Discussion Locked

ObamaCare: It's not about medical care; it's about control over your life

0 helpful
752 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

752 replies

by tonythetiger

[i]The US spend on healthcare is more than twice ours and far in excess of the Cuban spend - more than ten times higher per capita - and yet it seems not to benefit you at all.[/i]

goes for education... yet a certain group seems to think throwing even MORE money at the problem is going to fix it.

by Member 25348569

If you accept anything, you accept it all however unwillingly. You don't want to pay for someone else's healthcare, I don't want to pay for my government's shenanigans in Iraq and Afghanistan among others but all |I can do is vote out the people who make me pay for stuff I don't want.

by tonythetiger

[i]I think the only thing right about the "us vs. them" mentality is the "vs.". I don't think the government should be forcing us to pay for personal benefit of anyone. You don't think the government should be paying for "an unnecessary middle-east war". [b]I think we're both on the same side of the "vs."[/b][/i]

by tonythetiger

but since I have paid over $250,000 in the last 35 years for health insurance, and haven't used $10,000 worth of health services in my entire life, that I'm "owed" at least $240,000 in health services, even if I don't pay another dime!

by tonythetiger

[i]It's easy for those with insurance (me included) to criticize something that won't have a direct impact on them. [/i]

Sorry, but I just got a letter that beginning in 2011, the cost for the premium plan that is currently costing $597 per month (they pay $400, I pay $197) will go up to $1360 per month (they still pay $400, I'll be paying $960) until my wife turns 55 when it would drop to $796 (they still pay $400). Since my income is $2629 per month (less the $197), I'd say that qualifies as a "direct impact". I'll have to dip into my reserves sooner and to a greater extent than I had intended. I planned to live to 86, now I'll have to die at 77.

Oh well. If the government thinks 77's OK, I guess it'll be OK.

by the 'g-man.'

The NHS

Which I pay for through National Insurance on earnings, hence the 'free'.

But if I was jobless or had no income I would still recieve the care.

by the 'g-man.'

Each of the Countries of the United Kingdom has a National Health Service that provides public healthcare to all UK permanent residents that is free at the point of need and paid for from general taxation.

So it is my 'right' as a UK permanent resident from the ruling Government.

Even prescription charges are free if in Scotland.

by puppybreath

So, if you have a valid passport, you have a right to free healthcare, correct?

I noticed you didn't say free health insurance. That's the point. Did your country need to take over your insurance industry to provide your citizens with free healthcare?

by breezer85

When the NHS was formed many years ago there was a HUGE wave of opponents. NOW many years down the line we've got used to it and are thankful(to use the term loosely) for it!

15-20 years down the line Americans will also be thankful for it!

So stop bickering and moaning and get on with it!

by oz_media

But are headed in the right direction anyway.

One of the thinsg I like about Canada is that they are observant of others. They saw flaws in the UK system and have tried to devise an improved system in Canada, while still flawed, it does work, for the most part. The same goes for technology, several US deregulations took place during the 80's and 90's, Canada followed suit but not until several years later when the US changes coul dbe observed and a more suitable system was designed for Canadians.

I agree that these changes take decades to become effective, after many changes, trial and error.

It seems that many Americans feel this should come out of the gate running on all fours. While insecurity and doubt is to be initially expected of such an extreme change, I think people will eventually mellow as they see that they spend less and get more; even if they do feel that their money is stolen from those who earn it and given to people who didn't earn it (taxation seems to be an unfathomable repellant to many Americans).

by jck

[i]$100 a year. $8 a month? That makes it or breaks it for you?[/i]

I don't get to choose my insurance. It's forced upon me.

So if paying $50 more per year in taxes breaks your right to individuality, then my right is broken in having to give up $600+ a month in benefit I could keep to myself or choose another carrier if I had a choice...which I don't.

See, life is unfair.

Of course soon enough, I won't have to worry about that. I don't plan on staying where I am or having the option of "take our insurance or you get nothing".

by tonythetiger

Were talking about stealing property from someone who earned it and giving it to someone who didn't.

by jck

Who stole?

It's law. Therefore, it's the rule you are to live by in this country until you leave, die, or repeal the law.

Hence, there's no theft.

This is just your way of over-dramatizing what you don't want to give up that everyone else has to as well.

I suggest you become an activist and get on the phone daily to every US Representative and Senator you can, and get that law changed into thievery.

If anyone is thieving in this country, it's:

A) Members of Congress getting $170k+ per year, and then get their travel, benefits, etc., all paid for.

B) Corporations who take "grants" to do research that leads to no benefit to the people.

So when Congress and Corporations stop taking $100Ms every year in "stolen property", then we can work on halting giving it to those who really benefit from it.

by jamesrl

When UK, Canada and others implemented "universal" healthcare, the medical insurance industry were relatively small.

Its one thing to approve the principle, its another to implement "universal" health care when a large and complex network of comprehensiev health insurance already exists. Even if every US citizen supported the prinicple, and 100% of Congress did as well, it still would not be easy to move from where the US is today to a universal model.

James

by the 'g-man.'

if you want it.

By taking it you may reduce the level of 'waiting' for the care.

This 'waiting' is a whole other ball game which I'm sure you will soon find a whole lot more about.

Also, if I travel through Europe I get a 'E11 Medical card' for free whih covers me when in Europe.

All part of the valid UK citizen programme.

by j-mart

The more sensible option such as the National Health system as in the UK or the Government funded Public Health system that I have benefited from for all of my 55 years of my life was too big a hurdle to pass through your political system, so you have ended up with what you have.

We have a public funded system with enough room at the edges to enable private Medical Insurance and services to exist at an affordable rate that enhances and adds value to the public system. New Zealand being a small country with a small population spread across the whole country has to have an efficient cost effective system. The inefficient rubbish health system that the US operates on would be like having none at all. A sensible system needs to keep it's citizens as healthy as possible for the lowest cost, able to work and paying taxes, the more taxpayers, the smaller the individual load the better vale for your money. Paying taxes does not bother me if I feel I am getting fair value for my contribution.

by tonythetiger

Although I agree, he shouldn't be able to force you to a particular insurer. THAT should have been part of reform!

by maxwell edison

Posted here because the original thread reached its maximum.

Reference messages:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=327627&messageID=3267930&tag=content;leftCol

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=327627&messageID=3267936&tag=content;leftCol

[b]What the Ninth Amendment means:[/b]

[i]The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.[/i]

Definition of Enumerate: To count off or name one by one; to list.

The indisputable intent of the Constitution was to define those powers granted to the government by the people, not the other way around. These enumerated powers granted to the government were spelled out in the seven Articles that followed the Preamble. If such a power was not enumerated - specifically spelled out - then the government had no such power.

The first ten amendments, commonly known as the Bill of Rights, were added only upon the insistence of several delegates, primarily George Mason of the Virginia delegation, as a way to get them to ratify the constitution. These rights maintained by the people, so their argument went, were so important that they must be enumerated in the Constitution.

The opposing argument, however, primarily led by James Madison, contended it was unnecessary to list them, since no power to deny those rights was included in the original text of the constitution. Moreover, he argued that it would be impossible to list all such rights retained by the people, and that by including some of those rights, others (present or future) might see it as an opportunity to suggest no such right exists - an unwise and dangerous thing to do.

The solution they found was the inclusion of the ninth amendment.

[i]The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.[/i]

In lay-terms, it says that just because a right is not listed in these amendments, it shall not be construed (or assumed) that other rights retained by the people may be denied. In other words, this is not a complete list of those rights retained by the people.

And if the list of rights retained by the people could have been made complete, which would have been impossible, I don't believe the founders would have included one that said one person has a right to force another person to either provide or otherwise pay for goods or services received, medical or otherwise.

There you go, jmgarvin. That's your constitutional lesson of the day.

by santeewelding

Lie at the heart of debate in chambers now with regard to the second amendment: how to make it so without it coming back to bite our asses, constitutionally.

by maxwell edison

And the proper way to interpret the intent, is to consider the supporting documents explaining the intent - the Federalist Papers, speeches, letters, etc.

And for those who suggest that the Constitution is [i]outdated dogma[/i] (Oz_Media - as if we should care what he thinks!), or doesn't apply in the 21st Century, then we should still follow the original intent. Times may change, but human nature and [i]those rights endowed by our Creator[/i] do not. To accommodate changing times, the wisdom of the founders integrated the possibility of amending the constitution, not [/i]interpreting[/i] it (although various Supreme Courts over our history have done just that.)

It's not a perfect system, and it may not be a perfect document, but both are better than anything ever conceived by mankind in the history of the world.

by maxwell edison

I said, [i]The indisputable intent of the Constitution was to define those powers granted to the government by the people, not the other way around.[/i]

For those who've grown to know me over the years, you know that I'm very actively involved in the Boy Scouts of America. Part of that involvement is to council scouts who are working on Merit Badges, especially the ones required to achieve the rank of Eagle Scout. (Counseling, by the way, is merely verifying they've met the requirements. The boys do ALL the work.) Three Citizenship Merit Badges - in the Community, the Nation, and the World - are all Eagle required.

As you might imagine, I have to exercise extreme restraint in either challenging or advancing political positions. But I actually do it quite well. (The [i]global warming / climate change[/i] crap that I hear is incredible; but I withhold personal opinion and/or agenda, and judge only on how the requirements were satisfied. I bite my tongue often - and the time I saw a picture of a polar bear [i]stranded[/i] on a piece of floating ice, my tongue actually started to bleed.)

However, there is one question on which I almost ALWAYS correct a scout's contention, and that's the one that asks about the intent of the Constitution. Ninety percent of the boys say that the Constitution defines the rights granted to the people by the government. No, I tell them; it's the other way around (thinking, who is teaching you that misconception - or failing to teach you?) It's the ONLY time I correct them - and that's not a political position; it's reality - one all too many people either forget or weren't taught in the first place.

by notsochiguy

During my student teaching experience (15 years ago), the 8th graders I was working with were gearing up to take the constitution test.

As you can imagine from your experience with the scouts, kids were being taught content (1st Amendment covers....2nd Amendment says....) and not context (Why is 5th amendment important, what exactly is freedom of speech, etc). Rote learning at its finest!

On more than a few occassions, I did have to point them to other sources (Declaration of Independence and Gettysburg Address, for example) that clearly state that the government is empowered by the people, and not the other way around; just to give them perspective on what they were 'learning'. I vividly remember being chastised by the teacher that I was burdening the kids with too much to think about prior to the test.

My response: "John Dewey is truly dead."

Sadly, I think the reference was a total fly by.

by santeewelding

The [i]Antifederalist[/i] -- larger corpus of the two -- in these discussions.

Or, do you do so for economy of words?

________

economy

by maxwell edison

..... ratification of the Constitution, something with which I would disagree.

However, they were also in favor of a weaker federal government yielding to stronger state governments, something with which I would agree.

Perhaps the original anti-federalists had a point. Then again, if they had their way, the American Civil War would have never been fought, or the South would have won.

Like I said, neither the system or the document are perfect, but better than any alternative. I just wish the original intent would be more prevalent today.

Edit: And we all know - don't we - that the American Civil War was less about slavery, and more about states' rights - or lack thereof.

by maxwell edison

..... where?

Personally speaking, I would do it as well. But finding my way to [i]America[/i], which is more of an idea than a piece of geography, I wouldn't know which way to go.

Therefore what?

Therefore, I stay right where I am and try to make the grass under my feet a little greener.

by jck

Requires you to fertilize it. :p

I know where I'd go. But, I'm not saying the not-so-obvious ones.

I don't want a lot of Americans going there for retirement and ruining it by thinking it's their right to be there because they have money.

Florida, from what I understand, was a pretty cool place to live...before massive retirees and rampant housing subdivision growth ruined it.

50 years ago, US 19 was a 2-lane highway going through Palm Harbor, Florida with oranges groves on either side of the highway for as far as you could see.

Now, US 19 through Palm Harbor is an 8-lane highway with run down shops, strip malls, strip bars, and decent shopping centers and gas stations at major intersections.

Yay for rampant progress and unlimited growth...not.

by oz_media

US constitution was a document outlining which righs were to be [i]bestowed[/i] upon US citizens.

P.S. The UK monarchy is not a branch of government nor do they pass laws or bestow rights on citizens. Wel they once did but have very little influence now. The key is that the government acts with a historical direction (again just as in the USA).

You also have presumed "elite noblemen", as does Canada and the UK, who are democratically elected officials. They are the people who push bills through government to bestow rights on citizens, as per the bulk of the citizens desires.

The United Kingdom has an elected government, Canada has an elected governbment, the USA has an elected government, I don't see why or how you still believe you are so different. Just because you have a democratic government in office, Canada has a Conservative government in offie and the UK has the Labour Party (centre left).

In actuality, right now, the USA has the more, left leaning government out of the three.

But you knew that already, as you said, we've has this discussion before)

by tonythetiger

[i]US constitution was a document outlining which righs were to be bestowed upon US citizens.[/i]

It outlines the rights the people bestow upon the government.

"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

by oz_media

We also have elective health "insurance" also. What is deemed 'basic medical' covers injuries and most health issues. However most employers also offer an extended medical system, which is private insurance (which can also be obtained by the individual) to cover dental care costs (or portions of it) pay for time off work during injury, elective/cosmetic surgery etc.

So really we have an elective and private insurer available, but basic health care is provided by the government for a nominal monthly fee, which is mandatory and perhaps my only beef with our system. You MUST pay for monthly medical, if you don't the bill just gets higher and higher until they garnish wages or retain tax returns etc.

However, you ALWAYS have coverage whether paid for or not. With limited income, you can apply for a subsidized/reduced cost, which is about half the normal monthly cost (In BC regular medical is $54/month, subsidized around $27). Of course, when on welfare it is provided at no cost.

by oz_media

I agree with the cost to benefit consideration. In Canada, we also have a very small population and EXTREMELY small population desity too. However, the Canadian system has been in place and ironed out over many decades too, it's not a quick flip.
A quick turnover from oine system to another is not a reality, I think that, if it can be retained long enough by future governments, it will eventually become a stable, workign and effective system that sees millions more Americans live healthier, longer lives.

Perhaps the future focus of US political campaigning will become health care focused, instead fo military focused, now that would be a shocker indeed.

It could be a great turning point in US history that changes world view of Americans and removes some of the overly individualistic thoughts of US citizens. (well, mayve that's a bit of a stretch but you never know what will happen as their nation matures).

by oz_media

But wouldn't it be better to have someone like Bush work on universal health care than foreign relations and warfare.

Bush might not have been so bad is he hadn't gone war happy, lost track, left Afghanistan and pursued a war which nobody supported.

by maxwell edison

When, oh when, will I [i]mature[/i]? For all these years I've believed that I should take personal responsibility for myself. Silly me. When will I [i]mature[/i] and figure out that I should expect others to take responsibility for me? (And, assume that they, too, expect others to be responsible for them?)

Personal responsibility - outdated dogma. When will I ever learn?

by oz_media

And if you possessed such a personal trait you would have understood I was referring to the nation/government, not the people.

The US and Canada are both mere infants as far as politics and global maturity is concerned. Canada, being formed as a British colony, was able to adopt the lessons of history learned by a more marute British nation. The US, started fresh when declaring independance.

There aren't oo many other younger, 'more immature' coutries on Earth than Canada and the USA.

"America" is only 234 years old, as far as established nations are concerned, that's barely even a fetus.

I attended a primary school that was older than America or Canada. My neighbourhood church was older than the US and Canada combined.

by santeewelding

I see wondrous things.

On the other, I see immaturity and death.

My compact with the rest, and a compact of the rest with me, is being screwed with.

I get to abandon it, too.

by santeewelding

Leads, does it not, to ossification in all things living.

Vinegar.

Your time scale leaves too much to be desired.

by oz_media

I guess I shouldn't have overestimated you.

Of course when someone refers to a nation's maturity you will take it as a personal attack.

Are you now suggesting that at the ripe old age of 234, America is a mature nation and not just a youngster on the globe?

by maxwell edison

[i]..... as far as established nations are concerned, that's barely even a fetus.[/i]

And Canada is younger. Therefore what?

And you're Canadian. Oh wait, you're British, No, that's not right, you're Canadian. You're whatever is convenient to support your argument.

Nonetheless, we told the British to shove-it.

by maxwell edison

I should have under-estimated you. That's who you are. I shouldn't expect that you could rise above issues and rely on principle.

You believe - as you've so often said and/or proven - that [i]individual responsibility[/i] is [i]outdated dogma[/i].

Figure out where you stand, Oz, before you bore us with where you sit.

by oz_media

I already addressed that comment, had you been reading along and not simply cherry picking for an argument, as usual.

[i]The US and Canada are both mere infants as far as politics and global maturity is concerned. Canada, being formed as a British colony, was able to adopt the lessons of history learned by a more marute British nation. The US, started fresh when declaring independance.[/i]

You are so proud and loud about America being the new world, how your government and people's mentality rejects all the socialist, commie systems of yesteryear.

That is fine, but in the same sense, you have to see (well maybe that's a stretch)that America has an very young goverenment and a lot of growing pains to overcome yet.

Canada, which I ALSO had said is an infant, was built on the foundations of an ancient empire with a government and systems that had been tried and tested for many centuries. While Canada's government is no longer a mirror image of the UK, it was based upon and then adjusted to hopefully work a bit better.

Just as I also said about Canada's systems and even technology over the past few decades; how the Canadian government watched US deregulation (through the 80's)and adjusted their own deregulation laws to circumvent problems that arose in the US after they deregulated.

Of course that is the method of learning we teach our children, hopefully. Observing others and learning their mistakes, instead of simply your own, is usually more benficial.

Stop being so 'kin defensive over every word I utter and try reading instead.

by oz_media

Heals and repairs, as applied to my comments it would indicate improvement by new found formation over time.

Maturity, like wine not vinegar.

by santeewelding

For my part, I done told you already: I read you at your atomic level.

I am alarmed, in some respects, at what I find.

by maxwell edison

..... will serve us to shun those older nations that have proven, over hundreds of years of history, that they reject individual freedom in favor of state-controlled society.

You, Oz, favor state-controlled society. I don't. You favor individual weakness; I don't. Get over it.

by oz_media

Santeebabble - What, me worry?

Maxwell - You read an entire post, which was not condesending to America in ANY way. From that post you focused on taking a single word out of context, and then TRIED to begin an argument over what I actually meant by it.

Don't get it? Don't try to play along.

As you have proven time and time again with your nonsensical posts, you have the reading comprehension skills of a small child.

You extract meaning and intent that was never there, you completely miss intent of a paragraph as it sees you read with a tiny monacle that focuses on individual words and rewrites it own mental copy.

From an entire comment that wasn't negative on America at all, you feel that the single word 'maturity' needs further definition. If you had read teh rest of teh post, you owuld have understood my objective was not a shot at America but a mere observation of chronological reality.

I had defined it in the previous post, which I reiterated for your too. I did not copy the previous post verbatim, so that finite definition was excluded; however I assumed that, if you were astute enough, you would have read the full thread and could comprehend the context in which it was being presented.

All fool me, I suppose, perhaps I give you more credit than you deserve.

So now that I cleaned that up for you AND even explained my explanation because you still didn't 'get it', if you can't 'get it', just piss off and find someone elses's time to waste.

by maxwell edison

Oz is weak - because he has no underlying principle. He strives for more from himself than he gives others the credit for possessing and achieving. He's proven, time and again, to be a self-centered and arrogant elitist. Big government is good, according to Oz. Individual responsibility and power over one's own destiny is bad, according to Oz.

by oz_media

If yuo actually feel that the consideration of health care for all Americans is a "whim" then it is clear how you seem to miss the reality behidn whath the government does.

Is this the first time universale health care has been considered, discussed by your governmen? DO yuo feel that Obama, as your mations president, just had a giggle over breakfast and said, "Here's an idea, why don't we tax people more and offer others affordable health care!"

You have been debating this issue (and any other you can find) for a while now, so is it really a whim? Something done in passing? Something nto properly considered?

Of course not, so while you prefer to reduce the action by calling it a whim, you merely illustrate your own ignorance and offer a reason for others to not take you seriously.

by maxwell edison

..... if that's what it is, I've never before seen in these threads one person suggesting the death of another.

Either this is disturbing, or you are disturbed.

Do you really suggest killing another person on a public discussion forum?

by oz_media

"Big government is good, according to Oz"
Prove where I have said that. I HAVE in fact said many times that big government is NOT good.

"Individual responsibility and power over one's own destiny is bad, according to Oz. "

Once again, prove where i have said that. In fact I have stood firm and said COUNTLESS times, and you have agreed also, that I feel people should take responsibility for their own actions.

To equate personal responsibility as a reason to dismiss affordable health care is ridiculous. Making an argument from nothing as always, just for the sake of argument.

You actually feel that I started my posts in this part of the thread as an attack on the US, where I actually had implied, 'I know it isn't perfect but I am sure it will get better and people will accept it over time, as they have in other nations.'

Your instant defense results in your reading me calling Americans immature?! Such a narrow mindset is exactly what causes a lot of problems for America and has placed your nation in harms way and made you a global laughing stock.

You know VERY well and have commented yourself that I sit further right than left.

So for you to now come out and suggest the opposite and with no substance to support it, simply illustrates your own hypocrisy; not mine, as you like to suggest.

The difference is, I understand than being all right or all left is not the answer, I seek middle ground that is often right focused but also offer a certain level acceptance for the left.

So if, in your wee mind, being politically center/right means being hypocritical, then you simply need to pull out a dictionary and look up the word 'hypocrisy' yourself; or just go back and read some of your own posts for examples of hypocrisy in action.

You constantly make these baseless accusations in your titles as if you have a point, and then fall flat on your face with your own BS when the post is read.

Your intelligence or, more accurately, lack thereof, has been displayed here so many times this last year it's not funny. Your credibility has been reduced repeatedly with your nonsensical defenses to what was never said and your constant spewing of utter rubbish, implying it means what it really doesn't.

You are hardly worth the time anymore and by saying 'HARDLY' I am at least offering you some credit that really isn't due.

by maxwell edison

Threats on both my character and my life. I suspect the former was intended, but the latter was sarcasm run amok. But I could be wrong.

by maxwell edison

I believe this is a first.

One moment I thought we were on the same side, the next I was threatened with being killed.

Strange indeed.

by oz_media

Sleeping Dawg,

Damn I even gave him my phone number and address and was just minutes from the airport (which was 4 hours from home) when he was supposed to land in his private plane.

Some people just live to disappoint, what a day of joy that would have been for me.

by maxwell edison

...... your suggestion of killing another person.

If ever there was a time when you should take a few steps back and admit that you misspoke, this is it. If you don't .......... your words (and/or lack thereof) speak volumes.

by maxwell edison

I was right in the middle of that one. But he never openly suggested killing - either you or me (well, at least not me).

by oz_media

I forget the actual issue of debate but I do remember that you and he saw eye to eye and agreed on it.

And yes he did actually say, more than once, that he would come here and put me out of my misery. In fact he even spoke of how, which is when my invitation was extended to him...but the old bastard never showed, even though he said he did until I proved he was a liar and he finally admitted to it.

by tonythetiger

but it isn't the government's responsibility either.

Now if the government was forcing you to smoke, hang glide, eat too many fatty foods, shoot your neighbor, or anything else that might cause you to need medical services, I could see it to some extent, but they aren't doing any of that.

We're supposed to be treated equally by the government. If you're taking something away from one citizen and giving it to another, they AREN'T being treated equally.

If you're going to demand the same rights, you'd best be prepared to accept the same responsibility.

by maxwell edison

.... just bring it on and STFU about it. Like I said, you know how to find me. Either you'll succeed or not. But either way, you're a loser.

P.S. Let me stand back and get out of the way of the hoards of people who will rush to defend what you've been saying - or not.

P.P.S. Are you drinking tonight? If so, scrap the cheap scotch. Buy the good stuff.

by maxwell edison

'dawg suggested killing you, and Santee suggested killing me.

But damn, you're one-up on me. Santee suggested killing you, too!

You have me 2-1.

P.S. Load clip ...... pillow ...... under .......

by tonythetiger

[i]reject individual freedom in favor of state-controlled society[/i]

Seem to be admitting that they cannot handle their own affairs, so what makes them think they are qualified to make decisions about the affairs of others?

by oz_media

I will agree if I am wrong, but that is not a display of masculinity whether right or wrong. Perhaps that is where you falter and take such defense to anhything I say, you feel it is an attack on your manhood. Isn't that an issue of insecurity on your part that gives you the feeling that being right makes you a man?

"The indisputable intent of the Constitution was to define those powers granted to the government by the people, not the other way around."

As you well know, it took a John Adams a LOT of convincing to make "the people" agree to the need for the US Constitution and independance to begin with. If that is what you deem the people deciding, then you are completely mad.

No matter what you were told or lead to believe due to your poor comprehension, that document was not a result of people wanting their goverenment to declare independance and instill certain rights on their behalf.

It was the creation of politicians;
[i]"The U.S. Constitution is the work of several men, directly and indirectly. The three most notable persons whose work influenced the Constitution but who were not involved in its writing are Thomas Jefferson, John Adams and Thomas Paine. The group of men involved in the writing of the Constitution are generally referred to as the "framers".

No single individual wrote it. [b]Twelve of the thirteen states sent delegates to the Constitutional Convention to revise the Articles of Confederation and the entire convention worked on it. After the political questions were hashed out a 'committee of style' was formed to put the ideas into formal words.[/b] It is generally accepted that Gouverneur Morris created most of the actual wording included in the final draft from the Committee of Style.[/i]

So no, I will not say I am wrong, just because you feel otherwise, and that neither makes me more or less of a man for saying so.

Let your government brainwash you all you like, it has nothing to do with me.

Those rights were afforded to the people, under the pretense that it was in their best interests and was what they wanted.

by maxwell edison

Sure I am. After all, you suggested killing me, not the other way around.

Therefore what?

Therefore, of course, I'm [i]losing it.[/i]

Oooooooooookay.

by oz_media

Max has been a fair debate for many years, he has offered logical and wellr easoned debate for most of the 10+ years (oh gawd!) I have been passing time here.

Your tense is incorrect;
He is not losing it, he has simply lost the plot.

It is unlike him, even when he gets all riled and freaked out, for him to lose focus. However, as i have commented many times, he has lost that ability to make sense and his reading comprehansion is laughable now. Too bad really, I think Max is a decent guy (honestly) but he seems to have stooped to what he once shunned as disingenuous.

Max, sorry for the third party reference to you, however I won't support someone saying you are falling when it is clear you have recently dropped to the bottom of the tank like a lead based, plastic plant.

I don't know enough about fish to come up with the right name, but it seems you have become one of those that lulls around on the bottom and sucks the algae off the rocks, while the others all swim around you ignoring what was once your relevance.

by tonythetiger

[i]The 9th Amendment is quite clear. You cannot deny me my God given right to LIFE. Which you are clearly doing be declaring health care is only for the privileged few. [/i]

is what you can make of it using your own devices. That's it.

by santeewelding

I can only suggest that it is [i]your[/i] brand of Scotch. Myself, I don't. It's cheap cream sherry. Takes longer to spin out of attitude control. You know: the horizon line.

We are -- so is Oz -- at one in the basics of humanity. Only, I do not take comfort with anyone behind or alongside me without exercise of trigger or muzzle control.

You, of late, and, before, exhibit a certain untrustworthiness.

by tonythetiger

[i]Where will the hospital make up the other 99%?[/i]

Max is the ONLY PERSON who donates?

Where's the link when you need it?

by oz_media

And that wasn't added for the sale of THE PEOPLE.

State representative met with politicians and THYE wrote a document, supposedly for YOUR benefit. YOu are then told for 200 years that it was written by the pople for the poeple and you believe it and feel no different.

Mind you ANY country, save true communists, can say the same about their bill of rights also. It was written by politicians for the benefit of government and conformity within reason, the 'withing reason' is where some accptable practices are allowed to offer citizens a feeling of being heard.

Face it, America's government is really no different than any other. YOU just BELIEVE it is unique.

You vote for your 'leaders' and entrust them with making decisions on your behalf By electing a government you remove yourself from such control of your freedoms and just hope that those you support make choices that you favour. As you have proven yourself many times, your vote this term means squa and you now feel that the government acts with its own best interests in mind. Had your vote won the election, you would feel that they were acting in your best interets and FOR you.

If all your citizens had the exact same beliefs, things would be different; as they are divided, you now have to take what they decide and live with it, just as they did when the Constitution was drafted.

If 'the people' actually wrote the Constutuion, there would be tomes of ammendments to it.

by tonythetiger

is stealing. Whether you sneak into my garden and pull up some vegetables, or get your jack-boot friends to steal from MY wallet and give it to YOU as food stamps, it's theft.

The government cannot rightfully treat one citizen differently than another.

by oz_media

I wonder how many times you have said that over the years?

Yet, if they spend money on something YOU support and others don't, that's just fine and grand.

Your country is divided in two, it is logistically IMPOSSIBLE to treat all citizens the same. One side will ALWAYS oppose how the other is receiving funding for what they don't support themselves.

If you ever get over your ME and MINE mentality, you might be able to grasp this most simple of concepts. I don't think that will ever happen though, so you will always be a victim in your own mind. Of course that doesn't make you correct though, no matter how many times you repeat it.

by jck

I'm sure very few (if any) Americans gave their express consent to give Ohio monies that you yourself receive benefit from.

So in a way, you too take things from others. You just give it a pass since someone stole it for you.

Again:

You drive on roads that aren't wholly paid for by you and yours.

You get energy that isn't wholly paid for by you and yours.

So...how are you any different?

And, I do have to correct you:

The government can, and does, treat one citizen differently than another.

However, the government [b][u]should not[/u][/b], but unfortunately does, treat one citizen differently than another.

Cases in point:

Karl Rove
Dick Cheney
Oliver North

For God's sake. If I would have accidentally shot my friend in the neck with a shotgun on a hunting trip, I'd have been in a jail cell and under investigation and not let out for days or weeks...if ever.

America is theoretically a democracy. Hence, we decide [b]together[/b] how things happen by vote. And in the end, that vote puts in people who decide for us [b]together[/b] how we will be run, spend monies, and contribute to the common good...no matter how much or little good it actually does.

by oz_media

[i]The fact that there are those who believe another's liberty is subject to the whim of the government (via the majority's will in this particular country) is distasteful enough! [/i]

You pay taxes. You have to pay taxes.

There are two things you can can't on, paying taxes and eventual death.

When those taxes go to building a new shelter for the homeless, supporting rehabilitation efforts, encarcerating a prisoner, saving a hooker's life, sending an ambulance to assist someone overdosing on the street etc. you are in turn, allowing the government to take away your money and use it for someone else's benefit. However, these are just things we accept as necessary in society.

You have voted for and defended presidents who have done the same. You proudly support men and women putting their lives on the line to protect such a system.

And yet you pick and choose when it comes to the welfare of other Americans?

You are either against paying taxes at all, or you agree that every country taxes its citizens and you accept that not all taxes are spent exactly how you desire them and get on with your life.

Personally, I'd rather see someone, who can't afford it, get health care than the government paying $1000 to have a politician's light switch replaced in his closet.

You need to find better reasons to complain other than just moaning any time they make a public issue for you to oppose. I never see you complaining about them wasting your money on issues where they DO actually 'waste' money, such as wasting your hard earned money on unneccesary electricity use in government offices, salaries, extended vacations etc. Ways they actually CAN save your tax dollars and still help others.

You just like to complain about whatever money they make public in an effort to pull a slight of hand trick and make you ignore issues where they actually do 'waste' your money.

In the case of medical you DO benfit, your monthly premiums will drop too.

Don't even bother debating some trivial issue here, I don't expect you to ever 'get it'.

by oz_media

By moving troops out of a war that clearly had a supportable objective, to one that MAYBE half of your own country's taxpayers and nobody else's supports, they are in turn treating half of the US citizens who suported it differently to the half that didn't.

The only difference I see is that you supported it and therefore is was right and just.

What about the millions of tax paying Americans who didn't, many of whom had their own sons and daughters sent there too support it against their wishes too?

Doesn't matter, right? As long as they aren't wasting money on what YOU don't support.

by tonythetiger

Collecting tax money from me to make war is "exactly the same treatment" as collecting tax from my neighbor to make war.

Collecting tax from me and [b]giving[/b] it to my neighbor is not "exactly the same treatment".

Those who were "sent" had the right to choose that occupation. And yes, sometimes "sons and daughters" do things their parents wish they wouldn't. I think that's been true for all of human history, and is not likely to change anytime soon :)

by oz_media

Not that he wants or needs it, you would at least know when Max had a gun and was possibly going to shoot it, accurately and intentionally or not. You wouldn't need a Little Orphan Annie decoder ring to figure it out.

by oz_media

What 'creator' endowed you with rights?
Did God offer you rights?
Can you prove that?

I thought the people of America wrote their own rights, they weren't endowed to you by anyone. Or doesn't your earlier debate support your argument here?

If I read your comment correctly, and I really feel I have not due to the absurdity of it, your are suggesting that the US Constitution is the best document ever conceived by mankind in the history of the world ?!? A bill of rights that most free democratic nations also have?

by jck

You get choice to shop around for the plan that suits you best.

I don't. I had it shoved down my throat, or told to do without that bit of compensation.

So why is it wrong for government to offer a "marketplace" where you can choose, but employers can get away with not allowing you a choice?

It's why I see so much wrong with it.

And yes, I chose to work here. Of course, it doesn't mean that I should have things pushed down my throat.

And probably within 4 months, I'll be leaving here as well.

by tonythetiger

Simply require employers to pay to the employee what they would have paid to the insurer. If you like the company's plan, choose it. If you like another plan, choose that. If you want to pay out-of pocket, chose that.

by the 'g-man.'

mind you, if there was a war on your doorstep (god forbid) surely the post war health care would be free, no?

by the 'g-man.'

those TAX free days are at an end by stars and striped friends.

Welcome to reality, 2010.

Just wait until fuel gets the TAX treatement.

It will happen, one day.