Discussion Locked

Scott McClellan: "The Iraq war was not necessary."

0 helpful
154 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

154 replies

by jdclyde

There were MANY left of center people saying exactly that. It was Iran that was the threat we should be fighting, not Iraq. Of course they said this at a time when we obviously could not have practically taken that on, with everything else. After it started looking like it COULD happen, their lip service to this stopped real quick.

by jdclyde

a quick recap. To show how government makes exceptions for it's self all the time.

Simple, huh?

by jdclyde

but it was the beginning of lunch time, so the server was most likely at the max hits.

Ask your web admin how that can happen.

I was able to get in about an hour later.

by $$$$$$$$$$

How much did he know? When did he know it?

How long does it take to make a solid case against the President? Woodward & Bernstein took a fair amount of time, and it was their full-time job.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I don't know which pundit it is, but I just heard about half an hour ago on MSNBC's online videos, from a guy who seemed very confident in what he was saying, that the publisher McClellan chose pays no more than $100,000 for a book.

FWIW

by jamesrl

I'm reasonably certain that Scott would have been under a non disclosure agreement, signed when he joined the staff, that would have gagged him for some number of months.

James

by jdclyde

If this truly came as a "total surprise" to everyone, then it would seem that he had NOT expressed disagreement with the information he was pushing along.

That he continued to push the information shows one of two things, he agreed, or has no integrity, making anything he said then AND now suspect.

by jamesrl

That the Karl Roves etc are truly surprised.

Frankly you don't leave the press secretary position without some reason. And the chief of staff would have asked.

James

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]That he continued to push the information shows one of two things, he agreed, or has no integrity, making anything he said then AND now suspect.[/i]

That he didn't know, at the time, that it wasn't true. You could compare the time of his resignation to the time that it became known, in the popular media [exclude every "left-wing blog," which McClellan likely would never read] that his statements about the treasonous revelation of covert agent Valerie Plame's identity, had all been false. He states specifically that learning that he had been told lies about Cheney and Rove's involvement with the Plame leak case, and that he resigned because he was [Perino's word choice, not his] "disgruntled" over exactly that. So, unless you have access to information that is not on politico.com or Fox News, you know that he did [b]not[/b] continue to push the information after he [b]knew[/b] it to be [b]false[/b]. Integrity was in fact exactly how he chose to draw the line.

by cactus pete

Glad you figured me out. I would have certainly told you had you asked, fyi. Anyway...

I've read through the other replies to date before starting this (I'm infrequently here these days). Where James has stated similar topics, I'll just leave it.

My understanding of the "insiderness" of the Press Secretary is that yes, they know more than the average citizen, to be sure. But they are left out of the goriest details so that they can avoid answering some questions. They aren't in on every detail, and couldn't always be so. But they get the end result and the manner in which the administration wants it to be spun.

I don't doubt that they are often in policy meetings, too, by the way.

You might be interested in seeing his interview from last night on Countdown. He actually addresses this.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I agree, the interview on Countdown last night was the most in-depth conversation with McClellan I've seen, and the best source other than the book itself.

Who were you before you were Cactus Pete?

by cactus pete

I changed my ID because of privacy issues. But those with whom I had more personal contact in the part I would give that ID without them having to look.

If you just search the old posts, you can figure it out.

by av .

I'm sure he'll get royalties on top of that figure. I'm sure he gets paid to appear on shows to talk about his book. He could write another book too, this time for real money. If he isn't rich now, he will be in the future. Kiss and tell pays well. Unless, of course, its all a big lie.

AV

by $$$$$$$$$$

... when they're being paid by corporations to enforce no laws, and remove, repeal or nullify those that would govern them.

[i]I'm sure he'll get royalties on top of that figure.[/i]

I agree, an advance plus royalties are standard aspects of book deals, according to my reading of the publishing business. The question "how much" will the royalties be, depends on whether he is perceived to be (1) telling the truth (2) about interesting subjects.

[i]I'm sure he gets paid to appear on shows to talk about his book.[/i]

I don't doubt he gets paid to appear on some of them or could be paid to appear on some, but I'm not [b]sure[/b] he gets paid to appear on all the shows on which he has appeared, or wants to appear on. My understanding of his motive is that he felt betrayed by being told falsehoods, directly by Scooter Libby and Karl Rove about the treasonous publication of covert agent Valerie Plame's identity. As a result, I expect him to prefer the more reputable of the media concerns [among those with high circulation/Neilsen ratings, [b]of course[/b]].

The long interview on [i]Countdown[/i], for example, I could easily see as a [i]quid pro quo[/i] in which McClellan gets airtime and Olbermann gets a "world exclusive," in the language of journalists, "the scoop." I didn't know his background at the time, but I did watch McClellan on the podium quite a few times. I saw him squirm and fidget when he was caught in Bush's and Cheney's lies. I tend to believe him, absent specific evidence against him.

[i]He could write another book too, this time for real money. If he isn't rich now, he will be in the future. Kiss and tell pays well. Unless, of course, its all a big lie.[/i]

Or, the citizen-taxpayers don't care and don't choose to become his Customers.

by av .

I'm sure people around the world would find the read interesting. Ka-ching!

It took Scott McClellan an awful long time to feel betrayed. Its almost as if he quietly was taking notes during his time at the White House preparing for his tell-all book. I find it hard to believe the turning point for him was the CIA leak case when he finally realized he was being lied to by Rove and Libby. I think its more like he had enough information to write his tell-all book.

He is just as bad as those he threw under the bus. If he was a man of integrity, he would have resigned his position years earlier.

AV

by bill.porritt

Like lemmings to the ocean, the majority here appears to be playing follow the leader. A select few choose to question the leader's path. I applaud their skepticism.

Q - Why are Mr. McClellan's motives not suspect by more than this select few?

A - Because he's telling you what you want to hear so he can sell books.

Where else is he going to work after such a pathetic display as Press Secretary?

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Where else is he going to work after such a pathetic display as Press Secretary?[/i]

That is just a minor variation on the "disgruntled" angle, an angle so pathetically obtuse that the George Walker Bush White House gave up on it within a day of first trying it. I know McClellan was not in a line of work for which I was likely to hire him, whether his performance in his previous gig had been mediocre, superlative or abysmal. I assume, unless and until you tell me otherwise, that you probably also were never a likely employer of Scott McClellan. Nevertheless, you and I both know he had connections he could have leveraged for a next job as lobbyist or PR guy for any number of corrupt organizations wishing to influence politics, or industries notorious for sponsoring politicians.

by bill.porritt

WTF was that? A retort? Grow up junior. The world is a scary place that requires scarier people to tame. Ideological bickering gets us nowhere. If you aren't part of the solution you are part of the problem. Stop being part of the f'ing problem and grow up.

by bill.porritt

As far as what you and I know, I venture to say I know enough not to have dismissed the Syria/Jordan angle mentioned earlier as most here did. Not all facts are public. As far as hiring McClellan; I wouldn't hire him to wash my truck.

by bill.porritt

Your initial post referring to the Clinton/Lewinski issue as "banging an intern" should have been a red flag to all thinking people as insight into your sophomoric mindset. I now feel dirty for even bothering to respond.

BTW - my initial rebuttal was not about Mr. McClellan being disgruntled or even a "minor variation" thereof. It was about the economic factor. Dismissing the money only furthers my lemming statement and I thank you for helping.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[or, whatever corporate crap the GOP helps you over-price]

Specious arguments such as yours are easily recognized by the ease of turning them 180? without loss of relevance or accuracy.

by bill.porritt

You are apparently not stupid based on your vocabulary. I can only assume that you are narrow minded. You are blinded by ideology. I espouse no party, agenda or ideology. Your own statements expose you as a shallow thinker. My focus is the truth as evidenced by facts. You don't get that on MSNBC, CNN or Fox. You have to find it and that requires more effort than you are apparently willing to expend.

My advice: Turn off the TV, get offline, talk to someone over 40 and get to know what has made this the greatest nation in history. Believe it or not, dissidence for dissicence sake only makes you a whiner, not a thinker.

by santeewelding

That was a neat turn of phrase. I get to -- have to -- rely on the stratagem almost every day in what I do. It is near instinctive in those matters, and others.

by bill.porritt

GBUs going for 20K. Get 'em while they're "hot". All credit applications accepted. Not necessarily approved, but accepted none the less.

Those bombs and "whatever corporate crap the GOP helps you over-price" are what has provided us (you and I) the ability to even have this debate. One doesn't appreciate the things one takes for granted. I base all of my opinions of you on your own words. I see you as an element of our entitlement society. You feel that your opinion is fact and any opposing viewpoint must provide proof you do not offer. While intelligent, you are intellectually dishonest. Pretty standard among the youth we have raised. I have a son who I am trying to raise to think for himself. In today's society that is not an easy task. Left to his own devices he would likely turn out as a "cookie cutter" kid who believes in nothing and falls for anything. He would be a whiner without purpose or resolution. I guess your parents were busy.

by jck

Not only was he good enough to be the longest serving press secretary in the past decade, but Mr. McClellan also was moved up to fill the position vacated by Fleischer as well as having filled in for him at various times of leave.

Plus he was so horrible that Bush kept him around for 12 years. Guess Bush must like keeping pathetic people working for him then, according to your opinion?

by $$$$$$$$$$

How much money do you believe he has been paid?
[advance]

And how much do you believe he will be paid?
[advance + royalties]

I don't know; my only source is some guy on MSNBC whose name I don't know. He's a fairly frequent guest, but basically a press guy with no "inside" connections or high-level government experience that I know. He says that McClellan's publisher has never previously paid an advance more than $100,000. He does not claim to know the details of McC's contract, nor do I.

Like I said above, McClellan went "all in" on the positions he espoused in this book; he will either be vindicated by "history" relatively quickly, or become permanently unemployable, even more quickly. I don't see much basis for former Senator Bob Dole's reproach, which you can Google yourself if you haven't read or heard it.

by bill.porritt

You seem to be making my point that we just don't know yet. My problem with you is grounded in your initial statement that the Iraq War was unnecessary based on one man's book that merely sells you a line you are predisposed to buy. There are larger issues involved that transcend your statement. I will be happy to introduce you to my circle of friends who do not see their mission in Iraq from your perspective. I recommend you man up prior because these guys don't play as nice as I. They don't mince words, parse language or play games. All business junior. A business you, like the 60's hippies, can't fathom.

by ic-it

You are missing the fact that there was no immediate need to go into Iraq and that the administration pretty much dictated the resources to be used (rather inefficiently at that). What harm would have been done to finish job 1 first (Afghanistain and Bin Laden)? I believe that was and should have remained a top priority. Instead we pulled a lot of critical intelligence resources and special forces away from that to gather intell for an arguable un-neccessary target. Resulting in not accomplishing the primary mission.

by jck

I have friends too in places. Maybe my friends can meet your friends and have a discussion.

Meanwhile if you were all business, you wouldn't be on here...now would you, Mr. Bill?

I'd love to fathom your business. Please explain it to me. I have been entranced and enticed. Please...honor me with this business that you and your friends do.

I think I can. My name isn't Junior. lol

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]You seem to be making my point that we just don't know yet.[/i]

It seems to be an unknown, not a "known" therefore not a "point" for nor against ... either of us, as I see it.

[i]My problem with you is grounded in your initial statement that the Iraq War was unnecessary based on one man's book that merely sells you a line you are predisposed to buy.[/i]

Titles have a character limit. I decided that a "quote," McClellan's own words, succinctly indicate the topic I want to discuss. You merely assume (1) that I hold that opinion [correct] (2) that I hold that opinion "based on one man's book" [incorrect]. 50% is good in baseball, for a batter or in basketball, during regular play, but not impressive in "free throws" or matters of fact, where the time constraint of sport is replaced by as much time as necessary [or in your case, willing] to spend to learn the truth.

The remainder of your post is irrelevant to the subject of this thread. If I wish to have such conversations, I know where to find them.

by $$$$$$$$$$

What sort of truck do you drive? I have to admit [u]that[/u] made me laugh.

[i]As far as what you and I know, I venture to say I know enough not to have dismissed the Syria/Jordan angle mentioned earlier as most here did.[/i]

Do you mean the hidden WMD angle?

by bill.porritt

Dodge Ram quad cab with a 360 cubic inch motor. At 14MPG just doing my part to keep my good friend GWB and his oil cronies rich. Gotta support my homies ya know. After all, how can we ever take over the world without money? You will be assimilated if deemed worthy after the revolution. :o)

by jck

shoot me now!!!

if i had to be assimilated and talk like Bush...i'd wanna be shot. lol

by $$$$$$$$$$

... after the first sentence; you did cite a fact [my vocabulary] as support of your opinion that I am "apparently not stupid." Thanks for confirmation of that.

I can only assume that you are narrow minded.

Not "only"; you have the option to assume, or to check your own premises.

You are blinded by ideology.

That is quite an assertion. Which ideology? On what facts do you base your opinion that I am so blinded?

I espouse no party, agenda or ideology.

Sounds like anarchy. Or, do you mean that you do not espouse any particularly party, agenda or ideology, rather than espousing the absence of any and all?

Your own statements expose you as a shallow thinker.

Another dramatic assertion, equally lacking any factual support. Pick one example, please, of a statement of mine with which you disagree. Explain how it exposes me "as a shallow thinker." Or, STFU.

My focus is the truth as evidenced by facts.

Assertions are not evidence. Assertions are all you have.

You don't get that on MSNBC, CNN or Fox. You have to find it and that requires more effort than you are apparently willing to expend.

Your basis for that opinion?

My advice: Turn off the TV, get offline, talk to someone over 40 and get to know what has made this the greatest nation in history. Believe it or not, dissidence for dissidence sake only makes you a whiner, not a thinker.

Your basis for the opinion that my "dissidence" is "for dissidence sake"?

by bill.porritt

You are just a little boy whining because the world is not the eutopia you imagined as a littler boy. I need no facts to back my "opinion" any more than you. You provide nothing more than talking points from journalists selling stories to support your contention that an "author" selling books validates you. I iterate: Grow up junior. The world is more complex than your immature mind can comprehend. It is a grown up world that treats those of your ilk as gnats in our ears. Annoying bur necessary.

by bill.porritt

Please explain to me the difference between I (verb) no and I do not (verb) any. Is that new? I haven't been in school for about 30 years. Maybe the rules changed. If so, enjoy. I will carry on "old school".

BTW - not gonna get into a word war with you. You have your position, I have mine.
Mine comes from experience and having "been there and done that". Yours appears to come from spending too much time listening instead of doing. If you have a solution, GIVE IT!!!! Otherwise, STFU.

As always, just my opinion. :o)

by $$$$$$$$$$

Bill: [i]I espouse no party, agenda or ideology.[/i]

me: Sounds like anarchy. Or, do you mean that you [b]do not espouse[/b] any particularly party, agenda or ideology, rather than espousing the absence of any and all?

Bill's dimwitted reply: [i]Please explain to me the difference between I (verb) no and I do not (verb) any. Is that new? I haven't been in school for about 30 years. Maybe the rules changed. If so, enjoy. I will carry on "old school".[/i]

The former can be interpreted (as I did, humorously) to imply espousal of the elimination of those things; the latter cannot. Use of a colon will help to illustrate the joke.

"My joke is that Bill espouses: no party, no agenda and no ideology."

It was just to lighten the mood, a smidge. A vain effort, I guess.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I get to -- have to -- rely on the stratagem almost every day in what I do.

And, thanks.

by bill.porritt

We all deal with issues presented mentally that we have to turn into physical action. It is how we process that mental input through our filters that determines the physical output. This is essentially what separates "talkers" from "doers". The sound of one's own voice can become an addiction. I refer back to my statement of being part of the solution vs being part of the problem. Lead, follow or get the H out of our way. We have work to do. Simple, but appropriate.

by santeewelding

Your circle of friends: did they warn you about telegraphing, or shooting the adversary just a little bit?

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]ou feel that your opinion is fact and any opposing viewpoint must provide proof you do not offer. While intelligent, you are intellectually dishonest.[/i]

About what? Can you be specific? Why haven't you yet?

[i]Those bombs and "whatever corporate crap the GOP helps you over-price" are what has provided us (you and I) the ability to even have this debate.[/i]

Computers, communications and energy infrastructure provide us that ability, not bombs.

[i]You feel that your opinion is fact and any opposing viewpoint must provide proof you do not offer. While intelligent, you are intellectually dishonest.[/i]

On what [b]specific[/b] facts do you base that opinion?

[i]I base all of my opinions of you on your own words.[/i]

No, you don't.

by $$$$$$$$$$

[i]Those bombs and "whatever corporate crap the GOP helps you over-price" are what has provided us (you and I) the ability to even have this debate.[/i]

Ideology is a product of thought, and subject to discussion. The claim that "[b]bombs[/b] ... are what has provided us the ability to even have this debate" does not imply that thought was ever a part of the process of forming your opinions.

[i]You feel that your opinion is fact and any opposing viewpoint must provide proof you do not offer.[/i]

Go ahead and dispute something [u]that I've said[/u]. When/if you stop trash-talking and start replying to [u]my words[/u] you'll have some basis to comment on whether I provide proofs in response to challenges of my viewpoints.

by jck

And I suppose your ideology is any better?

Grow up yourself, lepton.

Ideological bickering has produced a lot more accomplishment than invading a country ever did.

by jdclyde

on how far back in history you go for that to be true.

I would say the Roman Empire accomplished a lot more via invasion than ideology.

Of course since the US doesn't take over and claim as the spoils of war, it isn't a fair comparison.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Halliburton does. Blackwater does. KBR does. They have taken over Iraq, and claimed from us, as the spoils of war, the cost+ of that takeover.

http://www.alternet.org/waroniraq/41083/
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi-kbr-war-profiteers-feb21,1,5231766.story
http://www.corpwatch.org/section.php?id=176
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/02/09/60minutes/main1302378.shtml
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/ops/sanctions.htm

[i]Of course since the US doesn't take over and claim as the spoils of war, it isn't a fair comparison.[/i]

Amidst "cakewalk," "slam-dunk" and "greeted as liberators, I had forgotten what I was promised about funding of the war. Thanks for reminding me.

There were [b]no weapons of mass destruction[/b] -- no nukes, no chem weapons, no bio weapons and no credible evidence there had ever been, [b]other than what the US previously gave Saddam Hussein![/b] -- and there were no credible ties to Al Qaida -- hospital security is not known for being as strict as, say, airport security, even in Third World Dictatorships -- and the cost has far exceeded the $300 Billion estimate [b]a Bush employee was fired[/b] for offering because it was too high [for Bush's propaganda campaign].

by $$$$$$$$$$

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bob-cesca/scott-mcclellan-and-no-wa_b_104161.html

Are the mega-corp media fixating on the McClellan story to look like "watchdogs," [i]ex post facto[/i], to rescue their crappy reputations? Or, are the mega-corp media fixating on the McClellan story to distract us from the build-up to war in Iran, because that's a greater challenge and they're not as competent as the average "moonbat zealot" or unpaid blogger?

Examples of either or both, please. ASAP.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Calm down, there will be no mercy killings of you today, and no assimilation into a Bush-style collective. Nobody with a higher IQ than a turnip still supports that clown.

[sorry about the confusing name change, just wanted to make sure everybody around here knows corn ethanol is double-plus dumb]

This discussion is closed to new replies.