I read this and really had to think hard about if I wanted to reply to it or not because I'm not sure you will understand my response. You do need to understand that I
have been on both sides of the fence and can see both sides of this question.
"Ever so often I struggle to manage one of my people. I've just turned 30 and this person is in their mid 40's. I've been her manager for just under a year, and started
with the company as her manager, whereas she's been here 5yrs."
You introduced age into this problem and that is part of the problem which I will explain farther down.
"This person is loud and likes to try to trip me up (loudly), when she knows the office is an open one, where the conversations can be over heard. I do have regular
meetings (weekly updates) away from the environment, but she just likes to try to prove she's right about things that she so obviously isn?t, but because of the noise I
back down, because I?m quite reserved, and basically not that kind of person."
Is she so obviously wrong or do you back down because some of her points maybe right?
"People try to look like they get on with her, and there is so much bitching about anyone and everyone you wouldn?t believe."
This is where you maybe wrong. They might just agree with her. If you are having a problem with bitching about anyone then you obviously have a team problem
and as the team leader means you are not doing your job effectively.
"The company has recently come to some trouble and recovered from Ch11. Her position/ team was moved elsewhere (the helpdesk) and she moved into desktop,
being one of the few to stay."
This is where the real problem stems from. You are dealing with employees who don't know if they will have a job tomorrow. She has been thrown into a new job
that she may or may not be totally comfortable with and her actions seem to indicate that she needs some training and reinforcement of her position. You need to
understand that people in her age group don't adjust to change as easily as you may. You indicated that her position/team was moved elsewhere, now if you mean
by that it was offshored then I can understand where she is coming from. Older people are beginning to resent our jobs being sent to other countries when we are
better able to handle them ourselves. It is becoming totally clear that companies don't give a damn about their employees anymore so why should the employee
care.
"I've come from an IT background, am used to managing younger peers, and am highly educated, whereas her snippets are from experience on the job, although she
misses so many obvious things that are staring her in the face."
I think you clearly show an attitude problem of your own here. You maybe better educated than her but guess what she is street smarter about the company than
you. There are things that you could learn from her and I'm sure things she could learn from you. That is what team management is all about, learning from each
other to do a better job overall. Right now I am betting that not just her but others are seeing the company problems being caused by younger managers who are
better educated but don't have sense enough to come in out of the rain.
"Often when I?m being nice, and mentor her it's shrugged off and feelings of 'I know that' etc. It's very hard to manage such a person.
Does anyone have any thoughts?"
So with all that being said I would do the following.
First pull her personnel records and see if she did her job well in her old position. If there were problems then you need to consider bringing in HR and documenting
her mistakes. If she did well then there is more to this problem.
Second, Get your team together and tell them where the company is at and make them realize that if they don't all work as a team you will all be out of jobs. Ask
them for input on how to make the team stronger and throw out some ideas for their comments. Remember you have been there only a year where as they may
have been there longer and have a better idea of what works and what doesn't.
Third, You mentioned the stockroom problem. You missed a golden opportunity. You should have given her that responsibility to handle the memory. This would
have shown that you are relying on her to do something and trust her. It also would allow you to do something more productive with your time.
You and other younger managers need to realize that people over 40 come from an age that the Golden Rule of management was don't ask somebody to do a job
that you can't do yourself. Older employees see younger management people as people who maybe book smart but have no hands on training and until you show
them that you can do their job they won't respect you.
Something that I have done and maybe will help you is to bring the team together and tell them that for you to better understand what the department problems are
that you are going to spend some time with each person. Then pick one day a week and one employee and spend several hours with them while they do their job.
Make it clear that this is not to evaluate them but to better educate yourself about their job. If they do something differently than you would just ask them why they
handled it that way so you can understand. Make them feel that they are an important part of the department because they are and your job depends on them doing
their job to the best they can. Most of all keep your mouth shut about how they are doing their job while working with them but don't be afraid to ask them what
they are having problems handling. After you spend this time with each employee make notes of the problems back in your office. When you have done this with all
of them then have a meeting where you list the problems for all of them to see and ask for ideas on how you can solve them as a team. Present some ideas that you
feel will help solve these issues. This will also give you a chance to find out the strengths and weakness of each employee and you may want to move them around to
be more effective. Remember that if you do this make sure that you let them know it is because they are good at what they do.
I know that a lot of this isn't taught in school but should be. Show them that you want to work with them and use your knowledge to make them better employees.