Discussion Locked

Out Sourcing and H1B visas

0 helpful
38 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

There are serious issues regarding the job market and it has nothing to do with the types of jobs immegrants are taking. It has to do with the loss of highly specialized and technical jobs. Jobs that once lost cause losses all the way down the chain. These are the types of jobs that had fueled the boom of the 90's. Let me see if I can clarify this.

Cheers, Shouts, Fireworks, and much drinking, resolutions, friends, family and much more drinking.

Ok so where are we? 2001, was the beginning of pretty rotten succession of months. 2002 and 2003 were pretty much down the tubes as well.

So what do we, in the heart and soul of the Telecom industry have to look forward to in 2004. If recent events in the news are any indication 2004 will be no different than the last four years.

The current administration gives all indications that IT and Telecom jobs will continue to flee the shores of the United States in ever increasing numbers. Almost all of the high tech companies are lobbying aggressively against attempts to limit moving jobs offshore. They give a number of reasons that they need to send work overseas. And none in my opinion has any merit besides fattening the corporate wallet.

Some insist that we are not educating our children well enough to fill the open vacancies. This is patently ridiculous if one looks to see the number of institutions giving technical education in America. Ever since the fabricated technology manpower shortage of the late 1990?s. Americans have been flocking to computer science and technology education programs through out the United States in increasing numbers. Students and established professionals spent years of hard work and considerable money getting the education, and experience to support the new wave of jobs that were becoming available. As a telecommunications professional, I made sure that I kept up with the latest technologies and focused on learning as much as I could in order to be able to do my job in the best possible fashion possible.

Another indication of this fact is that currently for every single new IT / Telecom job that opens up, recruiters are getting several hundred applications. Even while not every one of these applicants are best qualified. You cannot state that out of 500 applicants there is not one that can reasonably do the job.

I know some very highly skilled and educated people who have been without work since 2001, people that I would hire in a heartbeat if able. But we are being led to believe that these people choose to be unemployed because they feel that the available IT / Telecom jobs out there are beneath them or do not pay enough. Will someone please explain to me how these individuals are willing to loose their homes, their life savings, battle through medical emergencies without health insurance and loose any shred of self worth just because they would have to accept a pay cut?

During my two-year national job hunt, I have, lost my home, lost all of my family possessions; my wife was diagnosed with cancer and has no insurance. I have been aggressively applying for any and every job I felt that I could make a contribution to. Yet out of hundreds of applications submitted for positions that I was fully qualified for, 99.99 % have fallen into some black hole. I also had the time to do some research.

Go to Monster.com and do a global search for jobs under telecommunications and IT. Note that the number of listings for telecom and IT professionals leans heavily towards countries like India. Heavy, like a ratio of approximately 10 to one. There are hundreds of openings listed for telecom / IT professionals of every classification. Seems like the offshore market is having difficulty meeting the amount of jobs that US companies are shipping overseas. Think I am making this up? Well just go to the top job search sites and see for yourself. Like me you will be shocked.

Another interesting thing I learned is that while Americans are loosing their jobs in increasing numbers many tech companies are increasing their demand for H1B visa workers. They are claiming that because there is a shortage of educated and skilled tech workers here in the US they have to import from overseas. Not only are they shipping jobs out, they are bringing workers in. Why? Because they can be paid less! The law says they have to be paid the same prevailing wage but there are so many loop holes in the laws, that this is rarely enforceable. Plus if you consider that if you can save just $3,000 per year on each H1B and you have 5 or 6 hundred foreign contractor filling positions. Your savings can be quite substantial over the period of the contract.

Are these companies first offering these jobs to Americans? Well yes, they have to by law. But have you ever noticed the job ads that list a set of requirements that just about any experienced professional can meet. Then added to the requirements one obscure qualification or requirement that is a possible 1 in 1000 match? Some specialty in a obsolete, obscure, or supremely specialized technology? I see these types of job postings, regularly. This is tactic used, so if the company should come under scrutiny they can show the applications received or lack there of and prove that they could not find an individual with these highly in demand, important, skills. Think this is my imagination? As an experiment I have applied to such openings, I drafted a resume detailing word for word the requirements outlined, with a cover letter emphasizing the requirements. I have yet to get any response back to the applications. For research purposes I have applied to over 50 positions that in my 15 years of experience told me were requirements next to impossible to meet by a single individual. Mean while they open a H1B request to fill the same position but lo and behold the job requirements are just a tiny bit different. This is supported by the fact that while several major companies slashed their American work force by 40 to 60 percent. H1B contractors remained in position and even more hired.

On one hand the Technology sector is complaining that they do not have enough qualified people and on the other they claim that qualified people are not willing to take the jobs, or they can not afford qualified people so they have to go outside of the country, and they lobby for tax breaks to fund research and development! A tax burden that then has to be picked up by the very same people they laid off to pay to hire foreign contractors to do the research and development! CEO?s and top-level executives even have gone on record with the nerve to say that the American worker must compete internationally for their jobs from now on. I do not see any CEO, Director, or other top-level Executive positions being outsourced! So why does that attitude not surprise me. Should it be accepted the norm, for a person who invested years of time and substantial financial resources going to school, getting trained, gaining experience to work for wages at or below minimum wage, in a country with a cost of living like the United States in order to compete with the salaries paid to foreign tech workers in third world countries? Well this is exactly what was suggest by the CEO of HP corporation this week!

Is American technology setting it?s self up for a huge fall in the not so distant future? Where Americans no longer see technical work a viable means to earn a living. Where, the majority of the software, hardware, infrastructure, and operations that the United States relies upon is created and supported by foreign providers? Are we risking the possibility of being held hostage by foreign interests that control the technology that we use? These are not TV sets and Walkmans we are talking about any more. Talented individuals in increasing numbers are being forced out of the industry here in the United States. The prospects for new graduates are diminishing. But in the tunnel vision of boosting profits, companies, that created the technological revolution across the world, powered by American know how and determination, are now selling America?s lead in technological innovation to the lowest bidder.

Mean while hard working educated people are left floundering on the wayside. Were the people laid off from HP, Cisco, Motorola, IBM, Nortel, Lucent, AT&T and dozens of other companies offered the option of taking a pay cut in order to keep their jobs. Well on the whole they were not. I wasn?t. The only ones that had that luxury were the top executives in those corporations. And we were made to feel that they were force to make monumental sacrifices. Like not getting that 1.2 million bonus this year. Or instead of making $864,000.00 this year they had to squeak by on $734,000.00

If we as a nation do not take our politicians to task and implement real protections to American jobs in this country, we risk becoming pawn to those who we are teaching and tasking to do our work for us. Not because we do not have a local talent pool, but because unfortunately the US has become a place where Money Talks and the rest walk. At the lowest levels we are outsourcing the need for this nation excel in the sciences, to learn, to expand horizons by allowing these vital skills and knowledge to be outsourced.
In closing finally let us take a look at whom we are outsourcing our technologies to. India, Bangladesh, Pakistan, China, Korea, Malaysia. Am I crazy but are these not some politically hot and unstable areas of the world? India and Pakistan are a hairs breath away from a nuclear shooting war. China, Korea and Malaysia are certainly not Americas best friends. Some of these countries are even home to known terrorist groups, or have people in government sympathetic to radical causes.

As more and more of our technology gets developed in foreign countries, more and more of what keeps our national infrastructure intact, falls under the indirect control of individuals who?s motives and actions can not in any way shape or form controlled.

Here is a What if.

What if networking software code developed in (Pick a Country) had written into it a routine to completely crash the network and take down any network connected to it. Say this routine is buried in amongst million lines of code. Since the software was developed and written by a Indian software outsource firm, paying it?s engineers the equivalent of $15,000 per year and they are the only ones who can economically test and debug the software. What if the engineer who wrote the harmful code wanted to make more than $15,000 so was open to suggestion from a distant relation who just so happens to be tied up with some radical faction. What if that software was now running major networks in America?s banking system, Telephone system, Heath care system. Think about it, and like I did get mad, and go out and do something about it.

Think that this can not happen? Ask any software pro, Testing and debugging millions of lines of code is a time consuming and expensive process. Heck this is one of the reasons the US companies are outsourcing the work. If you had to then hire American engineers and developers to test, debug, and modify the software you might as well not outsource it at all. So it would be child?s play to embed malicious code into a application and get it through undetected. Programmers have ever since software was born left back doors in applications. Up until now these were for relatively harmless reasons, with the exception of a disgruntled employee or two. Plus as they lived and worked in the US for US companies with American colleagues such things were not as hard to catch and track.

Now just imagine a environment where none of the developers are American, some may or may not have issues with US policy. Screening applicants is far less stringent, records far harder to access. You have to remember these are third world countries. Is my ?what if? that much, a stretch of imagination?

Stop, Think, Act.

A few notes about the author.

Peter Nevai

Over 15 years experience in the deployment, and support of complex telecommunications / IT systems and networks. Having contributed to the efforts of several leading and prominent Telecommunications equipment manufacturers. Responsible in efforts that led to successful networked systems deployments in 8 countries and in the United States. Approximately 20% of the world population uses or has used at one time or another telecommunications services provided by the systems the author was instrumental in deploying.

38 replies

by oldefar

Except for the "What It" scenario. Yes, it can happen. However I don't think the risk significantly changes when the work moves to other countries.

The workers there are dependent upon work from the developed countries (this is an issue in Europe and Australia, and will become more of an issue in Canada in the near future). Most have a work ethic and personal ethics as high as any in the developed countries.

We are seeing a global change in social and cultural interdependencies unlike anything ever seen before. Looking beyond our local, regional, and national affiliations will be a key challenge for all of us. Let's hope we find we have more in common than we ever suspected.

by oz_media

"The workers there are dependent upon work from the developed countries (this is an issue in Europe and Australia, and will become more of an issue in Canada in the near future). Most have a work ethic and personal ethics as high as any in the developed countries."

The way I read this is that Europe, Australia and Canada are not developed countries? I don't think that's what you were implying but need to clarify anyway.
or do you mean "the workers there" (meaning USA) {which would change the context of your response}

OM

by oldefar

Sorry Oz. You can read an insult into my previous post if you like. It wasn't there at my end. To repeat - the developed nations are losing work to developing nations.

Canada has been a recipient of outsourcing from the US, a labor cost and location advantage coupled with a general feeling of good will towards our northern neighbor. Global communications ruins the location advantage, and the cost advantage is not as good as other places.

by oz_media

I know that Telecomm outsourcing by Notrel has been very big since the late 80's as has NEC's and Panasonic's. I also worked in the industry for BC's largest interconnect and Canada's largest VoIP and Key System dealer. I know that telecom outsourcing for building of circuit boards and components has been done for a lot more than a few years, I was dealing with Nortel's developers in India and the Phillipines in the mid-late 1980's.

This is a fact, it has been for a long time and it is not the same as IT outsourcing in the sense that it has almost always been done overseas, India or Phillipines.

Some of the best techs are from the Phillipines and the most popular university courses there are in telecom wiring and circuit switching.

Thuis hasn't effected sales or quality, it HAS reduced cost though. How is that bad? Because SoME people lost jobs? You will always be undercut for work, that's why we need to be more diverse in our fields of knowledge. If IT dies, I fix cars, if Cars become obsolete, I am a machinist, if machines become obsolete, I m an artist development manager, if music becomes obsolete... That way I never have to complain about the state of industry and simply find something more lucrative to do. Am I being arrogant? No. Am I more capable than others? I don't think so. Do I have more time? No. I just learned at a young age in another country, learning a single skill and expecting a career is alost cause and a dead end. One must be flexible in experience, ability and knowledge of industry to stay employed. In Canada and the USA, life has been much simpler as it is a gravy train for those who come here, jobs are aplenty and fame and fortune is available to all, not just the elite. As time has passed, youo must have skills, people get MCSE certs, PHP certs etc. But what if IT dies? It's harder to find IT work than it was ten years ago, is this only due to IT outsourcing? NO. It is because everyone thought IT was the gravy train, they all got certified and now wonder WHY there's no work and everyone is kloooking for iT jobs. In the same sense, Japan has a massive lack of skilled labourers, as they were heavily into IT as the future. Now it is hard to find a crew to build a new office building, everyone's an IT expert.

Certs are great but don't look at them as a future, just another thing you can do.
YOUR INCOME TAXES BEING FINISHED OVERSEAS.
What I did see the other night, was a fact that few people know. If you go to you Income Tax preparation company, even the larger one's (H&R BLock etc), they will SEND you taxes to India to be filled out in India in a secure and paperless office then returned to the preparation company for submittal.

How many people know that thier private information is sent across the net to India, someone you have never seen prepares your return and sends it back to you reputable tax service?

They used to send it to local houses where teams filled in the forms and sent them back, when you consider salaries, 400-500 month in India, 4000-5000 month for the same accountants in the USA or Canada, it's no wonder they are being outsourced.

this continent is too new and too used to being wealthy. Other European countries are a little more 'grounded' as they've been rich and prosperous, been downtrodden and now simply get by. One thing I notice in Europe that dies in North America. Many here live check to check, cost of living is high and money is less each year as more skilled people vie for our jobs at less pay. My middle class friends don't do too much. The odd night at the bar, dinner out when possible, movies less and less each year etc.

My upper class friends are the same, they have more money and do more but still not as much as 10 years ago.

In England, almost everyone is broke, yo live check to check, but the people ENJOY thier money. A two hour lunch at the pub is common at many companies, every night at the pub. Every other week at a concert or club.

They don't have more money, in fact most have less. The cost of living isn't REALLY cheaper. They are just used to not having a Playstation, or a new car lease or DKNY clothes or Prada shoes or... And simply enjoy the money they do have.

I find in North America it is MUCH more material, you are what you have. People will not go out, will skrimp and save to make sure they have a new Lexus, Prada shoes, Gucci handbag or whatever. It is WHO you are not what you have.

I'd give Noth American's another hundred years (less if you keep pissing away your money on the military)before low income and no Lexus becomes reality. the nice part of it is, people are more humble and accepting of one another.

I can't remember the last time I was giggle at for not wearing the right shoes in Germany, or hearing snickers as I wore a basic t-shirt without NIKE on it while in London.

Money and economy in North America needs to uindergo some serious pains before it becomes stable. The recession was nothing.

by worker bee

If the United States were headed in the direction to becoming more like Europe where people have lower living standard of living but a better quality of life then many of us would welcome it. But that is not where we are headed.

The reality is that unlike Europe, the U.S. economy tends toward the most brutal and darwinistic aspects of capitalism. If I can discover a way to make myself rich by making thousands of my fellow citizens poor and miserable then I will be praised as great captain of industry and treated no differently than someone who acquired their wealth by actually creating something of value. This means that as far as Corporate America is concerned it is perfectly acceptable to make themselves rich by transforming the United States into another Argentina or Haiti.

As we see others tossed one by one out of the liveboat into shark infested waters, many of us comfort ourselves by saying "He deserved it. He did not keep his skills up. He was weak and worthless. He was inflexible." But the lifeboat is getting emptier every day, and one day it will be your turn. The water is cold, the sharks merciless, and spending your golden years trying to decide which brand of dog food goes best with toast is not what any of us bargained for.

by oz_media

If I myself make such statements, I am quickly jumped on for being anti-American or simply WAY wrong. This is another reason why American companies qren't welcomed in Canada, they have no business ethics that coincide with our own.

Canadian's have no problem going an extra block or paying an extra dollar to spsend in a store with high customer service and employment ethics.

WalMart is just such a store that is abhorred here, they explot third world country workers, pay lower wages than others in thier field, although meeting our minimum wage requirements and offer no support in the sense of knowledgable staff, just workers who will work in several different departments as needed with little or no knowledge of the products they are supposed to HELP with.

I am glad to live in such a Liberal country without the same capitalistic corporate views as the USA, although I will admit not ALL companies toe the line and not ALL Canadian companies are better than in the USA. It is just a gereralization, but a somewhat realistiv one at that.

by oldefar

I suspect most people assume that the major corporations are the majority employers in the US. While they get most of the publicity, it has never been a fact. Most Americans work for firms with less than 1,000 employees.

Another assumption is that all the large corporations are US firms. Again, this is not always the case. It is worth looking into who the "parent" firm of a conglomerate is, or who the majority stock holders are. There are some surprizes waiting there as well.

As for the consumption based economy that is viewed as America, I suggest a couple of thoughts to consider. First, it began post WWII with the generation that grew up in the Depression. They suffered in their youth, and postponed their adult lives for the war. When they came back, it was to the only remaining economic power and was fueled by both pent up spending urges from both the Depression and the war years, and by the rebuilding of Europe under the Marshall Plan. Prosperity did not reach all segments, but more people entered the middle class than ever before.

Their kids, my generation, was the first to grow up without any significant want, and with a primarily urban or suburban population. Our parents and grandparents made quite a thing out of how we were better off than they had been, and the message was that we had to do the same for our kids - today's 20 and 30 year olds. Most of us missed out seeing our parents struggle during their early years of marraige, and even during our own early years. Our expectations were the highest of any generation.

This same period saw a social change in roles. Women began working outside of the home during the war, and our sisters grew up with an expectation that they should have both a family and a career. That two parent income helped to drive the consumption economy, a fact the ad firms did not miss.

Another result of this time was a dramatic increase in "retirement" benefits, both from work and from the government. A common mistake among older retirees is that their SS check comes from money they put in while working. It isn't. It comes from the FICA tax of today's workers and an equal amount from employers. A great idea when our population was growing, but a long term burden for a flat or shrinking work force. As a side note, each off shored job reduces the amount of money that goes into SS.

I suspect that the number of Americans whose lifestyle matches the stereotypical "American" lifestyle is far less than expected as well. I was going over the lifestyles of all the families whose children I have coached, and I was surprized myself. About 10% worked for major corporations, while the rest worked in small companies or were self employed. While a few were upper middle class, the majority were middle class and below. I know of as many who were struggling as who were rich. Most drove cars that were 5 to 9 years old. Most of the kids were going to have to help pay their way through college. Most vacations were visits to relatives in other parts of the country or were camping trips. About half the parents had or were planning one big trip by theirselves - a cruise or island vacation. Most had two working parents but this was making ends meet.

by oz_media

Not to downplay your experience or ability.

Did you aplpy at dinkin donuts? Mac Donalds? Or even as a retail sales rep?

Is no, was it due to the salary level being too low? The job being well beneath your qualifications? or....?

if you have applied and still couldn't find work, can I ask why?

by oz_media

I assume you don't consider Monster.comor related online agencies or even local recruiters as job searching.

Although they do offer SOME jobs, most people don't advertise the best jobs, unless for legal aspects.

Job hunting is cold calling, prospecting, and researching where you wnat to work, not looking for someone who is looking for you. If you lose you kid at the mall, do you wander around and hope he will also wander around where sometime your paths will cross?

No, you either prearrange a meeting place or more effectively, have mall administration announce were you are and where you will be waiting. Seeking someone who is seeking you doesn't work. Catch the guy who feels all is well and convince him why he needs you.

I know this is all easier said than done, but it IS done and ir DOES work, you don't run into these people often, because they are rarely out of work long enough to explain how they find work. If they are out of work, they are too busy looking for work to discuss employment shortcomings.

I don't believe ANYONE has a good reson to be unemployed unless physically or mentally unable to. I was never allowed to be idle, I had to find work. If I told my parents that I couldn't find work, they'd slap me silly for being so closed minded. There's work, you just have to be prepared to take it, even if temporarily while you find something else.

In fact the more I think about it, the more I see ways to seek employment. As my mum always said, if you're out of work, it's because you don't want to WORK.

Finding work is work, finding your particular chosen career is a LOT of work especially oin today;s market (can always be done though). To say you can't find ANY work and are losing your house, wife etc. just shows me, well I won't say it, you've already lost enough to realize that anything is better than nothing.

People often wonder why a guy with to or three PHD's would wait on tables at a restaurant, the answer: because he is employed.

Good luck,
OM

by jkaras

but I admit I wouldnt work for those companies since they wouldnt support much vs getting a bigger paycheck from unemployment. No matter who you are there is always someone willing to pay you to do something so not having a job is a bit whiney. I have worked 2 to 3 jobs simultaneously up to 60+ hours a week to survive and I dont have a family to support. Sometimes you have to do what you have to survive and pride has to take a back seat. It doesnt absolve corporate America or our politicians for not getting involved and doing their part to ensure companies offering jobs, even for a tax break. I wouldnt balk if they got a better break to stimulate American jobs that would pump money back into our economy.

I do feel his pain but the "what if" made me feel that it was a bit racist or bigoted or actually paranoid hysteria that the government has been selling that we need them and to trust them for our safety. Basically dont complain we know what we are doing. We give these politicans power and we can take it away by refusing to vote and demanding better solutions or else. Too long we have trusted them and they need to realize that the gravy train is over, its time to work or get out. I'm not suggesting violence by any stretch of the imagination but instilling a fear that they need us and not to forget that trust we give them.

by pnevai

Ok here it is a year later, In that time I have worked as a Car Mechanic, Part time contractor, and comupter tech for a itty bitty little shop.

In the past year I have earned right about $11,000 that is way below the poverty line!!!!

The wife and I have no medical insurance so guess what? Your taxes are paying for my wifes cancer treatments. Your taxes are paying for my food stamps. And the list goes on and on.

When a 4 year college degree earns you the right to live in poverty where is this nation going?

Employers for small businesses like you all claim are dieing for employees, only can afford people who know what they are doing in a given field. Any employer wants to hire the top people.

Move to a different field? OK how does one who never managed the books of anything besides thier own checking account going to expect to get hiresd as say a book keeper, office manager etc.

I am insenced by people who even suggest McDonalds and things like that. Are you people particularly dense? I have a wife with cancer! I am not alone! I need to be able to make enough money to be able to.

1. keep the car working and insured so I can even get to work
2. pay rent
3. pay electric
4. pay water
5. buy food
6. buy gasoline (Now $2.28 a gallon here)

Right now I am working 60 hrs a week 5 days a week and bring home $500
No insurance
No Phone
And my wife and I room mate with a pair of 20 year old kids in a 2 bedroom 1,200 sq ft apartment just so we can make the rent.
My wife and I are in our late 40's

I do not have the time at the end of the week (Sunday) to go back to school and by that time I'm lucky I have the energy to get through the sunday paper.

And now that I've been out of the mainstream tech sector for 4 years You can ask any recruiter, head hunter, employment agency. Than for all practical purposes I am unemployable in the tech sector.

So 22 years of education and work experience has been flushed right down the toilet.

I entered the tech sector employment force back in 1985. Long before the IT hysteria. While workin I've allways kept the skill up to date and even prepared for emerging technologies. I never asked for rediculous salaries even in the period when people of far less qualifications were routinely paid rediculous 6 figure salaries.

And to those who poo poo the risks of placing the responsibility of tech development in the hands of countries like India, China, Korea, etc.

You have your head in the sand.

China has nukes and where do you think they are pointed? China is getting more and more agressive to a Taiwan take over. When it happens what is that going to do as far as the USA is concerned? Will we just roll over and let China invade and occupy another soverign nation?

You know we probably will. Because any action by the USA will mean the severing of economic, technical and commercial ties with China and what would happen in the US if Wallmart and other hughe chains were not able to get any goods? What would happen if all american tech interests were expelled from the country? What would happen when the US debt al good portion of which is held by China would be called for payment?

Well the US economy would probably crumble within 6 to 8 months. And that is if there is no shooting war.

The united states just sold a bunch of F16's to Packistan. Needless to say the Indian govt is really pissed off. The tensioon between India and Packistan has been high for a century. India may be politically stable but thier neighbors are not. What happens when hositilies break out and all tech development in the region comes to a halt?

The US is already being held hostage on imported oil. Now we risk being held hostage by imported technology, and intellectual property.

How many American kids will have to die protecting our foreign held interests in future battles? When we have to protect Indian Software development houses. Malaysian, Korean semiconductor manufacturing plants and the list goes on.

The list dependent items that US is outsourcing keeps growing every year. Argentina has a issue with the US foriegn policy and gasoline jumps 50 cents per gallon at the pump.

It is only a sign of things to come.

Wake Up America.

by john_wills

I long ago applied for a job as Goofy or a hotel clerk at Euro-Disney. I was told I was qualified (the interview was in both French and English). Considering my work history, however, I would not be given such a job, though my CV would be given to IT. A while later I got a rejection letter from IT. Disney was not the only one to reject me as over-qualified: that period of unemployment lasted 5 years. Later, back in the U.S., I had an 18-month period without professinal employment. The Census Bureau took me for stints as a payroll clerk and as an enumerator. A soup kitchen with extra facilities took me on as an occasional receptionist. Wells Fargo, on recommendation by an agency, took me for two months as a telephone answerer, and customers complimented me on my care and competence; but when my manager saw my CV the 2 months became 4 days: over-qualified again. But this is somewhat off-topic: offshoring and immigration were not alleged to be the problems; I don't think they are the real problems in the U.S. now.

by generalist

In some instances I suspect that being 'overqualified' is an excuse not to hire someone who you fear will jump ship when a better job opportunity comes around. The hiring process costs resources and having to go through the hiring process after losing an employee to better opportunities can get expensive over time.

by oz_media

I understand your point. THat's why I actually have three resumes.

One outlining marketing and sales experience, one is strictly automotive, machining welding etc. the other IT.

If someone interviews me and asks me to fill in the holes, I can or else I will explain that my interests varied at the time and work exeperience is unrelated.

Funny avout Goofy though, when my brother bought Ikea in Richmonnd BC some years ago, I was hired to be the Ikea Moose for soe local activities, park openings, the trathlon etc.

Hot but worth the fun when seeing the happy kids. Hey $17.00 hr in '91 wasn't too bad either ! I was just drinking beer for a living while attending trade school anyhow.

Bt Goofy would have been a blast, I know when I wwas younger I had hopes of one day playing a Disney role, but there's no CanaDisney eh?

Goofy would be a polar bear, Mickey and Minnie beavers, Donald Duck a moose, etc.

by oz_media

"Won't Play
Sorry Oz. You can read an insult into my previous post if you like. It wasn't there at my end. To repeat - the developed nations are losing work to developing nations."
It was either the grammar used or just the way I read it. I saw it to mean, Europe Canada and Ausdtralia are undeveloped nations. As I said, I'msure this isn't waqt you meant but need to be clear, just as all of my posts are scrutinized based on grammar. I have no problem explaining my ideas and statements if misunderstood though.

No need to apologize, no I wasn;t insulted, I was just unclear of the meaning of the sentence.

You're right though, Canada is already outsourcing some jobs to India, the difference is, Canadian companies feel that suporting and hiring Canadians is more important than a slight increase in profit. We have less capitalistic corporations here, although they do exist, usually not for too long though. Wetsren Canada's largest (by a long shot) food store almost went out of business one year when the owner was said to have practiced poor ettiquette when he was young and selling cars. THis was turned around by providing a much higher level of service, better quality products and lower prices. Without catering to people, you business WILL not and CAN not succeed here.

For the most part, the ompanies that have capitalistic business practices here succeed when selling to a US market, not the Candian market. They often relocate or sell to US based corporations, where such practice is accepted or at least put up with because there's no paradigm to be compared to.

by oldefar

All posts in a forum are subject to being read only within the context of that post. To be sure the intended meaning is conveyed, the post should stand complete as written.

My post was written in the context of a response to a post, and without that context the meaning was ambiguous.

Readers will also apply prior experience with a poster to their interpetation. Again, I am guilty of reading past experiences into a post.

by mrbill-

I'm tired of you Canadians thinking your country is better than all the others. That Arrogant attitude is why nobody likes you. "Our companies are better, our society is better, our politicians are better, our country is better..." Quit waving the maple leaf nobody is buying it. Nobody is standing in line waiting to get into Canada, except maybe as a stopover for terrorist trying to get into other countries. I'm also tired of your portrayal of how we would be lost if not for the Canadian Recon forces, you did not save the world, get over it.

How does it feel to be on the receiving end of you style of attack. Sorry if I offended any Canadian friends.

Great, now I?ll be accused of being anti-Canadian.

by oz_media

Actually mrbill, I find it quite amusing and flattering that you would think of us.

I would agree with your wholy if Canada was tryig to get the rest of the world to follow her, I wouldn't impose out way of life on anyone, it would be too crowded here.

I have NEVER said you are lucky to have Canada supporting you, I have never said that Canada was better than the USA.

I have said on many occasions, I love Canada but it has it's faults as does ANY country on the globe. Fot this exact reason, I would never expect someone to believe me in saying tha Canada was better.

The difference, we donn't THINK we're better than the rest. YOU do. We don't fly to foreign countrys and show them how to build a government that coincides with our own. We don't expect ANYONE to follow our lead, and more than anything, VERY few people have much faith in the PM. We just let him have his meetings with whoever and say or do as he pleases. When there's no fish in the lake or I'm not allowed to take my dirct bike into the mountains, I'll have my say.

It would be really amusing to see Canadians wave the flag in other countries, it's is hard to imagine how many friends and ladies you'd pick up, we are loved in Europe, not hated because we are neutral and passive as a society, leave us alone and we'll leave you alone type of mentality.

When we are dragged into politics by the US or chastized for NOT joining in, we get pissed of at America. If you want to make enemies, be disloyal to your allies and poke your nose into things, leave us out of it and don't bitch that we didn't see your point.

But it would be funny if we were like that, what a clash of the borders that would be.

by oz_media

I missed your inacurate statement that nobody is waiting in line to enter Canada.

Well we turned away many Americans who were claiming refugee status due to the marijuana laws.

People aren't lining up here, we just let them in in droves. They aren't asked to wait in line, we just say welcome to 'Lichmond (I mean Richmond).

Richmond on a map looks like the mouth of the dragon (to the Asians anyway). They come here and are welcomed by the tens of thousands each year. They have no interest in wildlife or the wilderness though, so I say the mroe the merrier.

Canada hit the top ten list as third this year, I believe behind Sweden and England as the worlds best places to live. Just don't tell anyone, it's nice and peaceful here.

If we had acted superior to the USA, I'd accept your opinion. As it is completely unqualified, and inaccurate, I will dismiss it as just another pissed off American who doesn't like the fact that I don't see America as the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. I would rather move to Australia, England, Sweden, Germany, Austria or even France (which is beautiful, too bad you closed the doors on that one) befoe the USA.

Question: WHY would I benefit from living in the USA as opposed to ANY of these other countries?

by oz_media

"Another assumption is that all the large corporations are US firms. Again, this is not always the case. It is worth looking into who the "parent" firm of a conglomerate is, or who the majority stock holders are. There are some surprizes waiting there as well."

Not at all, I know the corporate ownership of any company I choose. I can also get you most of the important contact information, stock holders information, public and private portfolio's etc.

This is a line of work to me. I also work as an associate copywriter and marketer for a major advertising and portfolio design firm. We handle some of the largest deals, mergers and developments in North America, including US mining, oil, and electronics companies.

I was speaking in this case on a retail and customer service level. Not the ownership of the corporations. People base their shopping judgements on actions at a retail level, not the corporate level.

by tr_member

Well sorry to hear your plight. But the corporations, especially American ones have been interfering in other geographical areas too.

After almost destroying small farms in US, they are invading and destroying indigenous farmers. Heard about Cargill and issues with them regarding seeds - Seed Terminator Technology. You can google Cargill and India, you will get tonnes of results that talk about those issues.
It might be a non-issue in the developed countries. But paying huge amount of money to buy seeds is a big deal in the poor countries.

American corporations have been causing havoc just not in US, but through out the world. You must have read an article from the English newspaper - Gaurdian, about how the British banned the import of cotton from Ireland and India in the 16/17th century. It caused havoc to the Irish and Indian farmers. Looks like it is the ups and downs of the life. Now Irish and Indian software people are causing havoc.

by john_wills

will affect only farmers who buy such seed: those who stick with the fruit of their previous crop may get lower yields for one season, but they will get new seed indefinitely. Don't blame Cargill, which cannot force farmers to buy.

by tr_member

...the way these giant corporations crush the local competetion. With deep pockets and government backing they gobble up the local markets.

The poor farmers do not have that much of options then. It is easy for us to sit in the comfortable swivel chair and say don't buy the seeds if you don't want to. It is not like having a choice of drinking Pepsi or Coca-Cola products.

Well the developing countries that participate and adhere to WTO, need to allow these technology or else....

I do understand there are IP issues and these corporations spend huge money in developing good quality seeds and products. But it looks like gone are the days when people discovered, invented and improved materials with a passion to solve man-kind's problems. There is nothing wrong in having commercial gains for one's hard work. But, when that crosses into the zone of pure greed that causes destruction it becomes worrisome.
I am sure corporations like Cargill definitely would have got their share of ROI.

by jerrylee

Just an FYI, seed terminator technology was intended to be marketed to developed countries because the they could pay for it. The populations of those developed countries demanded higher quality food while using less acreage and the seed terminator concept was developed to allow the companies who developed these crops to insure a return on the bio-tech investment. How ever poorly thought out the idea was, at the end of the day it was never implemented anywhere mainly due to the same ill informed outcries that populate any GM/GE discussion. As is wont with the anti-GM/GE crowd when facts cannot be used to make your case, use FUD and scream bloody murder in the process. It is a pattern that has worked extremely well in Europe where they would rather people starve in less developed countries instead of having to face facts (1).

1) People starving in Africa due to fear that they would not be able to export crops grown there (to Europe, their major trading partner) if they used GM seeds. Foodstuffs literally rotting on the docks thanks to all the anti-GM folks in Europe.
While I wish America would emulate some things from the EU (emphasis on education, de-emphasis on religion), this is not one of them.

by pramodpatil

I read the article and all the comments about offshore and outsourcing. Let?s do a little recap of economic changes in last 20 years.

We will just go back a little bit and look when most of the manufacturing industry was moved from US to China. How many people raised the voice? I assure you all, people must have had raised the voice. And bigger corporation must have had defended the decision the same way as they are doing now. But after some "time" people got used to the cheaper goods and today almost everybody in US uses goods manufactured in China. Most of those people who lost their job in manufacturing industry entered into the IT.

There were protests about the move but still these people could managed to get new jobs and they were infact happy about the change as IT jobs were/are considered socially as high status as well as higher payment in 90's IT .Then came the Dotcom boom. This turned economy upside down. Stock Market was way high up. Housing market was absolutely crazy. Mortgage rates were high. People had good money and cheaper goods to buy. By looking at the market, though the manufacturing and import remained cheap because of outsourcing, all the retail corporations took the advantage and increased the values of the good to increase their profit margins. Nobody had any objection to this so far as everybody was getting enough paid. BUT point to be noted here is Outsourcing was still happening in IT during all these period to reduce work load on local workforce.

After dotcom crash, stock market went down. Lot of corporations/businesses had to either shut down the unit(s) or pull the plug because of higher cost of operation. Layoffs started happening. Every month unemployment rate started growing high. But even in these situations retailers did not lowered their profit margins which made difficult for the (IT) unemployed people to manage finance as they were used to living the lavish life style which they can not afford now.

Most of the corporations survived who had some kind of shared workload between outsourcing and local offices because they could maintain the cost of operation under control. Struggling Industry looked at the above strategy and started thinking of moving their part of Outsourcing to remain in the business by having shared workload and the advantage of time difference of closed to 12 hrs so that they can have almost 24 hours of work cycle. Particularly India and surrounding countries are almost +9 to 12 hrs ahead. This off course helped them to remain in the business and they could cut short the delivery time plus cost. This increased the stock market.

Good part of all this is "Design" aspect of all the system still remains in US. Just the development/call center(s) moved to the offshore. So if the person is creative, extremely good in his skill set and up to the mark with current technology obviously going to remain in the market. I do not agree with the author that H1B?s are getting recruited by bypassing Americans as all of the requirements posted do mention that they ?DO NOT SPOSNER VISA? or ?Sponsorship is NOT available?. This clearly rules out the possibility of hiring only H1Bs.

I also do not agree with author?s comment over the the security of the application. If that was the case then imported goods which we use at home might have some bugs planted or cameras mounted on it..most of them are imported. I am not saying buggy software is not possibility at all but if its going to happen , It can happen anywhere including US.

Now that we are seeing some movement in the share market, slowly the market as well as job scenario in US will improve. After manufacturing industry fall, people did had something to play with, a new technology called IT. I think, now as things are started improving again we?ll have some ?New Technology? coming soon and people will changed to it happily. Most of the times US had/have been a "Source of inventions". So just wait for a while and it will be coming soon.

?Change is unavoidable. As people dealt with manufacturing move , they will get over with outsourcing too. TIME is the answer?

Just MY analysis.

by oz_media

I agree with almost all of your conclusions except your reference to the US as a designer or Source of Inventions. The US is known for having the capital to but patents and develop products from them, thus claiming the patent and the US INvention status. However they are usually based on someone else's ideas from Germany, England,. Canada, or wherever and usually not properly developed due to lack of corporate or private funding. Example-the light bulb, Thomas Edison's (invention). That was originally German, refined in Canada, bought by Edison and refined further with his vast wealth and claimed as an American invention.

Look what happened when the US tried to copy the Japanese compact car as all they could build were muscle cars and full size boats. They came up with the PINTO and then later, Iacoca's great creation, the K-Car (also the Horizon, LeBaron, Omni etc that all had the same garbage parts in them no matter how upscale or costly it was).
But the USA has never built a compact car like the Japanese or Germans for that matter.

Half the space shuttle has been designed by many other countries around the world, but it is clainmed as an American creation even though it also has a Canadian flag on it from Canada's invention of the Canadarm, that has made it opssible for them to explore and dock in the cargo bay.

America has MANY inventions, but to say that you are a "Source of Inventions" is a lttle far fetched.
You're right something new WILL come along, and I have no doubt that US dollars will see it capitalized upon. This won't then make it an American invention though, unless truly invented in the USA. Mind you, the Japanese will just take it and make it smaller, cheaper and lighter, thus stealing all the revenue for manufacturing that one too.

What you need to do is come up with a cost effective invention that offers true value for money. Something corporations will not see a benefit in unless it makes them serious money. the workers just get used and abused, then the corps cash in on the outsourcing for better labour rates and to produce lower cost products to achieve a higher margin.

This all stops when capitalism is gone from corporations.

by tr_member

Man, you implicitly slighted Capitalism. You are done for in this forum :-)))))))))

Capitalism with Compassion: How does this sound?

Hey, looks like some Enron executives are facing the music....good going. What did it take..couple of years?

by pnevai

Thank you for your weel thought out and written reply.

But there are errors in your statement as should be if you rely on anecdotal evidence. I was in the middle of the game in IT.

An Insider if you will. First I never sought to get the insane salaries that were being offered. I remember being told during the hireing frenzy of the 90's that I was selling my self way to cheaply. Perhaps I did but personally I felt that I was being paid fairly for the work I was doing even though I was offered triple if I chose to switch jobs. I never earned more than $78,000 per year. I was offered at one point $138.00 per hour.

Being in a responsible position within a major corporation I was privy to memoranda and meetings and data that supports my allegation that the company wanted to shed it's self of it's American work force. Imported worker H1B and other visa holders were available at 30% less in salary, did not qualify for the companies retirement and 401K plans, and did not qualify for company health benefits. You had to be a Full time Permanent Employee to qualify for those benefits.

Loop holes in the laws were exploited to preserve the ability to import more foreign workers while laying off american engineers.

I watched the people in entire departments within the company laid off and one week later those same positions filled by Visa'd workers.
20, 30 people at a time in the span of 2 weeks.

The ones who stayed managed to keep thier jobs because of personal relationships with upper management or political reasons. In all fact people managed to keep thier jobs because they played Golf on the weekends with a VP. Or attended the weekly poker game. This is first hand knowledge not based on heresay or circumstantial evidence.

I would believe that similar events occur in corporations across the board.

This company had a American work force of 130,000 and cut it to 45,000 Americans out of the current 100,000 of those working in the United States. Thats just one corp.

Also as far as the security of the foreign SW products developed overseas. It has already been published that many times it is of inferior quality. Plus given the fact that 10's of thopusands of foreign programmers working on Billions of line of code the odds that 1 or more can place malicious code within the SW are too high to ignore.

Already there are reports of the theft of private information, Identity theft of Americans due to the outsourcing of this information. And those are the events that manage to leak out before they are quickly covered over. Can't risk a multi million dollar deal over security flaws.

We can't manage to keep terrorism under control in the United States a country that has become obsessed with preventing and catching such criminals.

So how can one ever expect that something as easily hidden, and accomplished be prevented in countries that have not 1 100th the security and are 1000 times more susceptible to corruption and bribery. Where the main concern is $$$$$$.

Also it can not be ignored that the countries that we are depending on to delvelop the SW and Semiconductors are in politically unstable regions. Each one has hostilities or tensions with their neighbors. When hostilities break out how many US soldiers (Kids) will have to die protecting these foreign interests? What happens to the US infrastructure and economy if this supply chain is cut off.

Too many have died protecting our access to oil already. What will be the new battle?

by tr_member

...US might strike peace deals with the Evils of the world before they accept Canadians :-))))))

by oz_media

the USA striking a PEACE deal with Canada would ruin our reputation throughout the world. People would then start lumping Canadians in with Americans and we'd be hassled everywhere too.

I'd rather our neighbours remained just that, neighbours. Crap in your own backyard and all that.

by john_wills

The availability of improved but terminating seed does not prevent farmers continuing to use some of each season's harvest as seed for the next season. Farmers are not stupid: they know about the non-terminatin properties of the specailly bred seed. As for monopolies generally, they will be reduced, not increased, by the presence of new suppliers: U.S. sugar suppliers have banded together into a government-supported monopoly, but CAFTA will bring U.S. consumers sugar from new suppliers. The same principle holds for farmers' supplies in third-world countries.

by mrbill-

The third world must be populated with Nobel Prize winning Farmers. Unless the farmer can remove the Inducer from the seeds or has gene-splicing equipment he is stuck with a crop he can not save seeds for the next year. His yield will be much greater but he will still have to replace the seed. Before if the environment turned on him and he lost most of his crop he would still have something for next year. With terminating seed he will still have to buy more but not have any funds to do so.

by tr_member

"The same principle holds for farmers' supplies in third-world countries."

....US has problems/differences-of-opinion with developing coutries.

You must have heard the...one man's food is another man's poision and all that :-)))

What is good in US need not be good in other parts of the world.

I agree the farmers are not stupid...but if they don't have choices..well.

by john_wills

The farmers DO have a choice: they only get the sterile seeds if they used the special seeds at sowing. If they stick with what they had before the biotechs came along they can continue indefinitely. Of course, their yields will not be so great, but they have to decide whether the greater yields of the biotech seed will yield enough profit to keep with the biotech industry indefinitely. No-one is being forced to abandon the old method of keeping seed from the latest harvest for use in the imminent sowing.

by tr_member

..as long as I get to pull some leg once in a while. You looked like a good soul who would allow me the momentary fun :-)))

This discussion is closed to new replies.