Discussion Locked

Laws in response to cybercriminals

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Tell us what you think about the Sept. 2, Internet Security Focus newsletter on Internet crime. Did you find the column thought-provoking?

7 replies

by peterpac

Naturally breaking into a governmental computer system should be illegal. But, I feel we need to take it further into companies and home personal computers. Problesm arise as most companies do not report break ins due to their not wanting anyone to know of the breakins. The people who breakin should be punished but there has to be a definite law of how and why and to what extent. Does John Doe get 10 years because he found a security flaw and reports it?
The weakest link of the internetis the home user (lack of security or know how to protect the computer) which can lead to hackers/crackers gaining access to multiple computers to create a massive power source to break down the security of both goverment and companies.
Is it not the time for manufactorers of computer systems to place security into the basic build?
Yes, I agree with this editorial and its time the world takes a stand on securing the internet.

by lwoldt

Tell me, is 'cyberspace' similar to 'phonespace'?

There is no 'cyberspace' and acting as though this is some separate realm of reality is part of the problem.

If I call someone in Los Angeles and I live in Boston, does the crime we hatch become part of 'phonespace'; governed by a different set of laws and rules? Of course not. Hatching a crime over the phone doesn't remove it from reality anymore than coming up with a crime using two or more computers.

Fraud is fraud and theft is theftwhether you walk in someplace like a bank or come in via computer - both are criminal acts committed in reality not cyberspace.

Finding the evidence of a bank theft may be a bit tougher if I use a computer instead of a gun but it is still a crime.

We geeks need to stop talking about 'cyberspace'
and start talking about reality.

by bundy

I agree. A crime is a crime. It is about time that we stopped inventing words to desribe inadequacies. How about 'spyware'? Is this a crime by companies or not? Cookies qualify also. As far as I can see the majority of crimes are instigated by immoral, unscupilous companies who place more emphasis on the daollar and will try any elaborate methods to obtain their results. These are the criminals who infiltrate my computer.

by webwevol

While the argument made for uniform (and enforceable)legal standards pertaining to the misconduct of those who would intrude into a webserver, network, or individual system are long overdue, I hope that this push will extend to uniform and active enforcement of (copyright and standards of decency) laws already in place (though not web specific) against websites themselves.
No one needs to be reminded what's being offered out there. Think how this makes us look. Dose the whole world understandthat just because "some_awful_website.com" is hosted in the US or Europe, that we are not necicairaly all depraved? Do we escape any appearance of complicity when we harbor and protect such sites?
Sure, they should impale hackers at the city gates,till the birds pick their bones clean (in a manner of speaking) but my hope is that the semi "legitimate" websites and hosts will be held to common societal standards also. If they ran brick and mortar stores, they'd be outside the law.. so it should be on line too.
No wonder our societies detractors find it so easy to abuse our image... why help it further along??

by dlw6

I keep looking for the article, so I can respond completely, but it doesn't seem to exist except in the e-mail copy I got. So, I'll respond to that.

I take exception to the comment "You don't need to be a criminal to look like one." Forensictech did something that's been illegal for what, 20 years? Therefore they are criminals.

I have heard the argument that they acted like the friendly neighbor who, upon seeing that your door is unlocked, locks it and leaves you a note. This argumentignores the facts, namely that they took copies of documents. That's more like entering the house, licking all the food in the 'fridge, and then leaving a note.

The thing about the situation that amuses me is that, in the mainstream media, the reporters don't understand the difference between classified and sensitive, and don't seem inclined to learn. While the documents that Forensictec took off those computers aren't meant for public release, neither do they put the nation at risk.

Good fortune,
Don

by jon yarden

Thanks for taking the time to post your comments to this article. Certainly some food for thought.

This discussion is closed to new replies.