Discussion Locked

Particulary Stupid US house of reps bill passed to sue countries over oil

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Wow! do morons travel in herds? Apparently they do in the US house of representatives who voted to pass a bill to sue other countries in US courts. While I'm not enamored with Bush (to put it lightly) the white house is vowing to veto it.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20080520/ts_nm/congress_opec_dc;_ylt=AqRpQ0TOhAlAwYO2ofZ8tYADW7oF

why is this so stupid?
1) It shows that we are willing to push around the world to try and get our way. Like the evil empire alternate universe star trek episode where they want to force the Organians to give up their di-lithium crystals.
2) At the best it makes us look stupid, demanding and bossy, the stereotype of the 'ugly american'; at the worst it could increase our oil dependence if it really was successful, (dont' see how it could be) or cause them to retaliate and REDUCE output. or start a war. WWII with japanese was started over resources issues.
3) this is like trying to legislate prices. it won't and never has worked. some don't remember but the US toyed with price controls in the 70's when they started printing money to a great degree after going off gold standard. Companies simply created new products with higher prices and gave 'rebates' for whatever they wanted to so they could slowly raise the price as inflation raged (at double digits)
Look how everyone loves rebates and the hassles of not getting them back today.
4) it ignores the realities of supply and demand. chinese, indians, africans, south americans are using more vehicles and petroleum (with exception of brazil which is using more energy but less petroleum). at the current price any country that doesn't maximize its output is losing out. they already know that and are pumping full steam anyway.
5) it is as stupid as bush asking the saudis to pump more oil. no one outside of that country has been able to know details of their oil production for 40 years. their huge fields are running dry even tho they deny it. THey are pumping 7 million barrels of ocean water a day into the underground oil fields to boost production and it is still declining. they CAN'T produce anymore, and they wouldn't want to anyway if it would reduce prices.
6) cheapening oil will simply delay the date of our switching off or reducing greatly our oil use.
7) wild downward swings in prices will discourage US production
8) lets just SUE everyone when price is too high! $100 homes would be nice! and a $50 automobile to go with it! Everyone knows that automakers are holding back and there are only a few big companies! Let's nationalize GM and sue Korea for not shipping enuf or cheap enuf cars here. See how ridiculous it sounds?

Where do they get these people? are the house of reps so dumb they didn't take base economics or have common sense?

28 replies

by maxwell edison

.....to open-up American sources of oil.

To suggest that our courts have jurisdiction over other sovereign nations is ludicrous - just as ludicrous as suggesting foreign courts (and/or the United Nations) has jurisdiction over the United States (regardless of the issue). It's also ludicrous to remain as dependent on OPEC oil as we are, when we could be less so by developing our own oil resources.

by charliespencer

I was under the impression all oil pumped in the U.S. gets sold on the same international markets as oil from other countries.

If this is true, how will increasing domestic production result in reduced prices? I'm not aware of the amount available in untapped U.S. reserves, but I find it hard to believe we can pump enough to affect prices on the global market.

If this isn't true, I've been wrong many times and I'm used to it.

Thanks either way.

by maxwell edison

I've even said as much myself - all oil worldwide is bought and sold through the worldwide oil commodity market. I'll admit ignorance, however, when it comes to the nuances of how it all works.

In that case, I suppose my comment doesn't make a lot of sense, except as it might result in increased supply. Flood the market with supply, and if it exceeds demand, the price will drop.

(Thinking out-loud at this point)

However, I'm not sure why we couldn't change the rules, so to speak, perhaps even using NAFTA as a vehicle. Between Canada, the United States, and Mexico, I might guess that those three nations could produce all the supply all three nations need (conceding that the USA is the biggest user).

It is a complex issue, and trying to look at it in simple terms is difficult. I suppose we're all operating from some level of ignorance. After all, if we were experts in the oil commodity market, we probably wouldn't be discussing it in this forum.

by maxwell edison

We can obviously break-down where the USA does get its oil:

http://www.eia.doe.gov/pub/oil_gas/petroleum/data_publications/company_level_imports/current/import.html

So it can be broken down to country of origin.

What I'd like to see is a plan to eliminate (to a large degree) those OPEC countries, and find a way to replace it - regardless of what replaces it. I'm all in favor of finding alternative sources of energy, as are most people.

What I think is silly, however, is when a Senator grills some oil executive by asking what his company is doing to develop those alternative sources. What a stupid line of thinking! What I'd say is, [i]I'm in the oil business, Senator. I'm not in the hydrogen cell business, the solar business, the wind business, or anything else. I'm in the OIL business. Why don't the alternative-energy advocates develop it themselves?[/i]

To think that we can snap our fingers and use less oil is not realistic. Here's what makes sense to me:

Develop more of our own oil - and use it ONLY for our own markets, while, at the same time, let other industries (not the oil industry) be responsible for, and tackle the challenge of developing alternative energy sources. Henry Ford didn't make buggy whips, and Mobil-Exxon shouldn't be expected to make fuel cells (or whatever).

That's one reason why I think a lot of the environmental approaches are scams - they don't JUST DO IT!

by oz_media

Firstly I agree that the US shouldn't go after OPEC and try to police a world market, however I don't see the same similarities in the relationship between the USA and OPEC or the USA and the UN. I don't know that I agree with OPEC but I think you are personally over the top with your bias when it comes to the UN.

I recently read that even if the US was to triple refineries and upgrade existing refineries, the benefits would be miniscule and bearely measurable compared to the total amount of oil comsumed and needed in the US. You still wouldn't meet the demand and would still rely on foreign oil.

As for the National Wildlife Reserves in the Arctic, the resources there are assumed to be so minor and worthless that it would dry up very quickly and simply spawn into a never ending search for more oil in the Arctic, obviously resulting in devastating effects on the area.

The issue I recognize is that we don't need to expand we need to either multiply our existing oil reserves by massive proportions, which is unrealistic, or we need to conserve useage.

Sure the Saudis say there is an unending supply of oil in the sands, but that information is classified and is not seen by anyone outside of thier circle, however we take thier word for it because Saudis don't lie to westerners.

So far only ONE country on Earth has become independant in the fuel marketplace, Brazil.
Now I know that GWB like their lead and wants to save all the corn in the US for his big Ethanol dream, but that's a bit of a balancing act too. Sir Richard Branson had that big dream several years back and invested 3 Billion himself into creating this new renewable energy source, Virgin Gas
was supposed to be the new resource 'mill'. However even he sees the limitations now, in order to meet the current demand, the entire USA would have to be a recirculating crop for Ethanol use. I suppose Canada would be a little cramped if you all moved up here to make room for corn fields.

Questions:

How is conserving oil and reducing our emissions such a hard issue for people to accept? What losses or inconvenieces do people see occurring in their day to day lives.

Why is it that being more personally responsible is something that people just can't conceive?

People go to great lengths to try and prove that they don't need to be 'wise in the use of thier resources' (Scouting quip for you there, remember that one?). Why?

Why are people so set on living in an old world and not seek out ways to improve our existence on Earth?

I just don't see what the immense inconvenience is to people.

It's not always apolitical issue, sure it involves politicians now but the issue is real and not just political posturing.

by jdclyde

more production locally improves in short term.

reducing consumption improves in short/middle/long term

alternate fuels helps long term because nothing is close to replacing oil as a viable option, and once it is there, it will take years to get a new distribution system setup.

ANY solution should be looking at all three, short, middle, AND long term.

Just like the new "twistie" lightbulbs are pushed as PART of a solution, a bunch of SMALL things add up and it is stupid to not go for the cumulative effect. Or should we give ALL conservation efforts the same measure as you do about oil extraction, "minor and worthless", that this effort is minor so we shouldn't do it?

by jamesrl

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helms-Burton_Act

One of the provisions of Helms Burton was:
Economic embargo, any non-US company that deals economically with Cuba can be subjected to legal action and that company's leadership can be barred from entry into the United States. Sanctions may be applied to non-U.S. companies trading with Cuba. This means that internationally operating companies have to choose between Cuba and the US, which is a much larger market.

Canada then introduced two bills, one which would allow counter suits against any sanctions on Canadian companies, and a joke one - Helms Burton would have allowed the US to sanction those using property in Cuba seized by the revolution for profit. The Canadian Bill would have done the same to anyone doing the same to property seized by Americans during the American Revolution which belonged to United Empire Loyalists/Canadians.

The only time that a Government can have the UN or any international body or any other government have jurisdiction is when they grant it. Both the US and Canada agreed to an arbitration process on Free Trade, for example, or the GATT strructure.

James

by Member 25348569

You'd burn them as quickly as you could and then you'd be back to square one and we'll be having this discussion again.

Until you all over there realise just how precious a resource oil is - no mention of GW here! - you really should leave it in the ground.

It's also ludicrous to remain as dependent on OPEC oil as we are, when we could be less so by [b]using less[/b].

Neil :)

by charliespencer

just as soon as you say something I can disagree with. I was unaware international litigation was part of our energy policy. Silly me...

by ic-it

You would think that our Reps. would consider all possible consequences of an action such as that.
What would happen if we sued and OPEC decided to vastly reduce supply? It would take the courts years to complete a legal action. In the unlikely event that we won, we still would have faced years of exhorbiant prices. OPEC would laugh all the way to the bank.
And that doesn't even touch on the audacity of the action (You've covered that pretty well). ;-)

by charliespencer

is that November is six months off and there's a lot of voters cutting back their vacation plans between now and then.

by jamesrl

Saw a report on the news about the dramatic decline in US tourists to Canada. In March 2001 (before 9/11) there were 2.7 million visits (in one month). For the same month this year there were just over 700,000 visits.

Its a number of factors though - Border crossing issues (lines, passports for air travel), strength of the Canadian dollar (which is par now and about 70 cents in 2001), and the cost of gas (which is about 25% higher here than US).

James

by robo_dev

The concept is one of import taxes or tariffs.

Import taxes or tariffs are the mechanism to try to legislate prices.

Would tariffs or import taxes based on oil prices be a good thing? Dunno....

The concept of 'suing OPEC' would only benefit the law firms involved, but nobody else.

by oz_media

Brazil has done it, more than 85% of cars in Brazil are manufactured for both PURE ethanol and gas fuels. Brazil is teh first nation on teh planet to become 100% self sufficient with NO oil imports at all. They use sugar cane the same way the US proposes the use of corn.

I don't think corn is the viable option though, as I just stated in another post, Sir Richard Branson (of Virgin fame)sunk 3 billion into an ethanol plant to create a renewable resource for suel, but now sees that you would need ot plant every inch of the USA several times over in order to meet demands, not practical.

by jdclyde

there was nothing in your post to show how drilling our own oil instead of importing it all will not help in the short term WHILE we work on the long term.

And no, I don't believe it will destroy the caribou to drill in the ANWAR in the place that was specifically designated for just that purpose.

I think MAJOR punishments (more than just monetary) of someones neglect is responsible for spillage, with accountability going to the top.

Same for taking oil out of the gulf, and by Florida and California.

The "it isn't enough..." is not justification or valid rational.

Edit to add:

how much does that save on fuel and the environment to NOT have to ship the oil around the world?

by oz_media

I saw a report not so long ago, I'll try and find it again tonight to get some facts straight, that illustrated the futility in exploration through the Arctic and through ANWAR. The amount of oil suspected there is miniscule, the impact on the environment will be far greater than the benefits of teh resources. now if the Arctic was said ot be like Saudi Arabia, what are we waitign for? but as they KNOW there is not THAT much there, it just isn't a resonable justification for drilling in teh area.

Caribou, sure they'll find new moigratpry routes, they will thin out but still exist i am sure, that doesn't mean that it won't have a more adverse effect than the benefits reaped.

You seem to feel that a short term solution needs ot be found while a long term solution is investigated. While that is reasonable, it is not what I consider responsible or even logical. A cat with a bowl of food for a weekend will have some left when you return. A dog will eat until he pukes and then starve until you return. Which is wiser?

But as long as there is oil available, nobody is going to invest the time or money required to develop an alternative, UNLESS people get off thier arses, get on the same page and start working on it together.

You can't expect Gerry in his rural backyard to save the world with a great invention if there are oil companies and governments who won't invest time and money into his ideas as opposed to investing time and money into STOPPING his ideas, which they find far mroe lucrative.

If GWB came up with a new resource or source of power himself, I am sure they would get on board, klnowing it wil benefit them financially. Americans would take the greenie approach and former opposition would quickly turn coats to join teh American revolution. But as GWB is dumb as a stump, it's back to the drawing board on that one. as long as it is Brazil, Germany, England, France, Sweden or whomever, don't count on it taking off.

As long as THEY stand to lose a great deal of money, as long as THEY don't have to change, THEY don't care what else happens and THEY will go to great lengths to stop Gerry from capitalizing on his idea.

In countries where oil is NOT tied so closely to the government, you see a lot more effort into alternate fuels, alternate energy sources and new ways of living life altogether. In North America they play lip service to keep the punters happy and then continue to fight for more oil. It's a dead end street.

How many people in North America now live in more resourceful and environmentally friendly homes that aren't even on the grid unless providing power to neighbours? MANY!

There are architects and engineers all over that have these homes, build and sell such homes and, apparently, the cost of materials is often the same or less as conventional products and the environmental impact is much less (not just oil but less lumber, fewer plastics etc.), not to mention how much money is saved on heat, electricity etc. just running the home. Again though, until the large players get on board, it is merely pi$$ing in the wind.

If only there were more responsible governments and corporations in North America, but there are not, they have never needed to be resourceful and never had to go without.

by oz_media

While I like your theory, I don't think there is enough of a supply between the three nations to sustain the consumption. as it is, 60% of your oil imports are from Canada already. At the increased rate at which new cars hit the streets every month, I don't think we have teh vast amounts of oil required to sustain such a system for long, even with the inclusion of Mexico and expansion of US drilling operations.

I don't think as three nations we could become self sufficient with oil and even if so, not for long enough to matter. eventually we would all be holding out our hands and looking for someone else's oil.

You would end up owing Canada a gazillion in unpaid tariffs, NAFTA has been a big enough kick in the nuts to Canadians already, yet alone with oil exports too, especially to a nation that consumes as much oil as the US.

I don think that if all three nations combined resources that we could find a more suitable renewable source of energy though.

I think there is too much economic control by the oil companies and they have far to much at steak to allow such ideas to follow through. Politicians are about oil and oil companies are all about politics it seems.

Perhaps more of an ivested global interest were possible, we could move forward, btu with too many people benefitting from oil production, I am sure we'll be stuck running in circles until A) it is too late and we run out of reserves B) Someone wakes up and fully invests in finding new energy/technology.

It is there and being used in many parts of the world but not enough of an investment is made on a global scale to really push development and reduce cost.

With the mental capacity of mankind since the computer age, I am confident that someone somewhere has the answer and it is simply ignored or set aside like so many advancements that are conveniently set aside due to political disinterest.

Until the oil companies lose political control, we will be stuck following thier lead.

by jamesrl

While Canada is a net exporter, we do import oil still on the east coast, because its cheaper for us to ship in middle east crude than to pipeline Northern Alberta crude to the east coast to be refined.

I suspect the US migh have similar issues. It may well bring up the cost of energy in North America to do this, but at least we wouldn't be held hostage.

James

by oz_media

Canada has many trade options off the East Coast we also have great alliances and a strong history with our trading partners.

We don't have enough oil to jump in with Mexico and make North America oil independant though.

by maxwell edison

OPEC oil comes from state-owned companies and supplies. We have a free-market system. The government does not own the oil companies. (Well, not in theory, that is; with all the control and regulation, it might be pretty close!)

by jamesrl

Not sure how long it will last but we now can supply our eastern refineries with some east coast crude.

James

by dr dij

Most posts above seem to think it is ridiculous.

Are you for this?
Can you explain why?

I won't make fun of anyone's answer.
(other people might :)

If no one here is for this and no one I can imagine is for this, why did the House of Reps vote for this?

Are they out of touch with reality?
Are they out of touch with their voters?
Are they ..any number of unmentionable things..?

by oz_media

Are you for this? NO
Can you explain why? It is not your job to be the world police, you've spent years tryine to convince the world of that, don't prove the rest right.

I won't make fun of anyone's answer.
(other people might )
I MAY be nice, but it could be fun too.

Are they out of touch with reality? YES
Are they out of touch with their voters? MOST DEFINITELY
Are they ..any number of unmentionable things..? Oh, YES, and then some!

can I go outside and play now?

by oz_media

I see your comment on WHY oil companies would not want to get into developing an alternate source but is there not a benefit too, possibly an even greater one.

Kinks:
Don't oil conpamies pretty much conrol the money in the USA? Are they not the big pockets that sit on the side of the government and fund campaigns? How would an individual get his ideas through to the government? I know there are quite a lot of alternate fuel loonies out there but I am sure that some very good ideas have been stopped at the congressional doorstep to protect the oil companies.

Why shouldn't oil companies get into alternate fuels? They have the funding support and resources to seek out a new energy source, thier business is based on fuel exploration (even if oil is the main goal, I am confident they have knowledge and resources to seek out new energy).

I also think it would be in THIER best interest to develop a new energy source, they capitalize on oil, who's to say there wouldn't be far more to gain in a new renewable energy source, if they were at the top of the totem pole of course.

I just don't think anyone is willing to change their ways and try something new or venture into teh unknown.

by $$$$$$$$$$

But the real expertise necessary for developing other energy sources will not necessarily be on the payrolls of current corporate oil interests. I understand that geology is a major subject of interest to oil companies; other than geothermal energy, that is probably not much in demand for other energy sources. Mechanical engineers have been useful in developing windmills, and will of course continue to be. Several of those probably do work in petroleum companies. Likewise for education in applied chemistry. But an oil company would not likely have any use for specialists in optical physics or engineering.

Far more than lacking a substantial portion of the necessary expertise, the amount of public outcry and coercive government action that were brought to bear before the oil companies created alternative energy development departments suggests very strongly to me that that industry's leaders lack either the vision or the benevolence, or both, to produce the type of alternatives that you and I both have in mind. I'm thoroughly convinced that the research phase in viable alternatives is complete, the development phase has been largely completed in academia, and I suspect that the [b]real[/b] roadblock is negotiation for intellectual property. I picture the oil companies trying to convince the inventors and their lawyers to forgot who needs whom; who has the expertise, and who has only some physical and financial resources, but not the talent, knowledge and wherewithal to turn a profit on energy, after oil fields are depleted past half their total capacity, or whatever the "peak oil" calculation is.

by maxwell edison

15 to 17 billion barrels is a conservative estimate - not to mention the 35 trillion cubic feet of natural gas. The 15 to 17 billion barrel estimate could dramatically increase once production is underway. All of it could be tapped with minimal environmental impact - and on a miniscule parcel of the whole Arctic Reserve.

15 billion barrels of oil, at current import rates, could replace all the oil we import from Saudi Arabia for 25 years; if the eventual production could tap upwards of 30 billion barrels from the area (which some energy experts have suggested), then we could replace Saudi oil for 50 years. Open up the off-shore wells in the Atlantic, Pacific and the Gulf of Mexico, and pursue the shale fields in Colorado, Wyoming, Montana and the Dakotas, and we could probably replace imports from all OPEC nations for the next 100 (or more) years.

In the meantime, let the anti-oil people find a viable alternative. I would never suggest doing only one or the other, but rather both.

If you think my estimated numbers are way off, please provide some of your own. If we disagree too much on the estimates, then we can provide the sources. But I think you'll find that my numbers are a pretty good estimate.

by oz_media

I know when we discussed this before there were quite a few completely different stats provided. I did just see a viable reason that the oil supply woul dno tlast as long as predicted. I'll dig and try to find it again, a bit tired for it all now.

I won't contest your numbers, as I said they did vary considerably depending on source, but I am sure there was a very valid reason.

I'll look into it again tomorrow, time permitting.

Edit: I don't disagree completely to finding a VIABLE source now, but only on the condition that a total commitment is put forth in the meantime or some form of global motivator (suppose a Nobel Peace Prize would be in there anyway)is put up finding a better alternative. The only thing I don't believe is that with drilling in ANWAR we would see a change at the pumps, perhaps a quick price drop to hush the naysayers for a bit but I don't think it will stay. Money is tasty once you get some more margin, losing it is hard to take. I don't believe that, with their reputation, the oil companies would keep prices down.

Cheers

by $$$$$$$$$$

If that would really buy 25 years of independence from Saudi Arabia, [b]and[/b] if the locals are given "fair warning," I [b]might[/b] be persuaded to agree with max, but only if those two conditions are met, and I mean to the total satisfaction of all the locals.

This discussion is closed to new replies.