that moment leaving the company powerless to avoid this from happening. My assistant could very easily pull this on me and I would have no idea he executed this until a situation arised to reveal it. I'm sure everyone agrees that in this field, the high up the chain you are, the more you have to trust your close staff, or you place yourself in position that no one has access to the passwords or rights to change a password except for you. In the government, we are required to complete a password security form which is secured in an safe off site from the IT location. This is an Army regulation and failure to do this and keep it up to date is a punishable offense against DOD and it's security access.

by oldtimer1

This is the first post I`ve read that gives a good arguement against my stand in defense of the guy fired.(Please forgive if I missed this in another post.This thread is so long I know I missed a few)
Unfortunately I`ve been on both sides(I use to be a union rep)
More often than not (90% of the time)Managemnt is at fault. I`ve been involved in enough studies and as soon as the company saw it was management they would drop the study.
But there are enough dishonest employees to cloud the picture.
Since I don`t have all the facts I`ll stop taking sides in this.

by tony hopkinson

There may have been procedures in place, they may even have been audited, as an admin he could have easily curcumvented the procedure. Though with auditing, this action would be documented. However the fact that he got the push and they are now in a mess suggests, that those at least who implemented the decision to throw him out of the door with the passwords were not exactly cognisant of the relevant issues.

Hmmm wonder if he's got remote access ?
or a modem inside the firewall for 'emergencies' ?

by oldtimer1

For one thing as worded it`s not telling all so we are walking a fine line. Second the handling by the company tells more about how poorly the company is run than the guy they fired. Third I have a hard time believing if they had such a crack group that could decide that he was Deliberately faking problems on their net but didn`t have the common sense to secure their own network?
Something is missing in this story, so until I know all the facts, yes I will give the guy the benifit of the doubt. And no after they fired him he doesn`t have to give them anything, including the passwords. That is their mistake.
I`ll give you an example. A co-worker was fired at his house while on company duty. But they did it before they got his truck back to the garage. So when asked where was it he said I`m fired go find it yourself. They did 3 weeks later-stripped.

by jamesrl

While I understand the temptation, the person who stripped the company truck after being fired not only lacks ethics and personal integrity, but also doesn't understand the potential impact of these kinds of actions.

Its a small world out there. People talk. Even in big cities stories go around about these kinds of incidents. You never know how something you do at one job will affect your ability to land the next one.

I was at a job at a massive organization and felt like I wasn't progressing, so I took a job as a Y2K project manager at another company. While I enjoyed the challenge, I did discover the grass wasn't always greener. So I looked up my old boss, who had moved on after I left to another company. Good thing I didnt bad mouth the company, and stayed friendly and open.

The reverse has also happened. When I got a new job, I ended up discovering that a manager was not performing well. That information became clear to his boss, and although I had no role in the actual decision, I think I did have something to do with his firing, though with no malice on my part.

Cut to a few years later, I've been laid off, and am interviewing for a great job at a place very close to my house - what a fit. But the interviewer asks about how I know the manager whose faults I had uncovered at that previous position. Needless to say, despite the excellence of the fit, I didn't get the job, nor even the courtesy of a phone call or letter.

The guy who strips the truck or encrypts the passwords and screws his former employer creates the kind of image that can haunt someone the rest of their career, and since people have long memories of those kinds of things, they are doing themselves a great deal of potential harm.

Even when I've quit in disgust at a job, I've tried to keep it professional, friendly and open - you never know when you will encounter those people again.

James

by masperring2003

Hi guys n gals
The whole issue that has come out of the last few! replies is as I see it
1. The originator of the thread does not have time to do a 'pretty' job of the discussion starter
2. If he does then he is defrauding his company, who are probably paying for the 'net time he is using to write his gripes.
3. Leave the English / grammer too others.
I'm a teacher in UK and find it hard to understand why somebody gripes (moans) about coloquial writting styles. We are all proffesionals?

by freemarkets

A better one would be: You invited someone into your house, didn't check them out, left the house unsupervised and then came back some time later and found it was trashed and that your property, which was out in the open and not locked up, was gone. You deserve the blame there--all of it.

by freemarkets

That kind of stupidity is your own fault. You need to take ownership of your mismanagement. And then to fire the person without knowing what he has done? Clearly they found out about the encrytion problem AFTER they fired him. Quite incompentent management.

by mikeh6

We ran an IT support agency, as outsourced Net Admin/Management personnel, and have run into similar situations many (too many times).

Whether the guy deserved firing or not is irrelevant.

ANY responsible IT admin/manager must give passwords, security codes etc. to at least one other peer or executive upline to ensure continuity in the event of tragedy, death, or fraud.

The probability is this guy would give false passwords anyway, but the principal is the same. A smart superior would 'test' the passwords for key operating necessities.

In Canada, where we operate, if this guy did this he'd be criminally liable to the employer for malfeasance, and civilly liable for whatever damages the company suffered as a result of his actions.

We once had a 'former' employee try to extort additional payment in exchange for his passwords to server admin rights. The criminal charge in Canada is extortion and carries up to 7 years prison time.

Mike Hedley

by jaqui

my habit, even when I worked as a cook was to train all my co-workers to be able to handle every position in the kitchen. since I was usually shift boss, I made sure everyone I was working with could do my own job. maybe not as well as I could, but they had the skills needed.

about 3 weeks after I got everyone up to speed, I had management tell me I was indispensable. I told them I wasn't. ( and took a week off without notice ) they got the point real quick on the value of my habit. every person who regularly worked with me was able to handle the shift.

by aapjanaya

Sometimes there are mischievous IT managers, it is true, but it isn't a rule.
An IT manager was fired after a disagreement with a brand new sales manager. The newcomer had no the slightest idea about company's spartan practices and tight budget on IT, his service demands were just unrealistic.
Five years of knowledge on the ERP suite in use thrown to wastage, network and IT users administration demolished, just in a single evening.
A substitute manager was hired but chaos still is the main performer on stage.
Recently the sales manager had a dispute with another 'main business streamer' -the manufacturing manager-, this time top people fired the sales guy.
IT admins are not disposable. If one has to be replaced, it must be done carefully and planned in advance, if possible.
Also IT roles must be well established, so that nobody becomes the sole resource on anything.
IT means no longer just the gadgets at office desktops.
An advice for a replacement IT Admin may be: "explain clearly the real problem to top managers".

by jaqui

SANS uses these. they have several at every convention to hack a network, where said network is from a participant in the security convention.
this is done to show the participants current tools being used by hackers.

so get some of these guys to hack the passwords out.
they are used to getting paid by a company to hack the network, risk of criminal activity is far less than you suggest.

by jaqui

language of IT since 90% of all programming languages, configuration files etc, are in english, or use english syntax.
( c, c++, basic, cobol, visual basic, perl, python ... all use english as base for the language )

not excusing any attack on someone, who may not be a native english speaker, just addressing the point of english as language for it.

by oz_media

But English grammar is not part of programming.
Probably why they call it a 'programming language' and not 'writing an e-book'.

by jaqui

the error:
[pre]
MyList.Add(Pointer((I+1));
should be:
MyList.Add(Pointer((I+1)));
[/pre]

;)

by tony hopkinson

Wonder if over use parentheses would be considered a style issue sort of like iambic pentameter for language statements.

LOL

by too old for it

You know, a sap upside the head and waking up with cement overshoes has a way of sharpening the memory too.

(Of course, that's my answer to virus, spyware and port scanner writers, so maybe I'm just a little un-original in my thinking.)

by jamesrl

And I don't see in the Original Post, that there was no due diligence done in the hiring process. I have fired employees for similar offenses who passed a criminal record check and had good references. They weren't encrypting data, but they were using the email and telephone system of that company to do business on the side, clearly in violation of policy (signed off on by the culprit).

I do agree that you need to make the rules clear unambiguous and get signatures. Management needs to do due diligence in hiring/background checks for trusted individuals, and have controls in place to ensure that they are not reliant on one individual. I'm not letting management off the hook. But this management bashing seems a little too much like blaming the victim while at the same time ignoring the fact that the admin was involved in what sounds like theft.

James

by crawk

... if he WERE.
(subjunctive tense - used to indicate something that might be but isn't)

by ssampier

We have the same problem in my company. The IT staff is fairly role specific (system admin, network adminstrator, etc), so anytime someone is gone on vacation or sick, we are stuck; we have no one else to turn to. I would even be willing to shoulder some IT burden with only a slight increase in pay (2% should do it).

by jaqui

before assuming that any personal aquisition through company resources was illegal, I would check to see if the person did in fact pay the company the money used for the aquisition.

I've ordered products for personal use with several companies, and paid the company for them before taking possesion of them. I get better quality products at a better price than by going and getting directly myself.

by code4life

The original post explained he was fired for illegally downloading software using company network. What part of *ILLEGAL* don't you understand?

by mgordon

I see that even Texas makes a distinction between legal and illegal lockout. See paragraph 8, near the bottom of tenant.net/Other_Areas/Texas/txlihs/tenant2.html or in other words, lockout is permitted if certain procedures are followed. However, it also includes a rather bizarre requirement that even after being locked out, a former tenant can demand a key and get it within two hours or the landlord faces penalties.

Now then, whether a contractor more closely resembles a landlord or a mechanic is something we may wish to explore. The landlord receives payment from the tenant, but the tenant has special protections because it is his domicile. In cases where this special case does not exist, I believe a mechanic's lein is a better analogy.

In the state of Washington, a mechanic's lien requires only the provision of, and acceptance of, a written estimate for the cost of services. This creates temporary "ownership" by the mechanic; the titled owner of an automobile can be charged with theft for removing his car from the mechanic without payment. In this case cited on this page, the mechanic failed to provide a written estimate and thereby lost his rights under the mechanic's lien. www.mrsc.org/mc/courts/supreme/118wn2d/118wn2d0585.htm

The application of these concepts to information services is fairly straightforward. the contractor is the mechanic and temporarily owns not only the contractor's own work, but such of the client's hardware and software as is being worked on (including passwords).

Full disclosure: I'm not a lawyer, but maybe I'd be pretty good at it.

by jaqui

it is bad style, simply because of missing closing brace errors.

but, some expressions require really heavy brace usage, the worst I saw was 15 sets of braces to process one task.
( if then else nested loops )

I rewrote it into three different functions for readability, and to make the nesting less.

by tony hopkinson

that given they had enough evidence to sack him for fraud, they would have enough evidence to bring charges. As for the passwords issue until he refuses to hand them over, he hasn't done anything wrong!
To be quite honest I can't imagine anyone intelligent enough to royally screw his employers like this being unintelligent enough not to realise he'd be spending a fair bit of time in cell 3 with Bubba if it got near a judge.

New procedures definitely as soon as they get enough system to have procedures for of course.

by mgordon

I regret some of the responses to your message from persons who otherwise possess excellent judgement.

I suspect some people miss the point of your message -- you are speaking of arrogance, hubris and/or pride. Or in other words, you see in sloppy writing and dress a character deficiency that may well also manifest itself in the invisible world of programming and administration, as well as suggesting management and reliability problems with the employee.

If you are hiring an expert, the idea is that he or she brings something to the table that you cannot already do for yourself. If that is so, how can you judge the "guru" on a topic for which you may not be expert? You cannot. We use a proxy to make the judgement; a person that has educated himself or herself and is well dressed and articulate makes a big positive impression at the hiring table. Soon enough you'll know if he or she can also program a Cisco router.

It is my experience that about half the people in Information Technology can neither write nor spell well enough to be displayed to the public or even the CEO and board. People that might know words but fumble the typing should avoid tasks that require precision on the command line -- database administration and Cisco router programming.

As to people that cannot spell; let us consider two possible reasons: They cannot learn or they choose not to. If the former, why shall we suppose such a person can learn the complicated languages of technology? If the latter, it bodes poorly for initiative and character; when is such a person going to start doing things correctly?

Sometimes it is funny -- a co-worker wrote our suite number as "sweet 200" and it is still there on a domain registration for the whole world to see.

With the decline in employment opportunities and the resulting large number of unemployed IT workers, I have and continue to counsel the 'whole person' approach -- be mindful of your impression upon the CEO, investors and other influential persons. Dress well, speak well, write well; these are the things by which you will be judged by the people with money. What I do with Cisco routers is absolutely invisible to everyone except our consultants. My back-end computer programming is invisible. The entire project is judged only by that which is visible, namely the web page interface.

by pickleman

Uhh, no.
Actually, the original post says no such thing.
At no point was there any mention of anybody downloading software illegally.

by davidvangelder

He works for Booz! Wayne you MUST work for Booz Allen, that is textbook BAH...and you are right of course...it's also a great way to build team unity and share successes.

by markfroe

In your analogy all you have done is to change the offense from Breaking and Entering to petty/grand theft depending on the value. While the management may have been negligent the admins actions are still worth a procecutors attention.

by the admiral

The first step is to complete assess all of the damage, and ensure that a dollar figure is put to the actual down time.

Second, I don't know if I would blame the management or the lack of corporate oversight for the inability to not put power completely in the hands of the one person that you fired.

Third, forget bringing the person back. You will not get him to unlock the site at all. Only more damage will be done if, in fact, he is carrying a grudge.

Fourth, if your tape backup strategy is to put it to unpassworded tapes, perhaps the new administrator can create a new server with storage enough to restore that info.

Last, time to launch a criminal prosecution.

by mdisbury

You can nicely ask him for the passwords, failing that suggest that the matter will be put into the hands of the legal team, followed up by discussing the matter with every agency in town to make it hard for him to get another job.

by pickleman

So...what you're alluding to then, is that you should present yourself as being nothing special...just an average slob, with nothing superior to offer when compared to the previous 20 Joe's that they just interviewed.

Yeah...way to go.
Super strategy there..

by jmgarvin

I think this admin is an unethical slug who needs to be taught a lesson.

While I'm sure the passwords can be broken, I'm equally sure the company could sue him into the ground, blacklist his name in IT, and make sure that his "ethics" are known.

by pickleman

> I think this admin is an unethical slug who
> needs to be taught a lesson.

Without knowing all the facts in the case, I find it amusing that you're so ready to convict the guy without even hearing his side of the story.

> While I'm sure the passwords can be broken

LOL

> I'm equally sure the company could sue him into the ground

LOL

> blacklist his name in IT, and make sure that his "ethics" are known.

LOL
This is the I.T. industry, not the movie industry.
There's no blacklisting, and nothing will be made known. The absolute worst that they can do to him is not give him a reference. I'm sure he's not the least bit concerned about that, all things considered.

by larry

You are dead on with your comments. I was agreeing with you. I am one of those IT pros that actually has to fix things since I do not have any pieces of paper. I had a guy that worked for me for a short time that had his MCSE and his A+ certifications, yet he could not even install a modem in a computer.

I have friends who have little bags with a dozen certification badges and patches stuck on them that call me when they can't figure out how to get OWA working on their server or open the ports on their routers and firewalls.

My point was not so much about the technical side, although the term IT professional is a loose one indeed, but about how important relationships are in business.

Having excelent technical skills should be the minimal expectation for anyone who calls themselves an IT professional, but having excellent people skills is just as important since laymen cannot tell if your skills are good or not.

Getting the job and doing the job go hand in hand when you work off of referrals and references.

Clients will always recommend someone they trust and someone they like. Even if someone is the ultimate guru, if they are unlikable or contemptuous when dealing with clients, referrals will be few and far between.

So, we are in agreement. Just looking at the issue from a couple of different angles is all.

by oz_media

And that's why I would NEVER email a resume for a job 'offer' or 'posting'.

I contact 'the powers that be' directly and sell myself instead, it's a great way to earn more than other employees, it's a great way to get the ball in YOUR court, because they want your skills and abilities at that point, it's up to you to decide how much your worth and what services you will provide for their money, not the other way around.

by oz_media

As Ive said elsewhere, it would probably be as easy as a quick phone call and he will offer the passwords. If not, a friendly call from the company's attorney would get him to provide it without need for a long drawn out court case. I haven't met a lawyer yet that would even entertain the idea of representing someone in his position.

by pickleman

> I haven't met a lawyer yet that would even
> entertain the idea of representing someone in
> his position.

Then I'm gonna go out on a limb here and make this crazy assumption that you haven't met many lawyers. What a shock that would be.

Here's a little dose of reality for you: a lawyer will represent a rapist, a murderer, and even a child molester. What is it about a Network Administrator that you feel would be so repugnant that a lawyer wouldn't "entertain the idea of representing" him? Is that more of the "OZ Media" wisdom we've come to know and love on this forum?

LOL

by oz_media

I think it was quite clear what I meant and anyone with any staff management experience would understand exactly what I wason about.

As for 20 Joes, only a mediocre conformist would be in an interview process with 20 other people. That's for the people/schmucks who wait for job postings to seek work, super strategy there.

How about a little assertion, call up and create your own job interview whether they are advertising a position or not? Or do you fit in with those who feel they can only fill positions and not create them? As you say, super strategy (or lack thereof) there.

by system sitter

If the case is true. The issue here is no longer about best practice... it's about personality, attitude.. trust.
Which means the network itself no longer can be trusted.
It's most unfortunate (financially AND technically) but I don't think there's any choice at all. Rebuilding is the only way.
Pay attention though... rebuilding doesn't mean overnight.. it is manageable. Some can not wait... but many can be sort out as the company go along...

by pickleman

> For instance I can reset your server passwords,
> crack your cisco router passwords, and almost
> any kind of document password.

Wow...you're special.
You have the ability to download freeware programs that crack passwords, and you take the credit as though you were some El33t CraCkEr D00d.
Please, give me a break.

> If the files are password protected at the file
> encryption level, I have software that will
> extract the files bypassing the encryption.

This last statement was the sole reason why I decided to reply to your post. I was originally going to ignore it and chalk you up to another know-it-all, but this kind of ignorance is not something I can just overlook.

Okay, let's start with the basics. You can't "bypass" encryption. If a file is encrypted, it means its contents have been mathematically scrambled so that every single byte from the first to the last is now different than what it used to be. In order to access the file, you have to decrypt it. There's no "bypass" involved. And there isn't anything that you or anyone else can do to "extract" the file without decrypting it.

The fact that guys like you are running around in the I.T. field just makes me smile, because everytime I come across one of you, I know that I have job security for the next 375 years.

by larry

Actually, I don't use freeware for my password recovery work. Although freeware is available, I choose to use commercial password recovery tools.

And yes, I can get past EFS using forensic software tools. I use the same software as most law enforcement agencies world wide. And, not it is not sleuthkit or other freeware stuff.

EnCase Decryption Suite (EDS)
Support for Microsoft Encrypting File System (EFS) encrypted files and folders, including domain authenticated accounts.
Support for Outlook PST passwords (except Outlook 2003).
Enables the automatic decryption and analysis of Windows registry protected storage area for Internet Explorer.

You assume that I don't know what I am talking about, when you know nothing about what I do.

by tony85

.. for what it is worth
I run the IT (as a consultant) for a number of small businesses. As part of this, I keep a Word document that contains all the settings and passwords for their systems. I keep this updated and give them a copy of it.

This solves most of the problems mentioned in this discussion - it covers
1) me falling under a bus
2) me being able to brief someone for cover so that I can go on vacation
3) the company know they are not being held to ransom

Incidentally, I did have a case of a client who did not pay, and was so inept that I had full access remotely to his system. However tempting it was, I had to resist abusing this access. In fact, even during the time he had not paid me, I periodically sent him an email reminding him that he needed to get certain patches on. I have no idea what he did about IT support in the end, but I did eventually get paid.

by tonythetiger

I don't know. I was just offerring an opinion.

I was most concerned with the "so we decided that we weren't going to be paid for the invoice, so why would we give up the password?"

and then "It's their fault for not demanding to know the password while we were all on good terms, I figure."

The two statements seem incongruous to me. If he was entitled to the password "while you were on good terms" then it should have been provided to him then. Blaming him for something you failed to do seems "unbusiness-like".

It also seems illogical to do something to damage someone's ability to pay because they won't.

Red State/Blue state? You give 2% of the population (the difference between 51 and 49) too much credit. Laws are enacted because situations arise requiring intervention by the government, nothing more.

by jmgarvin

Ok, why "LOL?" I think we've heard a good portion of the story. It sounds like he was using the business as a place to get parts and to fund himself, how is that ethical?

Sure the IT industry is like the movie industry. If you don't get a good reference, you are pretty well sunk. Plus, it will be a big question mark on his resume if he doesn't allow them to contact them employer.

So please explain why you think my comments aren't valid. "LOL" doesn't mean much to me other than you have little to say on the subject.