ObamaCare: It's not about medical care; it's about control over your life
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by puppybreath
they don't want competition. And in the current environment, thanks to government interference, they don't have much competition on a state to state basis.
But if you were to force them to compete with each other nationally, costs would to go down and they would be begging for your business.
Any company known for dropping people when they got sick wouldn't last very long in the same way a restaurant with lousy service doesn't last very long.
32 million people will be given medical insurance ..... but the price of medical insurance for everyone else will fall by $2,500 per year per family.
The price of medical insurance will be regulated ..... but they will still be in a competitive market.
No one will be denied medical insurance ..... but the cost of providing medical care will be reduced.
More people will have free and unlimited access to medical care ..... but there will be no additional strain on the medical care delivery system.
We'll be spending billions more on providing more health care for more ..... but the debt and deficits will fall.
Ain't life grand!
Now that President Obama and the Democrats have passed their [i]Health Care[/i] bill, we'll all be drinking that free Bubble Up and eating that Rainbow Stew - with a silver spoon, no less.
(Due credit given to [i]The Hag[/i])
by puppybreath
you'll never get some people off of their Kool-Aid long enough for them to try free Bubble Up.
:-)
I want my free Bubble-Up and Rainbow Stew!
I'm no longer going to buy medical insurance; instead I'll pay the fine for not buying it, which will be much cheaper in the long run. (Employers will also realize this.)
But when I do need medical care, that's when I'll buy the insurance. Hey, I can't be turned down, no matter how banged-up I am, or regardless of any pre-existing conditions. I'll wait until I crash my car ..... I mean myself, and THEN I'll buy the insurance.
I'm assuming that my free Bubble-Up and Rainbow Stew will be served to me in the hospital - not only with a silver spoon, but on a silver platter!
by jmgarvin
What we really need is to think about why the insurance industrial complex is the way it is...
It's a first step, but we're going to get raked over the coals by the insurance companies because they can.
by av .
We pay for all the uninsured and illegals now in our premiums. Thats why a Tylenol costs $100 in a hospital.
The 32 million people will be required to buy insurance beginning in 2014. There are subsidies for the poor, but it won't be totally free like it is now. Something is better than nothing.
It is going to strain our medical system, big time. I think it will create a lot of new healthcare-related jobs, but the quality of healthcare will take a hit and it will take longer and be harder to see a real doctor.
I think the bill is a work-in-progress. It has some positive things that I like. Everyone pays something is a good thing. Not being turned down for pre-existing conditions is good. If Democrats and Republicans can refine the plan, it would be a good thing for this country.
I'm real disappointed in the Republicans. Just opposing something and trying to stop it doesn't do anything to help the American people. We elected them to participate in government, not sit on the sidelines. I hate the partisan BS on this very important issue.
AV
by tonythetiger
the 1.5 trillion states will have to increase taxes by to pay for the additional medicaid mandates.
Take it out of one pocket, put it in the other, and call it "savings". Takes bright minds to come up with that.[/sarcasm]
by jck
Who advocated making things more local, rather than the federal government doing it all?
Well, here's your state that's going to take your tax money and use it there rather than it getting split up by Washington.
You got your wish, so don't whine about it. Tell your legislators how you should be taxed to pay for it, and live with it.
[i]Relax Max: I wasn't calling you uncompassionate. I was simply pointing out that we can't forget that even the battle has become Democrats vs. Republicans we need to consider that there are other losers in this debate besides the taxpaying Americans that oppose what the Democrats and Obama think that they have accomplished. They are the 32 Million Americans that do not have health care. Regardless of the outcome, they do need to be addressed and yes we do need to have compassion for these people. Trust me; we are on the same side. I was as disappointed as anyone to get the news late last night.[/i]
That's the dirty-little secret. Those 32 million people of whom you speak (or whatever the number du jour is) DO get necessary medical care. Hospitals can't turn down such people (as in jmgarvin's bank robbery victim), and the cost is already absorbed into the system. Sure, a lot of people abuse it. Some people shoplift merchandise, some shoplift medical care. The latter, however, is legalized, but the rest of responsible society pays for either.
As to non--emergency care, this is where the social-democrats play their shell game of claiming it's [i]cheaper in the long run[/i] to pay for them, and/or they play the compassion card. Moreover, medical schools, dental colleges, free clinics, doctors themselves, and charities used to pick-up such cases - before the government got involved.
The bottom line is this:
1. There's NO WAY more people can be provided MORE goods and services (medical or otherwise), and have the overall costs decline.
2. A person IS RESPONSIBLE for his/her own life and/or health and/or destiny. To convince people otherwise is irresponsible. To structure the system otherwise is destructive.
by jmgarvin
[i].....the average price of a gallon of gas from 1918 to the present is $2.37 in inflation adjusted dollars.
If we look at the average annual Inflation adjusted gasoline prices for each of the following years (1958, 1968, 1978, 1988, 1998, and 2008 )we see the following:
Inflation Adjusted Gasoline Prices
[b][u]Year Price[/b][/u]
1958 $2.24
1968 $2.11
1978 $2.16
1988 $1.75
1998 $1.35
2008 $3.23
2009 $2.28 [/i]
Source:
http://inflationdata.com/inflation/Inflation_Rate/Gasoline_Inflation.asp
Therefore, your comment is moot.
Hold onto your wallets. It's about to be reduced - or possibly eliminated.
http://www.chcchoices.org/Article/26590/Reform_Bill_Could_End_Popular_HSAs_Flex_Spending.html
Blame yourself - you voted for these guys.
Have you decided that you'd rather pay-as-you-go, rather than buy into some comprehensive medical insurance plan?
Hold onto your wallet. You're going to be FORCED to buy a product (medical insurance) whether you want it or not.
Blame yourself - you voted for these guys.
Nonetheless, you MUST buy insurance that will cover pregnancy and prenatal care, whether you want it or not.
Blame yourself - you voted for these guys.
1. Repeal the 16th amendment.
2. Support FairTax. (www.fairtax.org)
by tonythetiger
Regardless of the fact that you've worked DECADES to provide for your own needs, you MUST pay for the perceived needs of others - regardless of how total strangers define those needs. Otherwise, you lack compassion. In other words, just pay and STFU.
(Posted with the amount of sarcasm understood by the reader.)
by gpgreene
1. I am calm.
2. You've not proven to be my friend.
Okay, a third:
3. You compare apples and hubcaps.
Number three was a good one.
Shows that you are learning.
by av .
But I think it its time that both sides come together to solve the problem.
AV
by jmgarvin
by jmgarvin
Not me, too?
You have a very, very long way to go, [b]jmgarvin[/b], in order to address me, seeing as how I lift your skirt and see what lies beneath.
by jmgarvin
You collect hubcaps?
(I prefer the 1966-67 Chevrolet wire wheel cover.)
Versus the tossed salad of the Obama crowd.
by oz_media
In case you didn't notice already, the media is having a field day with his slip. Of course he didn't MEAN 3000 percent, it was simply misread, which I assume you know already. The White House transcript adds [i](sic)[/i] after that comment too.
However, a simple search, such as the one you used to find the clip on YouTube would show you the answer to your question.
Nicely titled AGAIN though to attract attention to nothing.
I think that should be the acronym used for your anti-Obama clubhouse.
"AATN" - Attract Attention To Nothing.
Here's what your right wing fans had to say, comparatively to how the left treated Bushisms.
"Don?t believe he said that? Watch video here" (which offers a link to same video clip as he had actually meant it)
[b]Barack Insane Obame:[/b][i]" And the audience of idiot drones started cheering? [/i]
http://atlasshrugs2000.typepad.com/atlas_shrugs/2010/03/barack-insane-obama-nationalized-medicine-will-result-in-a-3000-percent-decrease-in-premiums.html
And of course you read the Hota Air Gaffe article on HotAirPundit, which echoes many of your posts oh too well.
http://hotairpundit.blogspot.com/2010/03/obama-gaffe-at-rally-you-employer-would.html
From ABC news:[B]FACT CHECK: Obama Plan Only Slows Premiums Rise[/b]
[i]A White House press spokesman later said the president misspoke; he had meant to say annual premiums would drop by $3,000.[/i]
IN fact, it's pretty clear judging by the endless press that this was a matter most ignored as they were more focused on his suggesting savings in the double digits. Most saw this as an obvious prompter mistake and don't take it the way you seem to. To compare that with Bush, making up words with conviction, is ridiculous.
Bush was just plain stupid, sounded srtupid, looked stupid and acted stupid, Obama made a mistake in a speech. BIG difference.
Here's what a few others way about it too:
"Either he's an idiot or someone put the wrong numbers in the teleprompter. Can you imagine George W. Bush being this dumb???"
" but the biggest whopper is when Obama claims that, under his plan, employer health premiums will drop up to 3,000 percent (if this doesn?t sell, he?ll switch to a ?gazillion bajillion percent?), which will then of course lead to you getting a raise. "
So really, the right wing is having a field day, well those who don't realize it was a simple error that was quickly rectified by The White House after the speech was given.
And you think it is comparable to Bush makign up his own verssion of the English language, sending your troops to war/die based on a false premise?
Yeah, the two don't compare, Bush was flogged for being a moron that ignored international agreements, his own words and then placed Americans in greater harms way. Obama hasn't got that far yet.
Your, "yet", ought to have been separated by a comma.
Otherwise, you grunge in the dirt of wayward particulars.
by oz_media
by oz_media
He said "...which means [b]they could[/b] give you a raise".
Your argument, if applied correctly, means that no employer in America will be able to offer staff a raise if their costs are cut by $3000.00 per employee.
I simply love the way Americans miscomprehend and interpret comments to create their own false arguments. That's exactly what got Bush to support war in the first place.
by oz_media
Which do YOU expect to be supported?
Both save Americans lives, however one points a finger at a flawed American system, the other points a finger at someone else.
Remember, America is a perfect country, a paradigm of how a country should be; globally dependant, seriously in debt, divided amongst it own kind and war hungry.
Don't you forget it, how ungrateful you are to a nation that saves your life each day!
The health of 'the others' is irrelevant, Americans with money can afford health care, others are simply substandard citizens anyway. Sure they are also the bulk of US troops but that's irrelevant also, just because.
by oz_media
by oz_media
It most certainly was a blatant mistake, which the White House then corrected shortly after it was misspoken.
Being unable to pronounce common English words and making up your own words wouldn't see you hired in a help desk position, but a President why not?
Try and at least see the difference before you lump the two together as one and the same.
by oz_media
You just made a comment that Obama doesn't read his speeches because, if he did he would not have read a comment improperly.
PERHAPS, and this is just speculation, he read the speech and it was fine, made a few adjustments as they commonly do, and when retyped it was typed in wrong?
He's not trying to rewrite English and make up his own words, it was a teleprompter mistake.
Then again, Windows users have run out of valid arguments too and simply grasp at straws, now that Win 7 is such a successful system.
If he's articulate and well ehearsed, people complain that he's a typical canned politician. If he makes a mistake, people compare him to Bush, as if it validates Bush in some farcical manner.
Wow, some people need to find a new hobby!
by oz_media
If you don't fit on THIS box you MUST fit in that one. You should know how it works.
[i]"Little boxes on the hillside, Little boxes made of ticky tacky
Little boxes on the hillside, little boxes all the same
There?s a green one and a pink one and a blue one and a yellow one
And they?re all made out of ticky tacky and they all look just the same.
And the people in the houses all went to the university
Where they were put in boxes and they came out all the same,
And there?s doctors and there?s lawyers, and business executives
And they?re all made out of ticky tacky and they all look just the same.
And they all play on the golf course and drink their martinis dry,
And they all have pretty children and the children go to school
And the children go to summer camp and then to the university
Where they are put in boxes and they come out all the same.
And the boys go into business and marry and raise a family
In boxes made of ticky tacky and they all look just the same.[/i]
Wee, tiny boxes for wee, tiny minds. :)
It's wee, tiny minds that rely on the output of wee, tiny minds.
Quit grunging.
by oz_media
by oz_media
How many are there to the US Constitution now?
And yet that is the most valued document in US history.
Of course it will be ammended, stripped and changed over time, to think otherwise is pure ignorance. The issue is, if it doesn't get passed now, chances are it will be a LOOOONG time before it ever does.
by oz_media
Only, just, and only, someone looking you straight in the eye.
Don't blink, or, I have your ass.
by oz_media
There was a midshipman who once climbed Everest too but he fell to his death when Jimmy Carter heard about it.
Stay away from my ass, I don't go that way.
You do middling, fare-thee-well.
You escape, once, again.
by oz_media
I am assuming that with Washington gas prices averaging $2.79 and your carefully calculated valid gas price being $2.28, then jck's comments that gas is too expensive are therefore validated. Of course, that's giving that 60 cents per gallon more than the calculated inflation rate would be considered too much.
And I assume that the gas price is the same throughout the USA, as you buy at one price, and the cost of delivering to various states is free.
Why wouldn't gas be more expensive in Colorado ($2.43) than Washington ($2,79).
(aaaahhh, now I get it, it's not your concern because YOU pay less! Of course, just like everything else you stand for, it's all about you! )
I suppose the simplicity of your calculations and reasoning doesn't allow for such realities though, thus making your comment moot.
by oz_media
You support others having their hard earned money 'stolen' by the government to support a war that [i]you[/i] deem necessary even though they don't.
So they can pay for your supposed safety, but you don't feel it right that their lives are protected using your money.
The difference is, health insurance WILL protect many and save many American's lives.
War doesn't offer such a guarantee, though it DOES gurantee the death of many innocent Americans. Many who are also at war despite their disbelief in the need for war, just because they feel a need to serve their country and the likes of yourself, as well as those they actually care about.
But that's okay, you feel it is warranted, but your money being used to help them is not.
You feel that you should get to spend your money AND theirs because you feel it is right.
I have noted your streaming hypocrisy before, haven't I?
With Latin, having studied it extensively as a boy.
You...you are a boy?
by jmgarvin
by jmgarvin
by tig2
Kinda like I "pass" a horrible meal that has played h*ll on my innards.
I can only hope that Mr. Obama is held accountable for all that he has managed to do while in office.
by jck
...a really good concept bastardized by 520 (i'm giving the benefit of the doubt that there are maybe 15 good people on Capitol Hill) members of Congress.
I'm voting out everyone I can except for the one rep who has stuck to her guns and said what I have said all along. Make a system that fixes what's wrong...not everything that is there.
Of course, I heard today the reconciliation thing is going to add back into the mix giving illegal aliens medical care.
Sorry. If you break the law coming into my country illegally, we owe you nothing more than a short trip home.
by puppybreath
by jmgarvin
by oz_media
Daytime it is around $1.13L, at night (usually after 8PM) it drops to about $1.10, driving a half hour to the Valley drops it from 8-15cents litre. You burn the savings going there and back, but it works out to a nice drive for free anyway. If I drive to Washington, also about a half hour away (plus up to several hours crossing the border) I can buy US gas for only 2.79USD which is a mere $2.84 CAD Gal!
Try coming to Canada for gas!
1 Imperial gallon = 3.78L Metric Litres
1 Imperial gallon = (3.78 X$ $1.13CAN )$4.27 CAN per US GAL
$ 1.13L CAN = $ 1.11US (not much difference these days!)
$4.27CAN = $4.20 USD per US Gallon.
60% of the United States oil imports come from Canada, more specifically, Alberta; our neghbouring province. I have refineries within 20 minutes of the front door. Yet it is nearly double the cost compared to me hitting the US for gas. I used to get gas (milk, cheese, beer, smokes) in the US once a week at least but now the border is so crappy that I don't bother unless I have another reason to cross.
So I suppose what I am getting at is...
[b]QUICHERWDAMNBELLYACHIN![/b] :D
by oz_media
Always a straight up reality.
And shouldn't it be "...escape, once again?"
I had a look for specifics but only found the use of the term 'once again' in the descriptions, I don't think it needs a comma. :D :D
MUWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!! ]:)
(no, I really don't give a rats arse)
by jck
[i]The government of the United States of America was created to guarantee and protect those natural rights of man; the government of Mexico was not.[/i]
Actually, the government of the United States was created to provide protection from tyranny and religious oppression as were being exerted upon the colonies by the British crown.
It wasn't created to provide protection for some "natural right". Nature doesn't provide you religion or protection from it. A government does, which is man-made. Duh.
Out government was formed to stop the oppression and unjust deeds of a monarch called King George III.
You should have watched School House Rock. Then maybe you'd know what every other 3rd grader for 20 years learned on Saturday mornings.
Nothing...and I repeat, NOTHING...in nature gives you a right to protection from another man...even God doesn't protect you from that...nor does the Libertarian party.
Don't believe me?? Take your caucasian butt to Compton, CA or East St. Louis, IL and walk the streets and see if God or the Libertarian party protects you from another man.
Your government establishes you freedom of speech, press, right to peaceable assembly, from unfair taxation, to bear arms, vote, etc.
It does not give you a natural right. Otherwise, it would give you the right to breathe.
[i]I suppose that's why Mexicans flock into the USA in droves, while Americans are not exactly flocking south.[/i]
Yeah well, don't count on that for long.
With the labor market moving to Mexico and/or Canada (if not Asia), you will eventually see the tide of Americans moving from this country to find work.
In fact, I can tell you of 2 people I know who moved to Canada in the past year for work because they could get better pay and benefits. So, it could be already turning.
And remember, Max. The richest man in the world is now...a Mexican.
And, people will go where the money is.
I've tried leaving America. I'd be treated better as an employee in Europe...even by American companies who are based there.
Go figure. My own homeland affords me less rights as a person than a foreign country.
So, why do you have some high-and-mighty belief that Americans or any other worker would stay here and be mistreated for another 50 years?
So much for "natural rights"...
[i]Like I said, you have no clue.[/i]
Nah, I have a clue. I don't wear blinders like you. I can think outside of the "me me me" box.
[i]Debating with jck is either too easy or an effort in futility - or perhaps a lot of both.[/i]
And talking to yourself is a sign of dementia. Better go see a doc. I think that cowboy hat you wear is too tight.
[i]I'm amazed at how much you say, jck, but how little you know. [/i]
You keep on thinking that, since you believe so much in that "natural right" you have to what you want.
So when you need a 2nd income later in life because you trusted in those "natural rights" you say you have that don't protect you from guys like Bernie Madoff and Mike Milken, come see me in Central America. I'll let you pour me beers for 20 pesos a day at my cabana on the coast I picked up for about 1/6th of an American house. :p
by jck
The National Average for a gallon of Gasoline in the United States was $2.81 per gallon the other day, that would be the 2nd highest number you've quoted.
Hence, gasoline being almost as high as ever per gallon would mean that...it *is* expensive.
Otherwise, it'd be $2.25 a gallon again...
Oooooookay.
(Shaking my head in disbelief.)
It's really quite sad.
by jmgarvin
by jck
...could draw that's where I learned everything from. Simple mind...simple thinking.
Fact is, many millions of children in this country learned the basics of math, government, and science from School House Rock.
The fact that you speak poorly an educational institution in America that taught young children the basics of how their government was formed and how we fought for freedom from tyranny shows how truely unpatriotic you are.
BTW, here's the point I was making: School House Rock had a teaching episode called "No More Kings" that taught why colonists came to this country, why this country was founded, and what they were trying to escape when they revolted against Mother England.
If you really have no concept of how essential and basic that tool was to teach millions of American children about the simplest concept of the freedoms America was founded to provide, I truly pity you.
I really do.
"Rockin and a rollin...splishin and a splashin...over the horizon...what can it be? Looks like it's going to be...a free country."
See. I learned that at about 6 or 7 years old. And, I still remember it.
I even found you the video. Maybe you should go watch it. Maybe you'll learn something.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ofYmhlclqr4
Go look for "I'm Just a Bill" and "Mother Necessity" too on YouTube. If you haven't seen them, you might be impressed.
You and jck are among the most uninformed, naive, and historically illiterate people who try to pass themselves off as those possessing a clue. It's pointless conversing with either of you. I might as well be discussing things with a third grader. (Oh wait, jck admitted to being guided by a third grade PBS show.)
Recommended reading for both of you:
[i]A Conflict of Visions[/i], by Thomas Sowell
[i]The Vision of the Anointed[/i], by Thomas Sowell
[i]Free to Choose[/i], by Milton Friedman
[i]Wealth and Poverty[/i], by George Gilder
[i]The Way the World Works[/i], by Jude Wanniski
[i]The Wealth of Nations[/i], by Adam Smith (Full title: [i]An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations[/i])
[i]The Federalist Papers[/i], by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay
I could go on, but that's enough for now. After that assignment, we expect a full report telling us what you learned. In the meantime, turn off School House Rock and try to educate yourselves.
by jck
That's what I read about. That the Congressional Hispanic Caucus was pushing for that.
Scary. If you are Arab and come here illegally to work, a lot of people will scream you are a terrorist just because of your ethnicity.
If you're Mexican, you're just "coming for a better way of life"...poor babies.
They need to build that wall, boot out the illegals, put legal people back to work here paying taxes and being prosperous and not feeding off welfare/WIC, and put armed guards on that wall to keep the criminals from coming here illegally.
by puppybreath
that would solve the unemployment problem: No job? Up on the wall you go!
I have a feeling that after a couple of days of doing that, other jobs that they've passed up on for not being "just right" would suddenly look inviting.
:-)
by jck
in Dec. 2004, I was paying approximately $352 per month for health insurance.
in April 2008, I was paying $730 a month.
In less than 4 years, the insurance rate I had to pay for comparable policies from the [b][u]same insurance corporation[/u][/b] doubled.
Sorry. But, an industry who would double their premium in a 4 year period on someone who'd had 2 hospitalizations in 35 years...deserves no loyalty from me to keep their profiteering alive.
I hope they all die. All of them.
by jck
[i]You and jck are among the most uninformed, naive, and historically illiterate people who try to pass themselves off as those possessing a clue. It's pointless conversing with either of you. I might as well be discussing things with a third grader. (Oh wait, jck admitted to being guided by a third grade PBS show.)[/i]
It was ABC, you moron. Not PBS.
At least I knew what network it was on. You didn't even know that.
And yeah, I did get guided by School House Rock...when I was 5-10 years old.
So were millions of other kids.
Only a snot, know-it-all pious egotist like you would assume to think you know more about government and teaching it to child as to put down a program, created for ABC Television to show, by people with PhDs in Education.
So you go thinking you're so smart, Max.
Again...when your false "natural rights" fail you, Social Security crashes, and your retirement fund is drained by some financial charlatan...don't come whining to me.
by jmgarvin
This is how the bill will affect you:
DOOOOOOMMMMMMM
by puppybreath
I'm concerned with how it will affect the future of freedom and liberty in America, and how it will only add to the enormous debt we've been accumulating (for which both parties are to blame) over the past two to three decades; and how it will further add to the unfunded mandates (Social Security, Medicare, and now this), which are already upwards of $50 Trillion, which will, in addition to the national debt, be a burden to my (and others') kids and grandkids.
I don't care about me. I care about the future of this country. Freedom and Liberty have been hijacked by Socialism, and my kids will suffer the consequences. I care about how free enterprise is becoming less free, and how individual freedom is being infringed upon.
It's you and your ilk who only care about yourselves. You lack the fortitude to accept full and total personal responsibility for your own life, and accept whatever challenges life throws your way - and you can't face it without blaming others, whether that be [i]big bad business, greedy insurance companies, evil Conservatives and/or Republicans[/i], et al.
So keep blaming other people for any and every challenge you and your ilk are faced with. And keep running to nanny government to take care of everything you lack the courage to accept responsibility for yourself. Keep believing that government knows best, while individuals know least. And know that it's you and your ilk who will, for the first time in American history, pass onto future generations significantly less freedom and liberty enjoyed by previous ones. Know that you and your ilk are the ones chipping away at those things that made America great to begin with.
To be a free people is to accept responsibility that comes with it. Unfortunately, all too many people lack the fortitude to accept freedom.
To paraphrase Jack Nicholson's character in [i]A Few Good Men[/i], "[i]You want the truth? You Can't Handle the Truth."[/i] You want freedom? You can't handle freedom.
by delbertpgh
The great old free enterprise system thunders on, but it's modern times, and some of the stuff that made men rich is now illegal. The cheapest way to get rid of your manufacturing by-products used to be spewing them into the atmosphere or dumping them into a river. Stock and bond markets were machines for bilking the uninformed. Patent medicine was usually a hoax and often poisonous. Insurors were scammers. All of these actors were protected by laws (or absence of laws) that gave them the economic freedom to scrape up whatever money they saw. The flip side to their freedom was the lack of freedom of the public to avoid their poisons and financial traps.
Time to start thinking about new freedoms. The freedom to die from a curable disease is no freedom at all, any more than the freedom to stand in acid rain.
by av .
Under yesterday's system, you could be one illness away from bankruptcy. Just think about how that would affect your kids. There has got to be a better way than that. Maybe the bill they just passed isn't it right now, but it does end medical bankruptcy.
Government run healthcare, socialism, it doesn't matter what you call it, if it wasn't for Social Security and Medicare, I don't know what most seniors in this country would do. Its not a matter of government knows best, its more like most people can't afford to do anything else. Life is expensive, and we all get old.
Freedom and liberty, as we knew it when we grew up, is gone. After 9/11, security concerns replaced it and its going to be that way for a long time to come.
AV
by jck
Hm...let's analyze what you've said, oh all-knowing, super-intelligent Max:
[i]I'm concerned with how it will affect the future of freedom and liberty in America, and how it will only add to the enormous debt we've been accumulating (for which both parties are to blame) over the past two to three decades; and how it will further add to the unfunded mandates (Social Security, Medicare, and now this), which are already upwards of $50 Trillion, which will, in addition to the national debt, be a burden to my (and others') kids and grandkids.[/i]
Actually, there will be no additional debt from this according to the CBO:
[i][b]Estimated Budgetary Impact of the Legislation[/b]
CBO and JCT estimate that enacting both pieces of legislation?H.R. 3590
and the reconciliation proposal?would produce a net reduction in federal
deficits of $143 billion over the 2010?2019 period as result of changes in
direct spending and revenues (see Table 1). That figure comprises
$124 billion in net reductions deriving from the health care and revenue
provisions and $19 billion in net reductions deriving from the education
provisions. Approximately $114 billion of the total reduction would be onbudget;
other effects related to Social Security revenues and spending as
well as spending by the U.S. Postal Service are classified as off-budget.
CBO has not completed an estimate of the potential impact of the
legislation on discretionary spending, which would be subject to future
appropriation action.[/i]
-Congressional Budget Office
http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/113xx/doc11379/Manager%27sAmendmenttoReconciliationProposal.pdf
I can't handle the truth?
Evidently, you don't know the truth.
That "socialism" you fear is going to save billions. So keep crying wolf.
I've exposed your ignorance on the matter with the exact text from the non-partisan CBO report.
QED
jmgarvin and jck are beyond hope, but you should know better. We've conversed enough for you to know that I'm not advocating no government and no regulation of business. To suggest as much is beyond disingenuous, and it treads on dishonest.
I freely acknowledge those government things that have been a positive for American society, some of which you mentioned. But I also acknowledge those government things that have been - or will be - a negative for American society. And anything that makes more people more dependent on government - especially when it's forced dependency - is a negative. Do you disagree? If so, make your case, but please don't do it in a way that misrepresents my real convictions and real position. You should know better; you're smarter than that.
P.S. Back in the 60s and 70s, I was first in line to advocate regulation against environmentally destructive practices, racism, et al. However, just like the Labor Unions, they didn't know when to simply declare victory and cease. Instead, they took it to the next level and actually became the perpetrator instead of the victim. That's when I jumped off their band wagon.
Of course I'm concerned about myself. My comment was to deflect the notion that some government program would be good for me. My point was that I'm not acting in a selfish [i]what's in it for me[/i] kind of way, like jck and jmgarvin are obviously doing.
I'm so concerned for myself that I want government to get out of my life so I can be concerned for myself.
I acknowledge that the medical delivery system is totally screwed up in this country. I also acknowledge that the one thing that has been most instrumental in screwing it up in the first place was the interjection of a third-party payer, whether that third-party payer be insurance or government. In fact, that's the "REAL dirty little secret" - government and insurance screwed it up in the first place, so let's implement MORE government and insurance to fix it. YEA, RIGHT!
As such, why in the hell should we want MORE of the very thing that got us into this mess to begin with? It's insanity.
P.S. Over the years, I've been consistent in saying, [i]"The one thing that has been most instrumental in screwing it (the medical delivery system) up in the first place was the interjection of a third-party payer, whether that third-party payer be insurance or government.[/i]
I can't recall a single instance when a person conceded that point - or, more importantly, disagreed and debated it.
I challenge anyone to disagree and debate - AND REMAIN ON THAT POINT.
And if you can't disagree and debate that point, then concede the point.
P.P.S. Don't buy into it, AV. It's a trap.
P.P.P.S. The next "dirty little secret" is that the insurance industry and big-government are in bed together - good cop, bad cop, so to speak.
by puppybreath
that they won't consider amending the McCarran-Ferguson Act to allow interstate competition for health insurance?
Democrats are already arguing that they have the constitutional right to do what they want with healthcare reform because the US government already regulates interstate commerce, AND health insurance companies are regulated under interstate commerce.
This is important, because one logical solution to start fixing healthcare would be to toss the regulation which prohibits health insurance companies from competing across state lines. That is of course, unless you want even more control of people's freedoms.
So that's how they are going to shove this law down our throats if it ends up in court.
The Democrats absolutely cannot deregulate existing health insurance laws, because the interstate commerce law will be their Supreme Court argument in their defense.
It's the only way they can prevent the court from overturning the law.
..... the majority of the American people let them get away with it. They've sold their souls to the devil, in exchange for accepting [i]what's in it for them[/i]. We live in a nation with a lot of foolish people.
And this is one of the biggest fools of them all:
by jck
Oh my God. You aren't about yourself?
Yours is, and for a long time has been, a "Let me keep my money for me and my kids and grandkids, and to heck with anyone else who can't get what I got." attitude.
Fact is, there are people in the world who worked way harder than you ever have, and gained nothing to show for it and not because of mismanagement or lack of responsibility.
See, you think everyone will be as lucky as you have been if they do like you. Opportunity is no guarantee. Just like no stock is a sure winner.
And your thinking that everyone will be where you are if they do what you did and have no excuse is, in itself, is very egocentric and screams self-praising and narcissistic.
Get over yourself. You might have worked hard, but not everyone gets the breaks you did or is able to earn a better spot in life.
Want an example??
My parents, in their 30s, had saved six figures, had 4 children, their own home, everything. And, they both grew up dirt poor and worked their butts off.
What happened?
Medical costs bankrupted my parents. My parents had to spend every dime they had and exhaust their insurance coverage for my brother who had a malignant brain tumor at age 10.
Some people aren't as lucky as you, can't afford healthcare or can't get it, and even a 2 day stay in the hospital ruins them for years.
So, don't go saying people don't try that want this. Even having insurance doesn't mean you're safe for sure. My family is proof.
I know. Even though I have great insurance, I still had to pay over $5k out of pocket on a policy that was supposedly a "$2500 out-of-pocket maximum" policy.
So, you think that insurance company is going to stick to their word?
I sure as hell don't. And if they can't compete in a regulated marketplace, then maybe they don't need to be in business.
Wah. Poor corporations only profiting billions. I feel so bad for them.
by tonythetiger
to the pressure placed on it by the providers, who are increasing the costs to paying customers because the government programs only pay a small percentage of what they are billed. These providers still have staff to pay and equipment to buy.
They INTENTIONALLY created this problem, just like they intentionally create the other problems they pretend to "fix", in order to grow themselves. And a certain subset of the population buys into the con every time.
by puppybreath
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]$4.27CAN = $4.20 USD per US Gallon.[/i]
is taxes?
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
How are you suggesting that the cost to secure each citizen is the same?
Surely that would depend on who faces attack, from where and when. Therefore it could cost nothign to save you, if you are not attacked, but millions to beed up protection enough so that someone else who MAY be attacked will not be attacked.
To minimize the welfare of your fellowman based on their financial status is just too expected,
Oz: you muck with the fundamentals of "fellow man" in far, far too cavalier a way.
So does Tony.
by oz_media
the national average is about 32% according to Petro Canada. But that doesn't equate to upwards of doubling pump prices, especially considering that you pay around 20% federal and state tax too (according to the US Energy Information Administration).
So with a rough average of 12% difference in taxes, how does that justify such extreme difference when you are the purchaser?
by oz_media
Someone's definition of fellow man is entirely up to their own interpretation.
Citizens, of the country I live in, or those around me (friend or foe) are my fellow man.
If you find that it's just those who you feel warrant such recognition from you, that is your interpretation. In my view, that would be selfish, self centered and egotistsical. Again, interpretation.
We each are related to one another in how we absolutely are to one another; how we each stand to the rest of us; and, how the rest of us stand to any one of us.
There is absolutely no relative interpretation involved.
by oz_media
You just proved, in your 'special' way, that it is 100% a matter of personal interpretation, as your interpretation differs a great deal from mine.
A kindred human being (fellowman or fellow man) is one that is accepted as a peer. If I see all citizens as equal and worthy of the same privileges I am, then I also see all citizens as peers. In contrast you seem to feel that only those YOU accept or approve of ar worthy of such respect from you. As you obviously don't see all Americans as equals, if you did you'd be one in 330 million anyway. Your live in a divided nation, to think that you could grasp such a concept is laughable, you don't see it nor live it, how could you possibly undestand or accept it?
Again, pure proof that it is a matter of personal definition. Unless you think you are about to tell me who my peers are or who I consider a kindred being worthy of my respect and acceptance as my fellowman.
Like I said, give your head a good shake; you are SO far off base on this one, it's not even worthy of further discussion.
..... about Liberty
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--VMlvbkJbw
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.
.....endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.....
.....endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.....
.....endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.....
[i]You should have watched School House Rock. Then maybe you'd know what every other 3rd grader for 20 years learned on Saturday mornings...... Actually, the government of the United States was created to provide protection from tyranny and religious oppression as were being exerted upon the colonies by the British crown. It wasn't created to provide protection for some "natural right". Nature doesn't provide you religion or protection from it. A government does, which is man-made. Duh..... Nothing...and I repeat, NOTHING...in nature gives you a right to protection from another man...even God doesn't protect you from that[/i]
-jck
He must have been watching Barney and Friends that day instead.
..... and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, ..... We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.....
I wonder what he thinks that means?
And what this means:
......That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form.....
by jck
I'm a fool? Hahaha.
[i]He must have been watching Barney and Friends that day instead.[/i]
No, I never watched Barney and Friends. I watched Sesame Street. My parents taught me how to behave, share, and get along...not some purple dinosaur.
[i]..... and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, ..... We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.....[/i]
Very good, Max.
Now, explain how that means any more than you having a right to fend for yourself and make your way in the world, without oppression from a tyrannical government?
That's what they were writing to defend. The right to make your way. Not to allow you not to participate in the greater good of your nation.
People like you, who hoarded and kept for yourself were let to be castigated from places like Jamestown for being separatist and non-participating.
Your kind would have starved in Colonial America.
[i]And what this means:
......That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form.....[/i]
It means you have a right to revolt.
So, I implore you. Go to Washington DC. Be a revolutionary. Please. I dare you. Go alter and abolish your heart out.
I really liked School House Rock.
"Conjunction Junction","Gravity", "Elbow Room." and "I'm just a bill" were classics.
(just thought I would throw in my lame attempt at humor in this insanely heated and serious discussion)
Sort by Trending