Discussion Locked

Prompt to confirm folder move on drag/drop

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Greetings all...

Been scouring the net all day trying to find a fix/hack for this.

We have many users who perform an accidental drag/drop on a folder rather than a solid double click to view the contents of the folder.

We find that folders will go missing, only to find it has been moved to a nearby folder by mistake.

I would like to know if there is a way to force a yes/no (or whatever) prompt to appear when a user drags and drops a folder using left click.

Permissions are not an option.. as they may very well need to move it, and if they are deliberate about it, it is fine. It is the accidental moves that are driving me nuts!

Thanks for your help in advance!

17 replies

by charliespencer

As I understand the problem, the user is intending to double-click. Instead, the user holds the button down too long for the first click, and he isn't holding the mouse still, so the OS interprets it as a drag-and-drop.

I don't know how to force a prompt, but have you tried slowing the mouse down so it isn't as sensitive to the minor movement? Or enlarge the icons and the space between them so it's harder to overlap them? I think PowerToys allows this.

by alex.bailey

That's a good decription of the problem, which I see a lot. Users drag one folder inside another nearby. Its been a problem since Microsoft gave the common dialog boxes 'mini-explorer' functionality. I am looking for a registry hack or policy setting either to disable the explorer functionality in these boxes or to force a confirmation request before a file move. Does anybody know one?

by ward

Looking for info from IT managers on users by mistake moving folders; drag/drop rather than double click to view contents;etc. Looking for any data on how widespread human error a factor.

many thanks

by alan.kass

I'm looking for solutions to the same problem with our laptop users. Ever get a solution or work-around for it?

by jfigas

I also have users that don't pay attention to what they are doing and move files and folders by mistake. Has anyone found a way to receive a prompt like you get when you delete. ie: Are you sure you want to . . . .

by andy konecny

a long time ago, in the transition from 16 to 32 bit operations, we did have the option we desire in Windows 95 and 98, but Microsoft, in their infinite 'wisdom' decreed that we no longer need that option of a warning about folder moves. Apparently in the Microsoft world, removing features is a product 'enhancement'.
This is why I avoid using Explorer as much as possible, with my choice of an alternate being Total Commander from ghisler.com

by wcasinillo

Hi !

Can you share how do you solve your problem. I have the same case, if Microsoft Windows have the ability to record or to log a any drag/drop or moving of files/folder then this will solve the case in order for us to get the culprit. Since some users are denying of what they did.

by andy konecny

I'm sure that most good audit programs will track this problem, even if they don't do anything to stop this from happening.
The users who are denying doing these accidental drag and drops are very likely just not aware that they've done so.

by marco.monzon

Does anyone have an answer to this post, it seems to be a poputlar search and I keep coming up empty, some registry ones, where you go to HKCU or HKLM and modify SW/MS/Windows/CurrentVersion\InternetSettings\Zones\0 and 1 DWORDS 1802 change Value data from 0 to 1 . And that didnt work!

by m_bilal_sheikh

Hi,

I can understand the pain. I am/was in the same situation. Been looking and googling for ages. If you have AD you can tackle it by group policy through the following kb article.

KB833633
http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?Product=winxp&scid=kb;en-us;833633
More Info on
http://www.tech-archive.net/Archive/WinXP/microsoft.public.windowsxp.general/2004-05/20757.html

This go for the prompt when selecting the action. I have successfully implemented it with a sigh of relief when looking at the result.

Now i have one problem left of my own. I cant block users creating folders or renaming them without having to sacrifice their file renaming and modifying capabilities which are what i require. I am sure this is a typical scenario for most central storage based setups without a document management solution.

by rueg

Did not understand squat of what was described on that microsoft support page. I'm having the same problem, but could you copy paste the excact things you used, and how :) ?

Thanks a bunch!

by rcaryl

This appears to work for Internet Explorer but not Windows Explorer. Does anyone know a solution for Windows Explorer we have the same issues here too!

by gvl

Preventing or intercepting drag & drop actions through explorer can be done by writing a shell extension for explorer.

I had the same problems with users inadvertently moving files and am also a sw developer so I wrote an utility.

Although it's free for personal and non-profit use I don't want to spam a link here. But if you Google the title of this reply you should find it easily.

by ricky.obrien

i am amazed how hard it is just to get a comfirmation yes/no prompt to stop users moving folders/files by mistake, on windows nt and WfWg it was an option.

i believe almost every one just wants a simple soultion that dosnt involve reg hacks.
i work in the nhs with over 3200 PC's so something that can be done via Group Policy would be good.

by shertzer

Did you ever find an enterprise solution for this (i.e. Group Policy template)? I have tried the 1802 DWORD 1 registry hack, but it doesn't work (IE8? XP SP3? idk)... It is amazing that all of these threads I am finding are five or six years old with no solutions!

by trueanswer

Hi gvl@...
I tried to download your developed sw called Intercept Drag & Drop and installed it. However it does not work on my computer. Is it because it does not support Win 7 64-bit and I have a swedish language pack too!??

by swimxu

I have also downloaded your product and cannot get it to work. I am also running Windows 7 64 bit Enterprise SP1.

This discussion is closed to new replies.