Discussion Locked

Managing a loud and obnoxious subordinate

0 helpful
283 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

283 replies

by tlea

I agree with most of what amcol says. The only part I have contention with is his opinion as to the reason for the employee's behavior. There could be other reasons besides ego. Chief among them may be fear or uncertainty. But none of us can really know the employee's reason for her behavior without taking to her. This is where you come in...

You are the manager, and as such you must be in control of the members of your team, not letting them control you. Part of your job is to define boundaries and responsibilities, as well as to set performance expectations. This doesn't mean that you have to threaten the person?s job to make them perform, but it does mean that you have to tell them what is acceptable behavior and what you expect of them in terms of performance.

If the subordinate doesn't straighten up then you will have to pursue more drastic measures. Trust me, not getting this situation under control is bad for your whole team, and may cause some members to foster resentment towards you. Nobody likes to reprimand subordinates, but discipline is part of being a manager.

I had a similar situation, and after a few private discussions with him and my boss I ended up sending the employee to communications training. Not only did the training help him improve at his job, but the person was also appreciative that I tried to supply a solution instead of just telling him to ?get a better attitude?. Getting the results I wanted took a little more work and conflict, but in the end I didn?t have to hire and train a new employee, which would have taken quite a bit longer.

by tomsal

I've read Amcol's first reply, this one and the others before it.

I feel amcol's advice and management perspective on this issue is sound and professional.

by amcol

Yet another poster who's proved my point for me. You're making this far too easy.

"You have no idea what's going on through the other woman's head." Precisely. No one does, not even the original poster who's one of the players in this little psychodrama. That's why I said it doesn't matter what she's thinking...she's not the problem, the manager is the problem. Because the manager isn't managing.

"Every now and then the simplest explanation turns out to be the correct and accurate explanation." Precisely. And the simple explanation here is to manage, which is what isn't happening. No political correctness, no psychoanalyzing, no trying to figure out what's going on in her head and her life, no crystal gazing navel contemplating sensitive new age guy psychobabble, just pure, simple, everyday management.

Simple equation...you come to work to, guess what, work. If you're not doing the work you're, guess what, fired. Which part don't you understand?

Now, some may say that's a pretty hard edged view of life in the corporate lane. Perhaps. Don't get me wrong...in my view, every single employee who fails represents a management failure. There's no such thing as an unredeemable employee, there's only managers who have abrogated or ignored their responsibility to do whatever's necessary to extract every last ounce of potential productivity out of every last person. That's the manager's job. But the owners of our companies, whoever they are, are paying us to work. To get the work done. To produce results. If you can't do that, the owners will find someone who will. And managers, acting as the owners' proxy, are the people charged with doing just that.

Thanks again. Suggestion...go back and read the posting you commented on. Your response had nothing to do with what I wrote.

by tlea

Victim? He is the manager. He has the power to control the situation. How exactly is he a victim, except for letting himself be one? Sure it isn't his fault that the employee initially acted like a jerk, but it IS his fault that she continues to do so, and so the reason for his post. I think pointing out that he needs to have a little more back bone is good advice.

by by825

I have also had the unfortunate experience of dealing with persons with less than desirable attitudes. I can tell you that the only way to fight fire is with fire. You are going to have to stand up to her. You will need to pick and choose when the time is right for making your statement. Decide when she has said something that isn't accurate and call her on it. If she is using the office as an open forum then you will also have to. This is probably the only way to get her attention and to let her know that it is not okay to act in such an unprofessional manner. Of course, I would recommend that you first warn her several times in private and explain to her why she should act differently, if you have not already done so. She will probably not like you much after you do this the first time, but sounds like she doesn't have much respect for you professionally now, so what the hey. My experience is that once this process begins there will be an initial elevation stage where the person will try to act like they are in control. You must stick to your guns. After a while she will back down. Remember, most importantly, you must be very professional and respectful while under taking such an office maneuver because you have everything to loose and she has everything to gain. Good luck.

by keyguy13

You're making the same assumptions that you claim are erroneous. You also can't assume that a happy and trusting employee WON'T do a better job. Statistics are generally useless, as they can be made to show anything.

In general, it only makes sense that a happy and trusting employee is going to be more productive than an unhappy suspicious one. It's just common sense.

And none of this has anything to do with the topic of this thread.

by ladyjet

Explain to her that though she has work experience, so do you, and though she's been with the company for 5 years and you've been here for a year, you have found things that should have been obvious to her. Most of all, no matter how loud she gets, stay calm and keep talking to her--don't let her make you back down--if you're right, you're right, no matter how loud she gets. She's reacting out of fear or she wouldn't be getting so loud. Have you tried figuring out some way to diffuse her fear? Usually that's a clear sign that she's worried about losing her job as well as the fact that she's always trying to "trip you up."

On the other hand, YOU are HER manager/HER boss... You need to take control. You can do this in several ways: 1) take a dealing with difficult people class or 2) talk with your Human Resources person to help you with this problem employee. Take classes on managing people better--that never hurts. Take classes about asserting yourself without getting embarrassed about others' loudness. These are things you have control over.

I've heard about situations like this from a lot of people out there and if you don't take control, you'll be one of those ineffectual managers who usually get the boot. I saw that happen at my husband's last job. Try having a private meeting with her? If not, now may be the time.

Best of luck to you.

by ed.gonzalez

She is affraid of you and and in her mind you are a threat. These types of ondividuals rely on a buddy network to bully around the office.

First, you need to express your concerns to your manager and HR, to clearly establish that there is a behavioural problem that undermines the performance of the company - be careful of not creating this as a personal vendetta - it is about business performance. Explain the steps that you plan to take (as suggested below) to put you firmely in control of the situation.

Second, set the tight leash. Every week she needs to report to you on all issues being dealt with, and most importantly how she has dealt with them. Ask her to lead a risk session to see how she is going to deal with those risks - help her be successful at it so she can gain some self confidence and trust from you. If she has any weaknesses (i.e does know something) your "public" commitment to help her and her team to overcome such deficiencies will place you on top of the perception pole that she has been trying to knock you off.

Third, organize a session to have the IT group establish the desirable attributes of the organization in terms of acceptable values, beliefs and behaviours. In making such a list, the team will indirectly point out that her behaviour is not contributing to good workking relationships. By having set these as the desired outcomes, you and everyone else can remind her of what is not acceptable.

Lastly, with the help of HR, set performance and behavioural objectives that can be measured at least each quarter. be careful of not doing this first as this will be a salvo for war and in that you may lose.

Edgardo Gonzalez
ed.gonzalez@prsl.ca

by keyguy13

It's hard for me not to laugh at you jmgarvin. You obviously missed the entire point of that part of the article.

It had nothing to do with free fuel. It had to do with trust, which you obviously don't have for anything.

Look at the credentials of this guy. If he wasn't a good manger, do you think he would have been a manager in those companies?

Not only is it not bunk, but it was a demonstration of a great management style that seems to have been lost since then.

I for one, have always responded to being respected and trusted, with motivation and loyalty .

I don;t understand what it is that you don't believe about this article? That a manager could have the balls to give his employees a little credit? Or that they didn't take advantage of it and trusted him back? Which is it?

Because I think it's a sad commentary that you responded negatively to this article at all.

by jmgarvin

A happy and trustful employee is not always productive. You can have your trusting and happy employees all you want, but they aren't always going to be productive (there or not).

The article has no relation to reality. I highly suggest you read the links provided and take a course or two in organizational behavior. The implications of the article are that happy and trusting employees are productive. This is 100% untrue.

While trust is a sign of a good leader, it does not mean that your employees will be productive.

Motivation != productivity
Respect != productivity
Productivity = Productivity

The article claims that employees were more productive because of the "trust" involved. This could be true, but it could be a mirad of other factors.

I highly suggest you read the links I posted.

by bhenson12

1. There is a difference between being a manager and
a leader. From your post, you have been a manager.
Now its time you become a leader.
2. Hold a meeting with this person offsite (perhaps a
lunch or Starbucks} break. I would suggest you do that
with all your workers, so as to not single out this person
from the crowd. When you send out your official notice
to the department that you are having these offsite get
togethers, lay out the Rules of Engagement: such as a)
what is said here, stays here, b) You can slam
processes, but not people..etc., etc.. When you do the
Starbucks meeting, really listen. You are there to get
this person to talk about themselves. Maybe there is
something that you don't know about this person that is
making them react the way they do. If this person has
been there a long time, maybe they feel that no one
respects their time (In -grade). Ask this person about
their experience and some war stories. Try to build a
bond. You both don't have to like each other, but you
should both respect each other. What this meeting is
about is building TRUST, so don't betray it to other
people.
3. Remember, there might be a negative feeling toward
you because you are highly educated, and this person
is educated "In the streets" and may resent you for it.
Try to get across to this person that they have talents
you don't have and you rely on their talents to make
everyone win.
4. Get out of your office and LWA (Lead by walking
around}. Not to spy, but to build Trust and see what
everyone is doing and how you can help them
succeed.
5. Hold a Department meeting and go over the
Corporate Mission and Vision and Strategic Vision
statements - and how each department is critical to the
companies success - and how each person is
responsible to make the company successful. Try to
show how each persons personal job assignment
contributes to the overall goals of the company.
6. Give this person a project to complete and give all
the tools needed to help this person succeed beyond
their greatest expectation. Mention in the kick off
meeting that they have all the authority to make it
happen, and ultimately all the accolades when its
successful. Mention they get all the blame if it fails.
then back off and see what happens. Of course if you
set it up correctly, and help this person to succeed, - if it
fails, it softens the blow a little. IT departments are
firemen departments and failure is just a step toward
success.
7. In a Departmental meeting, stress what is
acceptable behavior and unacceptable behavior. Have
a HR rep there for back up and to answer any
questions they may have.

I could go on. I have spend 20 years in IT corporate
Desktop Support, Business Analysis work and have
come to see D.Top support people as very bright,
extremely overworked and usually underpaid. They
are great at what they are doing, but need a great
LEADER to keep them motivated and to bring out their
strengths. I challenge you to step up to that position
and help this person and your whole department shine.

Brad Henson
Author: Heart Attack Survivor - a field guide
http://www.heartattacksurvivor.com

by jerispringer

off of your post, prof. They were almost identical.
I don't have any experience managing but I think it's always best to put one's self in both peoples' shoes- the manager's as well as the employee's.
There are lots of difficult people in the workplace (whether they're your manager, your coworker or your employee). Making a friend rather than an enemy is a good approach as long as you don't let people take advantage.

Off topic here but you had a heart attack? They found recently that elevated levels of homocysteine is the largest factor. Homocysteine can be combatted, believe it or not, with taking folic acid and B6 and B12 everday. I'll visit your website.

by rush2112

This is pretty much what I was going to post but Brad has put it much more elequently that I would.

Have a meeting with all team members

Outline Responsibilities
Outline Priorities
Outline who is in charge of each issue.

Request feedback from subordinates and allow for them to approach in private where the conversations and information exchanges can happen in a less formal environment. Some people are just shy in groups.

LISTEN to the feedback. (as someone else already noted)

Include goals of the organisation and resposibilities of the department to provide
x.y,z,r,q,a,b,t and note that c,e,f,g,p are provided elsewhere within the company(whatever those items happen to be)

This will help focus on the CORE responsibilities and allow more time to be devoted to the tasks which need to be performed by this department and will allow for other departments to contribute their portions.

Being a one-person show isn't easy; and it often leads to disaster when the demands for time from the ONE come from many. When this occurs perception of non-cooperation could result, even though the ONE is doing the best he/she can.
So it is important to divide tasks among members leaving each a PRIMARY responsibility for this task/issue and a secondary(a backup)

People get ill, and go on vacation, go away for training and have other reasons to be out of the workplace, why not have someone who can FILL IN during these times to keep the company MOVING forward.????

As for the LOUD person, make sure that the entire group is given a chance to comment after you explain which are acceptable forms of communication between subordinates and which are INSUBORDINATION. (again contact HR if you are unclear about anything)

Managers must take charge, and must delegate whenever possible to those who earn the trust of the manager to accomplish the goals of the team.

Also let the entire team know that you do trust them to do x,y,z,r,q,p,t (or whatever it is) and that you depend on them each day for their efforts and that you appreciate them for the job that they do.

by ladyjet

This is called flaming and is not okay on NOT okay on ANY list. Didn't you learn any computer netiquette along the way? Or in other words, How could you not learn computer netiquette?

Flaming does not solve problems, it draws attention away from them.

by jerispringer

Redirecting her attention is a good tactic.
However, if she "has it in" for her manager, she might try something else next.

In that case, the only way to find out what the gal's real problem is, is to confront her. As tactfully as possible.
If I were the manager, I would inform my superior what is going on and tell him (or her) how I planned to approach it. It's important to let your boss know what's going on so that someone else (like the insubordinate worker) doesn't claim a grievance. Always let your boss know what's going on. Also, if you don't already know, find out what constitutes insubordination. Some companies define insubordination only as not doing what you (as an employee) are asked to do.
This particular issue might vaguely fall under questioning authority or upsetting the group morale or something, I don't know. Anyway, find out what your options (corrective actions, etc) are if everything you try does not work. Hopefully someone in the company can mediate if worse comes to worse.

This is what I would tell my boss about how I planned to approach her situation:
I would wait until she pulled another stunt, call her into my office (preferably as soon as she returns from lunch so I'm not announcing it in front of the whole group) and tell her that I would like to know if "there's a problem" and "can we do something to resolve this".
If she doesn't fess up, you have to precisely describe her behavior and why it is disharmonius and disruptive to the goals of your company and how/why the company needs each member needs to be a team player and work together.

If she acts like she didn't realize that it came off as so obnoxious, you have to explain that everyone's input is appreciated and welcomed but that there is a correct manner for doing it as well as a right time and place for it (like writing it down, as CTOS said, or bringing it up in a meeting).
(I wouldn't invite her to come into your office with every idea she gets, of course, or you might not have time to get your own work done!)

If, on the other hand, she acts defiant and is not going to tell you what her problem is (with you or with the company or whatever it is), then it's time to go back to your chain of command and let them know you've got to "go by the book". Either get the situation mediated by someone else or start taking corrective measures.
Give her a chance but if it doesn't work, you've got to protect your company and yourself.

by psalm2324

I too had this same problem years ago. I was the Dept. Supervisor at the ripe old age of 25, most of the women were well above my age group. I decided to seek help from the "human resources" Dept. and there is where I found my answers. First they had me sit down with this woman one on one. Sometimes it's a simple personality conflict which can be resolved with small meetings. Secondly, I had to document everything. This is usually a pain and it does take some time, but, if there is no future working with this person, documentation will become very important. Third, have human resources handle her if all else fails. Don't swallow her obnoxious behavior, be calm, don't raise your voice, but most of all don't back down. You're in charge! Good Luck to you.

by tracyf

Certainly, there must be a procedure, during reviews & such, to deal with sub-standard work & behavior? You bring them in, tell them the weak points, give them a probabtionery period to improve, review again- I mean, that's how it's always been for me? I'll also add that, when their has been a particularly aggressive employee problem, there would be a 2nd manager sitting in on the review.

My gut feeling on this- & please- no name calling & such. It is only my personal feeling- which has helped my through a lot of encounters:

Regardless of the situation, this person sounds like they are creating a less-than-stellar team environment?

I'd also like to add, after reading some of the other replies, that it seems the OP only mentioned the age difference in order to give the entire situation- not because they are age-biased. The age/experience of the employee does matter- a lot- in how they would react being managed by another, younger w/less experience (in their mind) person.

It would seem obvious that one issue is likely the employee probably thought they should have the manager's job. Perhaps the fact that they didn't get that position stems from their negative behavior issues. If so, then someone else already is aware of it.

The OP has some managing to do. It takes two for someone to be taken advantage of- time to step up & deal with this, following the company guidelines.

I wish you luck- this sounds like a terrible situation to be in,

TF

by ntguru

I understand what you are going through, but you need to remember that no two people are the same and will possibly never get along "perfectly". I would sugesst possibly contacting HR about the situation, but in all, it might be best to limit ALL conversations with this person.

by jvbrady

The choice to get rid of her, or reign her in, starts with needing for her to get a profound appreciation for subordination. You both have a disfunctional set up: you're meek, she's obnoxious. Nobody in your open office setting is going to feel comfortable hearing these kind of exchanges. (Interesting, that her department moved somewhere else, but for some strange reason, she got jettisoned to yours.)

For your own sake and stature, you have to pull her aside and give her as firm a picture as possible that as of right now, you've determined that she is insubordinate and without improvement will be released. Period. No mentoring, no qualified collegual this and that. You have to make it all about that one single issue, and you being the single judge. Why? Because she's coming from a place that many in IT or engineering are prone to, and that is that authority is organically in flux and determined by who is the rightest of the brightest. Great for engineering olypmpics; totally untennable in an organization. Because a really smart boss surrounds his or herself with people who are at least as bright as the boss, so the objectives get met and the org moves ahead. This is all about ego.
Your temptation will be to let her know that once you get this little problem past you, you want to mentor her, etc. etc. If you do anything like that, you will fail with her at your own peril. She must believe that fair or not, your not going to tolerate her insubordination, and that you are grading her and watching her every single minute for that, and that nothing she does is going to matter until you are satisfied that you can count on her. Because bottom line, she's not thinking beyond the moment and her ego - nobody cares if she is right or wrong, except her. She's only making you and your department look bad, undermining confidence among the people who need to count on you for uncomplicated, dependible support. All she is broadcasting right now is that Desktop is not sure of itself.
So have this talk immediately with her. Don't justify anything, don't debate anything, just let her know that her future with the company is going to depend on her ability and willingness to work within the structure, period, thank you , that will be all.
She'll resist for a while, and you'll have to be very frontal with her if you spot her in conspiratorial looking little confabs - just march right up, ask where she is with X, Y, and Z, and give her a new deadline.
You have only one correct choice if she goes theatrical on you in the office, and that is for you to interrupt her and direct her to your office on the spot. No matte how subtly she starts in, or how loud, your response has to be as boss, NOT PEER.
If she doesn't get it, then you need to visit with your supervisor and explain that you are having insubordination problems and hostility. Something tells me this won't be the first time they've heard it about her. Good luck. This is the kind of things companies don't train managers for, but are absolutely essential.

by bs analyst

If the employee wanted to put her boss in a difficult situation, taking them to lunch would be a gift. "He asked me to lunch, he harassed me, I turned him down, now I'm being disciplined".

by carlos.garcia.marcano

I'll recommend that, within your company HR managing policy you deal firmly with this employee. You do not have to be loud, yet you must let her know in a firm manner and unmistakably clear terms that her behavior is unacceptable, and that it is an area of improvement that will be seriously be looked into when her next performance review comes up.

Remember that good leadership, among other attributes, requires that conflict be managed, rather than avoided, and that authority be excersiced when there is no other way.

If let the lady whose behavior you described to continue to get away with it, you could find yourself facing the same problems with other subordinates soon enough.

Good luck

by lexys

Find somewhere quiet (if possible) away from everyone else and start off by pointing out a positive aspect e.g. her experience. Then explain to her what she does that makes you feel uncomfortable and then give her a chance to say her side of the story. Make it clear that you are not attacking her, you only want to work together more effectively. Tell her what you would like her to do whenever she thinks that you are making a mistake etc.
Also ask her how you can use a different approach when mentoring her. But there are some things in people we just have to ignore.
Most importantly, if anyone is doing something you don't like, you should let them know straight away, nicely but firmly. And give them the alternative behaviour that you would prefer, e.g "can you please come and speak to me properly?" Loud, aggressive people will take advantage of quiet people such as yourself but you don't need to be loud to be heard and to work together.
Of course, if nothing works and she wants to continue this way, I would make a formal complaint to the next level up, or your HR.

by gsymoo

Everyone looks to their Supervisor for "The Way", what?s normal, and often the whole atmosphere in a department can hinge around one or two people.
Often this sort of behaviour stems from a person not knowing where the limit is.
Some people will push and push to see what they can get away with. The more you give, the more they will take.
Often a small bark of authority or a quiet word in a closed office will do the trick, but you must come over as her Boss.
Everyone takes their cues from their supervisor. If you act like you are scared of your colleagues, then liberties will be taken.
You obviously have confidence in your abilities, so show that confidence.
When someone behaves unacceptably, tell them. When they do well, thank them.

by jvbrady

When you're 21, fresh on the job, etc., the maverick syndrome is something that we all naturally experience. You believe that the best answer is the best for the company, period. Structure sometimes feels, as you put it, draconian. As you go on, however, you see a wider view. A bad boss is no longer a meanie, but somebody who is ineffective, vindictive, petty, incompetent in the roles expected of a person who works effectively in an organization. He's not a life-coach, but can be. He's not a colleague, but can be. He's not somebody you have to like, but can be. The one thing he does have to do is make his team or dpt. effective for the company. Entertaining loud and continuous challenges of a subordinate is not effective in any way. I've lived through both sides of this, been guilty of and paid the price for letting righteousness be my calling card. If this seasoned employee is convinced of a plethora of changes needed, she needs to approach the manager and outline all this - not call out gotcha's. It's very obvious that team effectiveness - or improvement - is not on her radar. And if this manager was such the draconian you suspect, he wouldn't be asking here for advice on what to do with outspoken challengers. Draconians eat people like that for finger food. I get the sense that this manager has come up through the ranks, and is way more comfortable in the collegial role than the superior/subordinate interraction.

by blarman

When an employee is clashing with a manager, most of the time it is an effort by the employee to say - you're management style doesn't match with my needs as an employee. This is straight out of management 101 (having recently finished my MBA, this was a focus of discussion). And Managers who don't individually manage their employees are Accountants, not Managers. I know, I work for one, I have had this conversation, and was completely blown off.
There are four basic management strategies according to the motivation and skill level of the employee:
For unmotivated, unskilled employees, the manager has to take a dictatorial, micromanaging effort. The manager must train the employee and set goals as to when things have to be done and set disciplinary actions for failure to achieve goals.
For unmotivated, skilled employees, the manager should set the goals, but probably doesn't need to do the instruction. The manager should be working on finding a challenge to motivate the employee.
For motivated, unskilled employees, the manager should mentor: giving instruction while proceeding at a pace worked out between the manager and the employee. Many motivated employees can be given employee mentors or supplementary reading to speed up the learning process and decrease the load on the manager.
For motivated, skilled employees (rare and valuable), they need to be consulted to feel valued. The manager should work with them to set ambitious deadlines and provide new challenges. Regular progress updates and inquiries about resources they need will help get the most out of these employees.

It sounds like the manager is using the wrong management tactic - trying to mentor when he should be consulting. The employee is likely complaining because she wants to feel valued for her knowledge. So as a manager, you should cater to this. If she plainly doesn't know and is trying to BS an answer, then ask questions in a way that points out the results of an incorrect understanding. If she's not humble enough to handle the correction, you may need to assert the risk of disciplinary action. But I'd try switching tactics first.

by beoweolf

The employee (after 5 years) must know something; otherwise they would or should have been terminated long before.

This is an issue that requires better than a quick, off the cuff response. Professionally and personally, I would review previous evaluations of the employee...see how other managers felt and dealt with this person.

All too often, newly minted managers are the ones that are defensive, often mistaking opinion for being "opinionated" or defending a professional assessment as being "defensive, dismissive or obstinate?)... they may or may not be. However, learning where they are coming from may give you a clue. Put away your fears and prejudices?someone believed in you enough to give you the responsibility, use your skills to turn this situation around.

I don't see this, as it has been framed, as an age issue. It may be experience vs. academic knowledge...that hasn't been established. Again an older worker, may not have an advanced degree...it may not have been required. But to be honest, the benefits of a degree (even an advanced degree) are nullified, other than documentation, after a few years in the trenches.

It seems silly that despite all the evidence of wide spread cheating for degrees that has been revealed...we still accept a degree as necessary for a position, but discount many years of successful employment as not quite valid?

The point is...I agree mostly that a manager should use a different approach when dealing with skilled/unskilled/motivated/unmotivated workers; even more he should take into account how to elicit the best performance from high output workers. They can be your best ally or worse nightmare. What makes it so puzzling, is the choice is pretty much yours based on how you view the value of their knowledge and worth to the job you ask them to do. If they can't do the job...then educate them, demote them or fire them. If you don't know how to handle them; then experiment, learn the best approach!

by tom.lee

Without knowing the particulars it is hard to say if a person is qaulified for a job just because they have been around a while. I have personaly been involved in situations where, for political reasons, getting rid of person ran the risk of having that position eliminated and I have also seen situations where for any number of reasons, higher management was afraid of getting rid of a particular person.

It needs to boil down to their personal performance and their impact on the group. If they are the best performer around but they drag down the rest of the group then their benefit is lost.

As a young manager the most common mistake is not wanting to ask for help. One one has all the answers but the effective manager is the one that knows where to go when they they don't know what to do (this only works if you take these types of occasions as opportunities to learn).

by Member 25916250

The issue leaves a few unanswered questions:

1) Is there clarity of vision within the team? For example, do you have a clear mission? Has it been presented to the team? Have they gotten behind it?

2) Is there structure? Does each person have a job description? Does the job description lay out the escalation and reporting structure? Does the employee understand their/your role?

3) Is there a regular review process? Do you set clear and measurable goals and objectives? Quarterly as well as Annually? Do you use them? Is one of these goals or objectives to improve aspects of their behaviour?

4) Is there a performance appraisal that can be done based on aggregate input from the reviews? If the reviews show a negative trend, is there a Performance Improvement Process that can be leveraged to document the efforts/failures to improve? These PIPs generally lead to HR action.

5) Finally, why allow this to be continued reactively in the public eye? Can you not have all discussions in a meeting room instead of in the open office?

If the answer is NO, maybe it's time to address these items as well.

Cheers!
Mark

by anyhelpwouldbegreat

Thanks, and I agree. There are so many great suggestions here, many of which I will use.

Many issues are with the ch11. The team is running at 50% the staff level as in the past. There is no future plans to recruit, leaving much analyst work to be done by myself too, and so little time to actually manage / lead / guide.

I come from a company where there were performance contracts each 3mths. There was a vision and a mission statement for the team. So many of these things (like the staff) have been stripped down with this company. Leaving a yearly appraisal - this is looked upon as a waste of time.

I hold weekly meetings, where this week I started to introduce some suggestions about managing and being her manager. This worked well.

There are no job descriptions available to individuals, as the company is recovering, and is starting to get better in this area but negativity is still very much apparent.

I try so much to speak away from the environment, this mainly works, but as I mentioned earlier there is always blame ready to be handed out openly, when it comes to light - i.e. hardware not being ordered by someone/ software developments not working. Anything to be bitched about gets bitched about - in the open office area.

by k1eg

After reading your update of this situation I now see why you are having the
problems, infact I am surprised that your not having more problems. A company
that doesn't have job descriptions and clearly defined job duties is doomed to fail.
Apparently they didn't learn too much from the CH11.

As I see it you have several options. If you have an HR manager I would go to them
and ask about setting up job descriptions for your department. I would also bring in
your boss at that point and make it very clear to them that the department cannot be
run effectively without job descriptions and assigned job duties. You could make the
point that this is costing the company money which it cannot afford to waste. You
should be an integral part of setting up the descriptions and job duties since you
know your people best. If they try to put it off explain that without these in place
people don't truly know what their job is and can't be held accountable if there is a
failure somewhere.

If this fails, and I suspect it will, then your best option will be to get your resume
back out there since this is a company that is doomed for failure. You don't want to
gain the reputation of working for failed companies since this will hurt your career.

by keyguy13

And it's a passive aggressive, cowardly way to handle it. If he can't address her and look her in the eye when dealing with this issue, how is he ever going to manage her?

I disagree with this one...

by keyguy13

Ummm... If you actually read the post, you would see that it was zen37's response to AMCOL's advice that was called draconian.

by bsmntcritr

I've had a very similar circumstance and learned that being nice only gives an aggressive personality ammunition as much as anything else. In my case, the "Agressive" actually had been telling co-workers, and users alike that a desired promotion wasn't granted because of gender. This personality refused and laughed off all nice corrective action. Fortunately "They" self-destructed and threaten to quit - it was taken as a resignation (gonzo). Our ages were within one year, our experiences were similar, "They" simply demanded and got nothing in return.

by travlnbard

First I have to say that I agree with amcol's points but I believe that they could have been stated better understanding that anyhelp is uncertain in his management roll.

I think that the answer in the short run is to explain the flaws in this employee's "advice". And each time remind her that your weekly meetings would be the best forum for these issues. Further down the road, if she insists on stating the issues in an open forum, you can write her up for not following instruction. Make sure that during your meeting that you specifically ask her if she has any issues she wants to address and seriously consider her issues but make your own decisions.

Do not allow her to trip you up and by all means do not back down. If necessary take long pauses to gather your thoughts so that when you speak it is clearly and knowledgably. Acknowledge when she has made a constructive point (she obviously needs affirmation from others and it doesn't sound like she gets it from you). She must be right some of the time even if it is presented poorly.

Finally, I would recommend that you get the training you need to be a more assertive manager. The first thing I would recommend it read "The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People". Then read it again.

Hope this helps

by roxyred66

I agree totally. This manager is asking for sound advice and we have immaturity knocking on her door.

by gnx

You need to speak up to her when she gets in her moods. At some point a person under you will do something that you will get the blame for. I don't know why but it seems the more incompetent some people are the more likely they are to get promoted.

by roxyred66

This manager is looking for help and even though we all know she needs to manage a little better, you turn around and name call. You should apologize.

by keyguy13

Like she is an a$$hole and got ditched by her old team too. You said her postion/team was moved elswhere and she got moved to desktop.

You also imply that she is incompetant by trying to prove she's right when she obviously isn't.

I think the next time she starts to loudly bully you, you should scream at the top of your lungs "SHUT UP! SHUT UP! SHUT UP!"

Do that everytime she is loud and obnoxious and she will soon get the hint.

Other than that, she might just be in need of a spanking, and you could tell her to come to your office and give her one. That might quiet her down too.

By the way, I'm just kidding... In case you weren't sure...

by david.m.gingrich

Since you are the manager, you need to turn this around - one way or the other. You cannot allow this person to have a negative influence on the environment and the team.

My suggestion is to discuss the situation with the individual - giving her the benefit of the doubt on whether or not she know how she is coming off. It is important that she understand that you expect a respectful environment - which is why you are discussing this with her one-on-one.

You need to try to be as factual and objective as possible. If she still doesn't get it - or doesn't care - then you need to do the normal supervisory stuff for someone who is not doing what they ought - document, document, document - and regularly let her know how she is (or is not) doing.

Hopefully, she will either be appreciative that you bothered to tell her how she is coming across or will be smart enough to tone it down. If not, you still are on the hook for improving your work environment - so do what you have to.

by Member 32832203

Sounds as if you've let this thing go on longer than it should have already. YOu're this person's manager, and need to command respect from your other subordinates and those junior to you.

Cat-o-nine-tails first (official admonishment), hang from the yard arm next (fire em). Following that, extra rum ration for excellent work from other "team" players (negative example followed by reward for positive behhavior).
Know that you are going to measured yourself as to how you handled the problem. Solve this as quickly as you can under company guidelines, and then handle your next issues strictly by the book, so you set up a PATTERN of accepted practices, so that your staff and superiors both understand how you will react presented with a difficult staffing situation.

by tedc

It is time to decide who you are. Having suffered from the nice guy syndrome myself, I learned the hard way that you will be walked all over if you don't take a firm hand. Not only are you letting this lady get away with murder, you are setting a acceptable standard for all of the other people who overhere her interaction with you.

What I would do it order her into my office the next time she does this (when it is fresh in both your minds) and advise her that that behaviour is unacceptable. Do not get into a discussion about it. It is your judgement,not hers that matters. Advise her that you are noting this conversation on her file. Whenever she repeats this behaviour, pull her into your office immediately and repeat your position. After three occurences, advise her that her position is in jeopardy and, if possible, send her home immediately to think about it.

If she still doesn't get it, you may be better off letting her go. If nothing else, this will also send a message to everyone else that you will not be walked all over.

Good luck.

Ted

by Member 32832203

The next time something happens out in the open, calmly send the person home for the day and dock billable hours accordingly. Report the need to have done so to your immediate supervisor and HR. Show the person that won't tolerate bad behavior. If you can, make a condition for return to work the next day a meeting with you and a HR person where you lay down the "rules" for working in your department.

by nickinsd2004

You are her supervisor. You need to let her know that. Take her into a quiet room and set her down. Explain that fact to her. Her actions are bordering on insubordination and could be starting an open rebellion in the workplace. After you deal with her I would suggest a department meeting and lay down the law. If anybody has any complaints they should bring them to you. Find out how much support you have from your supervisor in dealing with this. If all you have is responsibility but no authority to deal with it I would recommend getting your resume back out there.

by raven2

You are not her friend, you are her manager. Set clear personnal boundaries, set clear team goals, define success, get your team into this process, it does not need to be labourious. If she can not or will not work within those parameters. A) Follow HR policies and move her out. B) Find a recuriter who will place this person into another company. C) You can suffer. Make your choise, do not let circumstances make it.

by zteccc

Managing people involves dealing with more than technical knowledge. It involves dealing with personalities. Still, the point of anyone's job is to do the work.

If a team member does the work better than anyone else, it is generally advisable to keep that team member, but that said, you must keep them in a way that doesn't damage the rest of the team. Case in point, Dennis Rodman was undoubtedly a great rebounder when he played for the Bulls. He also was disruptive, he didn't like to practice or be on time. The deal that the Bulls made with him was to allow him to do whatever he wanted as long as he produced the rebounds. If his performance ever dropped, he'd be required to attend practice on time with the rest of the team. The team practiced with a different rebounder in his position and wasn't negatively impacted by this deal (very important point).
People like this are worth more than the headaches they are causing. Look at your problem subordinate from a purely analytical point of view and decide if she's one of these people. If she is, you would be doing the company a disservice by getting rid of her and instead you need to simply place her in an area where she can excel instead of disrupting (her own office instead of a public setting).

If the team member is not performing, then document everything and work to get rid of them. The old addage that 20% of the people do 80% of the work is very true. It is also true that the bottom 20% of the people do almost no work and yet they require 80% of your management time. If you could cut your staff by 20% (deadwood) and free up 80% of your management time, wouldn't that be worthwhile? Are you doing it? More to the point, if she's part of that 20%, then you'd be doing the company a service to remove her based on job performance. Many managers make the mistake of coaching/mentoring/training these people. This is a waste of time. They're already underperforming, why waste your time trying to make them something that they aren't. Instead, spend that time where it is better served, with the 20% of your staff that are doing 80% of the work. Underperformers are simply a time and resource drain. Get rid of them.

Note that up to this point, I haven't mentioned anything about the complaining and her loudness as a job issue. Frankly, it shouldn't be a JOB issue.

If the person is in the middle 60% (e.g. does the work, but doesn't excel at it). Then you've got to decide what kind of manager you're going to be. First of all, you've described yourself as reserved. That is fine and a reserved person CAN be an effective manager, just don't forget that reserved or not, you are the boss. Many reserved people make the mistake of publicly backing down from a confrontation. This is a huge mistake. All of your staff will see this. Many managers also follow this error with a private conversation with the loud employee. This is a second huge mistake. If you are challenged publicly, you must answer this challenge publicly (you shouldn't do it loudly however, but put steel in your voice, make it clear that your decision is final). This shows the entire team that they cannot get away with this, and it lets them know that you aren't afraid of this loud person. It is very, very important to keep it about business. Don't make it personal. This is work, so personal feelings or attitudes don't come into play. If you keep it entirely about business, you won't have to worry about the subordinate complaining to HR because she won't have a business case.

Remember you aren't your employee's friend, you aren't there to be chatty. You are there to get a job done and to make sure that they get the job done. Focus on getting the job done.

If social chatting is leading to bitching, then don't allow it (you're the boss, remember?). If the weekly meetings are turning into a free-for-all, then change the agenda and don't open the floor (you're the boss, remember?). If being nice isn't working, simply give her directives (keep it business), and expect her to accomplish them (you're the boss, remember?). If she acts like she knows things, then give her assignments that require that knowledge (keep it business), and expect her to accomplish them (you're the boss, remember?).

Above all, she, and all of your suboordinates need to remember (as do you) that you are the boss. That should carry a certain amount of respect, but it won't come easy. You have to earn it from some people. Do you work. Show that you can do all of their tasks (if you can't then learn how), roll up your sleeves and get your hands dirty to help out (especially to help her out). Don't back down on policy or lose face in public (arguing in front of them and don't try to be their friends (you may have to fire one of them at some point and being their friend first makes it look like you are willing to backstab your friends). It is time to step up and be a manager.

-- Jeff

by keyguy13

There are plenty of Canadians that have the kind of common sense that AMCOL possesses. And plenty of Americans that have the "be nice" and be walked all over mentality too.

Sometimes you HAVE to be a little aggressive as AMCOL suggests.

I mean, he didn't suggest berating her in font of everyone else, nor did he suggest anything inappropriate. You just flamed him without any support whatsoever for how you would handle it. In essense, all you did was whine and critisize him.

How does your appoach help this guy with his problem?

You sound like the lady he should fire...

by hcream

Sounds like she is going through an adjusting period. In addition of being insecure and defensive, she may also feel like being micro-managed.

Instead of getting into the trap of proving who's right and who's wrong, you should focus on the task and schedule.

by the admiral

An impossible employee is always a challenge, granted, but you have to understand coming from a technical area that you are now in a management position, and the company expects you to fulfill your obligations for that position. There are a few steps that you should take when dealing with ?Loud Larry? or, in your case, ?Loud Lisa?.

First, you have to understand that he or she is an intimidator. These are the people who will air their dirty laundry to everyone to make you look like the bad apple, when you are being as nice as humanly possible. This is the person who can and will disrupt the entire nature within your company. As with any intimidator, they drag a lot of baggage with them such as hate, deceit, trickery, and will disrupt the normal flow if they can. These are also people who tend to get on the nerves of other people, but because the other people are either afraid of being termed the rat, not a team player, or told that it is a problem with them, they just look and not say a word. Their ego is bigger than their education or in some cases their common sense.

Second, the intimidator is a very ambitious person. It is your job as a manager of this person to understand the reason why they are loud and ambitious by having a formal one-on-one with each person and determine their goals in their career, and understand your role in allowing them to reach those goals. But the intimidator is out for their own good, and not that of the team. I have often told management when I was in that position that you can not play as a team if you are the only one playing on it. When you look at their actions, you will see that their history shows that they have done everything to benefit their own goals and objectives.

Third, these kind of people attempt to dominate everyone around them, and at some point in time will to some extent, the important part is that you can manage these people. You, being the manager and new, were probably caught like a deer in the headlights and were caught off guard, making yourself an easy target. What they will do is dominate based on becoming the center of attention, having in their own mind that they need to be the center of the universe.

Fourth, you have to understand that these types of people are the kind who lack self-control needed to keep their impulses in check. They lack the internal controls to keep their actions, or control their actions, the same about compulsive liars, thieves and obsessive compulsive behavior.

Here is how to manage the people that the intimidator reaches:

First, observe the interactions between the intimidator and the targeted employee. Determine if this may be a case or teasing, or pulling a chain or if the intimidator is harassing or bullying the target employee.

Second, listen to the company grapevine. This is the all-out indicator as to what is going on, what everyone is saying, and gives you and idea as to how the other employees feel. This is NOT a place to start taking action, it is only a milestone mark as to where you need to go from now.

Third, look for signs of tardiness, absentees, or a lack of drive from other employees or wanting to leave, transfer out, or change shifts to get away from dealing with the intimidator.

Fourth, check to see if people are having problems that they can not explain such as sweating/shaking, feeling/being sick, sleep deprivation, loss of appetite, anxiety or depression or even symptoms of withdrawing from the team such as irritability, withdrawn or aggressive or defensive, or signs of alcohol abuse.

If all of these shows that the person has done something that would be construed as intimidation by the person, then you need to take steps to stop it.

Have a private meeting with the employee with a peer manager. This meeting can occur at any time, but it is important that you follow these items:

1. Look the employee in the eye
2. Talk slowly and surely to ensure that what you are saying is being heard.
3. Do not raise your voice or conduct yourself in an aggressive manner.
4. Do not allow the intimidator to become loud or the situation gets out of hand.
5. Take control over the environment.

At the start of the meeting tell the intimidator what you have observed and been made aware of through different avenues. This puts everyone on the same level, and it puts the ball in their playing field. Then tell them where you stand or the company stands when it comes to harassment and the possibility of what be perceived as harassment or violence in the workplace and how their actions or their unintended meanings of words fall under those areas. Explain to them that as a leader of the group that you may be forced by the corporate guidelines to take actions such as suspension, demotion, transfer or removal against them to remedy the situation. As the manager you must be straightforward in your approach to the problem, don?t be politically correct and beat around the bush, since that tends to take the edge of seriousness away from the problem. Focus your energies on correcting the poor behavior!!!

As a manager it is up to you to advise them in how you want to see their attitude change toward a more team focused environment and that you will assist them in getting to sensitivity classes or anger management or other counseling. In some companies, they offer counseling for issues such as this.

It is important that you keep this professional and not show any emotion such as disgust or anger toward the employee, but talk very firmly. No matter what their excuse is, ensure that you re-enforce that:

? Such behavior does not have anyone?s interest at heart
? Affects the company?s bottom line by putting undue pressure on others.
? Lowers Morale to a point where people don?t care about their job.
? People do go postal over situations because of the added pressure
? That all employees have the right to dignity, and that everyone has principles as to how they act toward one another.
? No one has the right to inject their subjective intervention in relation to their privacy, home, family or employment.

These items may stick in there for a little bit, but you have to persevere in making sure that at meetings their voice is heard when it comes to how to further the team. You also have to be vigilant in that anyone else in management does not become targets of the intimidator.

When the meetings are done, then have the peer manager meet with you on how well you performed, have him or her critique what you said and if they have any other constructive comments about your situation. That gives you an idea about how to handle situations later on as well.

The important thing is to keep it high level and not a shouting match. Then, after the meeting, the person can then decide what their next move is. Then schedule sensitivity training for the entire team, not just for the intimidator. You then build the team.

If the behavior continues, you can then have the same peer manager come in and sit down to re-enforce what you stated above, and if it is not working out, it is time to get HR involved.

When it is all done and over with, you will look honest, fair, and someone your employees can look up to be unbiased when other situations come up.

by keyguy13

You tell her that you would rather she "shut the h*ll up" and the next time she has the urge to correct you, to count to 10 and then stuff that urge way down.

Then after a few months, when you know she's gonna pop, go on vacation. In a few days you can come back to see the carnage.

That'll teach her...

by Former member

This is what happens when you have a heirarchy that is forcedly enforced. Some people end up alienated. I've also seen companies hire people much younger that take over, over a person twice their age that has been there for a few years. It seems that the older people get upset (and in a way you can't blame them) because they were passed up for the promotion. It's like being told they are not 'smart' enough or 'young' enough. In some instances, it even DOES mean they're about to get forced into an 'early retirement' which means a LOT less retirement money than they would ordinarily get. These are all valid, and unfortunately very real concerns with older workers, esp. the over-40 workers who, if they lose their job, will have a very difficult finding another job that will appreciate their years of accumulated skills and on-the-job experience.

Younger managers should at least be considerate of the older person's years of service in the company and the possibility that they are reacting (though not actually saying) on their fears of a job loss or loss of appreciation of their years of service.

Be a TEAM player, not just a manager. Include everyone, young or old, equally in their jobs and make them ALL feel they are appreciated, even the older workers. In fact, even though you don't like treating people special, sometimes little things that will go noticed only by the older worker but not by the younger workers might make a big difference. A compliment here and there in their presence but not in front of others may even help. Backing away from them like the plague may make them feel even more unappreciated and they will try harder to somehow 'prove' their worth to you and the company, fearing that they are not 'good enough' otherwise.

That said, the other side of the coin could be that the reason you're manager and not her is because of her behavior. Some people naturally are just like that.

I of course don't know the whole situation. But if she's just 'like that' then there's nothing that can be done about it. You can't change someone who doesn't want to change. It'll only make things worse. But, if it has to do with the fear of a job loss due to age, etc. then maybe the above suggestions of not alienating the employee may also help.

Next time she says something, say maybe just as loud maybe something like, "You know, I think you may have something there. I was just thinking the same thing!"

Get into the team spirit. Might make things easier for you and everyone around you. :)

by wje_jr

This is going to be hard to do for you being a quite type of person. Your going to have to get used to confrontation. Politely take the offending person in a conference room and close the door. Explain to her that any more bullshit like this continues and you will rip her up publicly like she is ripping you up publicly. And end it with "do we have an understanding"
And then offer her a hand shake and ask "do we start with a clean slate or is the fight on?"

by lsa

This is your problem. She's causing a great deal of discontent and discomfort, but you've got yo nip it. This will continue to eat away at the group unless you stop it.
Written counselling with her signature showing she's been counselled and acknowledges it may stop it. If she sees you ain't kiddin' around anymore, she may stop after realizing she's not in charge. And if she doesn't stop, then you have ammo to stop her dead in her tracks.

by lsmith1989

I agree, every situation is unique and there is no step by step solution but in this case, I would rule with an iron fist.

Walk quietly but make sure you swing a BIG STICK.

by tape monkey

You need to start being the manager of your department. Your job is to manage your people. Get this issue under control before the negative atmosphere destroys department moral. Pull her aside and discuss what the real root of the challenge is. I would set up a discussion time with HR as an intermediate.This will also eliminate a "he said" she "said issue".Are you adapting to relate to her or is your ego trying to muscle her around? What is your non-verbal body language saying? If she has been there as long as you say she has, don't you think that job performance would have been an issue some time ago? If I was your supervisor I would be writting you up for not keeping your department in order. You might find that in putting your finger on the issue that there are three fingers pointing back at you.Maybe you need to re-evalueate your management skill sets. Document everything it is your only source of back-up.

by wdickerson

The following have worked for me in similiar situations.

1. Why is there a problem if your are the manager? You can let her begin her own downfall. Document, document, document. Emails with date/time. Other incident or events dates, times, names. What you did. Her response. Submit you complaint through HR channels. Follow up.

2. Kindness also kills the behavior. After a time this person will actually feel bad about the way she treat you. Self guilt, human nature or whatever you call it. Being reserved has its strong points.

3. Ignore her. Continue your normal routine. If you do not give her the attention, she will really look stupid. Good luck with this.

by jmgarvin

Ignoring the problem will not make it go away!!!! You must face this or there will only be resentment and backstabbing on the team.

by bilcook

It is entirely possible that the company emerging from a ch.11 is asking some of the personell to wear more than 1 hat. Trust me I have a desk full of them. I am the cad manager, lead draftsman, MIS guy, and tech support guy. I recently had a superior who was ok but did not know 1/2 of what I know and we did most definately clash. I tore this guy a new rear end more than once. We did eventually form a pretty good working relationship, that relationship ws based on him finally realising that I was more than qualified to do his job, and myself realising that he was just trying to do his job to the best of his ability. He was also one of those people who had a "better" or "different" way of doing things. When we both sat down for an honest and wide open discussion it straightened out a lot of things. The most important thing that got straightened out was his admission that not all of his ideas were "better" and he actually started to understand and except my "mentoring". Not sure if this approach will work for the original poster, but it worked great in my case.

by jmgarvin

A happy and trusting employee is just as able to produce (or not) as an unhappy and untrusting employee.

The question is bigger than that, but in the large picture, productivity is only tied to itself.

While I personally like my workers to be happy and relaxed, I also know that it doesn't mean they are automatically more productive.

I also agree this is quite off course and has NOTHING to do with what the posters needs.

by timaross

I am a union steward. What I would do in her case would be to have a private conversation with her and ask why she keeps on undermining your authority in the work unit and disrupting the team. I suspect her problem may be a sense of insecurity, a feeling that you are not as qualified as she believes you should be, or she just may be a toxic employee. If you can work out an agreement with her as to what is and is not appropriate behavior, good. If not, I would advise her that your conversation will be documented and held by you and any further actions perceived as undermining your authority will have disciplinary action taken for insubordination with our documentatin used to support the action. Then when and if she does it again, you would ask her to come with you into a private setting and go to whatever step of discipline your human resource guidelines suggest.

by ellemoj

I think it is interesting how most IT managers are excellent technical people who are promoted for doing a good job. Unfortunately that usually means they lack the management skills to look after people. Sure managing technical people can often be eaiser as you can all relate, but those with a different outlook can be daunting!

Sure this woman sounds like a real cow, but I think what you need is a mentor - someone who is not in the IT structure, who can coach you on the people side of management. Someone who has the respect of his peers and his staff. Someone who has had to fire people for not doing their job. Someone who has a good 10 years in management.

There's some good advice from what I have read in the posts. Beating up on her sounds like a good option, but just be careful there isn't a really good reason why she is behaving this way. That's why I think you should get the advice of someone in your company who understands the culture, HR processes, and what to do.

by jmgarvin

This is a YOUNG manager who is being attacked on purpose and with possible malice by a subordinate.

People KNOW how to act in a business environment, but this one just wants to push buttons and perhaps is jealous.

The manager is a victim of someone who is acting out ON PURPOSE. People are responsible for their actions...including the subordinate.

by jcarmona

You need to counsel this employee on her disruptive behavior. Engage the support of your HR department and document all sessions. If her behavior does not improve, you have no choice to terminate her with cause.

by rcojuangco

Do it by the books. If she performs below par, is causing undue stress to others & is not a team player, termination is the best option.

by bosston

Just remember to let her know who the boss is. She may have done things differently at a previous job but your place of employment may be run differently from where she has worked.

by edward_carpenter

Sounds like she likes an audience - Change the environment. You have been in the IT world long enough to start using the tools of your trade to your advantage. In an ideal world word of mouth would be enough but in the real world it fosters misunderstanding and daily arbitrations, roadblocks, and frustrations. You say you are the employees (documented) superior - if that?s the case - then take control. First start using written communications. Psychologically the written word (Email) makes people think about what is being conveyed without the verbal babble/battle. The use of email also fosters accountability on both the employee and the supervisor. Care needs to be observed especially on your part ? conveying facts and not emotions should be the rule. Tasks should be assigned as finitely as possible. Rebuttals and questions should be conveyed in the same manner. In addition to the added thought process and the accountability brought on by email use, it also records "at the time facts" necessary should you have to take action, counseling or dismissal, against the employee at a later date. Finally, I worked in government service for nearly 40 years. I that time I worked for and managed both older and younger individuals. I never allowed my personal or professional ethics to be compromised and neither should you. I have been in your position and dealt with the same crap. Keep your motives pure and ?Document, document? Feel free to reply.

BOL,
ejc

by macghee

Read Amcol's post. He's right on target. Do what he says in his post, in conjunction to talking to your HR manage and following the HR procedure so you don't leave yourself open to legal liability.

by stooobeee

I would like to commend you for restraining your anger; it is easy to want to retaliate. But you are a human being first, who must already realize that you are no better than anyone else. This is a wise and humble attitude to have. Out of respect for each other's frailities and insecurities, it is important to remember that you too have your own.

However, along with this given human characteristic, you have also been called to lead in a leadership position. In a sense, you are two people in one, and you must know when to act like merely a man of compassion for someone's needs and someone who can act the role of manager. As a leader in his field, you have a role to lead, and that is what you must do to gain a subordinate's respect. Playing the fence because of shyness or ignorance cannot make your role easier, only more difficult. No one is exempt from learning, including leaders.

Call her aside, and let her know that you will not embarrass her as she has embarressed you. It is important to act like a manager and remain friendly, without the desire to get even. If you do, you will be like her. You must use restraint. Tell her that you are aware of her behavior, and site examples. It is necessary to provide times and dates so that she will see undeniably that she has responded and acted inappropriately. Ask her if there are things about your behavior towards her that are possible causes of any friction. Be open and listen to her; if she is right, you must be willing to make changes yourself---first you, then she---in that order. Next, ask her how she believes she can change her "posture" in the company. Document your meeting---what you observe, the changes agreed upon...etc. Let her know what you are doing and be upfront. Explain that you and she have a chance to be on good terms, and that you would like that to happen, but if there is an unwillingness on her part to implement any agreed upon changes, you must be willing to further address the situation. Thank her for her time and see how she responds. If she does what is right, you have taken a positive step forward. If not, call her back into the office. Once you have acted as a manager, and she as well as others see this, you will feel freer to take the next step.

Your letter indicates that although you may know your stuff technically, you must also be willing to learn how to manage. If there is a course available, I strongly urge you to take it, and do not keep it a secret. Others will see that you are learning also, that you are willing to do what it requires of your position, and that if you are willing, so must others be.

You have a real chance to crystalize good relationships. Take it!

by martinez

Do not take this seriously

-Kill the mother fucker.
-Get a voodoo doll.
-When the guy goes home at night, put a bag on his head and nab her.
-Go near her and fart excessively.
-Blow your nose and offer to show the contents of your kleenex to her.
-Stare at her for a while, then announce You're one of THEM! and move to the far corner of the room.

by beoweolf

Either do you homework better, so that you can address the opinions, procedures that your employee brings up...or...make use of all your resources, enlist her help (before) in forming your plans. Getting her input on a proposal doesn't detract from your stature...just make sure the final decision is your own, based on input from as many sources as you can gather.

This will serve several purposes; hopefully you will get a new ally, you will give her some recognition, in a private way, that her opinions are valuable...it will give you the high ground if/when she acts out in a public team meeting. You can rightfully remind her that you gave her an opportunity to review the action, but your decision was not to go that way. If she wants to discuss it further, bring it up "after" the meeting where she can expand on the idea more and offer any reasons that she didn't mention when you gave her the chance "before".

Then explain, that until you have a chance to evaluate any new information...you would like to get on with the meeting and plan on getting things done in the way and as scheduled in the meeting notes. (You are presenting agendas and written outlines for the meeting?) Meeting are not a place to make plans, they are for detailing plans,imparting information and announcing decisions. There should be very few suprises or new/extended discussion in a well planned meeting.

by eelder1

Send her to school and tell why she is going. Tell her she needs to develop tact and that if she doesn't makes some changes in her behavior, it will be reflected in her annual evaluation. She is being insubordiante, stop her in her tracks.

I she can bully you, she will bully others. You don't need to put up with this. You are the boss.

by thomasdelora37

The main thing would require this mgr to respect the employee, have Union rep and HR meet with all parties in neutral territory. After getting Air cleared, set the rules applying to employee & mgr. document the process. If after this meeting, employee is rude and obnoxious, use doc's to make her unemployed.

by rm3mpc

You're the manager. Act like it. Take her aside (out to lunch if
you have to) and explain a few facts of life. Her behavior is
inappropriate. You'd like to deal with it in the most positive ways
possible, BUT... let there be no doubt, you'll be filling out her
evaluation, deciding her salary increase, assigning her work and
determining her promotability, and if it comes to that, you'll be
the one terminating her.

by guardianoz

The first thing you need to do is MANAGE.
Look at the value of the employee and ascertain if she is an asset or liability to the company.

It will be very easy if she is a liability, because you can simply commence by awarding her with a verbal warning, then written warnings then show her the door.
Problem solved.

If she is an asset to the company, than you need to manage her effectively.
Sometimes empowering staff with more senior duties can make them snap into line. It?s a good way to delegate your work and further enhance your own managerial skills.

You could also talk with her, explaining that she is a valued employee and that others in the team look up to her for guidance, so you need her to work with you more professionally to help the team develop.

You could ask her if you have her respect as a manager. You will need to word it in a way that you can only get a yes or no answer (no fence sitting).
If she says yes, then ask her to commit to her statement, being more professional in her mannerism towards you in public view, as positive and negative actions in front of the team will influence their behavior.
Also let her know that at any time she can address issues with you privately where you can address these in more detail.

If she says no, then ask her what you need to do to earn her respect and then commit to earning her respect.

Whilst it may appear that you are going to be doing all of the work to resolve the issue that she has created, you can rest assured that you are simply managing a situation and then making someone else commit to meeting you half way.

In the words of a great:
HOW TO WIN FRIENDS AND INFLUENCE PEOPLE.
Dale Carnegie

I strongly suggest that you pick yourself up a copy of this book (how to win friends and influence people).

by soupy

It's all been said already,but I disagree with asking if you have her respect,only in the sense that if she says no,you find out what you can do to earn it,and commit yourself to it.Forget that.I've dealt with this type as a professional athlete,coach,sales manager and IT manager,and they all come out the same.Out the door,following HR and other guidelines noted already,and your team's spirit will soar.
Should you try to appease her you will lose respect from some of the people that now back you.YOU are HER boss..Don't let the tail wag the dog.

by kb0lkt1

Your post is and has been my phylosophy about good Management/Supervisory/Leadership. We are all working for the same purpose; and that is making the establishment work better to make a profit for our owners. Still one must be strong in leadership.

It took me a few setbacks of my own and a hard look at my skills but made me a better leader/manager.

by saruvindan

Well,

Dispute her casually on her 1x1. Change the context and subject if you think that she wants to show off by raising her voice. Casually put a word to your manager.

Be asertive. If you think what she does is not the way it is supposed to be, tell her politely, "your idea may be right, but I would like to do this way, and that way I can answer to my higher ups and can achieve our team's goal"

The thumb rule usually is; accept in disguise!!

If things persists and affects your performance, then take things in writings like others suggested. I don't know if this would help in your situation, but it did for me though.

by mcac007

I understand your problem however sometimes being nice and mentoring is something that doesn't work so follow the conduct code of your company. If she is being loud than ask her to keep her voice down because of other staff members. However, I caution you once you start go down this path you may run in to sexual discrimination or other issues make sure your treatment is the same for your whole team. Also, as for the jabs at you this may be another issue. My former boss used to say, "If you can't respect the person, respect the position." You need to help her understand this concept. Good luck

by anands

I would suggest the following:
-Get her a 360 degree feedback and then coach her on the inappropriate behaviour
- It is also possible that the way you engage her nay need to be modified. You amy want to set-up a one-on-one counselling session when you can share your expectations and understand her needs in a open and constructive environment.
-

by chrispeebits

I've been in this situation on numerous occasions and would love to assist!
1. You do not have to put up with it...make that very clear to the individual...I normally do this sort of thing in my office and keep my voice in dulcet tones...when they get madder...you get softer with your voice.
2. Decide with the help of your peers (HR Manager etc) whether or not this person deserves thier job. If YES... then put some time in and show 'em that you care...chances are they have been neglected and never cared for as an employee...they then see someone come into your role...that they think they could do themselves...YEAH RIGHT...but that's how they think...and they get angry...and sometimes that is bad for you, them and the team...Give them a time frame to get back on track...1 month to turn themselves around...Be honest and tell them youre not happy with their behaviour...etc...
If NO... put them on the "AEP" (Anyhelpwouldbegreat Exit Program)... work with HR to set goals that are achievable that you know they cant achieve because their behaviour wont allow it! Any slip ups... Get rid of them...
Just be 110% clear on what you need them to do and that they are clear you, and the HR dept, are watching...

Anyway...hope this helps

CP

by sugadaddy

I guess most people in management positions have at some stage been challenged by one or more of their staff in some form or another. The question you have to ask yourself is whether or not you are management material. The skills required of someone in a supervisory position will determine the actions or behaviour of your staff. If it isn't obvious to some staff then it is your responsibility to pull them up and make it undeniably clear that demonstrating that sort of behaviour is not welcomed. If your intentions / boundaries are not clear to the person, it will continue. Like others have recommended, it is best done in an area away from the other staff as the immediate environment will impact on the dynamics and the outcome of any given situation. There are ways of addressing this behaviour without having to stoop to a level they are comfortable with.

by philip.wang

One way is to talk to her directly on her loud voice and explain her your expectation.
The other is try to speak as loud as she can.

by rsearson

First, you need to understand that your situation is not unique, that it has been experienced by most new managers and some experienced ones too. However, after noting that, it's time for you to step back and understand what your role is as manager: it is not to be the best or brightest individual worker, but to be the person who gets the highest performance out of those whom you manage. It is your job to address this situation. Thus far you have backed away from this responsibility, only making the situation worse and decreasing the productivity of your team.

The most effective approach to managing people is to understand your role as "manager as coach." In that role you hold your people accountable for work results and work behaviors. My guess is that your subordinate with the behavioral problem also has a work performance problem, and that may be the place to start. You should plan a meeting with her to discuss a specific work issue. The meeting should be in your office, not in the open work area. You should focus on the work itself, its unacceptable level, and not on the person (or it will quickly degrade into a "personality conflict," which is non-productive). Be clear about the outcomes you want from the meeting, and be sure you have her agreement and commitment about how she is going to correct the work issue. Do not allow yourself to be stuck with the next action being yours when the meeting is over. When you have those types of meeting a few times, and you feel more comfortable conducting them, and she is getting the message that you are the boss and you will not accept poor work, it's time to have the meeting about her negative behaviors. Again, focus on the behaviors and their results on the team and productivity (message is, "you're not bad, but some of your behaviors are").

There are a number of good books about management coaching. I suggest you get one or two and read them carefully as preparation for you becoming a manager coach. Then jump in and do it. Remember, this has nothing to do with age or gender; it has everything to do with understanding the difference in your roles and her lack of performance. If through coaching she just doesn't get it, then she has to go, another difficult but necessary manager responsibility.

Good luck.

by rolliemerrick

There are two types of leaders - ordained and earned. It sounds like your "problem employee," even after a year, has not "accepted" your leadership. Additionally, she MUST add some value or she would have been caught in the ?rightsizing.?

Could it be perhaps that YOU have not accepted her apparent "earned" leadership? Feel threatened? Furthermore, it is up to you to maximize the effectiveness of your team. Are you leaving someone out because of her obnoxious ways? If so, you are only hurting the team and your leadership?

Unfortunately, she is experiencing some sort of ?pain? and it is your job to figure out what is causing her behaviors and helping her. Have you tried inviting her into your ?inter circle? validating her perceived worth? It?s always better having an ally than a sniper working for you.

If you want job security - become a student of leadership! Some good books (both by Maxwell) are:
The 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership
The 17 Irrefutable Laws of Teamwork
IT people are now a dime a dozen but true leaders are valued at EVERY company!

It?s up to you!

Rollie Merrick
Corporate Sales Trainer
MCI
rollie.merrick@mci.com

by bizzo

From what you've said in your posts, you sound very similar to a manager I used to have (until I left).

Maybe she just doesn't like you? Not necessarily a bad reflection on either of you, you just don't get on.

So you're telling us that you "come from an IT background, am used to managing younger peers, and am highly educated". Are you one of those managers who looks down their noses at people who don't have degrees or professional qualifications? Remember Dilbert's "Certification Man"? Our manager was just like that, had all the qualifications, but couldn't rebaseline a PC to save his life. You also comment on her knowledge as "snippets", just because she learnt them on the job, does not mean that they are worth less than your classroom learnt material.

She may miss "obvious things that are staring her in the face", but don't we all once in a while? Especially when we're too close to a problem?

You're making your feelings very clear here, you don't like the woman. Maybe she can pick up on that and resents the attitude you take with her and so trys to trip you up, a bit of public embarrassment?

In another of your posts you mention that she pulled you up when you were putting memory away, and that you'd been tidying a stock room. Hang on, I thought managers got paid the big bucks to manage people, not to tidy stock rooms and store inventory. I know I didn't like it when my manager did things like that, especially when I was sat twiddling my thumbs for a day waiting for him to allocate work to me, whilst he was reorganising our stock rooms.

I apologise for not having any solutions for you, but resolution *might* be within your grasp, because maybe you just have to change your attitude.

by anyhelpwouldbegreat

I have nothing against learning on the job. I have a number of friends that I respect for gaining experience in this way.

I think a number of issues are from not having the resource, and this causes stress, and in turn attitudes.

I took on ordering as, like so many things, I didnt think it fair to load it onto her. And, it was something she said she didnt want to do, due to being too busy.

by mombasadog

I assume it is not just a personality clash between you and her. Often longer serving members of a company become embittered when an "outsider" joins especially in a more senior position, they use their inside experiential knowledge to undermine the new guy (You!), it is a difficult time for all concerned. These days its best to discuss the situation with HR ( if you have an HR department ). Highlight her failings and formally construct either a recovery process or ( as I think is more likely in this case...) an exit strategy for her, both need to be fair and based on measurable objectives and I certain this can include work behaviour concerns, which can disrupt team harmony. In my experience the embittered person will either reform or become much worse during the final stages of tenure! Be prepared for a backlash if she is well liked by the rest of the team. Often when the offending person is gone, calm returns quickly and you can build on this.

by mbatty

There have been lots of good postings on how to manage this person. Before you start, analyse what she does that pushes your buttons. What is it in you that makes you so uncomfortable? Does this replay some behaviour in your past that makes you back off? Once you understand yourself and your own feelings you will be able to implement the best approach to resolving the situation between you.

Once you are clear on your feelings, then be clear on what aciton you will take.

Good luck.

by marc b.

Tell her that because she is so smart, you have finally gotten her that long overdue promotion. (Put her in charge of a few other team members, but still reporting to you.) But also tell her that since she is so smart, if she makes but one mistake she will be fired.

by the_m0nk

I'm a football (soccer) referee, and I have to deal with a load of difficult situations. I've recently learnt that some people are just out to be as difficult as possible. In this case why not invite this person along to the next issue that you have and ask them to help you solve the issue, as you "Would like to benefit from their expertise". Instead of negative critism why not ask for positive feedback, as you want to be better at your tasks.

by wildaniels

There are a lot of good ideas, and I would offer another. Focus on job performance. It is easier to focus the employee (and ultimately your HR paperwork) on performance. Behavior can be debated too easily. ("you misinterpreted what I did/said, i didn't mean it that way.")
for example:
you said "Some memory came in - usually i take them out of their boxes and put them into dedicated central boxes. I got the "i'd rather you did'nt do that". "
Put a policy in place that says: when inventory arrives, it is recorded and placed into dedicated central boxes.
Now, train your staff on the new procedure, and you have a point of docuementation that cannot be disputed. Just be prepared to hold all staff accountable for this performance standard. You are the manager, set performance standards and hold your staff accountable. It will result in more reliable performance.

by mary.a.dempster

would not have taken that kind of crap from any of them. Fortunately, I did not have too. If I was in your shoes, I would write up a warning, detailing everything that has happened. Call your HR person and go over it with them first to make sure everything is just right. Then sit down with her and explain the problem,and the process you are initiating with her because nothing else has worked. You are the manager and unless you come across as a leader, you will never get the respect and cooperation from this person you need to have a good department. The way I see it, she is trying to make you fail. Don't let her.

by mary.a.dempster

amcol, I agree with everything you said. The only thing you did not add is that this issue has gotten to the dangerous point. HR must be consulted so that the steps that are taken are letter perfect. This is the type of person that would cause a big stink. It is a shame it's gotten this far,but it can definately be a learning experience for this young manager.

by libbo

Zen, I personally wish we had more take charge leadership in the world. When you establish "absolutes" you are letting your people know exactly what you expect of them.

An effective manager needs a combination of authoritarian and participative leadership styles to say the least, but I think the target of your last reply was being very clear about why he/she would be so firm: The disruptive employee is out of control.

"Managers are people who do things right, while leaders are people who do the right thing."

by texas_gal

Give her a project that she can do while her regular duties are slow. Something that makes her feel valued, but that she can't necessarily do any damage with. Then remember to let her be right in this area. Only discuss other things with her if there is a real problem you can't avoid talking to her about. Document every conversation you have with her. Don't let her goad you into any conversations/confrontations you did not initiate, unless she comes to you verbalizing her desire for your help. Keep control of all situations you find yourself in with her. If it takes letting her be right, and there is no harm, let her be right. It may seem counterintuitive, but it makes you look good to do that.

by avid

you need to find out if her animosity is personal or something else. i suggest simply asking her. maybe she feels like you took the job that she should have gotten. sounds like she has been there longer. also, if you are shoving your education down everyone's throat, then stop. i am not saying that you are, mind you. but it sounds like you have a degree and she does not. or she has a lesser degree. as far as the "obvious" things she is missing, solutions to problem appear different from different points of view. do not discount her point of view if you want her to consider yours. finally, if this does not work, talk to the person responsible for hiring you. they are likely to have more insight into this persons behaviour than you will have. if she is as bad as you say, this can't be the first time she has had a problem with an authority figure.
best of luck,
avid

by jamurray

You must confront the employee. If not, she will continue to manipulate you. Whether consciously or not, she has a goal to discredit you and maybe even to drive you to the point of leaving. When you know you are right, stand your ground! You don't have to get as loud as she is. Talk at a normal level. Do your best to remember that any embarrassment in the situation should be hers, not yours. I lived through a similar situation in my first management position. I listened to the position of the person (no matter how trying it was at times) and responded with what I knew to be right. The decisions were mine to make as the manager. That person eventually resigned, not being able to "manage" me. One other thing, do the best you can with whatever evaluation tools you have to document the things she misses. This physical record of performance may temper her outbursts. I wish you the best.

by tom.lee

This reply is dead on.

One other thing you may wish to look into is that many HR groups have supervisor training to confront and deal with difficult employees (like that would ever happen).

It's better th learn this early in your career instead of later.

by tom.lee

These types of situations can be difficult and it is important to note that you must first start by being honest with yourself. You must make sure that that everything stays professional and you don't make it personal. She may have a problem with your age or something else about you that rubs her the wrong way so you do have to consider if there is anything you are doing that might be making the situation worse. The was any employee that I used to have to work with that was very abrasive and people would often tune him out. After one particular incident I realized that if I had listened to the content of what he was saying instead of the tone then I might hear something I needed to know.

That being said, she must also realize that at the end of the day you are still the supervisor. This is what can make supervisory jobs the most distasteful and it strikes me as ironic that we often aspire to move into such positions and take on such unpleasentness to do less of the creative work that made us want to take a technical career path in the first place.

This is all part of being a supervisor and there will always be unpleasent subordinates to deal with so you better learn to deal with them now.

Good luck.