Discussion Locked

Obama Reverses Rules on U.S. Abortion Aid

0 helpful
266 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/24/us/politics/24obama.html?hp

[i]?For too long,? he said, ?international family planning assistance has been used as a political wedge issue, the subject of a back-and-forth debate that has served only to divide us. I have no desire to continue this stale and fruitless debate.?[/i]

Is Obama's exporting of the culture of US paid for abortions his idea of improving the world view of the US? How does pushing abortion as birth control make us look good?

This goes against his earlier statements that he would work to reduce the number of abortions. Looks like he just found a larger "customer base".

266 replies

by john.a.wills

but I would like to go off at a tangent. The agencies which push abortion, notably International Planned Parenthood Federation and its associates, do not teach Billings, the most effective method of family planning, but concentrate their efforts on the Pill and condoms and so forth. Why did not Bush feed the family-planning money into WOOMB and the like?

by jck

they didn't give enough money for his "office for faith-based initiatives" to help out with that.

by jdclyde

Obama said he intends to INCREASE faith based initiatives.

Being a community organizer (as you repeatedly bragged), he knows first hand that government can't do ANYTHING half as efficient as private organizations. More money and better care gets to the end user this way.

And the great thing, HE is intelligent enough to know that it IS constitutional for government to give this aid.

by john.a.wills

The Billings ovulation method of family planning is not faith-based but scientifically proven. WHO long ago tested it and found it successful, but does not promote it much, presumably because of IPPF influence.

by jck

It is wrong for a woman/couple to terminate a pregnancy of a child they can't/won't take care of?

But, it's okay for me and every other American who doesn't have children to pay tax monies to pay to keep your children in a public school, have a school bus, have sports activities, school buildings, books, etc?

I didn't choose to have your kids. Why is it fair for you to get MY tax dollars for 13 years of your childrens' lives to put them through school, when I didn't make them or choose them?

Guess it's okay for you to get my money to upkeep your children, but not okay for a woman and father of a child to have the option not to have a child she/they can't take care of.

See my point?

BTW...note: it's an [b]option[/b], not a mandate. No one is "pushed" or "coerced" or any other term you want to use to make it look like government is forcing or intimidating women into having them.

BTW, most other industrialized, civilized countries on this planet have legal, government funded family planning programs including abortion as an [b]option[/b]. So, most "world views" of us right now are that we are far too hung up on implementing religious ideology into government than to properly care for the health of people in our country or to think first of the welfare and well-being of children not born yet.

Even most Muslim states allow for limited condition abortions.

Except for, that is, places like: Iran and Iraq.

Guess you wanna have an abortion policy like Iran and Iraq?

by jdclyde

If someone wants to get an abortion because they are knocked up again, that is for them to have to live with knowing they killed their baby out of convenience.

Tax payer dollars should no more be used for this than to give someone a nose job.

In a time of financial crisis, we DEFINITELY should not be wasting US tax dollars on other countries to abort their youth. Let them pay for it themselves. People are losing their homes HERE, and we are worried about being able to pay someone to kill someone elses baby?

Something you can't understand, refusing to use taxpayers money for abortion is not the same as refusing to allow women to repeatedly get their abortions. Just make them pay for their own. Simple, really.

by jck

[i]In a time of financial crisis, we DEFINITELY should not be wasting US tax dollars on other countries to abort their youth. Let them pay for it themselves. People are losing their homes HERE, and we are worried about being able to pay someone to kill someone elses baby?[/i]

If that's so, why have we spent $100Bs in Iraq saving babies there? Why haven't we got out of there and taken care of our own?

Why are we worrying about someone else's babies and country, when ours is going down the $hitter?????

by Member 25348569

This is in the UK because that's what I know.

The "morning after pill" is an abortefacient drug. The coil and other IUD devices are also abortefacients so all ought to be proscribed the the Extremely Religious.

Early term abortions - up to 14 weeks - used to be all vacuum aspiration but this is being replaced by the drug misfepristone that blocks the hormones that maintain the uterine lining.

High-dose Prostaglandins in later pregnancies force a birth within a few hours.

The thing worth remembering about abortions is that when you have a society that sanctions early abortion, the late ones are fortunately much rarer. In the UK, 90% of abortions were carried out at under 14 weeks gestation; 60% were at under 10 weeks.

by john.a.wills

allow early abortions because their theology is still stuck with medieval biology. If we accept modern biology we accept that abortion is murder from fertilization onwards. Whether it should always be punished is another question, but certainly the state itself should never contribute to murder.

by jck

you say "modern biology"

let's get some "biology" right here.

if it is murder to terminate a fetus before the brain stem becomes active, then it should also be murder for you to chop up a carrot, eat an egg from a chicken, etc.

Biologically (and medically) speaking in the modern sense of biological science, "human life" is determined by factors of the embryotic structure differentiating itself from those things existing that are similar. That is, a fetus is scientifically considered to be fully "human life" once the brainstem and nervous function has fully developed, which is typically as early as 10 1/2 weeks and as late as 15 in a normal, healthy fetus.

The *only* precepts that say abortion is murder from fertilization onward are those religiously-perpetuated concepts that state "life begins with conception".

However, human life is scientifically differentiated by sentience and self-awareness. So if that is the case, then how can it be human without having the nervous and cognitive organs (even in their most basic form) in place?

I do have a question:

If you have/had a daughter, someone abducts her at the age of 9, molests her for days, then takes her, puts her in a trash bag, and puts her in a hole, and buries her alive.

Do you still think that person has a right to live after taking the innocence and life from your child?

by tonythetiger

"homicide" might be a more accurate term than "murder", because murder is defined as an "unlawful killing" while abortion is not unlawful. In fact, it might even be considered 'self defense'!

by oz_media

What about the women who are at risk by carrying it full term?

What about the women who are UNABLE to care for their cihld due to sickness and ailments due to unplanned pregnancy at an early age?

What about those mothers who are forced to give birth to children with special needs?

The only FORCE I see here is the fact that women are FORCED to carry a child full term and then FORCED to raise it or rely on the state to do so.

Lifting funding does not FORCE people to abort pregnancy though. What utter BS.

by jdclyde

As it wasn't illegal, they had the option all along to get as many abortions as they could afford, like anyone else that wants something that has a price.

There is no "force" involved either way.

by jck

faith-based doesn't necessarily mean "community". churches aren't required to let anyone participate. public funded programs require equal participation by law.

Oh, and btw: if Obama doesn't believe that government "can't do ANYTHING half as efficient as private organizations", then why is he trying to nationalize to some extent healthcare? Hm?

Please explain his concept of a "National Health Insurance Exchange" to be run by the federal government as part of his plan, if what you say is right?

You can't dispute it. He's looking to implement more government oversight of the operation of insurance to stop the system raping people (patients and doctors) for profits.

As for aid programs:

He is also intelligent enough to understand the Supreme Court decision that says you can't use your programs to push religion as well. He is, after all, a constitutional professor of law.

Unlike Bush, I don't think Obama will be as likely to overlook transgressions in the law in favor of organizations who "helped out" his campaigns in trade for a "faith-based" check-in-the-hand.

BTW, when did you think him to be so intelligent about government? I thought he wouldn't be able to do a good job cause he wasn't experienced enough in government? :^0

by jdclyde

again, reading into it what you want.

only, unlike many others of clearly limited intelligence in this country, Obama understands that if the Supreme court rules something to be constitutional, then it is.

There are many of questionable intelligence that have actually tried to say otherwise.

by jck

You still don't understand the concept of caveats placed upon the program by law.

You think because someone professes they are of God, then they have divine right to free reign to do as they wish.

If they start teaching God as a part of the program, they lose funding. As well, they can not exclude anyone from participating in it even if they are not of the religion they prescribe to.

Hence, it's not really faith-based. It's volunteer.

Just Bush was giving kickbacks through a loophole to religious orgs who contributed to his campaigns.

by jck

also depends on women having regular cycles.

The absolute most effective way to 100% prevent unwanted birth is abstinence.

Period.

by john.a.wills

the Billings method does not depend on a woman having regular cycles. You are mixing it up with something else.

by jck

[i]The Billings ovulation method (BOM) is a method which women use to monitor their fertility, by identifying when they are fertile and when they are infertile during each menstrual cycle. Users pay attention to the sensation at their vulva, and the appearance of any vaginal discharge. This information can be used to achieve or avoid pregnancy during regular or irregular cycles, breastfeeding, and peri-menopause. Described by the BOM organization as "Natural Fertility Regulation", this method may be used as a form of fertility awareness or natural family planning, as well as a way to monitor gynecological health.[/i]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billings_Ovulation_Method

Ovulation is not always tied to external body indicators, nor do eggs always drop on regular cycles. It has very much to do with cycles happening in regular patterns with indicators based on a standard assumption.

It is used to *avoid*...not prevent.

And therefore, is not 100% effective.

by jdclyde

are pro-abortion people so against what you have just said is the "absolute most effective way"?

Why do pro-abortion people want so many others to have abortions?

by oz_media

Do proabortion people really WANT people to have abortions? Now I am speaking of true pro-abortionists, not just doctors who stand to gain a lot of income through it.

Having an abortion is risky and dangerous for the mother, of course a proabortionist would never say that. Having an abortion is more reliable than the day after pill or the birth control pill, I'm sure proaboritonists offer that info too.

Yeah, those pro abortionists, they are at it again killing people with their lies...er, no actually that would be the ones who ban abortion funding not the ones who support it.

by jck

where pro-abortion people (all, most, or significant numbers) have said "we are against abstinence"....

please?

You can't do it. Because, most pro-abortion people wants *choice*.

Right-restricting pro-lifers want to impose their ethos on others and have control.

And also, please show me proof of the majority of pro-abortion people taking the stance of "we want others to have abortions!"

Again, you can't.

That is total sensationalism and hype.

by oz_media

Unfortunately we live in a real world.

Unless you also support locking up young girls until they are of age to be forcibly married to whom YOU deem the correct mate for her, what makes you think for even a second that abstinence is going to be the answer?

Sure, he best way to create world peace is for everyone to simply put down their guns, and its game over, but reality has to fit int there somewhere too.

by jck

I just said that it was the only 100% effective way to prevent pregnancy.

by john.a.wills

The villain you submit has forfeited his rights by violating them in another person. That is not true of the preborn child.

by jck

as I am someone with no children:

Why is it the right of anyone who wants to push out babies before they can take care of them to a normal standard...and make people like me pay for their schooling, after school programs, etc?

How is it fair?

Why do you punish me a viable, breathing, living, thinking, productive person who does good things, by FORCING ME to take care of OTHERS' children?

But you give more rights to a blastula or zygote or clump of cells that has no more humanity or ability to think or do than a potato?

It's hypocracy. You give more rights to a cellular glob than you do a human being who is proven.

As for it being a "pre-born child", I would agree after first trimester when if is a life. But prior to that, when there is no brain function, no brain stem, no heartbeat...it is not life scientifically to me.

And it is fair asking you about John Cooey. Would you...or would you not...have that man's life taken for what he did to Jessica Lunsford? If that were your daughter, would you not want to see his life ended?

by jdclyde

if the family loses their job and is no longer able to care for them, we should take the children and kill them, right?

by tonythetiger

[i]Why is it the right of anyone who wants to push out babies before they can take care of them to a normal standard...and make people like me pay for their schooling, after school programs, etc?[/i]

isn't those parents, it's the system that imposes the unfair consequences...

The government shouldn't be addressing any specific person's needs or desires to a greater or lesser extent than another's, nor should it be burdening one person any more than another. Equal rights demands equal responsibility.

by Member 25348569

WHAT is a "preborn child"?

Actually, I know what you think you man by it but, really, such emotive language just marks you as just another Religious Nutter.

You are up there with those who, when Amnesty International adopted what the Pro-Life organisation labelled a "pro-abortion" stance (it was in reality an adoption of the idea of a woman's right to choose, focused on a woman's human rights in the face of rape and other acts of violence), prominent members of Pro-Life withdrew their membership of and support for Amnesty. The Roman Catholic bishop of East Anglia, Michael Evans, stated "appalling violence must not be answered by violence against the most vulnerable and defenceless form of human life in a woman?s womb."

This tactic of emotionalising the argument and using 'human' words to refer to the foetus is a common one. It is an attempt to shock and manipulate when the facts of the argument are stacked against you and there is no logical defence of your stance.

Neil

by john.a.wills

By definition, life begins at conception. The question then arises where/when conception happens. In a jellyfish life cycle, the gamete is conceived at meiosis, the polyp is conceived at fertilization and the medusa is conceived at budding. In the human life cycle the gamete is conceived at meiosis and the soma at fertilization.

by jck

between "life" generically and "human life"

Otherwise, I can call you an abortionist for eating chicken.

I invite you to go read some scientific journals. You'll see that not everyone is in accordance with religious concept that fertilization means it is a human life.

BTW: Human developmentof a fetus in-utero is a process of mitosis...not meiosis.

by john.a.wills

development of the foetus, and indeed of all somatic mammalian life, is indeed by mitosis, but formation or conception of gametes is by meiosis.

by john.a.wills

is not eally the issue, because no-one is saying that human gametes are sacrosanct. But human somata are sophonts, or sapients, and their life is continuous from fertilization.

As it happens, I do read science from time to time, and I have in particular read quite a bit of biology. I have never found evidence in modern biology of the kind of sequence of discrete lives that mediaeval biologists thought occurred.

by tonythetiger

In circumstances where one's rights interfere with another's, one must give way. Should the government, for example, FORCE a raped woman to give birth?

by santeewelding

When you two uncover "being" by divvying it up into ever-increasing taxonomic crap. Then let me know when you're about to enforce your angels dancing on the head of a pin over the barrel of a gun.

by charliespencer

The previous administration stopped funding any program that included abortion as one of it's services, regardless of whatever other services it offered. How did refusing ALL services make us look? Resuming funding for programs that offer contraceptive measures in addition to abortion will reduce the number of unplanned pregnancies and, by extension, abortions.

by charliespencer

I couldn't care less either way. It's chump change compared to many other programs, and I don't have a philosophical interest in the question.

by john.a.wills

It has been empirically tested to be more reliable than the Pill. I mentioned this earlier. In China the method is spreading and "Recent surveys of all areas where the BOM is taught has shown a very pleasing seven-fold decline to 0.61% in artificial abortion-rate as compared with 4.06% rate where the BOM has not yet been introduced.".
http://woomb.org/bom/chinareport.html

by oz_media

You'll find anything you can and twist it into what you would like, controversy. Just like a cheezy tabloid "editorial". You even make up the comments by yourself and apply them to the people involved as if they actually said it.

For some reason, I thought you were more astute than to create your own comentary and editorial out of absolutely nothing at all.

Utter fabrications, such as:
[i][b]"How does pushing abortion as birth control make us look good?"[/i][/b]are cmoplete garbage and pure fantasy.

Stopping funding that RESTRICTS something does not equate to "pushing it".
Alcohol was once banned, lifting that ban did not PUSH it upon people.

It simply lifted a restriction on people's personal choices, which you obviously feel they are not entitled to.

But then in another heartbeat, you will defend YOUR right to personal choice, when it is aligned with your OWN personal choice of course, what a hypocrite!

Banning abortion does NOTHING to stop unwanted pregnancy, and does NOTHING to educate or protect people from spreading AIDS. That funding was also used for family planning education and was used to protect people, not force them to abort or as you suggest PUSH abortion upon them.

Comments such as this, which was not offered by yourself, "President Obama will be remembered forever not just as a smart, savvy, gifted and eloquent leader but as the Abortion President"
simply shows how small minded and ignorant people will choose to be when they see an opportunity to have THEIR say based on what someone else has already said. Its easier to condemn than create I suppose.

As with yourself, instead of coming up with compelling reasons to support your own stand, you simply discount someone else's, whether with fabrication or fact. in this case you are stretchign that limit pretty far, you offered NOTHING that was actually said but focused on speculation and your own fabrications instead.

Such as Douglas Johnson who said "the first in an anticipated series of attacks on longstanding pro-life policies as the new administration pushes Obama's sweeping abortion agenda."
What a crock of shite! Yeah, pushing abortion is all Obama's is about, you can tell by looking at his daughters just how much he hates pregnancy and procreation.

I am sure he too tells his daughters to go get knocked up and he will see that the state sorts it out for her afterwards. No education on pregancy or family planning is allowed because that will just push abortioon on her, just let her learn from her own mistakes instead of offering guidance.

What a typically absurd an thoughtless commentary!

The guy is a father of two daughters, for Christ's sake! Do you REALLY think he is PUSHING abortion or perhaps he is simply accepting it is a CHOICE that should be made between his family and his daughters, should they ever wind up in such a position?

You know, you are such a hypocrite; when it comes to welfare you say its a waste of YOUR money and people should be held more responsible for their own situations.

Then when they are forced to have a child even if it literally kills the mother, which you also proudly support, you feel that THEY should have no choice but to let it suffer in poverty if the mother is dead or can't afford to raise it herself.

To top it all off, she shouldn't even be educated on the subject of planned prenthood either, just lock her in a closet until she's ready for her arranged marriage and that'll take care of things. What is this, 1934?

Trolling, fabricating commentary, stirring the shite pot and putting it forward as a valid and reasonable discussion that illustrates the new president elect's shortcomings.

So clever!

Get a life JD, go see a concert or something.

by jdclyde

Abortion was neither restricted nor prevented.

Is simply wasn't paid for by Uncle Sam.

Uncle Obama is going to pay the bill, so step right up and be the first in your neighborhood to get your free abortion!

Wanna get an abortion? Knock yourself out.

Want to waste our limited tax dollars for it, especially during an economic crisis? Bullsh1t.

by oz_media

500 BILLION on an unnecessary war is okeydokey, alright Uncle Sam, just keep throwing money at that problem until you win or pull out but still claim you won....it protects YOU in your mind anyway.

700 Billion to the companies that have proven they are irresponsible in money management...shady lenders may help YOU when you need a mortgage, who cares if others iresponsibly take on debts they have no intent or means of repaying.

Lets bail out the auto manufacturer's that refuse to build a car that stands up to Japanese and European imports (even North American cars in Europe are ten times better than those built in North America).
They build substandard garbage to appease cheap as$ed American consumers who demand lower prices, regardless of the shite the product is. Who knows, you may want to buy a GM one day, and now you can!

But as for supporting our future generations who just may wind up operating companies that perform accordingly and don't leech billions of your tax dollars, forget it. They are slut-bags and deserve to be forced into having their unwanted, unplanned children, let them and their children suffer for eternity. That doesn't benefit you directly, so screw it, they get nothing from you, no money no support not a care.

Yeah, have a long sit and think. You really need to start looking at reality for a change and not just your knee jerk reactions in your neverending quest to dicscount Obama and make yourself feel better by think ing you have more money in your pocket by paying for fewer government programs.

"The money" is the saddest, lamest excuse I have ever heard with regards to support of government funded programs. Americans seem to believe that if they support fewer programs, that teh money will be put back into their pockets, that the government will tax them less or something, UNTRUE.

You tax dollars will simply be reallocated somewhere else, there's no surplus and never will be in the USA, you are simply not structured for it you consume many more times than you produce. Take oil for example, you have 5% of the world's population, but consume 25% of the world's oil resources.

How do you possibly believe that stopping anti-abortion funding is going to alleviate your taxation and fincancial problems in any way shape or form?

For someone who supports billions, trillions of ridiculous expenses from your government and your taxes, which you feel are taken from your pocket and wouldn't be otherwise, you sure are cheap and selfish when it comes to people other than yourself.

by jck

[i]Want to waste our limited tax dollars for it, especially during an economic crisis? Bullsh1t.[/i]

Exactly. All the abortions done in the USA in the past 25 years that were subsidized don't mount up to near the cost of 5 years in Iraq overthrowing a leader who had no chemical or biological weapons, and posed no threat to making a nuclear program...as was LIED ABOUT.

SO...GET OUR TROOPS OUT AND STOP WASTING $9B A MONTH ON IRAQ AND HELP OUR OWN PEOPLE EAT AND LIVE.

by jck

How many Americans were killed from 2003-2008?
25,119 dead as of July 15th 2008.

"Forces: U.S. & Coalition Casualties". CNN, From March 2003 onwards.

Number of Iraqis dead? Over 90,000

Saving a life, eh?

We've made that country more deadly now than before we went in there.

We've caused more deaths than we've saved.

Saddam may have been a tyrant and a psycho, but you didn't see the terrorists running his country.

We'd have done better keeping our butts here and having done our own little insurgency to take over the government rather than blow it up.

Shows ya how good that "go git 'em boys!" attitude you take has done.

by jdclyde

is what keeps any valid person of science from considering a baby with a beating heart to not be life.

It is valid to conclude at the time of conception, but it is NEVER valid once a child would be viable outside the womb. Ever.

by jck

when the brainstem activity begins in a fetus, that is when what develops into the heart starts to beat.

it's part of it. go read some NEJM or JAMA.

Oh, and btw: If you consider life to be a child that is "viable outside the womb", you are implying you support that as "not life" since fetuses generally don't survive until after 26-28 weeks.

And, it is not the "politicization of science". It is what medical scientists and biologists have categorized as what defines and separates human life from that shrimp you eat at Red Lobster.

by Member 25348569

"but it is NEVER valid once a child would be viable outside the womb. Ever." For a reasonable definition of "viable", anyway.

Still, that's a long, long time after conception. Five months and more and that's plenty of time.

by jdclyde

sure, they look like a doll instead of a person, but they are alive.

ThingTwo dropped down to 2.5 lbs the first night at just over 7 months.

by jdclyde

between having a safe procedure available, and making it free (financially) and free (from guilt).

It is a barbaric thing, and should never be done casually.

by jck

You're thinking in black and white again. Think for yourself, not in the box conservatives tell you to sit in.

And as a matter of being able to take care of your children:

When parents can't feed or house their children, we have a system to provide for those children.

When I'm talking about the mother and father not being able to take care of them, I mean this:

You have a 14 year old girl and 15 year old boy.

How do they get jobs?
Pay rent?
Pay for daycare?
Feed the baby?
Pay for doctor's visits?
Pay the hospital bill?

Simply put, you want ME to have to pay for the kids that I didn't have. Plus, you want a couple kids to have to ruin their lives because of a mishap.

I really hope your boys don't get a girl pregnant soon. Or, you will learn what it is really like. Whether you want it or not, grandpa would get calls and office visits and asked to take care of the baby on weekends.

If it does, have fun.

by oz_media

Have you gone completely mad?

What mother do you actually believe would abort her child and be "FREE OF GUILT?"

Just one, even the hookers and horrific crack whores with the lowest morals will not be FREE FROM GUILT if they abort a pregnancy.

Abortion is one of the most horrific and life damning operations ANY woman will EVER experience in her ENTIRE existence. Nothing will ever make that go away it is a scar she will always have on her heart.

To suggest, even lightheartedly, that ANY woman in such a situation would be free from guilt just illustrates how completely devoid of any real knowledge of the subject you actually are.

How can you even suggest having a rational opinion when you demonstrate such an outrageous misconception of the practice which you condemn?

by jck

for years evidently had something up your arse that makes you think you are so much better, and that women who have abortions never pondered having it or felt guilt.

You really need to go and work at a planned parenthood center, and go talk with a 14 year old girl who got molested that's having to go through it.

Oz is right. You have grand misconceptions of this, and never have dealt with it and it makes you ignorant.

Oh, and yeah Mr. Self-righteous:

I did have to talk with my sister about it when she got pregnant with my niece. And as much of a bitch as my sister is, she didn't have a walk in the park deciding one way or the other. It isn't easy like you think.

I'm logoff now, before I say something cruel.

by jdclyde

especially, as we find out, the bank bailouts. Should be stopped, not increased.

Auto bailouts? Stop bailing them out and stop over regulating them.

Any plan that increases government spending as a handout without a return to the US tax payer should be pointed out, each and every time.

Or we can just excuse it away, right? "At least it isn't as bad as XYZ was".....

by oz_media

Again such marrow focus. Your auto industry has FAR fewer regulations than Europe or Japan's does. Manufacturer's meet far lower standards or quality and build in the USA, that's why they are allowed ot produce teh crap you get sold. Go to Frankfurt or Okinawa and have a look at THEIR auto industry, ours doens't even come close as far as regulations, government quality control and plant demands are concerned.

RE: ANY plan....

How is you taxes being used to support the future of a femail amefixcan NOT giving back to the US taxpayer? Because it doesn't give to YOU personally?

So each and every tax you pay must directly benefit YOU as an individual, and not your country as a nation?

Go find an island, you are too selfish for words.

by jck

that is, or do you know?

(you were too terse. you rurn to speek engrish right lol)

by jdclyde

you talked about abortion and the war.

figure it out, you're a bright boy, right?

by jdclyde

and since it was just evil kickbacks on the part of Bush, it must be REALLY evil kickbacks on Obama if he wants to increase it, right?

Or can't you be honest and consistent on a topic?

by jdclyde

when the low lifes a few years back were handing out "I had an abortion" Tee shirts, as if it were something to be proud of.

Why do pro-abortion people NOT want a perspective customer to know EXACTLY what the procedure is?

by jck

Since Bush did it means Obama is gonna do it?

You have just made ZERO sense.

You really are losing it. Go home and have your booze and play your video games.

by oz_media

So removing funding bans does NOT force abortion? Why the change or heart?

What abut a teenage girl, can't tell her overly religious parents about it and is 'forced' to have a child because she cannot afford an abortion. They won't support it and you are in turn FORCING her to rely on YOUR tax dollars to raise it for the next 18 years, or even more for a suitable care home to do so at your expense.

How about the single mother who gets pregnant, even though using protection, a very common occurance also, but now she will be FORCED to have her child as she cannot afford other options or her options are limited enough that she is FORCED to have another child.

If you limit or remove OPTIONS and CHOICES, how is that not the same exerting FORCE?

by jdclyde

because I can't afford a nice fancy one.

I am "forced" to live in a modest home because I can't afford a fancy one on the beach.

It is an elective surgery and should not be paid for with government funds.

If there is a life saving emergency, it would be performed in the emergency room (if it really were an emergency) and if the person has no insurance or money, the debt is written off.

Don't believe the hype, "the poor" don't pay for that emergency visit, nor are they turned away.

As for dealing with her parents, that is a family matter, and government has no business getting involved.

Did you know they can't/won't give my kids a friggen aspirin in school without my permission?

by oz_media

Judging by your comparison to luxury items, car and home, you see abortion as a luxury item that is a decision taken on by someone who decided to get pregnant.

Your understanding of the subject matter you are trying to negate is hideous to say the very least. I wonder what world you grew up in where you have not been subject to the necessary side of abortion and simply see it as an unnecessary, luxy expense.

I don't even knw how you can continue to debate a subject yo clearly have no real understanding of, beyond the fact that your tax money may pay for it.

Whilst you accept the billions your government wastes to make YOUR life a little more comfortable you reject the importance of addressing unwanted pregnancy that may completely ruin two or more people's lives.

Way to be American, all for one and all for one!

by jdclyde

Would not they both go into the SAME system that YOU are paying for?

Why, yes, they would.

But you would kill one set of kids and pay for the other?

by jdclyde

pro-abortion people harping that "abstinence doesn't work" or that it is unrealistic to expect that anyone could abstain from having sex.

by oz_media

I don't know who your miniature mind works, but it certainly is scary to consider.

I am speaking of mothers who bear intense guilt at the thought of aborting whats was to be a child of heir own creation.

You equate it to a bunch of radicals handing out 'kin t-shirts at a pro-abortion rally?

When you fight against repression, then see that fight come to fruitition of course there is reason for celebration. Cigarette manufacturer's like to advertise and promote smoking but how many smokers do you see proudly parading that they are smokers?

Your example shows just how singular and simple your mindset is towards the issue, you are seeing radicals and protesters and trying to expose them as the majority or the or even the norm.

To suggest that women are "GUILT FREE" when they have an abortion, just because some people handed out t-shirts to celebrate their change in human rights, shows just how out of touch with reality you really are in this case.

I'd honestly like to see more female input on this subject also, it is THEM we are discussing afterall. I wonder why most have conveniently chosen to avoid your post lke the plague?

by jamesrl

No where does it say in the article that the US would fund foreign abortions. Period, full stop.

What the ban was on was providing any funds to organizations that in any way support abortion as a birth control method. So the UN Population Fund, a group that looks at worldwide population issues, would not get any funds from the Bush Government since they advocate abortion as one of many birth control methods.

I would not like to see my tax dollars to a group whose sole focus is pro-abortion, nor would I like to see my tax dollars go to an anti-abortion group either. But if I stopped supporting my local hospital because they provided a very small number (compared to their other sevices) of legal abortions, I wouldn't be giving any health instituitions any dollars.

James

by john.a.wills

Money is fungible. There is no practical way to distinguish between money IPPF gets from the US, which must not be used for abortion and money it gets from the EU, which, as I understand, may be used for abortion. There are accounting methods to try to monitor such things, but under Clinton IPPF was found to be making last-minute adjustments, shifting money from column to column, to be able to claim that US money was not being used for abortion.

by Member 25348569

does not take into account those societies where if the man wants sex, he gets it - or those marriages where society might not sanction that attitude but the man does, anyway.

It suggests to me that the IPPF are just a little more pragmatic than those groups who see the world through the filters prescribed by their Imaginary Friends.

by tonythetiger

[i]All the abortions done in the USA in the past 25 years that were subsidized don't mount up to near the cost of 5 years in Iraq[/i]

How did you arrive at the value of those lives lost to abortion?

by oz_media

Jck is not equating lives lost to money spent in Iraq. He is comparing the costs of war compared to the costs of providing abortions.

I believe it is JD that seems to have no concern for human lives and feels that if you can't afford an abortion, you should be forced to raise a child regardless of the cost of its welfare or the possible dangers to one's life.

The question being addressed here is not one of support for abortion, it is purely one of tax payers expenses. (as if it actually makes any difference to the amount of tax you will pay)

In the case of tax money, you can't possibly suggest that offering state paid abortions over the last 25 years equals or exceeds the 500 billion+ spent on the war in Iraq.

Even still, if we went from your viewpoint and declared the cost of lives, we would then have to consider the cost of all lives lost in the war too, regardless of country or the side they are on.

I am pretty confident that 500 billion+, added to the value of thousands of lives lost would definitely not equal or be less than the costs of state paid abortions.

So lets work it out, shall we?

A number out of the blue, $10,000 per human life, aborted or killed at war.

1.21 abortions in 2005 = a total cost of 12.1 billion dollars.

Now, I'll be overly conservative in the cost of war 2005 and suggest a commonly found number of $100 billion.

[i]"War funding, which averaged about $93 billion a year from 2003 through 2005, rose to $120 billion in 2006 and $171 billion in 2007 and President George W. Bush has asked for $193 billion in 2008, the nonpartisan office wrote."

?It keeps going up, up and away,? Senate Budget Committee Chairman Kent Conrad said of the money spent in Iraq since U.S. troops invaded in 2003.

?We?re seeing the war costs continue to spiral upward. It is the additional troops plus additional costs per troop plus the over-reliance on private contractors, which also explodes the costs,? said Conrad, a North Dakota Democrat who opposed the war.[/i]

Now lets say only TWO people were killed, one Iraqi in 2005 and one US soldier, at a value of $10,000 ea.

That equals 100 billion, twenty thousand in 2005 for the war "effort" and 1.21 billion for abortions.

Yeah that's pretty even ground, about 100 times. even if you added up the costs of abortions over the last 25 years, at a value of 10,000 dollars a head, you STILL would only JUST equal the spending on ONE YEAR at war in Iraq, not even including the lives lost there.

by jdclyde

While I will not stop someone from aborting their "unwanted baby", I will do nothing to help in that process either.

Some of us think about the dead baby more than the scared teen you paint all abortion seekers as, and do not see it as Obama does of "punish you with a baby".

Kind of simple, actually. Hope that clears up your misunderstanding of my position here.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I'd have thought the bean counters would have counted themselves into oblivion by now.

by oz_media

If, in your cryptic style, you are referring to stopping both abortions and the war, again you are equating them as equals that need to be dealt with the same way, jck didn't equate them but showed what an extreme difference in cost the two are.

If not, then perhaps being more concise and less cryptic would afford you some credibility.

Again though, you can accept an illegal war that costs you hundreds of billipons, and yet you oppose the health and welfare of future generations of Americans as it will take up your tax money, which for some reason you think will put more in your pocket.

If yuor government found 1 trillion sbarrles of oil, already refined and sitting in barrles in the Nevda desert, found a way to feed, clothe and house all citizens at no cost and all the doctors decided to work for no pay so yuo can get free health care, YOUR paycheck wouldn't change one dime, you would STILL pay the same taxes, they would just find something else to spend it on.

Government's DON'T give back money.

In Canada people think we actually get money back because the government pays average income earners a GSt credit 4X a year. People in Alberta were all given over a grand back in teh form of a check from the provincial government, but they take it all back in other ways. For example, Canadians pay a crap load more GST than they will ever get back and those who earn the most, spend teh most and pay teh most GST, but undisqualified from getting a GST rebate as they are above a set income level.

Albertan's got over a grand, but they also pay absurd housing and property taxes for living in such a rich and prosperous province.

YOU GET NOTHING BY BITCHING ABOUT TAXES, even if yuo feel you've won with a small victory such as no paid abortions, you get soaked out the backdoor on something else.

talk about whining about the wrong things. I'd say you need to get your priorities straight, American lives and well being should come WELL before your own interests or foreign interests.

by jck

You implied:

That since the Bush-initiated "Office of Faith-Based Initiatives" was shown to have been giving the vast majority of it's funding to religiously-affiliated organizations who contributed time and/or monies to his campaigns...

That Barack Obama is going to do the same thing?

That's a stupid thing to assume, since Obama has done everything he can to recuse his staff and appointees from all lobbying and special interest.

And, it is something Bush never did.

by jck

I have never heard them say that.

I have heard them say that it should not be the only option.

So, you're right.

by Member 25348569

I think not. Just indulging myself in, gently for now, prodding another owner - or do I mean pet? - of an Imaginary Friend.

Probably a good idea to leave me to it. I haven't properly cut loose in AGES.

:)

by santeewelding

This thing has spiraled and morphed and transmogrified into the purely unrecognizable. You falling from way up there won't make a sound.

by Member 25348569

Neither meiosis nor mitosis are in anyway reserved for human ontogeny even if jck's statement was wrong. Which it wasn't.

You feel that you must assign some "divine spark" and that fertilisation is an easy place to do it and I believe that the process of becoming a whole person with rights takes longer than that and cannot be applied to a ball of undifferentiated cells.

That's the binary that we can't get beyond.

I, however, do not choose to push MY view on another person and force them to an action - backstreet abortion - or an inaction - carrying and bringing up an unwanted child - that they do not want.

by Member 25348569

I don't reckon sapience is much evident anywhere else, either. If ever a species was badly named, "Homo sapiens" takes the prize!

Significant brain structures connecting the thalamus and the cerebral cortex develop during the third trimester of pregnancy. They are not usually apparent until at least the 23rd week of pregnancy and may not begin to be operational until the 30th week. Until this point, it is unlikely even that the foetus feels pain as pain is the conscious recognition of an unpleasant stimulus.

This research was posted in the JAMA in 2005 as part of a study when the US government was proposing that doctors be required to tell women having an abortion from the 20th week of pregnancy that the foetus felt pain.

Rather blew the pro-lifers out of the water.

Usually the case when the Extremely Religious argue biology.

by jdclyde

that people decided to make this a discussion about abortion rather than a discussion about funding abortion and abortion groups.

Quite two different things.

by Member 25348569

Generally, those who are against abortion are against government funding of it. I accept that there are those, like yourself, who are more against the funding on principal but in the case of this thread I was generally answering John Wills' anti-abortion posts.

It was your "elective surgery" that prompted my response to you as I was suggesting that the cost - monetary cost - of an early abortion is not as high as you might imagine if you don't have to protect your abortion clinics from pro-lifers or your society doesn't stigmatise people to the extent that they delay.

As for the psychological cost to the woman and the cumulative cost to your society, I leave up to you to decide.

by jdclyde

Interesting.

My comment was just to point out the consistent tactic jck takes when he can't understand or support an idea, he talks about something else, as if it will make the original idea go away or not mean anything.

You at least stay on topic, at least until you decide it is time to inform me of your low opinion of me and Americans in general.

by oz_media

So yu have no response other than to dig for the meaning of a single word? sucks when you realize how off track and wrong you are doesn't it?

Lets change that word, for your benefit to NECESSARY. Either way, by your standards they are screwede anyway. and MANY such cases are necessary, even imperative to th elife of teh mother, but that means nothing to you, as long as your tax money is accounted for and ONLY applied to what you support.

Looking at your ideals, lets say all of YOUR tax money was allocated ONLLY to what YOU personally support.
Of course, each and every American is afforded the same luxury; you'd sure be screwed in Iraq, there would be a lot more people in the USA declaring personal banruptcy due to delinquent mortgages, your streets would be littered (even moreso) with panhandlers and homeless people, crime, drugs and death.

But hey, they wouldn' tbe gettign at YUOR tax dollars to sort out problems anymore, and you call yourself a CiTIZEN and consider yourself an AMERICAN and are PROUD of your MIGHTY NATION.

You actually sound like a one-off looking to do his own thing by himself, but still reap the great benefits of a nation and government...however only those benefits you enjoy and none of the costs or obligations attached to them.

Yeah, maybe we'd all like to live in Wonderland and drink tea with rabbits while eating magic mushrooms with catepillars too.

by oz_media

I didn't see any combination of your words in his post.

Aborting babsies DOES give health to many mothers unfit to carry and birth a child, better to let them both die then?

Aborting babies often increases a persons chances at leading a normal life, as opposed to weighing them down with unfathomable costs and responsibilities hthey canot face, often due to a deadbeat dad.

For some, having a child is the end of their hopes and dreams, which you cherish your freedom to have it seems.

In SOME cases, yes you are correct. It is used as an easy out.

In the MAJORITY of cases I would suggest the opposite is true. I have yet to meet a single mother who is proud to have had an abortion or pleased that she did (and I DO know a lot of them from my past working as an employment councellor with a youth service agency). It is something women NEVER forgive themselves for, getting pregnant AND terminating it.

And you see it so lightheartedly claiming that they must be proud because they wear t-shirts advertising it.

Few does not make all.