Discussion Locked

Novell Linux and future of Netware

0 helpful
210 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

As a Novell dealer and consultant, it becoming clearer, that Netware is about to become the bastard child of Novell.

I am unsure as to where the pieces of the puzzle lie, in that I am getting mixed signals as to where to turn my expertise (Look, if I am going to have to retool from Netware to Linux, then why not just go M$).
The learning curve is a whole shorter in that I am fairly fluent in the OS anyway and M$ work is plentiful, while Netware is becoming very spotty.
I have had no inquiries about Linux and Novell.

I get more calls for Exchange and Windows admin than I do for Novell these days.
Money talks and I have serious concerns about having to start from ground zero on the tech front with a new product.

I have had little or no help with training on the new Linux stuff, while M$ offers me free (NFR) software (NOT time bombed) and substantial discounted training on their products available nationwide. AND I don?t have to travel hundreds of miles to catch a class someplace out of the way. Lookit, I don?t live in the middle of nowhere, unless the Silicon Valley has made the middle of nowhere list.

Novell needs to convince me that my time, effort and loyalty to their product is worth something, before I make a whole hearted effort to do a 180 on something I have never supported or sold.

210 replies

by djent

Why do you need to choose one or the other? It seems apparent that Linux is already or will be a mainstream technology, embracing it could only benefit you. If Novell's version gets some traction any Linux experiance would be useful. A good mechanic needs a full toolbox and the training to use them.

by mc

I will agree than knowing more than one vendor products is a good idea. I have to know MS products because they are in many places but learning Linux as served me quite well. Because I have Linux experience my current employer is looking at me to lead the Solaris project that we are getting. More training and more fun :-)

I think that putting all your eggs in one basket is too risky to just learn one thing. By knowing Linux and MS Windows it also helps me see strenght in both and were one solution is better than the other.

by prohta

I have to agree that the more you know the more powerful you become. I know Novell - am certified, I know M$ - MCP, and now I will be knowing Linux. My employer thinks that I walk on water because it does not matter what platform he talks about, I can enter the conversation intelligently. He is putting me through night school so that I can learn the Linux platform. How many bosses do you think do that? Usually only the ones that want you to learn what they already have, not what they don't have.

Being a businessman, my boss wants to stop enduring M$ and go to something that is more stable. Every month or more we are hearing about more patches, security breaches, and everything else that is going on in the M$ world. With Linux, I understand that I can lock it down so tight that I can't even get my little finger in there!!

Be good to yourself. Be good for your employer. Don't limit yourself. Remember, knowledge is power!

by oz_media

Well as you are a dealer I assume you've attended the Novell Ximian rollout seminar. It shows the power of Linux incorporated in a Newtare environment. There is no relation to this and standard Linux, there's is NO replation or even close proximity to anything MS offers. This is a benchmark in networking software and office ROI.

Just look at red Carpet and the thousands of bundled features, I'd like to see MS even come close to the same ballpark as this but know they never will.

If you HAVEN'T seen the Novell Ximian Linux for desktops seminar, contact Novell and get the tools at least. I sat with a few fellow netadmins and developer friends at the seminars and all of us watched with mouths open wide, trying not to drool too noticeably. Some of my 'partners' were also MCSE's as well as MCNE's like myself, the MCSE's were shaking thier heads at the amount of onty they had wasted on MS certs when this is going to be thier gravy for years to come now. I have already helped deploy a Novell Linux network with a few associate consultants and the ROI over MS, the power of the software, the ability to handle simultaneous logins and file requests made MS look like a cheapo shareware OS.

if you are simply looking at reviews, articles and the website, get ahold of Novell, this is the best thing that has ever happened to Novell and is something MS will be hard pressed to match even in the next 3 years.

Overall, PHENOMINAL solutions.

by dgenerous1

as a tech that works with both ms, novel, linux, macos and sun. it realy does not matter which you choose to pursue. though linux training will come in handy. ms is on its way out and they know it(hence the battles with lindows)but the software will out-live any of us and speacialists will be required. Dos died over 10years ago but people are still needed to work within the system. the choice will be simple A: learn linux with its extreme learning curve and reap the benifits or B:
go ms and fight with hundreds of other ms qualified techs that want the same job.

by pgm554

I moved back to the Valley a few months ago and from what I can see, the Novell presence here in terms of seminars is no where near what it is in places like DC, Pittsburgh or Philly.

Waltham,Mass. is the Novell center of the universe right now(and maybe the reason seminars are so easy to check out in the northeast) .

Strange, that THE high tech center of the world would be so hostile (or rather ambivalent) to the innovator of one of the classic NOS's of the past 20 years. Everything is situated in Irvine(on the west coast) and the Valley seems an afterthought.
But then again Google uses M$ AD for its infrastructure and Eric Schmidt runs the place.
So go figure.

As for the future, in 3 to 5 years, Novell Linux might be a cash cow, but budgets are built on what is selling now, and my dilemma is not an issue of better technology(Novell has always had that) ,but the bottom line(is it profitable?) .

This is one to ponder.

by oz_media

I live in Port Hardy, the tip of Vancouver Island, and they are in Vancouver a couple of times a year. I have a friend that is running a Netware/Linux seminar nest wekk for his prospects and customers. He is showing them advantages of moving away from Exchange and utilizing full messaging and CRM capabilities of GroupWise on Linux.

It's up to you to create a market I suppose as Novell isn't as aggressive as Microsoft.

Then again, it's the same thing in the audio world, Harman Kardon is very passive compared to JVC yet HK is desired by a more selective and aware audience. If you aren't into the upsell routine, you just have to look harder, but they are there .

by jaxjazzy

I've been using Novell since 2.0 and it like any NOS has come a long way.
I'm in the process of securing MC$E along with my Novell certs because I believe in versitility which begets knowledge and vice-a-versa.
I do think Novell is easier to use and doesn't have a target by hackers on it like M$.

by oz_media

Novell Ximian has been tingly all over. Just the concept, when I heard it some time ago was a fantastic thought, to see what they have done with thier FIRST release is stunning.

There is nothing on the market that even comes remotely close to the cost effective and secure solution they offer. No longer is livencing even a topic of discussion. MS will never equal it, but they will probably try to sway the way people look at a NOS instead.

by thomas.reno

Go MS. It's not perfect but I think it will be there longer than any other options we have at this point. The cost of keeping up with these technologies is quite high and getting to require bandwidth I just do not have anymore.

by mike.tinney

Netware still beats the competion hands down....and has very little attention from Viruses and Hackers...

My guess is that it will be around for many years to come...

Heres hoping anyway....

by haydies

Heres just one little question. What OS is running the Internet? A clue? Its not windows....

Weather Novel Linux is good or bad, there is one hell of a lot of "*nix" machines out there, and a they are more or less the same.

Sure, windows is easy...but then thats why every man and his dog can "set it up" and "build" a network with it. Well, as long as you don't want it to be secure.....

Thing is, windows is the main Corparate OS at the moment, but then Total Cost of Ownership comes in, and a lot of companies are starting to turn away from it.

Personaly, I am betting on Linux. More and more things are going "online" and it seems to me in the long run Linux is going to win out. Windows just costs to much, and is to much of a problem in it self....

by voldar

you are maybe right, but as far as I know, linux has a looooot to improve so that you'll have a whole linux network! And I mean clients also. Servers in linux, lets be fair, many of them are only web-mail servers, firewalls and routers. Nothing more! File servers that work good with other systems - no way ... it's a lot and hard work to do to accomplish that! Printservers? Same thing here, it's a looong way to go.
You all say about security - let me remember an article I read some time ago, from the Linux environment - you have to patch all the time with the latest updates (and you are complaining about Microsoft) or else, the system become unsecure. Go figure when it comes about the "patch" world.
I agree linux is a good thing, and he's best for what he is now ... but it's a looong way to become the number one.

by tomsal

Sorry, but I'm tired of self made facts people post all over the 'net... I hear that Microsoft is being dropped by many companies in place of Linux. Yes, some companies are...how many companies are in the world? What I mean to say is this according to recent articles in ComputerWorld, InformationWeek and spot ads for JetBlue, Intel and IBM...I'm see that a great number of *BIG* companies are sticking with Microsoft products, of those I just named they are all upgraded (or already upgraded to) Windows 2003 server.

Furthermore in recent issue of CIO magazine I read about another rather large company come straight and say that Linux wouldn't work with their company as it has lots of maturing to do before it hits the end user, so they are sticking with Microsoft for now.

It just hey I like Linux, but calm down its NOT READY FOR THE CORPORATE DESKTOP YET!!

by zgr

Well, the problem is quite simple:
Novell has technology excellence, while MS has marketing excellence.

I am in the Linux and Microsoft for more than 15 years now (yes, yes, it is sooooo old). I just checked: my first Linux was an Yggdrasil distribution dated 1994.

All in all, non-proprietary Linux (Debian for example - no holly wars, please) is a pretty good thing when it comes to installing firewalls, ftp servers, mail servers, even MS-integrated file servers. On the desktops, MS is here to stay, at least along the next five to ten years. Our customers are driving this, not us. Technical excellence is pretty good, but not sufficient.

Novell is well-known to change for trying new products and markets with hype and letting them covered with dust a short time after. Do you remember the famous UNIX buy ? Unixware ? I do...

by Member 30018865

Look, Novell is superior technolgy, coupled with Linux and all that is available for it is a great tool. But the reality is that companies that don't change to the industry demand (like it or not) just die. There is plenty of Microsoft out there, and plenty of work. Move into it, keep that cash a comin' and then burn some midnight oil learning Linux. It is MUCH harder to migrate to Linux than to Microsoft. The OS is getting easier to operate and install than three years ago but there are still a lot of little glitches and gotchas that M$ has seemed to work out.

by thearchitect

Right on the money...It truly is time to get out of the 90's and realize what year it is.
As security becomes more and more important to corporations I see more and more articles from independent organizations speaking on the new features of the windows platform and how they are dealing with security. Where IIS 4.x or 5.x was wide open, 6.x is coming out locked down by default, as well as Server 2003.
They may have failed us in the past, but they are coming to plate ready to play, and that's coming from a UNIX head!

by adeshayes

What do you mean by "Facing the END of Netware"

Netware assured us that it will continu to exist.
In my opnion its not Netware that is going to end, its the lack of support of third party's.
A lot of third party do not supprt the Netware platform anymore. Why don't they. Netware is the most secure platform at this time.
Maybe its easier for programmers to write the software for Microsoft Platforms in stead of a Netware platform. Or is it an money concern. Programmers can earn more money by writing their software for Microsoft Platform. So theu choose to write application the easiest way and earn more money with it, in stead of writing relaiable software for a reliable and secure operating system.

Netware is going to stay due to the existence of a few very good products. For instance eDirectory, which is the only reliable Cross platform Directory Services. Microsofts Directory Service is never going to be a Cross-platform product.

by zgr

Uh?

As AD (bad or good, it exists) is LDAP based it is by design cross-platform aware.
And I am using it from Linux boxen. Although it takes some tricky config, it works...

by dpbrant

I think you miss the point of cross-platform. While yes, you can ACCESS AD via LDAP, you cannot RUN it on anything but Windows.

by preston_terrell

Linux has the fame but BSD has really helped my business. No software licenses to worry about, which means more of the tech budget can be spent on you and not Microsoft.

Yes there is a bit of a learning period, but it comes quick. Believe it or not, you can do so much more out of the box with BSD than with Msft. A lot less reboots as well.

Don't snub it so quick, although if your new to it, try BSD from the get go. I used Redhat for a long time, their new license really messed me up. I don't think BSD will ever go that route. Plus BSD is much cleaner, in regards to adding applications.

by bichelmo

The reason a lot of third parties don't want to support Novell is because it is a far better Operating system. It rarely breaks. If you are in the business of fixing things then you want more business with something that breaks frequently hence we have Microsoft.

by mobilec1

Speaking as a part time consultant and Novell Reseller. I can understand where you are coming from. I had had similar thoughts myself about the future of Novell vs Microsoft. As I seen through Novell's aquisition of SUSE linux and their committment to Edir, I have a a renewed sense of purpose about Novell and their products. I also like the idea of selling a product that doesnt come with a BIG Red target on its package. It would be a wise idea to gain experience and knowledge in all facets of OS's. whether it be Novell, Linux or Microsoft so that you can make an informed choice.

by sedge

Very few people review history in making decision s for the future. Another thought that not many people are aware of or will probably even consider is that SUSE Linus is tied very closely to Software AG in Germany. About three years ago, Novell sent one of its top execs to Software AG. This send up a lot of red flags to me. Even if I was anti-Microsoft, I would be very wary of any company with a close relationship to Software AG. Another product that is very stable, but doesn't play well with anything else and a company that isn't concerned enough about its product to keep it up to date.

Seems like Novell keeps on partnering with companies of like mind.

by oz_media

I read the exact same thing in 1994. "Is Novell making it's exit as a player in the NOS market?"

Of course they didn't go anywhere. NOvell is superior and gets better each year. Ms just fixes thier NOS each year and people think its better. Better than what? A NOS that DIDN't WORK in the first place!?!?!? I sure hope so.

Novell engineers make a LOT more money than MCSE's, the product requires less time to patch and keep running, Novell just doesn't go down.

I'll stay where the money is, NOvell for me, the MSCE market is inundated and jobs are paying less each week, funny enough though, it requires twice as much work as a netadmin. Work twice as hard for less money, yup, just like most companies where those that do the least work make the big bucks.

by david_heath

Novell's BrainShare is on in less than 2 weeks. I'd strongly suggest you get there if you what to know where Novell's taking Netware and Linux. 10,000 geeks can't be wrong!!

by i.hilliard

The first question as always, when making a business decision, has to be "What best fits the needs of my clients?" It is only by understanding and supplying that which your clients need that you will continue to prosper.

The point here has to be though, ?Why haven't your clients already moved across to Windows?? The answer may well be that your clients don't want to use Windows. In my experience, those companies that have not moved to Windows don't believe that the Microsoft offerings are reliable enough or secure enough for their business. If that is the reason why your customers are your customers, then you would be doing yourself and your customers a disservice by moving to Windows.

Linux is more complex than Windows, but so is NetWare. The complexity is a consequence of the flexibility. As I see it, Linux will be a better fit to those customers who are looking for the reliability, security and flexibility associated with NetWare. I believe that this is the reason that Novell is now going down the Linux path.

It may well be worth while getting more information about Linux before deciding whether Linux is suitable for your customers. But always remember, if you do the best for your customers, they will look after you.

Ask your customers whether they really believe that a move to Windows would be in their best interest. When discussing the point, make sure to use valid information and studies. The use of some of the now discredited TCO studies, which Microsoft has had produced, may reflect badly on you and your company when the truth eventually becomes clear to your customers.

Ian

by tom_sawyer70

"becoming clearer, that Netware is about to become the bastard child of Novell."

The Netware kernel may be on the way out, but not the Netware services...they're just going to run on the Linux kernel. Just like DS or GW running on say, a Windows machine, the security and function is there, it's just not booting off of the Netware kernel.

As for Windows vs. Linux, there are plenty of signs today that Microsoft is losing it's grip. While Netware has always been secure and stable, Linux has those and the two things behind it that Netware never had...marketing and advertising.

by tek_slave

I think people who know both platforms understand that NetWare still carries validity. But Novell also knows that it must port to the Linux kernel for long-term growth and success. Hell, they were profitable last quarter following the SuSE acquistion. To the red folk out there, does it really matter if NetWare falters iff the new SuSE/Novell product-set eclipses it in quality and performance?

by felipe_alfaro

Making decisions on future predictions is risky
business. Making decisions on ease of use is
completely nonsense: servers don't have to be
easy to use, but must stand the test of time,
have high levels of availability and
realibility. It's not a matter of popping a CD,
run SETUP.EXE and click Next a couple of times.

Going on with M$ means a lot of trouble:

1. Faster upgrade cycles: means a lot of
investment in software that doesn't provide
anything new, except being forced to upgrade at
vendor's desire (M$). Read Service Pack 2, read
Windows XP, read Windows Server 2003.

2. Continuos upgrades and fixes: Let's get
clear, we know M$ software is insecure by nature
and it's installed, used and administered by a
lot of people without the know-how. You'll need
to be prepared to enter the daunting task of
patching almost daily and being the target of
works, viruses and hacerks almost continuously.
ALso, you'll need to deal with inexpertise users
running a flawed system: Ey, my printer doesn't
work, or what the heck is this blue screen?

3. No freedom to choose: once you choose M$, you
will be forced to use certain kind of software.
Software from third-parties will not function
correctly, or it will obsoleted when M$ includes
the same functionality into the core operating
system (read Virtual PC, for example), forcing
you to upgrade and retrain on using the "new"
built-in features. For example, AntiVirus, disk
defragmentation.

4. M$ software is costly: licenses are extremely
expensive, maintenance is almost a daily
process, bugs are common, hotfixes fix one thing
and break others, Service Packs must be
extensively tested before deployment, DLL's get
overwritten when you install new software which
causes other programs to stop working.

5. M$ lacks robust automatic updates: Almost
every Linux distribution out there has supported
automated updates for a long time. Even more,
you DON'T HAVE TO REBOOT YOUR MACHINE once
updates have been applied.

I could go on and on trying to convince you that
Windows was, is and will always be an "Operating
System" geared towards the home and consumer
users, which has tried to include enterprise
features, but has failed miserably. Windows was
created to run Solitaire, write letters with
Word and read e-mails. It was created to make
computers accessible to the average Joe user,
not to make enterprise-grade computing better
(we already have UNIX-like OS's).

Trying to use Windows to run enterprise-like
databases or something with requires high
availability is likely to fail. At least, we
failed and switched to Linux.

by sedge

Since when is every 2-3 year for an OS upgrade too often? Stop and think for a minute: Windows 98 - Windows 2000 (2 years). Windows 2000 - Windows XP (2 years). Server 2000 - Server 2003 (3 years). This isn't too often.

And what plays well with Novell? I agree that it's a good product, but who cares? It takes way too much tweaking to get it to play nicely with other software that isn't a Novell product or partner product. Everyone builds for Microsoft. Novell is an aftertought, if even considered at all.

Yes, a lot of it is in the marketing, but Novell just doesn't seem to care enough to market its products. For example, I hosted what was supposed to be a major presentation to compare Microsoft and Novell products with their own staff doing the comparison. After jumping at the opportunity, Novell didn't even bother showing up. No phone call, no cancellation, they simply didn't show up. That made for a pretty one-sided comparison. And several months later, I've still heard nothing from them. How can anyone select a product when the manufacturer doesn't care enough to try to sell it?

Another point to consider is why Microsoft is attacked so often. They're big. They're attacked because they are big. Who cares about attacking the minor players in the market? That won't get you a name or recognition. Even the media doesn't care. Novell does get hacked and does have security problems. Does it make the news? No...they won't even formally acknowledge the problems. They just issue patches. Microsoft is at least honest and acknowledges they have a problem.

We've been conditioned over the past few decades to consider big business as bad. So, right from the start, we consider Microsoft bad even without considering their products. We all need to take a step back and realize that Microsoft has created a lot of jobs worldwide and spurred our economy and those of other nations, too. Personally, many of us wouldn't even be working in this field without Microsoft. Indirectly, too, they have positively affected everything in the technology field. They made it easy for everyone to have a personal computer...creating the need for a lot of small consulting firms that otherwise wouldn't exist. They spurred manufacturing, both from direct production of their own branded products and from support of a variety of industries to make their life easier. I could go on and on about the positive aspects of Microsoft, a point that few people will consider.

What has Novell done?

Microsoft is the 800 pound gorilla on the block. But they;re also a very friendly gorilla if you just take the time to think the issues though logically. And I don't work for Microsoft.

by oz_media

Your post although a common opinion is so far off base it isn't funny.

To begin with " It takes way too much tweaking to get it to play nicely with other software that isn't a Novell product or partner product."

The partner products work seamlessly in a Novell ebvironment, MS works with MS end of story. As for third party products for Novell, you obviously haven't spent too much time looking at the NEW Novell since it aquired Ximian's Linux, there are 2000 PRE-packed software titles for the server and desktop with Novell Ximian. Microsoft offer IE and Exchange if you're lucky (note, BOTH MS products.)

MIcrosoft is the 900 pound gorilla on the block that forces his bananas down your throat each day and when you slip on the peel, just hands you a new banana. They spread themselves too thin and don't completely build any ONE product properly.

Novell started in business networks, have developed through Business networks and ONLY build Business networks, no joysticks, no games, no cheesy chat software, no BS networking OS etc.
They build NOS's and VERY good ones at that which Microsoft is miles away from being even close to matching. Microsoft has PAID for your interest in them, they have force fed thier substandard products to the market for too many years and many people don't realize that they haven't built a GOOD products since.....?

You shoudl stay current with a manufacturers product before voicing such a negative opinion, which is OBVIOUSLY baised in the first place.
" Novell didn't even bother showing up. No phone call, no cancellation, they simply didn't show up."

No bad feelings here, and obviously an open minded assessment, NOT.

by ryanrollings

We are a MS, Novell, Linux, Solarus, AS/400, running SAP, file and print, web servers, and on and on. M$ is the most expensive and irritating OS we have. We are slowly allowing it to die. In it's place are our Netware Servers, Linux and Solaris with eDirectory running on top. DirXML prividing identity management that is like magic having the disparate operating systems. We will be using Novell Linux and SUSE on the desktop soon but our Netware boxes will stay in place and run and run just like they always do. There are literally years between reboots on out Netware servers. It's usually a hardware issue that reminds us that the servers are still there. Tell your customers about Novell. SELL it to them. You are letting M$ sell their half-baked product for you and your customers are getting second best NOS at a higher cost.

by gorto

If you are not interested in relocating you would be well advised to find out what services are selling and what your client's plan to do when Novell in its present form, is no longer supported. Be ready to adjust to the customers need. There are still a lot of loyal Novell users out there. In my area M$ has a foothold but has been loosing ground to Linux and Solaris.
I now service all three.

by rupen

The market place is already far too overcrowded with Microsoft consultants. Linux is catching on fast. The are some very big players investing heavily in Linux--IBM, HP, Novell. Also consider that it that vendors with Linux expertise will likely make be able to charge more for consultancy.

by midzonetec

A lot of folks are looking to Linux based platforms for better security and less hassle and cost licensing. Novell has picked up a lot of good press with the Linux community. If they continue with the commitment to quality and security, the open source community will help drive them forward. They have a name for stability, running the Linux kernel will make it possible to use a greater number of tools. The combination of the Novell name and the Linux buzz should help propel the company forard. As the new products start becoming more visible in the real world the word will get out. If you jump ship now you may miss the real boat of the future.

by sedge

Linux is cheaper to purchase now, but it won't be if it really becomes a major player. Market forces will put it right up there with the big dogs. Just look at UNIX...after the Novell fiasco with that product. Then people can start to complain about its cost and look to the next product offering a lower TCO..at least until it catches on.

by bmuys

It sounds to me like you trying to choose one over the other. Why not embrace both? As far as training, why not explore distance learning courses, Web training, Web seminars, etc. Your physical presence is not always required for a training course.
Novell has a history and has dedicated clients. Microsoft has a history and has dedicated clients. Linux doesn't have a history, but it will! Knowing all of these products is the key to the future.

by michaeltsen

The fact that you are asking the question is another dilema of mine too. I want to make money but I don't really fall into the money maker category ie. Enterpreneur like Bill and Linus. So I just want to make 'more' money piggy backing on them.

Its apparent that you have already choosen Microsoft but just has slight concern on the shift. For easy money, sure go with the M.

Then again, the fact of the market and trend is that big market, many suppliers; small market, less suppliers. So it doesn't really matter which market you are in, if you are really good, you will make it through.

Don't be surprise to get a bunch of calls and great deals inviting you back to 'Netware' a couple of years later ... ;-)

by schnetman

"I get more calls for Exchange and Windows admin than I do for Novell these days."

I think this says it all. I work two days a week maintaining a Novell school network and that is all I need. Probably less than 1% of my work relates to netware. My colleagues in M$ schools work five days a week and complain they never have enough time. And in many cases there are two of them.

If your livelihood necessitates haveing lots of problems to solve, then yes, the Microsoft road is the only one to follow. Incidentally, I have (within the last fortnight) started adding additional Linux based storage to my network. Piece of cake.

by another butthead

What do you do sell a product that has bugs so you can provide the service to them in the future?

Or do you sell them a superior product that werves their needs and more and requires less baby-sitting?

When your customers find out that you have been selling them something for mostly your benifit, aren't they going to bolt? Wouldn't you?

Novell has always had the best designed software. Linux is close. With Novell's purchase of Xiamin and Suse, they have posistioned them selves to be at the tip of the spear in innovation.

M$ is still installed almost everywhere so you will have a customer base to feed your family, but it would be irresponsible for you to ignore Linux.

by hal5

The writing is on the wall for the demise of Microsoft and possibly for commercial software. What Novell is doing is choosing the obvious path to future survival. You can choose to put all your efforts into Microsoft but before you know it you will be useful like a Banyan Vines expert would be today. The whole world is going open source and companies like Apple, Novell and IBM know that they can not stop it or fight it so they leverage it to success. Microsoft is going to fight it and lose because they can't stop it, ever.

You would be best served to learn what is going on and consider if your clients can be served by a FreeBSD, Linux or new Netware 7 server.

I have a personal experience with a Novell to FreeBSD migration to share. We had a client running a Netware 4.1 server with an Act database with 50,000+ records and growing. They experienced random slowdowns and generally slow response from Act no matter what we did. The client was hesitant to upgrade to Microsoft Small Business Server due to cost concerns. We were sick and tired of the problems and I knew that Samba running on an open source platform like FreeBSD will outperform a Windows server so we loaned them a test FreeBSD server running Samba. The first radical change we saw was the indexing would now take only 15 minutes where before it took an hour and a half. In the almost 1 year of using this solution they have had no complaints of poor performance. They really don't understand what we did or that it did not involve Microsoft, Novell or any other "legitimate" vendor. They only know and understand that now they can get their work done and it only cost them $0 for software and about 8 hours of our time.

by rgrein

I get this all the time living in the heart of microsoftland (I can
walk to the main campus from home), but I'll repeat it one more
time: Netware is NOT going away!!! Sure, the pundits have
predicted it's immenent demise, but when have they NOT read
last rites for our favorite NOS?

Fact is NetWare 7 is slated for release in about 18 months, give
or take ALONG with the fully compatible product for Linux. Use
one, use the other, Novell doesn't care. This gives Novell a solid
application server, an in with the Linux gearheads (which, BTW is
a complimentary term). and something to distract Microsoft. The
story from Novell sources has varied slightly due to different
perspectives, but the main points are consistent - Linux is an
addition, not a replacement, they'll let long-term market forces
determine if or when to halt Netware development, and there's a
multi-year development plan in place right now.

What does this mean for you? Admittedly Novell sales staff has
been concentrating on other things, but support is still there.
Training oportunities are tougher, but between web seminars,
Brainshare and the partner resources you should have plenty of
opportunities to get your hands on future Netware materials as
well as Suse training. In fact, if you are indeed a Novell partner
you've been told recently about all this, as well as given
information about upcoming Linux training. If you missed it get
in touch with Novell TODAY and get your contact information
updated.

Now, as to which way to go - of course we'll have Windows to
kick around for some time, and it will continue to be a decent
revenue stream. However, that market is largely saturated,
whereas Linux is growing rapidly - at the expense of Windows
marketshare. Netware (installed base) and Mac (installed and
new machines) have stayed largely flat. My money, time and
effort is in learning linux - well, learning more than I know right
now.

by elamess

Forgive my fiendish chuckle my friends as I go over the topic of this conversation over and over in my mind. I just have to laugh. When was anything "The Cadillac" of anything else? A long time ago. Vindale mobile homes were The Cadillac of mobile homes and so on. Netware was The Cadillac of network software. Sigh, so long ago. Elvis was the King by the way, around that same time.

After years and years of pleading to come to your senses and use Microsoft, you remained rebellious, you thumbed your noses and swore pledges of eternal allegiance to the red and white boxes. (I think they were red and white....it's been more than 10 years since I've seen the boxes). Even now, when it should be very clear to you, you are even considering Linux?

I say to you now.....go there. Jump from Netware to Linux. This way your "do it my way" sort can remain the fodder of humor for a while to come. The fact that you have waited this long indicates to me that you may be happier as mayflowers at the big dance anyways.

Meanwhile, Those of us wearing the beanie hat with the propellor on top, with "Bill" on one blade and "Gates" on the other will continue to be on the cutting edge of innovation forever. Or at least as long as Microsoft remains the, uh....lets's see....hmmmm.....Lamborghini of network software(?).

Just curious....how many of you thinking of switching prefer an Apple computer on your desk?
I hear they are The Cadillac of proprietary systems.....yes?

by oz_media

Marketing and market share has NOTHING to do with product success.

"as long as Microsoft remains the, uh....lets's see....hmmmm.....Lamborghini of network software"

Well that's over so what now. MS, if they have EVER been considered the Lamborghini of software, make that NETWORK software and even more hideous attempt in which I don't think they've ever even been a proper player doesn't have a leg to stand on other than market share and advertising. The products don't outperform ANYONE else's on the market, they never have and most certainly never will. I believe (If I remember correctly) Novell benchmarking simultaneous logins, file updates, etc. showed that Netware 4.11 outperformed WIN Server 2003, and that is an ancient NOS from Novell. I can crash ANY MS server in less than 10 minutes, Novell, you practically have to use the down and restart to get the server to go down, it's the easiest job I have EVER had, and that includes some pretty cushy desk jobs.

Ms is mster of nothing but has thier hands into everything. This doesn't make them better, just bigger, like WalMart, HONDA, Panasonic etc. Big not far from best. It is an illusion of grandeur that makes them APPEAR to be the best. Unless you are in Texas of course where bigger certainly is considered better.

by psbruciu

If you want to deal daily, and sometimes even several times a day, with problems, then choose Windows.

by hagstrom

Seems like everybody thinks Novell is much better than M$.
Well.. we have both a Novell network and a M$ network, and most of our network-client problems are related to the Novell servers, slow connections, drive mapping problems, Groupwise problems, ZENworks problems to just name a few.

Yes, every desktop is a windows computer, but they have a lot less problems with windows servers than Novell servers.

by thearchitect

Preach on brother Hagstrom!!!

When I read this post I started asking around the group to see who was Hagstrom because this is our environment to the "T"!

ZENworks has been the biggest headache in the world. We have had to rebuild dozens of machines from an image because suddenly ZEN randomly decides to give NO ONE administrative rights on the machine.

The biggest pain is when asking Novell the only response, if any, we get from them is "...install a patch...install a patch..."

We tried implementing their portal EXACTLY as they told us to, and it just doesn't work. They tell us company so-and-so has it running so you should have no problem...problem is when we go and ask company so-and-so they comment that they had the same problems and tossed out the portal months ago.

In the past 6 months our Novell support has been ineffective, non-responsive, and lies.

Time for some visine around here...SO WE CAN GET THE RED OUT!!!

by oz_media

I dunno but I've set up MANY MANY Zenworks systems, soe for mixed environments and some for the red N only, NEVER had a single problem with either installation, configuration, abends ANYTHING. I know people with purely MS houses that will use Zen for deployment.

I assume you're an MCNE and not a MCSE, but if you are MS certed, THAT's the problem. Not a slam on yourself but just a reality check.

by arleenw

This is because M$ is designing their software not to work with Netware, and Novell has to keep jumping the hurtles. Novell's knowledge base and Cool Communities have tons of articles to solve the problems. Believe me, it's not the Netware servers causing the problems.

I found turning off the "Client for Microsoft Networks" and other unnecessary protocols on the workstations helped speed server access time.

by rktyr81

I cut my teeth on Netware, and I still have it running parts of the network, but several years ago I decided I needed more. I looked at MS and Linux. I went with Linux (namely SUSE). The bottom line for me was control. If I have the source code, I control what's happening on my system. I'm subject to a bunch of confidentiality laws, and I'm not interested in having my happy heinie held hostage by anyone's black box software.

As for learning curve, if you actually know how to run your system, as opposed to faking it the way I see a lot of sys ads do, the curve is small, no greater than with MS.

by oz_media

As a MCNE you will be paid more money than an MCSE, you will work shorter hours and experience less problems.

This will give you time to debug and patch all the Microsoft games you'll buy to keep yourself busy at work. It's like being a Maytag man, waiting for the phone to ring so you can fix something, other than the MS desktops of course.

by howard.blake

Novell has been smelling bad for a long time - they just didn't know they were dead!

Unfortunately, Netware sat on their laurels too long and M$ put them under. Their product is nice, secure and probably the best net OS out there, but MS made it easier and less expensive to network (not to mention LESS SECURE). Netware just couldn't figure out a new paradigm and has died a slow death.

Marriage with Linux could spell a niche market for Netware, but I don't see it ever having the prominence that it once had (pre-NT). A shame, really, as it is a nice system.

by mbaumli

Last I checked, there is more linux documentation online than that of any OS. Plus there are plenty of free distributions, included Novell's own SuSE. SuSE 9.0 is one that I have used personally and was quite fond of.

Microsoft may be easier to learn, but they limit what you can do by requiring a GUI for everything. The Commandline world is so much faster. GUIs should be used for presentation of information only. To use them to navigate is rediculous.

Linux gives you the option of the GUI, Linux gives you the option of what modules to load. Linux even let's you modify the kernel.

So with all that openness, you want to give it the cold shoulder and go Microsoft. That my friend is insane. True that Microsoft may be easier to learn, but that doesn't make it any better. I have spent over 4 years tinkering with Linux, I haven't gotten to where I can do whatever whenever, but I can do the majority of what I want on a Linux box. Infact, I am only a mailserver upgrade away from moving my system over to desktop linux at work.

I am pretty impressed with what is available for linux as opposed to Windows. And it is becoming easier to find support for Linux.

Go the Microsoft path if you shall, but OpenSource looks like it is out to make waves in the industry. Already Opensource as been eating away at Microsoft's IIS, how long before SQL server, or other Microsoft apps begin to lose ground?

by thearchitect

Sure there are free distributions...why would we as a corporation want the free versions with no accountable support? And seems to me there is a charge for SuSE...
http://store.suse.com/dr/v2/ec_Main.Entry?SP=10007&SID=40017&CID=0&CUR=840&DSP=0&PGRP=0&CACHE_ID=0

"Microsoft may be easier to learn, but they limit what you can do by requiring a GUI for everything" You may want to do some reading up on the operating system before making comments like this. I'm constantly at the prompt doing things!

by kmoskey

Novell Netware is the king of the operating system world. I compare Microsoft and Netware like this. Microsoft is the Walmart of OS's. Warm and fuzy ad's that lure you into the their world of cheap crap.
Netware on the other hand is the finely tuned mom and pop shop that has always provided the best products and service at all levels. Always consistant and reliable. Novell is only guilty of failing in marketing not at producing a quility product. I only dream of the day I can "pick the pockets" of hundreds of thousands of people of 10's of thousands of dollars and not be accountable for any damages. Its the old joke about if Microsoft made a car....

by synthetic

We have run Novel on the LAN side since our organization created them 13 years ago. Our work stations and WANs are both M$ operated. Towards the beginning of last year, one of the senior planners got bit by the M$ bug and started developing the possibility of going to a homogenous M$ environment. Thankfully, Slammer, and a host of other nasty exploits (as well as serious push-back from those of us who actually administer these systems in the field) was enough to show that M$ homogeny a bad idea. While many of our WAN functions were down for patching, some workstations, and some exchange server banks were out, our users still had access to local client and user data files, as well as LAN servers applications. Had this not been the case close to a week of total down time would have been experienced, and we could have stood to have lost $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$. Novell is solid, functional, and stays up with little oversight, and little need for heavy weight hardware. Microsoft has yet to show a thoroughly dependable product that requires little oversight, and limited expense past the point of purchase.

by thearchitect

"Thankfully, Slammer, and a host of other nasty exploits (as well as serious push-back from those of us who actually administer these systems in the field)"

You administer the systems in the field and got hit by Slammer? Read this!!!

http://www.cio.com/archive/051503/bugs.html

"Don't blame Microsoft. Don't blame the hackers. Blame yourself for insecure software. Better yet, stop blaming and start moving toward operational excellence."

by thearchitect

"Novell Netware is the king of the operating system world"...come on...*nix is the ruler of the operatin world!

"..mom and pop shop.." and like most of them it's going away, right out of the mouth of the engineers at Novell. "...the kernel is a commodity and will go away soon with the coming of Linux.."

by oz_media

We all know that Sunday is the end of the world and that the sky will fall next Wednesday.

I will build my fallout shelter this Saturday and stock it for many years of doom and gloom.

The end is near, thank you for your insight I was actually living happily, what do I know!?

by dwdino

With less than 17% (generous) of the NOS market, Novell is near the bottom. Most of this install base is probably at Novell.

Maybe Suse will turn Novell's foutune by meeting the biggest need of Linux - desktop/central management.

We run a completely native MS AD domain. The last string of viruses have given us 0, zip, notta problem.

I would love to save money with Linux, but until it is as refined as MS for my desktop users and controllable from my dugeon :D, forget it.

by oz_media

Honda build smaller lighter cars than Jaguar.

Honda builds cars that IF TAKEN CARE OF IMMACULATELY, will last for some time, as does Jaguar.

Honda sells MANY times the number of cars that Jaguar does.

Honda holds a MUCH larger market share in the mid and compact sized markets than Jaguar does.

Does Jaguar inundate the mainstream public with it's car ads? NO, it doesn't sell it's products to those looking for cheap solutions.

Does Jaguar advertise in magazines, radio, SPAM mail, etc? No, again high end market looking for high end solutions.

Does Jaguar cost more than a Honda? Yes.

Does Jaguar place thier badge on crappy SUV's, Luxury and entry level cars, VANS?? NO.

Why not?

They build MUCH better cars, why ruin a reputation by trying to fill a market segment that will detract from your manufacturing success.

My question:
Why does Jaguar still exist?

Better car, better manufacturing, FAR FAR better engineering, better braking system (also adopted by Volvo), ride comfort, reliability of parts etc.

Why does Novell still exist? Do the math it's a no brainer.

by paul_a_leroy

It?s best to have expertise in both MS and Linux camps. Linux will be big at the server level, but wouldn?t make any inroads on the desktop. With Linux you also have a large choice of open source tools and applications you can supply your customers and support.

by oz_media

"Linux will be big at the server level, but wouldn?t make any inroads on the desktop."

Were you asleep last fall? Perhaps winter hibernation or something? Novell Linux for (Suse)desktops is one of the hottest things I've laid eyes on in years!

You take the most reliable NOS and run it on a Linux kernel, sounds pretty viable to me. The desktop rollout is a massive package with licences for almost everything, including Office suite, graphics, multimedia etc. Windoze, not even a close relative in respect to licencing and desktop functionality/stability.

by teligence

Instead of trying to determine the feasibility of switching to either Linux or Microsoft, let's look at history in general. Generally speaking, any society that has taken the "easy way out" has always done so at a price. Often, the initial enticesments clouded realistic perception of future repercussions. People would side with certain barons, lords, or other type of leadership because of either convenience or force. The value of safety, food, shelter, and other necessities weighed heavily in drawing the loyalty of those in need. However, it was a rare occasion when those in charge did NOT usurp and misuse the authority they had.
Jump forward a few centuries to the present. Crime hasn't gone away - it has just gotten better at disguise and evasion. Take a look at the big cities - there is not one major city that does not have some type of organized crime offering "protection" for the people and businesses in their respective districts. Just going along with the flow just gets them in deeper, minimizing the recipients' ability freely operate. Enforcement stays away beecause it's either too costly, too complicated, or they are too closely associated.

In any case, whenever a "giant" controls the general populace, exploitation historically occurs. The historical remediation has almost invariably involved the victims banding together and creating their own "operating system".

I hope you can see the parallels...

With that aside, Microsoft is the easy choice, but the question for siding with Microsoft is "What is the short AND long term cost for this ease?". The subsequent question for the Linux choice is "What do I need that is missing in Linux that Microsoft provides, and what are the development and support costs for choosing Linux?".

by dbremer

You address some good points regarding a choice of OS. However, the origonal poster is not looking at choosing which to migrate to in his business. He is looking at which to specialise in to SUPPORT clients. This is an entirely different matter.

I regard it entirelly unethical to recommend a product simply because it requires lots of support (which I supply) - but it is just plain silly to put all my efforts in developing my support ability in products that aren't in the market - altho having a niche is nice if you can get a decent population.

For a support person (consultant, etc), the question isn't "which runs best for my business" - it's "what do my clients, or potential clients, need supported".

It's the old BETA vs VHS issue. BETA may be better - but you'd go broke only supplying videos in that format.

by synthetic

As stated, due to this and a number of nasty exploits, many discovered by outside vendors with viral releases before the patches were made available. And then please note, that servers were down inside of the organization due to those sectors and administrators either bringing down to patch, and test the functional level of the patches, or are you so enveloped in M$ that your unaware of the operational issues that happen time and time again with their patches and proprietary software? We in the field didn't get hit, but down time happens when a sector in the global organization is closed, or when a clients web based server is down, understand. Maybe one day you to can work for organization that employees thousands in the IT sector of the firm, with locations world wide and a huge range of operational needs, then you might also understand that patching the reactive M$ way is not enough. I had a NDPS print server in a closed environment at a client site that had been up and running without need of a reboot, without any lock, or any other maintenance for over three years. That the beginning, end, and forced upgrade period for Microsoft. That is truly operational excellence.

by voldar

just a question I would like to ask. What is the cost of a fully licence of NetWare that includes everything that W2K Server has (as services I mean)? Because I talked about that with a very friend of mine, specialist in Novel, and I have shown him what W2K can do. You know what he said? This can be done with Novel very easy, but for each of the "services" you have to pay and pay ... and so on.
Needless to say about group policies and VPNs and RRAS. Each of these costs lots of money! Or at last that's what he said to me.

by oz_media

Agreed. Ximian/Linux IS going to keep Novell around for a long time. nobody has built a better mousetrap, they don't build games or consoles, just stable NOS software. Perople that have used Novell use it for a specific reason, whether security, ease of administration or just overall reliability, it DOESN'T GO DOWN!!

These companies will always have a taste for the finer things and will laugh at the thought of Microsoft, or run screaming.

by voldar

Although you seam to be very confident in your lines, what about the client side? As far as I know - and I don't say I know much lol - the best networks are Novel + Windows 2000 clients (Go figure that!). What is good a NOS if there are no clients to meet the required expectations? And why are the best? Because as far as I start knowing, W2K is not that spread as many people thought - in Canada I mean. And there are soooo many people that don't even know about what W2K can bring on. For myself, the best are W2K and W2K clients (not XP - which is for home users)
And about patches - you always talk about patching MS, how about patching the Linux boxes orelse you are "cuit"? We'll end spending 3/4 of time just to patch the NOS - lol! Don't come with a statement like "you don't need to patch", because it's not true.
Lets face it, linux is in he's early development, and has much to improve. So, whenever a new release will be on, you'll have to switch to that, because is more secure. So, start patching mr. admin! And if I remember, RedHat has it's latest releases at an interval of few month, I don't know about Ximian, but sure is something the same.
That's my point. Linux it's good, but has a lot to improve, Novel has to do something quick so that he ends his period of "shadow". Microsoft is doing exactly what he wants - and W2K is a pretty good product!

by oz_media

I generally run W2K Pro desktops, when possible ( I LOATHE XP in all flavours for personal reasons).

Netware is a Network Operating system, NOVELL doesn't make games, joysticks, game consoles etc. Just NOS's and they work VERY well ad other have a paradigm to live up to because of them.

When I say Linuxm, I am talking via Novell Linux for Desktops, so technically Novell HAS entered the desktop market now with a custome Linux flavour designed to compliment Novell's NOS.

This desktop alternative also comes with thousands of open source inclusions, and patching is done effortlessly and in a batchlike fashion, similar to rolling out with Zenworks before.

I have seen this first hand, I have also helped design one of the first TRUE Novell/Linux netoworks in BC. It took a weekedn to configure and as second string supoprt, I haven't had a call yet. NOTE: They have ONE onsite CNE.

Now, this same scenario with a RedHat or Windows rollout would need several ONSITE techs, many support calls and second string support team would be onsite for weeks.

I think Novell's on the right path with this one.

by oz_media

Yes you are right, but Novell ended up Aquiring Ximian networks as a linux partner.

by thearchitect

"The partner products work seamlessly in a Novell ebvironment" is so far from the truth. ZENworks has been a thorn in our side, to the point we have to keep rebuiding windows workstations left and right because even administrators get locked out of the machine. Their portal can't handle more then 10 concurrent users with the configuration Novell MADE us use (not too open it seems) which was "supposed" to handle 100 users...
This has nothing to do with "an open minded assessment", just the facts.

How about what Gartner has to say..."NetWare's declining market share calls into question whether it is capable of gaining back its past momentum and even if it has long-term viability. Market share is not likely to increase anytime soon in the face of Linux's competition and stagnant original equipment manufacturer (OEM) enthusiasm."

by dchappell

I am surprised to hear that Netware is going away. Is this rumor or fact? It seems like a strange thing to do since they have spent so much time and money making iyt look like a windows app.

I dont think I would spend time on Linux either. It is much more beneficial to focus on Microsoft and Cisco products.

by oz_media

Kinda like the whole Alice in wonderland thing, too much hooka with a caterpillar.

As chicken little said "the sky is falling!"

Novell isn't going ANYWHERE but up, looking at the latest rollouts, I would say Microsoft has a long way to go to even begin competing with Novell, they are just trying to use some underhanded scare tactic marketing as always.

by the way, the entire discussion was started by a peer on TR. Your choice, fact or fiction, or even speculation.

by harperwill

But, right now, Microsoft is at the head of the parade. There ARE appropriate places for Linux and Xnix, but they aren't enough to butter the bread of everybody. It's a good idea to keep up with Linux/Xnix, because you will have calls and needs to use it - but your marketing plan should have Microsoft leading your parade.

Will Harper, MCSE, MCT, CCNA, CTT+ (etc).

by register1

I'm not usre I'd let my annoyance at Novell cause me to run over to M$. Take a look at your customer's needs, can the Novell-Linux path continue to provide them better, more cost effective solutions? If it can, I'd leverage my relationship with them, and with their current solutions and move on up with the Novell-Linux set. If, you see M$ as the only way to continue to server your customers, swith to M$.

Don't let a little change in skill sets cost you an existing customer base. Remember you didn't know Novell at first either....

Bo

by gometrics

Go where the work is. After deploying W2K3 for a 50+ employer, I just don't see how linux can compete in this market. It is an impressive system security concerns and all. Microsoft provided free training in Kenner, LA on the new features. Nothing like this for linux.

Bottom line is if my clients start asking about linux then I will learn linux.

by farkelnagelmak

I've been working computing in some form or another since being trained to fix airborneanti-radar computing on spy planes for USAF during VietNam "police" activities. After 8 years I got out and worked for the Wall Street journal on pdp-8's in octal. There was more money in software so I taught myself this new stuff called "c" on pdp-11's. Then I was offered an MVS job writing assembler. Then Vaxen,Suns,XP doing real-time prices to desktops at brokerage. Bottom line is- there was once an axiom ---"no one was ever fired for buying IBM". That referred to 12 million dollar mainframes. Then came RISC and those who didn't change their thinking went broke. Go with what makes you money and always look forward - TEACH YOURSELF. What makes money today could disappear overnight. Netware -- died with IPX/SPX. Start with whichever- XP or Linux (it's just the popular version of Unix today.) Learn the other as soon as possible and emphasize networking. Sorry I tend to ramble.........

mak

by dqbiggerfam2

you say novell netware is dead? They were aying that about apple a while ago(7-10 years?). keep your knowledge of netware. as someone with experience with macs, I can be worth money in the right environment.

by hankogwm

I too seem to be in a similar situation...why should I learn it if I may not need it!

by racerpat

Jaguar still exists because they were bought by a 900 lb. gorilla (Ford). There's probably an analogy there somewhere :-)

by oz_media

Jaguar was not bailed out at all, they were aquired by Ford just as Lamborghini was by Chevrolet. Lamborghini was not having financial problems.

Jaguar is owned by ford but they are still hand built in a separate facility and marketed and sold as Jaguar NOT Ford. Therefore ownership has no bearing, I am referring to quality here.

As a long time member of the SAE (And licenced Ford mechanic)I am very passionate on this paticular subject regarding automotive engineering excellence, something the Japanese can do but not to suit the North American market or price range, enter Accura.

by racerpat

Jaguar was flat broke when Ford bought 'em. I made my living repairing Jags for 20 years (I've owned more than a few of 'em). Before Ford, the quality was so good that a popular conversion was the replacement of the DOHC Jag engine with a 289 Ford V8 :-)

There's that analogy again, 900 lb. gorillas can be good things - if they're RICH gorillas :-)

by hagstrom

The admins for the Novell network are Novell certified.. plus so are the Novell tech support (I hope!) that has been out here uncountable many times, trying to "fix" the problems. Well.. so far nothing has helped. One little detail get fixed, 10 more show up.. !

To not talk about how interesting it is to setup a WinXP Pro workstation, that works very fast and fine on the network, until you install the Novell client, and then it becomes like molasses!
Then of a sudden all the network communication takes forever.. !

Maaan I wish we had a pure M$ network.. !

by oz_media

Well you'd stay busy at least and remain employed.

Again you are introducing your personal experience with one site as a way of defining Novell's products.

I again have NEVER had these horrible problems you mention. I even have clients who use PDA versions of the Netware and Groupwise client with no problem.

I run PBX Telephony servers with Netware servers side by side, no problem. Have users logging in from all kinds of devices using the XD2 destops (second to none right now) in house.

Things like i-Folder, i-Manager (browser based NOS support across the entire organization), NetWare virtual office stand unrivaled and it will be a LOOONG time before MS catches up, they will just deny the technology as opposed to meeting or exceeding it. These things save me HOURS and the customer THOUSANDS (A key when trying to close a contract).

Granted MANY business owners have thier heads up thier ass when it comes to IT decisions, whether or not they really know or if a firnd told them, they will be somewhat adamant about what is best for them, yet they rarely know and will opt for the MS NOS, hey they're the bigest, they MUST be best.

As for the client SLOWING down anything, this tells me that your issues lay much deeper than most. Novell's clients have been the most resouceful I've ever installed.

Liek I said, you have a bad install, a bad server/hardware/support or something, but your incidnet is the first of this nature I've heard of. QWhat you are complainging about is what makes most people EVEN MCSE's say that is Novells strength. So you bit a sour peanut and all the others taste bad now. This happens with Microsnot too except on a daily basis by thousands of pissed off companies.

I would also be interested in seeing what version of Netware you are rolling out, it sounds quite old due to your client problems.

by hagstrom

No, I don't think we have any old stuff, we have Netware 6.5.

As far as a pure M$ network goes, I'm taking care of our DMZ, which I have setup as a pure Win 2003 AD domain network. I very rarely have any problems, and when I do, I know what to do, to fix it.
Compared to the Novell problems, that neither the inhouse admins can handle nor the outside Novell experts. We just have to live with the problems...

Well, yeah, it's personal experience, and becuase we have had it forever and it never gets any better, I tend to think Novell is bad, and M$ rules.

And my personal experience wiht M$ is the complete opposite. Very stable and friendly.

by voldar

Arch! When you are hit by slammer you start asking what is about your system or what is about you as admin? My opinion is "what kind of admin are you?" In fact, lets face it once for all, it's not the system fault, it does not exist such system! It's only about what and which thing you do when in front of a server.

by oz_media

I've been an MCNE for a few years and have never had a problem with deployment via ZEN works in environments up to about 65 users. Have never rebuilt Windoze DUE to Zenworks login failures.

As for what Gartner says, who is he? An opinion, like you or me, just a voice and an opinion. I bet Bill Gates would also say something similar.

If Zenworks and Novell networking doesn't work for you for some bizarre reason, it is not because th product sucks because it works for so many other people just fine.

now with Microsnot, EVERYONE has the constant patch, repatch, update nightmare and everyone will agree it sucks big time. BUT. It is in our face so we accept it and learn to work with it??

Why bother? Why support a company that produces thousands of titles with MAYBE a handful that work right? That's not a good track record.

Do you honestly, in the bottom of your heart think Novell is hoing anywhere? They were just in town saying how they have gained market share, not lost it. They are actively marketing to the financial areas of Vancouver with Novell's Linux for desktops. They are running in MOST of the schools in B.C. as a collective agreement.

From where I stand, Novell is definitely not goping anywhere and has succeeded here just fine, this is also 4 hours from Microsoft HQ.

by oz_media

You mentioned IBM has just upgraded to server 2003. You failed to mention that they are also one of the first MAJOR OEM providers to incorporate Linux and also Novell in house and in thier pre-configured PC's.

These companies have thousands of servers and each is used for a different purpose or security level. Do you really think they are USING MS throughout? No.

Npvell just closed one of thier largest contracts ever with HP/COMPAQ, with the OEM's moving to prebuilt Linux boxes does this not show you that they are also looking for a Windows alternative? With Novell releasing the most phenominal Linux flavour I've seen, it just reassures me there are other things to consider than Windoze, ESPECIALLY in a business environment where security, stability and uptime are a major consideration, whereas at home, WHO cares, Windoze is enough.

by voldar

yes ... but remember what type of servers are those! Most of them are web-mail servers and routers!

by oz_media

I thought IBM was still in development? As is HP/Compaq.

Perhaps they have BEGAUN deploying it in routers and web-mail servers, but they are looking to target the desktop HOME user maret and offer a stable/affordable desktop for business use.

by jack_j_guarnera

A fool is someone who does something the same way as last time and expects a different result.
Novell has never made it easy for us to sell THEIR product to our employers. As pgm544 points out, MS supplies demos and presentations of their products while Novell admins have to make their own to convince higher-ups that it's a sound product. That's just one point, but that's how it's always been.
I began in the industry as a Novell Engineer. I've always liked the product and I do wish it survives but I won't be surprised if it doesn't and I won't have to wonder who's to blame. It may be too late.

by oz_media

Well Microsoft seels the product so it's dealers don't have to. This is why we end up with such misleading info about MS.

When I was growing up and started to learn sales management, if an IT guy wanted to sell a product, I'd laugh hysterically, techs do not make good sales people, they are methodical thinkers by nature and not free thinkers as you need to be in sales, therefore expecting an IT staff member to sell a product is an absurd thought.

Another reason why everyone has sales staff and IT staff. The two compliment one another yet they both need each other.

When I go out to do a quote or some consulting work, it is MY job to sell the vendors product, NOT the vendor. MS has made people lazy by selling it's OWN products and not relying on a tech to seel it, smart move as it allows them to use much more assertive sales tactics that most IT staff are not aware even exist.

When up against a good salesman, you don't even know you're being sold, because a good salesman has you sell yourself on the product to the point that you are asking him to sell it to you.

if you have a stable organization with an effective sales process, the tech doesn't even enter the picture until objections are raised or concerns adhereing to a specific networking issue.

The salesman just sells the soluition, if he can't you hire a real salesman.

What I see too often is IT techs and netadmins, saying "I wanna be a consultant" with at most a YEARS worth of sales experience or a couple of entry level sales courses AT MOST, he then ventures out to promote, sell, install and maintain products. Good luck and watch your toes, I'm coming through.

If you have a decent sales team, or ability yourself, you would not even consider how well the company promotes it's products. I've successfully marketed products where the company doesn't even exist here as it is a manufactuiring company in Taiwan. Good thing I didn't need THEM to presell thier products!

marketing, sales and presentation skills, don't look to the manufacturer it's not thier job.

Sell it yourself, make people believe it yourself, find the strengths and weaknesses yourself, find the reasons you r customer will benefit YOURSELF. Put your hand back in your pocket and get some work done, feature, function, benefit, trial close, rebuttal, trial close, close. It's work, if you don't want to do it, find someone who will.

by arleenw

My experience has been that M$ designs their products not to work with anyone elses - I've even found references to that fact in their knowledge base when trying to solve a compatibility problem.

The beauty of Netware is that it is secure right out of the box. YOu have complete control over your installation - what services get installed and everything. And it is compatible with most OS's - Unix, Linux, MAC, Windows. They go out of their way to make sure your OS can connect to their server.

Beyond that it is the PERFECT solution for small businesses that need a robust but cannot afford a tech on staff. An experienced consultatant can install and configure a Netware server in an afternoon and leave it. It just runs. Users never need bother with it. At my job, everybody is intimidated by it anyway because they don't see the point and click environment, so they don't touch it. Except for the occaisional service packs or patches, I rarely have to troubleshoot a problem with it. When I access it it is to make changes I WANT make or check logs.

I have no doubts the LInux version of Netware will be just as robust, and if they play their cards right will blow M$ right out of the water.

by oz_media

Go to Novell's site and check out XD2 it will BLOW your mind, and save you company a few thousand at least.

You're right though, the problem isn't getting Novell to work in a Windows environment, it is getting Windows to work in a Novell environment. I guranatee that ANY problems will be resolved by patching and fixing Windows, not the Netware server, unless a Netware patch to accomodate a windows flavour. Why can't MS patch it themselves instead of relying on Novell to do this all the time!

by voldar

But it's soooo long way to go. I am not saying that this is not a good step, but still, it's so much to work.
And now, returning to Novel-Linux, I don't argue when I don't know what the system looks like and what/how works, but .. the lack of "advertising" is not something to pass over. Who thinks that "everybody is supposed to know" about a new product and do not advertise it, is verrrrry .. you chose the word for me :)

by oz_media

Just because it's you, and I like you.

You say, "Who thinks that "everybody is supposed to know" about a new product and do not advertise it, is verrrrry .. you chose the word for me :) "

I'll say very NORMAL. Why should a vendor presell it's product and then pay someone else residuals for selling it?

Did you see your VCR on TV before you bought it or did a salesman talk you into it? (okay make that DVD player ;-))

Did you choose your car based on a TV commercial or did the dealer convince you it was the right car for you?

Do you buy ANYTHING site unseen? Probably not.

The job of a salesman, is to asses and fill a cusomer's need. As Novell offers something diferent for everyone, it is not thier responsibility to sell th product but just to build and support it, which in my experience they do just fine.

If I relied on Novell for sales, I'd go back to selling or fixing cars fulltime.

It is my job as someone who wants to earn money sellng and supporting a product to ensure I am prepared and have the toold to close the deal, not Novell's.

I was sold Novell by a very capable salesman, I didn't like him as a person but thought he was a salesman I respected and would hire myself, I was sold by his energy and product knowledge, NOT by Novell.

I jyust don't get it, several people's main complaint is that Novell isn't advertising and selling thie rproduct, it's insane. Only in IT would you read such tripe, sorry but this is a touchy subject with me. Lazy techs who feel the products should be presold, shouldn't ALL things in life be that easy? Yem but they aren't so get over it everyone and learn to sell or hire salesmen!

I say all this with all due respect for you and hope you don't see this as a shot at yourself, it is more of a generalization, the offenders know exactly who they are and will probably contest it as they read it.