Discussion Locked

More gamer geeks to vote? Xbox Live allows voters to register for U.S. elec

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I see two sides to the following article, posted on the Australian PAL Gamers Network website. (there are other similar/identical articles on CNet and others).

The aim is to get young voters to the polls, one site noting that young voters would have a tendency to vote for Obama.

1) It is a good idea to encourage young voters
to register and get to the polls BUT...
a) Will they be informed and qualified to cast a ballot?
b)If they are avid war gamers, would there not be more of a tendency to support the war? (making the Obama comments/hopes backfire)
c)Will they simply form peer groups of online friends that all vote one way or another to vote OPPOSITE enemy teams online?

I think youths SHOULD be encouraged to vote, but perhaps this is not teh right avenue. They also note that they are encouraging bands of another website to get fans to vote. Again, doesn't that just mean that a bunch of youths will be voting for the party simply because other fans of the band have? (Which I can honestly see being very Democratic favoured as artists and musicians generally vote for the Democratic Party "All we are saaaaaying, is give peace a chance")

http://palgn.com.au/article.php?id=12570&title=Xbox+Live+allows+voters+to+register+for+U.S.+election

SO while promoting youth voting is a good thing, isn't educating them important too? Should an very strong emphasis be placed on the importance of those votes so that youths will actually think about it before jumping on a 'me too' bandwagon?

EDIT: As it is clear that my post was either unclear or people simply do not read properly, I must clarify.

This is NOT a way to vote electronically or online. This is just s way to encourage youths to vote and a way for them to register as voters, they still must visit a voting booth and cast a ballot just like anybody else.

20 replies

by the scummy one

several scenarios that you posted ran through my mind.
Now, instead of figuring out who to vote for, they may just pause the game for 5 min. to vote, and then go right back to it! LOL -- how sad would that be?
On the flip side, no long waiting at the voting booths at crunch time! That is, if you trust MS SW to actually put your vote in correctly!

by notsochiguy

The dead still rise (a George Romero documentary on voting in Chicago seems like a natural progression for his films, if you ask me) to cast ballots in the Windy City. Matter of fact, I think the original Mayor Daley has voted for his son in each of the last 4 mayor elections.

Given that, I wouldn't think that a computerized solution, regardless of platform, could be much worse.

:)

by oz_media

This isn't a way to vote, but a way to REGISTEr to vote. It simply enourages people to register and allows them to register online, they still have to go to a voting booth to cast a ballot.

by jdclyde

Clearly, allowing voter fraud greatly benefits the Democrats.

Anytime there is any talk of reform, it is racists? ohhhhhkkkkaaayyyyyyyyy

by oz_media

This is not a voting platform, just a way to register to vote. The system encourages them to vote and they can register to vote, but still need to go and cast a proper ballot.

by the scummy one

inability to read properly when tired... Yes, thats my excuse for the day -- either that or my Religion made me :0

by locrian_lyric

Doesn't mean that any idiot should.

Encouraging people to vote, just for the sake of voting is a wasted effort, IMO.

by notsochiguy

...I was wondering how many young voters Obama turned off by sending a text alert at a little past 3am to announce Joe Biden (nothing says change like a VP candidate that has been in the Senate long enough to have rubbed elbows with John Q. Adams...but I digress).

It seems to me that just about any voter drive of note (Rock the Vote is another that comes to mind, as well as the many that were on my college campus when I was younger) seems to take a liberal slant. Not a complaint, mind you, just an observation.

As for educating the youth as to the importance of voting, I feel there is a lot working against that (for the record, I fully agree that people should walk into a voting booth as well informed as possible). First, it is usually in a party's best interest to indoctrinate someone into the party with as little thought (thoughts=questions=possible dissent) possible; hence the straight-line party ballot. Sport team rooting interests, religious affiliation and party membership are usually determined shortly after birth for many. Second, for first time voters, the process can be somewhat intimidating (there is less tension at DMVs than at local polling places here in Illinois). Also, it is hard to argue that someone's vote truly matters when there are compelling arguments to the contrary. For example, a candidate can win the 12 largest states by a single vote each, and lose every other state by the hundreds of thousands, and still win the election. Finally, the process of the primaries has little semblance to what occurs in the general election (I've heard the premise behind caucuses multiple times, and I still can't help but think they are little more than back-room deals open to the public...well, some public, at least).

Personally, I'd like to see a consistent process between the primaries and general election; as well as electoral votes awarded on the percentage of votes received in a state.

That's my 2 cents.

by tink!

It's good in that it does encourage the youth to vote. However, like you said Oz, they should be educated before they vote. Otherwise, yes I do think it will swing much the way you described - fan bases and friend bases will vote one way just because that's the way the majority is.

They should be made to go through some pages that describe running mates, their views, promises and backgrounds before their registration can even be submitted.

Of course, half of them will just click ok, ok, ok to each page without reading, but at least you can get some to. That's better than sending them [b]ALL[/b] to the booths uneducated.

Baby steps I s'pose. Progress in all the right areas usually is very slow.

by notsochiguy

I was just in the process of typing up a posting about how it would be interesting to have something along the lines of a voting personality test, to help people make an informed decision, when I found something:
http://preview.tinyurl.com/5e9rym

It says I should vote for Ralph Nader.

I'm going to go back, and chance all of my answers, and see if it still prompts me to vote for Ralph Nader (call me skeptical).

:)

by oz_media

First of all, the questions are loaded, they do not offer any explanations or partial agrements where multiple parties fall into teh same mold. You may agree to part of what a party has promised but not fully support it, so a social quiz just doesn't work.

With that aside: I tied. Both at 55% were Cynthia McKinney and Hillary Clinton, who I really don't support at all (uh oh, back to the drawing board), Nader tied in third with Obama and my only Republican was dead last with McCain, probably because of my economic views, being more business focused I support small enterprise and private business quite a lot.

Funny enough though, I found the socialist party was third to last with Brian Moore (just above Mccain). and I am supposed to be from a socialist country and have moved ot what Americans consider a socialist country.

But what we consider socialism is a LOT different than what Americans consider socialism.

by oz_media

I see a major issue with it though.

WHO would be responsible for compiling that information?

If it is the current government, thne it will be biased to their values and accomplishments. If it is the parties themselves, it woudl also be biased.

face it, ALL news and ALL political ramblings are biased.

So what about schools? Just teaching people how to read through and research to find conclusions themselves. But even then, it would be nearly impossible as each teacher would have som epersonal bias, if not a LOT of personal bias.

It's just one of those things; if you had a reliable, third party source, it could work but its not very likely that will ever happen.

by tink!

Getting unbiased info in politics is extremely difficult. That's why I don't pay attention to political commercials, or the emails that circulate around.

Quite frankly, I don't vote. If there was more info available, er UNBIASED info available, I probably would vote. But since most of the media is inundated with one-sided "facts", it's very hard to make a genuine decision.

by notsochiguy

...I just took Scummy's post to mean that the natural progression of using the XBOX to register would be to allow one to cast a vote in the same manner at some point (got the impression from the 'several scenarios' mention).

However, in Illinois (not sure how other states handle this), it is fairly routine to cast ballots via an absentee vote (which is how the bulk of the dead voters cast their selection). So, you could literally register to vote and cast your vote without having to move your duff off of the couch (assuming someone brings you the mail and sends the ballot back for you).

I suppose the next step would be to open this up to the Wii Fit...but in order to register, you actually have to 'walk in place' the same amount of steps it would take to get you from your residence to the nearest place to register! :)

by oz_media

There are many former Americans living in Canada now, and they are really pushed to send in absentee ballots, I know my neighbour does as he moved here from Alabama but still holds dual citizenship.

I still get sent the UKL ballots, but I don't vote for the UK elections anymore, I don't spend enough time there these days to justify making a call for their government. They have to live with it, I don't. While Canada and the UK are VERY closely aligned,culturally and economically, the political issues that really matter are not really shared between the countries. The UK keeps it's government to themselves these days.

by oz_media

Go cast a vote, stand up and be counted, make your mark in time, have your say and all that stuff.!

Simply take interest in BOTH sides of the debate and take each with a grain of salt, there IS truth in their it just takes some work to find it.

McCain AND Obama both have vali dstands on some issues, its just a matter of who is the best liar.

Here's what I do when in the middle.

Obama says XYZ and McCain says ABC.

So do a google search for Obama says XYZ. You'll get all of teh Repulican supporters saying what crap it is and why, investigate.

Then do teh same search and read teh positive, supporting ocmments, again research them for valiaidty and you'll find a fair common ground.

Now do the same for McCain said ABC and so on.

It takes time but I find you wind up with a conclusion that considers what the canididate said, what supporters think of it and what opposers think too. Take all those comments and find out which ones are correct and which are false, a la middle ground! TADA!

But VOTE, even if for 'none of the above', for Christ's sake!

You can be damn sure that all those with a political agenda are going to vote at least you can bring some reality and thought into yours.

by the scummy one

it told me what I already knew -- I hate people and should devote more time to bringing torment to the world!

Looks like I gotta berate more people till they off themselves :^0

This discussion is closed to new replies.