Discussion Locked

What are the REAL advantages of Linux?

0 helpful
35 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

After reading the article last week and responding to the discussions I was ripped left and right for defending Microsoft. I still say that while open source is great, Linux is no where near developed enough for a "Enterprise Solution" and most of the people claim it is have never worked in a very large corp where you need a vast amount of software that can work together without any critical problems and an incredible learning curve. I myself perfer Linux for a web server (Apache) but that is the only place I have found it useful and when you consider the increase in salary for a admin of has knowledge of MS and Linux I starting to wonder if it is worth the money. I'm still favoring Apache for security reasons but I am thinking budget and all.

So here is my question:
For all you Pro-Linux Admins and those who claim to know something here is your chance. What do you think the real advantages of Linux are when compared to Windows 2000 server? The truly technical stuff. Not better security, cheaper and the typical say nothing crap you can read anywhere.

So, lets rule out Apache and price. Why did I rule out Apache. I think any Admin knows for security Apache is better than IIS even if IIS is easier to use. There would be no real point mentioning Apache it is common knowledge.

Here is two examples of what I mean:

Microsoft - Many applications (written by MS and third party) are able to share information (and remain stable) under one log in. This ones is one of Microsofts strongholds on the Corp world and is hardly ever mentioned.

Linux- The ability to write "Custom in house" code to use in applications can be very valuable IF you have a good employee you can rely on. I feel this was the backbone of Unix and why many very large corps still have Unix systems running. It is also why Mainframes are making a come back in some areas.

35 replies

by ebob

I too have wondered about all of this Linux stuff. In a smaller shop, where the I.T. staff have a pretty good "hands on" feel for the whole picture, it may have some relevance. But beyond its abvious use as a webserver (Apache, like you say), the real application of Linux is pretty fuzzy to me.

When I look to an alternative to M$, my natural tendency is to some form of Unix. However, what I go for is Solaris. The price is right, the development exists, the support exists. It's stable, secureand so on. In general, it makes a great server platform, as long as the application can run in it.

Which brings me to what I think is the "real" point. In the "real" world, what's important is the application being provided to the users, NOT the underlying O/S. Yeah, yeah, the O/S is important, too, but the "proof of the pudding is in the eating", which is to say that that the real measure of the functionality of any I.S./I.T. environment is what it brings to the (damn) end-users, not what it brings to the "nerds".

So if it will run on Solaris (or Linux, or some other "alternative" to Windoze), great. If not, well, not so great, and we live with it. Sigh.

by radiic

Being a network administrator and also having to help support the workstations in my company, I have to say that Windows at the desktop is the way to go. Weather it be 9x,or Nt4,or W2k. I can't imagine trying to roll out A bunch of Linux desktops and secure each one, especially with all the nifty tools available to scan your network. Not that they are not available for M$, but I think it's easier to lock my users out from using those products.

Now the server arena: Of course having M$ workstations, you like to have a PDC and a few BDC's because using WINS& DHCP is easy to assign IP, and File sharing is easy. Profiles for NT workstation is easy to use.
Have to have an Exchange server for Intranet e-mail. But you want to know what Linux is good for.

How about taking one of those old pc's sitting around in the closet, throw in 2 nics and put it inbetween your internet connection and your network. NAT is easy to setup, Add DNS to the box too. (caching name server only) makes your dns querries go very fast. How about throwing on some IPSEC & IPCHAINS to filter out all the traffic you dont want. Throw on SNORT a free IDS and find out who is scanning your network from the outside world. You can setup an FTP site for your Internal network easier and faster and more secure than using IIS. Not to mention make an employee web site. Need another place for people to store files securely, you can use Samba, need to have email relayed to your exchange server, Can do. Get the picture.

by radiic

I personaly don't agree with all the OS bashing going on. Why can't we all agree that different OS's have different purposes, and that as Admins we need to use the tool that makes the Job the easiest. But I guess there is no way to say that this tool is better than that tool without disagreeing, so use what works best for you. Personally my goal is to have 100% uptime of my network and limit the amount of support calls that come in. What ever tool helps me the best than thats what I use.

Have a great day ;)
Radicalis

by claymuir

Tell me about "IPSEC & IPCHAINS" - I have to admitt you stumped me on that one. I was sort of including DNS when I said Apache but to tell you the truth I still prefer MS DNS. (Just because I first used DNS on a MS DNS server). Samba is great but isit possible for Visual Basic (using ADO or ODBC) to see files that reside on a Linux server, served with Samba? Also, can you make connections to AS400 and other various mainframes using Samba? Often the file security attached to MVS/JCL is a problem for third party software. I was just wondering if Samba knows how to deal with connecting.

by therustler

That was a good post. Most organizations also own license to some of their software that runs primarily on windows. Even if there was the slightest hope of rolling out a new OS for office workstations, the folks in IT have to give each piece of software a thorough test and ensure a is available for the new OS, the software works efficiently on the new OS, the software vendor supports Linux etc. So in effect, M$ very much dominates the desktop market.
However, Linux is handy when you want to roll out a centralized service such as ftp, an intranet site, internal web application etc.

by lordinfidel

We have a pretty large IT shop here.

It's a mixed enviroment, employing a lot of different OS's.

But I think you will find in most IT shops, that linux is deployed in the server end.

Some of the reasons, besides being quick, dirty and cheap. Is it's security features and it's a cool alternative.

Some main things that linux is used for besides a web server are:

DNS servers, Intermediate Firewalls, RealServers/Media Servers, Low cost-Routers and yes even a mail server.

Here's why.

Linux unlike windows, does not require beefy machines to run.

So when you need to employ some el cheapo dns servers,(we have 10) why go out and buy a $500 NT4 srvr liscence when you can install linux for free on crappy box's.

And if you run a decent size shop you will understand what I am talking about.

Now for security, I live in both the Windows and Linux worlds. A NT box can be configured as a Bastion Host just like a Linux box. The main differences I have noticed is in Windows, everything is open until you close it off.

In linux it's the opposite. Most things are closed until you open them, depending on what you install obviously.

Now would I deploy a army of linux desktops to my usr population, NO. It's just not feasible. Unless they are an army of developers, then it makes sense.

Basically, it's not what's overall better, it's whats better in each situation.

That is part of being an Admin is, being able to decide what type of system to deploy in agiven situation.

My personal prefernces, I like IIS over Apache; redhat and debian over SuSe and Solaris; Checkpoint FW-1 over IPTables (unless it's for internal use then IPTables); BIND DNS on Debian over M$ DNS;
2K AD over NT4 domains, Linux and Novell.

Like I said before, go with what works for the situation, you will never go wrong.

by therustler

Well, lme me start out by further making a mess of this. First of all are you referring to Linux as an application platform or a desktop OS ? Once you've cleared that bit it gets out out of one maze and you've got to do some (somtimes corporate) soul searching. Take for example an issue such as an IT strategy. Most companies have a standard platform OS-wise for applications mainly because it is more feasible to maintain licences, hire admins etc.
What you really need to conisder is the applications you are going to build/deploy and the requirements for the same. Teh cost of ownership and ROI is another thing you need to look at. Both MS platforms and Linux/Solaris/Unix-OSes have their own particular set of strengths and weakenesses that can be leveraged to provide good service. I'll cut short here on account of time. But if you want more information regarding the same, feel free to get in touch with me.

cheers,
-rustle

by claymuir

Actually, the intent of discussion was to find out some real strengths of Linux not to bash it. I am considering setting up some of are upcoming servers with Linux and I am trying to get some real in's and out's. On a test machine I have already installed Oracle 8i on the Mandrake 8.0 Os. That system works great so now I am thinking maybe some other uses. I did like your post- I found it the sort of thing I had in mind.

by anthud11

I was a frustrated user who was tired of having to pay and register software over and over again. My M$ system always seem to have some unfindable bug contained within the software which led to pqmagic.exe and resinstall of all necessary software.I saw no alternative on the market.

That is to say I did not see another system I could use on a homebuilt box that would use anything other than M$. I found Linux and have enjoyed a new world of computing.

From creating the partitions to using Suns office programs.

I wanted to know my computer, not just use it.

With Linux I can know my computer, and learn it's unique way of working. I can't write a driver for M$. I can but any nerd I know would ask why? They are already written. That was my problem, the wheel wasn't broken and if it was I could not change the flat because I did not know how.

Now I am experimenting with new options for web page design, compilers, and I am not limited to a M$ environment. The movement is about freedom. Don't restrict my civil liberties because you can M$. The corporate world is held captive in a guilded cage, don't be fooled it is still a cage. Take away their Excel and they will be helpless. Not I.

Don't get me wrong, I have a M$ box, but I am not limited to it.

Don't bash, however with Linux I don't crash either.

by unix_magic

Cool!
You've got the meaning and purpose of Linux.
Linux gives us the choice we look for in the computing world.
Sure thing, you can buy loads of expensive software for the M$ flatform and spends about the same amount upgrading every 6 months.
Or you can get good, reliable, powerful software free off the net or dirt-cheap and run your home PC for months without crashing it.
Don't tell me about "cost is not a criterion", because it is.
Agreed, there is an initial high learning curve on the'nix platform.
But once that threshold is crossed, it is escape velocity all the way.
The universe is unlimited and Linux is the ride of taste today.

Bottomline ---
M$ sucks - Unix Rules!!

by radiic

You stumped me on using Samba with ADO or ODBC. But you can map a drive from w9x or NT box and it looks and feels just like a server share. Maybe NFS on the Linux box wolud work better. As for the AS400 part samba can use WINS and server authentication to verify against.

Ahhhh IPCHAINS: Basically manipulates rule sets within a chain, 3chains called INPUT,FORWARD,OUTPUT. Uses the packet header to deceide on Deny,reject or pass of a packet. Its a packet firewall>

You are right, cant really run apache without the dns part installed. But I have setup both NT4 w/dns and RH6.1 w/Bind and both as cacheing name server only. The performance by the RH box was far superior than that of the NT4 box.

Radicalis

by claymuir

I'll look into the IPCHAINS - just because it sounds interesting. I'm not sure it would be a real value to me right now.

Now, that I think about it you must be right about Samba and AS400 - after all SNA is really taking care of the security. Just curious - do you find Samba difficult to use in a large network? Oracle recommends not using on a Linux system with a Oracle DB installed so I will probably rule it out for that server. However, I think it might be a interesting way to route multiple Database servers information to one place. We like do Backups of small chunks of information that we keep to help us make the Whole system work together. In shop code that I did not write.

by radiic

I know samba that came with the red hat 6.1 distro was fun :( to get working. I finally did get it to work and I could connect to it from my workstation. Even see the server in Network neighborhood and browse right to it. and it would open up my default folder that i had setup in the smb.conf

Now the tricky part. You can turn on WINS support and as clients connect they will be added to a database in the smb server of course it will validate those users using a wins broadcast,and hopefully your wins server will respond. I found that this wasnt allways the case and didnt work too well. That was over a year ago, I havent played with the version available now, but I would expect that there have been some great improvements.
For setuphelp try this--http://www.redhat.com/support/resources/tips/Samba-Tips/Samba-Tips.html

And for good samba support --http://us1.samba.org/samba/samba.html

Radicalis

by claymuir

Well, the page is certainly interesting. I went through a little of it just now and will look over more later today if I have time. One question - does any of the workshops and such take place in the UK? I'm American but I live in Newcastle, Englandand I would like to get out to some IT events from time to time. Now, about terminal server in a very large corp. To tell you the truth I do not think it is good idea for that application. The main reason is that End Users are comfortable with Windows and Business depeneds on MS Office and MS Visual Studio. On my test network I built for the Techie people I installed Star Office on one workstation and Corel Word Perfect suite on another. (Corel donated the Suite by the way - along with their version of Linux which I have not yet tried) On the Workstation with Star Office I also installed K-Studio. This is what I found. In a corp setting none of the products had near the functionality or ability to meet the needs of the company. I Found Star Office easy to use although it has some problems (or maybe the way I installed it) Either way even for the back end people the only way to go for workstations is Windows. Sorry Linux crowd - thats just the way it is. Having said that I'm beginningto find many more uses for the Server and post like the ones here are a big help. I recommend having a look at the site that aandw@techie.com posted even if your not thinking Terminal Services.

That site was http://www.ltsp.org/index.php

by thejazzman

Samba really isn't hard to set up. I have 2 Samba servers running on our network. I use the NT Domain to authenticate users and have had no trouble. The shares are a bit more work to set up initially but work great. In fact most of my users don't know they are attaching to a Linux server. Which is fine with me. Too many wanna-be admins among my users to deal with already.

by generalist

Could you provide more details about your comparison of MS versus Star Office and Corel Word Perfect?

I'm curious as to the strengths and weaknesses of each product as viewed by your organization. If you're a 'bleeding edge' group with international connections, your needs would require a feature rich, heavily integrated package like MS.

But other organizations might require less and be operating under a tighter budget. That's where knowing more of the details comes in handy.

by jdieter2

These three words say it all. Unlike E.T.
(who phoned home for a ride) XP phones home
to break itself. Specifically built in
functionality to down your system. Microsoft
has a habbit of forcing you to buy their new
stuff by not fixing their old stuff. When was
the last patch for Win3.11 released? Look at
the web site for NT4.0 sp7. (the "no more
fixes coming" message) If you are using a
proprietary system like Solaris or Windows,
you are at the vendors mercy. You cannot
guarantee that some "security hole" won't be
found - and then NOT FIXED! Its up to the
vendor! If they decide they don't want to fix
it, what will you do? You are at their mercy.
Windows is simply a graphics library and a
state machine. Whoopy. Big deal. We can get
those open source now that work just fine. If
you don't own the source code to the bits and
bytes you depend on, from the lowliest
calendar control to the fanciest SQL Server,
you are at the vendors mercy. Some companies
can afford to take that risk. But at least,
lets admit the risk exists!

by claymuir

First, of all XP has not released yet so No one knows if the Registration process will still be intact when it hits the streets. (by the way my Developers addition does not have any sign of the cursed feature)

Having said that what are you going on about? Who cares about the vendors technique of doing business? I mean to some end we all care but you sound like you have some issues with MS. Bottom line is thousands and thousands of Hugh Companies depend on Microsoft and Sun and many swear by them. Our Company uses MS- you name it,IBM - AS/400, Solaris and I am trying to include Linux. Which is what lead to this discussion. The topic here is what real world advantages does using Linux in business give you.

Your free to write and say whatever you wish ofcourse and I encourage free though but you definitely do yourself no credit with outpour like that. If you are die hard Linux or Open source then convince me of some sound uses for my company. If you can sell me you will have done the open source movement a great favor. Every person counts...

by anthud11

Linux in it's purest form was never truly intended for users. I was and is a HOS "Hackers Operating System". The potential for business applications exist. The development has not yet reached the level that is required to be successful in the business arena. I take that back it is not suitable to use Linux in an evironment in which *.xls and other M$ extensions are used unless you hack the system. That's the work of developement. We don't have to whine we should use WINE.

by lordinfidel

Actually, I do beleive the registration will still be intact.

Any OfficeXP programs that have been shipped out have the process imbedded in them

Anything you get thru the MSDN won't have that reg process because that is not what it's intended for. Which is why we pay 2K a year for it. The MSDN liscense is for strictly development use only and is only good while your subscription is paid and current.

I doubt M$ is going to back away from their new licsensing model. They have spent a great deal of cash already informing their vendors/resellers of the new products and liscensing. (not to mention the hundreds of flyers I keep getting from MS).

In the Corporate enviroment, I just don't see XP as a viable option. Not when 2K and NT4 domains are still around. Most admins will be very resistant to make a jump from NT4 to 2K much less to XP. (and 2K rocks).

Why Linux...Not for the desktop, yet... But definitely for low cost work horse servers such as DNS, internal fw's, load balancers, routing, real servers. You really need to explore what this free little os has to offer. You will find a very peaceful cohabitat with your present MS network, we have.

by unix_magic

Hey friend,
It is definitely wrong to compare M$ with Sun.
Sun Micro have been rather honest and straight forward in handling all issues, and their OS is one of best there is today.
Comparing Sun with M$ is like comparing a Tiger with a rodent(M$).
Agreed, the Open Source is a reliable and worthy option, but that doesn't mean Sun is a tyrant like M$.
Hope you'll change your mind about SUNW.

by saramiller

The mainframes in the computer are built on dfklg. That is the specific code for all of you geeks that think you know it all. Go ahead, get mad! I want you to tell me all about your comments. My computer is coded by a million skhdvb. Please write to me at babygrl282@aol.com.

by lordinfidel

Maybe **_you_** should check your facts.

Have you ever even seen a MainFrame?

Do you even know what the differences between a mainframe and a computer are?
(For some reason I don't think so)

BTW- This is a discussion about Linux Vs Win.Asking people to write to you makes you look desperate.

And before you go spewing off crap, you will need to back it up with proof.

It's called "Proof of Concept" Learn the term.

by claymuir

babygrl282 what are you talking about? We have 7 mainframes in our network and I have never heard the terms dfklg or skhdvd. Our mainframes use Unix, MVS/JCL and tons of
!Microfocus Cobol!. Beside, what does that have to do with the Advantages of using Linux?

by ebob

Hey everybody, let's calm down. This "babygrl282" is from AOL, so we have to assume that it (he? she?) has some serious IT handicaps. So it drops completely irrelevant posts in these discussions, but this is out of stupidity and/or ignorance, but I am sure there is no malice.

I have seen posts in other threads this morning from "babs", with the same amazing non-sequitir theme.

Let's just all ignore it's posts.

Here's a thought to lighten things up: Ignorance can be cured, but stupidityis forever!

by claymuir

We are a international company but the divisions run as seperate companys from a information stand point so other than Mail going back and forth the IT jobs relate to seperate areas. (US and the UK)

Let me start by saying the main problems were User knowledge and training. That aside there was Technical issues as well.

First, OLE is sometimes necessary for the kind of work my company does. (Power and Gas)
* My issue here is I do not believe that Star Office has a wide range of features we it comes to automating images into Mail and Spreadsheets. This was a problem for us with graphs representing underground photography.

Second, Again OLE but worth mentioning. You can not use OLE with Email (that I know of) with any product otherthan MS using Office and Exchange. Same problem really but I also want to include that many Companys use the Calender and meetings functions in Office. Star office does have something like this and I am told Corel does as well. I did not even look at Corel so I can not comment on that feature.(I had ruled it out before it came up) The problem with Star Office I had no idea how to do it and I knew if I didn't most end users would not either.

Third, everything had to be converted to MS Office format when mailed outside the company so we had to ask ourselves why not use MS to begin with?

Fourth, no Quality built in Program language like VBA. Also, no support for Ansi SQL-92 support. Corel does have a version of Basic that you can use toAutomate but it only works with windows and it is different. Why learn a new Basic when VB is so common anyway? Star Office has nothing really. You can write marcos but it is difficult.

Cont...

by claymuir

This is my take. If the company was very small say 75 users or less - I think you could use Star Office, Send Mail and MySql and get away with Linux but it would require either good training or end users that came with the knowledge. Those kind of end users dont exsist yet. I say that because if you understand Linux inside and out you well on your way to a IT job if you want one. Complication to expect if you run Linux Servers with MS workstations - Multiple Logins, Difficult to build workstations if the End users use Outlook express and other MS products and higher cost of IT staff for the Admin. (Usally one in a company that small) The advantage - Money, If you did run Linux servers and Star Office on the workstations you would save a lot of money. By the way Star Office does work on NT - I tried it.

by generalist

Thanks for the detailed feedback.

From what I'm reading into things, if MS is already established in an organization, then 'legacy inertia' is the biggest hurdle. Conversions and retraining would eat up any short term benefits Star Office and Corel Word Perfect Suite could offer.

Of course, that would apply to any technology change.

The functionality part might have some work arounds. Decent VBA and OLE capabilities, or their equivalent, could be added/enhanced. And file compatibility with other organizations exists for some word processing formats.

If non-MS vendors focused on some of these areas and eliminated the functional problems, then 'legacy inertia' would be the biggest problem.

by mishratron

Well if you do some digging about 3 months ago this site had a great article on IPCHains and IPSEC , What I took from it is that it is basically an accesslist you would find in a router except in a box running an OS. I dont think it is all that great if you can afford a PIx then its not worth it, If you cant then Windows 2k does not have anything close enough becuase port filtering is really sloppily done, but tahts just my opinion .
:-)

by unix_magic

IP chains is definitely a good way to go in securing your home PC or home network.
If you run Solaris on your PC, you can download SunScreenLite for free, which is a fully functional firewall software.
IP Chains is definitely not difficult to set up.
In fact, one can establish a rather basic filtering firewall in a matter of minutes if the Linux kernel had been compiled with IP tables and IP chains.
There are lots of advantages of running Linux on your home PC.

On the cosmetic front - you have simply fabulous desktops like gnome or KDE packaged with the distribution.
The graphics that you can get on a Linux driver-set is simply amazing.
Win-Doze doesn't come anywhere near it.
The reads and writes to/from the devices is mch fasterthan in win-doze.
The applications work most of times.
In case one doesn't actually work, it doesn't normally cause total paralysis of the system as it happens on M$.
Gotta run now,

Elighten you folks later sometime.

by lordinfidel

I'm not trying to beat you up here so don't get bent out of shape.

First, PIX? for a firewall, better then IPChains? Hmmm no, i don't think so.

I would not wish PIX on anyone.

Now, IPChains has been replaced with IPTables. The syntax is alittle different, but if you are familiar with chains then tables will not be a problem.

Tables is extremely flexible and offers you more control. Not to mention the fact that, oh it's FREE!.

It is not an Access List!

Now granted, it's hard to compare a commercial grade firewall like CheckPoint FW-1 to Chains. But then again, you don't need to spend 10K on chains/tables either.

We employ both types here. And when it comes
to logging and packet filtering, Chains does a much better job then Checkpoint.
(You checkpoint admins will know what I am talking with regards to the Log Viewer, can it be any slower!)

2K was never meant to be employed as a Firewall. It's not designed that way. It does not have a typical rulebase like a firewall.

But when it "filters" a port, basically all it is doing is closing that port off.

So is it "sloppy", that is not exactly the definition that I would use. But it does do a specific job and should be used in conjucntion with a firewall.

IE. if you have a mail server there is no reason to open up all of it's ports. Close off everything to just tcp 25 (443 if you are using ssl). This just enhances your security model, it should not be the basis for it.

by rmit_ceed_project

The problem i usually find with Linux users is that they fail to see the many tips and tricks that Windows offers. Linux is great and many of the little tips and tricks that make it great are available in windows, especially win2000/NT.
A perfect example of this is the command completion. Available also in both Linux and Windows 2000/NT4.

by anthud11

You are very correct in your assesment. Windoze has gotten very linuxy as of late. Scared of market share loss, the easy of a public owned OS, or just no more new things to do except copy Linux and it's features. I don't have anything against someone who sees a good thing and uses it. However, the same exciting things that windoze help to incorporate also seem to limit user choice. That's the essence of Microsoft Users VS Linux Users. Linux gives us not them a choice. Now if Mr. Gates wants to come out with Lindows... oops too late.

Linux Rules

by seeprakash

Hi
claymuir

Man from ages wanted comforts,in some way he works/fights for comforts.

As a Netadmin/Customer support Engg my opinion
about Linux is it is just a boon to computer users
community

MS provided some comforts like GUI,Easier Tools
but it was paid

But with linux it is a community baby ,it is by the people,for the people it is ours no $$

As a admin the main thing why u r deployed there
is that u know better know and understand what to use and what not in what situation

But with linux as per me u r pc works for u not visa versa
U understand u r pc better

So dont compare MS with Linux
Techbee
PRKS-->j

This discussion is closed to new replies.