Shared Network Folder Rights\Permissions

I have an existing Network Folder, let’s call it Test. Test has Full rights for the group, Everyone. Everyone contains all company users. I need to give rights to only two individual users for Test folder and deny rights to the Everyone group. The problem is that the two individual users are also listed in Everyone group and despite the fact that I have given them individual Full Rights, when I deny Everyone group, access is also denied for them. How do I need to make this change?