Discussion Locked

Scott McClellan: "The Iraq war was not necessary."

0 helpful
154 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/22425001/vp/24852326#24852326

This makes bugging the opposing political party's convention or banging an intern seem like kiddy pranks. Based on just the few excerpts I've seen on the tube this morning, any member of Congress who doesn't vote to impeach now is going to be permanently unemployable.

As Tim Russert said, "This is not moveon.org, this is someone who was serving in the White House for seven years."

154 replies

by jdclyde

Unfortunately, the video isn't starting for me, but as for impeachment, even if they had the votes, it would be seen by anyone with a brain as a waste of time to impeach him with six months to go.

Some of us remember that impeachment does not mean removal from office, so will be see as a purely political move and a major waste of everyones time.

Sure, it will give Bush haters a woodie, but will accomplish nothing.

Will try the video later.

by $$$$$$$$$$

George Herbert Walker Bush saw to it that outing a CIA agent is a federal offense. He described it as treason.

Lying to voters, or even just stretching the truth, in order to have a war in Iraq, is more important than issues which previously have resulted in impeachment, by much more than you're willing to admit, or able to comprehend.

by jdclyde

if he had a year or two, they they would go for it.

It would be symbolic at most, political at worst if done now. By the time the proceeding was done, his term would already be up. Something you seem unwilling to comprehend?

Outing of a CIA agent, who was not outted by Libby or Rove, and was not undercover? There was no crime, that is why there were no charges EVER for the outting.

by delbertpgh

Impeachment is tough to make happen, for legal reasons.

First, you're only committing treason if you help an enemy of the United States in wartime. If you screw up, then that naturally helps your enemy, but that isn't the kind of help which is grounds for treason. You have to establish that there was intent to aid the enemy.

Second, the Constitution allows impeachment for "high crimes and misdemeanors," not for high screw-ups. If GWB decided to order an simultaneous attacks on China and Russia in his last eight months in office, would it be a crime? It would be criminally stupid, sure, but is it a real crime?

Third, we tolerate a lot of lying by our politicians. Pick me a month in the term of any President, JFK or Roosevelt or Lincoln, when they weren't engaged in floating some ridiculous pretense designed to get a bill passed or to build a colalition or to disadvantage a foe. Would we be able to suddenly make political lying a crime on the order of perjury (which wasn't successful when they tried Clinton) or conspiracy (Nixon) or bribery (Agnew)?

by $$$$$$$$$$

Most members of both parties in Congress have, collectively, been less than satisfactory in fulfilling their obligation of oversight of the Executive Branch. But timing alone is not a valid excuse for not impeaching the President, based on a top aide's public testimony. Tucker Carlson's rant, that all these accusations implicate McClelland, as usual lead me to an opposite conclusion from Tucker: Why would McClellan take the enormous risk of making those accusations, if they aren't true?

[around 2:00]

by jck

All I can say is...over the months of trying to tell you all that Cheney and Libby and Rove and the others were up to no good...

I TOLD YOU SO!!! :D

If you can't hate that a president let a CIA leak go until it was discovered...surely you can hate that a president's action let over 4,000 Americans be killed over a big bunch of fabricated BS.

Sure...starting impeachment would be seen as a political move...by Bush's pundits.

But if they prove he knew about the fabrication and lies about things happening in Iraq, he should be held accountable for lying to America just like Bill Clinton was.

A lie is a lie...whether it's done in front of investigators or not.

by notsochiguy

I think the war was ill-conceived and timed, however, coming out after the fact, when trying to stump for book sales, seems to me to be as egregious an act as anything he's detailing--war profiteering at its worst (someone else can take all the blame, I can spill the beans and reap the $$$).

Also, it seems as though this guy is already being received in a positive light for speaking out. WHY??? The same people that bashed Jose Canseco will no doubt heap praise on McClellan for essentially doing the same thing: laying in the weeds like a snake, waiting to pounce on an economic opportunity.

Everything he says may eventually be proven true, but his credibility is exceptionally questionable, in my opinion.

Grain of salt....hrrrmph...more like an entire bottle to get through his stuff.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Here are some pundits discussing similar concerns to yours about the timing. As usual, they say some things I find interesting, but omit what I would consider most interesting.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/22425001/vp/24857424#24857424

I do see your point, but the way I see it, the campaign to discredit him would be trivially easy for the White House while he was working there, or shortly after. The book release coinciding with the tail end of the primaries would be suspicious, except that Rove and Libby lied about their roles in the Plame case, and other matters. I can look at this either of two ways.

First, he's merely a disgruntled former employee, making up everything. If so, he could get his pants sued off for libel.

Second, he's disgruntled for very valid reasons, and timed the release of this book so as to be most damaging to an Administration he holds in the most genuine moral contempt.

I suspect the latter, but I reserve judgment until I've read the book.

Like jdclyde said, impeachment does not [necessarily] mean removal from office, it means an investigation of the President. The charges are serious; impeachment is undoubtedly warranted, to determine whether they're true.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I do see your point, but the way I see it, the campaign to discredit him would be trivially easy for the White House while he was working there, or shortly after. [b]Taking a couple years to put his notes, sources and footnotes in unassailable order is a perfectly reasonable measure. He would probably have been foolish to do anything else[/b]. The book release coinciding with the tail end of the primaries would be suspicious, except that Rove and Libby lied about their roles in the Plame case, and other matters. I can look at this either of two ways.

[the part in [b]bold[/b] was intended to be included in the previous post, but I forgot to add it]

by notsochiguy

I can see the point about trying to ensure that the administration doesn't continue (in the guise of McCain). I would hope that is the case other than just the pursuit of monetary gain.

However, I think you'll soon start hearing (and maybe rightfully so...who knows) the following:
IF he did have evidence of the cover ups
and
IF he had come forth sooner
IS it possible that more American soldiers would be alive today?

I'm not saying that is the case (actually, I don't feel it is)...but I think it is a valid question to ask.

Of all the ways he could have shared the information (Gone to the media, started a web site/campaign, spoken with the UN, etc), he chooses to do it in the one of the few ways that will bring a profit.

I don't know...I still find it questionable morally; even if it ultimately does bring about some good (ala the Canseco book).

by mjd420nova

The invasion was warranted by the need to insure that Sadamm didn't use the chemical weapons we knew he had against any other Mideast countries. We know he had the hardware from the inventories that were taken at the end of the Gulf War. Unfortunately we telegraphed our invasion intentions and he had time to ship all the hardware to Jordan and Syria. As a result we were unable to locate any of the previous inventories at the documented locations. Luckily Jordan and Syria have not dared to use those weapons against our troops. Continued diligence at the borders has prevented them from trying to return the weapons components to the insurgents now coming into the country from other locations such as Iran.

by ic-it

He did use WMD against Iran (and we knew that then, while Rumsfield was trying to convince him to allow the pipeline across Iraq).
We know he had old stockpiles of WMD, because we provided them. We also know that a lot was destroyed. Why would Jordan get involved?
Really unbelievable that IED materials are freely flowing in, but that they wouldn't take the chance with WMD. Please!!!

by oz_media

Or is it something you read in a storybook?

YEs, we knoew Saddam had teh weapons we left behind, BUT many those shells were found. Nearing teh end of the investigation, when Bush cut it dhort and removed inspectors due to invasion plans, they has uncovered one such stach of UNUSED warheads. The warheads were said to be unused and useless for future munitions, furthermore incapable of intercontinental attack.

No you didn't go there to stop war IN the Middle East, unless you didn't pay attention to your media before the invasion, it was to save your OWN a$$es, not Iraqi's.

But those are old discussions we've had many time here already, if you are on a different page, go back and search them out to put in your two cents,

by delbertpgh

Sorry, it's time to get real. If there had been an ongoing chemical weapons industry in Iraq at the time of the war, we'd have found lots of evidence. We looked hard for it. We couldn't find it. The idea that it must have been real, and that it got smuggled out to Syria without anybody being able to detect it, or was made invisible by magic unicorns, flies in the face of all evidence and reason.

The only cause for thinking there were such weapons in the first place was flawed intelligence, caused by us not having spies in the right places to tell us what was happening for the prior ten years in Iraq. We made up ideas, based on capabilities and character sketches, rather than real evidence. Also, when you're in the intelligence business, you have to produce the kind of intelligence your customers (the President, the Pentagon, the NSA) expect to see, and they all expected to see chemical and nuclear programs in some state of continuation.

Plus, in case you haven't figured it out yet, we didn't go into Iraq to suppress WMD. The WMD argument made sense to the American people, so that's why the American President used it to sell his war.

by oz_media

The President's favorite gameshow.

Now by reserving all your crops and raising the price of grain goods throughout North America, he can start in on his hissing cokroaches spiel and use them to scare Americans into eating less in order to save grains.

"For every loaf of bread you eat and every ear of corn you barbeque you buy you will be furthering mankinds reliance on the hissing cockroach!

Now with Canada supplying a great deal of Americas grains, he will have reason (in his little tiny mind) to try and occupy Canada.

Good luck with that one, George.

by fregeus

Is the only consequence of impeachment removal from office? Aren't there any other type of punishment if found guilty?

They could always go for it to put a bigger negative spin on the republicans to assure a democrat victory in November. Politics is still politics.

TCB

by jdclyde

as William Jefferson Clinton showed us.

AFTER they are impeached, THEN is the vote to remove. He will already be out of office before they could remove him, no matter how badly they would want to, and regardless of if it is politically motivated or not.

A waste of time and effort, as well as one big distraction from more important issues. Intentionally so? You bet.

by fregeus

...but I was wondering if there were other type of consequences if found, after the impeachment, guilty. I mean, if being thrown out of office the only thing that can happen, that amounts to immunity for the person who occupies the function.

Does the president have immunity from any procecution except removal from office?

TCB

by jdclyde

do not apply to political ads. Funny how that works.

This is just a pipe dream that AB has been sucking on for a long time, and is never going to happen. Someone writing a book will not change that.

If you listen to the video (that I finally got to work, must have been busy because of lunch time) he NEVER said "lie". IF he DID say lie, then he will have to be able to back it up. I think he intentionally backed his language down to keep from being liable.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]First, you're only committing treason if you help an enemy of the United States in wartime. If you screw up, then that naturally helps your enemy, but that isn't the kind of help which is grounds for treason. You have to establish that there was intent to aid the enemy.[/i]

I don't believe anybody in the White House had the [b]intent[/b] to aid Al Qaida, but if they knew or had reason to believe that invading Iraq would lead to less stability, not more, and backtrack the pursuit of bin Laden, then the criminal stupidity we all take for granted these days might in fact be a real crime.

I don't know. I plan to make this my last comment in this thread until I've read the book, but I don't know what other interesting points I'll read, and want to answer, in the meantime.

by bukeypb

911, terrorist, starting wars, its all about us giving up all our freedoms and rights on our own free will to let the government have more control over our lives. Do you think we would give up our freedoms and rights own our own? Its only going to get worse. They are working on a one world goverment right now and with everyone running scared we are reacting just the way they want us to, allowing full control of our lives.
I just see bible prophecy coming to pass.

by delbertpgh

Prophecy has never been much of a guide to anything. Nor has secret information, sets of little known facts, or conspiracies of large networks of people who place an abstract group interest above all else. Nobody particularly wants to take your freedoms and rights, as though that were some objective in itself, like stealing your sterling silver.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]911, terrorist, starting wars, its all about us giving up all our freedoms and rights on our own free will to let the government have more control over our lives. Do you think we would give up our freedoms and rights own our own? Its only going to get worse. They are working on a one world goverment right now and with everyone running scared we are reacting just the way they want us to, allowing full control of our lives.[/i]

Rather than a conspiracy theory, I see domestic wiretapping outside of FISA as an attempt at CYA after ignoring Richard Clarke, even after his August 6, 2001 memo. The result, loss of liberty, is the same, which is one reason why marginalizing "conspiracy theories" offends me. Another reason is that 19 suicidal maniacs, calculating enough to highjack four aircraft [b]with box-cutters[/b] and missing one of their guys, and so stupid to leave the trail of evidence that they did, seems like a conspiracy theory itself. So all the "911truth" story lines are just alternative conspiracy theories. When the popular narrative is of a global religious conspiracy, to dismiss other possibilities as "outlandish" or "conspiracy theories" is about as disingenuous as one can get.

[i]I just see bible prophecy coming to pass.[/i]

Could be. I haven't read that recently, but I can see the Constitution being ignored and interpreted away.

I've always had trouble with assertions of the form "such-and-so is equivalent to the 4 horsemen, and that yonder is the Mark of the Beast." I do clearly remember that no person is to know the time of the Rapture, so I'm not able to take seriously any claims of such knowledge. I take the whole thing as a very graphic warning to be on one's best behavior, 'cuz you never know. Nothing more than that.

by mojodelirium

is nothing more than continued confirmation of what we already know. Makes for good copy, though. Oooh, they'll be talking about this for two or three days. Keeps the important stuff off the front page, you know.

What's interesting has been the White House's surprised response. Don't they know Scotty has a book to sell?

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i] McClellan's insider tome is nothing more than continued confirmation of what we already know. Makes for good copy, though. Oooh, they'll be talking about this for two or three days. Keeps the important stuff off the front page, you know.[/i]

I started this discussion because I think the fact that this comes from such an "insider" source tends to validate previous reports which were dismissed as speculation and fabrication based in various ulterior motives, many of which cannot be applied to Scott McClellan. They can still try to apply the "Bush hater" epithet, and "disgruntled" seems to be the first hint of doing exactly that. But McClellan's documented record of extreme loyalty makes that more questionable than somebody like, say, me or many of the sources I'd typically cite on the subjects of Bush, the Iraq war, Valerie Plame etc. I am a proud Bush-hater, and I tend to cite sources that are at least very critical of him. McClellan hasn't been very critical of Bush and friends publicly, and the circumstances of his resignation suggest that any grievances that he has are very valid, not concocted [b]because[/b] he's "disgruntled." He was quite gruntled, until he was made the fall guy for others' mistakes or crimes.

http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2006/04/20060419-1.html

by mojodelirium

I dunno...the media could talk about the John Warner Defense Authorization Act of 2007 or the Military Commissions Act.

Maybe, the media could discuss why senior citizens have to choose between medicine, gas, or food.

Maybe, they should ask why the government(states included) have been selling off and privatizing our national assets?

How about the state of corporate welfare and why taxpayers are footing the bill?

Of course, there's that severely decaying infrastructure.

But you're right...we need Scott McClellan to confirm that George Bush has been force feeding us a giant fecal hoagie.

It's curious that McClellan decided at this time he was disgruntled. Couldn't he have relayed this information a few months ago? How about being disgruntled during the time he was repeating the lies?

by jdclyde

http://www.senate.gov/reference/reference_index_subjects/Censure_vrd.htm

And a sitting President can NOT be brought up on charges for this while in office, but could after he is out of office. Any FUTURE President would not allow the office to be dishonored like that and would always grant a [b]full pardon[/b] (Richard Nixon).

Jimmy Carter is the only President in history to ever break the honor of the office by an ex-President bad talking a sitting or ex-President.

There has been talk for several years of a "world court", but they are a joke and are NOT recognized as a valid authority to charge Bush or any other US President. Nothing in our Constitution allows the recognition of a higher authority over our own Supreme Court. (hense the name).

by jdclyde

is when we start to run out of ice cubes for our scotch. THAT is when you will be assimilated....

B-)

by delbertpgh

If impeached by the House (the indictment phase) and found guilty by the Senate (the trial phase), they the President is out of a job. Nothing more than that. Congress does not have its own police or enforcement powers.

It does not mean that other suits by Federal prosecutors could not be brought against him on criminal grounds. The President is immune from criminal prosecution only for as long as he is President. He is not immune from civil prosecution at any time, as was established with Bill Clinton, who was sued by Paula Jones; his lies during the deposition phase of the Jones suit were what got him impeached.

A President can pardon anybody, including a previous President, as Gerald Ford did with Richard Nixon. It is unclear whether a President can pardon himself, and thus by his own action make himself forever immune from criminal prosecution. That would have to be established by the Supreme Court.

by delbertpgh

This is a democracy. That means a lot of uninformed and incurious amateurs get consulted every few on the adequacy of their leaders, as to whether they would like to see them stay or go. It's the worst system of government there is, except for all the others, as Churchill may have said.

As citizens in a democracy, we depend on politicians (whom most of us pay only the rarest attention to) to tell us what matters and frame issues. They have to assemble voters into majority blocs not only to win elections, but to make major national issues possible to act on. In a free state, with a free economy and free movement of peoples, no law that is deeply opposed will work satisfactorily or for long. So, we listen to politicians to tell us stories about the country. Like any good storyteller, they have to improve the story to get us to buy it; like children who listen to stories, we often enjoy being lied to. That's human nature in a democracy.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"As citizens in a democracy, we depend on politicians (whom most of us pay only the rarest attention to) to tell us what matters and frame issues."

Do you rely on politicans to tell you what matters and frame issues? I don't.

I think that attitude is a problem. It's our democracy, making it our responsibility to be informed, hold politicians accountable for their lies, bungles, cheats, and thievery. If we don't do that, we deserve whatever problems we have.

typo

by boxfiddler Hot topic

you want the press to keep us informed as to issues that affect us all and our hard-earned money?

Goofy idealist. ;)

by mojodelirium

indeed, much of the press operates like a public relations firm.

It's all about access and if you don't play ball, you don't get access. No access makes the corporate owners (Disney, GE, etc) very nervous. You can't scoop the competition if you ain't in the room.

In order to maintain a compliant populace, you must control the flow of information.

Of course, no access translates into lower ad revenues. Lower revenues lead to stockholder revolt/nasty board meetings. Which, in turn, leads to management turnover. Then, you hire someone a little less idealistic and more profit motivated.

In the end, dogs sleep with cats, night turns into day, the Mississippi flows northward, and yacht sales decrease.

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by $$$$$$$$$$

I hope McClellan has more than $64,000 in the bank; I don't expect him to have any source of income other than book sales any time soon. I'd compare publication of that book to what poker players call going "all in" -- he bet all his chips on public opinion not only keeping down on George Walker Bush, but swinging away from the failure of the war effort to disapproval of the decision to go to war in the first place. Come to think of it, I recall reading that exact progression of public opinion in [i]Once Upon a Distant War[/i] by William Prochnau regarding the Vietnam police action, then war.

Nobody, as far as I know, tried to minimize that as a "comma" in history books, when it proved a greater challenge than expected. Instead, the propaganda angle at that time was the VC v. US death count, IIRC. My guess is that history will look less kindly on George Walker Bush than I do, and worse still on Cheney and Rove.

Second:
[i]Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?[/i]

Do you really think it's necessarily either of those cases? I don't believe changing his story [b]necessitates[/b] any dissembling on his part. It's strongly implied, but not necessarily so.

If I was planning to publish a statement that the President had been less than fully honest, I'd be darned certain my ducks were all in a tidy row. Wouldn't you?

Putting myself in his place [repugnant!], if I learned that all I had been saying publicly for about 3 years fell somewhere between exaggeration and falsehoods that fall short of the legal definition of lies by a hair's breadth, but that all or most of my audience believed me, [b]and[/b] that those that did not were for the most part being [b]very effectively[/b] marginalized in public discourse as tin foil hat-wearing conspiracy theorists, I'd very seriously question my own credibility in taking their side [b]despite knowing that that side is the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth[/b]. In that case, I'd be inclined to doubt my ability to convince [b]anybody[/b] of what I "now" know to be the truth. Wouldn't you?

I have not read the book yet, nor followed Scott McClellan's story until very recently, so I'm just asking.

by jdclyde

on how Bush haters are more than willing to take him at his word... now that he is saying something they WANT to hear.

I would bet most Bush haters were not as big of fans over the last seven years?

by delbertpgh

George W. Bush, that is.

As for McClellan, who can say? When you're press secretary to the President, you have to carry his crap in a bucket every day, and sooner or later you screw your integrity by putting forth stories that are unworthy of the President's high office, except you do it because the President is too important to allow to be damaged by telling his own lies or spreading his own smears. A guy who does this for a living probably feels the need to explain himself after he's done with the job.

I tend to believe McClellan, because it all sounds like exactly the sort of stuff Mr. Bush would do. Of course, I lost all faith in GWB a long time ago, so I'm used to seeing him that way.

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by $$$$$$$$$$

He pushed "that button, 'Submit Post,'" one time.

Then, he pushed the refresh button 34 times when greeted by the standard daily server error message. It took longer than usual to get back on its feet, I guess.

by av .

I haven't read his book, but did see him on the Today show. My gut tells me Scott McClellan is telling the truth about the Bush Administration, but his motives are disingenuous in both cases. He looks like the good guy, but is he really if you take a good look? First off, why release this book now? What does he have to gain? We already know about the CIA leak case, there were no WMDs, etcetera. He's truly capitalizing on being an insider and will make lots of money. I'm sure he feels torn too, because he knows he is now an outcast with people he's known for years. How can you do that and look yourself in the mirror the next day? That is the ultimate deception in my book because he never said anything. Still, he doesn't care because he's going to be rich. Somewhere in there is a Joe Wilson inspiration.

AV

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by $$$$$$$$$$

I hope McClellan has more than $64,000 in the bank; I don't expect him to have any source of income other than book sales any time soon. I'd compare publication of [i]What Happened[/i] to what in poker is called going "all in" -- he bet all his chips on public opinion of George Walker Bush not only staying low, but shifting in its fundamental assessment away from the failure of the war effort to achieve its original stated objectives, to disapproval of the decision to go to war in the first place -- disapproval of the stated objectives themselves, based on disbelief in them.

Come to think of it, I recall reading that very progression of public opinion in [i]Once Upon a Distant War[/i] by William Prochnau regarding the Vietnam police action, then war. First, the embedded journalists were disgusted by inefficiencies. Only after several years of the quagmire did they gradually realize, then communicate to the readers stateside, that the entire premise of the necessity of the war was misguided.

Nobody, as far as I know, tried to minimize that as a "comma" in history books, when it proved a greater challenge than expected. Instead, the propaganda angle at that time was the VC v. US death count, IIRC. My guess is that history will look even less kindly on George Walker Bush than I do, and worse still on Cheney and Rove.

Second:
[b][i]Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?[/b][/i]

Do you really think it's necessarily either of those cases? I don't believe changing his story necessitates any dissembling on his part. It's strongly implied, but not necessarily so, and the circumstances are nothing if not extenuating.

If I was planning to publish a statement that the President had been less than fully honest, I'd be darned certain my ducks were all in a tidy row. Wouldn't you?

Putting myself in his place [repugnant!], if I learned that all I had been saying publicly for about 3 years fell somewhere between exaggeration and falsehoods that fall short of the legal definition of lies by a hair's breadth, but that all or most of my audience believed me, and that those that did not were for the most part being [b]very effectively[/b] marginalized in public discourse as tin foil hat-wearing conspiracy theorists, I'd very seriously question my own credibility; I'd be very hesitant to take their side [b]despite knowing that that side is the truth[/b], the whole truth and nothing but the truth. In that case, I'd be inclined to doubt my ability to convince [b]anybody[/b] that what I recently learned is in fact the truth, and what I had been saying, [b]and convincing the vast majority to believe[/b] is not and never was the truth. Wouldn't you?

I have not read the book yet, nor followed Scott McClellan's story until very recently, so I'm just asking, not arguing.

by cactus pete

What would make you think either or both or neither?

The man was a press secretary. He was told what to say - that was his job. Some people would believe that any press secretary would necessarily be dishonest and disingenuous while on the job.

From what I've heard about the book, much of is is praise for Bush - he states that it was a failure of advise, largely. I don't know for sure, similar to Rove (yikes) I would wait until someone else bought me a copy of the book before I read it.

But listening to the various reports on the book, it seems the man was trying to do his job then, and is trying to do his duty now.

by maxwell edison

I don't think the White House press secretary is given explicit instructions and/or verbatim answers to questions. Who would be the person to tell the press secretary what to say? I'm sure there's the usual strategy sessions between advisors and such, so everyone can advance an issue with consistency and without contradiction. But explicit instructions on what to say? I think not.

The job of the press secretary is to fully understand the president's policy positions and provide answers to any question that might be asked. He/she has to actually think for the president when confronted with any kind of question - many intended to make suggestion, set-up, or blind-side - and provide a quick answer to anything thrown at him/her. The press secretary often sits-in on policy discussions to gain that understanding. And in order to present that policy to the public in a convincing way, one would think that the person would be a believer in that policy.

If there's major policy decisions being made that a person disagrees with, it would behoove everyone involved for that person to remove himself from the administration. Can you imagine me, for example, being Al Gore's press secretary? How could any reasonably principled person help advance a policy that he/she does not believe in?

I don't think any person in the President's inner-circle is there to simply [i]do a job[/i]. Those kinds of people don't have jobs, but rather they follow their passion to try and make a significant difference and advance an agenda.

My comments apply to any president of any party and any administration.

By the way, it took me a while to figure out who you were ... or used to be ... or whatever.

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by maxwell edison

Was he dishonest and disingenuous when he worked in the White House, or is he dishonest and disingenuous now?

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]I think that attitude is a problem. It's our democracy, making it our responsibility to be informed, hold [b]politicians[/b] accountable for their lies, bungles, cheats, and thievery.[/i]

If the citizens and the politicians are not one and the same, you're talking about a republic, not a democracy. It's my opinion that the United States will benefit from more democratic processes and fewer republican posts, or fail.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

The US is a republic. My mistake in using the word democracy interchangeably.

edit: I have a problem with the notion that politicians are expected to lie and that it is tolerated, as well as the notion that others (politicians or otherwise) are depended on to 'tell us what matters'. Have we no minds of our own or is it just that we're not supposed to use them?

ermm... did I ask that?

by maxwell edison

I thought there was a glitch and the message wasn't posting. As it turns out, there was a glitch because it posted multiple times. I didn't think it would post multiple identical messages.

Sorry 'bout that.

by delbertpgh

I was trying to make posts and update my profile, and over and over, it kept going to some "unable to locate this URL" page. Around 11 PM or midnight, I guess. Sometimes it would work okay and then screw up the next minute.

Guess it kept posting and giving you error messages, and you kept trying.

by maxwell edison

The first three or four clicks on the submit button were done with several seconds in-between. The last thirty, however, were done in a rapid-fire manner out of sheer frustration. (Gee, I didn't realize I was THAT frustrated!)

by jck

[i]Outing of a CIA agent, who was not outted by Libby or Rove, and was not undercover? There was no crime, that is why there were no charges EVER for the outting.[/i]

There may have been no charges pressed, but there was a criminal act.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligence_Identities_Protection_Act

Read it and weep.

So I wonder why if Rove and Libby both were involved...that no one was charged?

hmmmmm...

by jdclyde

but next time, don't back yourself up with a wiki page that is incorrect.

She was NOT undercover at the time.

Libby was NOT the one that outed her.

The prosecutor KNEW that, but continued to investigate anyways? Ask yourself why.

Libby NEVER got charged with outing the agent because he didn't do it.

NO ONE was charged with it, because she was not undercover, so no crime was committed in the first place.

by jck

True...it never said "undercover"...it said "covert".

She was covert, as she was working for a CIA front company...and it was at the time that her name was leaked.

So not only did the leak endanger her, but it also endangered other agents who worked there.

CIA agents don't have to be on spy missions in the eastern block to be "covert" or "undercover".

Was she a covert agent at the time? Well, according to Congressional testimony she was, according to a Washington Post article from 2007:

[i]"Plame's testimony on the covert nature of her job was buttressed by a statement that Waxman read at the hearing's opening which, he said, was approved by Gen. Michael V. Hayden, the CIA's director. The statement said that Plame worked in a covert capacity at the time of Novak's column and that her employment status was classified under an executive order."[/i]

Straight from the CIA director's own statement. She was covert.

In fact, someone you work with...or who works at the bank your account is at...or the guy at McDonalds making your Big Mac...could be a covert CIA agent.

And if that Wikipedia page is wrong, I suggest you go read the subchapters at the Cornell Law School website. It's very valid in it's statement that:

[i]The Intelligence Identities Protection Act of 1982 (Pub.L. 97-200, 50 U.S.C. ? 421?426) is a United States federal law that makes it a federal crime to intentionally reveal the identity of an agent whom one knows to be in or recently in certain covert roles with a U.S. intelligence agency.[/i]

So, you're wrong about that too.

I'll get you other sources at a later time on Brewster Jennings & Associates...and how it was not false that it was a CIA front company.

And...can you tell me again...who was reported that the leak was from again in the Bush administration? Hm? Care to repeat that name?

Here...let me say it for you: I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby.

Need proof? From the same Washington Post article from 2007:

[i]"A few months after the Iraq war began in 2003, Plame was drawn into a maelstrom as the White House struggled with the stirrings of opposition to the invasion. In July 2003, an op-ed column by Wilson accused the president of distorting the findings of the Niger mission: that there was no evidence Iraq had recently sought to buy yellowcake uranium there for a nuclear weapons program. On July 14, 2003, Plame was identified in a syndicated column by Robert D. Novak.

Testimony at Libby's trial made it clear that Cheney and other senior administration officials and their aides worked aggressively to discredit Wilson. Prosecutors said Libby, then Cheney's chief of staff, and other officials told journalists about Plame to insinuate that Wilson was chosen for the CIA mission because of nepotism."[/i]

Read it...prosecutors giving statement in court said: [i]Prosecutors said Libby, then Cheney's chief of staff, and other officials told journalists about Plame to insinuate that Wilson was chosen for the CIA mission because of nepotism.[/i]

Libby and other officials.

That says it all. He outed her, along with others. It's court record.

You're wrong on that too.

Finally...saying he didn't do it because he was never charged with it...is like saying you never speed because a cop didn't write you a ticket.

I guess if I worked for the Vice-President, I could get sent to jail for lying too instead of a treasonous criminal act.

Guess it pays to kiss the right butt, huh? lol ;)

by jamesrl

The press secretary's role, and I am familiar with it from personal experience in the Canadian context as well, is to be the spokesperson for the White House, and as such they often follow directions from the Chief of Staff and/or the Communications Director.

I think its entirely possible for the press secretary to NOT know all the details at the time - you don't generally tell the press secretary things you don't want the press to know. It is possible that Scott learned some things after he left that changed his opinion or impression.

And I don't think the press secretary or any member of the administration has to agree "personally" with everything the administration does or promotes. But they do have to make a decision - if they disagree they decide to either go with the majority and be a team player, or chose to leave the administration. On smaller issues you might do the former, on larger issues, the latter.

One would think that if Scott really had major objections at the time to the war strategy, he would have left. Perhaps his impressions were based on insufficient information, perhaps his hindsight is better than his insight while he was on the job, I don't claim to know. I don't know if Scott knows either.

I can't imagine you being Al Gore's press secretary, but what about say Ron Paul - would you agree with every single thing he supports? Some compromises come with virtually every job, even that of president. Chosing when to compromise and when not to is easier said than done. I do know from my own time in politics that you have to balance the plusses and minuses - sometimes you stay hoping to be able to influence the admin from the inside, sometimes you hsve to decide that you aren't able to and you leave.

I worked for a Member of Parliament (MP) who had some personal opinions that were far from mine. We didn't agree on capital punishment or abortion, and he held some radical views on corporal punishment (cut the hands off thieves). But he was not in the position to change party policy on those issues. And those were not issues at play in the country at the time. So I could in good conscience write some of his communications to his constituents and talk about the policies that were important at the time.

If he had asked me to write about capital punishement though, I would have not had an issue taking his inputs and writing from his perspective. The Press secretary though, has to do more than write or speak, he has to sell.

I was working for a MP, who belonged to the party I supported. On balance, I'd certainly be more comfortable supporting him than a member from another political party. But thats not to say I was in an equivalent position, and the higher you go, the more you need to be aligned with the will of the administration.

James

by jdclyde

it is reasonable to expect that you would have at least voiced your opinion about things you are against, not keep quiet until your book comes out.

by jamesrl

To be honest, here is how it would play out.

Scott tells Chief of Staff, I disagree on the war, Chief of staff says, keep it quiet and leave quietly. Make a fuss and no one will hire you. Scott leaves and waits till public opinion is on his side and then writes the book, knowing it won't harm his career.

Judge for yourself whether thats ethical or not.

Personally, if it was important enough to leave for, you probably could make a statement shortly after you leave to say, we agree to disagree on the war.

James

by maxwell edison

I'm sure your take on it is better than mine. As close as I've even been to a president and press secretary was watching the West Wing!

Could I be Ron Paul's press secretary, you ask, agreeing with every single thing he supports? Well, I could probably work in a Ron Paul administration, even though I don't agree with him on all issues - but I don't think it would work too well; his libertarian views are too extreme, especially when it comes to our current state of war, so my stay would probably be short-lived. Fred Thompson, on the other hand.......

I'm not suggesting than an administration should be filled without any dissenters. Disagreement can be good, as long as core principles aren't in conflict. In the case of Iraq and the people in the Bush administration, I would guess that there was near unanimity on defining the enemy and acknowledging the state of war in which we were (are) engaged, even though there were people who thought that Iraq should not serve as one of the fronts in the war. (Some would have preferred Iran!)

by delbertpgh

"Do you rely on politicans to tell you what matters and frame issues? I don't," and "It's our democracy, making it our responsibility to be informed, hold politicians accountable for their lies, bungles, cheats, and thievery." Hmm. You sound like a very responsible fellow.

Sad for you, everybody else in our democracy (or republic) has a vote exactly equal to yours. A great many people who take the trouble to vote don't bother taking hours every week, for the years between elections, to identify their values and learn the issues; they are perhaps more susceptible to political snake oil than you. That means that our leaders' political skill, and especially their rhetorical ability to color an issue, is crucial to your satisfaction in our political process. Your prosperity in a democracy does depend, after all, on how all those other guys vote.

In fact, since people like you, me, JDClyde, Maxwell Edison, and Absolutely all have equal votes, and agree on next to nothing, it would take a certain political skill to draw a line in the right place so that a majority of us could find enough we value in common, that we can support a political act that makes such a distinction. And building a coalition, even though it might live for just one vote, involves building up some distinctions and blurring others. It could even include raising a false issue, so that the more rowdy part of the electorate would enjoy yelling and complaining about it. (Immigration comes to mind.) Tell me how different that is from lying.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

"It could even include raising a false issue, so that the more rowdy part of the electorate would enjoy yelling and complaining about it. (Immigration comes to mind.) Tell me how different that is from lying."

by jdclyde

his years of silence about his "issues" speaks louder than his book does.

The people that are drooling over this book are the same people that believed "the story was true, just the supporting evidence was fake". Is supports what they believe and want to hear.

Interesting how he is suppose to have mentioned in his book about what other members had meetings about, when he was not IN the meetings?