Discussion Locked

What to do when good offers come close together.

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Some of you here may have seen my rants about how much I hated my old work environment. When I resigned they acted as if they might make a counter offer until I told them there was no chance.

I've taken this "contract-to-perm" gig thinking it was my only option out of my old employer. I was unclear as to what that means exactly. It doesn't guarantee I'll have a job at the end of the contract term. It just means the place where I'm contracting has the option to hire me from the contracting firm. Of couse, since this is a right to work state my security is really no worse than a regular employee. And I have verbal intent on the part of the firm I'm contracting for to hire me at year end.

I keep "waiting on the other shoe to drop" at the new gig because what they see as a "major modification" seems to be something that was typically viewed as trivial and requested last minute in crisis mode at my last job. And not knocking their code base at all but the actual code work (meaning beyond all the fuctional design documents, test plans and etc. that DIDN'T get done at the old place) seems dramatically easier and all this for quite a bit more money.

However, I just got an e-mail today informing me I'm still in the running for a permanent position at another large corporation (although I'm happy here I miss the small company feel already). This other position is probably a step up the technology ladder from what I'm doing now.

My quandry is what do I do if it comes through? Do I just accept it and bail on my contract (I have the right to do so with 2 week's notice)? I worry that's rather unprofessional since I've been here 5 days. The e-mail I received said I'd get a yes or no answer within 2 weeks. Do I go to the placement firm and say "I have this offer but would be willing to go perm where I am now" and let them arm-twist for me?

This is all speculation if nothing comes through but I want to try maximze my carrer opportunity, compensation and integrity all at the same time. I'm having a hard time making it all line up.

16 replies

by absolutely

It is not unprofessional to find and accept an offer for a good permanent job while working at a temporary one. To worry about quitting a temp job where you've been working only five days implies a high level of professional integrity, but also less experience than I (regrettably) have with temp jobs.

Just be open about the permanent job as soon as the offer is made--no sooner--so that your current employer has enough time to find another temp, and you will have fulfilled your obligations admirably.

by sjohnson175

I've been working IT in some capacity since 1995 but always as a permanent employee.

I really did think "contract-to-perm" meant I would defiitely convert to perm at the end of the contract period.

That isn't the case as I read the contract. The firm I'm woking for just has that option.

by steve v

I have work a few contracts during my career and have never seen anything wrong with leaving a contract. You are going somewhere that is probably better for you, and would also provide an added challenge. Take it.

by michael.hasslinger

Any employeer will cut loose resources at the drop of the hat. Loyalty has long since past. While this decision should not be made with respect and dignity to your current contract, you must always choose what is in your best interest. My only advice is to not make a habit of jumping around. Once or twice in a career won't hurt.

by sjohnson175

But the placement firm wanted to charge the client firm a fee to take me perm at contract end.

So it's been renegotiated to 10 months with an option to hire anytime after 6 with no fee.

What I was told by the client firm during my interview that they'd be hiring a permanent position but they can't get money to add permanent staff right now but can get money for contractors. Strange corporate politics.

by zen9744

You have to choose what is right for you. I have been contract since 1986 and have seen a lot of the market and many firms. Business is business. If you feel you want the job you ae in ...and want to accept the permannant role then stay put. However if you feel that the new role is what youve always wanted then go for it. This notion of Profeesionalism is somewhat misunderstood. No-one wouild want you to be unprofessional. But Your first responsisbilty is to you and your family. If the firm had issues they would drop you like a stone and wouldnt think twice about it. Thats business. You must act with the same ruthlessnees and selfish attitude. Give notice, give of your all until the ;last minute fo the last day on your contract. Thats prefessional.

BEst of luck. P,ease post and let us all know what you decide and how you get on.

Regards

Dave

by bertsilv56

You need to do what is best for you. Listen hard to your gut feeling and go with that.

I have a 25 years background as a programmer. All of my jobs, including several with "contracting" companies were salaried with full benefits. The current concept of just hiring as an hourly employee is just a method to use you and do whatever they wish to in the end -- good or bad. To them you are just a cog in the big wheel and can be replaced next week, if so desired.

This is risks with everything, but you need to be true to yourself. You'll be happier that way.

by onwynn

You cannot control the fabric of time, fate or destiny. You can only do what you think is best for you, because nobody else will. Be up front with your recruiter, the company you are contracted to, and to the people who have presented the current offer. Answer questions honestly, in the end no one can really fault you for taking the better deal. After all, any one of them would do the same regardless of their sense of loyalty to their employer - loyalty is an admirable trait but it can be misguided when you ignore the loyalty you should have to yourself as well. Do what you think is right, and most others will go along with you.

by mctazman2

I have been contract since 1994. Did your post say you have been on the contract to hire position 5 DAYS....... ? If so, I don't think that I would worry about them arm wrestling for you because you don't even have a track record with them. If you have been with them for a longer period of time, then YOU need to make a decision about what would be best. From my experience, the grass isn't always greener on the other side.

by craig_b

I would wait until you have a firm offer from the full time position. Once you have that offer you will have a choice to make, either take it or stay where you are and take a chance that the temp will become perm.

To help make that choice, list all the things you would want in your perfect job, the type of work, environment, benefits, etc. Then which choice seems closer to what you want? Take some time and choose.

Then you will be able to know that you have gone in the right direction and will be able to explain to anyone why you chose that direction. Also, if a company decides to change the parameters of your employment, then you can review your plan and see if it makes sense.

Good Luck

by sjohnson175

until I have a written offer.

I also plan to request to come tour the new place if I get an offer. I'd like to check out the environment and get a handle on exactly what technology and applications I'd be assigned to initially.

That seems like a reasonable request.

by drmemory

You cannot have a conflict unless you have a choice. When the choice appears, you must act to fulfill what you are contractually and professionally obligated to do. A permanent position is likely to offer some degree of flexibility on start date, the contract you have gives you an out that defines the risk placed on your taking the assignment (i.e. small).
The best of both worlds is having the opportunity to move on/up to permanent from a successful (not necessarily complete) conclusion to your current contract. List your options and decision criteria moving down from the ideal.

by sjohnson175

my question was more of an ethical one and those sometimes take the longest when I have trouble arriving at the win-win situation (always my ultimate goal).

If another offer materializes I want to be ready to act rather than foot-drag over the ethics.

by keith2468a

I would see ethics would be more of an issue if either:

1. You were received considerable training and bailed shortly afterward.

2. You were a key player (project leader, senior analyst, etc.) and bailed several months into a long project.

It is normal for contract work to pay more than full time work -- 30 to 70% more on an hourly basis -- due to the uncertainty that occurs near the end of projects, the need to bridge your income to the next project, to provide your own holidays, health insurance, disability insurance, etc.

So it sounds like your current client and the agency got you on the cheap if you can get a full time permanent job for similar pay.

I would see no problem for you leaving for a considerably better position, especially if it occurs in the first month on the job, you aren't getting training, you aren't a key player, and you are being under paid for the contract nature of the job.

This discussion is closed to new replies.