Discussion Locked

Alienware vs. Dell: What laptop shall I ask Santa to bring?

0 helpful
184 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

An elf told me that I might get a laptop for Christmas (or shortly thereafter). There are two that I've been looking at:

The Alienware Area-51 m5700 (at a special Holiday price)
http://www.alienware.com/product_detail_pages/Area-51_m5700/area-51m_gallery_rside.aspx?SysCode=PC-LT-AREA51-M-5700&SubCode=SKU-DEFAULT#specs

The Inspiron 9300
http://www1.us.dell.com/content/products/productdetails.aspx/entnb_9300?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs

This will replace my home desktop which I use for word processing, lots of Web surfing, music downloading and playing, photo uploading, editing, and posting, etc. I'm also hoping to venture back into the world of the Sims (http://www.maxis.com/) when I get a new system.

Basically, I'm looking for speed, ease of use (a good layout in terms of keyboard, screen, etc.), and the ability to fulfill all my Entertainment needs.

Any opinions on these two?

184 replies

by Erik Eckel

I experienced the same dilemma in August. Partially on a whim, I chose an Apple Macintosh PowerBook.

How much do I like it? Let's just say I'm actively working to replace every Windows system I own and operate with a Macintosh.

Speed? Check. My 1.5 GHz Mac (with half the RAM) easily outpaces my 3.4GHz Sony Vaio.

Ease of use? Please. Apple wins hands down. No need for antivirus software, antispyware programs, weekly security updates, etc. And the GUI? Outstanding.

Ability to fulfill entertainment needs? Unsurpassed. Check out the full iLife suite that comes with most Macs (and you can get the Sims, too).

Think Different!

by Erik Eckel

My reply was on subject. She asked about which laptop was best. I introduced a third option. What's wrong with that?

by cactus pete

You might still consider getting the antivirus, antispyware and security updates. But maybe you're right, no one will EVER compromise your system in any way.

That must be why Apple has so many security updates all the time... At the very least, you should be downloading and installing those.

And the original question was between competing x86 based systems. There's a good chance that's for a reason.

But that's just me...

by apotheon

MacOS X uses a unified "monolithic" graphical environment and GUI subsystem that undoes a fair amount of the security inherent in a unixy architecture. It's not the kind of unmitigated disaster the Windows architecture has tended to be, all these years, but it's still not what it could be (and was before Apple screwed with it).

It'll be considerably easier to keep the system secure with MacOS X than with Windows, but it still needs to be [b]kept secure[/b]. Absolutely, use those security tools that are available. A virus may have less ability to trash the entire system than on a Windows machine, but it can still wreak incredible havoc within the user environment, since Apple has decided in its infinite wisdom that autorunning executables (one of Windows' biggest security sanfus) is a good idea.

by jcritch

For those of us who need to use a laptop for extended business needs, owning a entertainment laptop just does not cut it.

Enjoy your MAC, more power to you :)

by conquistador

I'm not trying to be difficult by asking this question. It's a serious question. I work as an IT consultant, and my Alienware Area 51 can run circles around any computer that I use at the office with any application. What types of business needs can it not handle?

by mjwx

I think she was after a laptop that she could USE. A Macintosh cannot use most windows or Linux software (this includes most games I.E the sims). Also Macintoshes are notoriously difficult to use (especially for a non-techie type) and provide little in the way of connectivity with other platforms.

I do tech support for a small web/graphic design company which is part of a small enterprise here is oz and trying to get the 3 Macs to use the corporate email system is a pain in the *** and that is the beginning of my problems.

Now Beth, seeing as alienware doesn?t sell much here in the lucky country (we ausies call ourselves that, BTW ausie is pronounced ozzy as in Ozzy Ozzborne) so I can?t recommend which one you get but please don?t get a Mac it?s a headache you don?t need.

PS I hope no one finds this patronizing (except possible the 2 or 3 percent of the IT world that call themselves Mac users).

by biomood

ok this might be a bit off topic but I've been using an apple
ibook for the last 5 months, first thing is that macs do have
equivalent software such as Mac Office, Gimp, FileMaker, and
they also have the Sims, all the expansion packs and the Sims 2,
secondly they aren't notoriously difficult to use, thy are on par
with windows, if not easier. Thirdly they can connect with other
platforms, at the moment I'm connected to a wireless network
that runs off my windows pc with no problems, am able to open
shared folders and printers. It has never caused me any
problems, I use both XP and OSX,

by apotheon

You must be working with MacOS 8 or 9. MacOS X doesn't fit that description at all.

by apotheon

MacOS X is proof that it's easier to make unix pretty than Windows stable and secure.

by bkittel

Don't bother getting an Apple even if you're considering it until at least spring when Apple announces the new Pentium-M based laptops release date. The older systems will be stuck running emulators until you upgrade them in a few years.

Btw you should run AV and Anti-malware on any machine as there are still plenty of things you can pickup with osx.

My counter apple suggestion Think Different get a Linux laptop... don't support the man at all. ;)

by cactus pete

But I have fallen off of the Dell bandwagon lately. I have not tried Alienware, and I may never try them. But I have a better feeling about them than I do Dell these days.

Just to point out one thing about Erik's suggestion: My wife's PowerBook is great for her business needs, but somewhat less hot for her personal needs. She often can't get into certain web sites (for instance) if they are custom designed for the newest version of IE, or at least a version higher than 5.5. Often, scripts don't run properly...

by mgorsha

... but is someone codes their site to depend upon IE 6.x+ features,
is that the fault of the PowerBook / Apple, or is that a web
developer not working hard enough?

Personally, I prefer the PowerBook - I fix enough Win problems
during the day at work, and I'll typically be able to have sites and
scripts work with one of the 4 different browsers I have on my Mac.

by cactus pete

it doesn't matter whose fault it is if you can't pay your bills online. If you can't update your contact information after you move... You still can't do it.

So the point is, conform a little, and you'll be happier.

by smorty71

"Alienware vs. Dell," your response would have been on topic. Apple wasn't one of the choices. Not everyone wants to drink the Apple Kool-Aid (no matter how tasty you claim it to be). :)

by deejay54

I can't speak for the Alienware, however I bought a Dell 6000 recently for personal use. (took a screwing on the rebate)Be careful!!! After uninstalling all of the junk that I didn't need and all of the startup items, it turned out to be a very nice machine.

by antuck

Between the two I would probably try the Alienware laptop.

I like the fact they are using the SATA interface for the hard drive. The SATA makes a big difference when reading and writing to hard drives. Although, this is the first laptop I have seen with SATA installed. Just on that fact I maybe a little hesitant because it is new to the laptop. But they have had SATA in desktops and I haven't seen any issues with it yet. Also the fact you can add a second drive in the laptop is great. I looked and replacement drives are about even par with IDE drives.

I know Alienware gained a name with the gamer crowd. I was some what surprised to see they were offering an Intel chip. Most of the desktops I have seen have been AMD chips.

I've seen the Dell 9300 and it is a nice laptop. I'm just getting burned out on Dell anymore. There customer support I have had several issues with them and don't care for them. But the 9300 is a nice laptop.

Good luck in your choice. I'm sure either laptop will perform very well.

by beth blakely

You've hit the nail on the head with the "gamer" comment. My husband is an avid PC gamer and it was he who started the Dell vs. Alienware debate. According to most of those who've chimed in, I think I'm losing. I don't mind much, though. I just want a great system.

by antuck

Maybe to help you out becareful of getting a gamer system if your not and your husband is. You may not use the laptop as much. It will be ok I'll be off in just a couple of seconds and then a couple of hours later...

But then I still can't recommend the Dell. There customer support has dropped so bad I would buy almost anything but Dell.

On the Alienware laptop, I didn't look but do they offer an AMD chip for the laptop?

I know Alienware's desktops offer the AMD chip. If the laptop does have the AMD chip, I would consider that (well ok I would get the AMD chip but that is me) You can generally get the AMD systems a little cheaper. And if it's the 64 bit chips, AMD is really shinning brightly with them.

by reality.bytes

if you are an individual consumer purchasing a dell product and you need customer support, you will probably learn to hate dell. if you are a medium to large sized business, and you are willing to pay a few dollars extra for the next business day service level or the 4-hour response level, you will not be unhappy. in the past two years, i have converted our entire network of four servers and 70 desktops to a 100% dell network. i've only had to call tech support four times in two years, and each time was a pleasant experience, with immediate response and fully satisfactory results. dell resolved one issue over the phone, and replaced one hard drive, one cpu and fan, and one power supply. three of my calls to tech support were answered by a us-based tech within 60 seconds of placing the call. the fourth call involved two transfers and a four-minute hold time.

now if you want to hear me badmouth dell, just ask me about the non-technical side. in two years, i have been shifted from one account representative to the next about a half dozen times. sometimes the new account representative neglects to let me know and i can spend several days just trying to track down who my account representative is to get a quote for a new pc. and their accounting and finance people are even worse. for two years now, i have been trying to get our account straightened out so that it has the correct company name, the correct contact name (me), and the correct account history. the non-technical side of dell is seriously screwed up.

getting back to the original question, if the laptop is for fun, choose the alienware. if it's for business, purchase the dell, but buy it at costco, where you will get premium level support.

by ga_itgyrl

I had been looking to buy a high end Inspiron but decided on the Latitude D810 with the 3 year business warranty. A better machine overall and tech support won't be an issue. Paid about $2k. As far as gaming goes... it has the horsepower, video is OK, but not great sound. I have a Sony Playstation 2 for that! No-hassle gaming there.

by sql_joe

Last December I bought a DELL Desktop for myself and my daughter bought a laptop. We both love our systems and couldn't have asked for a better computer. So far hers has been running great, but with mine an issue did creep up. Fortunatly, the system has all kinds of warning devices in it, so it warned me that my hard disk was going bad, which gave me time to do backups.

I then called DELL with the problem. The call was immediatly answered (in India) and the problem figured out. That's where my problems began. The tech said I needed a new hard drive, so they would go through the "sub contractor" to get it taken care of. I notified him that I was a tech and would prefer to do the install myself. He said I could, but that he didn't want me to, and therefore could not authorize it. (Yes, I said WANT, not RECOMMEND). He then gave me HIS number to call direct if I needed to, and the subcontractor number I had to call to get a technician to come to my house and replace the drive and reload the operating system, drivers etc (the reload is why I was not allowed to replace my own). Armed with the numbers and a work order number, I made the call.

An hour later, the call was finally answered (again from India). I made an appointment to have a tech show up at my home at 5PM. I was also notified that the tech would call me by 10AM the morning of the appointment to verify. On the day of the appointment no call. I get home and am notified that a young man had come to the house and pushed his way in saying he had to fix the computer. This was at 2PM. My daughter tried to protest, since she was home alone at the time, at which point he was quite rude. She showed him to my computer. 5 minutes later he was gone. (Yes, she got lectured about letting people in the house).

So, I am at home, its 5PM, and the tech has already done everything. A bit miffed about the rudeness of teh tech, I boot up the machine. Disk Error. Its not formatted. Lovely. I call teh special number my tech from DELL gave me. I sit on the phone over an hour. When its finally answered, its the subcontractor! I explain the situation. They say they can't help me and that its not their job to reload the DELL drivers, OS, etc.

I call DELL. 5 minutes later I am talking to a tech. He tells me its not the tech's job to reload but that he would be glad to help me. I ask him why they told me that I couldn't do my own HD replacement because the tech was required to reload the system. He says he has no idea. He is very helpful and efter going through the secret HD reloading routine I am up and running.

I file a complaint about the sub-contract company, the long wait times, and the rude tech who failed to keep his appointments.

For the next week I get inundated with calls asking why I filed a complaint when my service was obviously so good. Finally, I am sent a questionare which I fill out honestly. Finally, they stop bothering me.

The GOOD: Its a great computer, and it now works again.

The BAD: Support is hell, and if you complain, they will call you over and over again to try and talk you out of it.

The WORST: They don't even do their own support; so while DELL's call wait times are low, you have no idea what you're getting for the REAL SUPPORT.

Even though I love my DELL, I will never buy another one again!

George

by patsn

I have purchased Dell products since 1989. Only in the past year has support become really awful. The foreign support staff does not know how to address problems. They have learned the old trick - "you must replace your (pick a package - operating system, word, etc) before I can help you." they know that most persons will not do that. Then they give you a call back number and get off the phone.
The purchasing operation is no better. They have lost two of my orders in the past year. The orders were for discounted units. When I call to follow up, they offer some other device, at no discount, or a lesser discount than the original.
Dell himself is a good businessman. I am convinced that he is not aware that support has reached such a miserable level. It was a good company, but I will not do business with them again. Service was one of the keys to their success, and that key no longer exists. Sad state of affairs.
I recommend that you try the Alienware device, it cannot be any worse than Dell.

by Erik Eckel

Apparently suggesting a third option is against the rules, so I'll try again. I vote for the Alienware system.

I researched several laptop models in August. I narrowed the list to three models (basing my research on the same factors you state). The Alienware was third on my list (the second-placed candidate boasted performance equal to the Alienware's, but it was slightly less expensive, hence the better grade).

by mgorsha

... is not out of the question, at least not the way the original post
was worded. The original post finsihed with 'Any opinion on these
two?'

So if your opinion is that you would recommend a third option ...
well, then, there you have it!
[mpg]

by mike

Dell has customer support issues, Alienware is much more expensive... My suggestion? Take a look at ABS (ABSPC.com). Very configurable, great customer service, much less expensive than AW... I could go on. The most important thing is they are ready to roll out of the box. No need to spend hours removing bloatware you dont want or need.

by jmgarvin

I HATE my old Dell Inspirion 8100. Not only is it clunky, but it always had fan problems and a high pitched whine that would drive you insane.

I also would pick the Alienware for gaming because it is just built better (SATA is nice)

The big question is, will Santa bring me one too?

by stargazerr

If I were you I would go with Alienware ... I dont feel very good about Dell at the moment ..

The SATA addition is good to have ....

But in favor of Dell, They have excellent product support and are quite cheap ... but I still root for alienware

]:)

by blondefriend

The Alienware is better equipt plus is battery is better. Dell laptop batteries have a 6 month warranty and they normaly go bust after that e have had to replace numerus dell bateries.

by brad mankoff

At the company I work for we just went through the IBM v Dell and Dell won. The battery warranty is 1 year. Support is better than any company I have ever delt with. Keep in mind that Dell computers are more business orientated and Alienware is more multimedia geared.

by dr. tarr

Dell is a good systems provider if you need a bunch of identical systems, or if you are willing to pony up for the gold level support plan. If you are an individual or a small business with only a few systems, I recommend that you include a speaker phone in your purchase because although (in my experience) the tech at dell have been competent enough, which really means the tier one knows when to escalate to tier two knows when to escalate to tier three, you still have to listen to the dell advertising for a long time between answering the script readers questions.

Unlike the majority or the responses I have seen, my only experience with Alienware has been in a massively large corporate environment. I have had no (read that as 0.00%) unscheduled downtime with these systems. We use them to encode and stream sound and light as part of an international videoconferencing and presentation network. The down side of that is that I have absolutely no idea how their tech support works when the thing finally breaks. I kind of like it that way.

by jkaras

People who want to show off that they have money or have a gaming computer choose Alienware, that's what you are paying for. If you buy an Alienware computer you better play something with a more graphical intense game than the Sims. Why have something that good to play solitaire?
If your gaming is something along those lines dont waste a porshe on getting groceries. Both laptops will give you what you need. I will give the nod on Alienware's support, it's bar none. They will even tweak your computer if you feel it isnt performing to your standards, Dell wont. Dell's support really sucks. That's my personal opinion, its marginal if you have a business account, the public support is bad. Also know that if you have an Alienware laptop, you have a huge target on your back to get stolen, so letting people know or see it isnt advised. Basically you can make your own decision of which cool car you want to drive. Me personally? I would make a kick butt pc to everything I want or need to do that is upgradable, laptops you cant upgrade too much. If you get a laptop it better be for earning you money doing business, otherwise it is only a cool expensive toy.

by 120721-000083

For what it's worth, I've seen an Alienware laptop in action and was impressed. Last Xmas my brothers, cousins, and some friends got together for a full day of gaming. One of my cousins brought his new Alienware laptop. Can't remember the model, but it played the games flawlessly(UT, 1942, Rainbow Six Urban Ops)!

by beth blakely

I don't have money, so I'm not trying to show off. I'm considering Alienware because--due to the Holiday pricing--I can get one for nearly what the Dell would cost. If I can buy a Porsche for nearly the same price, wouldn't I want to get my groceries really, really fast?

I've never had a computer who could handle anything more intense than the Sims, so I don't know if I'd like to play those or not. It would be nice to have the ability to at least try, but I'm not about to spend big bucks just to see if I like it. (I sound really committed, don't I?)

I want a laptop so I can roam around the house... I get stiff sitting in one location, and it's bad for creativity.

I won't be taking it out of the house, most likely. I doubt I'll be any more of a theft target than I ever was. (Of course, they're much easier to walk off with, so I might find a special hiding place to store it when it's not in use... so it's not in full view when folks pass by on the street, etc. Good tip there.)

by jkaras

I get your point on bang for the buck, if your needs dictate a powerful laptop. Like I said their support is ungodly fantastic, that is why the premium price. They know how to maximise any computer and their reputation is the most valuable asset, they will not do anyone wrong. I am a gamer and I like only pc desktop for my gaming because the upgrade ability for far cheaper. My anology of laptops and cars are because there is pratical and fun. They depreciate fast and cost money to hot rod. Although Alienware wont depreciate much in price so when you want to roll over for a new one you could unload it for a cheap price easily.

I did like their site that gave upgrade updates when you added or subracted items. Go for their highest support and the respawn. I wouldnt get the remote auto fix, I am not comfortable with someone fixing or peeking around un-noticed, but it sounds like a decent idea for stability, just not sure I trust it.

People tend to go overboard on computers thinking they need the ultimate super fast machine when they dont use it to its potential. Most of the things you listed any three year old laptop could handle. I hope I didnt offend with my post, I just wanted to illustrate the point that you are buying one heck of a laptop that has one purpose;gaming, lots of intense gaming. The problem with the laptop is the upselling that makes it sooo expensive but if you buy one go pretty much all out oncertain things on the Alienware for long term turnaround. Only games need fast processors, video cards, and ram. Basic programs, movies, music, etc.. dont need anything special. My advice get a least 1 gig or splurge for the 2 gig ram it will make the most difference(its great that it has the capacity to reach that high most top out at 1 gig). Next I would get the middle processor, the 1.7, that's plenty fast for even Doom 3 (well maybe a bit low) which I doubt you will play those type of games. I would get the 80 hdd (5400) plenty of space and fast enough. Anything faster is cream, but over priced in my opinion. You can always replace the hdd when they get cheaper, trust me they will and it just plugs in, just wait till after warrantee. Basically put ram, decent processor, and video card is the only prerequisits for a gaming computer, ram being THE MOST IMPORTANT. The other plus is teasing your significant other with your porsche mocking him so close yet so far away. Go with XP Pro and I like media center if you want it. I doubt you will record shows on it unless you have a wireless router with A/G capabilities, home edition really doesnt offer much of anything. If you can sucker the other into buying it for you, then Merry Christmas to you!!!!

by jdclyde

gaming places are springing up all over the place. They will have a room of computers, with all the latest games and a fat pipeline to the internet all set for gaming.

That is where you go to test out games. They have the hardware AND the games and you can try them all out for about $10 for a few hours. When you concider how long it would take at $5 per hour to pay off that gaming computer PLUS games that you would buy it is a LONG time. A low end gaming system is going to run a minimum of $1200 PLUS paying for the monthly internet costs.

They even do lock-ins so it is a huge lan party without having to bring anything!

by w2ktechman

I have never had an Alienware unit, nor a Dell. But, I have worked on Dell systems and have known many people to own a Dell. All of them were very disappointed, to the point of buying other brands the next time they got a system. But, these were all desktop systems. I know 9 people that had a Dell and started hating Dell within 6 months.

by jkaras

They are no longer the little company that could. The yare too big trusting big companies to make products specifically for their computers and taking the lowest bidder to meet the demand. It's sad when a great company gets too big and suffers from supply and demand, not concerned with their reputation first and foremost.

If they got back to basics and did things right again they could take the whole market, seriously. Their support was all about customer service, now they are just trying to keep pace with their sales and demand. Their servers though are rock solid and they appear to be concentrating on their business line since their is a larger profit margin.

I never had Alienware because I am a poor mofo. If I was wealthy I would, but you could build an equal machine for far less, desktop that is. They although know the proper secrets to maximize the pc's potential and be stable, that's what your paying for. Man I would love to work for them!!!!

by dr. tarr

point one: A powerful desktop and monitor isn't that much less than the equivilent desk top.

point two: If you are buying a system, particularly a personal system that isn't going to be replaced by the company in three years, then buy the most powerful system you can afford. You may not need it now, but when which ever OS you are using comes out with their next release, you'll probably need the juice

point three: a home user needs that superb support a lot more than the average corporate user, because the corporate user has geeks like us to take care of them and the home user typically doesn't. I do a lot of home entertainment and automation systems, and I always recommend / specify the company with the best support, particularly if they are not going to write a service contract with me. Even my customers whe write a contract normally don't renew the second year simply because a service contract is pretty expensive insurance for a home user.

by jkaras

"point one: A powerful desktop and monitor isn't that much less than the equivilent desk top." huh? Did you mean laptop? Well if they have a same speed processor and ram specs than yeah they are the same. The difference is scalability. A laptop isnt scalable like a desktop is, that's why a desktop is better.

As for point two. Buying the latest and greatest is a waste of money. Her needs are low processing applications. Only games require uber processors and video cards. The laptop has the primo video card so so choice there. Name one OS that cant run on a processor over 1 ghz? The only future os that is quite demanding is "Windows Vista" which isnt out and not going to be needed for another three years. Even then a 1.7 with ample ram can handle the load. If you ever studied the computer history techology is bled out over time to maximize profit. Originally the market almost collapsed when computer manufacturers doled out the newest twice as fast computer too quickly, lessons were learned. If she was buying a computer to game, not work on they the desktop is the superior choice. She is only using standard apps for simple things, hence waste of money. By a year and a half the top of the line parts will be half price. Her middle of the road extras will still work effectively until the warrantee expires then she chan upgrade a better hdd, dvd burner, maybe more ram. Laptops were designed to be limited on upgrades. Why? So you buy another and get rid of a perfectly good laptop for the new faster didnt make a difference in my programs new toy.

As for point three I agree that a superior warrantee is quite important and weighs in on my judgements on trusting a company with my purchase whether personal or business related. The flip side is Hyundi has the greatest warrantee on their cars to bolster customer confidence, however no one is buying their poorly made car, since it constantly breakdown. Great warrantee, horrible quality that costs more because it's always getting fixed rather than being in use.

I get your points but her needs arent the same as yours, she just needs something to tool around with that has flexability wrinting documents, emails, listening to MP3s, minor gaming that doesnt require more than 128 bit card if that. I like and prefer Alienware's support no question, but what she is buying to make that laptop worth while with the upgrades is quite a premium price.

by rexworld

I don't know if the recent spate of Dell problems includes laptops. But the Dell desktops and servers we've purchased lately here at work have been abysmal. IS has had to replace way too many motherboards and power supplies.

Luckily we've got a next-day service contract with Dell but for a consumer I don't think it's worthwhile. Better to opt for a higher-quality manufacturer than Dell.

by synthetic

I have had to support Dell products, laptops only as all my servers are Compaq/HP or desktops running a MS server product, and I have yet to be satisfied over all with any of the business segment laptops we have purchased over the past 5 years and I feel the design has become more flawed, not less. I have some serious complaints with their tech support as well. I am pleased we no longer use their products and most are on their way out due to age and ending warranties. Not all are bad, not all have needed extensive work, not all calls to their support have been horrid, but that has been the rule! I have no experience to share with you on alienware. Good luck!

by topry

While we use only Latitudes for corporate purchases, we also have a few Inspiron's that employees purchase for home usage. While the Latitudes have performed well, we have had significant issues with the Inspirons (all model 6000s). Most recent was a motherboard replacement.

Since this was a 'home user' we had to suffer through outsourced support (India) which resulted in 3 separate calls over two days and almost 6 hours in total. We were transferred once without notice, disconnected another time and had to deal with 'techs' that could do nothing more than read a script.

Even though all our laptops have the Complete Care warranty (next business day), it was one week after they agreed to replace the motherboard that the service tech (Bantec) arrived. Took him 2 hours and a lot of gnashing of teeth to swap it out. Even then, he left it in Manuf mode and with the internal WiFi disabled.

I've been extremely concerned with the Inspiron quality and after this round of support woes, could not in good conscious recommend them to any 'end-user'.

by too old for it

My trusty WinBook Si croaked this past spring, and if I hadn't needed to replace it on a Sunday, I would have gone with Alienware.

My top of the line WinBook V240 has to go back less than 10 months in because of at least 3 problems, and that is just in the shell.

Glad I bought the 3-year warranty.

L

by rosenjared

I decided to go Apple myself. But accepting the Windows constraint I'd recommend taking a serious look at the Sager notebooks. Sager manufactures the Alienware notebooks. So not surprisingly, Sager's lineup is comparable to Alienware, but more affordable, and without the fancy day-glo color schemes. Real nice looking LCD screen option. As with Alienware they can get heavy. But with two internal Drives and a 2nd aux battery pack and so forth this should be expected. As a data point, for around $1900 I was looking at the Sager 7620-C with 15.4" WUXGA LCD, 3GHZ P4 CPU, ATI Mobility Radeon X800, 1024MB RAM, 100GB 5400RPM Hard Drive, 8x DVD+ combo w/ DVD+R DL, internal wireless, and 1 yr warranty. Weight came in at around 8lbs which acceptable weight for business travel. For all you "Carlords-walk-alone-two-lane-blacktop-watching-gear-heads" out there just think of Sager as the Subaru WRX of notebook computers.

Best,

Jared Rosen
Principal Consultant
Jade Fox Consulting LLC

by stargazerr

But what about people like me who get a craving to blast off aliens at 2 o' clock in the morning??

]:)

by jdclyde

just get over it! :p

It all depends, as there isn't a one-size-fits-all solution.

Advantages of going to these gaming places.

You don't have the big investment for the computer, games, and internet.
You don't have to maintain the computers. Viruses/trojans/spyware? Who cares!
Hardware burns up? Not your problem!

Disadvantages of going to these gaming places.

Limited by the hours that they are open.
Not in the comfort of your own cave.

Now, go frag someone!

I like this solution because I have twin boys. Imagine having to have THREE top of the line systems and THREE copies of every game you want to play? Sorry, I don't have 10K to throw away on GAMES.

We can do the middle of the road games at home, but for the bleeding edge games, it is more cost effective for me to go there.

by stargazerr

Unfortunately I dont have 10k to throw away either ..

I just like to pretend I am rich :D Not that that gets me very far (just far enough to own 16 pairs of jeans) .. Luckily work gives me a computer, so I can blow up the low end aliens at home ...

]:)

by beth blakely

I'm really appreciating all the helpful advice I'm getting here.

And believe me, there's an evil streak in me that wants the big bad Alienware just so I CAN flaunt it in front of my spouse! That's not wrong, is it? ;-)

by v_jaye

Well, As long as its Santa who is getting it for you, i suggest you pick up the Alienware. If not, I suggest you save, save and save and buy it whenever you can. ;-)

by jamesrl

This so much reminds me of when I was a kid, buying presents for my brothers. One was pretty musical like me, and I would buy him albums, usually ones that I wanted.

Why would Santa bring you a hot gaming laptop if he didn't have designs over it - borrowing it for lan parties etc.

Just about any laptop can play the Sims and games of that ilk. You might be better off with a gaming desktop and a less powerful laptop. The advantage of a gaming desktop is that it is easy to upgrade over time, as gaming requiements increase. You can trade up video cards, add memory, second HD etc. I would also suggest that in most cases, a CRT beats a LCD for the type of intense gaming like the latest and greatest shoot em ups - refresh rate is an issue, and to boot, CRTs are brighter and have better contrast than LCDs.

But thats my humble opinion.

If you want to flaunt it, there is a Ferrari laptop - not sure whats inside but the case is Italian racing red with a prancing horse logo - sweeet.

James

by zyphlar

Dell might not be popular with IT guys right now, but I'd still choose Dell over almost any other laptop manufacturer. After carefully researching other brands, Dell laptops have proven to be some of the most reliable computers I've encountered. Who needs support when 50 clueless users still can't manage to crash them? The support isn't great, but I've had worse.

My work Latitude D505 has survived many hard drops and general software and hardware abuse, and it's still going strong. I'd take it over any other machine, unless I wanted serious gaming or serious chic-factor.

And yeah, you might want to get the Dell just to keep your husband from hogging it (and installing a bunch of stuff, potentially affecting stability).

Just my experience. I'm sure you'll be happy with whatever machine you get. (No fanboy counterarguments allowed.)

by mdmenterprises

DO NOT BUY EITHER BRAND. BUY A SWAGMAN SERIES. They are the best you can get and they come from Australia. First Class Laptop and what a range. Just contact MDM Enterprises at mdmenterprises@ozemail.com.au

by manuella13

I'm a computer engineer and was looking for a system to fit the specifications i wanted back in may. Alienware's Sentia was the only one to do so. And i looked at everything : Dell, Toshiba, Panasonic, IBM, Fujitsu... anything you can think of (though not mac, sorry) Only Alienware had the level of customisation i wanted.
I got my Sentia in may. In september i got a job, and in october my boss got me a PC, a Toshiba laptop. My Sentia is smaller, lighter, and outperforms it (and all other machines in here) on any given day even though it's older. Better specs :) Better manufacturing... Better customer care... what can i say? I'm absolutely ecstatic with it. Light and portable and everything. Though you'd be better off indeed with the Area-51 :) It has a graphics card (unlike my Sentia, which has Intel integrated graphics) so the SIMS are guaranteed to run perfectly. AND a 17" screen!! I wanted small and light so the 12" widescreen was absolutely perfect for me.
As for Alienware? Overall i'm seriously very very happy. The reasons might be silly, but look, the CD drive is on the left and since i'm a righty i can change disks without incapacitating my mouse... it has 3 usb ports and one is hidden so i can have my wireless mouse connected permanenently with no protrusions... The 5-in-one media card reader came in handy when a friend visited in the summer and wanted to empty his camera. No software to install! Took out the card, popped it in, transferred the pics... no wires, no installs, no fuss.
What can i say? I've seen many other laptops since then, and my little baby still kicks their ass, hands down.
Let's just say i'd recommend alienware my eyes closed. They know what they're doing. And they do it well. So if you can afford it, go with it. It's definitely worth it.
Once you go Alienware you can't go back. It's that simple.

by csnuts

Playing games? Alienware hands down!!!! They are one of the original gaming pc companies and a premier one at that. They go gaming first, business second on the machines and Dell is exaclty the opposite. Don't get me wrong, Dell puts out a decent machine but considering the quality of the components you would be much happier with Alienware...

Not to mention Alienware machines are just plain COOL!

by bucksandchange

Yes the Alienware machines are better for gaming than the Dells, but I do not think that a gaming machine is needed to play the Sims. The Alienware laptops are designed to play cutting edge games where high framerates are a necessity as in FPS. The dell will do everthing that you need it to do and more. Most of the Alienware machines have overclocked components designed to squeeze out every ounce of framerate possible. If you are going for envy or cool factor, or even to impress others, the Alienware machine would be the way to go.

by pchem

I've used Dell laptops and multiple Desktops/Servers. Moral: They are "cost effective" for a reason: stripped-down OEM components with marginal long term reliability. We'd had multiple motherboard, power supply, HD failures on Dells. Dell's support has told me "anything after 3 years is considered throw-away." Either laptop will give you the 2 week oooohs and aaaahs of satisfation. The real issue is 2 years out. If you go Dell, make SURE you opt for the max warranty. Personally, I'd avoid Dell. No LONG Term value!
And Dell's support is worthless. Can't even understand them (non-native-English speakers). They've even hung up on me. Another issue for long-term ownership satisfaction.

I've not personally used an Alienware Laptop. However colleagues with their desktops have not had problems, and Alienware uses honest-to-gosh ACTUAL RETAIL COMPONENTS, not the OEM crap.
But you have to carefully ask them the component story regarding their laptop.

by mandm

Whatever laptop you choose, buy the longest extended warrnty you can get. I own a small computer store and you would be blowed away at the cost of repairs on a laptop. A new motherboard can cost as much as a new laptop. Also check if it does need repair under warranty, do you ship to them for repair or do they come to you. Your laptop could be gone for weeks

by binarypc

I recently tried to purchase an Alienware PC for my wife and dealt with the nicest people, who couldn't figure out how to get my order in. After 10 days, a financing department who received my paperwork via UPS and multiple calls, Alienware still couldn't get my order started. When I finally spoke to the finance department to make sure they had received my payment info, they had to go hunting for it. (I had record of their receiving signing for it 4 days previous). They then told me it would be another 3 weeks before it shipped. Though I prefer the AMD 64bit processor over the Intel HT, I started considering cancelling.

My research included hitting google and doing searches on Alienware s*cks (fill in the blank). After reading some of the horror stories on people trying to get onsite support and one guy waiting 4 months for his computer and then having to send it back, I cancelled the order with them. (It took them two days to cancel an order that hadn't even reached the "look for parts" phase!)

I ordered a Dell XPS for my wife that night and it was on her desk 10 days later (including weekends), when with Alienware it would have taken three weeks to ship.

At work we have had lots of the Dell product line and lots of problems. I myself had received a low-end business laptop (i.e. good for PowerPoint and e-mail, but not much else) to use in a technical job that demands a lot of the hardware I use. However, I tend to think that is more a corporate decision and not Dell's. Reflective of that decision on the part of corporate, myself and many other techies in our company have had to engage Dell support, and they have been awesome! So that partially influenced our decision.

The other influence has been another friend of mine at work that purchased a Dell desktop and he lives in a somewhat remote, rural area (types of places reporting problems with Alienware sending onsite support) and Dell volunteered to send someone out for him, and did a couple of times.

I've always been impressed with Alienware hardware but am disappointed in their ability to even process my "attempted" purchase. Dell, however, started building our machine the first day. With Alienware, I'm also just disappointed because I really looked at them as delivering an awesome product that I would one day splurge on, and it doesn't seem to be really a sensible thing to do now.

This is just my buying experience, I hope that whoever you choose, you have a great buying experience.

by the_biochemist

Antuck made a very good point, the newer range of AMD chips (Athlon XP64 or even the Turion 64 to some extent) really are great chips. If there is an option then I would choose AMD over intel in the laptop market. purely for their low power consumption which will increase battery life and also stop you burning your legs if you have it on your lap!

And as for Dell vs Alienware... when a company is relatively small they have to spend a lot of time creating quality products and first rate support... once they get to the size of dell a single user is of no real financial benifit to them... your only going to cost them in support. They spend their time looking after large corporate and government accounts where they can turn real profits.

So it would have to be the Alienware with an AMD64 option if possible!

by apotheon

Last I checked, Pentium M processors (that's the M, not the 4M) are the fastest 32 bit x86 chips available per dollar spent, per megahertz of clock speed, and per watt of power consumed, by a quite comfortable margin. In fact, a Pentium M 2.1GHz processor benchmarks about on par with an AMD Athlon 2800+ or a Pentium 4 3GHz.

I'd definitely recommend a Pentium M over any other 32 bit chip for basically any purposes at all -- and the Centrino chipset with a Pentium M processor will give you some awesome battery life.

The place where AMDs come into it is in 64 bit processing. On that score, they just murder Intel. If you're looking for high performance 64 bit processing power, get an AMD.

Last I checked, AMD had only just barely managed to get power consumption rates and waste heat down to about the level of a Pentium 4. I don't know where you guys are getting this "less power use, less heat" nothing for AMD processors. Granted, I haven't checked in a few months, but still. . . .

by virtual1

Virtually none of the "Name" brands manufacture their own laptops, with the about the only exception being Asus.

Instead they buy their laptops from what is called an Original Design Manufacturer (ODM). These ODMs sell their computers to several different OEMs (like DELL, Toshiba, IBM, HP, Compaq, Sager, PowerPro, Sony and many others) who then install the Hard Drive (usually a Seagate, Fujitsu, Hitachi or Toshiba), an Intel or AMD Processor, and System Memory. They then put their label on it and market it.

For example:

An ODM named Clevo makes the Sager NP9880 and the Alienware Area 51-M 7700, the Voodoo Envy u:703, the Hypersonic Aviator EX7, the Falcon Northwest FragBook DR 6800 and they are all the same computer (although Sager usually has the more advanced and exotic technology). Sager and Pro-Star are under the same ownership, and market all identical Clevo computers

Of course the Sager models have a much sweeter price tag!

An ODM named Compal makes some of the DELL, Hewlett Packard and Compaq line of laptops, among others, as well as the PowerPro M 5:6.

If it were me, I'd buy the Sager.

by vante

I worked Dell service for 5 years. Dell assembles notebooks, the parts are made by Sony, Hitachi, IBM, Samsung and others. Dell's customer service is divided into 2 categories, $$$$ customers and everyone else. Dell's concern, the $$$$ customers. The rest get shipped off to India to try and talk to someone who has never seen a dell notebook and learned english in a british school in India. I know several ex-dell people who shop at best buy (no dells there) and buy the warranty. They don't want to have to wait a home for service or have to ship the unit off. Plus if the problem persists, they get to pick a new unit of any brand off the shelf. Dell does not do that, they just keep replacing parts with used parts. Dell is not for the home user.

by wcosales9

Beth find a good computer dealer locally who will build you a laptop. My experience with Alienware is that they do not support there computers and warranty. It goes bad and you have to do the work and their warranty is not worth the paper it is written on. With Dell if you need support you will talk to a forigenier that you cannot understand. I have started to build to order Notebooks and can build them as cheap as Dell

by ga_itgyrl

My experience with build to order desktops has not been great over the years. Switching small companies from clones to all Compaq (pre-HP) or Dell reduced many support headaches. Maybe laptops built to order are better, but I wouldn't recommend it unless price is a real issue.

by conquistador

We have an Area-51 at home that I share with my wife and son. It's the best computer I have ever purchased. Great performance and great service.

by dreis

While I use to think Dell was the way to go. Working the support phones have convinced me otherwise.

I like the HP laptops. I have been using one for about 2 years now with no problems.

by philuk

I also used to think Dell was the last line in decent prebuilt systems, after working with them i relise i was wrong.

And HP are you mad? :) i recently had to throw away 4 scanners because their are no availble drivers for windows xp. (Fair enough they may be a bit old but they arnt that old) If they wont support their products i wont support them.

by reality.bytes

hp hasn't been worth a $#!+ since they merged with compaq. even their printers have taken a nosedive.

by slave2themachine

Alienware: Designed for Gaming, though they are attempting to get into the standard home user market.
Dell: A solid computer builder that has a proven product track history with a wide variety of systems.
Other available options: Toshiba Qosmio G25-AV513, Dell Ipiron 6000 (ecode 1111-i6004pc), Fujitsu LifeBook N6010, Sager Notebooks,

I myself would say if it has to be with one of the two laptops you listed, go with the Dell system. If you want to consider another system instead, go with the Toshiba System I listed.

I have personally dealt with Dell for over 5 years and have seen many of their systems age. Yes after two or three years the warranty runs out but by that time I have either had the bugs worked out of the systems or they are so far behind the times I have replaced them. I mean really, a P3 500 with 512meg ram just does not cut it any longer in my line of work. I have not always had great tech support, but that is counting maybe 2 out of 15 times I have needed them in five years covering over seventy five units (fifty desktops, twenty laptops and five to ten servers) in two serperate offices. I also use a 3ghz Dell desktop media center at home and the family loves it. Another thing you should be aware of is that if there is a company that builds some thing there is a negative review of it out there on the internet. Most of these I recommend you take with a grain of salt and only take advice from sites you trust.
Inspiron 9300 has been out for several monts so it may have all the bugs worked out of it already compared with the alienware gaming laptop.PC Magazines full review can be found at http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1895,1785174,00.asp
Other systems you may consider:
Thoshiba Qosmio G25-AV513, it recieved editors choice over the Dell XPS M140 in the December 6, 2005 issue of PC Magazine (review on pg 168, benchmarks on pg149). Quote for the Thosiba: "Still, the Toshiba Qosmio G25-AV513 is the best-designed multimedia laptop we've seen.-CC". The Full review can be found at http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1895,1827545,00.asp
Inspiron 6000 (MCE) laptop, PC Magazines eidtors choice for the entry level media center laptop over the Averatec AV3715-EH1, Compaq Presario V2000Z, and ACER Aspire AS5000. They recommend you use e-code 1111-i6004pc for a sub $1000 price tag and upgrading to the dvd burner. PC Magazines full review can be found at http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1895,1878510,00.asp
I would also recommend you take a look at the Sager line of notebooks http://www.sagernotebook.com/index.html . They are looking pretty nice and Sager has been building a good name for itself in the notebook area for both Intel and AMD based machines since 1985. I have heard on the negative side though that they need to revamp their customer service side of the house so be aware of that should you actually consider them.

A good source on notebooks is http://www.notebookreview.com , they really do try to bring you accurate information. Also as you can tell I read PC Magazine, their website is http://www.pcmag.com .

Key notes to remember when dealing with dell customer service:
If you can not understand the person your talking to ask for a US based customer service representative.
If the person your talking to is new or sounds like they really don?t know what they are doing ask to speak with a different representative.
If they make you do stupid things like look at the lights, put in the diagnostic disks, etc... Just do it instead of taking an attitude with them. Often times you over looked the easy fix with your in dept overly complicated troubleshooting techniques.
Oh I have heard of it happening to someone else, do not fdisk or format your hard drive. No tech support should ever have you do that.

Key notes I try to consider with laptops:
#1 Overall Performance only in the areas you inted to use it.
#2 Amount of Ram available at time of purchase
#3 Screen Size
#4 Battery life

In conclusion I hope this helps you some how and does not add to the clutter in your post.

by mpage

Dell SUCKS. Their service is completely rotten, product quality is going downhill, and hardware ergonomics/style is weak at best.

Alienware ROCKS. Service is responsive and detailed. Product quality is stellar. Ergonomic/style is awesome. Some downsides? Their products seem to produce more heat, and they aren't cheap at all.

I guess this question is similar to deciding between a Dodge Charger or a Ferrari Scaglietti. Personally I say OUT with the crooked E and IN with the Glowing Eyes.

by jbellrmr

Just another thought on your laptop...Hp DV4000 series. Not the fastest ever, but respectable Intel 1.7 BHz Pentium M (read low heat-this really is a comfortable LAPtop). Comes with all the hardware and has dual boot with the instant play setup for playing CDs and DVDs. This is actually a Linux partition on the 100GB HDD which boots in seconds. Also has the wireless G built in and a 15" widescreen with the ultrabrite technology and a hard glass surface. I have tested mine outside at 20 degrees running my telescope and it works perfectly. Check out the specs on HPs site, then pick one up at Best Buy (great pricing).

by subs

... why not consider Leveno (IBM)? My ThinkPads endure when friends' Dell notebooks are dust ... although I doubt any computer can ever satisfy ALL your entertainment needs ... ;-)

by vdopantera

The alienware has better specs overall, and a great GFX card, which you might need for your sims (especially if you upgrade to Sims2) =)

by scott.lewis

I have to say in all honesty that whenever I see anyone using a Windows laptop, I just feel a little sorry for them. In the desktop world the Mac and Windows might be fairly equal for most mundane tasks, but in the laptop world, Mac Powerbooks, though underpowered, remain a superior design. One simple reason is that the one-button configuration is just much, much easier to use with a trackpad. Also the Mac is just a perfect balance between features and portability.
With Apple possibly set to release an Intel-powered Powerbook in February, I would definitely wait for that.

by apotheon

The one-button design is the one thing that I [b]don't[/b] like about Powerbooks. Everything else is awesome.

by mgoldman

I'd be thrilled if mac, firefox, opera, netscape and everyone else with sub 5% market share would close up shop. Than the anal-retentive Marketing types would stop having people who do real work check and re-check code because an object is 2 pixles different on their $3,000 solitaire-worn laptop.

by ni70

but if you haven't I imagine it's because of their atrocious consumer (public) tech support. http://www.google.com/search?q=dell+hell. But I'm sure if you googled any computer manufacturer's tech support, you'll probably get as many hits. I've not had the privilege nor opportunity to use Alienware desktop or laptops, but they're pretty much top of the line, as far as horsepower, etc are concerned. Eric mentioned Apple, have you thought of an Apple? I haven't used an Apple, but my son has one and he's quite please with it (graduation gift).

My sister has an Inspiron (not sure which one or when it was manufactured) and it started shutting down all by itself for no apparent reason. Since I work in IT, I offered to take a look and call Dell Tech Support, boy was I in for a surprise! I got a call center in India, and the techs were very hard to understand! I asked to be transfered to the US, but they wouldn't even do that! I was very shocked because I was so used to Dell's corporate (Gold? business?) tech support, of which I have no complaints at all! Money talks and the home consumer beware!

Anyway, my 2cents!

by lofyr

Beth,

I have been a consultant for about 5 years, I am not quite a pro but I have jumped through some experience hoops in my life.

I worked with Dell, HP and this is my first experience with Alienware. Let me tell you some down sides. Well there is only one the m5700 is heavy (Over 15 lbs). If you want a lighter laptop go with a Dell.

But for raw power and performance Alienware is the 100% way to go (At least is has 4 fans on it to cool everything off and they aren't that loud). When you first get it they have a document on the desktop and gives you all the bench marks they did on it. Sims 2 or even the original Sims will run better then great on the m5700. Service and support is fantastic too. Plus right now you get a cool free T-Shirt.

Dell in my experience are good quality laptops. They have pretty good support and usually reasonable with getting replacements for things go "wrong". They do have decent power but you will have to pay a lot more then if you just went with a Alienware machine.

I resell both of them in my business, Alienware is pricier but you pay exactly what you get, a solid powerful machine. Dell, you get good support, rock solid running machine and pretty light in weight.

So see if more people have opinions of these machines because more is better.

by jdclyde

to being rich. you DON'T throw 10k away!

I know many people I "concider" to be rich, and the are the biggest cheapskates you ever did meet.

So if you want to pretend your rich, wear nice cloths and don't let anyone know you live out of your car because you spent all your money on cloths! :D

by gnx

Just get a 1968 Impala SS 427 instead. It's more fun than a laptop. If your desktop works, why replace it. If you must get a laptop, my choice of the two would be Dell.

by apotheon

I think Jcritch was referring to a PowerBook. I guess he hasn't noticed that the Mac has, with the advent of MacOS X, once again become a great graphic design platform, supports the same office productivity software as Windows, and in general is a very viable business computing platform.

by apotheon

I wouldn't use any website that requires such an awful security-incompetent browser as IE for the purpose of managing my money. I don't much like the idea of doing the digital equivalent of storing my credit card numbers on a big ol' billboard on the front of my house.

by peter_es_uk

The internet can be used for very secure communications but there are some things I never ever do:

Intentionally store personnal details on my windows machine.

Use IE 0f any variety for anything but windows updates.

Allow any windows machine root access to my linux servers.

If you nailed up a neon sign with your credit card info, you would know what you had done. Type confidential info even on a secure connection with IE, you just don't know what is stored where.

by vmwarez

I got my 9300 about 6 or so months ago and am VERY happy with it. Don't skimp on the screen, though, go with the more expensive one. 1900x1200ish resolution on a laptop is awesome.

by sleepin'dawg

We tried Dell equipment and had unfortunate results. We went with Think pads c/w port replicators or docking stations. Toshibas have given excellent results as well. Not sure that I am all that impressed with Apple.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Erik Eckel

But not the one I sought. Good catch, Apotheon!

Some people believe spirits haunt their PCs, though, you know, the whole ghost in the machine thing!

EE

by reality.bytes

"Thirdly they can connect with other platforms, at the moment I'm connected to a wireless network that runs off my windows pc with no problems, am able to open shared folders and printers."

that's not the same thing as being able to connect to a standard enterprise domain and use standard enterprise software such as ms exchange.

by bkittel

It's just as capable of running business apps as a dell. The misconception maybe stems from the fact that most business' run either dell or compaq for their desktop systems because of the quantity discounts they give.
I'd love to see a business office running Alienware. Not only are they far more expensive but much much nicer/cooler. Personally I built my Asus laptop from a barebone chassis and am quite satisfied with it.

by alganon

If you really are in IT then it it is almost essential that you introduce yourself to Linux, or get left behind. Choose anything but a Dell, IBM is best for Linux, and HP is close behind. All of the activities you nominated are easily achieved under Linux desktop. Dual boot your machine with XP and Mandriva 2006 Power Pack. Before the holidays are over you may just find yourself forgetting to boot into Windows.

Mandriva is outstanding!

by 69552901-69552901

I purchased an inspiron 8500 a few years ago, when they were brand new. It's bulky, heavy, the power cord broke very quickly (it's flimsy) and the battery lasts less than 20 minutes now. But that's not why I'm typing this.

A few months ago I decided to purchase a couple monitors, an axim with carrying case, and a few little things. After waiting weeks past the anticipated delivery date without getting any answers I finally found out that a ocuple things were backordered and they had no idea how long it would be. I couldn't wait any longer for some things, so I cancelled the order and made a new one for the things I had to have and decided I'd order the others later.

About 3 weeks later the original order arrived. But they got the order wrong! By this time I'd already purchased some must-haves (for work) from another place and already had that second dell order on the way. Of course, I called them immediately. They gave me a hard time because I had signed for it. I tried to explain that I'd signed for it because I thought it was the other order I'd made. At the end of it I had to speak to a supervisor and threaten legal action for them to send me the return info.

I sent everything back out the same day, then they didn't want to refund my credit card after assuring me there would be no charges or service fees (since it was their fault I was sent the order, it never should have been shipped). That was two more phone calls and threats.

It the meantime, the other order came, there's a 3 inch blotch on the 20 inch monitor (as if someone spilled something on it, but it doesn't come off), and dell is refusing to repair or replace it even though it is still under warrenty.

Sooooo.... that's my dell horror story! The next laptop I purchase will be either alienware or apple, I have yet to make my decision.

by binarypc

Beth,

Are you going to let us know what you choose to go with and how your experience is? Personally I would like to know that someone else received better service from Alienware than I did. :-)