Discussion Locked

Novell Linux and future of Netware

0 helpful
210 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

210 replies

by oz_media

Volvo bought the brake caliper piston designs from Jaguar before they were picked up by Ford (as they had tried to do for too many years). Ford offered them MORE money than they needed and they took it. They had already resolved the major financial problems before the buyout.

This still bears no meaning whatsoever on the point I made though, Jaguar has made and kept a niche market for themselves that Honda can't and won't, it's a different market. This doesn't mean either is right or wrong, but proves that you don't need mass mareketing to sell a quality product, people 'seek' quality.

I just sold my Jag before moving to the Island, I REALLY miss it on the Island Hwy which used to be fun. I am looking at a 450 SL but I dunno If I wanna machine parts again every other weekend, I think I'll hang on to my truck.

by hagstrom

No, I don't think we have any old stuff, we have Netware 6.5.

As far as a pure M$ network goes, I'm taking care of our DMZ, which I have setup as a pure Win 2003 AD domain network. I very rarely have any problems, and when I do, I know what to do, to fix it.
Compared to the Novell problems, that neither the inhouse admins can handle nor the outside Novell experts. We just have to live with the problems...

Well, yeah, it's personal experience, and becuase we have had it forever and it never gets any better, I tend to think Novell is bad, and M$ rules.

And my personal experience wiht M$ is the complete opposite. Very stable and friendly.

by oz_media

with 6.5 your problems are even more vexing.

I don't know how you could possibly be having probs with 6.5, it is the best NOS I've seen/configured to date, by far.

The only thing I noticed with 6.5 is it requires some fairly robust server hardware, dual processors and a gig of ram to start.

Other than that it has been seamles in three installs I've done in the area, including GroupWise with clientless login.

by oz_media

NE 6.5 comes packaged with Apache, MySQL, PERL, TOMCAT and PHP.

NOvell XIMIAN Linux for desktops or XD2, includes
"All-inclusive - no additional license fees for enclosed applications:

Open Source Office Suite: OpenOffice.org
SUN Star Office
Codeweaver Crossover Office for the integration of MS Office
Communication unlimited:
Mail client, scheduler application, data exchange with PDA
SAP client, Windows 2000 terminal client, x3270 - and x5250 - terminal emulators, etc.
KDE desktop security system (Kiosk)
Automated installation with SUSE AutoYaST
Remote administration via SUSE YaST Online Update (YOU)
Network services (samba, FTP, DHCP, HTTP, SNMP, etc.)"

Spend sometime browsing Netware and Ximian, Suse Linux desktop under Products at http://www.novell.com
You'll be amazed at what is in the box!

by oz_media

"For a support person (consultant, etc), the question isn't "which runs best for my business" - it's "what do my clients, or potential clients, need supported".

In a financial perspective this may be of interest to someone, much like the car that dies after the warranty expires.

Then again, from a sales and performance perspective, selling on or two good installs of Netwaer has fed me more business than I could generate myself. Peolpe talk, when one guys is complaining about his IT budget rising the other has NO IT budget. This gets people asking how they can also fire one or two guys and lower thier operating costs. my number gets passed on, I sell and install a viable solution. do you think I'm ever NOT going to get repeat business from these guys? Plus I made a bundle on the software/hardware sale itself, and have nothing breaking up my day with BS issues that have me driving all over the island to resolve and reboot servers. I just remote in if users need adding, email accounts change etc.

by yanipen

I agree to the previous comments. Putting all the eggs in one basket is very risky, especially your eggs. I have been around long enough to see the changes. One thing comes after the other. Yeah, the tools that you have in your toolbox, you should know them by heart.

If shifting to MS works for you, then go for it. But, if you want to shatter the stereotypes, it could mean a whole new thing. The point is, it is always okay to try something new. Especially if is better than the one we've gotten used to. Linux has been GROWING slowly but surely, it surely works for me.

To top that, I live in a country where it is a MS fanatic. We few here, are already making our mark! You should evaluate everything first, what suites you best.

by ajmsandy

Having worked in this industry of ours as a networking consultant for the last 20 years or so I grew up with Netware. For many years earned my living working here in the UK and in NYC. At that time I could never have envisaged what would happen to the then Giant of Networking. The way this company have squandered the family jewels is nothing less than tragic. Since the debacle with Word Perfect and DR DOS, the company never seemed to recover drifting into one disaster after another, without doubt the huge cash pile they accrued in the late 80's to middle 90's has helped them to survive.

Where I live here in Hungerford, we had located a half mile away the Novell European Support Centre, stocked with a finer bunch of engineers as I have ever met. Support was fantastic, by skilled people who really knew the product and cared about the problems you brought to their door. Many I have worked with became good friends. Without warning a few years ago now, they were all dismissed and the centre closed. Technical support then went from brilliant in every way to non-existent.

As a networking course instructor for Learning Tree International the first course I gave was for installing Netware V5. So I can say that I put the commitment into the product and saw it die in the marketplace. Yes, 8 years ago I decided it was time to have a look around after dabbling in Banyans 'Vines' ( Another product that faded away) I started to move into the Gates & Co Camp, what a revelation it was, this stuff was toy town compared to Netware. Over the last 4 years or so I saw the products from the MS camp become heavily adopted in the business arena. I believe this was for a very good reason; I was working on Wall Street and the London Stock Exchange at the time. I became aware that companies were running for cover as they were to a man scared to death that Novell was going to go bust. Anywhere would do as long as it was not Novell. As the PC desktop was rapidly becoming Windows, the logical progression was to move to Microsoft Networking even though the products were difficult to say the least. The damage was done and nothing Novell was ever going to do was going to stem the tide of change. Remember the Sony BetaMax tape? Do I think the Linux thing will be another ill conceived disaster, you can bet your life on it.

I say; Make your move and don't look back, you have a living to make, and sentiment is just too dammed expensive these days. I really do not believe that Novell is not coming back, like dinosaurs they always end up extinct and that?s the way it should be. Compete or die!

This is one Dinosaur that likes to compete, Oh! Last year I started into the Apple stuff, but that?s another story as they say..

by oz_media

well your morbid account of your views on Netware makes me want to tell all my customers I was wrong, the new systems that they ove so much are junk and the company is going tits up.

The fact that Novell has shown a positive cash suplus in thier last four quarters has me thinking otherwise. Companies here are JUMPING on the NOvell bandwagon as they are tired of hirig a team of netadmins to keep things running. Novell's market share has grown substantially over the last year, they didn't go away and haven't come back but thay have become better and thier newer system as always is one to be looked up to and matched by others.

My customers are happy with the MS > Novell switch. They are even happier when they aren't targeted by all the crap that Windows users are always addressing and patching. You see, Microsoft is a US product controlled by a coporation that rubs Canaidan business ethics the wrong way. MS would've lasted a year in Canada before being shunned from the marketplace for thier marketing approach. Many people here would rather go back to pen and paper filing systems than deal with a MS product. We support business based on ethics and morals shown by the business, that's why smaller businesses thrive in most Canada and major corporations move to Toronto or Washington. Wierd example but it's true, corporations have taken over the Toronto business district, they have learned to accept it although they don't like it.

So while YOUR days with Novell are numbered, they are growing here stronger than ever.

by pipe guy

Well at least in your travels through the IT world, from Netware to MS to Mac you ended up with a product that at least logs onto a Netware server. Just another one of those features that a person in a pure MS environment would never have to worry about. Here's another situation. One of our users recently took his laptop out of country and forgot to take his power adaptor with him. Since he figured he only had about two hours of battery life on his computer he basically logged onto the netware server over the internet from his highspeed connection in his hotel room and copied all of the necessary files for his presentation to his "mapped drives" on the server. The connection was pretty slow compared to being connected at the office, but in about 10 minutes he had put all of his files onto his user drive on the server. He then shut his laptop down. Went to the hotel's business suite, downloaded those same files onto one of the desktops in the hotel using the "netstorage" ability. He then was able to work on the presentation for four hours. Then he uploads it back to the server and gets the customer to download it the next day in the customer's own office. Yes they were impressed, yes "netstorage" worked very well. Yes they didn't even know that this could be done by small companies, without a VPN client on someone else's computer that basically only has a browser attached? Yes the guy could have downloaded it if he had a mac or a wireless palm for that matter. Could it have been done in a MS environment... Not out of the box. But these sorts of situations never happen to anyone else. But when they do... it sure was nice to have a solution that worked.

by araspa

Netware kernel will still exist. You have the 'option' of running netware over linux or a linux desktop. They have done this as a strategic decision to move forward with the times. This will further cement netware notsee its demise.

by makins

M$ uses LDAP but their version is not LDAP 3 compliant. Also, AD is not a true x500 directory and is still based in domains. What is more, MS uses a unique version of DNS. Also, how many other systems can run Active Directory? Oh yea, NONE! Novell's eDirectory will run on Linux, Novell, Microsoft and Unix. The truth is M$ makes a needed application server and Novell's eDirectory makes the better and more secure cross platform directory. To be good in this industry you need to know how to work with both systems but everyone knows who makes the better and more secure product.

by masinick

Consider that the installed base of Netware is pretty significant. Though perhaps its finest days have past, in terms of adding features and selling in large numbers, that doesn't mean that Netware is through. I was thinking that Netware was in decline nearly ten years ago, yet it's lived on this long. There's nothing wrong with it at all, but I do expect to see other products get more development attention. Expect to see Netware-like features, perhaps even the Netware protocol stack widely used in other places. I've already seen it on some Linux systems, expect to see more of that.

I believe that Novell is branching out, not to completely kill Netware, but to develop new product lines with the hope of rejuvinating a company that's had good, but fairly stagnant, products for many years. I give them a lot of credit for their recent work with Ximian and most recently with SuSE. I expect them not to take over those works entirely, but to focus them and integrate them into the kinds of things that Novell does well, and that's interconnectivity and interoperability. Ximian's Exchange Server converter is one example of a commercial product that permits Email and information management interconnectivity.

Expect to see more tools and applications that further improve interoperability and connectivity between systems. Afterall, that's what Novell knows how to do well.

by pipe guy

I think it would be a very safe bet that in the next two years there will be a catastrophic failure of the Windows Server Products. When this happens, it will force many IT Directors to seek out "secure" and "safe" products. The class action lawsuits haven't started yet, but when they do... Everyone will turn from these products that caused the problem faster than you can say, "Firestone Tires on Ford Explorers". There is no question that learning the new Netware/Linux product will be time consuming and a frustrating ordeal. Many Netware specialists are daunted by the task at hand. But once they've built two or three servers in this "brave new world", they will start to appreciate why Novell has gone down this apparently lonely road. The only threat that M$ claims in their annual report, isn't Sun, Novell or IBM... their only threat is "linux" and "open sourced" IT systems. If Linux runs successfully for Banks and Insurance companies on Netware boxes... as it will. Smaller businesses will also adopt it just has they have adopted the Apache web server that currently runs on Netware servers. Especially when their information has already been compromised on a recent MS box. With the host of privacy legislation enacted over the past year or so in North America it will only be a matter of time before M$ will be attempting to defend itself against a "hopelessly" insecure server system. But as a consultant who gets paid for fixing systems.... the M$ world is probably a lot more lucrative until you get named in the law suit... So just because M$ has the resources to fight a lengthy legal battle. This doesn't mean that the dealers and network specialists that convinced the law firms and insurance companies to turn to MS in the first place will still be in business after some enormous identity theft occurs from a large firm and the fingers start to get pointed. But of course this is only a theory. But if the recent spat of viruses is any indicator of what is to happen in the future... Just one of the viruses has to be successful at both spreading itself, "hijacking" information and then causing huge physical damage by "repartitioning" or reformating hard disks. It will happen... its only a matter of time. And when it does... the handwringing will soon turn to "neck wringing" . Personally I'd prefer to had recommended the system I knew wasn't full of security holes. But having to patch two of them each week, does provide a tempting consulting fee.

by elph

Hi, I've lived on both sides of the fence for quite some time now - supporting large Email environments that center around Microsoft Exchange. We've got a lot of infrastructure that makes up the environment, including edge devices that are running an extremely secure build of Linux with Postfix doing mail relay. Inside we've got bridgeheads and mail servers running W2K and Exch2K. As far as supporting the environment goes, the people who carry pager for the Windows boxes are busy 90% of the time responding to issues, etc. Whereas the Linux pager people spend maybe 10% of their time responding to issues, etc. The learning curve for Linux is a little steeper, but the advantage of that is that it's going to be harder for other people to reach the same level of expertise that you can acquire, without investing a similar amount of time.

Linux is definitely here to stay - but Microsoft is not going anywhere. I believe Novell has made a very wise decision in embracing Linux and leveraging their expertise in building solutions around it. The biggest difference between MS systems and Linux-centric systems, in my experience, is that Linux systems are much more specific in nature - or in other words, you don't run as many apps on them. That, in combination with an inherently secure OS, makes for a very pleasant platform to work on (once you reach a certain level of base knowledge). Microsoft boxes are generally multi-purpose, serving several different roles in an environment, which automatically cuases the support time to increase, due to the increased complexity. Both have their place and things they're better at.

I don't think you can go wrong with investing time in learning more about Linux and the new offerings of Novell. Regardless of how Novell does with it's offerings, the skills you'll learn with Linux will transfer easily into any future jobs you may have. And if you get the training now, you'll be slightly ahead of a wave of people who are looking more every day towards a landscape in which *nix is a big player in places previously dominated by Microsoft. Skills with Microsoft product will also continue to be in high demand, but your best strategy is to pick a niche where you want to become known as a "specialist" - be that messaging, active directory, networking, etc. Do the work to gain the certs but focus your electives and personal study to becoming proficient in that niche and eventually you'll be to a point where the certs are nice for the resume but your experience will be more important when it comes to face to face time with a customer or employer.

Good luck, making a fork in the road decision like this is always hard.

by rpvlko

I am trained in the use of NetWare mounted on both Linux and Microsoft OS and in Microsoft products used to provide a secure Enterprise enviornment. NetWare mounted on Linux isn't any harder to learn than Active Directory and it doesn't have all the "backdoors" Microsoft builds into its products. If you want security go with Novell. The written material may not come with as many illustrations but your better than that anyway.

by oz_media

Nobody has mentyioned what is the real backbone to Novell right now, which in my view is GroupWise and the i-Folders.

Groupwise is like a fortress for email, GWAVA for groupwise gets the spam and virus scanning taken care of BEFORE the messages are passed to the MTA for distro.
Groupwise has the nicest and safest web access i've worked with, the Border Manager VPN is second to none and ZenWorks is well.....zen to work with?

Novell isn't just the NOSprovider anymore as they have improved messaging and file sharing/collaboration systems that are finally offering funcionality, stability and security well above and beyond the MS offerings.

Now with NW 6.5 ALSO coming BOXED with
Apache 2.0.45
MySQL 4.0.12
Perl 5.8
PHP 4.2.3
Tomcat 4.1.18

they are providing an entire suite of tools instead of the basic NOS offerings of yesterear.

Couple that with Virtual Office and you've got one hell of a value for money.

http://tinyurl.com/2fwfz Check out the Virtual office FLASH demo from the first link it's STUNNING!!

by stephen

Sounds like you're frustrated with not being sure of where to go, and although there is plenty of MS work out there, you'll also be fighting for that work with every other equally experienced (or better) MCSE out there of which there are many. Easier work usually = mediocore money.
Even from your own original post, you've already identified a possible good source of future income - Migrating NetWare clients to Linux. Yes, training is necessary but you should easily be able to command more money with NetWare to Linux migrations than with the currently more common NetWare to Windows migrations.
There will be fewer people properly qualified and with the number of NetWare installs still out there you should find plenty of business.

BTW: You CAN get plenty of software from Novell that isn't timebombed - it's called the Novell Software Evaluation and Development Library which if you qualify comes for free, or is US$250 which if you're running a business should be completely tax deductable and is a very small price to pay to enhance your business.

by junk

I absolutely agree with you. In Islamabad, their are only two well known netware guys, I am one of two, Once both of us are hired for a project by world bank based on netware, some where out side of islamabad, NDS Technologies a netware 5 user co. had to wait for one week, I had an experties in linux, mac & ms, I am often contacted for technical support for the above mentioned platforms, I don't feel hasitant, to support them. some of my clients are ISPs, pure unix environment.

I am proud that my 1st NOS is novell netware 3.11, from where I had developed my experties of NOSes, you should be multi dimentional, don't stick to one platform.

This is your experties, who will pay, not the novell dealership.

regards.

by stephen

But I've seen FEWER problems with Novell than MS products which can't be explained/fixed. I don't like one eyed Novell supporters any more than MS supporters... Both products can work.

On a slightly different topic, maybe Hagstrom could have his Novell buddies post their problem in the support.novell.com newsgroup forums. I've been helped on many occasions from people who support and install the systems themselves, so they're not just phone tech support, which has proved invaluable to myself and others in the past.

by philip.coakes

It's lunchtime her in Blighty, so I can't resist...

"No system is problem free". Never a truer word was spoken! And as Stephen says, both product families can be made to work, and work well.

But my experience indicates that the biggest cause of a broken network is poorly trained specifiers, implementers and administrators. There are dozens of reasons why this happens: Poor management, that accepts the lowest bid to get the job done, without appropriate risk evaluation and management; Company Culture, that sees IT as a cost and not as a business enabler; Lack of a sandbox or test network. I could go on...

I'm Bi-Certified and have set up many a network of either flavour, from scratch or migrations (both ways - MS to Novell & Novell to MS). I have also gotten involved in trouble shooting small business and corporate networks. Here is a truism: There are "good" networks, and there are "bad" networks. A network is much more than just the flavour of NOS & client OS. A badly designed or poorly understood or incorrectly configured network can be a nightmare. Once again, I have encountered both good and bad with either an MS or Novell NOS.

Poorly designed DNS and associated name services, bridge / router / filtering, mixed frame types and additional protocols on the wire can have a disasterous effect on the environment, so I would suggest that these elements are factored in to your problem solving. If you don't address your network foundation, you can migrate to MS, and still have a huge raft of problems to deal with.

Thinking of the cited example, I encountered a mixed eDirectory/AD network, where as soon as the Novell client was introduced to an XP Pro workstation, it went like a dog with its hind lege ripped off! Turns out, the DHCP client scope was pointing to the Novell DNS server, and not the AD DC's DNS. I changed the DHCP scope, renew leases, and XP client went like a rocket again. The guy who installed the AD had also configured his DNS server as a root server (think about it...) Just one example of many where a look at the fundamentals of the network changed the way the whole thing worked.

Problems can also be compounded, by simply upgrading. So is it possible that a "new" NetWare 6.5 server is in fact an upgraded server, carrying forward all the configuration faults of its previous incarnation, rather than a "freshie" followed by a tree merge, or the use of the Server Consolidation Wizard? Have problems that were cleared up in the past been properly documented, and the reasoning behind the "fix" understood?

Have you ever installed a service pack, without reading the readme.txt? It's a mistake you should only ever make once.

My wife used to be in the dressmaking / tailoring trade, where they have a saying. "Measure Twice, Cut Once"! It's stood me in good stead since my own "bad" network - I haven't had one since.

by asimpson

Some good points were discussed about the training and software availability that Novell defeninitly needs to work on. However, in the past Novell has consistantly delivered fairly straight forward packages that don't require thick books to learn enough to support and install. I installed 2.2 as a test from my boss when I was hired, I had never heard of Novell before that, and had no documentation, the install took an hour and was fully functional. From there I learned 3.12, and 4.11 on the job, again, no big books required, Became a 5.0 CNA by self study, no professional classes, (but did buy 2 big books for that), and again with 6.0 and 6.5.

Our company has 2 MCSE's that still have read or go to class for everything they need, ESPECIALLY Exchange and its miriad of problems and fixes.
I've never had a Groupwise server take more than
3 hours to fix. And don't get started on Microsoft's complex licensing requirements.

I'm sure that changing to Linux will cause some headaches, but with Novell's expertise in packaging their products it will be manageable. Plus Novell is still the most stable and (in my opinion at least) superior product. Besides, Linux is cathing on, and being able to support it in the future might be a bigger benifit than anyone realizes now.

by oz_media

You're right. Even though I went to school for my MCNE, I studied for my 5.1 CNA just by on the job experience.

I actually went to London Drugs (big retail drug store) that has a clearance bin for computer books. The Mastering 5.0 text was $9.95 (down from $80.00) I just looked into what had changed between 5 & 5.1 and passed the CNA first time around. Piece of cake really. the MCNE was a little more daunting but I talked a former employer into paying for that one.

by smcgirk

A recent TCO published by IDC shows the cost of MS Windows vs. Linux over 5 years that Windows is a lower cost. Smart companies will go with what is has a lower TCO and better ROI. While it's good to have skills in both but my money is on MS. Server 2003 and II 6 blow away the competition, i thought i would never say that but it's true.

PS: don't count out Netware yet, it's still as solid as ever.

by stephen

It's nice to quote TCO stats isn't it? Win3.1 workgroup server, NT3.51, NT4..... none had reasonable TCO's yet they were still installed. If you, or anyone else bothers to read entire TCO reports you will see they are never as obvious as a single stat. Business structure, industry, country and many other factors will heavily influence TCO.

I can quote REAL LIFE stats from where I'm sitting but somewhere else it may be very different. We run *legacy* NetWare 5.1 on 40 servers (newest is 3 years old) with GroupWise, ZENworks for Desktops, Handhelds & Servers, BorderManager supporting 1500 users with 2 admins - total. This includes all facets of server related monitoring, maintenance (inc. backups), troublshooting and 3rd line support issues which our service desk can't fix.

We are moving to a complete Win2003 environment using 20 servers (all brand new) and a SAN and are using consultants from MS - not a partner, but MS themselves. They've told us: 2 admins for Exchange, 1 for SMS, 1 for Mom and 2 3rd line support. These will be dedicated roles. Add to this the increase in licensing and for OUR environment it will carry a LOT higher TCO than our current infrastructure. We are still moving to a consolidated MS environment due to business goals and long term strategy where MS will be playing a very big part.

TCO isn't the be-all-and-end-all of why you should choose an OS.

by grindylow

It's can be fun to speculate about the demise of Novell an poke fun at some of their past business decisions. But we won't know the results of Novell's recent and present strategic moves until sometime in the future. What will the market reaction be over time? Will we embrace the Novell robust support infrastructure combined with solid Linux solutions integrated by the Suse and Ximian acquisitions? Who knows. IBM is trying the same thing...

What about eDir, ZENworks, iFolder, BOMA, iPrint, etc.? Novell is working to make all of these tools platform independent.. and their functionality is excellent at present.

I currently manage an environment with 6000 workstations at over 100 sites utilizing ZfD4 (with and without the client) to deploy over 1200 different applications, Netware 6.0/6.5 over IP using CIFS to eliminate dependence on IPX for highly available, fast, and extremely manageable file services, iFolder for data replication and backup at more remote locations, iPrint maps for techno-tard printer installation, and more... Novell helps us kick major butt..

Our Netware 6.5 clustered servers offer cheap, fast and highly available file services (and a few other services we've included in the cluster)along with data replication services.

Yes, we have some EMC filers ($$$$$$), and YES they are unbreakable and fast... So we have a battle there, and so does Novell in the long-term.

I think Novell is making some bold, smart, strategic moves. But only the future will tell if they (and I) are right about that.

We'll see...

My biggest gripe right now is AD GPO management, Desktop vulnerability holes, and other MSFT related pain. We're patching fiends just like everyone else, but in this case ZENworks is saving MSFT butt.

my 2 cents.

by skiphefel

Linux: no experience, but anyone that is keeping up with the trade journals and technology jobs will see that Linux is quickly becoming the defacto open standard. Why else would Novell's stock go from $2.50 up to $10.00 in a short time that it acquired it. The intelligent wall street investors know something. Security: About maybe 1-1.5 security notices/ issues per month according to the SANS report. Plan to see tighter security as users implement eDirectory famed for it rock solid security.

NetWare: I've worked with NetWare and GroupWise since late '94 and have found it to be secure, stable, and robust when I worked for a major college publisher and later a major midwest health care provider. Both used NetWare and GroupWise for major cost savings and minimal babysitting of it's servers. Presently, I do some consulting for a couple of small businesses that I average about 40 hours per year on work station and server issues. This past year about 10 hours was wasted on a failing HP tape drive and troubleshooting it. They are running NW4.2 for small business and GW5.2. They have no people with any IT background and are fully dependent on external support. Just recently I was asked to start working on a upgrade proposal to NW6.5 for Small business.

Presently, the company I work for using NetWare 5.1 throughout the enterprise for file, print, and network security. Also we use the ZenWorks for Desktops to quickly apply the M$ policies for the specific departments and users and to deliver shortcuts to apps and upgrades.
Security: one or two issues a year if that.

Micro$oft: Spending is the largest chunk of IT budget. Virus attacks and security issues twice a week on the average. Network traffic is generated daily for the workstation to constantly get updated almost daily with virus signatures.
Major amounts of baby sitting and maintenance.

Good luck on your decision!

by dwdino

Come up with a decent product. Refine it. Bury it.

What actually killed Novell, was Novell. Microsoft sold itself. Unix was entrenched. Therefore Novell found its niche fans, and was content. Novell needs some Gates influence if it is to become a major player again.

I am hoping Novell doesn't drive its great aquisitions into the ground, as is its habbit.

by sbastian

Just a thought.. The day when we all can get things done without learning shell commands *and* simultaneously have all the necessary *stable* software available, we'll be in heaven. Until then, I couldn't ever recommend a Linux/whatever only neighbourhood. Netware is dead, so is NT4.. MacOSX will probably stay dictated by Apple also, so the best choice would be to try to pick up the best things from all worlds. Which, sadly enough, is going to be pretty darn expensive.

by nicknielsen

I knew that you could...

Actually, nothing other than Windows will ever be ready for the corporate desktop. What M$ has done (and quite successfully, so far) is to calculate to the third or fourth decimal place exactly how much change they can force down corporate users' throats without causing them to change OSs.

The one thing business users hate more than M$ is spending money, and it costs more money to train your end users to use a completely new operating system than it does to bring them up to speed on the new M$ excretion...

by oz_media

We will never have need for more computing power than a 386 offers.

We will never be able to have a secure credit card system in place and if so, nobody will use it.

From your BOLD statement that you will eat in time,all I can say is never say never.

I know several Medium/large coporations that are using Novell's Suse Linux for desktops or DX2 as opposed to having ANY MS products onsite whatsoever.

A company I remote network admin for has not a single shred of MS anywhere in house. They will NOT use any MS product for any reason and have banned MS from thier organization all together.

Never say never, or at least not in such a closed and blantant way. You are already wrong, I wonder what will happen when this becomes wider and wider spread.

by dwdino

I just finished downloading, installing, and playing with XD2.

It is a much improved interface than most other X environments.

Still, nothing from the Linux world comes anywhere near the refinement and ease of the Microsoft desktop. While I like and use Linux in the server arena; for desktops, HELL NO!

by oz_media

What do you mean what actually killed Novell?

Novell has shown a positive cash surplus for some time now, they are going strong as ever and building new customer relationships all the time. Novell hasn't been KILLED nor have they gone anywhere.

It's the same thing (sorry for this) as 80's heavy metal bands. Because they aren't playing shows in North America they are considered GNOE. Most of those bands have had full careers and have been recording as always, because they are not in YOUR media focus, they are considered dead or gone.

Twisted Sister just headlined a gig in Sweden, they are considfered GONE too as they aren't in the media spotlight in North America anymore.

Just remember, YOU may have foprgotten about NOvell, they may not have the same in you face advertising tht MS has, but they are FAR from going anywhere. They have recently released thier most robust and full featured NOS yet, AND have already been deploying Linux Kernel networks all over North America. BUT, you haven't heard or seen too much of them lately so they are gone or as you say "killed".

Way to close a door and cut yourself off from opportunity!

by lsisk2

I find that in the IT industry there is one overwhelming problem that plagues it. It is the lack of talent, and the number of certified persons who hold jobs when they can not perform the required task. There are too many paper certificates holders still. But true talent is always in short supply. I?ve met quite a few MCSEs, and CNEs that I would never let work on a system I was responsible for, if I had my say.

One company I worked for migrated to Win/AD because the CIO loved it. They called it more stable than NetWare. But they have a regular reboot schedule for the Win2K servers, something that they would never have considered for the NetWare servers. The biggest problem they had was with the third party server apps. You know things like virus scan and backup software that caused problems with all of their Intel servers.

I agree with you networks are complicated creations. Each is different. There are many legacy networks that need work. If you upgrade your old systems without looking at all of the settings, you are just perpetuating old problems. I find that you find a lot of people that complain the most are the ones that know the least about the problem.

As far as Zenworks I?ve found that if you don?t standardize your desktops you will have major problems. That is true with any desktop management program. I don?t mean the same OS, but each OS must be consistent. This should have been part of a properly laid out and fully implemented deployment plan.

A lot of in-house deployments that are under-funded under staffed and/or under financed turn out to be disasters. Management always seems to blame the product (Which is valid in some cases.) But it is always easier than excepting management?s shortsighted understanding of the total value of the project. Of course a good desktop management tool may hurt the empire building ambition of midlevel managers.

by david_thomson

Hello people,
The question is not so much about quality of OS but the profitability of understanding the OS. As a comparison Betamax VCRs were better quality and I am sure the Betamax technicians and VHS technicians were arguing just as solidly.
Betamax is still in use today, just not the general public.
If one is a consultant, one will follow the money (first rule of business). This means understanding as much as possible. This does not mean we blindly follow a single path - that is not the way of the consultant.
If one is an Admin for a company, whatever is best for the company (read: good business case + financial stewardship = solid IT for company). Fact is all things being equal I can buy an MS professional for 2/3 the price of a Netware guy and 1/2 as much as a Unix bod (I won't even bother about Mac OS).
The reason for the debate is why should someone spend a bucket load of money and time for a NEW OS with NEW bugs and NEW features that will take 10x the implementation time in after shocks to settle down.
If I was responsible (read: CIO/IS Manager) of a business with 1000s of nodes I would want something that could be rolled out, supported and upgraded with two conditions: 1. Don't Spend alot of $ and 2. Make it easy and smooth. (in order of preference).
If anyone thinks they can say "Patches, we don't need no stinkin Patches" - they deserve to be booted out of IT.
My experience tells me: Sofwtare companies don't fix problems they patch them.
Fact is: MS has done alot for the industry (and me personally) by bringing IT out into the open. Let us not forget IPX/SPX was based on (and I have never seen Novell doco to credit)XNS and also that Novell abandoned IPX only recently to join the world with TCP/IP (and I won't even credit the wrapping up IPX/SPX into UDP packets as a protocol).
I had to support these environments - it can be painful.
Alas, I digress.
Thank you for your time.

by yule

I have old hardware running old Novell 4.11 - - -It just runs - and runs and runs - - get it.

Now Microsoft - - Well - - If I could have all my stuff on Novell, I could sleep at night knowing it would still be running in the morning.

Nuff said there

As for the original question. Learn the Linux. Microsoft will have to live with penguins in the network regardless of how much the whine and give SCO money to fight with. My 14 year old is living in a Linux only world, and he does his own management on old hardware. Yes there is a learning curve, but if you have the time - you can do it.

by garryallen

I don't make a lot of money from Novell, at least not directly. Most of my clients who have Novell Servers have almost forgotten that they have them. They practically never go down and they certainly don't generate a lot of service revenue. I have never had a client request a Novell Server - I've had to SELL every d*mn one of them. On the other hand, I'm very popular with my clients and between us we can generally find other (more interesting) ways for me to make money than servicing flakey systems.
If you have been doing this for very long, you surely must have noticed that change and a constant need for learning is inevitable in this business. Novell 6 is not Novell 3, XP is not NT, GUI apps are not DOS apps, etc. Try thinking of the Linux/Novell thing as Novell getting a new kernel. My guess is that on the level that you normally have to deal with, there will be much that is familiar.
I've been doing this long enough (25 yr) that I must confess it gets a little harder each time to contemplate the effort of 'starting over' but I'm actually hoping that Novell makes a big success of this venture.

by all2tropical

No system is fail safe, right? However, the major difference in
the Unix world is that the OS is only as safe and secure as the
Admin is savvy. A novice Unix/Linux person does not have the
base knowledge to manipulate a complex configurations of open
Linux systems, or large clusters of Sun systems that have to
route and interface with other platforms. It is especially trying
when programers are creating security holes with their web
applications. It takes knowledge, time and a lot of patience.

by pauldrumm

I have been working with NT since Advanced Server 3.1 (no this is not Windows 3.1 young'uns), Novell since ver 2 and Unix, probably SCO was the oldest ver. 4 or 3? I forget. Apple? not worth the text.

I have had networks running MS, Novell, and SCO (HP-UX, and Sun).
I kept hearing about BSOD and NT is not stable Mostly from novice admins. People whom did not know how to read the HCL(look it up) did get blue screens much the same way SCO or unix dumped with ineffective hardware or improper set ups or the same way Novell abended when it had improper hardware or improper setups. I saw it all as a consultant.
MS was always picked on, why? They had a GUI admin interface in the server OS that took the majority of the market so of course you heard more complaints from more novice, and I admit, experienced admins.

NT 3.5 was rock solid for a file server as long as you followed MS guidelines. So was SCO but it was a pain in the keister to administer and too often the hardware selection was limited. Novell was the same. 3.12 was a great product but the admin functionallity really blew. Novell 4.11-6.5 had great addons and nice features for admins but fell short. They all had patches and security flaws, always. I never considered one much better than the other for a base OS but MS was easier to administer. If Checkpoint and Raptor could put firewalls on Microsoft NT then it could not be too bad.

Hey, I have pushed customers from Novell 5.1 to 6.5 so I am not against any OS. It just made business sense.

I still consider all products as rock solid, but for a administrator that needs to integrate 20 different functionalities on the same platform MS is the best, always improving. SQL, Exchange, Visual Studio, ISA, Biztalk, Commerce, IIS, etc. Sun, SCO, HP,and Novell failed to offer products to compliment the product line. Apple finally went to Unix, for Novell the writing was on the wall. Hmmm, I need an OS, a mail server, a database server (ouch Novell, should of bought out Sybase) that all comes from one vendor who I can call. I do not need vendors pointing fingers.

Bottom line guys and gals. Move to MS and stop calling it M$ and whining. Most good admins saw the writing on the wall years ago. Novell is still a good system but with the smaller companies paying pennies to novice admins make you say, which is easier to administer, Novell, SCO, Solaris, Linux-pic-a-flavor,BSC Unix (or its variants - gee-Apple?), or Microsoft? Which has a shorter learning curve?

Paul Drumm
MCDBA,MCSE+I, MCSE, MCP+I,MCP and oh yeah, CCNA.
The only other cert I bothered to get was a Cisco. I knew both of them would always be around.

by jmstrupp

HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!
HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!
HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!

by oz_media

Your demeaning attitude shows one thing, and it's not pretty. Your arrogance of your knowledge is completely uncalled for as you know absolutely nothing about anyone here except what you perceive from these posts. Your conversational attitude is that of a child and REALLY looks bad in such a mixed forum of IT staff from all corners of the globe.

The experience I have seen on TR covers everything from the new WinDOZE user to the seasoned M$ engineer, your ssumption is without qualification. Your post was simply an arrogant slam at anyone who had voiced an opinion on the subject that didn't have the audacity or arrogance to list a plethora of BS certifications after his/her name.

I know people who would probably walk circles around your abilities and certified knowledge that have never even seen an IT classroom.

What an absurd, uneducated, immature and overall pathetic attempt at making yourself look and feel good.

"Novell failed to offer products to compliment the product line" - GroupWise, PHP, MySQL, Apache, ZenWorks, XD2, Console One, GWAVA, Virtual Office...?

Many of which are included in the box.

by davwatson

I had the pain of dealing with NetWare 5 for 8 months, what a P.O.S. But what else is guy thinking of doing besides following the money? What is he thinking he has a long term career in the U.S. with something? If you are still making the payments on the BMW keep following the money, you know what happens to people who don't.

by oz_media

I think the scary part is (judging by your domain) you are affiliated with the school system and you're knowledge, or lack thereof, maybe passed onto tomorrow's youth.

Do you always take a single experience with the most reliable and easily configued product around and use it to determine tha products effectiveness?

Do you REALLY think Novell is going somewhere, even though they are showing positive growth now?

Other than MS, they are one of the ONLY NOS providers with a positive cash flow/surplus, people who KNOW Novell have no problems with it and swear by it's stability.

Perhaps an educated opinion would come across a little better next time, not just a frustrated experience.

by marmstrong

For all of Microsofts flaws, in the end it comes back to one simple thing. Ease of use. I've trained people in many different environments, and by far Windows is the simplest. The likelyhood is 95% of the people on this forum are accessing it using a Microsoft OS. And as for stability, we have 7 servers, and most go 6 months before reboots. It all boils down to compatibility. If it's compatible, chances are, your problems will be few, and far between.

by oz_media

I manage several Netware servers for several companies vie remote networking.

Lat week I installed a new Antivirus system on one, I installed an excellent SPAM solution on another (has caught 98% of SPAM , no false positives) and haven't rebooted either of them.

This is NEW software and software upgrades, NO REBOOT.

If I had to reboot a Netware server every 6 months, I'd be onsite trying to find out what the hell was wrong with it. I nkow in a MS world 6 months between boots is a reason to bake a cake but in a Netware world, it's reason to rebuild your server.

as for user friendly, I am starting to see the exact opposite.

First you assume that everyone uses a MS box to access TR, I think you'd be surprised at how many don't or how FEW do.

As for users friendly, I think it's the other way around. A new user isn't as strapped to the MS GUI as a savvy user may be. A proficient MS user knows how to tweak and edit the registry and system files, this all changes with linux and therefore the savvy user is now a new user and doesn't like the change. A new MS user, email and surfing, isn't as OS dpendant and can be easily taight XD2 (Linux for desktops)which REALLY doesn't take any adjustment as it acts almost the same as windows. I have a feeling you are al picturing a blank screen with a prompt on it, not the pretty GUI of XD2, which by the way comes prepacked with a MS Office compatible suite, graphics programs, AV, etc. IN THE BOX!

If I saw a compelling reason to recommend MS, I would do it, I sell and service networks, why would I cut off a segment of my own income?!?
When I see nothing but headaches and complaints from customers, I smile knowing that I didn't recommend thier nightmare and some MCSE did instead, yet I will profit from switching them to something more stable and keeping the user happy with the same tools on a reliable system.

by therrington

Maybe all yo guys that have all the cerifications are missing a point: It's ALWAYS hard learning something new. I have 3 Novell servers, and 1 Win 2000 server. I have no classroom training, and really no outside help. From my perpective, neither one is particulaly easy to use. Nether is especially "friendly", and the documentation STINKS for both. I am the sysadmin at a small school. The nearest source of help is 70 min away. I can't call, as they don't do phone support.
I will say that I rarely have an outage on any of my Novell boxes. My advice is to suck it up and bite the bullet, and learn something new

by mill3502

Novell isn't dead and never will be dead. But I believe you have to watch just how much you become a jack of all trades and an expert at none. Even if you decide to specialize in a peticular manufacture of server operating system it is always best to know them all a "little" because there is no such thing (outside of governments) as a single OP SYSTEM in your shop.

by 1coordinator

I could not agree more!

It was Microsoft who gave computers and Software the acceptants it has today.
Im in this businnes for almost 20 years.

Sorry for the type flawes but my englisch is a bit rusty

CNA - MCSE - CLP (Novell - MIcrosoft - Notes)

by dostberg

Novell was not doing well with only NetWare. They seemed to finally realize this and are attempting to make adjustments. I am learning this new offering now and I think that if it can deleiver on half of what it promises, Novell will succeed. Change is good and growth is needed to survive.

by gorto

I administer a blended environment with Novell, Microsoft, Linux and Sun Solaris. By far the Unix machines are the most expensive to support with Microsoft second and at the other end of the $cale Linux and Novell. The only expense for Novell was the initial purchase 4 years ago and a couple of failed drives. The Linux machines have been running two years without a problem and just require scheduled maintenance. All patches and application upgrades for Linux go on via apt-get and I can't say enough about how great this works. We will probably not continue with the MS Solution due to upgrade costs to operating system, client access licenses and hardware. I think the Linux/Novell union is a good thing. The simplicity and logic of Linux and the rock solid file and print services of Novell. I really think that this is a win, win.

by midzonetec

Unix was developed as the "software" and "IP" concepts were being defined. The players were less numerous. Linux is controlled by the community. it will be a lot more difficult for a company to justify price gouging when you can just pull it down for free and get people to administer it in house. Also the number of computer literate people has increased tenfold from when the Unix's were developed. It is not the arcane art it once was. As more people become familiar with Linux the TCO will continue to drop.

by rickb8

Novell introduced 'NetWare'? At a time when Microsoft was not shipping a GUI, Novell was shipping personal network servers. NetWare, NetWare68 (!), NetWare86, NetWare 2.x, all came out before I knew Microsoft had a server product.

Novell even tackled the problem of small hard drives. Remember the DCB?

Many other companies came and went in the server business... LanTastic, 3Com, even Banyan, where StreetTalk was the only directory service anywhere for a long time. Even Novell followed them.

Claiming that Microsoft has given computers and software the acceptance it has today points out the method they used: Make the systems prefer each other, ignore or thwart compatibility with existing competitors, and seed the development community with tools. And give developers a consistent environment from server to user. Only Apple has done as well, and well they have a very small market share. Probably due to mistakes similar to Novell's.

Besides, I'm unaware of a recent NetWare security flaw. I thin you can count all of them on one hand. And maybe an extra thumb...

rick

by ninejaguar

"Show me proof"

If you're reading this or typing a reply, it's right in front of you.

= 9J =

by oz_media

as a webdesigner myself, it is common knowledge that practically everybody 'big' is using Linux , Apache, PHP and MySQL. Not too many companies run a reliable portal or web app server in a Windows enviro.

Funny enough, Novell's Netware 6.5 comes with PHP, Apache and SQL IN THE BOX!

This is besides Novell Linux!

by voldar

Oz, this confirms what I said before. Linux is used because for now is free, let's not pretend we don't know the reason, and yes, LINUX is GOOD in WEB environment. What was before linux on the web? This is a question I'd like to know the answer.
(UNIX? NOVEL?)

by ninejaguar

"Servers in linux, lets be fair, many of them are only web-mail servers, firewalls and routers. Nothing more!"

You're quite off on that. First, when you say "only web-mail servers" you're dismissing a wide range of products. For instance, TechRepublic which you're reading and typing replies too isn't just a website. It's an application that runs on Linux + Apache. When you go buy a book from Amazon, you're interacting with a very sophisticated application that runs on Linux. When you Google your way through the Web, guess what you're using? When governments over the world are beginning to mandate transitions to Open Source Operating Systems, guess which one they're talking about? When Universal Studios needs to whip up a quick internal web-based application to interface with their legacy mainframe data, they turn to Java on Linux.

Speaking of Java... now that it's about to be Open Sourced by Sun with IBM's pushing, plan to see the Java + Linux killer combination everywhere. There is some overhead and time required to learning something as powerful as *nix-like Operating Systems. Now's the time to start if you don't already know how to operate Linux, and get a jump on the rest of the M$ crowd.

= 9J =

by voldar

And it's very well known that it could be run also in a Windows 2000 - Apache server. The key ward is Apache = "An open source >> Web server << originally formed by taking all the "patches" (fixes) to the NCSA Web server and making a new server out of it" (definition I found on the net).
I was not that wrong I think when I said about WEB SERVERS. And yes, it's a good thing to know linux, but this is not because it is better or the best of. Be rezonable and agree with its limits and limitations. There is no program/OS/NOS which is the best, but is allways a program/OS/NOS that best suits your needs. Point of story!

by tom_sawyer70

Sounds like an administrative problem (based on the W95-XP roll out and support of a 5000 user environment, and seeing the two techs here support 16,000 users). I've never seen Zen randomly pull administrative rights to a machine, but then I don't want my users to have that type of access anyway.

"The biggest pain is when asking Novell the only response, if any, we get from them is "...install a patch...install a patch...""

You've got a point here...You don't have to ask Microsoft for a patch, just watch the news, the papers and the internet sites. If you have a question whether you need the patch, an easy litmus test is whether your entire network is down or not the next morning. You can save the 'well, my network has never had such a problem,' because the fact of the matter is that either you're lying or you've wasted your life applying all of those patches (and will continue to do so weekly).

Many times, problems are incurred because of Microsoft's software, but they will not own up to it. Why, when an OS upgrade comes along, do I find myself on the phone with third-party companies who are now scrambling to patch their software rather than having MS fix what they obviously corrupted? Ever wonder why you have to upgrade third-party applications when you upgrade your Windows OS (in addition to the probably hardware upgrade you'll need), but a 16yo can write a virus that whacks every Windows version?

Yeah, go to an all-MS shop. Good luck.

by oz_media

I installed an XD2 based network for a major accounting company.

Whle the users had good keyboarding skills they only knew Windows basics from using at home.

The learning curve was easy for them, they absolutely LOVE the stability and thoer accounting apps run like a top over the VPN.

VERY happt clients that didn't have much computer experience other than the home user basics, email , surfing etc. These people didn't manilpulate Windoze system files and tweaks they just used email web surfing etc. an EASY adjustment unless you are a savvy user that relies on the Windows system structure.

Which brings me to another thought. Is it maybe the OPPOSITE as people think? Savvy Windows users will be inclined to use Windoze as they know where everything is hidden/tweaked etc.

A basic or 'non-savvy' Windoze user wouldn't be SO tied to the OS and would adjust easier to a new OS?

by 1mimmer45vvan

I don't think it have anything to do with reading up on the operating system before making comments.
It true M$ really is a bad OS to begin with. $$$$ greedy, too expensive, too many bugs and holes, the list goes on...........

Too many law suit against the company tell me something about the company to begin with.

Go with Linux or Mac if you want your money worth.

by johnatakis

I guess I am coming from the other viewpoint, thus a different "Paradigm" I am certified as a MCSE with Microsoft and have been supporting Microsoft since 98. I am also Novell certified with a couple MCNEs. I have been doing Novell since 91.

I needed to learn Microsoft because that is the number one client to Novell. I did more Microsoft work because for every 300 machines I had one Novell server and 299 Microsoft machines. I now help support a network with a directory just shy of 100,000 objects. We have over 5,000 Microsoft machines and just 30 Novell servers. Even though I am hired as a Novell Engineer on the Novell network, I still have to know and understand Microsoft because much more than half of my time is dealing with Microsoft problems on the network.

So now Novell gives me another choice to sit my best of breed services on. GroupWise, NetMail, iFolder, iPrint, eDir, HTML, LDAP, security and don't let me forget File services. So what if they don't sit on a DOS machine with NetWare on it any more. I am not using NetWare, I am using the services. Let them sit on a Linux box; let them sit on a Microsoft box. Just don't take away my Novell services or the quality and ease of use. I still have to support the Microsoft machines anyway.

I am looking forward to what Novell has to offer.

Johnatakis
MCNE, MCNI, MSCE, CTT+

by dherde

I have a Novell shop and am currently actively fighting to keep my workstations from going to XP. We had an "XP, Novell, AS/400" trial that bombed so miserably that I dare not put XP on the desktop. Now heres the rub.. Although Novell has acquired ximian, and I am hearing good things about that, I have not been able to ferret out what the advantage is for my organization. A novell server on Linux is a great thing, but...

What I need is a solution for the desktop. Ximian is supposed to be able to provide that, But I still cannot see (And have not been able to get answers) how the linux desktop will:
1- map drives so that my users are not too lost in the sea of /dev.
and
2- Utilize the Novell scripting

There is a learning curve that I have to go through and it is very hard to ramp up without some help. (Book or close by and non expensive.)
I have not been able to bring up a Ximian/Redhat desktop that will get to my Novell servers and work with the files there. (Mostly MS based)

I would rather have the novell alternative because I do not want to dive into windows server heck. As well, I do not have the staff to support Microsofts problematic software. (I think this is a safe statement.)

by raiderx

I work as a Process Technician for a Global Mfg. Co. and wear multiple hats. ST has control of the global network but administration of our local plant control network has fallen to me. We replaced our plant vax system used for data collection with RH linux several years ago just before I started with the company.

When the rash of worms began last september our systems technology group dropped the ball and the worm invaded our local process control network running on NT4 boxes. The SCADA system took a serious hit that we spent many hours fixing.

To make a long story short, I had started studying linux when I discovered we had it in limited use at the plant. When the worm hit, I grabbed an old PC and setup a bridge firewall using linux for 60$ US.

That single act which I was able to do because I knew linux in addition to MS has earned me a promotion because I am the only local employee proficient in linux.

What I'm trying to say is you never know what doors lie ahead. Don't exclude yourself due to MS loyalty or any other reason. Be prepared!

by dwdino

All OS(es) have their problems. Those who proclaim MS sucks are simply not initiated to its quirks.

Point 1: MS receives the most Hack/Virus attacks because it is THE biggest target. Period. Why write destructive tools for something as puny as Mac, Linux, or Novell.

Point 2: Sorry Mac, but I have more than one brain cell, I can handle more than one mouse button. (Also cost)

Point 3: Linux is not centrally managed. Another main reason (besides familiarity) that MS is on the desktop is that with AD, I can do anything to any desktop from the top, down. ZenWorks also provides this functionality, and I believe this is why most IT persons are anxious for the Novell Linux child.

Point 4: Linux is designed to empower the knoledgeable user. One, my users would hurt themselves trying to sharpen a pencil. And second, I don't want them having any power. I am the almighty network admin, and I will grant them what I deem fit. Muhahahaha :D

Point 5: Security is the responsibility of the user as well as the OS. The problem is, too many people want to leave a system wide open, not do their homework, then whine when it is hacked. That is like driving a Porsche 911 convertible into Miami/Harlem with the top down and keys in the ignition and wondering why it was stolen. C'mon!

Point 6: Software - definitely MS favor.

See, I have multiple platforms in my environment. I have W2K AS, Novell 4 & 5, Linux, W2K Pro. Each fills it particular role. Each does it's job reliably. Each is secure. Each requires little management.

Novell is being retired, AD has been implemented. I am not, however, paying MS fees for things I can do free on Linux.

So, find the tool that works, and use it.

by oz_media

Realy? I better warn my friends who are holding an Exchange to groupWise seminar next week!

They are telling peopl eto uipgrade to something that is being retired? Oh my god, does NOVELL know? They just released 6.5 one of the most robust and secure platforms around?

Oh no! The sky is falling!

Then you woke up, right?

by dwdino

In our network, WE are retiring Novell.

The word is context, you need to quit pulling
one phrase out of a sentence/thought and getting
so worked up.

WE, US, OUR decision has been to remove Novell
as it is no longer of use. To costly to upgrade,
replaced with ADS, doesn't fulfill any purpose
on OUR network anymore.

Also, I must be one unusual dog. We have 3 W2K
AS systems, the shortest (unscheduled) reboot
cycle has been 7 months. To clarify, a scheduled
reboot is one that is done for system patches
only.

Also, I am typing this on my Dell Latitude with
SuSE 9.0. I have had to reboot this thing about
10 times to get the wireless Linksys card
working. On XP, I never rebooted and was
connected in 5 minutes, so, keep trying
Linux. :P

by stefan.davenport

I believe that the recent acquisition of Ximian and the new products that have been included in the NetWare 6.5 Operating System will be a huge benefit to NetWare but also Novell's other products. This fills a big gap for Novell, developers. One of the main problems in recent times has been a lack of 3rd party software developers working on products for the NetWare platform. By positioning NetWare to be able to run almost any Open Source web applications and leveraging this with the identity management and security provided by eDirectory Novell have opened up their developer base considerably.

The other big plus for Novell is that they are prepared to work across pretty much any platform and offer tools that can assist in minimising the additional administrative cost involved in managing multiple directory services and other systems.

Lastly, the Ximian acquisition means that for the first time in Novell's history they can actually provide products and services from the server all the way to the desktop. Assuming that the take up of Linux at the desktop continues this will also assist Novell.

by voldar

as the users don't use specific programs like AutoCAD, ArchiCAD, Plateia and I can give you a lot of other names of programs that simply don't run under Linux, and never will be.
As an Architect Firm, Civil Engineering Design firm, which is the benefit of the Linux? NONE! It's as good as a good hot steam water on wooden leg.
And I am sure, that if it was the case for you to give a solution in such a case like I specified, the only answer was M$ also. This is the story, and this it ends, for now.
As long as someone needs only text writting, mail and IE, Linux is okay. For the rest ... ouch ... still so much work to do!

by oz_media

One of the included benefits ion XD2 (Linux for desktops) is that it comes with an auto cad suite (free addin) that offers MAC AND PC AutoCad compatibility. I used to do a lot of AutoCad as a machinist and also when studying architectural draughting, so I understand your point. But any diagram you can send a XD2 user, he ca open, view, manipulate and return with full compatibility in tact. Not QUITE as robust as AUTOCAD's full featured system but compatible. not bad for a first go around, eh?

by voldar

don't get me wrong .. I know there are some signs here, there, but at a professional level, there is a lot of work to do, sometimes maybe will never be done.
What I don't really understand is why AutoDESK don't want to have a Linux ready program also. And then, I remember when working in Lyon, with an Unix program named CESAR_LCPC (finit elements in structure modeling), and it was a demand from Grece to have it in the Windows platform. At that time, LCPC did this version, but it was only for Grece, and never again. Why? Because it is so hard to move complex programs toward another platform. Sometimes is better to start from scratch.

by relicksc

If you were as aware of the origins of your CAD software and the OS that it originally ran on . . . you'd know that your statement is extremely wrong. Also, check out the CAD/CAM systems at the major design studios and see what NOS and OS is in use.

Then you'll be able to make an informed comment.

Novell is here to stay . . . M$ had better get ready to take a back seat . . . Those of you who are scared and are now complaining and crying need to go learn Linux and Netware soon !

M$ is go for home and small business use. Unix, Linux and Novell are for the rest.

by voldar

tired about people that don't know when/where to read. I said AutoCAD, not CAD, go on their site and inform better what are the requirements for installing the program. I don't say that maybe other CAD programs do not work (UNIX especially), but I am talking about specific software used in Architecture-Civil Engineering, not used in Mechanical.
Also, I have asked the re-seller I bought from for my company in Europe the licenses about the intention for creating also a Linux compatible version. For now, he said - there is no intention.
My point is that there is NO best product in the world, but there is ONLY the best product that suits your needs.
NOS - there is and there will be always UNIX/Novel/Linux/Windows, for OSs the same.
I don't really understand you guys when you blame one product against another product. Every product has its own purposes and clients.

About the question in the topic, I would say - be multi-operating systems guy, it will be the best thing to do. Know and learn how AD works, how linux-novel works, so that when time comes to give a proper advice/solution you'll be very aware about what you are talking about!
That's it! And, please take your feet, they really need a bath!

by oz_media

There have been many platforms used before Linux.
What was 'then' is irrelevant though, nothing has been stable enough to offer a viable alternative or to even offer a viable first for web apps.

The idea here is to discuss the future of these applications. Let's just say Microsoft has the worst track record in history, there are other morestable alternatives. One of the most stable codes I've ever seen run on the Internet is Python, a condensed C++ code that actually works without 45 hours of debugging by a 10 man team.

Netware has a fantastic future and is lined up to continue bringing astounding solutions to the web, the server and the desktop. It doesn't take much of a discussion to understand that MS has NEVER been stable and due to the constant need to sell new code, never wil be a stable NOS.

Sure, some people find it fun to work with and a challenge, but who wants fun or a challenge in a NOS? I'd rather firse and forget, add an update once or twice a year at MAX and never need to run maintenance or reboot. This is why I only work with companies that have the budget for Netware, the loyalty to thier IT dept (I always sign a contract, so some goofball MCSE doesn't go and start the MS push) and the knowledge of WHY they want Netware and why they benefit from it and GroupWise, Virtual desktop (sweeeeeeet!) etc.

Thise that wanna play games, go buy a joystick and MS Server 2003.

by Member 30018865

...and I'm a guy who's blood has always run red and my breastplate always sported the letter "N". I am a CNE/CNI for GroupWise and NetWare 4 and 5.

by voldar

Don't you think you are a bit "refractar" to anything else? Just a question of a novice. My blood is also red, but I don't see in that an advantage against the others :P.

-----------
Just teasing you, but we are supposed to be open minded, not to stuck on a single idea, and to think in black and white. There is a lot of "grey" between those stages.

by heywoody_99

Well first of all it has us given a stable, secure platform for mission critical files. Novell has given us an enterprise level directory, NDS/eDirectory, which Microsoft has tried, and failed, to emulate.
Every Netware shop I have worked in, almost all critical, must have, never be corrupted, cannot be lost files have been trusted to Netware servers.
Netware is not perfect, but it has come a long way, and it doesn't require insessant patching. If your box is running, and you are not experiencing problems, no need to patch.
Windows is a clickers paradise: Click here, click there, if you get it wrong, well then you point a finger at Microsoft, and shrug it off as a Windows problem, reinstall the box, and keep clicking until you get the desired (wished for) result.
Wih Netware you actually had to know what you were doing, and if you screwed up, the other admins would know very quickly who screwed what up.

by oz_media

I never really thought of the monetary costs of cross platform design. You would think Linux would be easy enouh but I am sure the problems would be crossing back to the Windows platform from Linux, Printing, rendering, finished document formats etc.

On the other hand, the COST of Autodesk software would repel a Linux user as they are generally the open source type.

Is there a term for these open sourcers yet?

We used terms tree huggers, flower power etc. to describe our 'Green Peace' save the world types of people. Usually extreme lefties politically.

But what about all these guys/gals that are into P2P file sharing, open source computing and free/community software development?

Is there a term for these freedom fighters, yet or we need to have another naming contest?

by heywoody_99

I worked a very large pharmaceutical company. All Windows boxes were scheduled for a reboot every month. We didn't even consider a reboot schedule for the 4.x and 5.x machines.
One Netware server had a CPU go bad, when we went to shut down for replacement, the Compaq tech looked at the number of days up time, which was around 1100 or so, he said that there must be something wrong with the system clock....which there wasn't!

by voldar

the time a server is up it's such a low credit to me, I even don't care about this. Will you all here say that I am lying when I tell you that my W2K server was up and running for more than 2 years? And that my linux server I had to reboot it every two weeks because was having a problem with the motherboard!
My point is the following: be master in all products and then talk. At that time I will give you all my credit. Till then, let me doubt about you.
And in the end, all is about how a server is setup from the beginning, and if it suits the needs he was build for. Till then, I am sick of hearing ?This NOS/OS is SHIT, that is the BEST?.
P.S. I may not set up properly the Linux box (but I did, and even with a guy that knows linux as I know my name). It was a DEBIAN version, and it was a real headache, and never stopped until we had to change the motherboard ? which functioned very well under Windows. That?s my experience with Linux, I don?t say this is usual case, but ? there is no PERFECT software/OS/NOS. Keep that in mind!

by oz_media

I will tell you first hand, MS NOS is garbage. Novell is the best there is.

Microsoft sucks as a company, as an operating system, as a NOS. Thier engineers are alaughing stock of wannabe coders. Security in Microsoft is an oxymoron, there's no such thing.

If you had problems with Linux, it's bacsue you are an idiot and whoever helped you didn't know his A** from a hole in the ground! Or maybe it's just because you live in Montreal and like most Canadians you are a dummy.

I know that's what you wanted to hear so I said it!

Actually, I'm just joking to get you going, honestly. ;-)

Have a great weekend mate, keep yer chin up, pour a cold beer and watch the hockey game, it sure beats all this NOS BS , talk to ya soon. :-)

by john jakus

NetWare is not going away. It is evolving. You can look at NetWare in two ways. NetWare the Kernel and NetWare the suite of Services.

NetWare the Kernel is just the Kernel. It may be replaced by Linux. As of NetWare 7, you will have your choice to run on the NetWare Kernel or Linux Kernel. The Kernel is not what makes NetWare the excellent OS it is. It's the Services that sit on top of the Kernal.

Think about it. What makes NetWare so powerful:

File System
-NSS
-File Rights are powerful yet simple
-Salvage (can't forget that nice tool)
-iSCSI
Print Services
-NDPS
-iPrint
eDirectory
-Best meta directory on the market
-Replication
-Partitioning
-Scalable
-Secure
-Efficient
WebServices
-iManager
-iFolder - Internet synching for desktops
-NetStorage - Remote access via file server
-Virtual Office
-eGuide
Netdrive - VPN type solution
DHCP - uses eDirectory instead of text files
DNS - uses eDirectory insead of text files
Cluster Services

NetWare services are easy to manage. They are scalable, stable and secure.

Now look Novell is porting all this to Linux. They are not killing any of these NetWare services.

NetWare on Linux will have:

NetWare Filesystem
eDirectory
NDPS
iPrint
NetStorage
NetDrive
iManger
iFolder
Virtual Office
eGuide
iSCSI
Cluster Services

With the Linux Kernal you will also have:

Support of the open source community
-A new bunch of appications
Apache
Tomcat
J2EE
PHP
MySQL

So if you really look at it, NetWare is not dead but evolving into a more power Operating System. The Linux Kernel is growing rapidly in the industry and Novell has some of the best technologies to enhance it.

When the world moves to Linux they will see NetWare as a must have to run their corporations.

Cheers

by john jakus

OK you say that Linux needs all this. Needs improvements to the File Services and Print Services. Well read my link below. NetWare is know for it's excellence in File and Print Services. Guess what. NetWare services are now available for Linux. NetWare 7 is due out soon and it will run all NetWare services on top of the Linux Kernel. So there you have an excellent combination of product to form a rock solid solution.

Novell is bringing some good technologies to the Linux World.

Cheers

by john jakus

Any if you have been watching the news you would have seen that IBM has a gameplan of replacing all MS software with Linux and Open Source by the end of 2005. I think a lot of large companies are going to consider this or follow suite shortly there after.

Cheers

by oz_media

But if you read the opinions here, these companies a will soon be bankrupt as they are focusing on a technology that nobody wants. We are all happy with Microsnot products and they work beter than any on he market. I mean, if the secretary can figure it out, it MUST be the best! (not to downplay the ability of any secretaries out there).

by john jakus

The reason they didn't code for NetWare was because NetWare NLMs where difficult to code. Windows was easier to code for. Novell just never got the development community plugged in.

Well now think about what is happen. The development community is divided by Windows and non-windows developers. Non windows includes open source open standards and Java technologies. Windows programs only work in Windows environments. The non-windows developers can develope for all platforms. Now look with NetWare services sitting on Linux Kernel, NetWare now has a entire new development community over night. They don't have to build the development community that they desperitly needed.

This bring great value back to NetWare.

Cheers

by treborgt

Lets face it folks, the future entails a world where there will be multitude of different NOS's, platforms, db's, etc. As was previously said, knowing more than one will be a big plus, not to mention - I think - fun. I come from an MS background, but Linux fascinates me. The one trend I see clearly is that compatibility and cross-platform support is becoming more and more the norm. It sure isnt worth arguing which is better, its a toolbox, some products are a better fit under certain criteria. Competition will spur some great improvements.

by oz_media

They waste too much time in school and then propose to know everything about an industry.

Or are you referring to overcompensation for the miniature manhood syndrome? ;-)

by voldar

Oz, as for myself, you know that I am not against anything. Just I am asking myself questions. I don't know what experience you have in a Civil Engineering/Architects environment, with a use of strict professional programs, not only MSOffice or IE or a mail (which is the most used in the most of the firms).
Linux, Netware, Novel have not been, or are not yet so "large mass expanded" to the user level so that they can look interesting for the software developers. Or I may be wrong, but ... looking from only the perspective of NOS and not also the CLIENTS and their needs (when you migrate all to another product) is quite a silly thing. And, believe me, no user is ready to learn new things once he is very proficient with a program that he used long time. When I was network administrator and did also so much desktop support (Office, AutoCAD, Corel, MicroPISTE, ArchiCAD, etc), from my experience I can tell that: if you want to change something, change also the person!! It's cheeper!
But this is hard to do, specialists are not everywhere, and when you have 10 projects to make in 1 month, you think twice before changing/switching to another environment. This is why I said and still say that switching to something just because is the best, looks to me hilarious. I, for myself, I will check on what is really the best for my entire environment (NOS and CLIENTS/SOFTWARE used), and take the best decision. Even if it may cost me lot of bucks. From now in ten years maybe things wil change, but the market, for me, for my needs, don't let me a choise, and I say that for my needs MS is the best for now.
And yes, NOS is important, but client side is also a very important thing, and when you say MS will be gone, you are so wrong, that I am almost asking myself why you say that. The development will not stop in 2004 to MS and continue only to Novel, Linux etc. This is not a natural option. It is going to be a long fight, and if you want my opinion, I believe that Linux in 10 years, if it will grow, will be no more FREE, and the professional programs will cost at the same level as they cost for the MS environment. I agree with you, there will be always free programs, but when you want professionalism, free programs is nothing. MySQL, is good for a mini, hardly a medium database, but it will never have the power of SQL or name you any other GOOD database server. And my examples may continue.

So, my answer for the master of this thread will be: learn MS if you want, learn Linux also, learn as much as you can, sometimes, knowing about other programs/software may make the difference between a good and a "best" administrator.

by antbtm

I would have thought as a consultant you would be looking at the services provided by the NOS and not the effort in retooling your organisation. If the business that you are working with requires the services offered by product "x" then this should be the provided solution. I understand as a dealer there are certain pressures to streamline the technical support for a product you supply, but don't cut your self short on product selection. There are already a number of suppliers of MS solutions, maybe Novell/Linux provides a niche market to work with.

MTC worth.

by oz_media

"and when you say MS will be gone, you are so wrong"

I didn't say that did I ? If I did, I never intended to, I have never even thought MS will be out of business, how could they? Too many people swear by MS for it to go bankrupt.

If you are referring to my last post here, I was implying that everyone seems to think Novell is going bye bye. This couldn't be farther from the truth. As I jokingly said, "...if you read the opinions here, these companies a will soon be bankrupt as they are focusing on a technology that nobody wants." I was referring to all the people who are claiming Novell is on its way out. Obviously they haven't paid much attention to Novel who is actually showing more strength and market growth than when they were one of the only options for a NOS.

I don't really care myself, I am just stating that all these people who figure Novell and Linux will soon die and leave Microsoft as the only choice are completely dilusional. How does a multi billion dollar corporation who has a niche, high end market suddenly disappear after releasing thier most valued offerings yet?

You're right, Novell, MS, Linux are not going anywhere. It will just be an issue of whether or not people have enough Microsoft patience to keep using such unfinished/unrefined products. If MS spent mroe time engineering and testing before hastily looking for new revenue and releasing it's products full of holes, it would have a much better reputation. Windows as an OS is nice to use, unforyunately, it just isn't stable enough and needs constant attention. These bugs get fixed but by the time they have a well patched OS available, they release something new. I'd just ike to see them realize that Billy Gates has enough cash for now, don't be in such a ruch to get a new flavor on the market in order to match what others are doing, just release something that is solid right out of the box.

by oz_media

Your COMPLETE unedited and paragraph in full context was;

"Novell is being retired, AD has been implemented. I am not, however, paying MS fees for things I can do free on Linux."

Where does this say "WE, US, OUR decision has been to remove Novell as it is no longer of use."

You said I have taken a phrase out of a sentence and got so worked up.

Now here is an example of a phrase taken out of one of your sentences and taken out of context.

Your full sentence;
"MS receives the most Hack/Virus attacks because it is THE biggest target. Period. MS receives the most Hack/Virus attacks because it is THE biggest target. Period. Why write destructive tools for something as puny as Mac, Linux, or Novell.

Taken out of context:
"something as puny as Mac, Linux, or Novell."

To which I may say "What is PUNY about one of the most robust NOS's on the market?" These guys pioneered many of the secure network technologies that we use in our networks today.

Now that is taking you words out of context.

Perhaps your statement that I had addressed would be better left as part f the paragraph before it where you IMPLIED but didn't state that it was related to YOUR environment. You didn't though and it stood alone as a separate paragraph/statement about Novell being retired.

In a discussion where many are slating the end of Novell, it may be better if you are specific. At the very least you could learn to correct someone's misinterpretation of your meaning without implying they have a comprehension problem.

If we are going to criticize grammar and comprehension, I will admit full out that my use of grammar and spelling here needs much to be desired, I just don't pay that much attention when I am typing in a conversational manner.

BUT...if we must nitpick, you said;
"Point 1: MS receives the most Hack/Virus attacks because it is THE biggest target. Period. Why write destructive tools for something as puny as Mac, Linux, or Novell."

Which SHOULD read(I believe), "...because it is THE biggest target, period."

'Period' is NOT a sentence by itself.

Now that we understand how easily grammatical mistakes can be misinterpreted, perhaps you will understand why people read a different meaning than you intended. This is the root of all evil in these discussions, people making bold statements and others misinterpreting them.

Do we dwell on this as an issue that needs to be addressed or do we just move on without correcting people, it could really impede the converstions if we stop to reiterate our posts.

by voldar

I'll drink for that! Someday maybe you'll join me (french or not french speaking:))

And yes ... you are so right .. I'll never understand why XP appeared (with all the problems - hardware needs, networking gaps..) when W2K is the best product I used from MS. And I will not change it to another product 3 years at least from now. And, now, talking from experience, XP in a network = headaches. XP is good and fun for homecomputers, with all media enhancements, but please ... not in network environment.

by pauldrumm

I have walked into several companies where they had a shareware Linux OS (is there any other kind?). I asked them, "Who is your support?" and they had none. Most corporate entites have support contracts with SCO, Sun, Microsoft. Who has that hot fix for your system that you can call? They moved to another OS that had support for what they are running. Most networks use Windows for the desktop. Makes sense to use Windows for the whole shebang(!). You just do not get the support with Linux as you do with HP-UX, Sun, or SCO. SCO was pretty good. Novell ha(s)d decent support if you can get a real Novell engineer which is not likely any more. I have been installing Droopwise and Novell OS for many years. I had an issue with my Droopwise migration from 5.5 to 6.5 with the clients that I had never seen before. I had to call a third party recommended on Novell's website. I sent them the errors, the diags, ran all the tests they asked and even had them come in through Terminal services (it's a MS product, kind'a like telnet with pictures) and then they asked me for a ghost of the clients hard drive (a legal firm). I had my end with this and told them I could not do this for legal reasons and wanted our money back. THEY SAID THEY DO NOT GIVE REFUNDS AND DO NOT GUARUNTEE ANTYHING. This is one thing that su-ked about Novell going from in house support to that third party ,Sento Corporation.
In fact the policy is, and I qoute

Q: What if the support engineer doesn't resolve my problem? Am I still charged for the support?
A: Novell considers access to an engineer an incident. If you spent time working with a support engineer, it will be considered an incident. If you never communicated with a support engineer, your incident will be canceled.

===Note that it never says anything about fixing you up. It just says that if you do not contact the engineer the charges are cancelled. What a bunch of hooey!!
When I call for support it is because there is a major issue and I need a 3rd level engineer.
Sun, HP and Microsoft do not charge you if they can not fix it.

Bottom line. Who ya gonna call? Might as will be the ghostbusters! They did not give refunds either.

Use what makes the most business sense for your company to support that 24/7 enterprise app that brings you in millions/year in revenue. Make sure you can fall back on a solid support contract. Most companies could not do that with Linux on a "reliable" basis due to support and also due to a shortage of decent Unix admins.

Can not wait for the replies on this one.

almost forgot

Paul Drumm
MCDBA, MCSE+I,MCSE, MCP+I ,CCNA

by pauldrumm

I have seen so many Novell abends because a novice admin tried to install Novell, or actually got it installed, it is pathetic. Not to mention all the bugs inherent to the NOS itself that cause it to abend under load. Oh, check the Novell KB for "ABEND". You will find as many hits for it on Novell's site as you do for "BSOD" on Microsoft's.

I bet you have one server and 10 users.

Sorry for the sarcasm, nothing personal.

by oz_media

Actuallu in my experience, I have only ever seen one NW server with an abend issue. It was due to third party FaxServe software that wasn't compaitlble with the most common brooktrout fax board.

Other than that, I have 5 NW servers under my wing at two companies right now. One with 150+ users and the other with 700+ srpead throughout four Canadian braches.

Since the original install until today, I have only rebooted one company's web application server when the ISP was down. Almost three years.

The other is only year old but hasn't abended once.

All it takesis a little time and patience when designing hardware andinstalling software and your good to go. You can add NW patches, updates etc. on the fly without rebooting servers.

Bottom line, the company's network is always up and the users are happy. Which, at the end of the day, is really all that matters in ANY network OS.

Hardware and software reliability are important but if you can hot-swap drives and keep the server up to date without taking it down, that's the ultimate goal. Novell's products have always provided this for me and therefore my customers have been happy with thier NOS choice. it doesn't matter how much time and effort YOU spend with the server as that's your job, I just prefer to do it during the daytime and forget the after hours and weekend reboots and rollouts.

by tanjnt

Remember when Novell had the superior product, but M$ kept gaining market share? Well, it's probably still happening today.

NT wasn't a better NOS, but it was easier to learn, and install, and administer (until it crashed or got hacked). It was also priced better, and more cleverly marketed.

Novell was king of the NOS hill, and arrogant. They watched their market share dwindle while doing (not) clever things like paying too much for WordPerfect.

Now they are fighting an uphill battle against an entrenched and cash rich M$. Has their management learned enough to win that battle?

I'd like to think so, because I am fond of their products, but I am also skeptical. If they were doing their job right, the original message that started this thread might not have been written.

This guy is an existing reseller worried about being able to make a living with Novell products. In that environment, it's gonna be tough for Novell to win new converts.

by terryt

Why don't you keep your absurd, uneducated, immature, and pathetic rants to yourself? All of the cutsie, anti-Microsoft (M$, WinDOZE) name-calling only reveals an irrational hate and overall lack of objectivity and maturity.

by oz_media

It was a play on your post. They say if you san't beat em join em so I figure one must respond to you with the same knee jerk. biased attitude you shared here.

Perhaps you can just remember that yours s not always the best opinion and your not dealing with the newbies you propose your sre.

If it is beneath you, the Internet is full of similar sites without you finding a need to belittle others knowledge in order to reinforce your own point. Try offering positive support for your own opinions instead of negative towards another opinion.

by j.neufert

Also erst mal - wenn ich alle 96 Server, die ich momentan unter meinen Fittichen habe, alle 6 Monate rebooten sollte, w?rde ich wahnsinnig werden.
2. F?r alle, die hier mit ihrem MCSE-Schei? hausieren gehen - eine Grundbedingung, von mir (gegen ziemlich gutes Geld, wie ich finde) angestellt zu werden, ist, keine von diesen verbl?denden Schulungen hinter sich zu haben - und bitte auch kein IT-Studium einer deutschen Universit?t (mann braucht dann n?mlich mindestens 2 Jahre, bis man den ganzen Quatsch wieder aus den K?pfen rausgepr?gelt hat). Oder anders gesagt - mir ist v?llig wurscht, was einer f?r Diplome hat - mich interessiert, was derjenige im Kopf hat.

UND DRITTENS - Meine Kunden werden vor eine einfache Wahl gestellt - m?chtet Ihr eine Klicki-Bunti-Welt mit vielen Funktionen, die Ihr weder braucht noch nutzt ODER m?chtet Ihr ein funktionierendes, manchmal auch spartanisches, aber immer SICHERES System, mit dem mann produktiv arbeiten kann?

Ob Ihr es glaubt oder nicht - 92 Prozent der Leute, f?r die ich arbeite, entscheiden sich f?r die zweite Variante - f?r die restlichen 8 Prozent arbeite ich nicht - meine Zeit ist mir dazu zu schade.

Ich werde f?r?s Denken bezahlt - meine Kunden k?nnen von mir daf?r erwarten, das ich Sie in Ihrem Sinne am besten berate.
Da in der heutigen Zeit aber Sicherheit f?r mich an erster Stelle steht, habe ich da nicht viel Auswahl - M$ geh?rt einfach nicht dazu. Punktum.

PS: Zur?ck zum eigentlichen Thema: Ich denke, dass Novell mit seiner Strategie durchaus richtig liegt und sich in seiner Ausrichtung konsequent weiterentwickelt.
Von einem Sterben sehe ich nichts.

mfg Janek

by oz_media

Sehr gut gesprochen. Ich sehe ihren punkt.

Dank zu Online-?bersetzern, ist das.
;-)

OM