Discussion Locked

Best Hard Drive? Worst Hard Drive?

0 helpful
113 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've had two Maxtor 60 GB (Model 6Y060L0) hard drives fail within 4 week of each other. I was not able to recover any of the data. (Not a huge deal, as it was mostly employees' personal type stuff and/or files they didn't save to the servers.) I have quite a few more of these drives currently in use. Are these drives a time-bomb waiting to go off and destroy all the data they hold, I'm beginning to ask myself?

I'm inclined to replace them all before they fail. But will they fail if I don't? I have six out of the original eight still in use -- a 25 percent failure rate. They are all two years old, give or take.

What's the best drive out there right now? What's the worst?

113 replies

by maxwell edison

Have you seen any talk or documentation that indicates there are some drives out there that are documented to fail at huge rates - a true "bad batch"? If so, has there been a recall that I missed?

I haven't compared the S/Ns, but the model numbers are the same.

I think I'll replace them all anyway. I wonder if Maxtor will do anything about it?

by unclerob

I've never had any problems getting replacement drives from them, harddrives usually carry a decent warranty with them, Maxtor will at least take care of your existing 2 bad drives, they probably won't assist you with the other 6 that haven't failed yet.

by pwest

If you registered your harddrive(s) on Maxtor's website, there is a possibility they will replace them if a Maxtor is what you want.

I am not sure whether they will reimpurse you or not but worth a try.

by jkaras

Max,
we bought Dell GX270 pcs and GX260 with 40 gig Maxtors. They were a defective batch on recall. We had to get past the failure rate to enable a recall or call individually on each one. If these are in a Dell pc at boot up hit crtl+alt+D and it will run a diagnostic. You will get an failure code of 7 or just call and give that code ;)
I have a 120gig Maxtor in my personal computer at home with a Seagate 200 gig. Both work great and have been dependable. I chose the Seagate simply for the refurbished price and a whopping 5 year warrantee. All HDDs are the same based off the same technology and quality. They are made in third world countries in mass quanities. You just have to roll the dice.
The only company I refuse to do business with is Western Digital. They sold me and my roomate at the time a defective 80 gig. It took almost three months with a ton of harrassing emails and calls to finally get our hdd. The only problem was they sent back a smaller drive. It was only a 60 gig. Since my roomate bought it and the pc had parts of mine, he decided to just deal with it. Wanting any longer or any cross shipping was out of the question.

My vote is Seagate the best for bang for the buck principle, Western Digital the worst over worst support imaginal. Nobody should be subjected the hassel we had.

by w2ktechman

Western digital drives seem to fail for me quite often. I had mentioned it to another tech and they said the same thing happened with them.

I prefer seagate or toshiba for notebooks or seagate or Maxtor for desktops

by pwest

If I may offer a small poece of advice on this New Egg website deal.

If you register any new Western Digital harddrive on the WD website, the warranty through them is good for up to three years. I do this with all of my Western Digital harddrives.

by tyche

I have built many computer systems over the years, and have never had a Maxtor fail yet. I used one IBM drive (failed) and one Seagate (failed). I especially like Maxtor, not only because of it's reliability, but because of the utility and ease of use of their MAX BLAST drive setup and copy utility.

by deadly ernest

Over the last 20 years I have used just about every brand of IDE and SCSI drive that has been made, and purchased thousands for home and various clients. I have had the highest failure rates with Maxtor drives - about 25% of those purchased and usually within 15 months of the warranty expiring - warranty being only 12 months.

I have had 1 Fujitsu and 1 IBM drive go within warranty and replaced. All the other drives that have failed have been over 10 years old and allowable time to die of old age. Yes I do keep a lot of relics going.

I have not yet had a failure with a drive over 40 GB and most of my current drives are IBM and Seagate.

by mjd420nova

I've not experienced any maxtor drive failures
and I have about 60 of various sizes. Two units
have 60 GB and have been running non-stop
for over 5 years. I anticipate a failure in the
first years but feel that what I'm getting now
is hard to believe for this installation.
WD, and a few samsungs have been our biggest
problems, with less than half installed failed
within two years. We have our own clean room
so data recovery was no problem, but now even
our test bench drive (WD) failed with head servo
lockup. The samsung had drive control logic failures and one buffer failure.

by granitech

I recently had to replace a Maxtor 40GB at one of my client sites. Maxtor has been reliable until recent manufacturing problems (within last year) cropped up. Might explain their buy out by Seagate. With both major manufacturing in Taiwan, I suspect a combining of facilities. Seagates new facilities in US and China have been upgraded and seem to be producing solid performers in the SCSI and SATA brands. I've used their ATA and ATA3 drives with no problems.

by unclerob

...I've been able to ship defective drives to them (even some that were already past their warranty period by 6+ months already) and they've replaced my drives free of charge (aside from the cost of shipping the defective drive to them).

by maxwell edison

I'm going to call Maxtor to see if I can, at least, get a couple of remanufactured drives for free. But I might wait a couple of months in case another one fails.

by rayjeff

I'm glad I checked this topic out. I read the article and in 2003-2004, I had a Maxtor 80 GB drive and a 60 GB drive that were problematic at times. I would have to reformat the drives at times. I would say they lasted about a year each before I had to dump them.

I didn't have to send them back to Maxtor because I got them from Staples and had the insurance on them. But either way the drives would be sent back to Maxtor, I guess. But the customer service has been at least good whenever I use it and I pretty much can deal with the problematic nature of the drives. Now, if I was choosng drives for a job, then it would be different.

by gralfus

I purchased 4 IBM Deskstar drives and in less than one year they died within weeks of each other. I learned to recognize the "bleep bleep bleep" they make before keeling over. They had been recommended as being the fastest drives at the time, but I have avoided the Deskstar name ever since. It looks like Hitachi has it now.

The warranty required that the drives be shipped back in their original containers or equivalent, and that styrofoam or bubble wrap was not acceptable. This said to me they had no intention of honoring their warranty, because not many people keep the original packing materials.

by smorty71

I believe a class action lawsuit was filed against IBM over the Deskstar drives due to their high failure rate.

To make my situation worse, IBM refused to ship me a replacement drive out until they got my defective one. Because I needed to use the PC immediately, I was forced to go out and buy a new drive anyway.

I ended up selling the IBM replacement on eBay as soon as I got it back (didn't even open the box). Then a few days later, I got flamed by the eBay buyer because the replaced drive died on him as well. I'm assuming he had to go into the IBM warranty vortex to get that resolved.

by maxwell edison

I used to buy the IBM Deskstar, and I had about a half-dozen 15 GB drives around here. The first one lasted about three years; the remaining drives lasted about three years plus a week, or two, or three. Once I lost the third one, I took them all out.

That's one reason I'm leary about these two 60 GB Maxtor drives failing, one right after the other.

By the way, I still have some Deskstar 40 GB drives. They seem keep going and going.

by dmambo

I'll sign the petition to outlaw IBM DeskStars. We bought 13 Dell Dimensions in late 1999, and while they're still in service, I've had to replace the drives in 5 of them. The first after just 2 years. This is the worst performance that I've personally seen.

I've never had a problem with WD.

Who here has heard this comment from users?
"It started to make really weird noises about a week ago, and today I get this blue screen with some kind of message on it."

I usually thank them for not disturbing me last week, but tell them that if they had, they'd still have their data.

by jim s.

A few years back I order 6 Apple G4's, for our art dept., All of them came with 60gb Deathstar drives, and before the end of a year passing, I had to replace the drives atleast one time in each, and twice in a couple of them, after that, I ordered Seagates to replace them and they are still running today, and it has been going on 5 years, which reminds me I better start thinking about getting more.

by odracyr

That's so true. I worked for a company that had nothing but grief when they purchased those Hitachi drives in bulk. We've regretted it. We even found a few which were dead-on-arrival!! - just open the package, install it, and nothing! That's a strong hint of poor quality control.

What??? They want the drives shipped back in their original containers? That's a stupid condition in order to return their DEAD DRIVES! An obvious ploy to put barriers so they don't have to honor the warranty. I guess that explains why my company didn't return the drives - Hitachi put up many nonsense barriers so you couldn't.

I guess that also explains why Hitachi drives are so cheap nowadays. They aim at the unsuspecting bargin hunter since those in-the-know avoids them.

I doubt they will be in the hard drive business for much longer. Even if you are a retail outlet, why face angry and soon-to-be ex-customers because the drive you sold them is junk? I'd get smart and not offer them for sale no matter how cheap I get them for resale.

by goal120

In 1999, we purchased over 50 desktops with 6.8GB Quantum Fireball drives, and by the end of 2000 nearly half had failed. None of the 30 desktops with the 8.4GB size drives failed, so it was just a bad batch of the smaller drives. Got them replaced under 3-yr warranty via pc mfr as they failed.

I agree with one of the other posters that the IBM Deskstars seem to have a high failure rate, but I don't have any stats on them.

For laptop drives, do NOT get the Toshiba HDD2190 drives (MK4025GAS). There is a known problem if they run for over 300hrs straight (that is less than 2 weeks).

Hard drive manufacturer warranties are often longer than the pc mfr warranty, so if the pc warranty is up, look up the hdd model number online for warranty length info.

by maxwell edison

Although I'm certain that I'm past the one year warranty, by only mere months, perhaps Maxtor has extended it for a known bad batch. It's worth a try, anyway. Thanks.

by jakesty

If you buy a Dell and after the warranty the drive goes bad, you can't go to the drive manufacturer for replacement. OEM drives are supported only for as long as the PC manufacturer warranty lasts. I tried it.
Not every PC maker uses OEM, but it's safe to say the top 10+ makers would as it is less expensive to buy drives by the case.
Jake

by smorty71

I've used IBM, Hitachi, Maxtor and Western Digital; however, the brand I find myself buying over and over is Seagate.

I have 2 of their 300 GB drives in my Windows MCE 2005 machine and they work great. Fast and super quiet. Plus, they have a 5 year warranty.

by goal120

...sounds great. I definitely try to avoid any drive with less than a 2-yr warranty. The prices are often the same, so might as well get the longer warranty.

by shraven

Funny, I've only had Seagate drives fail on me. And Seagate routinely tests slower and louder than Maxtor and WD in Maximum PC tests.

The warranty factor is real, because let's face it, no matter what brand you have, when it fails, the only thing you have to lean on is whether it's covered. The reputation of the manufacturer doesn't mean squat at that point.

by maxwell edison

I haven't bought a Seagate drive in years. I think the last one was maybe a 40 MB drive. A couple of others recommended Seagate as well; so Seagate it will be.

I've decided to take out those other six drives, so I can do it on my own time-table, and not find myself scrambling if another drive fails. I'll try Seagate as replacements for all those drives -- and sell the others (reformatted, of course) as a lot-of-six on ebay!

by smorty71

I've found great prices on Seagate drives lately at both Outpost and Newegg. I got my latest 300GB Seagate from Outpost for $89 (no rebates!) and free shipping about 2 weeks ago.

by tbm

be on the lookout for a 6-pack of Maxtor drives. JK.

depending if there is important data on the drive, go the extra step and do a KillDisk, it's a downloadable free utility. even with a regular format, someone can use an unerase utility and get at the data.

by hal 9000

I've lost count of the number that I've had to RMA back to the supplier in one lot there where 4 out of 6 that I had to return in a single day. What made things even worse is that they passed the Drive Test before I used them and after installing XP onto them they failed.

Talk about a massive waste of time and effort. From the way that I was treated when I returned two thirds of the drives I got the impression that they had been a [b]Bad Batch[/b] as there where none of the usual complaints and the like.

After that I switched to the Samsung Drives and [b]So Far[/b] I haven't had a single problem [b]YET![/b]

But I've only been using them since just before Christmas so I'm still waiting to see what happens.

As far as the Seagate's go they seem to work if they are going to and don't if they are faulty, it's just annoying having to return so many of them and have to run the gauntlet all over again with another lot of unopened Drives which you still don't know if they are going to work.

I've also seen numerous computers where Seagate's will just not play nice in a Master Slave configuration even though they have worked that way for a while for some reason they all seem to drop one of the HDD off the IDE Chain. I can't apply that to the SATA drives as it doesn't apply but the IDE ones are a headache when this happens.

Col

by maxwell edison

You mentioned that you recently tried a Samsung, but it hasn't been in use very long. So, Colin, which brand have you had the BEST "Luck" with over the years?

by tracyf

Why buy something the maker doesn't even have the confidence to warranty for more than 1yr? (Maxtor, WD). 5 yrs. should be standard.

Ditto on 1 yr. for PC systems from vendors- how Dell & the others can even dare to sell something like a PC w/a 90 day warranty is beyond my comprehension (& yes, I do understand they do this to save money- that isn't my point).

On a sidenote- Samsung's drives seem pretty nice to me, as well. 3 yr. warranty & also quiet (especially their Spinpoint notebook drives).

by it cowgirl

I have had 3 100 GB WD drives bite the dirt since October. But all are from the same batch and are 6 yrs old.

by hal 9000

Talking SCSI Hot Swappable here as those things really are expensive.

Even today I'm still using a lot of SCSI HDD and the current 146 GIG Upper Limit is driving me crazy. But it seems that all development on the 15K SCSI's has been stopped and the R&D transfered to the SATA side of the market.

Col

by antuck

It's matter of when not if a drive will fail. I've seen alot of drives fail. I always figure with the amount of movement going on, they eventually will fail.

In the last couple of years I have had luck with the Maxtor and Seagate drives. I was buying Western Digital drives for a while but then they started heating up really bad. These were workstation computers not gaming computers, so I didn't figure they would heat up like that. I will say I just bought a Western Digital SATA II drive that does not heat up (bought it because of price 250GB for $100)

Seagate's drives come with a great warranty. I know the models I've looked at had 5 yr warranties. I haven't had to use the warranty process so I can't comment on that.

But to answer your one question "but will they fail if I don't" I would say yes they will but they will also eventually fail if you do replace them. After all they are mechanical/electrical parts that wear out.

by smorty71

It got pretty ugly. Neither of us could prove/disprove who broke the drive. He claimed it was DOA and I said that it was still sealed from IBM (which it was). I stated the condition of the drive (sealed after being sent in for repairs) and listed it "as is" (but offered it dirt cheap). He conceded that he knew what as-is meant; however, he didn't want to deal with a dead drive.

After some of the nasty e-mails he sent me, I became less-inclined to be a nice about it and referred him to IBM for another warranty claim.

by maxwell edison

I had an instance once, not too long ago, where I sold an item, I did everything right, but the buyer was being a real PITA, even to the point, in my opinion, of trying to keep the item AND get a refund. She was really just trying to cheat me. Needless to say, I wouldn't give-in, and the "you-know-what" hit the preverbal fan. Anyway, she gave me my very first negative (out of more than 800 sales and ~800 & 100% positive rating), and I gave her about her 7th or 8th negative out of only a few hundred transactions. I was really fuming since I wanted to keep my 100% rating intact.

I let about a week go by, and I then sent her an email suggesting that I would open a SquareTrade arbitration action, and that if she would mutually agree to remove the negative feedback we both left for each other, that I would abide by whatever decision SquareTrade would make. At the same time, I submitted a "mutually withdraw feedback" action with ebay. She quickly agreed to the suggestion, and she completed the feedback withdraw. Once that happened, and the negative rating she left for me was removed, there was no way for her to reverse it back. The negative that she left for me was removed for good.

I sent her a final email telling her that in order for SquareTrade to mediate this dispute, that someone would have to pay the fee that they'll charge to handle it, and it was not going to be me. Wow, you should have seen her reply email. I never saw such words come from a, so-called, "lady". She tried to cheat me, and I got the last laugh. Yea, I tricked her into it, and I'm still laughing about it.

by x-marcap

I would believe EMC knows just a bit more than I do about drives. They use Seagates as a base...

I can't tell you what they have in Clariions, as I am on the Enterprise side of things.

Tim

by wayne t

MUCH worse: In my experience, their support is largely automated (badly) and is lousy. [I have a 40 page email exchange with them that I'm gonna put up on the web somewhere as a warning to others].

[*Everyone* is gonna have bad days/batches/runs/models what matters is HOW they react to the problem.]

Maxtor's: Dreadful.

Their ONE experience with me has cost them sales of (literally) thousands of drives since. I refuse to support them - I just don't have the time to muck about with them.

best of luck.

by maxwell edison

I, too, think I've purchased my last Maxtor drive. In addition to the 60 GBs I have around here, I also have quite a few 80s, 100s, and 120s as well. So far, however, only the 60s have failed.

(.....knocking on wood......)

by don_the_newbie

I have maxtor drive each failing in less tahn two years. the sound advice is simple: Use either Seagate or Western Digital.

Maxtor is Dreadful? 100% Sure

by jd255

For the past five to six years I've personally stuck with WD drives. I've seen Maxtors (both in commercial and consulting areas) fail repeatedly and more frequently. One of my main reasons for being "loyal" to WD is their customer service. On the one or two drives which have failed on me; they did the RMA quickly and effeciently. Further they sent me the replacement drive rapidly and paid for the return shipment. I found other HD companies often wanted their defective product first before sending the replacement. Customer service reps were more "polite" at WD as well. That's my 2cents.

by jaqui

drive brands I have never had problems with are Seagate and Western Digital.

I have yet to have a Maxtor not fail.

I just wish that the local shops didn't carry maxtor as "the drive" brand to have.
I have to go out of my way to get a seagate or western digital drive.

by stress junkie

The only two hd brands that I purchase or recommend are Seagate and Maxtor. I have never had any problems with them. On the other hand I've had three Western Digital drives die within a few months of putting them into service. Those drives were each purchased in different years from different vendors. They were probably also different models although they were all in the Caviar line. So I always tell people to stay away from Western Digital and to choose either Seagate or Maxtor. At least we both like Seagate. :)

by jaqui

it's the barracuda line that I most frequently see bad, usually the ancient ones [ less than 500 mb ]

I've literally never had a single problem with WD, and I have only seen one WD drive that went bad.
[ I think the jibbernaught that was playing with components fried the drive ]

brand spanking new maxtor drive, 120 GB, on a p3 @ 600 MHz, 30 days after install, failed, bios couldn't find a hard drive.
reboot of system found it. winxp crashed a week later, rebuild, winxp crashed a week later....
every 4th week hard drive gone from bios.
every week windows crashed.

I finally took a small section of the drive away from windows, but linux on that section and used lilo to dual boot. guess what, it wasn't the drive, it was MS' bootloader conflicting with the intel 810e chipset on the board.

by michael_orton9

I have a collection of old HDs, they were from a local Gove dept and a nuclear power ststion. They wanted the latest PCs and let them go to a recycling company. Ther are mainly 6, 8 10 gig, Ideal for Linux PCs.
My oldest is a 1 gig CONNOR (do they exist now?) and they all work in disk caddys.
The only problem was that XP wasn't able to format them, neither fdisk, they had used some paciliar wiping system.
I used Nortons Diskdoctor to try to recover something, and then I found that I could format them with PM-8 on a windows/linux dual boot PC.
They are in daily use, both in my Pcs and in friends PCs some running Linux (SuSe 9.3 pro) but one running DSL and some 98se.
They have never let me down.
They cost from free to ?3 each too!
My biggest HD is a Maxstor 120gig and this has been running for two years, with 8 partitions, NTFS(x2) Fat32, Linux swap and Reiserfs (x4) with no problems.
PM-8 finds no bad sectors on any of the HDs.
One of the PCs had been in a skip in the rain for several days.
The only hardware failures that I have had since 1988 have been from overclocking, both Gigabyte 8 something MB and P-IV destroyed when someone disabled some non MS software that would have slowed down the CPU when it overheated.
Even then the HDs, the RAM and the AGPx8 video card survived the smoke.

by jamesrl

In use at a former employer - they had a PC attached serially to a data collection box, whole unit was 12 years old - on all day.

Drives are much smaller, faster and less expensive today than the used to me. There has to be compromises somewhere - on the whole I think older drives were built to a higher standard.

James

by pmshah9

I too have a 14 year old 520 mb Connor connected to a VLB controller running Netware 3.1 on a 486 machine. The system boots in under 17 seconds! I just wish that Connor had not been bought over by Seagate. Only problem is the mobo is not y2k compliant & I must set the date in bios everytime I reboot.

by cgoeckel

In the last 4 months I have had to replace 75% of the hard drives that were Maxtor. I wasn't able to recover anything off of them.

What bothered me about it was that the systems they were coming out of were all the same batch which made me wonder if it was a bad batch of drives.

When I called the big D about each of them I didn't have to go through the 50 steps to verify it was actually dead. They admitted there was an issue with the maxtors and sent out new drives.

All of the failures happened when there was less then 120 days till the end of the warranty.

I received WD drives as replacements and those have not had any issues.

by ben "iron" damper

I too have had many problems with Maxtor drives failing prematurely.
IDE drive wise I've had the best luck with the Quantum Fireball drives. Now they are a tad noisey but so far I've had excellent luck.
I've also had decent luck with Western Digital drives as well. Just my two cents.

by jellimonsta

I agree Col. SCSI IS expensive!!
I makes me chuckle to think of the acronym RAID. It may be a redundant array, but it is FAR from INEXPENSIVE!!! :D

Oh well, DAS is a lot cheaper than SAN though.

by dmambo

The last time I saw the acronym spelled out it was Redundant Arrat of Independent Drives. I kind of chuckled at that.

by x-marcap

Prices of mass storage

HP= High Priced
EMC= Even more costly.
IBM= I've been Moved (the price could make you spasm)

I believe that I have heard enterprise storage puns that all fit the cost. Inexpensive it isn't...

by tonythetiger

type problems, I think the failure would be relatively sooner (a couple of months) rather than later (a couple of years). I wouldn't replace a working part that has shown two years of good service. They're rated by Mean Time Between Failures, which probably means that your two year failures are offset by someone else's six years of rock solid use.

by tbm

You might also want to run diags on the remaining drives prior to them failing if you suspect they might be problematic. This way you can RMA all at once if there are additional problems.

Seagate drives have been the most reliable in my experience.

by ~omega~

In my 15 Years of experience with varieties of HDs, Starting with a 420MB WD - which BTW, would still be running if it wasn't useless - The majority of failures I have seen were in Maxtors. I have heard they have gotten better, but I am WD all the way.
In all of that time I have seen 1 bad 6GB WD hard drive. Every computer I have personally owned (Going on 10) I have trusted to WD and have never been let down (The 1 6GB held only mps3s that I had elsewhere, and I had gotten it used. Still lasted 3 years).
My major complaint with seagates is compatibility, but I have seen more than a few bad ones come in from my customers. To be fair, they were mostly 5+ years... but I still have running 6 and 2 GB drives from 8+ years ago....

by vid419

I haven't had problems with either of these drives, but I've had to replace 3 failed Maxtor 40GB drives within a period of 9 months. Needless to say I was furious that they needed to be replaced (back to back to back). Luckily I had the drive backed up. I used to work for a company that resold drives to resellers and retailers and the hardware guys there always stood by Hitachi and Toshiba drives.

by critch

How about the good old Quantum Bigfoot 8GB from a few years ago - everyone that I ever touched needed to be replaced -

by jellimonsta

I have a Bigfoot 12.73GB in my 6 yr old PC. I have not turned it on much in the last year or so, but I think it still works! :D ?:|

by hal 9000

They do make an excelent paper weight don't they? :p

Over here the biggest one that I saw in that range was around the 2.5 GIG as they stopped importing them here for some unknown reason. With thier failure rate I couldn't understand why. B-)

Col ]:)

by sparkin

I'd forgotten about Bigfoots, I went through three of them in a matter of months before they finally gave me a Fireball. Luckily the name wasnt an indicator of things to come

by stress junkie

... the platters ran at 300 rpm and a full height drive only stored 75 MB.

Current hard drive technology is amazing. Like everything else in computers it's a wonder it works at all. The fact that it works really well most of the time is almost like science fiction. It's hard to believe what we have today compared to 1985, when I started in this field. I remember on one job the manager said to me "We have almost a terabyte of data storage in the lab." The lab was about the size of a football field and it was crammed with equipment. Now anyone can afford to buy two 500 GB disks and put them into their 3 GHz computer with 2GB of RAM.

Two 500 GB disk drives: $700
3 GHz CPU: $450
2 GB RAM: $500
Total price: $1650

Back in 1985 that kind of capacity would have cost hundreds of millions of dollars. Amazing.

by hal 9000

But as of November last year they seemed to go off quite a lot I think that every one that I've bought since then has been returned at least once for replacement.

Currently the Samsung Spin Points are working quite well and I've yet to have a problem with one but as I said previously it's early days yet.

Maxtor's only seem to be any good in external USB Caddies and I've never had any joy with WD in any form and I'll not mention the infamous IBM Death-stars. But at least with the Glass Platter IBM's they made a nice rattling sound when you dropped them onto concrete. I think that's the only nice thing that I can think of to say about them.

The ones that I really never had any problems where the old Quantum's but since Maxtor bought them they have become next to useless and WD's haven't been much better either.

I take it that you only want feed back on the 3.5 inch variety here so I'll leave out the NB Drives that I've used over the years. It's just at the moment I'm a bit iffy on any HDD as since November I've had close to a 100% failure rate on Seagate's and even the 5 year warranty means nothing if you are constantly pulling them out and replacing them.

While I haven't used the Hitachi Drives since IBM sold off that part of the company I haven't heard good things about them as Canon uses them in the Image Runner Photo Copier and the head tech here is full of praise of their unreliability so much so that he always carries at least 20 with him when ever he's out on a service call as he doesn't expect a new one straight from the packet to work. And they are the biggest single spare part that Cannon carries.

The Seagate's used to be very good but for the last 6 months or so I'm not too willing to recommend them and as the Samsungs haven't been around long enough I can hardly recommend them either although I do have one NB Samsung that has worked quite happily now for about 16 months in a NB that gets less than gentle treatment and when I last saw it a few weeks ago it wasn't showing so much as 1 bad sector though the NB was looking fairly Second Hand.

Col

by hal 9000

I laughed so much that I chocked on the peppermint that I was sucking on and now I need some monitor wipes to clean up the Screen. :^0

I love it and I'm going to keep a copy. :p

Col ]:)

by pmshah9

Some years ago Seagate moved their Singapore manufacturing facility (originally connor) to mainland China so reduce their manufacturing costs. Their supplies to India came from this plant & for almost 6 months their failure rate went to over 20%. This when the warranty period was only 1 year. Samsung gt into the act & started offering 3 year warranty & the assemblers migrated enmasse, which included myself. Unfortunately & without exception every samsung drive needed replacemnt. For a while I used IBMs but with their erratic behaviour had to shift back to Seagate - NOT MADE IN CHINA - & have stuck to them ever since without a single failure. Can you believe that I still have a 13 year old 520 mb Connor (mae in Singapore) & 2 x 2.5 GB Quantums - incidentally made in Japan ( probably by Panasonic) still in good working condition? You stick to Samsung but make sure not to misplace the warranty requirement papers, you will need them.

by hal 9000

It's a bit hard to say that Seagate has good Drives when you get 10 one day and 6 of them don't work fresh out of the packet. The remaining 4 which did work at first tested OK but all of them failed within 1 week.

Personally I would have preferred it if they all didn't work as it's time consuming reloading only to have to do it all over again within the week.

The Samsung's' that I've used so far have all been excellent and they range from the 2.5 inch ones that was all I could get after last years disaster that took the Fujitsu Plant in Malaysia off line for a while to the bigger SATA Drives all of which just seem to work.

While they where not my first choice after having so many Seagate Drives fail in such a short period of time it makes it hard to recommend them. But as I've said previously the Seagate's only started this problem since November last year so maybe it was just a [b]Bad Production Run[/b] but no matter what right at the moment I can not recommend them for the time being. I've been running at about a 60% failure rate on them and because I don't get the [b]Third Degree[/b] when I return them I think that the wholesaler that I buy from has experienced a problem with these drives and are just accepting them back and replacing them as they come in. One of my personal Seagate's has been replaced at least 4 times since November but on the up side I am keeping my DR Plan really up to date. :^0

Col ]:)

by oz_media

When it comes rto cheap drives, which I only assume these are, there seems to be no real deciding factor. I remember when Western Digital made a great 40 a terrible 60 and a great 80 a couple of years ago. Somehow one drive in the middle of the line was pure shite. I think the same goes for all entry level drives, without investing big coin and buying really high end drives, that's teh chance you take.

I prefer Seagate or WD to most entry level drives though.

Now, to make a case for OEM, if your company had invested in X number of OEM machines (not retail boxes but professional workstations) they would be covered by 5 year onsite service, all of a sudden entry lebel hardware doesn't really matter.

I've proven that point for a few employers over the last few years. Yes i can get you a white box for less, but isn't this your business? Did you buy a cheap/unreliable/homemade car to visit your clients? Did you solder yoru phone sstem together in the garage? Did you buy the cheapest all-in-one photocopier/fax/coffee machine? NO!

So why did they buy a cheap computer system?

When it comes to personal/family use, who cares. But cheap as you can get if that's your motivator. When it comes to your business, how important is it that your business is operational everyday? Why not take down the sign and lock the doors while you're at it?

Max, I'm not ranting at you here, I'm just frustrated with so called 'big player' companies that think buying cheap sh*t is the smart way to save money.

Fools deserve what they get, nothing for nothing.

by nordic_skater

Midway through a defrag, my MAXTOR "DiamondMax Plus 9, 200GB ATA /133 HDD", MF'G DATE 25DEC2003, put in service June of 2004 "crashed" on 20jan2006. It did not recover from the aborted defrag and nothing I could throw at the PC (HP m495c) restored it. The following may be useful for those interested in recovering data that simply can't be restored conventionally: The Maxtor was permanently replaced with a Seagate. The pc was about 95% backed up but to recover some "lost" data, the Maxtor was temporarily swapped with the HDD in my external USB drive in order to enable a sector search. The file system was totally corrupted by the aborted defrag. Ironically, it was being defragged as the first step of conversion to V-Com's AutoSave backup software. This shows even the "pros" can get burned. In the process of doing a sector by sector search for data, the disk editor software hung on certain areas. It was possible to work around those areas. Three unreadable areas were encountered in the middle of real data. My conclusion: Since drives are mapped at the factory for bad sectors, the defrag probably encountered these unmapped bad sectors and barfed. I have to also conclude this drive was a stinker from the get-go and this thread seems to suggest the Maxtors are not exactly reliable drives. It was my first HDD failure in over ten years. My usage is 95% daily, at least 16 hours per day, one on/off cycle per day.

by edania

What a coincidence! My Maxtor 60gb just crahed today. I was looking for some utilities on the web, and decided to check my emails, and found this post. Not going for Maxtor anymore!

by marketingtutor.

Of both old and new hard drives in the non-SCSI class, I would put Western Digital at the top of my list. I would put Maxtor at the bottom of the list, just one step above IBM drives. In my experience, I have seen IBM drives beat Maxtor in numbers of failed disks by a 2:1 ratio.

Maxtor had a reputation for a long time, as have some other brands, of not being able to mix with other brands on the same cable. I have not found this to be the case with the WD disks I have used.

As far as a good disk to go with? Well, at the time of writing this reply, I would say that you couldn't go wrong with four 150GB WD Raptors on a 3ware 9550SX RAID card.

by dcs

Well no luck here with Maxtor or Mitsubishi drives
but on a good note Seagate seems to be a winner even with fail over i have always been to recover user data,

Currently we are evaluating samsung drives and to date they are doing the thing, my portable users are running them, they seem to be good out at 12 months

by gem

I have a simular experience. We keep a list of dead drives going back 3+ years. 83% of that list is populated by Maxtor drives, including dead external "one-touch" drives. I have had two failures of those right out of the box.

Currently, Western Digital is our drive of choice. My vendor says his return rate on them is 6%-8%, but we experience less than a 2% failure rate.

by capnpauly

I've been working as a tech for an in-house dept for 4 years now, and I have had HDDs from each main manufacturer fail on me.
I can say that most of them have been between 3-5 years old, but I'd say that because most of the Compaq Evo desktops we have had Western Digital drives in them, they've failed the most on me.
From a 'reliability' standpoint, however, I'd have to say that Maxtor have been the worst, what with having drives fail on me that were less than a year old, and Seagate have been the best - only have had one fail on me ever that I can think of.

by w2ktechman

on the model of the drive. I have had bad luck with travelstar line (notebooks) failing within 3 weeks, and more often around 6 months.
desktop drives, I have had WD in 3 systems, and each drive failed within 2 months. and 2 had to be replaced after only a week. After we went throgh 5 drives, we switched these systems to Maxtor and had no problems with the drives after that.
goes to show, that it may depend on location, average temps, etc.. Or it may just be certain models outright.

by pradipsagdeo9

I have used Seagate, Micropolis(remember?), Western Digital, and Maxtor drives. My original Maxter drive is at least six years old. None of my drives failed. They had to be replaced because they were to small, 1 to 3 GB. The smallest and the oldest drive I have now is 20GB. Most hard drives fail because of lack of care, in my experience. I have actually seen people move computers like pieces of furniture while still powered-up, dragging on floors, desktops, etc.

by wfs1946

I think, like everything else, all drive manufacturers have had one or two series/size of drive have a bad reputation. Seagate barracuda is one example, I had two fail in a server and sent them out for data recovery and the company said that at that time, 80% of their business was that model drive.

I feel that they all make good drives, it just depends on that chance model being bad (does the word Edsel ring a bell?).

I think it all goes back to personal preference.

Good Luck!

by douglashead

Hmmm I'm wondering how long its going to be before I get asked by dad to replace the Maxtor hard drive with the Seagate one I took from his computer a little while ago. It started off as a problem with the cd drives and any usb drives oh and the floppy drive...you had to put/plug them in before turning on the computer...otherwise you had to restart...sounds a bit like a driver problem or something, but I put in a new hdd installed windows and drag dropped files onto the new hdd pretty easy, then stuck the old hard drive into another computer as a spare drive as the Master drive has 4 operating systems on it...my excuse: I'm a student and my sisters wanted win98 and xp for their games, and I needed win2003 and a trial xp for my studies.
In my recent computer that I just put together I got WD, as I new they had a great reputation and they usually performed the best in the Australian PC User magazines. 2 are in a RAID 0 and one is an independant...although they did initially start off as a RAID 5.

by panzrwagn

Quick lesson here, most HDDs today are rated for at least 1M Hours MTBF. If you do the math that means that if you manufactured 1M of a particular model, on average you'd have one failing every hour and still be in spec. As an end user you could have all 6 fail in a day, and the manuacturer still wouln't have a problem. The greater the number of drives, the larger number will die at any time,

by wjacomb

I have problems with Seagates, Western Digitals (early models), Hitachi Deskstars.

Currently I am having a good run on Western Digitals.

Some useful hints and tips on avoiding problematical drives are:-
1. Develop a good relationship with your supplier - when considering buying a particular model - ask him what their current warranty rate is - a good relationship will get you truth.

2. Buy quality not on price - I always insist that the drives I buy are at the higher end of the spectrum i.e faster rpm and bigger cache.

3. Always enable smart in bios and inform your suers what to do if a smart error occurs.

4. We all preach it but often don't do it - blessed is the pessimist for they have made a backup!

Hope this helps

Regards

William

by Member 22907884

Got a Seagate 160 GB External USB/Firewire Drive about a year ago thru Oupost.com (Fry's Electronics on the West Coast - great site for us NYC folks unable to physically walk into the computer warehouse store) and it FAILED right out of the box!

I have been in systems for close to 20 years with multiple types of drive purchases and while I echo most users here on this thread (WD sucks - hence their cheap price, Toshiba/IBM/Segate ususally all good, my two new contenders - Fantom and Nandano), ANY DRIVE CAN FAIL FOR ANY NUMBER OF REASONS. Backup, repeat, Backup, repeat, Backup - there is nothing sweeter than Recovery.

To conclude, I had gone to the Seagate site and registered with a DMA and sent the drive back to Segate (must do this within 30 days of purchase from an online outlet-type vendor) who within 2 weeks time did resend me a new drive (with new attachments (power cord, USB cable - nice bonus) albeit it was in a fairly new condition, but not shrink-wrapped like the one I had purchased. Same size, works great and that's the key here anyway.

I think that some vendors may unknowingly and or maliciously ship to their supplier/3rd party outlet store partners the drives that come from a batch that have known issues or reported problems from QA.

Anybody else had issues like me with Online Outlet store drive purchases (Outpost, TigerDirect, eCost, Geeks, Newegg, FutureShop,..)?

by fjames1

We bought about 20 Maxtor drives between 2002 and 2005, ranging in size from 80 to 250 GB. 80% of them have died. We've gotten zero satisfaction from Maxtor -- they advertise 200,000 hrs MTBF, or something like that, but I think we're getting around 20,000 or less. As long as a drive lasts 1 year (8,000 hrs), it's out of warranty. They're thinking strictly short-term.

Some of these drives were in Maxtor external USB cabinets, but others are in server-grade cabinets with extra cooling. It doesn't matter. They simply break. Our company policy is now that we junk any Maxtor drive we find in a PC, whether it's broken or not, because it's cheaper than having them die on the wrong day.

by irhastings

edison, Maxtor is probably the better of the hard drives that I like. But they are 2 years old and I would say to start backing all the information that is on those disks so that you have mirror images of the information then start buying one at a time at different times. that will give you a higher rate of success.

by hal 9000

That range from 50 MEG up so that's letting you know how old they are and they just keep working. Currently they are attached to a P90 as the 286 M'Board was killed by the girl who comes in here do do some [b]Work Experience[/b] but I have Connors, and Quantum's [b]Not the Big Foot models[/b] that just run on and on without a problem. It seams that the older the drive the better made it was as I've yet to see one of those really old HDD fail. The worst that I used to see Way back when was [b]Bad Sectors[/b] appearing but only after the drives had been moved while running. I'm currently wondering just how many of the USB ones will still be running in 6 years let alone something like 12 years or longer.

I've even got one of those non IDE Drives sitting here with the ribbon cable and controller card though I've yet to find anything that I'm game to put it into to see if it works. It came out of a 386 where the CMOS Capacitor had leaked and taken out the M'Board so I'm not sure if it actually works still.

Col

by aaron a baker

Over time I've had occasion to use pretty well all of the aforementioned. For the longest time, I didn't trust Maxtor. Especially since they had merged with Quantum I had nothing but problems of one sort or another always leading me back to the MBR. Then I discovered that I liked Western Digital and Fujitsu even less. I found Fujitsu, a drive that is supposed to roll at 7200Rpm quite slow. Now I'm back to Maxtor and I must admit that they seem to have improved the product.
The drive is faster, or at least it seems to run full 7200Rpm and I haven't had any problems with it as of yet.My conclusion is that when buying a drive, you really are taking a shot in the dark. Doesn't matter what kind of Drive, they all make the same grandiose promises and all are capable of breaking down, so now it becomes which do you want to Die with? :)
So I took a chance and so far Maxtor leads the way for me. Small main drive, 40Gb 6E040L0
I'm sorry about your troubles with Maxtor but I'm wondering if the root of the problem doesn't lie elsewhere causing this effect in your drive? I can't see four going one after another or Maxtor would definitely fear from me.
Good luck
Warmest Regards
Aaron

by wayne t

Col,

are you sure you're allowing/testing correct mag alignment for these drives - with the new Parallel Aligned thermal-Sink Yttrium (Southern Aurorasphere ThermoMagneticlyAligned - SATA-2) Storage mediums - and the fact that many of these drives are arssemebled and tested in the Northern Hemisphere i think you'll find - as we have, that you have to take the average phase ('polarisation', really) of the incoming 50 Hz power AND the 'magnetic C of G' of the metal ccomponents in the Peecee assembly *itself* into consideration when positioning/orienting the drives within the cases - or, indeed in realigning the heads for best results in prevailing local 'hemi-magnetoRF' conditions which are often of spurious or even idiopathic origin.

by hal 9000

You need to apply Fung Shea to the way that you fit a HDD into a case. Silly me I thought that by buying decent Antec Cases and PS's that would do as well but now I see the error of my ways. :D

Not only do I have to have the computer pointed the right way in the right room but I have to point the HDD correctly as it's fitted. :_|

But I have all my [b]Apples[/b] hanging outside in the rain clunking together to scare the evil spirits away and there is always FRED to scare off any unwary interlopers. :p

It's a bit of Ultra Modern Art made up of broken Computer internals hung together with paper clips FRED actually stands for [b]F***ed-up Ridiculous Electronic Device.[/b] I learnt that one from a guy that parked an big excavator on his work supplied desktop and asked me with a perfectly straight face to fix it up. He wanted it all panel belted straight and the plastic welded together as well as a custom paint job [b]Cost Wasn't a Factor in the Repair[/b] :D

Col

by pmshah9

I agree entirely. Unless one starts installing laptop drives in the desktops any movement while the pc is on runs a great risk of heads scraping the platter leading to disk failure.