Discussion Locked

Why we just don't understand the RIAA's train of thought

0 helpful
38 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

For years (with me it was since 8-tracks) we have been scratching our heads wondering exactly what makes an 'organization' like the RIAA tick. I have seen some pretty stupid moves by the RIAA over the last 20 or so years, and they never cease to amaze me.

So I tripped on an article on their website today and had to laugh, are these guys for real? Perhaps the complete idiot would not see through their smoke and mirror analogies and stats, but anyone here can that's for sure.

TITLED:
[b]The CD: A Better Value Than Ever[/b]
http://76.74.24.142/F3A24BF9-9711-7F8A-F1D3-1100C49D8418.pdf

Here's where these guys have their heads:
"Positioned within an increasingly competitive entertainment marketplace, the
CD has become a better value than ever before, according to a newly updated
comparative analysis by the Recording Industry Association of America. While
many forms of entertainment have increased in price in both nominal and real
costs, the cost of a CD has actually decreased in real terms, and is on an
inflation-adjusted basis less expensive today than it has ever been.

The numbers are up and down, even mentioning that a vinyl album was over $20.00, but we all remember the $3.99 versions when they started pressing crap vinyl not even strong enough to wallpaper the kitchen with.

So now they are on about how cheap CD's have become, compared to such entertainment as a live concert (which has gone up due to increasing travel costs, added security costs, higher wages for tour staff, much lower income from recording with the RIAA gouging the artist etc.

But this they see as a relevant comparison to CD costs. On the other hand, CD production costs are a mere fraction of what they once were, the price has dropped but not consistently, some years actually saw a hike in CD costs, but not the production costs.

They are comparing an industry with a constantly inflating cost, to a mirror of a commodity industry with a constantly lowering cost.

But hey, it looks good when they show you how cheap CD's are now....I suppose.

No wonder nobody cares about them anymore.

[b]RIAA- Proudly ripping off artists since 1952![/b]

38 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

ran on tracks leaving the station of 'Suck All the Money We Can Out of All the People We Can'.

by pgm554

it was 90215 by Yes and I was glad to find it!

However,they were all promising that the price and availability of CD' s would improve.

List price on most new Cd's are still at about $18.99.
So what we have is another hummjob by the record companies.
They ,unlike the government ,never lie!

by oz_media

Great CD, great era for cheesy pop music made by talented artists who sold out to the big four(I still load the car and MP3 with the 80's, manage 80's metal bands and Dj 80's dances).

I sometimes use Owner of a Lonely Heart as a speaker demo disk (intro is a good test of driver excursion speed and accuracy), when people can't appreciate audiophile demo music. I get a choice piece of a Chesky recoding to demonstrate soundstage and some people want to hear pop music instead. Uh, that's fine but pop doesn't push a speaker ya know. :)

by tig2

Ahh! Memories. Where did I put that iTunes icon?!?

90125 is one that I would happily pay the price for in physical CD. Excellent music!

by jaqui

I thought they couldn't even work up a good link for a chain never mind a train ;)

by jaqui

the uproar when cassettes were first introduced.

"they would lose money from people copying the tapes!!!"

when home cd burners were introduced

"they will lose money from people copying cds!!!"

gee, those kind of sound like

"they will lose money from people downloading music!!!"

which is RIAA's current call to arms. :D

by oz_media

One of my first sales jobs was in retail Audio. I remember when JVC brought our a dual cassette deck, the RIAA imposed a levy on all blank tapes.

There are still many people who feel teh RIAA is an independant, governing body, when in fact the RIAA is actally manned, governed and operated mainly by the big four.

They have simply built their own governing body to ensure that THEY can reap/rape more money.

by jdclyde

college football and the NCAA....

Lots of money flying around, but not to the players? hmmmmmmm.

by jdclyde

them saying the price of CD's would come down once the technology became standardized.

Guess they are still working on standardizing it, huh?

The COSTS to produce the CD was so much less than the Cassette, yet the PRICE was still double the Cassettes? Was BS then, it is BS now.

The way to keep people from burning copies of their CD's is to lower the costs to buy it, so that it won't be WORTH the time to make a copy.

I really cut back in how many CD's I buy ever since RIAA and little Napoleon Lars started suing the fans. Something that still makes me laugh since free distribution is how Metalica got their start.

by oz_media

The physical cost of the materials is lower, AND the production costs were much higher back then.

In many cases today, the record companies get prerecorded material and simply tweak and engineer it to industry standards (which are lower and lower all the time).

When cassetes were made, it was analogue boards, hours upon hours of adding new tracks and dumping thousands of feet of tape in the trash. Today it is point and click editing with the many artists spending just a little time in the studio, especially when studio musicians are brought in to rerecord tracks the bad f'ked up in the first session.

SHITE, BOLLOCKS I TELL YOU! :)

by rfink

I remember that campaign from the late 1970's. It ran in all of the record stores.
If I bought an album in 1980, why should I have to pay the artist a second royality today because the physical media failed? I should be able to download the music because I bought the license when I bought the album.
Your thoughts, please.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I've already paid a premium price for an album. I should be able to acquire the CD without cost. What happens when they decide to quit manufacturing turntables?
Tyrants!

by oz_media

In the case of an artist spending cash to release independant material and using quality reproduction services to produce it, I will always buy their material, even if i need a new copy, it's a personal issue I support independent artists and often offer my services gratis, with minor residuals only.

In the case of the Big Four scamming a band into recording with little or no benefit to the artist, I am all for P2P. the artist doesn't benefit unless you buy their concert ticket, t-shirt, hat, banner, program, headband, keychain, wallet, stickers...the lot.

I know many bands who benefit from P2P, in fact most do and even the big four even release material online to see what will sell and which tracks to make singles. I can't stand conglomerates whi buy out everyone in the industry in a bullish tactic to lead the industry. The RIAA is simply an umbrella name for eth big four, who have already bought everyone else out of market.

If you can stick the boots to the RIAA, don't forget to get a good backswing in first.

by jdclyde

If you buy ANYTHING, it will wear out.

A TV will wear out.

A shirt will wear out.

A Video game will wear out.

Just because you bought something on BATA, does that mean you should also get a free VHS, and then a DVD copy as well?

You bought a DVD, but wish you had BlueRay. You are not going to get it again "free" just because you bought a copy before on a different media.

You paid for something, and it broke or wore out. Everything does.

That is not a convincing argument for P2P sharing.

Just my thoughts. B-)

by oz_media

I agree in the case of upgrading fornmats. I was personally referrign to when you buy a CD and want more than one copy (car, MP3 player etc.). As for downloading music to begin with, anythign I feel is worth listening to is either old, offered by an artist, or somethign I need for a quick play and already have teh cassette, CD, album etc. somewhere but am too lazy to look for.

I see your point about format upgrades though. In the case of some material, Pink Floyd The Wall for example, I have the CD, DVD, have bought many copies on vinyl, VHS etc. If I want to hear Floyd, I'll download a good copy, if I can't find anything 320 or over I will rip it myself.

by tonythetiger

I am paying for the right to enjoy the performance that is recorded onto the media, at the time I wish to enjoy it.

by rfink

I don't have a problem paying for the media. The CDs, cassette, whatever. I should not have to pay the royality more than once. It's the same music regardless of what format it's in. Besides it was the RIAA advertising "buy it once, enjoy it a lifetime."

by boxfiddler Hot topic

anything will wear out, my lp's are not likely to wear out in my lifetime. I take very good care of them. But I would not be surprised to see - in my lifetime - the death of the turntable. This is a 'backwards compatibility' issue.

by oz_media

Just an FYTI, because many people don't really know what the RIAA means when saying residuals for the artist.

IN teh case of residual income, radio play, commercials etc. It's not the 'artist' that gets the royalties or sees the levy from blank CD's.

It is the songwriter that gets residuals, not the performer. This goes for CD levy too, you aren't supporting your favorite band, you are supporting their label, who in turn supports the writers.

I am sure many people would hae a different view on P2P if they knew exactly who got the money. As it sits now, they have collected billions on CD levies and they are simply sitting in limbo, writers are dead, labels are gone (or bought up by the big four)etc.

So there is all our CD levy money sitting there doing nothing, if they aren't going to use it as intended, I'd like to have mine back so I can collect interest instead of the RIAA bastards.

rant over, have a nice day y'all.

by jdclyde

Making an MP3 for personal use, or burning a copy of a CD (for yourself) so you don't have the original sliding around in your car, are all things that I allowed to do (as I understand the laws).

I don't like to leave originals in the car. Who wants to have $200 worth of CD's laying around? I have GOT to get a player that will play mp3's in my car.

My boy was VERY geeked out for Christmas. He got The Wall on CD. B-) Both of the boys are hooked, because I recently showed the movie "The Wall" for them. It is cool when kids love great music instead of the sheeeet that is so abound these daze..... They love Priest as well... :D

by oz_media

Your dedication to getting your boys into a real world of music has always given me hope. Halford and the gang would be proud of you (took them to a Maiden concert too, didn't you? Ozzfest?)! It's nice to know I'm not the only one who knows a real ARTIST when he sees one.

by jdclyde

Ever since they were about 8, I have been taking them to show.

We hit DTE in Clarkston (Pine Knob) all the time and all the 70/80/90's bands have been coming there with four or five band playing.

They have seen Maiden as well as several trips to the G3 tours. Then of course took them to a Mudvayne down in Detroit. THAT was an education for them..... I don't play in those mosh pits and they see why. they get mean. :D

It helps that I don't ALLOW rap in my house. B-)

by oz_media

I figured JD meant he needed one but hadn't got around ot doing it yet, as for MP3 players for cars they are everywhere.

Crappy Tire (Canadian Tire) sells a noname deck for about $80.00 CDA which accepts qa flash drive, plays just about any disk etc.

I figured they were all going that way now.

by jdclyde

Hadn't looked for one yet, but figured they would have something like this around.

It has just been a hell of a last year. Blew up three motors, totaled a car, ThingOne broke his hand (skateboarding), ThingTwo snapped his collar bone on the friggen FIRST day of wrestling practice, and now my furnace has died. Getting by with a space heater for now till I can get this worked out. [i]~sigh~

If anyone has an extra four leaf clover or horse shoe, send it my way, will ya?

by jdclyde

There are many choices in format that you can purchase the performance on, and you have to pay for each format that you wish.

Good luck getting free bluerays just because you have an old VHS laying around.

by tonythetiger

that the original publisher should be required to re-record it to your media of choice :)

(I seen your message RE: Car MP3 Players... I recall seeing something that replaced your CD changer... I'll find it again and get back to you. (What kind of car?)

by jdclyde

had to change to a smaller car because gas is killing me. I am down to about $100 a week for gas.

by jdclyde

it just might last you a lifetime.

I have MANY albums that work just fine. Of course I don't have a working turntable to play them on, but the RIAA isn't responsible for that. Neither are they for scratches and warping.

I also have a case of cassettes from back in the late 70's that still work just fine, that I pull out from time to time during my lifetime.

No where in the "buy it once" does it say anything about upgrades in media, now does it?

by oz_media

And you can actually get a good quality release too, as it is has been released many times.

Nice dynamics, good compression (in the original mixing not the digital file)a great CD (was a great show too)!

by tonythetiger

when looking for something for myself. The one I found simply plugs into the changer plug in my trunk and works just like the CD changer from inside (except each "CD" can have up to 99 songs on it). Prior to that I just plugged my Ipaq into a $9 cassette adapter :)

by oz_media

I was wondering if perhaps they weren't sold in the US due to some ridiculous copyright law or something.

by jdclyde

When your raising twin teen boys on your own, one of my two pay checks goes to food and gas. The other is the house and other costs of living.

It sucks putting other peoples needs before your wants..... :(

by jdclyde

over the last decade or so.

Can't say how GOOD they are, (but I bet OZ could!).

Backwards compatibility for music or anything else in life is the problem of the purchaser. If you have a 50 year old car, who's problem is it if you can't fine a part?

There are MANY things I LOATH about the Music industry [i](the wh0res they are)[/i] but this isn't something I can or will blame them for because I can't think of a single other product that doesn't do the exact same thing.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Cool! While I have been spending some time moving my favorite LP's to CD, the prospect of doing so for all of them is daunting. The last time I purchased a turntable (10 or so years ago) it was quite difficult to find one. I think perhaps I will start shopping for a spare or 2. :)

by armstrongb

The RIAA is brain dead, I totally agree. Their tactics are reprehensible and they will die a slow painful death I hope.

I recently purchased the new John Fogerty and Radiohead disks and a 2 disk set of concerts by the Flying Burrito Bros from 1969. Radiohead cost $7, Fogerty $10 and the Burrito Bros $13. My sales tax was less than $3 on top of the $30 with no DRM issues.

Yes, I know there was a time where I could have downloaded the Radiohead files and not pay a dime. But I like the band and 128kbs MP3s sound thin to me.

The CD sound quality is light years better than mp3 and I have already ripped them to my iPod and Sandisk players. If I purchased all of these from iTunes or Amazon ala carte the price would be over $50 but that cost to me would be less if I bought them as albums as most of you know.

While AAC and 256kbs MP3s are not bad formats the CD sound quality is much better when I use my high fidelity surround sound system in my home versus the crappy headphones that come with most iPods and iPod wannabees. If I am going to buy music than I want the best fidelity possible.

by oz_media

Way to step up to the plate, I have met way too many deadbeat dad's in my time.

It was pretty hard for me in my 20's too, with only one son to support; you've earned my respect for that alone.

I think TR should buy you one for all of your participation here, perhaps if we all stand up, it'll be anarchy!

This discussion is closed to new replies.