Discussion Locked

so-call "ISMgr" logs in as other usrs?

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Can someone tell me if it's proper for an IS mgr to constantly log in as other users in the organization and go through their documents while doing so? I'm a network assistant and have noticed the IS mgr doing this frequently. "A real IS Mgr shouldn't have to use other login names, should they?"
It seems ok for testing a username and password but not to actually use the username. This all started a couple weeks ago when this organization announced it wanted to go union. Is the IS mgr doing this legally? It just doesn't seem right! Please reply.

6 replies

by mike_mds

Let me take the technical part of your question first. The IS mgr is in all likelihood logging in as the users for two reasons. First, it allows access to files the users have set with strict permissions that may exclude the Mgr. from accessing without actually taking ownership of the file by logging in as an Administrator(in a NT environment). This would tip the user off that someone had accessed their files (the second reason).
Unfortunately, the ethical portion of your question is not aseasy. Normally I would recommend taking this to your manager's supervisor or organization's legal branch, but the union issue that you raised means he may have orders for his snooping from higher up the ladder. I don't know what type of policies your organization has in place regarding employee use of the computer equipment and monitoring of their email, internet access, etc., but the type of access you describe smells unethical all the way from here, especially if there is no defined policy for monitoring user's activities.
If it were me, I would either confide in an officer in your organization that I trusted, or talk to an attorney with some knowledge of privacy and legal issues in the IT environment. If you blow the whistle on the Mgr's activities, you may need some legal recourse depending on how things go. Make sure you thoroughly document EVERYTHING that goes on if you plan on bringing the Mgr's activities to light. You may need to CYA in a big hurry!

Good luck!

by tmaclennan

From an audit perspective, it is usually company policy that users can log in only as themselves. Users, as a result, are obligated to guard their passwords and change them if they might be compromised.

For an IS Mgr or any other employee to login with another employee's security shows a sloppy organization, and makes any action an organization might wish to take against an employee far more difficult, because the employee can quite reasonably raise the defense that there is reasonable doubt -- obviously he is not the only person who could log in using his "personal" credentials. Proper or not, the IS Mgr. is poking holes in his own case by the practice.

As to the act itself -- if an organization has clearly stated and actively publicized policies on proper use of corporate equipment, and that it retains the right to all information and data on all corporate platforms, the IS Manager is the proper authority to investigate, regardless of his methods.

by mt_salazar

Does Win98 have a feature to log and record when and who logs on a computer? If so, please share utility name information. Thanks for your responses.

This discussion is closed to new replies.