Discussion Locked

Views on P2P Piracy Prevention Act

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Do you share Jon's views about the proposed Peer to Peer Piracy Prevention Act, as featured in the most recent Internet Security Focus newsletter? How do you think people who use P2P services legitimately will be affected if this legislation passes?Share your comments with your peers.

7 replies

by angelo

I have to agree with the end of the newsletter - the RIAA and MPAA are essentially looking for a license to do what they do not want done: decrypt and do whatever they want to do with the information that they can obtain. Further, they wish to start attacking those who may be legitimately sharing information instead of using their massive legal engines to prosecute properly. Could it be that their legal machines are beginning to really start costing them money?

by nycgriff

I'm old enough to remember when we used to trade the old '45's between my buddies. I also remember "ripping" songs off the radio and copying the tunes to cassette tapes so that we could play them at gatherings over the weekends. I also remember copying LP's onto cassette tapes and exchanging them with with other folks for their jams. Stealing? Hardly. Every oldies song that I've ever gotten from Napster, Audiogalaxy, etc., I've bought and paid. The MP3 format makes it a heck of a lot easier for me to get the stuff into my computer in order to burn those babies onto CD's. Hey, who wants a lot of dust-collecting records lying around? Those record companies and "watchdog" groups need to lighten up. They're still making tons of dough. As a former singer with a group, we've never gotten one red cent of royalties from our record label, and to this day, I still hear some of our stuff being used in commercials to sell dog food and headache remedies. Not one executive has attempted to contact any member of my old group to offer to share in the profits. A good deal of the material being traded off these P2P outlets has been bought and paid for by countless people thousands of times over and over. Stealing? Just who is the thief here?

by caspian

As usual, I appreciate the thoughts expressed in Jonathan's article ("Is P2P a threat to privacy and security?"). I am likewise concerned with the potential for havok if any entity is given the right to perform hacking legally. What a great opportunity for someone to hack into the systems of the authorized entity and use that information to launch their illegitimate attack. Moreover, what will keep the legal hacker from using their power inappropriately and how will IS security officers stay ontop of who has the right (or has been contracted the right) to probe their systems?

by buster

I can not believe that our legislative branch would even consider making it legal to break the law! Hacking is an act of illegal entry. In our homes we would call it breaking and entering. Hacking into an ISP, no matter what the reason, is still breaking and entering. The proposed Peer to Peer Piracy Prevention Act is an unconstitutional piece of garbage. This is a direct violation of the unlawful search and seizure protection provided by the Constitution of the United States. It is compounded by the fact that it will be carried out by an organization(s) that have neither the legal jurisdiction nor the venue for such an act. I would not trust the FBI, CIA, or my local police with such power, and we are supposed to just sit back while it isgiven to private organizations! Since when did we start allowing private citizens and private organizations serve and enforce their own private search warrants?

If this piece of garbage passes, I am going to serve a private search warrant on thecomputer at my local bank to see if they have any illegally obtained copyrighted material of mine. All that is required is that I suspect that they have something of mine, right? Who knows, I might even decide to search the county court house computer after that. After all, it will be legal, I will be looking for illegally obtained copyrighted material that belongs to me. If I understand this Act correctly, I will even be empowered to enter the computer system after hours when the bank or the court house is closed for business.

by milhart

I agree completely that we're in for a great many problems if the government allows companies to start hacking into systems at will. Hacking is hacking by any other name. I also will take it as my right to attack anyone who shows up on my log as having attempted to access my network without my permission. After all, rights should be reciprocal, right? If they have the right to enter, or try to enter, my network, I have the same right to enter theirs. There are many others who feel the same way.The proposed legislation could well lead to the equivalent of a cyber war from which no one will gain. Congress couldn't be so stupid, could they???? Please don't answer that. The thought is too frightening.

by kingyon

I share your view on P2P. My biggest concern is if the ISPs are going to have to police there servers, will the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA), the
Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), and the Software and
Information Industry Association (SIIA) pay them for there efforts? What about privacy rights?

by berolina

RIAA, MPAA, and SIIA are using their deep pockets to pay their lobbists and politicians to make the internet a sweet spot for US-American commerce, or so they think. They ( RIAA, MPAA, and SIIA ) define their "laws" so that they as the "good" guyscan break into "bad" guys networks top take revenge.
This will work only in the short term ... the world and the internet is not US property and will not be defined by US laws - period!
RIAA, MPAA, and SIIA has managed to kill Napster, even gotsome fine judge to undermine a feasible business model with Bertelsmann/Germany, just because it was a company outside of the US - what a fine new world these RIAA, MPAA, and SIIA pirates trying to setup - never mind that the majority P2P users are still paying customers of their clients - but greed governs the US as the CEO's of GE, Enron, Worldcom FGlaobal Crossing and probalbly hundereds more have so lively demonstrated the public.
Let's review this issue in five years ...

This discussion is closed to new replies.