Alienware vs. Dell: What laptop shall I ask Santa to bring?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
After Hours
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by wwoolley
I recently had the same decision to make and chose the alienware 7700 -- full speed P4 cpu, 3 gig ram, 2 x 100 gig hard drives. I have in mind using vmware intensively.
Within 2 weeks the hard drive controller failed (read motherboard replacement). During the troubleshooting (2 more weeks) I noticed a label on the bottom to the effect that it was assembled from tested components, but NOT tested as a full system! Who thinks that is a smart step to skip. I also noticed that the screws holding on some cover plates were loose (no end of the line quality control).
Then, with the hurricane disruption, it is likely to take a month more to repair. So, I suggested that the warranty should be restarted then they shipped a _working_ laptop. The answer was 'No!'.
When I asked to speak to a supervisor, I was treated to the 'on hold' long enough to get rid of my call and log it as a 'disconnected'.
These are signs of a company either in financial trouble or attempting to boost profits atificially. Either way, it seems that the 'bean counters' are making the poor operational decisions.
I just hope they are around long enough to support the 3 year warranty period. If you buy alienware, make sure you run a burn-in program when it arrives to flush out the infant mortality problems they are shipping.
by mek804
The 15" powerbook is by far the least troublesome of all
powerbooks. I have had one at work for three years. Bought one
for home. Bough one for my wife--no troubles with any of them.
Alienware, Dell, Compaq, and Toshiba are the ones I see the
most often, so that should tell you something.
The 17" powerbook, which is no longer a "laptop" IMHO, had
some problems with the lid hinge and how the connection to the
monitor works. Hopefully, they have fixed that, but I don't know.
The 12" powerbook had no troubles at all, though the screen is
limited to 1024x768. They may have fixed that by now, too, but
I haven't looked. The 15" seems to be the way to go, so I've lost
interest in the others. ; )
You could have thrown any two brand names out and received the exact same responses. HP, Gateway, Dell, Sony, whatever! Everybody has had similar experiences with any vendor. It's the nature of the business. Don't take too many of those posts to heart.
I currently own an XPS Gen4, but have owned Alienware (any numerous others) in the past. They're all the same.
I'd buy whichever computer will make you feel warm and fuzzy when it shows up at your doorstep.
by apotheon
by apotheon
Are you aware that there's a version of Microsoft Office that runs on Macs? No problem using MS Exchange there.
Are you aware that there are other, non-MS alternatives to Exchange that can provide all the same functionality (and then some) for less money, with greater security and stability, and without locking out a lot of users? Try Open-Xchange on for size.
I suppose you're not aware, either, of the ability to connect unix-based OSes to a Windows Domain via Samba, or the fact that many businesses use network models other than Windows-based models. Perhaps you should familiarize yourself with some of the technologies that we, as IT professionals, often have to deal with on a regular basis.
by apotheon
"Think Different get a Linux laptop"
More like:
"Think Different. Get a Mac laptop."
or . . .
"Think Differently. Get a Linux laptop, and use proper grammar."
Heh. Heh heh.
Ahem.
by beads
Theres a couple of benchmarks that escape my memory that usually place Alienware slightly behind on some business related benchmarks.
Usually find the reviews in MaximumPC. For the most part the difference would be miniscule in comparison to Excel.
The newest king of the hill on this is a guy in London who does nothing but ultra-custom work - to include the paint job on the outside. Of course they also start at $15,000+, but hey if you want the very best... The old adage used to be the computer I always wanted was $3,000 and held true for many, many years.
- beads
- beads
by apotheon
by beads
I'm trying to find the exact business benchmarking software the MaxPC uses. Unfortunately, theres alot of tech crap that I found I really need to throw out in the form of old magazines.
Agree, it depends on which software you're refering to but at these speeds we're talking negligle differences.
- beads
by dr. tarr
Benchmarks are a useful tool; the problem is finding meaningful benchmarks. Back when I had problems finding enough computer to meet my needs, I was a real benchmark freak, compiling benchmarks from at least a dozen sources, and deriving a weighted average based on some esoteric formula that brings back headaches just trying to remember it. Today?s systems are powerful enough that I have problems with end users (excepting some of the researchers and scientists) who tell me they need more CPU.
your comment about $3K computers brings to mind Machrone's Law (http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1759,1545383,00.asp) which states:
"The machine you want will always cost $5,000." He continues with the qualification " Note the third and fourth words: the machine you want. Not the cheapest machine, not the one that makes the most sense. The one that makes you drool."
After I read this post I popped over to the Alienware site, and sure enough, the laptop that I want came out to a little over $4900, and still needed Vega (aside, Vega is a GREAT editing tool), which seems to provide some empirical evidence to support the law.
by apotheon
by dreis
Well, I also stopped using a HP scanner because I could not find the drivers. But I have a laptop laser and an inkjet printers that I have not had a problem with. I may replace the laser printer, not because I'm having a problem, but because most everything for a printer uses USB now.
So, I must have been lucky.
by apotheon
This message posted from a Thinkpad T42p running Debian GNU/Linux 3.1 "Sarge".
I haven't used Mandriva yet, but I've had to deal with a lot of Mandrake 10.x systems, and my experience with Mandrake can best be described as "frustrating", in comparison with other major Linux distributions. First and foremost amongst my annoyances are the Mandrake-specific configuration tools, the obtuse behavior of urpmi (as compared with package managers like APT and YUM), and the lack of good documentation (not many friggin' manpages on a Mandrake install). It's still a darned sight easier to maintain than a Windows machine, though, once you're familiar with it.
by allenhood
by crake
Smearing Windows is a common practice of you Apple polishers.
Most people don't appreciate Apple's "lock-in" model, which explains Apple's paultry 4.7% of the market.
Your argument that Mac is immune to viruses is a fallacy. It's just that Mac is such a small target, virus writers don't bother. They want the most impact for their efforts, and since some 90% of the entire market is Windows - well, you do the math.
If you truly want to advocate Apple's OS, you should consider a different tact. Don't slam other OSes; it's a tired, worn out approach that has never worked.
Regarding the OPs question, I'd have to go with Alienware simply because I like their components more than those used in Dell, but that's just me.
by Erik Eckel
I introduced FUD? I don't think so.
Beth said she was looking for a laptop that would let her work well with digital photographs and play the SIMs. I bought my PowerBook (when, in August, I was considering a similar Alienware unit to that she described) for its digital photography capabilities. I've found the Apple manages all the other work-related tasks I perform equally well, and I've been pleasantly surprised at how working with the Windows alternative is so refreshing (this is the first Mac I've used since 96/97). Also, I know you can buy the SIMs for the Mac platform, so I mentioned she give it a look.
If that makes me an Apple polisher, so be it.
by crake
Fear Uncertainty and Doubt.
You said,
"Ease of use? Please. Apple wins hands down. No need for antivirus software, antispyware programs, weekly security updates, etc."
That is FUD. Also, you're wrong in inferring that Apple OS cannot be infected - it can.
It would be FUD for me to point out the the OP how Mac OSes are never backwards compatible, so if you upgrade, you need to accommodate both old and new to run older applications.
It would also be FUD for me to say Darwin (OS X's *nix backend) is not portable and won't run on anything except a Mac.
Those are types of FUD.
by apotheon
"[i]Most people don't appreciate Apple's 'lock-in' model, which explains Apple's paultry 4.7% of the market.[/i]"
Anybody choosing Windows over a Mac doesn't care about "lock-in" at all. Sure, you may tell yourself that's a reason you use Windows, because you don't like Apple's "lock-in", but you're just kidding yourself if that's what you think. Seriously, anyone that claims to avoid Macs because of lock-in of any kind and uses Windows instead isn't paying enough attention to have an informed opinion.
by brichpmr9
by apotheon
I was comparing 32 bit with 32 bit. 64 bit is a whole different animal.
There are places I'd avoid 64 bit. For one thing, not all the software many people use on a daily basis is at all 64 bit compatible yet, and thus some operations actually NEED to be run on a 32 bit processor, or at the least run in a 32 bit mode, at which point one wonders what the point of getting the 64 bit processor was in the first place.
Also . . . there's still nothing (non-Mac) better suited to use in a laptop than the Pentium M if performance is at all important to you.
by beads
Alienware has been doing high end machines and only high end machines for many, many years now and rarely have I heard a complaint.
Dell on the other hand is renown for building marginal but servicable machines as a market niche.
If your concerned about the quality versus the price, Alienware is the way to go. Its what Alienware does and does it well. On the other hand if you don't care who engineered the technology or what goes into it or if price is a concern then go with Dell.
Besides, no one, techs particularly, will oogle a Dell like they will an Alienware laptop. There is a certain "cool" value associated with Alienware over a Dell.
- beads
by mjost
members feel that attends".
by geraldkiii
by techrep10
...but the basic level you get for free sucks. Tell them you are s small to medium business, then get "business standard" support. That is an upgrade (about $260 to $350 for a two year extension and first year upgrade) but well worth it. You get domestic support and short queues. Hey - they even know what you are talking about and have actually seen a computer first hand!! That's not true for Dell's offshore support.
I support about 75 mostly Dell laptops and make a service call on over 75% of them in the three year service window. Believe me, the upgrade is worth it.
by brichpmr9
by dr. tarr
I did in fact intend for the second computer to be a laptop. So much for relying on spelling and grammar checkers, I guess I need to actually read what I wrote instead of seeing what I meant, which brings me to the second point.
When I reread my original post, I found that what I typed in point two isn't quite what I intended. What I was trying to get across wasn't necessarily that a user would necessarily need today's latest and greatest system even three years down the road, it was that most user's will want more power because of a perceived need to be able to run the latest and greatest app, even when they aren't using it.
In the end, I'll stand by my recommendation to buy as much computer as you can afford. That will put most people in the knuckle of the price - performance curve, which is a good place to be.
by beth blakely
by tom_minerd
I have been reading through some of the replies to the original post on whether to buy an Alienware or Dell portable system. I have to agree with some of your complaints because I know it happens and I won't argue with any of it. It makes me sick in my stomach to hear some of the horror stories that people go through to get things taken care of. When I was a tech at Dell (by the way, I still work there in the training department for business tech support), I did my best to make sure the customer was satisfied with the support they received. The worst thing a customer can do, even when their order is wrong, is to threaten legal action. I have had people threaten me like that and it really does them no good. Techs will refer customers to our legal department when this happens in which case you have to contact them in writing which doesn't get your issue resolved. I'm assuming that you were only threatening customer service, but they should be doing the same thing as tech support.
Anyway, I would be upset also if I had to go through what you just did. One thing I have found out is that a lot of times, being nice can get you what you want faster than yelling at someone. But that depends on who you yell at.
My recommendation is that if you do buy a Dell system, you should get it under a business name if you do run a business, and be aware of the time of year in which you buy your computer. Around the holidays can be a hectic time and orders may not be fulfilled on time due to the holiday rush to get a computer. When you order online, pay special attention to any notes given for a particular configuration where you may be informed that it might delay shipment due to availability.
One thing you might not be aware of are the TBR reports on these computer companies. Although some people are going to have a bad experience at some point with any company, Dell is the leader, hands down! I'm just going by what the reports tell us.
But again, I am sorry for your poor experience and would just hope that your next purchase will be a pleasant one. Thanks for at least trying Dell.
by antuck
I was looking at Anandtech's web site this weekend and saw a little article about the Pentium M chip vs the AMD Turion Chip. Well they don't do a real test on each but does give some information regarding the two.
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2374
One interesting note, was as ususal, AMD and Intel market things differently. The article shows AMD using more wattage but it is also noted that Intel mesures there wattage differently. Over all they seem to be impressed by AMD's chip offering.
As far as going with a 64 bit chip, personally that is what I would make sure I had if buying new. The AMD 64 bit chips will run 32 bit software.
by bschmidt
Why spend thousands of dollars on a laptop when it's much more economical to buy a LazyBoy? They come in nearly any color you could want. I'd suggest suede upholstery, pillow-top cushion. Throw in a mini-fridge at minimal cost. :)
Now while I'm half joking with this...I'm also half serious. My experience with laptops in general, no matter the brand, hasn't been that great. They're small and hard to use IMO. The keyboard is only big enough if you're 12 and the mouse just plain sucks unless you get an addon. Working on them (as far as support) is a nightmare. Don't EVER lose the driver disks, and have you ever had to replace an internal part? Desktops are much easier to work with, easier to support and WAY cheaper than a laptop. You can build your own desktop from scratch and get exactly what you want for well under $1000. Or buy one prebuilt -- if you do that I'd suggest a Dell simply because they're cheaper (just make sure you uninstall all the crap that comes with it -- as with any other prebuilt PC).
Seriously, you want a laptop for comfort but it won't leave the house. I'd say instead of going for a comfortable computer, make a comfortable work area. Less headache on the computer end. When supporting a laptop vs. PC, the laptops are murder. At least with a PC you can swap out parts if you have to without it being a huge ordeal.
If you're sure about a laptop though, I'd say get the Dell. A computer is a computer, no matter whose name is on it. They both have a HDD, screen, DVD etc. I don't know about Alienware but I do know Dell support sucks for home user, although I've found that once you do their little song and dance they usually get the job done. Basically the bottom line is this -- if you can do your own support it makes sense to go with the most cost effective solution. And from what your explanation of usage is, it shouldn't cost that much.
I still vote for the LazyBoy though...or if you want to treat yourself get one of those massage chairs. Yeah...I could live like that. :)
Beth:
There is a laptop out there called Sager. (http://www.sager.com)
Purely amazing, and much cheaper. All high-end components and has been around for a long time. I bought a 3.4 gig p4, with hyper-threading (software), and ATI 9700 video card (256 mg of ram on the card), the 17" high-rez screen, a gig of ram, 60 gig hard-drive, and all the possibile bels and whistles for about $2200. I have three teen-aged kids and play the single-person shooter games with them to stay in their world, and this machine screams.
It also has a speaker system (either 5 or 7) that includes a sub-woofer. It makes the music sound great. The only draw-back is it's heavy.
Whatever you get, it sounds like it's going to be a good Christmas.
by apotheon
I'm partial to Thinkpads. Part of the reason for that is that there's typically excellent support for Thinkpads using Linux (as long as you wait about six months, give or take, after a new one is out so that any hardware support issues for new internals will have been worked out by Thinkpad lovers), but they're great with Windows, too. Get yourself a comfortable mouse/trackball and keyboard, a Thinkpad docking station, and a nice flat panel monitor, and you'll have all the user benefits of a laptop along with all the user benefits of a desktop.
In my experience, Thinkpad support is exceedingly good, at least in comparison with the sort of support you'd get with other laptops. They're very sleek looking, have very well-designed keyboards for laptops, and have highly configurable BIOS settings, even allowing for network boots and turning off the trackpad, trackpoint, or both, if you desire. They've got great internals, too -- my most recent Thinkpad had a FireGL graphics adapter (like an ATI Radeon, but better: the FireGL series is for graphic design workstations and other high-end graphics-intensive stuff).
. . . or, as has been noted already by others, you could go with a Powerbook or iBook. MacOS X is, in my humble opinion, a far better option than Windows XP.
Among PC-compatible laptops, I'd put Sager in second place, right behind Thinkpads (depending on what you want out of your laptop), and they tend to be cheap.
by rzimmerman
by ccvenard
Santa brought the Mrs. an Inspiron, nice machine, but the keyboard doesn't appeal to her.
The son loves it.....
by apotheon
by trekman1
I agree the Macintosh line is the best especially now that it is a Unix based. I am almost done moving the rest of my family over as well.
I will never go back to Windoze.
by apotheon
by big scoddie
The Mac may be a great machine for first-timers or basic users. Let me qualify that statement: If you have little or no investment in any PC applications, then a "switch" to the Mac camp may be viable.
However, what about those that have a considerable investment in PC software?
I suppose this debate can be likened to the Beta versus VHS format wars. If you had a huge collection of VHS movies and tapes, no matter how superior the Beta format may have been, it would have proven to be quite stupid and costly to change your platform.
As nice as the Mac may be, I'm certainly not silly enough to put myself in the situation where I have to repurchase Adobe CS 2, Macromedia Dreamweaver, Sony Vegas 5 + DVD and the myriad other apps and utilities I use every day. And, NO, I don't want to relearn the Mac "alternatives".
by trekman1
First off the MAC is much more secure in how it handles multiple users and the system files do not share the same trusted interdependencies with the applications. In brief what that means is when you install an application first off you are greeted with a password box to confirm that you want to install and then secondly when the application gets installed it does not use a privlidged account to do it so no virus can worm its way into the system files like a windoze machine.
Windoze uses what is known as dll hell. An application gets installed and it installs dll files using a privleged account and possible modifying system dll's which can introduce viruses, etc.. Another problem with the windoze architecture is that you can get dll overwriting other dll's and then when you try to open your application again it mysteriouly does not work.
Very Sloppy way of doing things.
by trekman1
by apotheon
There are other "beautiful" GUIs out there, and when Apple ripped the surface off unix to pave it over with its own proprietary upper layers of OS, it introduced some problems into the mix that didn't previously exist. In particular, it has introduced security issues that, though minor (for now), are endemic to MacOS X.
I grant that it's a pretty darned good OS, all things considered, but I wouldn't say it's the "best". If it was, I'd be typing this from something running MacOS X rather than Debian GNU/Linux.
by trekman1
If you can be specific what security issues? If anything the MAC OS has made the Unix environment very secure, much more secure than any Linux platform out there. Don't get me wrong I like linux as well, anything is better than windoze.
I don't know of any other GUI out there that is more elegant then the one that is on the MAC. Linux definitely does not have one and neither does windoze.
I am typing this from the MAC OS X platform on the top rated browser safari.
by trekman1
If you have not stayed in touch with the MAC architecture how can you even make such statements? If you can't site specifics then I am just supposed to believe you as well? Yeah right!!
Let us see Gnome, KDE cannot even compare to the MAC OS's GUI. I think you should sit the monitors side by side and then you would know what I mean., because you have not been in touch with the MAC OS. Also, the ease of use for end users is much better on the MAC then Linux from the GUI all the way up to configuring the system. Linux is still in its pinto stages. Linux has a long way before it is ready from primetime desktop use that is provided that Apple does not squash it out of exisitence come next year since it is switching to Intel.
As for your last statement you had put this in the last message " I grant that it's a pretty darned good OS, all things considered, but I wouldn't say it's the "best". If it was, I'd be typing this from something running MacOS X rather than Debian GNU/Linux." My feelings exactly SO WHAT!!!!
by trekman1
Hate to burst your bubble but Linux has a monolithic kernel.
You have not addressed my orginal question. This little high
school back forth is crazy. Come back to me when you are more
informed about the MAC OS and I disagree with you it is
irrelevant if you do not know what you are talking about.
If anyone here has the narrow mind it is you. If the MAC OS X
was not one of the most powerful OS's then why did they built
the 3rd Worlds's super computer with it and not Linux it is
because Linux is not capable. The EU is using thousands of
Xserves to create one of the Worlds largest computer system,
Deutsche bank, etc.. I can go on but this discussion is starting to
bore me.
I can go on but it is Friday night and I have a life to get back to.
I also see that we are running out of threads under this
discussion
by trekman1
Hate to burst your bubble but Linux has a monolithic kernel.
You have not addressed my orginal question. This little high
school back forth is crazy. Come back to me when you are more
informed about the MAC OS and I disagree with you it is
irrelevant if you do not know what you are talking about.
If anyone here has the narrow mind it is you. If the MAC OS X
was not one of the most powerful OS's then why did they built
the 3rd Worlds's super computer with it and not Linux it is
because Linux is not capable. The EU is using thousands of
Xserves to create one of the Worlds largest computer system,
Deutsche bank, etc.. I can go on but this discussion is starting to
bore me.
I can go on but it is Friday night and I have a life to get back to.
I also see that we are running out of threads under this
discussion
by jmgarvin
For the love of god, DIE already. Not only does it limit functionality, it stinks on ice.
Give me 3 buttons or at the very least 2!! Jeez
by Erik Eckel
by brichpmr9
Here's a review of an Alienware notebook.
http://www.theregister.com/2005/12/09/review_alienware_m5500/
I will add that I saw some Alienware notebook computers at Circuit City. They look like they are cheaply built and would probably break. The hinges on the screen looked like they would snap off with a gentle twist.
by apotheon
"[i]If you can be specific what security issues?[/i]"
I can't be as specific as I'd like -- I haven't stayed in touch with MacOS X architecture so much, and thus don't recall all the specifics. I do know, however, that the modular top end of unix interfaces has been replaced with a nonmodular, monolithic blending of higher-level OS functionality and lower-level GUI functionality. Anyone with a reasonably good understanding of the fundamentals of software architecture can begin to imagine all sorts of problems that would be pretty much unavoidable with such a design.
"[i]If anything the MAC OS has made the Unix environment very secure, much more secure than any Linux platform out there.[/i]"
Yep, I'll just take your word for it. Your complete avoidance of any substantive reference to how MacOS X was magically made so impenetrable has managed to convince me of your omniscience.
"[i]I don't know of any other GUI out there that is more elegant then the one that is on the MAC.[/i]"
Perhaps you should define what "elegant" means to you, then. I disagree. We clearly have different definitions of "elegant", or you are simply unaware of the wide range of GUI front ends that exist for free unices running the X Window System.
"[i]I am typing this from the MAC OS X platform on the top rated browser safari.[/i]"
I am typing this from the Debian GNU/Linux platform on the top rated browser Firefox. So what?
by apotheon
The problem here isn't so much that Macs come with one-button mice that can be replaced. The problem is that you can't replace the integrated pointing device on your laptop. For the built-in pointing device, you're stuck with what they give you. Period.
That's a problem for me, when it's a one-button pointing device.
by brichpmr9
by apotheon
Since I'm unlikely to use a "desktop" system again, preferring laptops and servers for everything (since I can just unplug peripherals from a laptop and take it with me) at this point in my life, laptops are really my only likely use for Macs. Since Mac laptops only have one button for the pointing device, I'm unlikely to get one at this time because of how friggin' annoying I find that.
Yes, you can use pointing devices with more buttons with a Mac. The problem is when you're dealing with integrated pointing devices for convenience's sake. I prefer something that doesn't make my life less convenient for the sake of some bizarre convention of idiosyncratic functional branding.
When Apple starts using more than one button on laptops, I'll reconsider my attitude.
by Erik Eckel
No significant user-to-user virus, in the wild, has ever plagued the Mac since OS X was released.
Spyware's simply a non-issue on Apple systems. There's no registry to corrupt or enable spyware distribution.
As for security updates, I run both Windows and Apple systems. In the past six months I've updated the Apple systems maybe twice. The Windows systems? It's been so many I've lost track of the count.
by skylarjoyner
I am another IT Guy that will not deal with Dell anymore. All of my Clients, from the corporates/medium-sized businesses in Los Angeles all the way to the farming community/family business here in Wichita, KS listen to my advice, which is based on applied truths, have changed from Dell and are now onto Alienware/other. 5 situations immediately come to my mind- all in the last few months- that have forced my mind into not dealing with Dell at all. One example? I talked to 3 tech supports from Dell in a simple problem- enforcing the warranty on 3 business systems- in which the warranty expired the next day actually- and they INSISTED that the warranty was expired- which it was for them due to the fact that they WERE IN INDIA.
The Dell tech supports (even two "supervisors") there LOCALIZE all issues, not even having a clue that they do sell Dells here in the U.S. and elsewhere- WELL, they at least DID :).
by oz_media
Have Santa brong you something with reliability, durability, functionality and STANDARDS.
IBM, ThinkPad, get a 3 year onsite warranty and you're good to go. FINALLY good hardware, EXCELLENT durability with a titanmium cage, onsite suport that is yet to be topped and performance of much 'faster' higher-spec'd machines. CHEAP? Not a chance, first born and a few linbs wil get you one, but you get what you pay for, not just a run of the mill notebook that is no different than anything else on the market.
by jmgarvin
I've gone back to my old ways and started using FVWM. You might think it is ugly, but I can customize the hell out of it AND it is very light weight.
Also Apple crippled the command line, which has taken the power away from the user...
by oz_media
Yeah Smorty, and since what year did we start staying with people's topics and not just speaking our minds? C'mon mate, that's what makes TR the best site online!
Have a good wekend! OM :)
by oz_media
Yeah Smorty, and since what year did we start staying with people's topics and not just speaking our minds? C'mon mate, that's what makes TR the best site online!
Have a good weekend! OM :)
by jmgarvin
by jmgarvin
It drives me nuts that Apple will not cater to anyone but the drones.
Note to Apple: I hate one button mice. I hate the fact that I have no choice in the matter on your laptops. Sure I can plug one in, but I want a multi-button mouse to be integrated.
Thanks!
by brichpmr9
by apotheon
"[i]If you have not stayed in touch with the MAC architecture how can you even make such statements?[/i]"
I haven't stayed in touch with it to the extent that I'd be able to rattle off a laundry list for you. I'm rusty. That doesn't mean that what I remember isn't still relevant, and it doesn't mean that the specifics don't exist. You still haven't addressed even something as simple as the integrated, monolithic structure of everything above the level of the kernel, and the security issues that raises. You've made a broad statement without support that Mac security is better than everything else and disparaged Linux security in comparison without identifying any security-related differences between the two. If anyone here is full of it, it's gotta be you.
You clearly are less in touch with Linux than I am with MacOS X, anyway, if you think KDE and GNOME represent the be-all and end-all of Linux-compatible GUIs.
"[i]the ease of use for end users is much better on the MAC then Linux from the GUI all the way up to configuring the system.[/i]"
I disagree with that. Ease is not the same as accessibility to newbies. MacOS X is far more accessible to new users than most Linux distributions, but it's a heck of a lot easier to do script-automated network-wide multi-system configuration changes in Linux than MacOS X (for instance).
While it's pretty easy to point at an OS and say "This thing sucks for most purposes, and here's why:" as many do with Windows as regards security, stability, and openness, it's not so easy to say something is the "best" across the board. Much of what makes something "best" is task-specific or a matter of personal preferences. You seem incapable of differentiating between your narrow little world of limited tasks, your personal preferences, and the concept of an objective standard of quality.
Allow me to clarify: MacOS X is the technical "best" solution for some purposes. It is, by no means, the "best" for all purposes, and in fact is nowhere near the "best" for a great many purposes that I have to address on a daily basis.
by apotheon
I'm a Linux user who for the most part uses the window manager only to house multiple terminal emulators. The major exception to that, generally, is my web browser.
I use the hell out of keyboard shortcuts. I prefer to avoid using a pointing device as much as I can. That changes when I'm using a browser, though: the Web is a very mouse-intensive place. Most of the time it's faster to get things done with keyboard shortcuts, even in GUI applications with clicky buttons, but webpages are another matter entirely.
When I'm using a mouse or other pointing device, though, I don't want to have to keep switching back and forth between it and the keyboard because I don't have enough friggin' buttons on the mouse. Got it?
One of the reasons I use the heck out of my keyboard rather than a pointing device most of the time is, simply, that I don't want to screw around with having to move back and forth between interface devices all the damned time.
by agirard
I came across this post and went out and ordered the alienware laptop.
Thanks for the great discusions.
by apotheon
Linux has a modular/monolithic kernel. That's completely beside the point. I wasn't talking about kernel design. You might have understood that if you were paying attention -- or, if you were, perhaps you simply don't have the basic knowledge needed to understand the difference between terms like "kernel" and "interface".
Linux not capable? Are you aware of the dozens of world-class supercomputers made out of Linux clusters in the world? Hell, Linux has been trading tops spots amongst the world's supercomputers for years as more powerful Linux-based supercomputer clusters have been built all the time.
The current fastest supercomputer, IBM's Blue Gene/L, has all its I/O nodes running Linux. The MACH5 supercomputer, which is the fastest Apple XServe cluster currently in existence, is only 15th, behind a bunch of supercomputers built using clustered more-traditional unices, like Linux. Meanwhile, the XServes making up those supercomputers aren't even running MacOS X, so your argument is completely without point.
The next few "fastest supercomputer in the world" candidates are likely to be running Linux, too:
http://news.com.com/2100-1001-963285.html
Do your homework before you start spewing crap like that.
by jaqui
simply because of support issues with Dell I had for an inspiron laptop, Dell canada didn't support the 3200, and Dell USA [ which did support it ] wouldn't send parts here, because Dell Canada exists.
[ yes, valid support contract with Dell at the time even ]
for that reason alone, I will never buy Dell, nor recommend them.
by jmgarvin
Here is a source of information about supercomputers. This site verifies the information provided by apotheon about the Apple Mach5 being in 15th position. Plus, it seems that this machine is "self made". I don't know what that means.
by bchesmer
by bchesmer
by apotheon
by trekman1
Hey Apotheon,
Be more clear in your statments next time. Don't expect others to clarify stuff that you do not understand yourself. Second of all I am done replying to your threads because you contradict yourself. In previous threads you state how great the MAC OS is. I think you like arguments which is fine provided you are consistant.
Back in 2003 Apple's Super computer ranked third.
http://www.geek.com/news/geeknews/2003Nov/bma20031104022503.htm
by trekman1
mmm.... looks like the military is going to be using MAC OS X for its super computer.
Maybe you should do your homework Apotheon.
Are you ever coming to CA? Would love to meet the know it all. Maybe for MAC world? LOL!!!
http://news.com.com/Apple+sells+supercomputer+sequel/2100-1010_3-5242487.html
by apotheon
You don't seem able to see the forest for the trees.
1. I'm not inconsistent. I think MacOS X is a great OS. It's just not perfect, and it's not always the best. As I've said elsewhere, it's the best in some cases, for some purposes, but not in all cases or for all purposes (or, for that matter, even most -- just some). In fact, I'd probably get a Powerbook if there were Powerbooks with three buttons for the pointing device rather than only one. It wouldn't be my primary system, but it'd be nice to have. There are some things I quite like about MacOS X, including the extensive use of the duck-typed, object oriented programming language Objective C, but I'm not a Mac-head like you that cannot abide any discussions of Macs that don't declare it the greatest technology since the wheel and fire.
2. The Virginia Tech xServer supercomputer you're so proud of barely snuck into third place over the previous third place, which was running Linux. It has since been superseded by a great many Linux-based supercomputers. A momentary spike in placement among the fastest supercomputers doesn't make something the be-all and end-all of supercomputers.
Get over yourself.
by trekman1
Can't take it when someone confronts you. Too bad.
Look who is talking about getting over himself, have you looked in the mirror. Out of all the people that I have talked to on here you are the most arrogant, pompus, individual. Get your head out of the clouds.
Yes, the supercomputer list will consistently change and I am sure Apple will be there again just a matter of time but you can't see that because you are too much of a linux cry baby.
by Erik Eckel
by big scoddie
Seems a little silly to "think differently", purchase another platform and then just make it emulate the old one.
You're right, it probably isn't the best option.
by madcap
Just wanted to let you know I appreciated your post. I, like Beth with her Santa dilemma, was comsidering a laptop from either Alienware or Dell. I've spent more than an hour reading all the related posts and have experienced info overload. It seems the world is split down the middle between the two. Has Dell lost the drive it had that made it so successful? Is Alienware overpriced and too specialized? I am now turned on by the idea of Sager, and will check them out. Have you heard any more concerning their support since your post? Has anyone out there??
Things important to me for my laptop purchase:
#1 - reliability and support
#2 - not getting ripped off/buying something I don't need
#3 - good battery life, the ability to upgrade hardware, and versatility (a note about gaming: I don't need to be able to play shoot-em games, but a hardware combo that could handle something like Rome:Total War would be nice)
Thank you again and any additional insight concerning my plight would be appreciated from anyone!!
by beth blakely
I got this:
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=7625572&type=product&id=1130986316451
Hewlett-Packard Pavilion Notebook with AMD Turion? 64 Mobile Technology ML-37
Model: dv8135nr
by antuck
by beth blakely
by lzdwren
If you do not know BOTH Windows and Macintosh Computers, then
you claim someone has drunk the COOL-AID.
I have personal knowledge of Windows systems for more than 10
years and it does not even come close to Macintosh.
Have you seen the stock values of each company?
by ernestor15
Hi, my cousin, she has e macs, one Imac, and 2 mac minis. I love them.
I don't like it too much because in contrary to you wife, it feats my personal needs but not my professional ones, because I cant install SQL Server or any other Microsoft stuff there.
And also you told that you are having issues viewing some webpages, I think there are plenty of web browser out there that can run them. But specially there is Firefox which is far supperior to INternet Explorer and you can install it on your MAC.
And by the way, I buyed a dell xps m1210, It will arrive any time soon. I think Alienware should be awesome as I haven't test no one yet, but I take the opportunity of buying Dell because I work there and they give me a small discount so, I hope the laptop behave.
Regards
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending