Discussion Locked

XP forced by marketplace terrorists

0 helpful
32 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am not an anti-Microsoft radical. I'm learning Linux because it's interesting to me and MS does need competition, but it's really not that bad. Who hates the conveniences Microsoft has offered?
However, I have been forcibly moved to the rant sector. I am developing an app in VB that has been designed to use an Access 2000 database. My boss has dragged his feet about providing the Access software I needed until one day he wondered why the database portion wasn't done yet. Anyway, on Wednesday, I received a box of Access and put it down for later installation. My attention was diverted for a couple of days by the Nimda virus. When it's back to business, lo and behold, my new Access is of the XP(2002) variety! I had already decided to boycott XP because I'm not sure it's entirely compatible with VB6(despite what they may say)and I must protest MS's well-known dictatorial practices with XP. So, I call my supplier to return it. Two days later, they call back to inform me that it can't be done. Access 2000 is no longer on any retail shelves. They even called MS to get just a LICENSE for a copy of Access 2000, but they will not sell them one. Is this not illegal? (I mean clearly, not a matter of interpretation.) Are we going to be forced by this fascist regime to pay for this crap? If I cave in or am forced by the suits to make do, will I have to upgrade everything else? Will I be forced to pay tribute for support every time I wipe out my hard drive and reinstall this XP morsel of anti-consumer terror? I didn't think breaking them up was a good idea, just sour grapes from those who couldn't. But who can really argue now? I know the world is in an uproar over more serious things, but can we let the Evil Empire use this for cover? A terrorist is one who uses such tactics for their own agenda. Who will stand with me in the fight against these marketplace terrorists?

32 replies

by pxttocyob

Yes it is marketplace terrorism. The tactics are not the same but the intention is just as bad. They are laughing in our faces because they can be a monopoly and nobody will stop them. It is extortion by any definition.

by terrent

Yes, thanks. Extortion is perhaps the more appropriate term here. It implies that we're being forced to live and or pay in a way not of our own choice.

by rommi

It is true that Microsoft uses somewhat forced tactics especially nowadays, since Windows 2000 is not selling, Office XP is not selling and MCSEs such as myself are not getting recertified in Windows 2000 / XP track.

In Microsoft?s defense I would like to point out the following. They are the greatest company when it comes to support and issues like that. I played with Linux as well, but dropped it for lack of information and it?s complexity. Show me any product provider of which has something equivalent to MSDN online, which is FREE.

The point is Microsoft is business like any other, if they have to do what they have to do, to provide me for FREE with what they do, I will live with it and find ways around. Buy Access 2000 from ebay.com.

by wayne m.

You seem to have far better luck in getting questions answered by Microsoft than I have. Microsoft truly has the worst technical support of any company I have dealt with.

It is virtually impossible to talk to a knowedgeable Microsoft developer because they are completely screened by their help desk, and the typical answer from the help desk is reinstall the application. Most Microsoft support is provided through non-Microsoft personnel via mailing lists.

I have been a long time Microsoft developer, but I can only feel growing frustration about incompatible software releases, forced upgrades, and having to pay exhorbent fees to so-called "help desk" people who don't have the slightest inkling of the underlying technology.

by qballrail

It appears to me that MS is making a very large campaign to control what the user does with one's own PC. I can understand in a corporate setting, being an IT professional myself, however what a consumer does in one's own home is their own business. I understand from beta testers that XP requires the home user to reactivate after a certain time or number of program installs. MS is nothing more than technological terrorists themselves!

by bill cromwell

My employer beleives they are a Novell shop but we have the creeping Microsoft disease. I have personally spent the money for MS licensing on my own home network and been disappointed.

I am moving into Linux systems and preparing to support "Linux shops" even though I know I'll be changing employers as well (the suits beleive the MS hype). Does anybody need Back Office, Win2000, MS Office suite, or a bunch of NT and 9x licenses?

Vote with your wallets.

Bill

by ttrinh

I totally understand your pain and frustration, and think you have a perfectly valid reason to gripe, but to use this term to brand Microsoft is cheap and uneducated. It's a childish ploy to use the pains and suffers of thousands to lend strength toyour cause is utterly insensitive.

I want to fight MS on this issue too, but I won't stand with you

Tuan

by terrent

It wasn't my intention to equate MS with the ignorant cowards who recently attacked the US. The similarity between MS and the way that terrorists and fascists force people into a certain way of life just seemed especially striking after my own recent experiences.

by dcrowe

Very brave to want to fight M$ Mr. User Deleted! (or Mrs, as the vase may be!)

What guts and determination!

by ttrinh

This happens to me all the time, I post a reply, and when come back to check, it just post user delted. I also saw this happen to a number of other posts, so I assumed it is a bug. I never intentionally delete my name. How long have you been here ? 5000 points and don't know this bug ?

Oh... and any thing to say about my posts, other than personal attack ?

I checked, and my alias is listed correctly, but just in case it got deleted again, here is my email...in case you want to attack on the minor details again

Tuan

TTrinh@JT-Int.com

by mishratron

You have a license for XP GREAT, read it
you may use an OLDER version because the license is backwards compatable
you can have 100 license for win98 and actually have 100 stations with win95 on them
All licensing is abckwards compatable just notforwards compatable
why should MS care if you use an older version if you paid for the new one and are not using it ?
This is how my company has survived audits by the BSA
Thank you and please calm down

by terrent

Thanks for the tip. I really mean that. Problem is: by opening the package I agree to the license agreement but I have to open the package to read it, so I must accept the agreement before I read it.

My supplier is now calling MS to confirm this backwards licensing thing. If it works, I can accept that an unused copy of Access XP will sit in my desk drawer, but how will this send a message to MS?

I reiterate: before this, I thought those Netscape guys were just a bunch of whiners and cryers.

by admin

"Pralines and Cream" with "Pralines and Cream XL" -pulling the former from the shelf- I'm sure some people would cry unfair. Still, it's their business, and no-one is forcing anyone to enjoy their product. This is not Terrorism by any stretch of theimagination. Microsoft is NOT a government program, not a basic human right and not the only option. I have never seen anyone's life threatened by choosing not to use MS, unless you consider not making larger amounts of money life threatening.

I also work for a place where we still use 9x and O97 on workstations. The last licenses we bought were WinME and 02k, which were promptly downgraded without ever leaving the cellophane.

by admin

The license is used, and that's all you own. You never own Access XP. An "unused copy of Access XP" will not be in your drawer, and you will be using the license. If you feel bad about wasting resources to get the disks and packaging, get your employer into a business licensing program.

All you ever buy from them is the right to use one of their Access products at a time, the disks, packaging, etc. are just a complimentary part of some (not all) distributions of their product. The only official item you are buying that means anything is the EULA. You can have a hundred disks and boxes and absolutely no legal licenses from MS. Your only other hope in an audit is that a court see's your reciepts from reputable re-sellers as close enough to proof, although MS, if you talk to them says only the EULA.

I believe they still post sample EULA's on the MS website (although I sometimes wonder if they intentionally hide them). The last one I read there actually disallowed networking with a non-MS product in a LAN, near as I could understand. A good thing to know before you buy....

by admin

old software. The only thing you ever purchased is the right to use it. You CAN still purchase the right to use the old software. The packaging is incidental.

by generalist

If 'Pralines and Cream XL' were as good as the original and was fully compatible with my taste buds (bio-operating system) and other senses (bio-applications), I wouldn't have a problem with it.

But if they failed to meet miminal requirements, I would reluctantly drop 'Pralines and Cream XL' from my list of preferred products and consider mixing up my own variation (Vanilla and toppings Linux...)

by admin

So if you preferred P&CXLand were happy with it, and B&R also was pushing it because their net per serving showed a 50% increase over the old P&C, it really wouldn't matter much if their were a lot of upset people considering that the business was prospering, the shareholders happy, etc.

I like Linux too, but beyond my original point that this is NOT terrorism by any means, I would have to say that this plan is very successful business wise. It's not only the cost of the OS, it's all the related upgrades, new certs, classes, tech support revenue and kickbacks from other companies. This is a GREAT business model that is extremely successful, and it may be other things (possibly immoral, unfair, violating anti-trust laws etc.), but it's not consumer terrorism.

It is a popular product, and people seem to naturally gravitate to thinking that Coca-Cola is "their" drink and that Corvettes "have" to be made a certain way. In truth, MS, Coke, and Chevrolet do keep an eye on the public,but it doesn't drive the business model until, of course, the public stops buying. -which gets around to , I believe, your point.

No one is running a Microsoft free shop that I know of. Outrageous complaining does naught, lack of monetary support does wonders.

I see posts here occasionally calling for boycott, but really, IMHO, we buy it because it does meet our needs for the purposes at hand.

by generalist

MS products meet a need for compatibility between different computers. So when you get down to specifics, people buy MS products because they SHOULD be compatible with other MS products.

What ultimately happens is that organization 'A' buys MS products because then need to exchange data with organization 'B'. And organization 'B' buys MS products because they need to exchange data with organization 'A'.

Call it a system of self fulfilling purchases. Neither ogranization wants to risk being out of synch with the other, so the treadmill continues. And if either organization needs to add more computing capacity, the lack of the ability to purchase earlier editions of MS products eventually forces an upgrade.

(Of course, this alsoapplies to other vendors. For example, is it possible to buy a copy of R:Base 4000 nowadays?)

If people want to move from a MS world, they need to agree upon a non-MS standard and demand that everybody they work with stick to that standard. These compatibility 'demands' would be no worse than organizations 'demanding' that things be in a MS format like Word.

It would be hard though. MS products are like the air, hard to live without unless you take special measures.

by admin

I see your point to some extent, and it makes sense. Still, it seems that when this comes up, especially in word processing, that once you use .rtf most people can communicate effectively. Is it that users are so lazy or untrained that they can't dosimple file conversion anymore, or that they really need so many bells and whistles in their documents they can't live without them?

I do see your point however, and must admit that I have seen at least one more major partner of ours finally switch from Wordperfect to MS Word this past year.

by wayne m.

A better comparison would be if Baskin Robbins replaced Pralines and Cream while you were eating it and also replaced the napkins with ones that would not wipe up Praline and Cream drippings.

To carry the analogy further, what if you then discovered the Pralines were not in the ice cream at all and you were forced to additionally purchase Pralines and Cream XL in the hope of finally getting Pralines.

I think this reflects the frustration many long term Microsoft users and developers feel towards the company.

by terrent

Thank you. That's much better. In my case, the Pralines in the ice cream I was eating were hypoallergenic. The new ones threaten to make me swell up like fresh roadkill.

by generalist

You might want to add some of the following 'features' to a very tasty analogy:

- You are charged extra when Baskin Robbins replaces the Pralines and Cream you were in the process of eating.

- You find that that the new Pralines and Cream doesn't quite taste right because of new 'enhancements'.

- You learn that Pralines and Cream XL makes you violently allergic to your favorite form of JAVA.

- You have to reapply for your Baskin Robbins Certified Eater certificate (BRSE) because Pralines and Cream is 'different'.

- You are informed that you will have to keep paying for your Pralines and Cream as long as there is a trace of it in your body. This 'subscription' plan will shut down everything associated with the Pralines and Cream traces.

Hmmmmmm. Can anybody think of additional 'features' while I go out and get a gallon of honest to goodness Pralines and Cream. Talking analogies makes me hungry for the real stuff.

by generalist

From what I've seen, a lot of people don't realize that RTF exists and works well for most purposes. I would estimate that most of this same population barely uses the bells and whistles found in the latest packages.

But mental inertia is a 'wonderful' thing as far as product loyalty is concerned, especially when the product requires an investment in time and training to be useful. And when you add in such things as the 'first love' phenomena and the preponderance of training that is strictly MS oriented, mental inertia reduces the odds of other groups gaining marketshare.

MS would have to make a major marketing mistake and other groups would have to offer more for less in order to reverse this trend.

Another option would be forvarious government agencies to demand that documents NOT be in MS formats. People would then have to learn how to output them in formats like RTF. At that point they might realize that other organizations could receive non-MS formatted documents.

by admin

It would be a great thing though, if Government and other agencies just started posting .rtf in addition to .pdf and .doc

I bet a switch would slowly but powerfully start that would have a lot of inertia behind it soon, especially in this time ofcutbacks and cost savings.

by terrent

I get the backwards licensing thing. I just don't happen to have an old copy of Access 2000 sitting around. The fact that MS so promptly cut off the supply seems to me to be a clear indication of their do-as-I-say business doctrine. By the way, Mike, thanks for the laugh.

by admin

But I honestly don't know for sure which laugh you're thanking me for or what context it is in.... I guess I'm wondering if your laughing with me on the absurdity of the whole thing....

Ah, the difficulty of message boards.....

The funny thingabout copies of old software is that I am confused in my extensive conversations with Microsoft on this. Since the EULA is what they recognize, and backwards licensing is ok, then what's the big deal (if any legally) about having copies floating around. Also, what good are registration numbers? Everytime I've asked them this on backwards licensing they have replied, in the end, that it is the EULA that matters in court. If this is true, why do they bother putting in all the other stuff? Does itjust serve as a marketing ploy to keep people in the dark so that they purchase more software in response to their doubts?

FUD - dangit

:>

by generalist

I know that I have gotten the 'User Deleted' name myself when I post after exceeding some sort of time out. Usually, if it takes me longer than a few minutes to compose a comment I go through a process of saving the message and posting it after signing back in.

That tends to stop most of the 'User Deleted' entries. There have been occasional times when the problem is on TechRepublics side though.

by ttrinh

Thank you for your tip ! It makes a lot of sense. It certainly takes me at least as much time to compose a message. This "bug" puzzles me for a while, and it is especially hard, since it seems to be intermittent. Your observation makes them all fall into place now, and I really appreciate it. Now...let's see if it works, I will do exactly as you suggested.

Cheers,

Tuan

by dcrowe

Tuan,

I apologize for stepping on your toes. As you noted, I have subscribed to TR for quite a while. However, in that time, I have not come across the username deletion issue you stated. From that perspective, the thought of anonymously raging against the M$ machine was particularly amusing. Again, please accept my apology.

Regarding your chastisement for not keeping my comments on point: I too agree with the original issue of forced-marched upgrades, and that 9/11 and M$ have no relation. After reading terrent's rebuttal, I can better appreciate his/her remarks.

I hope this public apology will relieve any hard feelings.

This discussion is closed to new replies.