Discussion Locked

IT Admin "Was Fired" But... Was it a GOOD idea?

0 helpful
266 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

266 replies

by server queen

Walking off with either passwords or company data still in your possession is no different from retaining your key to the front door, or keeping your company-issued laptop or credit card. It is theft, as electronic information is still "property." That case has been fought in court many times; the former employee would lose. You do not have the right to retain passwords to the systems of a position from which you have been terminated. Contact the former employee and require the passwords. If the employee does not provide them, then legal recourse should be taken - JUST AS YOU WOULD DO IF THEY STOLE ANYTHING ELSE.

Whether or not the employee was truly malfeasant is not an issue. The issue is leaving a company while still in possession of company property. If it is not promptly returned, it is theft.

by oz_media

Yup that was one weak little limb you fell from alright.

As some know here, my brother is a very high profile corporate attorney that represents some of North America's largest corporations.

Have I met many lawyers? Literally HUNDREDS.

I'm also a manager/promoter in the music industry and have represented bands in Canada, the US and Europe, have spent countless hours in courtrooms over IP, copyright and other issues.

I have sat through more endless corporate cases than you have sat in classes in school. No, most lawyers would NOT represent someone with such a dead end and useless case. It takes time and money and even if this admin was willing to cough up a few grand to even launch a suit, no sane lawyer would tarnish a reputation with such a lose lose scenario. This isn't criminal law, sponsored by legal aid, this isn't an accident claim, it is a LOSING situation with no possble way that the admin would come out on top. Corporate lawyers rely heavily on a win:lose ratio, they don't want to take on dead cases as they would never gain enough of a reputation to get a worthwhile company to use them.

Now on top of all of this, IF...by some ridiculous stroke of luck, he were to find some tin-pot lawyer trying to make a name for himself, and IF he were able to pay the legal fees, his chances of standing up against the company's own corporate attorney are absolute ZERO, NONE, NIL, NADA, SQUAT, SWEET F-ALL.

I have sued more than my fair share of employers who feel they can pull one over on you as you leave, they are usually quite shocked to find out that their lawyer won't represent them as their lawyer is often MY lawyer and I can afford to represent myself properly (not that I have mounds of money but I have my obvious connections), moreso I understand when I have a case that can be won, unlike the sad situation here.

So it seems like the "picklman wisdom", or lack thereof got the better of you this time as you spoke irrationally and without knowledge of which you speak. In doing so you also made rash unqualified assumptions of my character, which you don't even have the most minimal grasp of.

by pickleman

> Actually, I don't use freeware for my password
> recovery work. Although freeware is available,
> I choose to use commercial password recovery tools.

So even though there are plenty of freeware products that work fine, you choose to pay for something even though you don't have to. Wow, that's just brilliant.

> And yes, I can get past EFS using forensic
> software tools

Yeah, well, guess what. At no time was in mentioned that this particular administrator limited himself to EFS. I think it's safe to assume that if the guy was pissed off enough to go to these lengths to screw his previous employer, then he would no doubt use real encryption, and not the joke that EFS happens to be. If he had in fact relied just on EFS, you can rest assured that we wouldn't be here discussing it because the problem would've been solved long before it became an issue.

> You assume that I don't know what I am talking
> about, when you know nothing about what I do.

Sure I do. I could tell everything I needed to know based on your wording alone. You're one of those guys that gets through his days by "winging it". But once you empty out your bag of freeware tricks and still have no solution to a particular problem, you're left scratching your head with no clue as to what to do next. I see it all the time..

by robertmi

Instead of bagging a professional Forensic Analyst, why don't you put forward your solution to the problem raised in the original post? Password cracking is not an exact science because new and more sophisticated methodologies are developing all the time. Nevertheless existing commercial software available to trained forensic people can be used to recover passwords very quickly from virtually any system. Encase and FTK are reliable and well established examples of forensic software. What is your experience in computer forensics?

by oz_media

>This guy's's Nuckin Futs!! :D

Just read all the other posts from him/her, perhaps a little attention grabbing? Nobody's that dim, nobody old enough to go potty by themselves anyway.

Kiddie in mom's basement syndrome.

by robertmi

Way to go Larry! Have none of these people heard of Forensic Tool Kit and in particular Password Recovery Toolkit? A Forensic Analyst is the quickest way out of the mess this firm has gotten itself into. I note that most posts are about what to do with/to the perp. The original question was how to get back up and running. The new IT admin person is guiltless in this scenario and should be entitled to expect sound and sane advice from this forum on the most effective way to get the show back on the road. It is easy to badmouth firms for their lack of understanding of IT matters including security, but hey, that's why IT staff have jobs.

by oz_media

>well it seems you haven't seen life in a reputable position. Company owners of all sizes of organization generally know each other quite well. Any city I've worked in, I know all of the worthwhile business owners in a short while and even pass employees off if they are looking burned out with the routine, this way you don't have to 'fire' people you think are good but done in. Yes you will get blacklisted, especially within your own vertical, the most likely place for movement.

Any industry I've worked in, everybody knows everybody, unless they are nobody of course.

>jm, sorry for the title.

by boomslang

If you have a lawyer worth his salt, this guy could be put up on felony charges if he does not divulge the passwords. Tampering with or intentionally destroying your comany's data can and does land you in the clink.

by shailace

CURRICULAM-VITAE

SHAILENDRA SINGH ARYA

MAILING ADDRESS: C-94
GURDWARE WALI GALI
JEEVAN PARK
NEW DELHI-110059
MOBILE NO: 9818439467,9871391826
E-MAIL: shailace@gmail.com,shailace@rediffmail.com,
shailace@hotmail.com

CAREER OBJECTIVE

To make a mark for oneself in the field of Information Technology. I believe on the objective of being growth with the growth of company & what I studied in theory to implement practically.

PROFETIONAL QUALIFICATION

Completed three years ?DIPLOMA IN COMPUTER ENGINEERING? from Maharaja Surajmal Institute of Pharmacy & Technology. Pursuing BCA from IGNOU.

PROJECT UNDERTAKEN

Name: CDACs OPEN Process Solution
Location: CDAC (Computer for Development of Advanced Technology)
A-335, Shivalik Enclave
Near Malviya Nagar,
New Delhi-110017
Client: Power Grid Corporation of India Limited
Tool used: SCO UNIX, C
Duration: Two Month

WORKING EXPEREINCE

I had work with HCL INFOSYSTEMS LTD. as a Customer Support Engineer from April 2002 to February 2004 & after that I got selected in Digital Solution Pvt Ltd.,I had worked for Digital solution for one year & posted in Fortis Healthcare Ltd,Maharani Bagh as a FM Engineer. Now working with Team Computer Pvt Ltd as a System Administrator from 10th Jan 2005 to till date & posted in CDAC.

JOB PROFILE

Responsibilities in Fortis:
? Handling the Exchange Server 5.5 on Windows NT Server 4.0
? Maintaining the space on Exchange Server.
? Handling the traffic on the Mail Server, & Create the Space to run Exchange Server smoothly.
? Handling the Win proxy Server2.02
? Creating new user profile for Microsoft Outlook
? Handling the Norton Antivirus Corporate Edition on Exchange Server & make daily updates.
? Support the Desktop on all Windows Operating Systems as well as peripheral also.
? Handling the user queries, keep the backup of user data as well as Server also.
? Handling routers & having the knowledge of little bit voice over IP (VOIP).
? Purchasing of all components related to computers & peripheral.
? Handling little bit of Administration also.

Server Management:
Objective under this section is to ensure that the operating system is administered and tuned well. Administrate the operating system and ensure the availability of the platform for running of applications and aid processing by users.
? Maintaining operating system and ensure the proper functioning on the server 2000/NT.
? Ensure proper connectivity to operating system.
? Backup and support for restoration Data.
? Domain account management.
? Daily checklist will be provided on server health.
? Create new file systems and correct the file system inconsistencies.
? Install Operating System upgrades and patches.
? Reload Operating System on servers as and when needed.
? Monitor disk space usage.

E-Mail Administration:

? Mail boxes maintenance i.e. user mail ID creation / transfer / deletion on the Exchange server version 5.5.
? Workgroup management through the ID creation and deletion.
? Address Book maintenance.
? Procedure for mail account management ? creation / deletion / transfer of users.
? Monitor the mail system at regular intervals for pending mail to ensure prompt mail delivery and take proper action whenever required.
? Monitor the disk space occupies by users, submit a list of disk space defaulter to the IT head on regular basis.

Responsibilities in CDAC:

? Desktop Support includes installation, Support, Maintenance, troubleshooting of various hardware, operating systems and applications.
? Defining and resolving the problem alerts.
? Call logging.
? Tracing, diagnosis and resolving faults.
? Identifying recurring problems, reporting trends to management, and recommending solutions or correction procedures to initiate escalation process if required to resolve the problem.
? Maintenance of asset register.
? Maintain and Monitor warranty/ AMC details.
? Create /delete/Modify users & group.
? Desktop to LAN connectivity.
? Printer management.
? Shifting of all PC?s, Server?s and Peripheral from one site to another i.e. site shifting.

Server Administration:

? Network Maintenance issues such as attach, login, printing.
? Creation/ Maintenance of users and allocation of access rights/ID?s
? Support for virus prevention and cleaning method.
? Managing Disk space availability.
? Operating system up gradation and maintenance.

KILL SET

Operating System: MS-DOS, SCO UNIX, WIN 95/98/2000/XP/NT, MS Exchange 5.5
Server: WIN NT/2K Server
Language: C, DATA STRUCTURE, PASCAL.
Others: MS OFFICE 97/2000/XP

AREA OF INTEREST

Networking
Management

ADDITIONAL QUALIFICATION

Six months certificate in Hardware & Networking from GEC, New Delhi.

WORKING EXPEREINCE

Total three year of working experience.

ACADEMIC QUALIFICATION

Complete Diploma in Computer Engg. Securing 69%.
Completed 10+2 with Science Group in 1999 from CBSE board New Delhi.
Completed High School with Science stream in 1999 from U.P board Allahabad with First Div.

PERSONAL DETAILS

FATHER?S NAME Om Prakash Ayra
DATE OF BIRTH September 09,1980
SEX Male
NATIONALITY India
HOBBIES Listening music, chatting, journals

(SHAILENDRA SINGH ARYA)

by wayne m.

The company is facing an immediate problem, the data is needed now. Going through a legal proceeding may result in a solution in weeks or months. After solving the immediate problem, the company can consider whether the benefits of legal action would outweigh the costs.

by oz_media

Check your legal options, and then just cal the guy up. I think I would simply call and ask him first, he would probably offer the info without a problem. What's with people being too freaked out to simply ASK for the damn passwords? I know it sounded like he'd string him up by the short and curly's but I think Max would try a personal call then a legal call before taking action.

If that fails, then yes a 'legal' phone call on the company's behalf should do the trick, the company has a lawyer, have him make a quick call, not too expensive if not free and quick.

If THAT fails, you have requested it personally, THREATENED legal action and now have ROCK SOLID foundations for taking further action, again, IF needed. As Max said, the lawyer's call would be enough for most script kiddies to soil themselves over, but I doubt it would even take more than the boss simply requesting the passwords and then having the replacement admin keep his eyes open for intrusions.

by maxwell edison

.
....just take things too literally.

Call the DA, call the corporate attorney, or whomever, but my point was to establish a legal basis for placing the fear of God in the guy, and then contact him to give him an ultimatum. If you read any more into it than that, you read too much.

And I never suggested to go through long and drawn-out legal proceedings while putting the "immediate needs" on hold. I think most people, and most companies, are able to multi-task just fine.

Some people just argue for argument's sake, I guess.

by jeffersnet

From what I've read so far I am not sure that anyone asked for the password. A good admin is going to keep the passwords secure and there is a good chance that this person would just tell the new IT manager the password. Of course there are a$$holes out there who would rather go after someone when they are down because some people have no other way of making themselves look good to others. Bad managers build themselves up by stepping on other people.

by timbstoke

Part of a good IT admin's responsibility is precisely to keep the network passwords out of the hands of users. This includes senior management, as much as they would like to suggest otherwise.

In the fired admin's position, I would want a written request from one of the company directors, detailing exactly who I was to pass on my responsibilities to, before I would release any passwords to anyone. If there wasn't anyone in the company who the director was prepared to hand over responsibility for the companies entire infrastructure to, I would leave an email and snail address with the company, so that the director could get in touch when such a person was available.

by jeffersnet

Only if the admin was ever asked the password or if there was some policy that the password had to be stored in a certain place.

No one has said that the admin was ever asked for his passwords.

by jeffersnet

Ok, read the post way at the top!

It does not say that he broke any law of any kind. What if he downloaded software he paid for but on company time using the company network and the software was only so that he could learn it on his own time so that he could work on it? I buy books all the time to assist me in my job and I will go to Barnes and Noble using the company network on company time to learn more about my job. Would you arrest me because I spend my own money to order things for myself when my employer should really buy it for me?

There are way too many people out there who act before thinking. Maybe this old IT manager wasn't fired for a good reason and will end up getting a bunch of money from this company, that would be good. There are a lot of companies who have internal investigators who know nothing about computers and don't know who to ask about computers and then end up acting on bad information. I once worked for such a company in Nebraska and LB 757 was introduced to get rid of the investigators. This legislative bill will be voted on in 2006 and I'm sure it will pass. The bill and testomony makes interesting reading, it is on the Internet if anyone is interested. Anyway, the bill was written after the investigators went after someone who they thought used a server disruption to make it harder for the investigators to find a picture of a monkey with an administrator's face. The person was arrested for attempting to hide this monkey picture that he did not create using a system he was in charge of and was never told to stay off when he was not informed of the search details.

Don't assume you know things you don't and try not to be such a jerk.

by jeffersnet

OK, depending on the company size and other factors the business manager may not have been asked for the password in your situation when you get fired (not that it will really happen)and so now there are a bunch of people suggesting coming after you. Now, if the company is run by a jerk who doesn't want to look bad in front of the County Attorney then this business manager may have been told to keep his mouth shut when they finally figure out that the old IT manager wasn't such a bad guy after all.
This kind of crap really does happen. Make backup plans for backup plans for backup plans for CYA purposes.

by venator

Maybe I'm wrong here, but...if the fired admin hasn't refused to give the passwords, prosecution may be difficult due to a lack of evidence of intent to damage or deprive the company of it's resources. Once the fired admin refuses to give the passwords, I think you have a case.

by sleepin'dawg

The story goes there was an IT honcho that was working for a Fortune 500 company that was going through downsizing. After living under the threat of being made redundant he wrote up a program that would kick in after x number of clock cycles if his employee number came up for severance payout. After due consideration and a bit of selective system scanning he was able to hide his handiwork by attaching his program to several other employee numbers that would probably be laid off at the same time as himself. If his program ever kicked in it would be hard to determine the culprit because it would be traced to several supposed sources. The program was designed not to activate fully until he and the others were outside the company for over 15 days. His program was designed to take down the whole company wide system in a gradual worm attack. By the time anyone was aware of it the data would be so corrupted that he'd probably be undetectable and untraceable. Did it actually happen??? Who knows??? but I've heard this story so many times over the years that maybe there's something to it. Either that or it's just another urban myth. Would any company be willing to admit they had been victims of something like this. I've heard this story applied to NASA, GM, Citibank and others but would any of these admit something like this happening. I personally think it is urban myth and most companies would/should have backups available to get up and running in a few days if not hours.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jamesrl

But never once met someone who has first hand information.

On the other hand I do know well a company who writes software for a vertical market who can and does reserve the use of such a device in a situation of last resort - when the customer refuses to pay for x months and it looks like going to court is the only way to resolve the issue, some software is installed that will stop the system from being able to be accessed by the customer. Its all in the contract, but many customers don't read it.

James

by wayne m.

I believe the recommended course of action was "The first thing ... is to call the city/county/state District Attorney ...." I question whether this is the most effective way to get the company's information back quickly.

I do not believe that a DA is going to drop whatever he is doing to make a telephone call for a small business. His interest is only going to be piqued if the intent is to press criminal charges and take the case to court. This is simply going to take too long to regain access to the desired files.

Even if the company has a lawyer on retainer, there is no need for the manager to check with legal counsel first. The first reaction should be to talk to the individual in question and ask for his assistance. There is no need to make threats, legal or otherwise at this point. If the person in question is not willing to help when asked, I doubt that a legal threat will provide very much more motivation.

In the end, this seems to be what Oz_Media suggested above, and this approach is a far cry from starting with a DA. From the information provided in the initial post, I would assume that the uncommunicated passwords and encrypted files were not an act of vengence, merely a matter of timing. A simple request may be all that is needed to put things right.

by maxwell edison

.
....my message and the original message.

If you read in the original message that you "would assume that the uncommunicated passwords and encrypted files were not an act of vengeance, merely a matter of timing", then you and I have a different definition of deliberate and software-hardware theft.

Yea, right, it was just an "oversight" - NOT!

by thomaskelly

If I were the new Admin I would first assess whether or not the "essential files" are mission critical. Then, look for any back-ups exist outside of the previous Admin employment and assess the back up strategy.

If there is an incremental back up plan, when the files were encrypted they got backed up. If you could find that time (possibly around the time when the Admin started falling out with the company) you could see if it exists on the previous back up. Look on the server that the files reside on, when where they last modified, accessed ect? Then look for files (including programs) that were created/modified around that time as well to see if perhaps there is a file denoting any pw references or even the program that was used if Third-Party.

As for the unexpected, by definition, if one has a plan then one expects it.

by Member 32650361

The company does need a quick transfusion of brain cells to make sure this does not happen again, but the Admin has more than bent a few laws. At the very least, he needs to pay for all costs associated with regaining control of the programs, plus costs for lost productivity. It would be a lot cheaper for all if Admin just gave over the passwords. NO WAY do you let him onto the system without adult supervision-- and there may not be any available at this company.

Now, how do you handle this in the future when you are contacted about Admin's past employment? Current law makes it difficult to say anything negative, but I would think one would be morally required to report the unethical (and probably illegal) conduct of Admin to any possible future employers.

by maxwell edison

.
The original message indicated that this was "deliberate mismanagement of the company's network systems ...... to obtain software and hardware for both personal use and for personal private transactions".

Deliberate is the key word here; and "to obtain software and hardware" -- MY software and hardware -- is theft.

If this is accurate, the time to play nice-nice with the guy has long passed, at least in my opinion. I'd jump down the guy's throat with a vengeance, and make him wish our paths had never crossed. I might even hire a thug named Vito to pay the guy a visit. And after he was scared sh1tless and gave me everything I wanted, I'd probably still have the guy prosecuted for corporate sabotage and theft.

But for Wayne M to read that I intended to suggest taking legal action instead of addressing the "immediate needs" is silly. Most people can walk and chew gum at the same time; and most companies could rebuild their network as necessary AND pursue legal action against a criminal at the same time.

But no, I definitely would not ask nicely.

by eternal confusion

You say things like "Takes advantage". Exactly how does the consultant/contractor watch out for himself? This is a world where the burden of proof is almost always on the innocent. I would cover my arse the same way. Going to court, been there done that and it took over 6 months of never ending BS before it was settled and guess what, they do not pay you for time lost going to court!

by rbtux

Best way is to contact ex-admin before it gets to late and issues become out of hand, and secure any type of back doors the ex-admin might of put in to protect yourself. Work on policy's as well for company to go by for future issues of same nature.

by toad464

When setting up computer a password that subseads all other passwords and can unlock all and any part of the computer and software this password can also change or remove all passwords bar its own this password is used only by the ceo or full owner of the company and if its dune right you don't even need to be an IT Pro to do it when other people use a system that can be tamped with or when a person whom could be fired or just leave for what ever reasos should not I repeat should not have access to the main control password they all should use secondary and third passwords depending on the needs and the persons job fuction.

Thomas the Toad

by Former member

i dont find the action of the old admin a professional one ,i dont know the way that his was fired ,and make him to do such an action , any way we are ADMINISTRATOS AND HIGH PROFFESIONALS we mustnt do things like that in any way .as for the company seems that is not a good one because the relay on one person and they dont have any idea of recovery ,they have only two solutions or the hire from some secure company people to brake the passwords ,or if they have backup plan to build up the all network from the begginig and to restore all the applications ,if this is not possible ,the will pay a big packet of money to the old admin to give the codes or to some company to brake everything .

by tonythetiger

A healthy start would be putting terms and conditions in plain language at the start, spelling out all of the forseeable "if/then"s at the beginning of the business relationship.

In the particular example I replied to, it appeared that the contractor was negligent in not giving the password to the client at the beginning of their relationship, and only later using non-payment as an excuse. Most people I know would see a problem with that.

Oh, and if you include the lost time in your claim, it is often compensable.

by jeffersnet

Someone has to ask for the password. The problem with so many people is they rush to judgement. A good admin will keep his password secret and if someone fires him and doesn't ask for the password I don't see why that is the admin's fault. As for the reason he was fired you should read the post because you will find that it does not say he broke a law or did anything unethical, this is just another assumption. The post says he used the company resources to buy something, it didn't say it wasn't work related. Maybe he bought something so that he could do a better job supporting the users. Remember, the post does not give the details.
It is too bad that people always assume the worst out of everyone without checking into the facts.

by irishgjf

Reading all of these posts reminded me of something I heard long ago; DOCUMENT, DOCUMENT, DOCUMENT. And, should one person really be the only one who has all of the documentation? Depending on the company, I would say, No. An Owner, President, VP or someone in authority, even though they may not have the knowledge how to use it, could provide the road map to the company's proprietary information to the next admin.
As far as the contractors, I agree with a couple of users who mentioned spelling it out in black and white to begin with. But, I guess that still goes back to what I said at the beginning.

by jeffersnet

As far as you or anyone else here knows the old Admin has a folder on or in his old desk with the password that nobody has asked for. Or do you and about 3/4 of the people here think the admin should of had a huge neon sign made with the administrator password flashing for all to see.

I am so glad that I don't work with you or anyone else who assumes they know things that are never stated.

If you fire someone you first need to ask for the passwords because you must have been too stupid to have a plan in case something happened. Failing to ask for the password does not place the blame on someone else.

We don't know if the firing was really justified but since people are wanting to assume so much here lets just assume that the old admin didn't feel it was justified. Now, with the old admin headed out the door do you think he or she should have stopped and said, "Wait, I want to tell you where I wrote down my administrator password that no one seems to care about." NO WAY, the admin should have just walked out and let them worry about figuring it out when he knows they never cared enough to plan this out.

I change my password from time to time and I do not announce my new password nor will I ever announce my password or put it up on a post it note for all to see. In my current job there are plans in place in case one, two or even three people with that much permission has to be replaced at any time. We never know when a tornado or something may keep a few people away. In my last job I made plans and documentation but I know that a lot of people in administration won't be able to remember where the information is kept because they just don't really pay attention to what the IT people say. Just about everyone makes a plan of some type but sometimes you just need to ask.

by boomslang

[quote]Now there is a new IT Admin running the show, which just became a circus... The old IT Admin, apparently created personal encrypted passwords which have locked in all essential files, and has been unsuccessfully decoded... now the company has become paralyzed by and Admin who no longer is with them.[/quote]

So, is this a case of his personal user account and EFS with a forced password change that now is denying access, is it a case of a lost admin password, or rather that he went in and applied his own encryption to critical company data?

Sounds like he intentionally locked up the data to purposefully deny access. Activity like this has been successfully prosecuted in criminal law courts and any company with a lawyer on retainer is going to head in this direction whether you or I like it or not.

by jeffersnet

I was just saying that from what I read I am not so sure anything was done by the old admin with the intent of locking anyone else out and maybe the old IT admin was just trying to keep the admin password secure. I just don't trust secret investigators who may or may not know anything about IT. The secret investigator comment in the post was what set me off.

by boomslang

Agreed upon that the owner of said company, "Kenny" is an extremely hard but in his own way, fair person to work for.

Anyway, they are a company with some quite high tech computer driven metal machining equipment. One of the employees got disgruntled and decided he would bring the operation to a halt. He took one key computer in the engineering department, put it in his car and drove to his California digs. Kenny got word of it and decided to hunt the guy down. In the resulting fracas, Kenny stuffed the business end of a Colt .45 up the guy's nose and proceeded to tell him all the ways Kenny could make his life difficult in the presence of Kenny's brother and another of the employees who came along for the ride. They got the computer back. Whatever Kenny told the guy must have impressed on him that insanity is not a good thing to come up against because he never pressed charges.

by thumper1

I worked for a firm for seven years as the Network Admin. During that time, the network had a total down time of four hours. They asked me for a network upgrade proposal which I gave them in detail, including wanting to bring in a server consultant to insure a smooth transition. They said ?Thank You? Nothing more was said for four months. I thought they decided not to proceed. Next thing I know, they are announcing a total network upgrade. They went to the consultant I was going to use and hired him. Luckily, I had made arraignments for other employment. Had I not, I would have been let go. My reward for maintaining a reliable network was to be outsourced. No good deed goes unpunished.

by jmgarvin

You cannot "steal" IP from a company in such a way. The precidenct has been set!

Also, the admin must give the incoming admin the new passwords and any other information that may keep the IT infrastructure from functioning properly once the previous admins leaves.

by jacobhusain

Took charge just this week of a branch office whose previous IT Admin was ejected. Myself being the new Admin will take time understanding the network and tracking the IPs. Given a few days all will be fine.

My companys backup plans ?? NIL
they never think an Admin would leave them and believe that this job is like anyother clerical job where it takes just 2 days to get to know the job.

But Dear Admins remember the Johnny Walker tagline
"KEEP WALKING ! "

by brent

If he can get away with what he's already done for as long as he did, the last thing you want to do is let him back in. Bruteforce or a Data Recovery Firm would be my choice as well. With documentation for proper litigation if needed.

However, from the admins point, it was his responsibility to maintain security. Giving up passwords to the wrong people would most definitelybe a violation of that responsibility, no whether or not he's been fired. If I were him, I would have left contact info, or requested my replacements public contact info, to pass on the necessary passwords and such. This assumes that I didn't feel jaded in some way by the company that let me go. If I did, I might be a little less willing and then simply let them come to me.

by jeffersnet

If you read the actual post you will see that it does not ever say he broke a law. It does not say that he refused to give the password or that he locked anyone out of anything. As far as anyone here knows he was never asked.

It is a big stretch to say he broke a law, some of you just don't read very well or always jump to conclusions. If you have the ability to solve problems with computers then you should be able to apply that to other areas. If you don't have anything on your monitor do you assume the monitor died? I would check the power and look for other causes while some people here was just get mad and throw away a perfectly good monitor.

THINK!!!!! USE YOUR GREY MATTER!!!!!!!!!!

by jmgarvin

"They found in there investigation, that this IT Admin, deliberately mismanaged the net work to obtain software and hardware for both personal use and for personal private transactions."

Unethical behavior. This is the first glimpse we get as to how the admin acted and his ethics.

"... The old IT Admin, apparently created personal encrypted passwords which have locked in all essential files, and has been unsuccessfully decoded... now the company has become paralyzed by and Admin who no longer is with them."

I think a lot can be infered here. No company were just "not ask" the admin for the passwords and stay dead in the water. Further, the Admin locked out essential files that the company need to operate and did not provided the passwords because they have "been unsucessfully decoded."

I think I agree with Stress that this is a tort, but IP theft can fall into the criminal realm (although I'm not a lawyer, I just know that IP theft is a fuzzy area as far as criminal vs civil suits)

As far as using grey matter, the OP stated that the admin was unethical and implied that he/she would not give up the passwords....

by grobi43

The new IT admin should request outside assistance from IT forensics, internal and external IT adutors and software personnel to trace just how damage the Old IT admin has done; if charges can be pressed on the Old IT admin, then charge him with the appropriate computer crimes, otherwise the company's sole focus should be to support the new IT admin's efforts to get the shop back right!

by jeffersnet

Since this is the WWW we can't all have the same standards as American's would have. I usually assume that people are not guilty until there is some sort of evidence and it does not ever say in the post that there is evidence. You are trying to read between the lines and I just don't see what you do between those lines.

How about looking at this line, "operates an internal investigation department... one which no employee had been aware of." The internal investigation department may not have any technical knowledge and may assume that since they can't get into the administrator account then it must be encrypted. This secret group may not even have any experience, we don't know because there just isn't any information contained here to lead us to believe that they know what they are doing. If you were to read history books you would find many examples of people who did nothing wrong being investigated by secret units. I've seen people who have been taken to the cleaner because of some moron who has been put in charge of security and they get on a power trip.

I do not get the impression that a fair investigation was conducted at all. I also do not get the impression that most of the people here would be willing to listen to the admin's side of the story if we were able to figure out who he or she is.

We do not know what the person was using the companies system to purchase. It appears as though the admin used his or her own money to purchase something using the companies time and contacts but was it to have a copy of something to gain more knowledge for work? I use my companies time to purchase books from Barnes and Noble so that I can fix problems quicker at work.

While my experiences are not exactly the same as what is posted here I have had a run in with secret investigators in an agency. The investigators tried to go after an employee who was suspended because he had his position listed in his signature of his personal email. The employee wrote a supervisor asking when he would have his hearing and the signature at the end of the email contained his title and below that it listed his work email address. The investigators assumed that he was illegally using the agencies email system because of the signature even though the email came from a personal acccount. The same investigators went after an employee because there was a folder on a file server that was named with that employee's name. The investigators assumed that the employee was responsible for all of the folder's contents even though the whole agency had full permission to the folder. The folder contained pictures of women and even though none of them were nude they charged the employee with using the state's resources for personal gain. The employee received a warning even though no one could prove who placed the pictures there. No one bothered to ask one of the system administrators for information on the folder.

No, I never assume that any secret investigator knows what end is up and what end is down. I will also stick up for people who I feel haven't been given a fair shake until I hear enough of the story to make up my mind. It does make me upset to see so many people being so quick to jump the gun.

by jonathanpdx

You don't sound like a schmuck. I don't think you were the only one who had a problem with the manner in which the user posted their "story."

Holy Cow! You'd think that people would learn to state matters or concepts in a clear and concise manner. Anything that can be said can be said clearly. There is no excuse for poor grammar, spelling, and communication of concepts, especially in a profession that depends so much on attention to detail.

It's also not a matter of being an English major, it's a matter of simply speaking (or writing) English. Sloppiness and laziness is why we ended up with the Y2K fiasco, why the company in question is in the straights they're in, and why IT is such a costly expense for companies. Maybe some people are satisfied with shoddy quality in whatever they or anyone else does, but I don't see why I, anybody I work for, or anyone who works for me should have to stand for it.

Maybe this is just a simple board posting, but there's no excuse for appearing a simpleton by looking like your post was constructed by a 5 year old.

You're is not Your,
It's is not Its,
Their is not There,
Prolly is not Probably,
etc., ad nauseum.

by jonathanpdx

I certainly hope your post wasn't an example of the level of competency you're teaching your students, but rather a tongue-in-cheek poke at the poor quality of stuff we continually see on the boards.
:-)

by oz_media

Reading something is useless without comprehension. In just about country, it is illegal to tamper with company owned equipment. As the OP stated :
"this IT Admin, deliberately mismanaged the net work to obtain software and hardware for both personal use and for personal private transactions."

This is against the law, in most countries we use the term THEFT to describe such action.

"The old IT Admin, apparently created personal encrypted passwords which have locked in all essential files, and has been unsuccessfully decoded"

This would also be constituted as corporate sabotage and theft, if allegations of such encryption are correct.

Now you have also stated that he was probably never even asked, which is a fair point also and I agree that in most similar cases, the admin would hapily give up such info as needed....but who knows what else he has installed, encrypted or hidden that he still has access to?

Regardless of company policy, regardless of whether this is in America, England, Canada etc. This is still unlawful as it hinders the company's ability to conduct business as it normally does in a day to day fashion. They have had the locks on the front door changed and they weren't given the key. (perhaps that will allow you to see the issue here). Even if they called and he returned with the keys, he has STILL tken it upon himself to change the locks, which would also be just as ilegal.

So while this would most likely be resolved by a simple phone call, what the admin has done IS ilegal by laws in most countries that I've worked in.

So now we come to the investigators, they accuse him of locking out the system, yes that could be fraudulent if proven.
You dont trust investigators, neither do I, the problem is the admin hasn't provided his passwords, this is theft of company property, and if a simple phone call doesnt bring him to action, then a lawsuit should follow. As you say, give hi the benefit of the doubt, if he doesn't offer ALL passwords and open access to ALL systems, have him arrested.
The guy has made unauthorized changes to the system. He has left with private company information, which may even be used to access critical client data, passwords, employee information, financial records, etc. Again, he would be a theif in any country I've visisted.

His ONLY, and I repeat, ONLY way of saving face is to return with all passwords and physically unlock all systems with the new admin present. At that point the company should then change all the passwords, restrict access and provide a strict, written company policy regading usage just so others understand the difference between shopping for office supplies and theft.

With or without policy, with or without investigators and with or without speaking to the admin, he has broken the law and stolen from the company. He can either admit it and come clean, or face prosecution.

by tejones

To answer the first question I need to know how bad the network is. If the network is operating at less than 40% and network users are getting ready to stage a revolt I would start over. Personal experience has shown this to be the fastest way to make the most users happy. And for the second question, since I am the sole IT person in my company (200+ people) I keep mirror image drives (the HD) of critical computers locked in my desk, just in case. I don't worry about work stations.

by jwong

All management personnel should always have a recent up-dated list of passwords for their entire environment. IT Administrators the necessary power to place any organization into a long tail-spin before it is all resolved.

I get along with my CEO and other upper management very well and with some outisde of the organization. But prudence would have me have a list of recent passwords so that I am never accused of holding the corporation in "ransom" for the "passwords".

As for the IT Admin that was unethical, you can ask for the passwords and you might get them; but more than likely if the termination was on "bad terms", hire an expert and crack the codes and learn from this "expensive lesson"

by jeffersnet

OK, I give in. String him up, it will teach him a lesson. Let's just cut off the hands of everyone who we think may have taken something.

Who cares if the old IT manager really did anything wrong. This is just about finding a reason, any reason, to go after anyone. After all, if you are not able to lift yourself up in any way then the only way you will ever make yourself look better is to step on whoever you can.

I don't care what other stupid thing you have to say, I'm not coming back to this discussion again. While there are a few people here with the power to reason there are way too many without any reasoning power like OZ.

Hasta la bye bye, I'm out of here....

by boomslang

But a really good warning that as someone with a little power in IT thinking that they can walk away with the store because they feel they have been slighted can lead to rather deadly situations. I relate it to make a point.

If you are an admin and you are working for a company and you think that you are justified by NOT TELLING THEM THE PASSWORDS when you leave, make sure that you are not working for an ex-Navy SEAL or any type of war veteran. They once operated under very different rules than you have and if they saw combat, they know how to wield some very scary power, and they just might not care about the legality. The best bet is to early on, find another job if you work for them.

Same goes for any city where you have any type of organized crime. It takes nothing to happen to know a member of the local Cuban or Russian mafia who's willing to take a swat at you for a small favor.

You might think that what the company has done to you justifies your actions, but locking up their data resources is unethical. If you did it intentionally, there are worse things than civil lawsuits. Your national government after all has, under the PATRIOT act, redefined a lot of minor things out there as terrorist acts. Who you work for and what you do can mean the difference between being in a managerial spat where no one wins and hotel greybar time.

by boomslang

Some rules with computers...

1) Never do anything illegal on a computer. The only way to remove all traces of activity on that machine are to do a full hard drive wipe with multiple overwrites.

2) The fact that the drive has been wiped is a good indicator that it once held data that the investigator needed to see and depending on the size of the business and what they do, this may be a crime.

3) Even if you do wipe the computer, there are always logs just about anywhere that show what activity has occurred.

4) Most Evidence Eliminator programs don't. If you are using the computer for what you think is harmless activity, all it takes is a good session with Ontrack Easy Data Recovery to bring a good portion of all the e-mails and sites that were erased unless you are running something like BCWipe to wipe slack space. See 2)

5) And here's the big stickler... Never trust anyone to believe something was done innocently. IT is always viewed as having too much power because the people you work for usually have no understanding of or wish to understand the technology you work with. Never do anything shady to begin with because your reputation is on the line. Shoot straight and be ethical for your own sake and never rationalize or justify diddling the company you work for... It is better to find a new job than try to get even with imagined or real slights by your employers.

by mysterio41

It never ceases to amaze me that IT Admins are often blamed for "poor network performance", and then are subjected to rather ruthless evaluation by others who do not understand the job.

"There was an IT Administrator who had been fired from his Company, do to deliberate mismanagement of the companies network systems in order to acquire new products and software for which they proposed - was the best solution in order to fix the problem, "

Can any one of you administrators out there (myself excluded) tell me WHEN you've not proposed solutions to problems with your network?

I find it odd that there are torches burning, pitchforks in hand, etc., when we have only one side of the story. Do any of you REALLY think that your bosses -- unless they are IT pros -- know what you do for the company?

How many admins out there live with a stranglehold because what you know should be done to improve service, cannot be done as management has decided it isn't as important as YOU think it is?

I'm going to go with an "I've seen this situation before, lived it, got the T-shirt, didn't like it, gave it back." approach. Oddly, I wonder if the admin didn't surrender the passwords out of spite, or to force the company to do what is RIGHT for his/her replacement by starting over.

Oh, and so I'm not forgetting, the software for personal use? Who DID discover it and how? Someone had to have committed a crime there to find it on the admin's personal home computer, no?

Just asking.

by jmgarvin

This has be discussed ad nausium and you are late to the show....so read the thread....

by mysterio41

Yes, I am late to the show. And, YES, I have read the thread. But I will note, other than your derision, you DIDN'T answer my questions.

Care to respond with something else? Or should I ask you to read the thread?

And I am certain you meant for me to RTFT... But that's ok. As I said, we're not expected to be perfect. But we can at least try to get our points across. I actually read your post 6 times before I realized you just mistyped your derision. It's ok. I shan't give you trouble... I prefer the haughty types who don't read what I've posted, and shoot from the hip. I'll have your job within a month. If I desire it.... Now imagine what your bosses will think (they read this thread also) and you sound like what?

M.

by twaka

I agree with the previous post. Even though there are no loyalties either way between employers and employees these days, there are still certain obligations.

The IT Admin was wrong, and the boss mishandled the situation. The organization is also paying for not having the proper policies in place and a proper disaster recovery plan. Too many times the treat is viewed as coming from the outside.

There have been similar cases which ended in court and the company won! So beware.

by jmgarvin

I think he might be crying in a corner RIGHT NOW...

What do you have to say for yourself!!

:-)

by jmgarvin

I don't hid whole I am, nor do I feel the need to respond to your points. You hide who you are with nothing in your profile and little, if any, content in your posts.

If you read AND comprehended the thread, you would known that your questions (and invalid points) have been addressed.

I refer you to the top of the thread:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11189-0.html?forumID=3&threadID=182462&messageID=1863818
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11189-0.html?forumID=3&threadID=182462&messageID=1867311
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11189-0.html?forumID=3&threadID=182462&messageID=1861989

My bosses know who am I am they know my mentality. I have no time for self impossed ignorance. I also highly doubt you could "take my job" or even do what I do, but thanks for playing.

I don't hide who I am, but you...Mr. Troll...do...So if you are so great, why not add information about yourself to your profile?

by zeppo9191

"I'll Tell You What I Would Fire Someone For"?

Try, "I'll tell you why I would fire someone", or "I'll tell you for what reason I would fire someone".

For someone so willing to criticize other's use of the English language, you don't seem to have very strong skills, yourself...

I may be proving myself a hypocrite to some, but I find far less fault in those who are being criticized (irrelevant of whether said criticism is valid) than I do in the critics - especially when the critic is guilty of the same 'crime'.

This discussion is closed to new replies.