Discussion Locked

Roots of IT worker shortages

0 helpful
143 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Some groups say that there is an IT worker shortage in the United States. H1Bs and international outsourcing to places like India are a response to the symptoms of the shortage.

The response doesn't address the roots of the shortage though. If the United States truly wants to solve the IT worker problem, it had better look at getting more people into Math and the Sciences. And that involves some major social changes when it to how people view these fields.

I suspect that, in some of the social groups in India, those who are adept at Math and the Sciences are respected a lot more than they would be in the United States. That respect may provide a lot more of an edge than anything.

Unfortunately the United States doesn't supportits future scientists and engineers by respecting them in schools. The word 'geek' tends to be a very negative term that lots of kids try to avoid.

The media doesn't help. Jocks, musicians and movie/TV stars are idolized in ways that are harmfulto society, especially when they get away with various crimes that would get lesser folk locked away.

The same media slams scientists and engineers of all types, especially when things go wrong. This negativity then trickles down to the school kids, steering them away from math and the sciences.

I'd love to see a paradigm shift where the jocks and media stars are deemphasized in favor of teachers, scientists and engineers. Such a shift, in any country, would ensure its place in the future.

"Perception becomes reality. You become those who you admire."

143 replies

by epepke

One of the main problems is that math and science are percieved as strongly nonsexual. There are relatively few computer science groupies. How many times have you heard "I'm a people person, not a numbers person?" I generally respond, "Well, you're not good enough at it to realize what an insulting thing that is to say."

It's also desocialized, dehumanized. Postmodernism, the bastard child of Baby Boomer dumbth and the French, does this formally. It is much easier to declare science "just an opinion" than to learn about it.

To a large extent, Americans have given up on the dream of technology to make our lives better. It's only natural that those who still have the dream be shunned and attacked. Nobody likes a smartass.

Indians largely do not have these problems. The tradition of arranged marriages obviates the sexuality conflicts, and there has not yet been a time in India where technological comfort was so widespread that people percieve it as something that grows on trees. However, it is important to remember that the Indian workers we see are the cream of the crop; most people in most provinces in India don't give a wet slap about math and science.

by generalist

Computer science groupies, hmmmm. Now that has some interesting possibilties.

The sexual aspect of math and science might be something to promote in the United States. You'd have to do it outside the current entertainment infrastructure though. Perhaps an independent movie company or so might be able to handle it.

Distribution will be another problem, unless we actually use technology to pull it off. Digital movie downloads and DVDs might work. So would selling the stuff direct.

Another aspect would be marketing. If you don't have a big name star, you need ways of getting the word out to people that the product is a good one.

And for that matter, making a decent media product that promotes math and science will require a lot of creativity. There is a certain amount of truth to the stereotype that 'geeks' are non-sexual.

But if you think about it, this stereotype might be a self-fulfilling one.

by epepke

It's definitely accurate and definitely self-fulfilling. Speaking not only for myself, growing up as a technically-oriented male is a special kind of hell. I often see people wondering why there are so few women in IT; I want to shake them by the shoulders and say, "It's OBVIOUS! Don't you GET IT?" Of course, they don't.

There have been some media efforts along this line. _Revenge of the Nerds_ was pretty good. One scene is as follows. The nerd hero has successfully bedded the prom-queen-equivalent. She says, "That was fantastic! None of the jocks ever treated me like that!" He responds, "They're jocks. All they think about is sports. We're nerds. All we think about is sex."

And of course there was _Hackers_, which was aterrible movie.

When I was a kid, I always liked Barney on Mission Impossible, because he was the guy who did technical things. Also Bill Cosby's character on I Spy. There are very few roles like that nowadays. I guess the closest in recent years has been MacGuyver.

However, I think this problem might take care of itself, but probably only after enough Baby Boomers die and take their distrust of all generations other than their own with them. The real question is how to accelerate theprocess.

by shanghai sam

Your DVD ideas, etc. are pretty good. However, I think there's a better venue: computer games. They're already distrusted by adults, and they already appeal to the technical kid. But artistically they're like movies around 1910. There have been many worthy efforts (e.g. _The Space Bar_), but the computer game equivalent of an Orson Welles or even a D.W. Griffith hasn't come on the scene.

Part of the reason for this is technical. Writers don't need to know how their word processor works,and screenwriters don't have to understand emulsions. But game-writers need a deep understanding of computing. Even then, the effective lifespan of a typical computer game is four years at the most. (_The Space Bar_ has a copyright of 1997; it isn't even on the Segasoft website any more.)

What we need are tools for producing solid and technically competent games that are open-source and run on all existing or future platforms. This will release artists to concentrate on the content and not the technical side. They need to be sellable for about the price of a trade paperback new, and authors need to be able to get about the same amount of money with the same amount of work as a book.

At that point, I think, there may come to be mainstream art dealing with mainstream issues such as sexuality in a technical medium.

I've been looking for existing projects like this for some time without much luck. I've been thinking about starting one, but it's a fairly daunting idea, and being employed now, it's hard to find the large blocks of time that such a project would require.

by shanghai sam

Your DVD ideas, etc. are pretty good. However, I think there's a better venue: computer games. They're already distrusted by adults, and they already appeal to the technical kid. But artistically they're like movies around 1910. There have been many worthy efforts (e.g. _The Space Bar_), but the computer game equivalent of an Orson Welles or even a D.W. Griffith hasn't come on the scene.

Part of the reason for this is technical. Writers don't need to know how their word processor works,and screenwriters don't have to understand emulsions. But game-writers need a deep understanding of computing. Even then, the effective lifespan of a typical computer game is four years at the most. (_The Space Bar_ has a copyright of 1997; it isn't even on the Segasoft website any more.)

What we need are tools for producing solid and technically competent games that are open-source and run on all existing or future platforms. This will release artists to concentrate on the content and not the technical side. They need to be sellable for about the price of a trade paperback new, and authors need to be able to get about the same amount of money with the same amount of work as a book.

At that point, I think, there may come to be mainstream art dealing with mainstream issues such as sexuality in a technical medium.

I've been looking for existing projects like this for some time without much luck. I've been thinking about starting one, but it's a fairly daunting idea, and being employed now, it's hard to find the large blocks of time that such a project would require.

by generalist

Cosby, on I Spy, was one of my favorites too, back in the days when African-Americans were rarely sighted in the media. And if I recall, Barney was also Arican-American.

Then there was Columbo. Not much on the macho, good looking cop side, but fantastic at his job.

Accelerating the process of promoting competence might take a bit of work and involve creating modern day heroes that don't have gaping holes in their ethics.

The SF series that Michael Flynn just finished might be a good example of what could be done. Change society by starting in the schools and providing new standards and heroic goals.

Of course, to do that you'd have to work around the Boomers. Or, perhaps, work with them in certain ways.

Hmmmm. Hari Seldon and applied psychohistory. Madison Avenue with ethics. Competence, Incorporated.

What are the resources needed to transform society into a better tomorrow? And how can we start the ball rolling with the resources we have?

"Imagine the future and make it so"

by epepke

Yep, Barney was black. We didn't have the word "African-American" then, although in New York you sometimes heard "Afro-American."

Come to think of it, we didn't have role models, either. We occasionally had heroes. The role model has always connoted to me something constraining, as if a culture says, "We have all your roles ready. Here's your model. Pick one." A hero, on the other hand, is someone who transcends roles. Transcending mediocrity is what any improvement has to be about.
Another advantage of a hero is that you don't have to care about sex or skin color or anything irrelevant like that. I joke that if I were growing up today, I would probably have to undergo psychiatric evaluation for admiring Barney who, after all, had a different skin color from mine.

I think some good, solid methodology of the competent would come in handy right now. Mission Impossible was a show very much along those lines. The TV remakes (which, incidentally, featured the real-life son of the actor who played Barney as his replacement and movie son) were quite good but weren't popular, and the second IM movie seems to be about the Tom Cruise school of acting like a sociopath.

We don't have too many good myths any more. Leaders never speak of having dreams. The Challenger has replaced Apollo as a symbol of the future. The air and water are cleaner, the food is better, the wars are less numerous and bloody, and the gas is cheaper in terms of income than three decades ago. Why are people so uninspired?

The Great Work of computing has largely been abandoned for the Latest Upgrade. Electronics is no longer something clever, made by people; it's something you buy, and people in other countries are happy to make and sell us. This is sad. How *can* a young person feel inspired in this climate?

I have no clue. However, maybe if we keep talking, some good ideas will emerge.

by generalist

I hadn't really thought of computer games. Of course, my family tends to be the type that runs games like Civ II with the goal of getting railroads by 1 AD or sooner. For us being technologically ahead of the rest of the Civ world is a goal unto itself.

It would be nice to have other games that emphasize competence. Imagine a 'Mission Impossible' type game where knowing electronics and physics could give you a higher score than having lightning fast reflexes. And then imagine schools using such games as teaching tools.

It could be done if there were decent tools for writing the games. And if you really put the brain power into the game, it would always vary.

Want to join forces so the blocks of time would be smaller? Synergycan be a wonderful thing.

by epepke

That's the problem. Whenever you say "game," people think of relatively simple experiences. Think instead of an interactive narrative with such things as characters that you can care about. Why not? People have been caring about characters that are nothing more than smears of dirt on paper for thousands of years, or that are bits of silver in boiled bone juice for about a hundred years. We just haven't gotten the hang of it yet, that's all. If we did, I think that would go a long way toward making computers seem more humanizing and the people who work with them be treated more as humans.

WRT to your offer of joining forces, that might be a good idea. Of course, eventually I want it open to the whole open source community, but I've had a hard time getting started due to the "what's the point" factor. So, if you were also involved, it might keep me honest.

Right now I'm trying to find underlying principles for as large a class of games as possible. I think I have cinematic, panorama, and static image adventure games pretty much sussed out. I'd like to expand the class to include first-person full-physics games as well. Faster texture hardware has blurred the lines (c.f. _Nightfall_) between the genres, but the underlying code metaphor is still quite different.

I'm also looking for ways to support users with disabilites. It seems to me that any game should be playable, possibly in degraded form, by individuals who are blind or deaf.

Eventually, of course, other classes of games should be doable, but I think this class is a good one to start.

by generalist

Books and movies tell a story in such a way that you identify with the characters involved. If those characters happen to be designing an electronic circuit or building a power plant, so what? You get into the story and learn something on the side.

Heck, if the computer is the story teller it can have graphics and sound to entice you and really good characters that can become your friends. Those characters could then 'seduce' you into checking out things that interest them. If the character does a good job, they'll be the teacher at one end of the electronic log while you're the student at the other end.

As your skills improve, you meet some of your character's friends who introduce you to other topics. You can also join in withother adventures. And in the on-line version the adventures involve real people as well as constructs.

The above is a start at one type of 'game'. It would require a lot of specialized knowledge in story telling and education, in addition to the open source programming side of things. But I think it would work.

Of course, by the time it has gone through a few product life cycles, some of the better game 'characters' might be able to pass a Turing Test...

by packratt

While it's easy to get caught up in the questionable allegation that there is a techie shortage in America I think that the "geek factor" has a more sinister outcome when concerning IT than a supposed shortage of people willing to go into this line of work.

When a company looks to cut costs, there is a person who makes the final choice on who or what segment bares the brunt of the measures which usually impact employees first. This person probably, if general social ideation is accepted and applied to the average, views IT professionals as socially inept geeks.

Now, if we accept this premise, without getting into whether this assumption and generalization on the decision maker's part is real or imagined, then we can look at the humanfactor and say that if this person had to make a cost cutting measure would it be against the people in, let's say, accounting who this person can understand ad is friends with or would it be against the supposed geeks in IT?

To the point... Whatprofessional class of labor is outsourced more than any other? Are they outsourced because they are the only class that can be or is it because they matter little to the decision makers?

...

by packratt

Now, with that out of the way, let's discuss some new factors beyond the geek factor that will begin, and may have begun, to keep people out of IT.

Is the four plus years of college or the thousands spent in training classes each year now worth the return of being an IT professional? At one time the answer to this would have been fairly easy, thus why many who are in IT now had done it for the supposed money.

Well... Now it seems a different story. IT jobs are outsourced to other nations.Salary levels have been dropping. Perks are almost non-existant. Available jobs have plummeted if you look at the job boards. IT people are getting hacked off org charts left and right by the hundreds of thousands. And the tech sector does not anticipate a rebound until, at the very earliest if ever, the second quarter of 2002. There is no evidence that a rebound will even happen then.

So, you are looking to spend a considerable amount of time and money getting ready for your career. A career you hope will be profitable enough to pay your loans back while making it possible for you to at least survive... Well... How are you going to do that when someone in India or China or elsewhere is willing to do the same work for a salary that would put you bellow the poverty level, under the level that you would need to meet your basic needs in the US?

IF... IF there is a tech shortage in the US, there is now a lot more than the geek factor that will keep more people from getting into the field at this point.

by generalist

The cost/benefit ratio of education for IT and other areas becomes a major factor IF you survive the anti-tech culture of society. Both areas would have to be addressed.

Given this, perhaps the companies looking for tech types should consider paying for part of the education of their future employees. Furthermore, the student loan system should be set up to write off student loans for those areas that have high employer demand and low student interest.

The loan write-off technique is used for some areas. It should be used for technological areas too, as long as demand exceeds supply.

I suspect that some companies may offer help with the educational side. But who are they?

Perhaps those special interest groups that track such things could help.

by epepke

The problem is that, IF people are persuaded not to go into computing due to the spectre of international outsourcing, THEN it will cause it to happen more.

Personally, I have little patience for people who get into computers thinking only of themoney. These are the people who write the unusable crap code that plagues the world. The best reason to get into computers is for the love of it. Ironically and not incidentally, the people who make the most money in the technical track are the ones who do it for the love of it. They may have to prostitute themselves a bit to get it, but that's just a balancing act.

I know that you personally are unemployed now or have been recently unemployed. I was unemployed for more than a year, which caused me to lose everything EXCEPT my love of computers. Now I'm doing well. But that risk of hard times is one of the risks that you have to take for something you love, and it's the risk-takers that wind up in the best position in the long-run.

I think we've gotten too complacent. We're used to a steady stream of consumer yummies, in a country where a homeless person has a higher standard of living than the average in large portions of the world. It's unpleasant to fall upon hard times, and we've forgotten the love, the myths, and the dreams that sustain us during those times. I learned a lot from being destitute. It wasn't fun, but I'm better because of it.

by uncle ramus

I tend to agree with you. If more emphasis was put on studying and education and less on entertaiment and extra curricular activities it would help a lot. Math,science and academics are not put on the pedestals they should be. A premium is put on entertainment and sports and this I believe is one of the causes of such shortages.

by generalist

Some extracurricular activities would work out well though. Imagine if there was a Technology Club that had field trips to 'cool' places and things.

For example, imagine a field trip where you get to see all the 'behind the scenes' stuff at a football stadium. From the highest reaches of the press box, to the lowest basement level you get to see how things work. Such a visit could cover electronics, structural engineering, computer graphics and lots of other things.

If you have interesting guides for such a field trip and you start early on, you can hook a lot of kids on technology.

You would also give those kids some bragging rights when it comes to dealing with the 'jocks'. And if there are 'jocks' along, they can see ways of being a part of their favorite sports without having to face the long odds of becoming a professional.

by epepke

In High School we had an electronics club, which Gary, Jon and I started. We were sponsored by the physics teacher and used his room after hours. Our field trip for each year was to go to TRW where we got a tour and got given some of their surplusjunk, which was pure gold to us. Later we had a computer club.

I remember that they gave us flak for putting references in the yearbook, because it was Not an Official Club. We stuck to our guns, insisting that we were doing something all thoseafternoons in Mr. Kroll's building.

When I was a kid in New York, my mother used to take me two places: the Allied Chemical building, and the GM building. Both were free, and both were like mini-science museums. Also there was the science museum in Flushing, where I remember signing a petition calling for a return of Star Trek for the third season.

None of this stuff exists any more. There are some science museums, true. When I was in Academia, I did a lot of pro bono work for the local science museum, but there was so little funding.

by pandadude

JLo's hips...Britney's waist...Ricky Martin..the newest heartthrobs...We are possessed with bodies, appearances...always !
It's only going to get worse, as far as I see.

by packratt

Is it really desire that drives people away from tech, or is it fear?

The average person understands the superficial. They masses know looks, they are familiar with mediocrity, they can see physical ability. However, the average person has trouble dealing with depth of thought, intelligence, emotional maturity, even competence, and technology. What people do not understand they fear.

When I was young I was fairly popular in school, the people I wasn't liked by still respected me. I was a good athelete, I was fairly good looking, and I was easy going and tolerant enough to get along with just about anyone, I didn't do cliques. However, when I would answer the questions in class that others could not there would be silence and strange looks. When I won awards for academic competitions instead of the usual atheletic ones there would be that eerie silence again, whispers of "I didn't know he was a geek."

They didn't understand, and that's fine. Only the strong trancend the need for approval and set their own courses. When I got into the real world I steadily understood that managers and coworkers didn't want excellence from me, that threatened them, they feared that. They wanted mediocrity, they failed to understand the drive for perfection or closeness to that lofty goal.

So... Is it really a desire for physical beauty and strength that keep people away from IT and science? Or is it the fear of the unknown that keeps them away and the want for the familiarity of theknown that makes them seem shallow?

by generalist

Physical strength and beauty are things that are easy to comprehend and admire. Basic survival promotes it in a variety of ways. Madison Avenue and Hollywood promote it even harder because it makes money.

Technology is a lot different.

Technology can be hard to comprehend and can be both admirable and frightening. It is also extremely complex and is changing extremely fast in some areas. A good analogy would be a vast set of river rapids that is overwhelming when you're near it and iscapable of killing you if you get caught in it.

The overwhelming complexity of technology keeps people away from it because of various types of fear. But if people learned the basics of how things work, a number of the fears would decline. And if they learned enough about it, they could see that the river rapids can be survived if you go into them with the right tools.

by generalist

It has been getting worse over the years, especially with the media 'helping' out. One side effect are the eating disorders in the female population. Another is age discrimination.

What we need to do is figure out a way to have people apply extended standards to how they look at people. Those standards could deal with competence and other abilities that are more than skin deep. That would allow the competent 'non-body beautiful' types to have an edge over visual perfection.

It would also give the smart 'body beautiful' types a chance to show off their other attributes without scaring off the rest of the world.

Doing that will be a trick though.

by juanita marquez

You're absolutely right. There is no offense worse than looking the wrong way in society, and the one that is the most acceptable to make fun of. Gay jokes? Bad! Making fun of handicapped people? Unthinkable! Racial stereotypes? That's just wrong. But everyone jumps on the bandwagon when people make fun of skinny, bald, or fat people, or the guy that wears hornrims or a bow tie. Especially as a woman, you just can't win. Article after article talks about an actress that has gained weightor looks bad out of makeup or terrible at the Oscars, when writing such things about an actor would be considered useless drivel. When Christie Brinkley says that even she thinks she's inadequate when looking at the covers of magazines, what hope do the rest of us have?

I finally realized that I had to do what makes me happy, because there will always be a detractor of some sort out there, no matter who I am or how much I make or what I do or how I look, so I might as well please myself at least. I'm still licking my wounds from mental injuries inflicted years ago. If only more people could feel the freedom in taking command of their thoughts, knowing that they are a good person, and screening out the idiots that pronounce judgment on them, perhaps the world would be a better place, and they would be free to live life in whatever fashion and in whatever job pleased them most.

by kenbarker

The nerd nation already has a role model.

A person whose distinctly nerd like visage is routinely plastered across newspapers, magazines and the television. A person whose nerd like activities have resulted in unmatched success, which could bean excelled example to our youth. An un-abashed nerd whose brand identity is instantly recognizable as "nerd-like"

That person is * GASP * Bill Gates. The UBER-nerd.

Now, who are the people who most viciously deride and slander this icon of nerdliness? US! The other nerds!

You can't have it both ways. Our craft won't have an attractive image until we at least stop eating our own.

by packratt

Bill Gates is not a role model or hero of any sorts since he is a businessman and not a nerd. Also, one would like to see and ETHICAL role model since we have quite enough unethical ones already.

by kenbarker

It would probably have been more accurate to state that you do not believe Bill would be a good role model, or that he is a nerd, or that he is ethical. To state these as fact is inaccurate and amateurish. Let's review them objectively and within the framework of our current goal.

A role model is (per websters): "A person who serves as a model in a particular behavioral or social role for another person to emulate"

Clearly Bill would fit this definition. If we are interested in gettingmore people into this field - then holding up a member of the field who was able to use the industry to amass great wealth (a goal however impure shared by most rational humans) would seem a reasonable proposition.

A Nerd (also per websters): A person who is single-minded or accomplished in scientific or technical pursuits but is felt to be socially inept

I don't know if you have seen/met Bill...but allow me to propose that he has met all of these standards. It would be impossible to have risen to his current station without single-minded focus. And of course, Bill's social adeptness was clearly demonstrated during the anti-trust trial depositions. ;)

As far as Bill's ethics go I would suggest that your assessment is entirely personal.

When viewed from the capitalist perspective the behaviours engaged in by "microsoft" the corporation are purely logical and ethical.

I don't know if Bill cheats on his taxes, beats his kids, or is unfaithful to his wife - which would be unethical personal behaviours. I do know that he gives generously to charity and has been loyal to those who have assisted him - which would be ethical personal behaviours.

So, it would appear then, by objective analysis, that Bill Gates wouldindeed make a good role model...in so far as his example could be used to entice young people to emulate him and enter our profession.

by epepke

Jim Blinn was a hero for a long time in the computer graphics community. He always had an entourage following him at SIGGRAPH.

However, his star has been waning ever since he decided to go work for Microsoft. I see him at SIGGRAPH with nary a groupie following him.

For a brief time, Bill Atkinson was a kind of hero. I haven't heard anything about him in a long time.

Donald Norman is also a bit of a hero to many of us, but he doesn't personify the technical person so much, and in recent years he's distanced himself from us.

None, alas, has much in the way of public sex appeal. Maybe Linus Torvalds could become an international playboy and get in the scandal sheets.

You're right about Bill Gates. Way back when he was selling Microsoft BASIC, which was really a great tool for the time, he was great. Now, however, it's all business and "innovation" used to mean copying.

by admin

Bill Gates is not a nerd, but learned early on to appear enough like one to be accepted by true nerds in order to turn a profit, something most nerds don't inherently want to trouble their brains with learning how to do.

He obviously doesn't value intelligence and commitment and yes, love of technology. This was exactly the enviroment that the original DOS was programmed in. If he really held nerd values, he would of shared his eventual ridiculous wealth with the true person who gave birth to this out of respect.

by danarothrock

Our indignation with Gates is justified - he is not the icon of nerdiness - he is another icon of irresponsible greed - we reward those who steal, dominate with brute force, and make our lives more difficult and painful. Praise be to Gates - the quasher of the Computer Revolution. Long live the mainframe. 90% of the population can never afford a computer - hurray. Schools still can't afford them - whoopee.

by generalist

If you look at Bill Gates and others of the Microsoft realm at a high level, they are an excellent example of 'nerds' who have made good. That view from fifty thousand feet is beautiful.

But when you get closer you see flaws.

This phenomena isn't new though. You can look at a lot of the movers and shakers of the last couple of hundred years and see beautiful views from fifty thousand feet and horrible flaws up close.

I think that the best approach towards using any role model is to emphasize the good points yet point out how things could have been better without the flaws. Don't completely condemn a person or group because they have flaws, because those flaws are often a part of the environment they face. But don't hide the flaws either.

Also remember that bias comes in many forms. There are those who feel that Microsoft can do no wrong. That is as bad as those who feel that Microsoft is the IT world's anti-Christ.

by epepke

Forget MS bias, pro or con. It's irrelevant.

I find it telling that you consider being perceived or presented as socially inept to be essential to an IT role model. That's a bit like insisting that every African-American role model act like Steppin Fetchit. It certainly is legitimate, however, to suggest that Steppin Fetchit is not a good role model for precisely those reasons. Spike Lee does that. Personally, I think that Steppin Fetchit was far more nuanced as a performer than Spike Lee gives him credit for, but I don't think he's bad for rejecting certain role models as unsuitable.

I don't see any problem with rejecting Bill Gates as a role model for the reason that he's percieved as socially inept. Anyway, there's another point. Bill Gates exists, is plenty celebrated, and is manifestly NOT attracting droves of Americans to the field. This, pretty much, is the whole point. It's broke, which is why we're trying to figure out ways to fix it.

I personally would liketo see public characters who are smart AND socially competent, possibly even a bit over the top. The James Bond films would have been more to my liking if Q was the one who got laid a lot.

You simply aren't going to attract lots of adolescents into a field unless it's portrayed as sexy.

by kenbarker

I don't think Jeff is actually a technical person, but he is associated with the computer business.

He might make a good role model. He at least looks the part. If you've never seen Jeff in an interview you might not realize he's a great speaker, and just gives the impression that he is having WAY too much fun making things work.

I think if we can create an impression that this is a fun business to be in then we might boost the numbers of people who get into it.

by epepke

What you describe is a kind of highly nonlinear game. This is a good idea, but I'm not quite that ambitious right now.

I'll try to describe what I want to do with an analogy with something that's already happened.

Bill Atkinson sits down and develops a program called HyperCard. It's influenced somewhat by ideas such as hypertext, which are popular but not widely implemented. He has a "power to the people" mentality. He imagines that this will be used for address books, CD catalogs, etc. I would have done things a bit differently, but it's still a nice piece of work.

Some other group looks at HyperCard and says "Hey! We can make a game with this!" They take HyperCard, change a few things, get a third-party program to add color, but spend most of their time developing the plot, visuals, and sound.

The result was Myst, the best-selling computer game of all time, which established an innovative level of richness.

Myst got written because HyperCard existed. Maybe it would have been written if it hadn't, but it would have taken way more work and maybe wouldn't have gotten off the ground. Or maybe the existence of HyperCard got them thinking, and the spark wouldn't have been there. Or maybe they would have had to spend so much effort on the technical details that they lost sight of the world they were trying to build. At least probabalistically, I think, the fact that HyperCard was there made Myst happen, and HyperCard isn't particularly well suited to games.

by epepke

What I want to do is build the thing that plays the same role that HyperCard played in this history. This time I want it to be well suited to games. I want most, if not all of the paradigms associated with as large a class of games as possible to be built in. I want full support of video, audio, panoramas, spacialization, walk-throughs, joysticks, pads, goggles, speech synthesis, graphics cards, multiple monitor sizes and depths, network games, and possibly even speech recognition. I want it to run on every extant operating system, hence the Open Source bias. I know that this is a big list, and not everything will get done, but this is what I want to make, and I see no point in planning what to give up just yet.

Then I hope someoneelse will see it and say, "Hey! We can make a game with this!" Somebody who wants to write the Great American Interactive Novel but who doesn't want to become a grand master in C++ to do it. I'll be the grand master. And you, if you're still interested. And the rest of the Open Source community, if they are.

Still interested?

by epepke

This, I think, is the issue. Fear, itself, isn't the problem; it's the context in which the fear is placed.

Are they frightening like the rapids in _Deliverance_ or some other rapids?

Are they frightening like driving off a cliff or frightening like a roller coaster?

Are they frightening like HIV or frightening like a panther?

It seems to me that the key is to be dangerous but not threatening. Give the thrill of power but leave control to the user. Leaving control to the user, however, is something that computers do very poorly. When the user is not in control, all fears are magnified. When the user is in control, fear can be quite fun.

I think one of the reasons that people accept the Intranet more than other technologies is that you can hit the Stop or Back button whenever you like.

by juanita marquez

I'm going to make some generalizations, so those easily offended, brace yourselves:

The heart of the demand matter is the fact that IT takes a devoted interest in technology. The AVERAGE person has neither the smarts nor desire to pursue it. End of story. As a software specialist, I don't find hardware at all exciting...yet the problem-solving opportunities of software are very gratifying. If I, as a tech-oriented female, don't find hardware exciting, I'd think average women wouldn't either, and few things will change that.

I would bet that a good number of IT people have above-average intelligence. Just as there is a small percentile of above-average IQs, it would follow that the pool of those eventually going into IT would besmall as well. How to remedy that? I don't know. If you want a picture of today's young geek (and I use that word positively), go to geeklife.com and see what they are up to.

Role models had nothing to do with my career choice; I think Steve Jobs and Linus Torvalds are hot geeks, but I certainly don't worship them. Supposedly Bezos has a scary laugh that frightens children. I would also like to think that I don't pattern my life choices after other people who may or may not be worthy of emulation, and I daresay others may feel the same way, so a "role model" won't draw people in. I enjoy problem-solving and constant learning, and this field feeds that hunger, which is why I pursued it.

If you want to believe that my enjoyment of the sciences led me to IT, that would be incorrect...I wanted to be a doctor. From the outside looking in, IT would seem to be a difficult profession that deserves dedication and logic, which can be intimidating to those considering that as a career.

For all of these reasons, I think that IT will always be a field that has a limited supply of workers...which, as an employee, I'm very happy with.

by epepke

I work with computers because I have a passion for it, and if you believe in IQ tests (which I don't) I'm four sigmas above the mean.

I read one description of the "brilliant superstar" as someone who writes Lisp compilers on the Palm over a weekend for fun. I'm that sort of person. I'm happy. I would have been lot happier, though, without the social ostracism.

There are also a lot of bread-and-butter, almost blue-collar people in IT.

I don't like the idea of role models very much, but I do think it would be nice if cultural representations were not limited to mad scientists, hapless dweebs, budding Columbine bombers, killer computers, and saccharine-cute robots.

I also don't want what happened to VCR, televisions, and just about everything else to happen to IT. The issue is not a shortage period; it's a perceived shortage in the U.S. (whether real or imagined) that is resulting in significant outsourcing. There's only one VCR made in the U.S., and I don't want only one program to be written in the U.S. either.

Even if there isn't a real shortage, the point is still important, as I think that prejudices prevent significant classes of people from finding jobs easily.

by pmercer

Another poor stereotype of an IT person was the computer programmer in Jurassic Park - the first one :-)

He was portrayed as a slovenly, piggish, self-centered immoral individual . . . not the best representation of software programmers.

Granted, he had to be immoral for some of the things to work in the movie - but he could have been portrayed differently otherwise - such as: A smart, well-groomed woman in her 40's . . . :-)

by generalist

Generalizations are fine by me, especially when you acknowledge them front-end.

Your comments are good ones because they present other viewpoints, especially those of a tech oriented female. (Very rare...)

I particularly liked the comments about IT and high IQ people. It fits my situation quite well. It also applies to my eldest son, high IQ with an interest in computers and drama. We'll have to consider this factor in a number of areas.

For that matter, I know by experience that high IQ types require special handling. When my eldest was in third grade the school district had him tested for learning disabilities. He had two. One was ADD. The other was a genius IQ. We had to take him to another school district for a decenteducation.

One of the things we learned was that roughly half of the high school dropouts are kids with abilities that put them head and shoulders above everybody else. It is a pity that such potential is wasted.

Dealing with my eldest son has helped us with the other two kids, both very bright. The biggest problem was that his math abilities intimidated my daughter. It wasn't until last year that she found she was good at math. Come fall, she will be in Honors Math in high school.Your words of wisdom and experience from the female viewpoint are greatly appreciated. Feel free to join in any time and in any capacity.

by cjt

As a Senior IT New Business Development Consultant to an established offshore (India)software development/IT full service company with four (4) development centers and 750+ professionally trained IT professionals, I wish to commend the participants thus far in this discussion group for being so candid, committed to IT, and portraying an intellect that understands the requirements that we stress more technical academic programs holding our students to higher standards and expecting more from them if the United States is to continue to play a pivotal role in the second half of the technological revolution which is sure to commence shortly - within 12-18 months....

As an American businessman represneting India in securing corporate entities here in the States who understand the IT business and the advantages of outsourcing as well as affording today's IT Manager and his/her employees some stability in employment by he or she sending at least a portion of IT project requirements to usin India with us providing value-driven solutions enabling the IT Managers here to maintain stability in the workplace helping to work within budget constraints.

China, India, Australia and others are involved in IT development and we as Americans must demand that our children get an education which they must secure if they are to be at all competitive!

Thank you.

cjt@world.std.com

by admin

Mark Twain, I believe, once said something like: " We must educate to the middle because the geniuses will educate themselves, and the dunces are beyond help."

This leads me to believe this is not a new problem. Basically, I'm pretty pragmatic onthis issue. Yes there is a problem, yes it's been going on since the beginning of time.

People can't value what they don't understand. This is the reason Plato's "Philosopher King" didn't work either.

Most people don't have the ability to understand a lot of technical things. Therefore they don't exist to them. If somebody tries to share with them that other things they don't understand exist, it threatens them and makes them uncomfortable.

by admin

I will always remember 3rd grade math, where I, in class, demonstrated to my math teacher that he was not only teaching us an innefficient way to solve a problem, but that learning it his way would later lead to difficulties for all his students in their pursuit of math. He admitted he was wrong after a while, but then came back and started derisively calling me "Brain" or "The Brain" in class, which ostracised me. I got my only "D" ever by the end of that class. Since my family moved a lot, weleft that school, and I decided I would NEVER let someone that was stupider than I was make me give up on something I liked. So I learned how to make stupid people appear even more stupid the more they derided me. Then, of course, I had to learn to physically fight until I could win. Then of course, I learned how to steal their girlfriends attention. I became very good at controlling others, a skill I no longer need or use much, but the point is education will always go to the middle. If you are outside the middle, people will attempt to punish you and you either get strong as hell or give up, because you won't be allowed to be in the middle. I used to wish I was "Normal" sometimes as a kid. Now I never do. I am smarter than the normal person and that suits me well.

Schools inherently will never do well at training high IQ people. What they do that is very useful to us if learned is first that we have to learn how to interact with those less intelligent, and second, hopefully show us how, or at least provide opportunities to learn this in. Let's face it, you want to get this lesson in as soon as possible if you are smart. Otherwise you can waste a lot of time wishing it was different.

by admin

Having said this though, one thing I want to do in life is to provide an example and tell smart kids what's really up with this issue. Too often they just don't have adults that have been through this validating it for them. We are often too nice, when what they really need to know is: Yes- it sucks. No -it's not going to change. Yes- here are ways others have dealt with it, and you are smart enough to develop a toolset to thrive in it too.

by generalist

Odd that you should mention Myst. The headquarters of Cyan, the creator of Myst, is within ten miles of my house. To get there, I'd get on the street in front of my house and go north until I reach Mead.

I like your tactics of providing the tool sets needed in an open source environment. If it were done correctly, the Great American Interactive Adventure could be written for any platform and constantly be updated without a lot of effort. That would guarantee the availability of the product for a long, long time.

Better still, a really good set of ergonomic user interfaces would make it easy for content developers to concentrate on their specialties. And if things are done correctly, these interfaces will be rock solid for decades if the developer wanted them that way. (No more learning curve with new releases unless you want new features.)

I'm willing to do what I can to get this tool set into place with an example or so to show what could be done. My skill set may be more on the creativity side at this time, with knowledge of applications programming in green-screen environments. I don't quite know enough about more modern languages, unless it is JavaScript and HTML.

by packratt

PLEASE... PLEASE KILL THIS STUPID SPAMER'S ACCOUNT!!!

First of all this person is an utter moron and secondly he is advertising on TechRepublic without paying you for that ad space. Charge him for this, make this fool buy a damn banner!

Also, I would like to report that this idiot is using the peer directory to send spam. IF you do not delete his account I will start telling EVERYONE that is listed in the peer directory that you do NOTHING to prevent spammers from using that directory.Do something about this jerk, this is disgusting.

by generalist

I now know one set of organizations I wouldn't consider hiring, even if they were the best in the world.

One or two posts in a different discussion thread would be okay, especially if they were closely tied to the topic and actually presented different information each time. This 'canned comment' approach gets more than a little tedious.

The professional image it presents is one that reminds me of a socially inept geek trying to be a sales person. They know that you have to be persistent to make a sale, but they don't vary the sale pitch much.

As far as I can tell, only the last paragraph changed from other posts in other areas. While it touches on the topic of THIS thread, it doesn't do a very good job.

CJT, you might want to vary your approach and provide useful comments without the sales pitch. As it is, your professional image is reaching the point that I think of you as the GTE of outsourcing.

Note that, to me, GTE stands for Garbage Telephone Equipment, an organization I've detested for years because of their inept handling of a single yet aggravating event.

If you want help improving the image, contact me. I'm willing to provide it for a price.

by admin

I think that Doom and then classic Quake did spawn the creation of a social group that was technical. You could play straight up head to head fast twitch, but to be really good you had to be writing maps and bots and know all the cheats etc. and a total culture still revolves around this. No matter what comes out, my friends still put better classic Quake servers up each week and sex is part of the whole gameplay scene. I remember the first time I was playing on some new maps that a girl wrote with all these sexual images in the walls, getting turned on that this girl at the LAN party was beating me 'cuz I was distracted and having an all out grudge that lead right to my bedroom. Come on, Quake gurlz are the ABSOLUTE best in bed! I am so hot for women that play a mean game. Hell even the "Asheron's Call" and "Everquest" players I know meet their boyfriends and girlfriends through the game and end up flying back and forth for sex all the time.

Women seem to like my "geek" glasses these days -even though they aren't horn rims but handmade in France. I, in fact, have seen more "Geek" guys not have girlfriends for reasons that have nothing to do with their technical abilities, but more their standoffishness in social interaction. I do this amazing thing when I am interested in a woman -I talk to her. I have found a lot of interest by geek gameplayer gurlz (who are the hottest looking and most mentally stimulating anyway -oh, did I metion that good sex is mental too?)

Everhear of Stevie Case a.k.a. Killcreek? One of the best Quake players of any sex ever. Her and John Romero (a Doom and Quake Founder) got together for the ultimate romance story in Quake history (involves her winning a Ferrarri in a game). You may have also seen her feature in "Playboy" or elsewhere.

Check out my next post too... "The Fragmentation of society through the decentralization of mass media"

by admin

One of the things that comes to mind is that most people used to watch "Mission Impossible" so we had a common language and experience. To put it another way, we follow "a story in such a way that you identify with the characters involved" together and then can share our own unique experiences through this common shared language developed through the story. This is the way mythology and story telling kept humans together socially for bejillions of years.

Right now it is all changing rapidly.We all watch different things on tv. We have so many channels that we are losing any common thought or language as a group. Are you a "Friends" person or "Discovery Channel"? "E.R." or "Seinfield"? "Sex in the City" or "Voyager".

Ok... so now onto Gaming. In the future we all want this wonderful cohesiveness around a game that is "interactive" I would ideally want this too. However, the very nature of interaction is to individualize the story line which ultimately played out, brings one awayfrom integration. Simple games as we have now still allow social integration through their inherent limitations, but as gameplay evolves, storytelling will become whatever you want it to be in real time, which may be interesting as one of the reasons we can still survive somewhat cohesively as a society is that while we are headed that direction, we still are close enough to a common history and mythology that we bring this into the games. What about a time after this is lost? Of course, groups(clans, tribes) will form for power, but will they be able to control large numbers of true individuals outside their own common experience? An interesting indicator of this in our democracy is whether the 2 party system will be accepted much longer.

by admin

The best way to change society into accepting a group is too get them interested in non-interactive stuff, or carefully controlled interaction. The problem is, people, especially youth, don't find this course too palatable.

I actually like your game idea a lot and am not throwing stones at it. I think that it is possible to create games that are accepted and provide positive role models for youth. I'm just not sure if we will be using the word "society" with much real meaning for much longer, so I don't know if it should cater to changing that view.

by admin

Now I don't have to say it.
I will say though, that there are way too damn many non-geeks in the IT world now.

by admin

Oregon Museum of Scince and Industry! OMSI. I was there every chance I got as a kid. And Wally Lundeen, the bench guy in the local Sears repair shop who let me sit at his bench and use his tools. He even gave me equipment (some of which I still have) and broken parts to desolder and build into "projects"!

No school clubs in the many schools I went to, but good friends and school memories of having the hands down best stereos around. People were always bringing music over to hear it on my stereo's. I also did most everyones car stereos, and much rewiring of custom motorcycles and cars and was taken in by the "stoners" and "hot-rodders" for my skills. I had a lot of friends non-tech and tech that valued these skills growing up. I guess I was just lucky or something.

by admin

"single-minded or accomplished in scientific or technical pursuits" No, he is objectively not this. If he was, he would of left everything for the lawyers and business folk to sort out due to the fact that his love of programming precluded all othertasks. In fact, he gave this up to pursue business. this does make him single minded and a good business role model, but not a nerd, even by your own use of Webster.

by epepke

In reply to admin...

I've solved my sexual difficulties. I started about seven years ago, at 33. I will spare an account of my escapades since then, as they would be percieved as bragging in almost all communities.

However, the point is thatI did it at 33. Not 16 or 18 or 22 which is when people expect to be able to do it.

As for your comment that many geeks have social difficulties due to ineptitude rather than technical prowess, that's one of those statements that is both true and useless. It's a bit like saying that people don't die from falling off a cliff but from the sudden stop at the end.

For me at least my intelligence provided a social barrier that prevented me from learning social skills and self-confidence at the "correct" time. From the experience of my ex-stepson, this still happens, and I think it is the norm rather than the exception. You may have been lucky but more likely were saved by association with motorcycles, which already represent a sexual image.

WRT your comments about society, perhaps culture would be a better word. It seems to me that there is always going to be some sort of culture wherever there is more than one human. It may be different, but I think the basic point of life is that I get to influence how it changes.

by generalist

One technique of survival for smart kids is to develop enough social skills to survive and look for intellectual equals in non-school environments. Parents and friends can help out with this.

Another technique is to be tolerant of others and befriend some of the tough kids that are basically decent even if they look like hoods. My eldest did this in high school.

A third technique is to find somebody smart with similar interests and marry them. (That technique has hazards. Your kids may be even smarter than you. I know this from experience.)

A fourth technique is to find some sort of science fiction or technology club where being smart and/or creative is admired. It is kind of nice when you run into people who appreciate you for what is between the ears...

There are times, though, when having a mentoring system for the social side of things would be useful. We could, as suggested, teach kids that the system is more than a little marginal and it probably won't change soon. We could also teach them coping tactics...

by pmercer

What is obvious about so few women being in IT? Sorry, I guess I am maybe a little dense about this :-)

Please enlighten me . . . thanks!

by generalist

Personally I'd say that there has long been a bias against women demonstrating that they are brainy. It has been improving a little in the last thirty years or so, but not as much as it could.

For that matter, there is a lesser bias against men demonstrating that they are brainy.

I believe that a few people have mentioned that the population at large doesn't like people that are smarter than them. It doesn't help that some high IQ types rub it in sometimes. But that is a socialization problem with hints of public relations added in...

by juanita marquez

Women are biased against for many reasons - appearance, age, bimbosity, sexual experience, social status - as John Lennon said, the "nigger of the world" - but I honestly don't know that I've been biased against for being too brainy. I HAVE been biased against for some of those other reasons. I may be naive. I try not to flaunt my intelligence, I try to be decent to all people and that means making them feel comfortable in my presence. Then again, I've been accused of "thinking like a man" and have always preferred the company of geeks - they tend to be more sensitive, caring, tolerant, and stimulating to talk to, therefore, worth my while.

I think the fact that I've been perceived as "thinking like a man" stems from the fact thatI like technology and other things that are typically designated as "male" interests. Part of that is because - just face it - women on average don't find technology exciting, and they won't choose a career in something that holds no interest for them. There is an interesting article on this subject in the 9/1/00 issue of CIO magazine, "Why Women Hate IT".

I think the best thing one can do is promote strong will, self-esteem, independence, and encourage creativity in all youth. Each person will find his or her niche, but be better prepared to deal with what life throws at them if they are inherently secure in their decisions and better able to make sound decisions in the first place, thus relying less on outside influences such as peer pressure and better able to go into the field they desire because it is truly what they want to do, instead of having society dictate what it thinks is proper for them.

by epepke

OK. I have a picture in my high school yearbook, probably sophomore year. Jon, Gary, Kevin, Heidi, and I are sitting at one of the picnic tables. We guys have brought in bunches of electronics: circuit boards, wires, etc. They are splayed aroundus. We guys are having a great time. Heidi has her nonchalant grin.

Gary is a lot like me. We don't drink or smoke. Jon smokes a little weed. Kevin is a Bad Boy, drinks a six-pack in the woods regularly during lunchtime, pukes at Young Republican parties, etc. Heidi wants to get into Kevin's pants because he's a Bad Boy. She doesn't give a wet slap about computers or electronics. No other girl would deign to be seen publically with us. We're all very smart; we had to take a serious test to get into the school, and the school has about the same number of boys and girls.

Fast-forward a decade or so. Jon is a partner in the company that makes sound spatialization cards. Gary consults. I'm head of Scientific Visualization at the Supercomputer Computations Research Institute. Kevin is a hot-rod mechanic. Heidi works in a shop.

by epepke

Girls are smart. They know that being associated with "nerds" and technical boys is the kiss of death for their social life, power, and standing. They wisely avoid it, for the most part. A few are in unusual circumstances, and we see those in IT a decade later, too. But they're only a few.

Nearly everyone agrees that girls are more mature at that age than boys. That means they figure out the social score earlier and start dividing their classmates into an elaborate social hierarchy. Boys are dumb. A lot of them never grok the social structure, can't figure out that appearing to be involved in technical matters is social death, and you're supposed to fight and get drunk and stoned and act like a sociopath. In other words, like anolder male.

So there's a much larger pool of boys who stay home and work on electronics and computers instead of going out and exercising their social power. It's from this pool that most people in IT, and certainly most of the people in the highly paid positions come.

by epepke

Now, there are exceptions. There are boys such as Kevin and admin who have grokked that you can be interested in technical stuff if you're also a mechanic or an athlete and hang out with the sociopaths. There are girls such as Donna Cox who rise to the top of the profession through a "safe" girl activity such as art. There are some girls who like geekhood and are willing to pay the price in terms of their social power or who were cut out of it anyway.

But people talk about numbers and statistics. The race not always to the swift, nor the contest to the strong, but that's the way to bet. And, if you need any evidence that this is a nearly universal pattern, hang out in ANY high school in the United States for fifteen minutes in the corridors between classes.

Someone told me that schools in Vancouver were less brutal. I'm sure they're not brutal at all in India, with its lack of the "modern" sexual behavior that most Americans think makes them morally superior to the rest ofthe world. But that's the issue behind the thread that spawned this one: the lack of solid IT people in the U.S.

We won't see a lot of women in IT, let alone the best paid ones, unless this social convention undergoes a radical revolution, and then we won't see it for at least ten years. Even if we start fundamental changes now, which we don't have the power to do anyway, I'll be well on my way to dotage AT MINIMUM before it happens.

by epepke

Excellent point. If it had been a smart, well groomed woman in her 40's, Spielberg would have gotten bomb threats.

Oddly enough, in the book, that character is still not very nice but has some motivation for behaving that way. He's been screwedby the employers. It's almost as if Spielberg decided that no employer could be portrayed as bad. This is consistent with one of the other differences: in the book, the mongul behind the park was a real fruitcake.

by danarothrock

There have never been shortages of scientists, engineers, or programmers in this country, and never will be. My brother is an electrical engineer whose job experiences have been the same as mine - layoffs, mergers and acquisitions, downsizing, and most dominant - H1-B.

The problems are MBA's squeezing one more penny out of a product without regard to quality or sustainability, sales VP's making engineering decisions, and Greenspan jacking with the money supply. All of these tactics have ended in disaster, but no-one keeps track and the scamsters rake in $billions.

by generalist

That is one of the reasons that I qualified my statement by saying that 'some' groups claimed there are shortages.

It would be interesting, as an aside to the primary thrust of this discussion, to document H1B coverage versus unemployed US citizens. In theory the H1B program is set up so that US citizens have the ability to be employed before H1Bs are brought in. I can't see Congress passing laws that would favor immigrant employment at the cost of US jobs IF US citizens were available.Unfortunately there are some organizations that would try to cut costs by meeting the letter of the law while creating a bias toward lower cost H1Bs. I won't say that they are a majority, but given human nature they undoubtedly exist. All I would need is a single example of abuse and my claim would be true.

If there was hard data about such violations I'd love to see it. One or two instances like you and your brother are just a hint of a trend. Dozens of verified cases in a small area would be hard data that could get the media up in arms and your local Congress critter in hot water.

You might want to consider networking to find out the true employment picture for tech types. A lot of them may have changed careers rather than face long term unemployment. When that happens, you get an artificial shortage.

by danarothrock

I have been working in mainframe systems for 27 years. H1Bs have been employed to code COBOL and CICS on mainframes, which, as you probably have heard, are as dead as Latin. Mainframers careers have been on the skids for 10 years. Mainframes have not been replaced as expected, though, and work may be more prevalent - but we aren't getting it.

A study of the numbers of H1B's coming in will show the skills are in the mainstream of IT systems, engineering, and technology - not rarified specialties with no domestic talent. I have freinds who are H1B's - once they see the true picture in the US, they are ashamed of what part they are playing. Two have actually asked me how can I stand for what this is doing to my country? These people have more respect for America than we do. We need to get our act together or our sons, daughters, and grandchildren will hate us for the desolate landscape we pass to them.

by danarothrock

I have been posting my resume all over the country (thousands). Responding agencies are saying they are getting 300 to 500 resumes a day for the same mainframe jobs. My last 3 jobs have been displaced by "offshore" projects using H-1Bs as agents.At least one of the "offshore" projects failed - hurray for our team - I'll get back to you about the others.

As for as complaints - collegues of mine have complained and get royal run-arounds. The justice department does not have enough agents to investigate all the complaints of abuse by consulting companies and sweat shops. These companies are extorting 1/2 to 2/3 of the salary of the H-1Bs and aliens have no judicial recourse. The primary companies get cheap labor and no responsibilityunder the law. Real sweet deal for a few.

by mikeking23

I think many of you are missing a large point. I am a software engineering major and am noticing a disturbing trend. The computer science major at my school is one of the largest majors on campus. Students in this field are largely non-geek in nature. This is a bad thing. Most are greedy and jumped into the field because 4 years ago they read every magazine article that stated computers are the hottest thing going and the money was huge. The amount of kids graduating with computer relateddegrees has skyrocketed leading to a large non-skilled workforce. (no one that is reading this falls in that category though because face it, we are all geeks if we are reading a techrepublic discussion thread this far down!! :-)) All I'm saying isgive it a few years until the people who shouldn't be in the field leave and it should settle down.

by epepke

However, it points out another problem. While we're waiting a few year, the dumbth people are nailing down standards, conventions, and culture according to their perceptions.

There was recently a thread on good database design. Most of the suggestions in the thread were actually bad database design which were only required as workarounds for software such as Access and SQL Server that aren't designed properly.

This frightened me. I am well acquainted with the need to work around bugs and bad design, but in geek culture, bugs and bad design are, well, bad. They are to be fixed. Geeks write kludges, but they *know* they're kludges.

But in the dumbth culture, a bad kludge to work around a bad defect magically becomes a *good* design. This philosophy is starting to dominate the indusrty. Already it is dominating the business culture. Pundits are praising the fact that more time is spent on maintenance. They say that it's good business sense to plan for continuous bug fixes. Something that works for five years without a flaw is percieved as worse than something that requires twenty "innovations" during that time which are just needed because it wasn't done right in the first place.

Good design is already difficult simply because it surprises people, and they think it's therefore wrong. At some point in the not-too-distant future, good design will become impossible.

The process will certainly become complete and probably unbreakable by the time the overabundance of dilettantism fades.

by generalist

Having things dumbed down and cast in concrete might present an opportunity for the future if handled correctly.

Imagine a world where IT has reached a point where bad design rules and good design is apparently impossible. Maintenance empires have been established and people are prepared for the long run.

Then a group of geeks, with a few good front men and women, come up with a 'new and improved' product that is hundreds of times faster and thousands of times more reliable than the so called state of the art. Better still, the interfaces are ergonomically sound and the old to new conversion process takes less than a week, ignoring training.

Then comes the kicker. They can offer the product for a tenth of the cost of maintenance on the currently installed product.

The MBAs would love the product because of cost savings. Good design would be hauled in the front door for the simple reason that bad design is too expensive.

The only drawback would be that IT workers would be laid off. But if there were some sort of test procedure that could reliably find the good IT workers, they could be the people who remain because they understand good design.

It would require a fair amount of work on the product design sideand a lot of work on the marketing side. But the quality of the product, combined with the price, would make for a easy sale.

by generalist

Interesting observation. We may be missing the point because we aren't on a college campus with a large Computer Science school.

What you have observed might result in something like the MBA glut that happened a couple of decades ago when 'everybody' went into that field because of the money.

Unfortunately various organizations continue to wave the flag that there is a worker shortage in IT so people keep getting into the field. Equally unfortunate is that fact that IT has a very fastlife cycle time in some areas, so that a person with hot skills today may be obsolete and unemployed tomorrow.

When the supply curve and demand curve hit big time, the shakeout might occur. But by then a lot of older IT workers will be unemployable because of salary demands and lack of hands on experience with newer technologies.

There may even be a lot of H1Bs competing for the same jobs, helping drive the salaries down with the non-geek IT types.

It is going to be interesting...

by epepke

Needless to say, I agree.

You write: "I think the best thing one can do is promote strong will, self-esteem, independence, and encourage creativity in all youth." Of course, I couldn't disagree, but it makes me feel the emotion of wistful hopelessness. Its like saying "Gee, it would be nice if people could just get along and not kill each other any more."

The whole purpose of the educational system and nearly all of the socialization through age 18, and increasingly later, is to DISCOURAGE strong will, self-esteem, independence, and creativity in all young people. Did I say discourage? Wipe it out! Eradicate it! What we want are a bunch of weak-willed, insecure, codependent, and dull people as fodder for Our Great Economy. We want loyal plastic robots for a world that doesn't care.

In the face of the blight of Education, real teaching does happen, but it's ALWAYS a subversive act. That's why they sentenced Socrates to death.

I've been a subversive all my life, and I've suffered for it. The latest kick in the crotch threw me into a destitute state for a year, but now I'm getting some vim back.

But, what to do? Simply put, how do we rip this cancer apart?

by generalist

Strong will, self-esteem, independence and creativity...

Oh to have a society where such attributes are taught as part of a comprehensive education system that includes all parts of society, not just the schools. That would be wonderful.

It would also be nice to eliminate the "thinking like the opposite gender" bias too. In some areas, like quilting and tatting, you may have one male per fifty or more females. That male is often considered to be gay, even if he looks like a mountain man and has a wife and ten kids. That or he is a really tough football player...

Getting to that point will take a lot of effort, but it is theoretically doable. We 'just' need to show that people of all types can be competent in a variety of fields without conflicting with their genetic and biological backgrounds.

We also need to show that competence doesn't necessarily have to be threatening. If competence is combined with cooperation and a lack of backstabbing, then it isn't threatening. If anything, it is something you want to have in your organization, be it a household, company, social group or government.

Any thoughts on ways to promote this? Or do we need specialized help?

by juanita marquez

I don't mean to imply that we will change society at large by promoting positivity and self-esteem et al. As an intelligent geek female in the minority of the population, I never expect to be able to get the average person to accept me... I just got to the point at which I stopped letting people who don't know me from anything other than my appearance or intelligence or job or what-have-you provide (negative) self-esteem that should have been developed by me and people whose opinions TRULY matter in the first place. I take direct action by encouraging and fighting for the geek circle I have around me and letting them know that NO, just because a magazine/tv show/jocks/educators/other judgmental factions say that they are emotional hermits worthy of derision due to their intelligence or appearance, that opinion is valid. My point is to fight back, give your children or friends or whoever you find around you the courage and strength to develop their own validation and self-esteem so they can suffer less and at the same time be productive. I may be an optimist, and I can't control society's perceptions or attempts to put me in a box, but I can control what goes on in my own head, what I allow to reside there and shape my beliefs, and try to encourage those I care for to see their own worth. That, I think, is far better for psychological survival in the long run.

by juanita marquez

The same girls that like "bad boys" also tend to be the same girls who are always mystified as to why they can't get a guy that doesn't treat them well. They are willing to take poor treatment for a long time because they either lack enough self-esteem to put a stop to it and demand better, or they are fickle and go for whoever's the "cutest" or "most popular", even if he does treat them like hot gum on a shoe sole. In my opinion, those types deserve what they get. Granted, that's a harsh assessment, but that seems to be what happens. Guys are equally harsh when evaluating who they want to be date, even the supposedly enlightened ones. But chances are a geek will find more value in someone's depth than the star football player will. I'm not about to spill this secret to the general female population. ;-)

Social inequality and debasement will never change, as proven throughout the course of history. Attempts at raising the bar and being enlightened, responsible, caring people(think various prophets or religious leaders) have encountered resistance from those for whom baser elements run unchecked. Everyone always has to be better than someone else, and that goes from the smallest playground altercation to wars over who gets what piece of land. The answer isn't to change society, because that is impossible; it is to change the individual. Then, collectively, perhaps those changed individuals can make a better environment in small pockets. That is the best I am hoping for.

by generalist

You've made lots of good points here. And you have the elements of a plan that has worked over time. It may work even better with the Internet helping out.

If you start with the individual and help them learn how to overcome the slings of adversity, you create a core of people that can be intelligent and proud of themselves.

This core, via things like the Internet, can get together and work at creating virtual enclaves or fortresses from which they can work at improving the world. In some cases they may even be able to get together physically, which can be even better.

By providing mutual support and places of safety you can put more effort into improving things and less into defensive measures. At this point you can work at promoting the ideal world for everybody, a little it at a time.

Part of that promotional process might involve raising the standards of social movers like the media and the education system.

You may only be able to do a little bit at a time. But a little bit, constantly applied, adds up.

by admin

But what I disagree with is that changing social ideals is the answer. As Juanita is saying:"The answer isn't to change society, because that is impossible; it is to change the individual"
I would think with a deeper understanding of the will to power, or whatever paradigm you all used later as adults, that you would realize that what needs to be done is to reach the kids as individuals and validate what they already know to be true. That society never really values intelligence, but that it doesn't matter - you will , as Epepke says, get to the top of your field of interest by your intelligence. I believe this most likely happens when you give up on pleasing or fitting in with the masses and develop confidence in your own abilities. Thisis also when you appear "sexy" or "mate3 material" to others in my view.
Intelligent kids need to develop this confidence.

by admin

How? I want to help develop a community center were kids can practice breaking into each others networks, battle robots, and breadboard music and art projects etc. Tons of kids, male and female are interested in this, but they don't have confidence because "Hacking is bad" and needs to be hidden etc. Well, we all know it's not inherently evil and kids should have access to the tools, so let's give it to them, even if it's a few kids in the neighborhood at a LAN party, as I do now, or a full blown community center. (Actually, it's funny, but by word of mouth, my LAN parties got so big I couldn't get enough power through my circuit box to keep the lights from occasionally dimming and have suspended them until I get a new service...)
People are attracted to people who excell and are confident about things they value. there are usually about 40% Girls and 60% guys when I throw a LAN party for kids in my area and they hook-up at these things. Maybe it was different earlier, and I'm not atall wanting to blame the victim here when they've already fallen off the cliff. I'm just saying let's catch them and let them honestly know this happened to us too, we figured out how to beat it later, and are willing to help them learn it earlier.

Honest to God, if specific people in my life hadn't helped me, I may still not have gotten this. I really think that girls need this encouragement a lot too. I have been happy to see them trickling into Battlebot teams and always glad to see themgaming because what better way to meet your spouse than doing something you both enjoy.

by admin

Amen!
Thank you Generalist. I love the show "Freaks and Geeks" because of this. They have their "Circle of Support" and in one episode, Bill doesn't back down and they take on the school bully, or another they take over the baseball field. The point is they are empowered at least somewhat through helping each other. Of course, having ties into the "Freaks" (we called them "Stoners" even though some didn't even smoke ganja) further gives them some influence.
Now, it's not perfect, but instead of just giving up, like they are always tempted to do, they find the moxy to do things like replace the keg of party beer with near beer and sit back and watch. Or Bill actually gets to kiss the cutest girl in school after being hoest in a conversation with her, and she actually unexpectedly likes it.
The thing is, general society won't make this happen for us. General society is stupid.
Smart people can figure out how to make a lot of difference and rise up and control things, but socitey doesn't like this, thinks it's unfair (see Kurt Vonnegut's Welcome to the Monkey House) and so they do the one stupid thing they can: ridicule and strong arm. Well, we can beat it. We just have to stop listening to the inane and start helping our own more. I mean, how many shoe salesman my age can really make fun of me about anything? None. How many people can beat my alarm system and attourney? Very few.
Kids need to know they can have POWER over the idots they have to deal with in High School. Sure, it sucks, but so does the workplace etc. Largely because stupid people still make the rules as we fear asserting our power. We've donwe it individually, a lot of us, the next step is to do this for others in our areas.

by admin

This is exactly the type of conversation that drew me here in the first place :)

I have to say though, the "bad design" guys and the geeks that solve it remind me Waaaayyy to much of the movie "Brazil" and I intuitively believe that smart thinking like yours won't be accepted by the system that came up with bad stuff in the first place, but rather fought against. The success of Microsofts marketing inferior product leads me to believe that we must use our intellect to design plans that catchthe masses unaware that we are delivering a superior outcome. As silly as that sounds, I'm resigned to it. We've tried with open source and all geeks pretty much believe the idea. We know Mac at the very least used to be superior. We know Unix and variants network much better. The market shows that intelligence is not valued by the masses. We need to use our intelligence to figure out how to market good stuff effectively for this to work, yet, by nature, most of us couldn't really care less about this aspect for it's own sake.

your second to the last sentence is great:"It would require a fair amount of work on the product design side and a lot of work on the marketing side. "

I'm not sure about the last one though, because quality and price don't seem to lead directly to good sales, evidently because the masses buying can't comprehend or see quality product, and often buy programs based on something other than price.

Extremely good points though :)

by epepke

That's what the last chapter of the book I'm writing is about.

I disagree with Generalist that the MBA's will love an easy, cheap product. The whole history of Microsoft versus everybody else goes against this. MBA's and managers and business owners don't want to save money or make profit for the company. They want to save money and make profit for themselves. They also want to control and dominate people and advance their careers. The easiest way of doing this is giving the impression of being invaluable for making profit and saving money for the company. The worst way of giving that impression in a large corporate environment is by actually doing it.

One thing I'd like to see that would fit into the existing scheme of things but would also encourage good design. Most packages already have a "professional" and a "personal" version. Usually, the "professional" packages have more functionality, which indicates to me that designers haven't grokked it yet.

I think there's a better idea, which I'm going to try out with my current for-money side project. Put out a professional and personal version. Make the personal version much easier to use but have it contain all the features to do everything the professional version does. Make the professional version "professional" by adding useless, overcomplicated interfact doohickeys, unnecessary dialog boxes and wizards, an "acolyte" mode, clip-art of people with ties on, intrusive crashes, frequent for-pay upgrades and help desk support, and a much higher price tag.

If I am right, people will buy the "professional" version because it's professional, and the money will subsidize doing things right.

If I am wrong, people will buy the "personal" version because it's better and the "professional" line can be dropped.

by admin

Thank You :>

Of course the professional version, requiring professionals to operate it, will probably be recommended and/or purchased by the professionals who will then maintain it's superior image. I think a Blue Coloring to the error screen would add a bit more professionalism and enable them to add even more weight to words like "intuitive" when it goes to marketing :>

by generalist

Oh the possibilities with spoofing the idea of having a professional versus personal version.

Start with two 'end-user' types.

One person spends a mint on the professional version and training to use all the bells and whistles. They have their own specialized jargon used when dealing with the product that shows they are superior to others. They also have certification programs and professional magazines that are further 'proof' that the professional version is superior. After all, itcost more and it has the support from all the top management and top magazines.

The other person uses the personal version which lacks all the eye-candy but has all the functionality of the professional version. It also has a well managed user support group that can provide help for specific items and make suggestions for the next edition of the product. And if you want a magazine, try the e-zine that has a new issue every month and a permanent archive.

The life and times of each user is followed during the spoof. Sometimes the users work on similar projects so you can do a running comparison of the costs and benefits of each version. Sometimes they interact with other people, and have to show how well they know the product.

The spoof could serve as a primer on software design from the user's point of view. Packaged properly, with funny illustrations, it might become a book that every package developer would want to read.

And the rest of us could laugh at the story line, especially when we run into those who praise 'professional' versions for the wrong reasons.

by packratt

What is an image? We see them all the time on TV and in Advertisements everywhere. But, do images reflect reality, and are these images elsewhere in our lives?

Sure, there is the need to be social beings and thus adhere to norms to a degree. There is a need at work to be professional, but these things are not what I am talking about.

I am talking about the projection of images we do ourselves out of insecurity. The compulsion to be what we are not and to be what we think others wish us tobe. Many of the socialization difficulties that I see daily are caused by the attempts to edit ourselves when dealing with others in order to conceal what we are.

Are you intelligent? Then project that, do not be ashamed. Are you interested in certain things, then be interested and fear not the others who would deride your interests because they are only interested in the fad that helps the image and have no more real desire.

Do we really want to have an IMAGE that makes us look better tothe masses? Do we want an advertisement that we will have to change for in order to propagate that beast?

OR

Do we just want to be free to be ourselves? Perhaps we should be our own heroes first and thus be true to ourselves and let the sheep be sheep.

by epepke

I think it's a bit of a straw man to say that I think society should be changed, as I don't think that "society" exists. At best it is a statistical result of how a lot of people do. What I am saying is that certain things won't change until a major revolution in culture does happen. This doesn't mean I know how to bring off a major revolution in culture, or that I think it will happen. I'm simply describing a precondition. If you don't think it can happen, that doesn't argue against me.
It's as if I were to say "You can't have free antigravity without violating the conservation of energy and mass." It isn't a counterargument to say, "well, you can't violate conservation of energy and mass, so you're wrong."

Reaching individuals. Fine idea. I do it whenever I can. A community center teaching kids how to test systems destructively. Great idea. I support it. Now, if you knew how to do this without having the local gendarmes come and throw your butt in jail, and in the long run gain support for the culture's anti-intellectual way of thinking, that would be something.

All of these great plans and great ideas sure make us feel good, and like Juanita, we can call people wimps. Hooka-dooka for us. We can be like 60's clowns, marching and singing "We Shall Overcome," while in the meantime the ghettoes get worse and worse. As Tom Lehrer said, "Some people may prefer action, but give me a folk song any old day," and "We all hate poverty, war, and injustice unlike the rest of you squares."

But I'm a bit tired of folk songs as a way to make the singers feel virtuous and good and morally superior.

by admin

I obviously couldn't say it better myself :>

I admire the way you struck the nail.

by admin

Ok, first I am unsure whether or not we are using the same language. Society has several meanings, at least last I checked Webster. One is: "people in general; community." Another is:"People of good breeding, or education." It can also relate to a club or association or other subgroups of the first general group.

Culture on the other hand seems to never mean people in general, but rather, similar to yogurt or cheese culturing, it refers to people who have gone through a process, such as education.

From this it is true that I am using both meanings of Society, when it may be more clear to use culture, however, I believe it is correct in our language currently. I could be wrong though.

Last I knew, stating that your premise or precondition is wrong is valid, yet falls prior to logic and is not an argument. Still, if I were to say:"What's your point" when you state that: "You can't have free antigravity without violating the conservation of energy and mass." it would be valid, just not an argument.

I know you reach individuals as you can too. I can tell in your threads. I may have been too hard edged in the way I talked about the game, which, by the way I think is a good idea.

I'm not singing "We shall overcome".
Ileft Moral Superiority at the bottom of the hill. Moral Superiority is a way to keep the strong weak as long as possible.

by admin

I do think you have a point about me talking about this won't make it happen, and I appreciate that. You are right. It's something to do, not because it's "good" or "right" but because I want to. I am probably not completely sure of myself on this idea and looking for peer support in my postings here, when in reality this is the sort of project I need to have a strong personal vision and strength to pull it off.

I guess I don't see the need for culture to approve all that much. Culture doesn't approve of many things that put many leaders in power, why should the technically strong need approval? Basically, I think we need to learn how to exploit the system and stop caring about whether anyone likes us. The point is, we are potentially the most powerful people in the part of the universe known to us. Technology runs everything, and the common person doesn't understand it, but can't live without it. That's power, pure and simple. It's just like owning all the transportion or water used to be.

I believe we need to band together and exploit our position and then we could re-write and redo whatever we wanted in our cultural present and past that suited us best. Because of this, I believe that getting culture to change is a step in the wrong direction. It's a bit like asking the horse if it would like to wear a saddle and how it could help us learn to put it on.

by packratt

See, most H1b visa holders have aspirations of becomming US citizens and those that do see their future careers as citizens to be going down the drain by the very mechanism that gave them the chance in the first place. Yet, they are powerless to do much about it due to that mechanism. It's not the people who come over who are to blame, it is a corrupt system that was designed to allow for abuse that is the problem that we hate. I would like to see most H1b holders become citizens because then they are not constrained by the H1b indentured servent programme and can demand better compensation as green card holders.

But, this does not deal with the overseas outsourcing which will still drain the compensation rates of those who remain in the states. There must be controls put on the globalization process that will bring foriegn rates back into a competitive range. 1/2-1/3 of our rates is uncompetitive and there is no call for undercutting the competition that much. Bring the cost of doing business overseas back in line with the costs of doing the same business here and let quality be the determining factor.

Let me state that I am lothe to embrace governmental interference but business leaders are not thinking straight by allowing the current undercutting to continue. This will hurt business in the long run as well as the people doing the work. Also, India and the likes will teach other nations the lessons of undercutting competition with cheap labor and the cycle will go against them in the long run as well.

But... I do not see these things happening soon, the lobbyists will not allow it and the governments are in their pockets.

by juanita marquez

I use the term "wimps" in conjunction with the people that mope around commenting on how bad things are and yet can't be bothered to attempt to change them for whatever reason, whether from perceived futility, oppression, laziness, etc. To get anything done - big movement or convincing an individual of their unique worth - one must be willing to take appropriate action. It helps me to sleep at night knowing I've done all I can do about a particular situation, and if it fails, at least I can say I gave it an honest try, and am not haunted by "what ifs". Those of us willing to take steps in the right direction are the ones who will be rewarded for that action, while the rest find reason to fault us, bicker, and whine when they come up against things that don't go their way.

If you really have a problem with ANYTHING, you need to DO SOMETHING CONSTRUCTIVE to change things. Determination and action are key to progress.

by generalist

I'd like to thank everybody for their support in this thread. We have lots of viewpoints and lots of ideas that can, and should result in action. (The word and idea density in this discussion has been phenomenal!)

I might suggest that we take action to make the thread a little more accessible by restarting this thread at the root level. We might want to split it into different areas too. One of those areas might be creating and enhancing the support group we've been talking about. Another would be philosophies on changing the universe, a little bit at a time.

And I would like to consider other thoughts on society and tech types. Things like folk songs and music.

by generalist

If the justice department doesn't have enough people to investigate things, then maybe some other groups need to do it.

You might consider collecting making a master list of who is complaining and who they are complaining about. Names, dates andother items, with memos, photocopies of ad and even e-mail would help.

Hard evidence is needed if you want to avoid royal runarounds. And if the evidence is hard enough, some groups are very good at putting pressure on the justice department, especially if discrimination can be proven.

And if those discriminated against are in the AARP range, that organization has been gaining power for years.

Who knows? Maybe the media will pick it up from both the immigrant side AND the native side.

by generalist

The support group concept is a good one. We have a start of one with the people that have been posting to this discussion. Idea sharing and philosophy honing does wonders for the mind and can uplift the spirits.

Now, where do we go from here? And how do we get others involved with things?

We might try thinking sideways in several areas. For example, there was the idea of supporting LAN parties in youth clubs and the like. (Expose kids to technology, provide mentors and they'll be hooked for life...)

Environments for LAN parties could provide ways for companies to get rid of their older hardware, a topic of a couple of discussions on TechRepublic. They could also give people with certifications a chance to gain experience in a very rough environment, also a topic of discussion. And the added benefit of contributing to the community can result in contacts that could lead to a good social network for possible employment.

The above would be an ideal that would allow tech types to show that they are willing and able to lead others to the fountain of wonders that knowledge of tech can provide. And if we do a good enough job at it, starting at an early age, people will willingly drink from the fountain.

The media would look at us as being people who are trying to help the community. They may not realize that we are selfishly trying to help ourselves by changing society...

by admin

If there is one thing I know about youth culture at this time, it is that it is willing to tattoo itself literally or figuratively in anti-social ways.

Somewhat like Fakir Mussafar was to the piercing movement, the youth can find inspiration fromthose that bear the Yellow Star proudly and still function in society enough to prove it's possible.

If there were ten kids in the order, I'm sure that it would get "Gang Related" status (can you believe the word "Vegan" is considered "Gang Related" in the Utah school system?) So the first trick I was going to try was getting the cybercops involved and declare the LAN parties "Drug-free" zones. With police teams protecting servers in the games or having a "Police Bot" to battle with, they and the kids would probably be better informed about current networking issues. Hopefully this will forstall some of the people concerned by what they don't understand.

Epepke is right though, our public high schools here have security systems including cameras and wire at some of them. They are completely bastions of big brother, perhaps even with the occasional added "Nurse Cratchett" (I doubt I spelled that right) and although it makes it easy to find kids that want an alternative to this, alternatives are often fought by the powers that be. If you're not careful, or even if you are, you will probably feel the wrath of somebody at some time. To me this is just how it is if you're actively doing most anything- someone will be unhappy, but as much as possible I would want to keep the pressure down, it's just easier that way. Historically, you're in good company in jail, but it's harder to get things you want done in there.

Generalist, you're right about why people do this. All community service is selfish at heart. A realization that, to me at least, doesn't necessitate deciding it's somehow "bad".

by epepke

I wonder if circuitry-looking tattoos might become popular. There is still some pseudo-technological, sexually charged cyberpunk. I never had terribly much use for it, but it might have some value.

Selfishness is good. Few things scare me morethan someone on A Mission for Good. About two nanoseconds later you start hearing how many eggs need broken to make the omelette, and it usually involves scientific notation. Sometimes they keep the skulls for flagstones.

I'd like to hear more about your net stuff, admin, and how you managed to pull it off.

by generalist

My family happens to like folk music because you can actually sing along with it. It also can cover a wide range of things from history, social activism and high fantasy.

Unfortunately there isn't much folk music that deals with technology in a positive way. You have to go to obscure places like SF&F conventions and find a good filk circle to make connections. Even then the tech to fantasy ratio can be rather low.

Another option is to be a completist for various artists. For example, the Kingston Trio has several songs that deal with technology. One involves the sinking of a destroyer during World War II. Another the sinking of the Thresher, a nuclear submarine. And Desert Pete does involve the hardware of a water pump combined with a moral message.

I think that Woodie Guthrie had a song about the building of the Grand Coulee dam. And was it Gordon Lightfoot that did "The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" a few years back?

Of course if you stretch the definition of 'folk' you might be able to include Jan and Dean and the Beach Boys when they do their various 'hot car' songs. And Chip Davis of Mannheim Steamroller fame is the author of that trucking song Convoy.

Can anybody add to this list? And does anybodyhave any decent sources for music that you can sing along with that also has technology in it? (Other than Yoda and others from Wierd Al Yankovich...)

by admin

Nine Inch Nails, Moby, Chemical Brothers, DJ Swamp, Tool and a host of other bands deal with technology. I sing with them sometimes. Especially in the car.

In years past, I seem to remember songs by Rush and even VanHalen's Atomic Punk dealing with technology in some way.

Come to think of it, movie soundtracks like Pi, the Matrix, Blade Runner etc. deal with technology, although I'm taking artistic license with the idea that the music itself can express technological themes as well as lyrical content.

Still, as far as folk music proper, I'm not too well versed in it, so I may well be way out of the topic here, if so, pardon me while I burst -into flames :)

by generalist

My family has tended to avoid most of the newer groups, mainly out of habit and a desire to avoid certain types of sex, profanity and violence. As a result, we have probably missed a lot of things.

In fact, our knowledge of a lot of the newer stuff comes from Weird Al Yankovich. We hear his stuff and then start listening for the originals. In many instances, his stuff is better...

I'll keep the groups you mentioned in mind when searching for tech oriented music. It may not be folk, but good music on the right topics is hard to find.

by epepke

Can't think of any technological folk songs. The closest I could come would be the Ballad of Mervyn Schwartz, which is about a midnight subway race.

There are some disadvantages:

1) It was written for a 1963 television program called Omnibus and only survives in tape recordings of crazy people who had Wollensak recorders back then.

2) Only people from New York find it funny.

3) You need about a two-and-one-half octave range to sing it properly.

4) You also need to be able to sing as fast as Danny Kaye, which is faster than Jello Biafra.

Other than that, it's fine.

by admin

than Jello Biafra!

The Dead Kennedies sang about the dangers of technological warfare sometimes, but I can't remember a pure technology song.

I'll have to watch for Danny Kaye :)

by epepke

It's weird; due to an artifact of the software, all these appear to be a response to Juanita.

Anyway, I'm responding to Admin's suggestion that culture need not approve. In theory, I would agree. I don't need cultural aproval. But then again, I'm 40, make money, read a lot of Nietzsche, and can shoot the salivary glands off a fruit fly. Besides, I could get an Isreali passport if I needed one.

The world is different for kids. I don't think that too many adults are quite aware of just how fascist the public school system has become. I'm aware of it because of the explusion of my ex-stepson. I think I would have been able to prevent it had I been a "real parent," but I'm not, and so my legal recourse was limited. (Having no money at the time didn't help.) I think I escaped my public school experience just in time 20 years ago and was probably in the last generation to be able to emerge from it scathed but not destroyed. I've talked about my largely unsuccessful yet vigorous attempts to get something happening in other threads, so I'll spare you here.

I will still encourage a random kid to be individualistic, and if that involves technology, so much the better. However, in the current climate, I know that it's tantamount to tattooing a yellow star on his and/or her forehead.

Maybe it would be different if I lived in a more "enlightened" part of the country, such as California is reputed to be. However, whenever I go to California I am struck by how transparently a slave culture it is, and that's part of it, too. To me, it does little good to encourage individualism but for only those who live in a certain place, have a certain skin color, and a certain L1. I have nothing against elitism, but I dislike hereditary, ineluctable elitism. And I still don't know how to make stuff like this work.

by epepke

Let me tell you what I've failed to do in the past few years, just off the top of my head:

1) Mentored a couple of high school kids to do a Java animated model of the solar system. This wasn't a complete failure, because it worked, but the two already came from a privileged background.

2) Mentored some middle-school kids to do a game based on the digestive tract. Failure because I was called in too late on the project at a point where the kids couldn't get it done in time, so I had to do it. I felt terrible about this.

3) Started developing a virtual human physiology exhibit/training program. Had a bunch of good people, including a bigwig in the local science museum, a pioneer of minimally invasive heart surgery, etc. After awhile, some local women's group offered to donate 15,000 if we made it on the reproductive system. We said OK. Some pederast priest objected to it, and so it all fell apart. The bigwig was fired.

4) With the dean of the school of criminology, starting to develop a system to teach at-risk kids how to develop computer games. A modest funding request passed the state legislature and was scratched by Lawton "Prozac Boy" Chiles.

5) With the local Marine Institute, a sort of special school for convicted criminals, a project to develop computer experiences with a marine theme. Ended pretty much when somebody burned the whole place down.

6) Here in Atlanta, trying as hard as I can to get to do guest lectures in local schools. No bites, no permission.

7) Quite a few class groups in the old days, but eventually didn't get to do them any more.

It's not enough to be willing to do something; it also has to work. I keep asking about ways that work, and nobody so far has suggested any. This leads me to believe, prima facie, that nobody knows very much. This is fine, but in that context an admonition to do something is empty.

by bill-beaton

Being from Canada, devoting a fair amount of resources to supporting the US southwest, I see almost all of the same pressures(?) up here, and believe that a lot of them are totally phony.

Case in point: I was recently asked to help fill a job order for an administrator. Required 2 years Solaris 2.8, 2 years Windows 2000, 3 years Oracle 8i, 3 years SQL-Server 7.

I'm sure that maybe a dozen folks world-wide who participated in alpha and beta programs could qualify, but as a required skill set for a project????

I'm seeing many requests for skill sets that are just as ridiculous; if the inability to fill this type of request is widespread, then just maybe the skill shortage is really in the ranks of HR and PM staff, eh?